Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:29374
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP (FC) NO. 63 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED IN IA 20/2022 IN
GOP NO.1537 OF 2016, FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR
PETITIONER/RESPONDENT IN IA NO.20/22 AND 40/2023 IN
GOP NO.1537/2016 AND RESPONDENT IN GOP NO.1537/2016
OF FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR:
DIVYA M.S, AGED 31 YEARS,
D/O SUKUMARAN, MONEKATTU HOUSE,
KANNARADESOM, NEAR COMPANYPADI,
KANNARA P.O., THRISSUR DISTRICT,
REPRESENTED BY POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER
SUKUMARAN.M.N, AGED 71 YEARS,
S/O NARAYANAN, MONEKKATTU HOUSE,
COMPANYPADI, KANNARA, PEECHI,
THRISSUR, PIN – 680652.
BY ADVS.
PRAVEEN K. JOY
E.S.SANEEJ
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER IN IA NO.20/22 AND 40/2023 IN
GOP NO.1537/2016 AND PETITIONER IN GOP NO.1537/2016
OF FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR::
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-2-
AMITH, AGED 37 YEARS, S/O SOMAN,
THANDASSERY HOUSE, PAZHUVIL WEST DESOM,
KURUMBILAVU VILLAGE, PAZHUVIL P.O
WEST, THRISSUR TALUK, THRISSUR DISTRICT,
PIN – 680564.
BY ADVS.
DHANYA P.ASHOKAN
M.R.VENUGOPAL(K/000472/1994)
S. MUHAMMAD ALIKHAN(K/000644/2020)
ATHULYA V.R.(K/000850/2021)
THIS OP (FAMILY COURT) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION
ON 04.04.2025, ALONG WITH OP (FC).108/2024, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-3-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP (FC) NO. 108 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 04.11.2023 IN IA 26/2023 IN
GOP NO.1537 OF 2023, FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR
PETITIONER/PETITIONER IN IA NO.26 AND 27 AND RESPONDENT
IN GOP 1537/2016 OF FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR:
DIVYA.M.S, AGED 31 YEARS,
D/O SUKUMARA, MONEKATTU HOUSE,
KANNARA DESOM, NEAR COMPANYPADI,
KANNARA P.O, THRISSUR DISTRICT,
REPRESENTED BY POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER,
SUKUMARAN.M.N, AGED 71 YEARS,
S/O NARAYANAN, MONEKKATTU HOUSE,
COMPANYPADI, KANNARA, PEECHI,
THRISSUR, PIN – 680652.
BY ADVS.
PRAVEEN K. JOY
E.S.SANEEJ
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT IN IA NO.26 AND 27 AND PETITIONER
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-4-
IN GOP 1537/2016 OF FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR::
AMITH, AGED 37 YEARS,
S/O SOMAN, THANDASSERRY HOUSE,
PAZHUVIL WEST DESOM, KURUMBILAVU VILLAGE,
PAZHUVIL P.O, WEST, THRISSUR TALUK,
THRISSUR DISTRICT, PIN – 680564.
BY ADV.
DHANYA P.ASHOKAN
M.R.VENUGOPAL(K/000472/1994)
S. MUHAMMAD ALIKHAN(K/000644/2020)
ATHULYA V.R.(K/000850/2021)
THIS OP (FAMILY COURT) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION
ON 04.04.2025, ALONG WITH OP (FC).63/2024, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-5-
JUDGMENT
[OP (FC) Nos.63/2024, 108/2024]
Devan Ramachandran, J.
We propose to be as brief as possible in
this
judgment,
adverting
to
the
peculiar
circumstances and facts presented.
2.
We are disposing of both these Original
Petitions
together
because,
the
factual
circumstances involved are common.
3.
The petitioner and the respondent were
married, but divorced and admittedly, both of
them are remarried now. They have a son of 11
years
in
their
union
and
he
is
now
caught
between the fight of his parents regarding his
custody. The petitioner-mother went to Canada to
study
and
she
moved
I.A.No.26/2023
in
G.O.P
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-6-
1537/2023
before
the
learned
Family
Court,
Trissur, seeking permission to take the child
with
her;
while,
the
respondent
filed
I.A.No.20/2022 in the same G.O.P., seeking that
he be given custody of the child, so as to take
him to Dubai, where he was employed.
4.
