Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
RFA No. 03 of 2019
Ms. Dinku Khati, aged about 41 years,
Daughter of late Tek Bahadur Khati,
R/o Utpal Nagar, Road No. 4,
Siliguri-734003, P.O. Anchal,
P.S. Pradhan Nagar, West Bengal
C/o Ms.Shanti Ramudamu,
Near Tathangchan School,
Upper Tathangchan.
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
...Appellant/Plaintiff
Versus
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba,
Wife of Shri Ashok Kumar Subba (Tsong),
R/o National Highway 10,
Sisa Golai,
P.O. Gangtok & P.S. Sadar,
East Sikkim.
…Respondent/Defendant
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, C.J.
For Appellant
: Ms.Gita Bista, Advocate.
For Respondent
: Mr. Vivek Anand Basnett, Advocate.
Date of Hearing
: 17.03.2020.
Date of Judgment
: 24.03.2020
JUDGMENT
This appeal is preferred by the plaintiff against the judgment and decree
dated 27.02.2019 passed by the learned District Judge, East Sikkim at
Gangtok, in Money Suit No. 14 of 2015, dismissing the suit of the plaintiff,
whereby recovery of Rs.32,47,200/- was prayed for along with interest of 18%
from date of filing till final execution.
2.
The case of the plaintiff, in a nutshell, as projected in the plaint is as
follows:
(i)
The plaintiff, who is a practicing Advocate, was introduced to the
defendant by the husband of the defendant, Mr. Ashok Kumar Subba (Tsong),
in the year 2009 and she had rendered legal assistance to the husband of the
defendant and his other family members. Husband of the defendant had
started a company in the name of M/s Zingtang Consultancy & Service Pvt.
Ltd. and she had accepted the post of Legal Advisor in that company. It is
pleaded that the defendant had approached the plaintiff in and around August,
2009 for a loan of Rs.2,00,000/- for the purpose of payment of fees of the
daughter of the defendant who was studying in Australia with a promise to
repay the loan within two months. With much difficulty, the plaintiff managed
to collect the said amount and delivered the same to the defendant without
executing any document. Though the plaintiff had asked for repayment of the
loan after two months, the amount was not paid. Nevertheless, the plaintiff
arranged one rented flat belonging to one Nima Gurung at Siliguri for the
defendant and her family members to stay at Siliguri.
(ii)
In respect of default of payment of loan of Rs.90,00,000/- taken by
the defendant from the United Bank of India, Deorali Branch, a notice under
Section 13(2) of SARFAESI Act, 2002 was issued to the defendant as well as to
her husband, who was the guarantor and an amount of Rs.18,41,540/- was
paid by Mr. Ashok Kumar Subba (Tsong) from the account of the company
towards loan repayment.
The bank loan dues of the defendant mounted to
Rs.1,42,00,000/- and to save the property, the defendant requested the
plaintiff to manage a loan of Rs.6,00,000/- which she stated would be paid
with interest along with Rs.2,00,000/- taken earlier. It is the further case of
the plaintiff that she mortgaged a plot of land along with two dwelling flats
belonging to her late father, namely, Tek Bahadur Khati to one Chandra
Bhusan Tiwari for Rs.6,00,000/- which was to be repaid by her within a period
of six months. The plaintiff paid the defendant the amount of Rs.6,00,000/- in
two installments: one of Rs.5,00,000/- on 25.05.2011 and the other a sum of
Rs.85,000/- out of Rs.1,00,000/- on 22.12.2011 after deducting 15% interest
at the source itself. The defendant, despite approaches made by the plaintiff,
did not repay the loan with interest accrued thereon forcing the plaintiff to
borrow money from her brothers, namely, Mr. Amit Khati and Mr. Manish
Khati, to pay the accrued interest.
