The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. In such circumstances, the impugned order is hereby set aside.
22. Learned Trial Court shall issue witness summon upon the head of the institution i.e. ‘Sishutirtha Academy’ for production of the documents as mentioned in the petition dated September 2, 2025. Learned Trial Court shall proceed to decide upon the application under Section 36 of the Special Marriage Act filed on behalf of the opposite party/wife in accordance with law.
23. With the aforesaid directions/observations, C.O. 4242 of 2025 along with connected application stands disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No. J (2)
In The High Court at Calcutta
Civil Revisional Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi
C.O. 4242 of 2025
IA NO: CAN/1/2026
Dipankar Sarkar
vs.
Payel Nath (Sarkar)
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Satyam Mukherjee, Advocate
Mr. Kingshuk Dasgupta, Advocate
Ms. Debomita Biswas, Advocate
For the
Opposite Party
:
Mr. Narayan Ch. Mandal, Advocate
Mr. Bhaskar Mandal, Advocate
Heard on
:
11.09.2026
Judgment on
:
11.09.2026
Uploaded on
:
14.09.2026
MD. SHABBAR RASHIDI, J.:1. The
instant
revisional
application
has
been
filed
by
the
petitioner/husband assailing Order No.9 dated November 19, 2025,
passed by the Learned Additional District & Sessions Judge, 3rd Court,
Basirhat in Mat Suit No.19 of 2025.
2. By
the
impugned
order,
the
petition
filed
on
behalf
of
the
petitioner/husband dated September 2, 2025 praying for issuance of
C.O. 4242 of 2025
witness summon upon the head of the institution i.e. ‘Sishutirtha
Academy’ and for keeping the hearing of the petition for alimony
pendente lite in abeyance till recording of evidence of the head of the
institution i.e. ‘Sishutirtha Academy’, was dismissed.
3. It is submitted by the learned advocate for the petitioner/husband that
in a suit for divorce against the opposite party/wife, an application for
alimony pendente lite was taken out by the opposite party/wife. At the
time of hearing of such application, the petitioner/husband by two
petitions dated September 2, 2025 prayed for issuance of witness
summon upon the head of the institution, ‘Sishutirtha Academy’
where, according to petitioner/husband, the opposite party/wife has
been working for gain.
4. It
has
been
submitted
by
the
learned
advocate
for
the
petitioner/husband that the learned Trial Court did not consider the
established principles of law at the time of passing the impugned order
rejecting the prayer of the petitioner/husband.
5. Learned advocate for the petitioner/husband refers to the petition of
the divorce filed in Mat Suit No.19 of 2025. It is his submission that, in
such petition, the address of the opposite party has been shown as
working
in
‘Sishutirtha
Academy’,
Baduria
Road,
Post
Office-
Kholapota, Police Station – Matia, with the District – North 24
Parganas. Such address of the opposite party/wife was in addition to
C.O. 4242 of 2025
the residential address of the opposite party. Learned advocate for the
petitioner submits that the summons in Matrimonial Suit No.19 of
2025 was served upon the opposite party on both the addresses. He
relies upon the service report in respect of the summons in the
Matrimonial Suit.
6. Learned advocate for the petitioner submits that the opposite
party/wife has been suppressing the fact that she was a working lady
and has been earning by working in such institution. In the affidavitof-assets filed on behalf of the opposite party/wife, the opposite party
has manoeuvarably not disclosed the bank statement. Learned
advocate for the petitioner/husband submits that the impugned order
is liable to be set aside.
7. On the other hand, learned advocate appearing for the opposite
party/wife submits that the petitioner never worked in ‘Sishutirtha
Academy’. She used to go to such institution 3/ 4 days in a month for
recreation.
8. Learned advocate for the opposite party/wife further submits that the
learned Trial Court was quite justified in rejecting the prayer of the
petitioner for issuing of the witness summons upon the head of
‘Sishutirtha Academy’. He stands by the impugned order.
9. As it transpires, the petitioner instituted Matrimonial Suit No.19 of
2025 as against the opposite party/wife seeking divorce in terms of
C.O. 4242 of 2025
Sections 27(1)(b) and (d) of the Special Marriage Act, 1954. Upon
appearance in the Matrimonial Suit, the opposite party/wife filed an
application under Section 36 of the Special Marriage Act, seeking
alimony pendente lite. Such petition was being heard by the learned
Trial Court.
10. In course of hearing of such application, the parties were directed to
submit their affidavit of assets which both the parties had filed.
11. By filing an objection to such petition under Section 36 of the Special
Marriage Act, the present petitioner/husband made out a case that the
opposite party was very much working for gain and earning from
working in ‘Sishutirtha Academy’ which was sufficient for her
livelihood. He submitted therein that the opposite party/wife was not
entitled for any alimony pendente lite. Incidentally, the Matrimonial
Suit was filed by the present petitioner/husband upon an allegation
that the opposite party left her matrimonial house on her own accord.