The
learned
Family
Court
dismissed
I.A.No.26/2023 filed by the mother holding that:
‘If the child is taken to Canada there is no
doubt at all that the child will be totally
alienate from the father. Moreover in view of
the diplomatic strain between India and Canada
it will not be possible to inforce any of the
orders
of
the
court
at
Canada.
petitioner
and
step
father
become
Suppose
the
citizen
of
Canada and the child also acquired citizenship
at Canada there will be no purpose at all for
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-7-
all these proceedings. None of the orders will
be able to inforce and the father will not be
able
to
exercise
discharge
his
any
duty
of
his
towards
right
the
or
to
child.
The
petitioner has no property in India whereas the
respondent has no properties in India. So, I
find that in no circumstances, the petitioner
can be permitted to take the child to Canada. So
there
cannot
be
any
direction
to
give
authorization letter to the respondent (sic).
5.
The
learned
Court
then
allowed
I.A.No.20/2022, thus allowing the father to be
in custody of the child. For ordering so, the
learned Court concluded as under:
I find that in the happening of
change of circumstance whereby child is
alone it is necessary to give the
custody of the child to the father of
the child. It is also important to note
that UAE is a reciprocating territory
has notified by Central Government u/s
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-8-
44 A CPC. So it is easy to exercise the
control over the child by the court. In
these circumstances, I find that the
father can be permitted to take the
child to Dubai and to continue his
education at Dubai after this academic
year.
6.
After
ordering
as
above,
the
learned
Family Court reserved certain rights in favour
of the mother, to the following effect:
At the same time, the petitioner
mother will be entitled for the custody of
the child during the vacation period
whenever she came back to India. Similarly
the mother will be entitled for the
custody of the child during every 2nd
Saturday and Sunday (from 10 am on
Saturday till 5 pm on Sunday).
All
the
visitation
rights
now
available to the father as per the
mediation agreement and subsequent orders
will be equally applicable to mother.
7.
The
petitioner
challenges
both
these
orders as being illegal and unlawful.
8.
Sri.Praveen K. Joy – learned counsel for
the petitioner-mother, submitted that his client
is now returning to India permanently, and that,
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-9-
therefore, she is entitled to the custody of her
child. He asserted that, by the liberty reserved
to her in the afore extracted portion of the
order, she is fully entitled to seek the same.
9.
However,
in
Asokan,
learned
Senior
Sri.M.R.Venugopal
–
refutation,
Counsel,
learned
Smt.Dhanya
P.
instructed
by
counsel
for
the
respondent-father, submitted that the order in
question was not based on a summary procedure,
but
after
allowing
the
parties
to
trial
and
adducing of evidence. She contended that, it is
the welfare of the child which is paramount and
that
this
was
learned
Court,
orders.
She
specifically
noticed
by
the
while
issuing
the
impugned
concluded
arguing
that,
in
any
petitioner
cannot
assail
the
event,
the
orders
because,
she
admittedly
now
was
in
Canada
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-10-
throughout; and that if she is to now return to
India,
then
she
action,
but
may
cannot
obtain
a
fresh
cause
of
prosecute
these
Original
Petitions.
10.
There
is
submissions
of
the
because,
efflux
by
some
force
learned
of
time
in
the
Senior
and
afore
Counsel
conduct
of
parties, the orders impugned here have already
been implemented and are in operation.
father
11.
The
child
in
Dubai,
is
handed
admittedly
over
to
with
him
by
the
the
petitioner – mother, subsequent to the orders in
question.
12. Indubitably, therefore, as and when
the petitioner – mother returns to India, she
surely
will
obtain
a
right
to
seek
further
custodial arrangements with respect to her son;
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-11-
and this is inescapable even if specific liberty
for this had not been reserved to her in the
impugned orders. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held
it
permanent
apodictically
custody
is
that
every
essentially
order
of
interlocutory
in its tenor and that, should there be changed
circumstances, the parties can seek modification
or variation of the same appositely.
In the case at hand, if the mother is to
establish that she is back in India and thus to
urge changed circumstances, we see no reason why
she
cannot
again.
In
Smt.Dhanya
approach
fact,
the
Ashokan,
the
learned
learned
affirmed
Family
Senior
this
Court
Counsel,
as
a
proposition of law.
In the afore circumstances, we close these
Original Petitions, without intervening with the
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-12-
impugned
orders;
but
reserving
every
liberty
that may be available to the parties as per law.