(iii)
A Possession Notice as well as a Sale Notice dated 26.03.2012
were served on the defendant on 23.02.2012 by the Bank in connection with
the loan taken by the defendant and in the aforesaid situation, the defendant
approached the plaintiff expressing her inability to repay the loan and to
protect the building constructed by her husband before the Debt Recovery
Tribunal, the defendant had taken a loan from the plaintiff amounting to
Rs.6,79,000/-. It is pleaded that the plaintiff paid the aforesaid amount from
the amount received by her by cheque dated 10.04.2012 from one of her
clients, namely, Ashok Lama.
(iv)
A sum of Rs.35,000/- was also stated to be paid by the plaintiff by
cash and another sum of Rs.5,000/- was deposited in the account of Mr.
Yehang Subba, son of the defendant, on 20.04.2012, on being requested by
the defendant when her son had gone to Delhi for his treatment of
Tuberculosis.
(v)
The plaintiff also stated to have mortgaged her gold ornaments for
a sum of Rs.2,45,305/- to safeguard the property of the defendant and handed
over the said amount to the defendant.
(vi)
It is stated that plaintiff had borrowed a sum of Rs.72,895/- on
19.04.2012 from Leela Shilal, Rs.2,20,000/- on 11.07.2012 from Manju Khati,
Rs.2,00,000/-
on
04.09.2012
from
Sashi
Khati
and
Rs.8,50,000/-
on
29.04.2012 from Jyoti Subba, totaling Rs.13,42,895/- and the said amount
was given to the defendant on various dates by executing a Hand Note/Money
Receipt dated 16.07.2013. In the meantime, though the plaintiff continued to
appear in the legal proceedings, due to non-payment of dues, physical
possession of the mortgaged building was taken over by the Bank on
20.03.2014.
(vii) It is further pleaded that by an Agreement dated 21.04.2013, the
defendant had sold the property, namely, M/s Hotel Golmaheem for a
consideration amount of Rs.3,00,00,000/- and received an advance amount of
Rs.1,56,00,000/-, but in spite of that, the loan amount was not paid to the
plaintiff. It is stated that as despite the execution of Hand Note dated
16.07.2013, the defendant did not pay the amount to the plaintiff for long two
years, the plaintiff was compelled to file the suit.
3 (i) In the written statement filed by the defendant, it is stated that the
plaintiff was introduced not by her husband, but by Mr. B. Sharma, Senior
Advocate, with whom the plaintiff was working as a junior and the family
members of the defendant had only formal relation as she often came with Mr.
Ashok Kumar Subba, who used to extract money from the defendant. Many
cases were filed against the plaintiff and Mr. Ashok Kumar Subba in connection
with the functioning of the company and they were also arrested on allegation
of cheating people of various places.
(ii)
It is categorically stated that she had never approached the
plaintiff for any loan and the plaintiff had made a fabricated story. It is pleaded
that it was Mr. Ashok Kumar Subba, who rented a flat for himself and not for
the defendant and her family members. The defendant had admitted about
availing of loan and issuance of notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI
Act. The defendant denied that she ever received any amount from the plaintiff
and she also stated that she had not received any amount from her husband.
Rather, it was Mr. Ashok Kumar Subba, who had taken a sum of more than
Rs.10,00,000/- from the defendant for the purpose of a case in the Gauhati
High Court.
(iii)
It is pleaded that she had never taken or agreed or promised to
pay the amount of Rs.6,00,000/- with interest of 5% and Rs.26,47,200/-. She
also denied her signature on the said hand-note. It is submitted that the
plaintiff, in collusion with Mr. Ashok Kumar Subba, had been maliciously and
fraudulently trying to extract money and accordingly, a false and concocted
case has been filed.
4.
On the basis of the pleadings, learned trial Court framed the following
two issues:
(i)
Whether the defendant is liable to pay a sum of Rs.32,47,200/- to
the plaintiff, and
(ii)
5.
Relief, if any.
During trial, plaintiff examined herself as PW1 and Ashok Kumar Subba
as PW2. In support of her case, she exhibited a number of documents.
6.
The defendant examined herself as DW1 and her sons as witnesses in
the form of DW2 and DW3.
