The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. Hence, the impugned Order of the learned Trial Court is set aside and Appeal is allowed. RFA No. 19 of 2016 Smt. Domaki Bhutia & Another vs. General Public and Another
15. A Certificate be granted by the learned District Judge as ordered hereinabove, on application being made thereto, in supersession of the Certificate, if any, already granted.
16. No order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED: 22nd June, 2017
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Single Bench : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI,
JUDGE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RFA No. 19 of 2016
Appellants
: 1.
Smt. Domaki Bhutia,
W/o late Tempo Rapgay Bhutia,
Resident of Development Area,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok.
East Sikkim.
2.
Master Tshering Bhutia,
S/o late Tempo Rapgay Bhutia,
Resident of Development Area,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok.
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
: 1.
2.
General Public
Smt. Pempa Choden Bhutia,
W/o Shri Chochung Bhutia,
Resident of Pangthang,
P.O. Penlong & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
Appeal under Section 384 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Bhusan Nepal and Mr. Loknath Khanal, Advocates for the Appellants.
None for Respondent No.1.
Mr. Rinzing Dorjee Tamang, Advocate for the Respondent No.2.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
This Appeal arises out of the Order dated 21.9.2016,
passed by the learned District Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok in
Civil
Misc. Case (Succession) Case No. 55 of 2014, Smt. Domaki
RFA No. 19 of 2016
Smt. Domaki Bhutia & Another vs. General Public and Another
Bhutia & Another vs. General Public & Another. The learned Trial
Court after taking into consideration the evidence of the parties
ordered as follows;
“34.
It is therefore, ordered that the
Petitioner (on one part) and opposite
party No.2 (on the other part) shall be
entitled to equal share (on 50:50 basis)
to
the
family
pension,
leave
encashment, GPF and other securities
left behind in the name of Late Tempo
Rapgay Bhutia.”
Aggrieved by the aforesaid Order, this Appeal assails it.
2.
The parties herein shall be referred to in terms of their
appearance before the learned Trial Court.
3.
The facts briefly stated are that the Petitioner No.1 is
the wife and the Petitioner No.2, the son of late Tempo Rapgay
Bhutia, while the Opposite Party No. 2 claimed to be the second
wife of the said deceased. The case of the Petitioners No. 1 and 2
was that all documents, such as Voter’s Identity Card, Aadhar
Card, Certificate of Identification and family details as recorded in
the Office of the deceased, reveal that the Petitioner No.1 is the
wife of late Tempo Rapgay Bhutia, while the Opposite Party No.2
was found to be the wife of one Chochung Bhutia. Therefore, the
Petitioners No. 1 and 2 were entitled to the Family Pension, Leave
Encashment, GPF and other Securities left behind by the deceased
and the Opposite Party No. 2 had no share in it. The Opposite
Party No.2 resisted the contentions claiming that she was married
RFA No. 19 of 2016
Smt. Domaki Bhutia & Another vs. General Public and Another
to the deceased in 2009, as per the customary rituals prevalent
amongst the Bhutia community and was equally entitled to the
pension, debts and securities left behind by the deceased. From
the evidence led by the parties and from the admission of the
Petitioner No.1 thereof, the learned Trial Court reached a finding
that besides the Petitioner No.1, the Opposite Party No.2 was also
the wife of the deceased Tempo Rapgay Bhutia, although, she had
previously been married to one Chochung Bhutia from whom she
had not obtained a divorce. Similarly, the Petitioner No.1 had also
been married to one Gyamtso Bhutia @ Khiluk Bhutia, before her
marriage to the deceased but she too did not have any decree of
divorce, from her first husband. That, in any event both the
Petitioner No.1 and the Opposite Party No.2 were protected under
Section 2(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, both being members
of the Scheduled Tribe.
4.
The finding of the learned Trial Court that both the
Petitioner No.1 and the Opposite Party No.2 are the wives of the
deceased is not being assailed herein, the only grievance of the
Petitioner No.1 is that the debts and securities ought to have been
equally divided between the Petitioners No.1 and 2 and the
Opposite Party No.2 and not between the Petitioners No.1 and 2 as
one part and the Opposite Party No.2 as another part, as ordered
by the learned Trial Court.
RFA No. 19 of 2016
Smt. Domaki Bhutia & Another vs. General Public and Another
5.
The learned Counsel for the Petitioners stressed on this
aspect and submitted that this Court grant the Petitioners No.1
and 2 also an equal share with the Opposite Party No.2.
6.
Learned Counsel for the Opposite Party No.2, however
contended that there was no error in the Order of the learned Trial
Court.
7.
I have heard the rival contentions of learned Counsel
at length and given due consideration. I have also perused the
appended documents and records of the case.
8.
What falls for determination is;
Whether the Petitioner No.1, Petitioner No.2 and the
Opposite Party No.2 are entitled to 1/3rd share each, of the
Pension and debts and securities left behind by the
deceased?