12. In the affidavit of assets filed on behalf of the opposite party/wife, the
opposite party/wife was required to furnish copies of bank statement of
all her accounts for the last three years. In her affidavit of assets, the
opposite party disclosed that she had one bank account in SBI Bank,
Basirhat Branch but due to machinery problem, the opposite
party/wife could not update the bank passbook. This statement
according to learned advocate for the petitioner, was suppression of the
C.O. 4242 of 2025
income of the opposite party/wife which included her income from
working in the ‘Sishutirtha Academy’.
13. In course of hearing of the petition under Section 36 of the Special
Marriage Act, the present petitioner/husband approached the learned
Trial Court for issuance of witness summons to produce certain
documents upon the head of the institution of ‘Sishutirtha Academy’ in
order to ascertain whether the opposite party/wife was working with
them and/or earning any income from such work. Such application
filed by the petitioner was refused by learned Trial Court by the
impugned order.
14. On perusal of the impugned order, it transpires that learned Trial
Court refused to accept the contention of the petitioner on the ground
that the address of the opposite party working in ‘Sishutirtha Academy’
was not mentioned in the application under Section 36 of the Special
Marriage Act. It was also held by the learned Trial Court that the
petitioner/husband did not file any document or copy of document of
any other case pending between the parties on the basis of which it
could be said that the opposite party/wife is involved or engaged in the
said institution in any manner. The learned Trial Court also observed
that the petitioner/husband had mentioned the address of the opposite
party/wife working in ‘Sishutirtha Academy’ of his own without any
supporting record or document. He has also noted in the impugned
C.O. 4242 of 2025
order that the summon required to be served upon the opposite
party/wife on the address of ‘Sishutirtha Academy’. The process server
gave a report to the effect that he was informed by the head of the
institution that opposite party/wife was not attending the said
institution for last few days.
15. Learned Trial Court also held that in the facts and circumstances of
the present case, there was no need to call for the Attendance Register
etc. from the said institution i.e. ‘Sishutirtha Academy’.
16. Therefore, from the materials on record, it transpires that petition filed
on behalf of the present petitioner seeking production of certain
document from the institution i.e. ‘Sishutirtha Academy’ where,
opposite party used to work was refused by the learned Trial Court. It
was held by learned Trial Court that the matter with regard to alimony
pendente lite was to be decided on the basis of affidavit and no
evidence was required to be produced.
17. It is true that an application under Section 36 of the Special Marriage
Act is required to be considered and decided in a summery manner on
the basis of affidavit evidence but, at the same time, it is to be borne in
mind that such affidavit evidence filed on behalf of the parties must
disclose the true facts. As I have noted hereinabove that by filing the
affidavit of assets, the opposite party/wife has refrained from disclosing
her income and the source thereof on the plea of machinery problem
C.O. 4242 of 2025
resulting
in
non-updation
of
passbook.
If
that
be
so,
the
petitioner/husband cannot be debarred from bringing forth the
documents which would unearth the truth.
18. However, in the instant case the parties were directed to submit their
affidavits of assets in the proceeding. The parties submitted such
affidavits, but the opposite party/wife withheld valuable information
with regard to her bank account on the ground of machinery problem.
As per the case of the parties as made out in their respective affidavits,
the petitioner/husband made out a case that the opposite party/wife
was earning by working in ‘Sishutirtha Academy’ and for such reason
she was not entitled for alimony pendente lite.
19. On the contrary, it was the case of the opposite party/wife that she
had no income of her own. She was a destitute lady and she was very
much dependent on alimony to be provided by the present petitioner.
There were contentious claims between the petitioner/husband and
opposite party/wife which could have been decided on the basis of
documents
sought
to
be
produced
at
the
behest
of
the
petitioner/husband.
20. In such view of the facts, the learned Trial Court was not justified in
refusing the prayer of the petitioner for calling for the head of the
institution to produce relevant documents with regard to the
C.O. 4242 of 2025
employment of the opposite party/wife, if any, in the institution i.e.
‘Sishutirtha Academy’.
21. In such circumstances, the impugned order is hereby set aside.
22. Learned Trial Court shall issue witness summon upon the head of the
institution i.e. ‘Sishutirtha Academy’ for production of the documents
as mentioned in the petition dated September 2, 2025. Learned Trial
Court shall proceed to decide upon the application under Section 36 of
the Special Marriage Act filed on behalf of the opposite party/wife in
accordance with law.
23. With the aforesaid directions/observations, C.O. 4242 of 2025 along
with connected application stands disposed of.
24. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
25. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied expeditiously after complying with all necessary legal
formalities.
(Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J.)
CHC
CHINMOY CHAKRABORTY
Date: 2026.09.14 17:38:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review