Sd/-
DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
JUDGE
Sd/-
M.B.SNEHALATHA
akv
JUDGE
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-13-
APPENDIX OF OP (FC) 108/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
THE TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE POWER OF
ATTORNEY
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE MEDIATION
AGREEMENT IN GOP NO. 1537/2016 DATED
03.03.2017 OF FAMILY COURT THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE ORDER IN GOP NO.
1537/2016 DATED 24.04.2017 OF THE
FAMILY COURT THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE ORDER IN OP NO.
2178/2017 DATED 12.04.2018 OF THE
FAMILY COURT THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE ORDER IN IA NO.
3461/2018 IN GOP NO. 1537/2016 DATED
22.04.2019 OF FAMILY COURT THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN OP(FC)
NO. 530/2019 DATED 11.10.2019
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE COMMON ORDER IN
IA NO. 3707/2019 AND IA NO. 4070/2019
IN GOP NO. 1537/2016 OF FAMILY COURT,
THRISSUR DATED 27.11.2019
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE COMMON ORDER IN
IA NO.18/2022 AND IA NO. 25/2023 IN
GOP NO. 1537/2016 DATED 27.03.2023 OF
FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P9
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE PETITION
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-14-
NUMBERED AS IA NO. 26/2023 IN GOP NO.
1537/2016 FILED BEFORE FAMILY COURT,
THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P10
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE PETITION
NUMBERED AS IA NO. 27/2023 IN GOP NO.
1537/2016 FILED BEFORE THE FAMILY
COURT, THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P11
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN
OP(FC) 503/2023 DATED 10.08.20203
EXHIBIT P12
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN
OP(FC) 319/2023 DATED 24.08.2023
EXHIBIT P13
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE COMMON ORDER IN
IA NO. 26/2023 AND IA NO. 27/2023 IN
OP NO. 1537/2016 OF THE FAMILY COURT,
THRISSUR DATED 04.11.2023
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-15-
APPENDIX OF OP (FC) 63/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE POWER OF ATTORNEY
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE MEDIATION AGREEMENT
IN GOP NO. 1537/2016 DATED 03.03.2017
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE ORDER IN GOP NO.
1537/2016 DATED 24.04.2017 OF THE FAMILY
COURT THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P4
THE TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE ORDER IN OP NO.
2178/2017 DATED 12.04.2018 OF THE FAMILY
COURT THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE ORDER IN IA NO.
3461/2018 IN GOP NO. 1537/2016 DATED
22.04.2019 OF FAMILY COURT THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN OP(FC) NO.
530/2019 DATED 11.10.2019
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE COMMON ORDER IN IA
NO. 3707/2019 AND IA NO. 4070/2019 IN GOP
NO. 1537/2016 OF FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR
DATED 27.11.2019
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE COMMON ORDER IN IA
NO.18/2022 AND IA NO. 25/2023 IN GOP NO.
1537/2016 DATED 27.03.2023 OF FAMILY
COURT, THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P9
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE PETITION NUMBERED
AS IA NO. 26/2023 IN GOP NO. 1537/2016
FILED BEFORE FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P10
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE PETITION NUMBERED
AS IA NO. 27/2023 IN GOP NO. 1537/2016
2025:KER:29374
OP(FC)Nos.63/2024 & 108/2024
-16-
FILED BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P11
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN OP(FC)
503/2023 DATED 10.08.20203
EXHIBIT P12
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE PETITION NUMBERED
AS IA NO. 20/2022 IN GOP NO. 1537/2016 OF
THE FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P13
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE PETITION NUMBERED
AS IA NO. 40/2023 IN GOP NO. 1537/2016 OF
THE FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P14
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE OBJECTION IN IA NO.
20/2022 IN GOP NO. 1537/2016 OF FAMILY
COURT, THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P15
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE OBJECTION IN IA NO.
40/2023 IN GOP NO. 1537/2016 OF FAMILY
COURT, THRISSUR
EXHIBIT P16
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN OP(FC)
319/2023 DATED 24.08.2023
EXHIBIT P17
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE COMMON ORDER IN IA
NO. 20/2022 AND IA NO. 40/2023 IN OP NO.
1537/2016 OF THE FAMILY COURT, THRISSUR
DATED 04.11.2023
EXHIBIT P18
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE MARRIAGE INVITATION
LETTER
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review