7.
The learned trial Court held that the plaintiff could not prove advancing a
loan amount of Rs.2,00,000/- by her oral evidence. Learned trial Court also
held that advancing of loan amount of Rs.6,00,000/- is also not proved. It was
observed that Exhibit-4 contains names of other persons and there is no
indication that any money was received by the defendant from the plaintiff to
substantiate her claim. Exhibits - 5, 6, 7 and 8 show that the plaintiff received
certain amounts from different persons. None of the persons from whom the
plaintiff received the amount has been examined and therefore, the said
exhibits have no relevance in respect of the claim of the plaintiff. The learned
trial Court also noticed that plaintiff failed to exhibit any document to show
mortgage of gold ornaments of plaintiff for giving a sum of Rs.2,43,305/- to
the defendant. With regard to the Hand Note dated 16.07.2013, the learned
trial Court observed as follows:
“The evidence of the Plaintiff and her witness is in contrary with
respect to the documents i.e. Hand Note dated 16.07.2013. Further, it
may be noted here that although the Plaintiff heavily relied the Hand
Note document i.e., Exhibit-9, however, on careful perusal of the content
of the evidence-on-affidavit of the Plaintiff at paragraph 24 and the
content of the Hand Note Exhibit-9, is contrary. Further, it may be noted
here that content of the Hand Note Exhibit-9 is no consonance with the
contents of the plaint. There is serious materials contradiction.
On careful perusal of the evidence of the Plaintiff and her witness,
it is seen that the Plaintiff failed to prove the content of Exhibit-9, simply
on mere exhibiting the document is not sufficient to grant any relief in
favour of the Plaintiff. Further, the Defendant denied the execution and
her signature appeared in Hand Note Exhibit-9. However, the Plaintiff did
not make any effort to examine the handwriting expert to prove its
contents.
It is to be noted here that although the expert opinion
supported the case of the Plaintiff that the signature affixed in written
statement marked A1 to A15 and the specimen signatures affixed
marked S-1 to S-20 are similar in nature and characteristic. However, on
the basis of the handwriting expert, case of the Plaintiff would be
successed unless the document and its content is verified and proved. It
is seen on record that the opinion of handwriting expert is inadmissible
since the contents of the same is not proved by either of the party.”
8.
Ms. Gita Bista, learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the
learned trial Court failed to appreciate the evidence on record in its correct
perspective. It is submitted by her that the learned trial Court erred in law in
holding that Exhibits-4 series, 5, 6, 7 and 8 do not substantiate the claim of
the plaintiff. While candidly admitting that there was some confusion with
regard to the marking of the Hand Note as Exhibit as at various places the
same is referred to as Exhibit-9 or Exhibit-10, the same does not go to the root
of the matter and in that background, learned Court below failed to appreciate
the Hand Note. It is submitted that the learned trial Court was seriously in
error in holding that the plaintiff failed to prove the contents of the Hand Note.
She contends that it was the defendant who had requested the learned trial
Court to send the Hand Note for the opinion of the hand-writing expert and the
hand-writing expert having opined that the signature of the defendant in the
Hand Note matches with her admitted signature, the learned trial Court
wrongly shifted the burden to the plaintiff and drew adverse presumption for
not examining the hand-writing expert. She submits that this Court may also
compare the specimen signature of the defendant with the admitted signature
of the defendant. The learned trial Court was wrong in holding that Exhibit-9
was not proved by either of the parties. According to her, the plaintiff had
proved by leading cogent evidence that a sum of Rs.32,47,200/- is payable by
the defendant to the plaintiff and as such the learned Court below was not
justified in dismissing the suit of the plaintiff. Ms. Bista has cited a judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of H.K.N. Swami vs. Irshad Basith
(Dead) By LRS., reported in (2005) 10 SCC 243.
9.