9.
It would be apposite firstly to refer to the Sikkim
Services
(Pension)
Rules,
with
Sikkim
Services
(Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1985 [Second Edition] 2014.
Rule 40 deals with Family Pension. The relevant provisions of this
Rule are extracted herein below for clarity.
“40. Family Pension.
(1)
…………………………………………………………………………….…
(2)
………………………………………………………………………….……
(3)
…………………………………………………………………………...…
(4)
…………………………………………………………………..………....
RFA No. 19 of 2016
Smt. Domaki Bhutia & Another vs. General Public and Another
(5)
.……………………………………………………………………………….
(6)
(a)(i) Where the Family Pension is payable to
more widows than one, the Family Pension shall be paid to
the widows in equal shares.
………………………………………………………………………………..…………….
(7)
(i)
Except as provided in sub-rule(6), the
Family Pension shall not be payable to more than one
member of the family at the same time.
(ii)
If a deceased Government Servant or
pensioner leaves behind a widow or widower, the Family
Pension shall become payable to the widow or widower,
failing which to the eligible child.
………………………………………………………………………………………………”
Thus, from the above Rules, it is manifest that the Family
Pension shall not be payable to more than one member of the
family at the same time, except, as provided in sub-rule(6)(a)(i),
i.e. where the deceased has left behind two widows. In such a
situation both widows are entitled to an equal share of the Family
Pension. In keeping with the Rule, the minor child is not eligible for
Family Pension.
10.
That having been said, it would now be essential to
address the question as to;
Whether the minor child would be entitled to equal
share in the debts and securities left behind by the
deceased?
11.
In Bulu Das & Ors. vs. Moni Das & Anr. 1, the Gauhati High
Court while deciding a matter under Section 10 of the Hindu
Succession Act, 1956, for distribution of property amongst heirs,
a question arose as to whether the children from the void second
1.
2003 (3) GLT 400
RFA No. 19 of 2016
Smt. Domaki Bhutia & Another vs. General Public and Another
marriage are entitled to succeed to the property of the deceased.
Following the ratiocination in Rameshwari Devi v. State of Bihar2, it
was held that the children of the said void second marriage are
entitled to an equal share with the first wife of the deceased and
her children but the second wife would not be entitled to any
share. In Rameshwari Devi2 referred to by the Gauhati High Court,
the Supreme Court had held that the marriage of the deceased
with
his
second
wife
was
in contravention of Clause 1 of
Section 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and was thus a void
marriage, however under Section 16 of the same Act, the children
of the void marriage are legitimate. Under the Hindu Succession
Act, 1956 the property of a male Hindu, dying intestate, devolves
firstly on heirs in Clause (1) which include widow and son. Among
the widow and son, they all get shares but the second wife could
not be described as the widow of the deceased, her marriage to
him being void. But, the sons of the deceased and his second wife
being the legitimate sons of the deceased, would be entitled to his
property in equal shares, along with that of the first wife and the
son born from the first marriage of the deceased.
12.
Maintaining the ratiocination of the aforesaid decision
but not losing sight of the fact that the Petitioner No.1 and the
Opposite Party No. 2, belong to the Scheduled Tribe and are under
2.
AIR 2000 SC 735
RFA No. 19 of 2016
Smt. Domaki Bhutia & Another vs. General Public and Another
the umbrella of Section 2(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, it
would be in the fitness of things to state that the Petitioner No. 1,
Petitioner No. 2 and the Opposite Party No. 2 are entitled to an
equal share each of the debts and securities left behind by the
deceased. In other words, each of them are entitled to 1/3rd share
of the debts and securities of the deceased. In fact a perusal of the
Certificate issued by the Senior Accounts Officer, Finance and
Pension Department, Government of Sikkim, dated 13.9.2013,
would clearly reveal this aspect, while at the same time indicating
that the Pension would be 50% each for the Petitioner No. 1 and
the Opposite Party No.2.
13.
In the end result, it is ordered that;
(i)
The Petitioner No.1 and the Opposite Party No.2
are entitled to 50% each of the Pension amount
of the deceased, Tempo Rapgay Bhutia.
(ii)
That, the Petitioner No.1, the Petitioner No.2
and the Opposite Party No.2 are entitled to a
1/3rd share each of the debts and securities of
the deceased, Tempo Rapgay Bhutia.
14.
Hence, the impugned Order of the learned Trial Court
is set aside and Appeal is allowed.
RFA No. 19 of 2016
Smt. Domaki Bhutia & Another vs. General Public and Another
15.
A Certificate be granted by the learned District Judge
as ordered hereinabove, on application being made thereto, in
supersession of the Certificate, if any, already granted.
16.
No order as to costs.
17.
Records
of
the
learned
Trial
Court
be
remitted
forthwith.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
22-06-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review