While supporting the impugned judgment, Mr. Basnett submits that
entirely a false case has been filed by the plaintiff and there is no pleading
even to show as to how a sum of Rs.32,47,200/- was due and payable by the
defendant to the plaintiff. There is not even one single document other than
the so called Hand Note evidencing receipt of money by the defendant from the
plaintiff. Bald statements have been made without any material particulars
regarding payment of money by the plaintiff to the defendant as loan. None of
the persons from whom the plaintiff stated to have received money for the
purpose of making available loan to the defendant has also been examined. It
is submitted that there is no cordial relation between the defendant and Ashok
Kumar Subba, who stood as alleged witness in the Hand Note.
10.
Drawing attention of the Court to paragraph 21 of the plaint, he submits
that the Hand Note dated 16.07.2013 was stated to be executed for an amount
of Rs.13,42,895/-, which is contradicted in paragraph 26. In that Hand Note,
reference is also made to the civil case of T. Lachungpa, B. Jain, etc. about
whom there is no pleading whatsoever. He has submitted that the Hand Note
was exhibited as Exhibit P-9 and the FIR was exhibited as Exhibit P-10 and
therefore, it has to be understood that the plaintiff did not prove the Hand
Note when repeatedly reference was made to Exhibit-10.
11.
He has submitted that it is true that the Hand Note was sent for the
opinion of the handwriting expert on the request of the defendant. However, as
the defendant was not satisfied with the report, prayer was made for sending
the same to another handwriting expert but such prayer was rejected by an
order dated 05.12.2017 on the ground that the defendant would get an
opportunity to cross-examine the said expert. In view of the aforesaid order, it
was for the plaintiff to have examined the handwriting expert, if so desired, but
the plaintiff did not examine him and therefore, no reliance can be placed on
the so called report of the handwriting expert. In support of his submissions,
he places reliance on the cases of Bhagwan Kaur v. Shri Maharaj Krishan
Sharma and others, reported in AIR 1973 SC 1346 and Life Insurance
Corporation of India and another vs. Ram Pal Singh Baisen, reported in
(2010) 4 SCC 491.
12.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties and
have perused the materials on record.
13.
H.K.N Swami (supra), relied on by Ms. Bista, lays down that the first
appellate Court has to deal with all the issues and the evidence laid by the
parties before recording findings.
14.
The plaintiff submitted her evidence on affidavit, reiterating the version
put forward in the plaint.
15.
PW2 referred to the Hand Note dated 16.07.2017 as Exhibit P10 and he
deposed that Exhibit P10 (a) is the signature of the defendant, which was
signed in his presence. In cross-examination, he denied the suggestion that
Exhibit 10(a) is not the signature of the defendant.
16.
The DW1, in her evidence stated that the plaintiff had never provided
any financial assistance to her and she had also not asked for any financial
help. She denied execution of the Hand Note. It is stated that the plaintiff and
her estranged husband had maliciously connived and filed the suit with ulterior
motive. In her cross-examination she stated that her relation with the husband
was cordial till the end of 2013. The suggestion given to her that the plaintiff
transferred a sum of Rs.2,00,000/- to her daughter in Australia through
Western Union Money Transfer, Nepal was denied. The suggestion that she had
borrowed money from the plaintiff’s mother was also denied. She also denied
the suggestion that she was in Guwahati from 15.07.2013 to 17.07.2013.
17.
DW2 deposed that his estranged father and the plaintiff had never looked
after him and had not taken care of his medical expenses as alleged. He stated
that signature appearing in the Hand Note is not that of his mother. He denied
taking of any loan by his mother. It is stated that his mother did not go to
Guwahati on 16.07.2013 and because of her illness whenever she travels long
distance his elder brother or his wife mostly accompanies DW1 and sometimes
he also accompanied her.
18.
The evidence of DW3 is also more or less the same line as that of DW2.
He also denies that the signature appearing in the Hand Note is not of his
mother and that mostly he or his wife and, occasionally, DW2 accompanies
DW1 on her long distance travel and that she did not go to Guwahati on
16.07.2014 (apparently year is wrongly written). He denied the suggestion
that on 15.07.2014 (year again wrongly written), DW1 had boarded the flight
to Guwahati with Senior Counsel B. Sharma. DW3 had denied the suggestion
that plaintiff had transferred Rs.2,00,000/- from Nepal in the bank account of
his sister, who was then studying in Australia.
19.
Law is well-settled that the plaintiff has to succeed on his own strength
and not on the weakness of the case of the defendant.
20.
A perusal of the evidence goes to show that the plaintiff claims to have
given a loan of Rs.2,00,000/- for payment of fees of her daughter, who was
studying in Australia. When the said loan was given and in whose presence, if
any, is, however, not indicated. This amount of Rs.2,00,000/- is the first loan
claimed to have been advanced by the plaintiff to the defendant. The
suggestion given to DW1 that money was transferred to her daughter through
Western Union Money Transfer, Nepal gives a different dimension which was
not pleaded. If money was transferred in the above manner, the plaintiff could
have definitely pleaded so and also adduced documentary evidence.
21.
Another loan of Rs.5,00,000/- was said to have been given on
25.05.2011 and an amount of Rs.85,000/- was handed over on 22.11.2011 out
of an amount of Rs.1,00,000/- from which 15% was deducted. These amounts
were said to have been given on the basis of a sum of Rs.6,00,000/- received
by the plaintiff by mortgaging a plot of land with two dwelling flats belonging
to her father to one Chandra Bhusan Tiwari. No mortgage deed is exhibited by
the plaintiff. How plaintiff could have mortgaged her father’s land is not
explained. Four receipts are collectively marked as Exhibit-4. By the Exhbit-4
series, one Bushan Tiwari acknowledges receipt of interest of various amounts
of from one Bidhya Khati, who is the mother of the plaintiff. In all these
receipts, loan amount was shown as Rs.5,00,000/-, contrary to the stand of
the plaintiff that she had obtained a loan of Rs.6,00,000/- through the
mortgage. Bushan Tiwari and Chandra Bhusan Tiwari, evidently, in absence of
any explanation, have to be treated as different persons. That apart, name of
the plaintiff does not figure in the said receipts. Signatures appearing therein
are not proved. It is also significant to note that in one of the receipts dated
19.06.2011 Ashok Kumar Subba signed on 13.09.2011 as a witness. Exhibit-4
series do not substantiate taking of loan by the plaintiff for the purpose of
making available the amount as loan to the defendant.
22.
Another sum of Rs.6,79,000/- was said to have been taken on loan by
the defendant from the plaintiff. It is the stand of the plaintiff that the said
amount was paid by the plaintiff after receiving the amount by cheque from
one of her clients, namely, Ashok Lama on 10.04.2012. How the amount is
paid to the defendant is not indicated. The cheque was not exhibited and
Ashok Lama was also not examined. It is a self-serving statement.
23.
With regard to the loan amount of Rs.35,000/- as well as Rs.5,000/-
also, no date has been mentioned as to when the loan was paid.
24.
With regard to the amount of Rs.2,45,305/-, there is no evidence that
the defendant asked for the amount as loan as the aforesaid amount was only
handed over to the defendant thereby signifying a voluntary act. The said
amount was stated to have been obtained by the plaintiff by mortgaging her
gold ornaments. It is not stated to whom gold was mortgaged. No document is
produced demonstrating that she had pledged or mortgaged or pawned some
gold for obtaining some amount.
25.
The plaintiff also said to have given to the defendant a sum of
Rs.13,42,895/- on various dates after collecting the same from Sashi Khati,
Manju Khati, Jyoti Subba and Leela Shilal. The plaintiff had exhibited Exhibits5, 6, 7 and 8, which are receipts signed by her and stated to have been signed
by Sashi Khati, Manju Khati, Jyoti Subba and Leela Shilal, respectively. As
none of them have been examined, Exhibits-5, 6, 7 and 8 cannot lead to a
conclusion that the plaintiff had taken money from them.
26.
The plaintiff exhibited the Hand Note dated 16.07.2013 as Exhibit-9.
Where this document was executed is not mentioned in this document. PW1
stated in her cross-examination that the document was executed in Guwahati.
The address of the defendant was shown at Sikkim in the said document. No
cogent and reliable evidence was led by the plaintiff to establish that she was
in Guwahati on that date.
27.
In cross-examination of the plaintiff, the Hand Note was referred to as
Exhibit-10. She admitted that apart from the Hand Note, she does not have
any other document to support her claim for a sum of Rs.32,47,200/-. She
denied a suggestion that the defendant did not execute or sign the Hand Note
and that she had forged the signature of the defendant. It is noted earlier that
PW2 had exhibited the same as Exhibit-10 and DW1, 2 and 3 had also referred
to the Hand Note as Exhibit-10. This Court will not hazard a guess how it has
happened. The learned trial Court, though had given much emphasis on the
above discrepancy, I am of the considered opinion that the said discrepancy
will not have any bearing as evidently the parties were aware that they were
referring to the Hand Note.
28.
The plaintiff had to, in the first place, prove that she was capable or was
in a position to, may be by herself obtaining loans from others, to provide
loans to the defendant. Giving a go by to the case projected in the plaint,
suggestion was given to DW1 that she had borrowed money from the mother
of the plaintiff. In the context of the case projected by the plaintiff that no
documents were executed at the time when defendant had received the
amounts as stated by the plaintiff and when substantial amount of loan which
the plaintiff claims to have advanced to the defendant as loan was received by
the plaintiff herself from others, it was necessary for the plaintiff to have
examined persons from whom she had availed loan to lend credence to the fact
that she had, at least, obtained some loan though the same may not have
proved advancing of loan to the defendant.
29.
In Ram Pal Singh Baisen (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
mere admission of document in evidence does not amount to its proof. In other
words, mere marking of exhibit on a document does not dispense with its
proof, which is required to be done in accordance with law. Contents of the
documents are required to be proved either by primary evidence or by
secondary evidence. Admission of documents may amount to admission of
contents but not its truth.
30.
It is evident from the evidence on record that though a report of hand-
writing expert was received by the learned trial Court, the hand-writing expert
was not examined. The Court cannot rely on the report of the handwriting
expert unless he is examined and unless the same is admitted by the parties.
It is to be noted that Expert evidence, though relevant in view of Section 45 of
the Evidence Act, is not conclusive. It can rarely, if ever, take the place of
substantive evidence. As stated in Bhagwan Kaur (supra), evidence of
handwriting expert is of a frail character unlike that of a fingerprint expert. A
Court is competent to compare the disputed writing of a person with others
which are admitted or proved to be his writings. However, it may not be safe
for a Court to record a finding about a person’s writing in a certain document
merely on the basis of expert comparison, but a Court can itself compare the
writings in order to appreciate properly the other evidence produced before it
in that regard.
31.
The Hand Note (without the signatures) reads as follows:
“HAND NOTE DOCUMENT
I, Kamal Kumari Subba, wife of Shri Ashok Kumar Subba (Chong),
resident of Sisa Golai, NH31A, Gangtok, East Sikkim, do hereby
undertake I shall pay a sum of Rupees 6,00,000/- (six lakhs) with
interest of 5% and Rs.26,47,200/- (twenty six lakhs fourty seven
thousand and two hundred) only, on or before 15 th September, 2013 to
Ms, Dinku Khati, which I have borrowed to same from Dinku Khati as my
legal expenses incurred in DRT case at Guwahati, Civil Cases of T.
Lachungpa, Binod Jain, at Gangtok and for the study of my daughter
Ningwaphuma Subba at abroad (Australia).
I DO HEREBY PROMISE to pay the aforesaid loan to Ms. Dinku
Khati, D/o Late Tek Bahadur Khati, resident of Utpal Nagar, Road No. 4,
Siliguri, P.O. Anchal & P.S. Pradhan Nagar, District Darjeeling, West
Bengal, on or before 15th of September, 2013, and if I fail to repay the
same amount she can recovered the same by filing money recovery suit
in the competent court of law.
I FURTHER UNDERTAKE to pay the said amount on or before the
said date failing which I shall be held liable for criminal breach of trust,
cheating and other penal provisions also.
I sign this document on this date 16th day of July, 2013 in presence
of witnesses.”
32.
It will be appropriate to extract the relevant part of paragraph 21 of the
plaint, which is as follows:
“xxxxxxx For this purpose, the plaintiff borrowed some amount
from her friend and relatives, details of which are as under:
1.
Leela Shilal
Rs.72,895/-
on 19/04/2012
2.
Manju Khati
Rs.2,20,000/-
on 11/04/2012
3.
Sashi Khati
Rs.2,00,000/-
on 04/09/2012
4.
Jyoti Subba
Rs.8,50,000/-
on 29/04/2012
A sum of Rs.13,42,895/- (Thirteen Lacs Forty Two Thousand Eight
Hundred and Ninety five) was borrowed as above and the said money
has been given to Defendant on the various dates and further executing
Hand note(s) Document/Money Receipt on 16/07/2013.
The copy of the Money receipts are annexed herewith and marked
collectively as Annexure-14 (Colly).”
It is to be noted that the above extract without the annexure part was
repeated in the evidence in affidavit of the PW1 at paragraphs 23 and 24.
33.
Paragraph 26 of the plaint reads as follows:
“That after much pursuance by the plaintiff and after several
request,
the
defendant
issued
the
Hand
Note
Document
dated
16.07.2013 wherein she has agreed and promise to pay the amount of
Rs.6,00,000/- (six lacs) only with interest of 5% and Rs.26,47,200/- only
to the plaintiff on or before 15.09.2013. The said Hand Note was signed
before the witnesses, Shri Ashok Kumar Subba (Tsong) the husband of
the defendant and Ms. Usha Khati, sister of the plaintiff.
Copy of the Hand note Document dated 16/07/2013 is annexed
herewith and marked as ANNEXURE-17.”
It is to be noted that the aforesaid paragraph without the annexure part
was repeated in the evidence in affidavit of the PW1 at paragraph 29.
34.
In
the
pleadings,
there
is
no
explanation
how
the
amount
of
Rs.32,47,200/- was accounted for. Perusal of the aforesaid paragraphs would
go to show that the pleadings and evidence in respect of the Hand Note cannot
be reconciled. It is also on record that the defendant has an estranged
relationship with Ashok Kumar Subba, husband of the defendant. The other
witness in the Hand Note is also an interested witness, being the sister of the
plaintiff. It is not pleaded what was the rate of interest on the loan amount of
Rs.6,00,000/- though a statement is made in the plaint that the amount will be
paid with interest. In the Hand Note, rate of interest is shown as 5% for the
amount of Rs.6,00,000/-. It is somewhat odd that plaintiff had claimed that the
amount of Rs.5,00,000/- and Rs.1,00,000/-, which she had obtained on
mortgaging her father’s property, carried an interest of 8% on Rs.5,00,000/and loan of Rs.1,00,000/- was to be repaid with interest of 15%. In the
pleadings as well as in evidence, there is no reference to any civil cases of T.
Lachungpa, Binod Jain, at Gangtok. How the amount of Rs.26,47,200/- has
been calculated has not been explained. The loans stated to have been
advanced by the plaintiff, without taking into account Rs.6,00,000/-, comes to
Rs.25,05,200/- only.
35.
In view of the discussions above and taking note of the evidence
adduced by the plaintiff, I am of the considered opinion that the learned trial
Court was correct in holding that plaintiff had failed to prove her case.
36.
Resultantly, finding no merit, the appeal is dismissed.
37.
No cost.
38.
Lower Court records be sent back.
Chief Justice
jk/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review