Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
(1)
wp9627779611
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 9627 OF 2011
Dinesh Ramesh Thakur,
Age : 28 years, Occu. Nil,
R/o Ordinance Factory Estate,
Subhash Nagar, Type 1/19/147,
Bhusawal, Tq. Bhusawal,
District Jalgaon.
PETITIONER
VERSUS
1.
The State of Maharashtra,
through its Secretary,
Home Department, Mantralaya,
Mumbai 32.
2.
The Deputy Superintendent
of Police (Home) (Rural),
Thane Rural, Tq. & Dist. Thane.
3.
The Scheduled Tribe Certificate
Scrutiny Committee, Nandurbar
Division, Nandurbar
RESPONDENTS
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 7796 OF 2011
Vina Eknath Saindane @
Vijaya Pramod Thakur,
Age : 43 years, Residing
at 11, Shivsagar Apartment,
Pathare Park, Ambarnath (East),
District Thane.
1.
VERSUS
The State of Maharashtra,
through its Secretary,
Tribal Development Department,
Mantralaya, Mumbai 32.
PETITIONER
(2)
wp9627779611
2.
The Scheduled Tribe Certificate
Scrutiny Committee, Nandurbar
Region, Nandurbar, through its
Member Secretary, having its
office at Nandurbar,
District Nandurbar.
3.
Brihanmumbai Mahanagarpalika
through its Chief Accountant
(W & S Deptt.), Room no. 300,
3rd Floor, Mahanagarpalika Marg,
Boribandar, Mumbai.
4.
Executive Magistrate,
Amalner, Dist. Jalgaon.
6.
Mumbai Housing and Area
Development Board, the Regional
Unit of Maharashtra Housing
and Area Development Authority,
having its office at Griha Nirman
Bhavan, Kala Nagar, Bandra (E),
Mumbai 51.
RESPONDENTS
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 15395 OF 2011 IN W.P. 7796 OF 2011
Adivasi Mahasang, Nandurbar
Through its Regional President
Shri Suhas Vechya Naik
APPLICANT
VERSUS
Vina Eknath Saindane @
Vijaya Pramod Thakur and others
RESPONDENTS
....
Advocate for the petitioners
Mr. M.S. Deshmukh, Advocate holding for Mr. Vijay B.
Patil, Advocate with Mr.A.S. Golegaonkar, Advocate in
W.P.No.9627/2011.
Mr. R.K. Mendadkar, Advocate
Advocate in W.P.No.7796/2011.
with
Mr.
A.S.
Bayas,
(3)
wp9627779611
A.G.P. for the respondent/State
Mr. V.D. Godbharle, A.G.P. for Respondent Nos. 1 & 2
in W.P. No. 9627/2011 and for Respondent Nos. 1 & 4
in W.P. No. 7796/2011.
Advocate for the respondentCommittee
Mr. P.P. More, Advocate in W.P. 9627/2011.
Mr. P.S. Patil, Advocate in W.P. No. 7796/2011.
Advocate for the Intervenor
Mr. V.D. Sapkal, Advocate for the Intervenor.
AND
Mr. S.B. Talekar, Advocate, as an Amicus Curiae
in both the Writ Petitions. (Appointed)
....
CORAM : B.R. GAVAI & M.T. JOSHI, JJ.
DATE OF RESERVING
DATE OF PRONOUNCING
: 5th JANUARY, 2012
: 28th MARCH, 2012
JUDGEMENT (PER : M.T. JOSHI, J.) :
1.
Rule.
Rule made returnable forthwith.
The
Writ Petitions are taken up for final hearing, with
the consent of the learned counsel for the parties.
2.
Civil Application no.15395 of 2011, seeking
intervention
allowed,
for
applicant
is
Petition.
in
Writ
the
Petition
reasons
permitted
to
no.7796
stated
intervene
of
is
therein.
The
in
Writ
the
(4)
3.
wp9627779611
In these Petitions, common questions of law
have arisen upon rejection of the claims of the Writ
Petitioners,
by
the
respondentScheduled
Tribe
Certificate Scrutiny Committee, that they belong to
Thakur Scheduled Tribe.
4.
One of the grounds in common for rejection
of the claims of each of the petitioners is that mere
old
entries
in
the
school
record
that
either
the
petitioners or their ancestors shown as belonging to
Thakur Caste, has no relevance and as such, one of
the factors for determination is as to whether the
petitioners or their ancestors had migrated from the
area for which the Thakur tribe and other subtribes
of Thakur were declared as Scheduled Tribe before the
removal of area restriction by Act No.108 of 1976.
The respondentScrutiny Committee has held that the
removal of area restriction by Act No.108 of 1976
would not enable any person belonging to any tribe/
community
to
claim
the
status
of
Thakur
Scheduled
Tribe, and he will have to establish that he or his
predecessors
have
prescribed area..
migrated
from
the
earlier
(5)
5.
the
wp9627779611
Since the said common question had arisen in
present
Petitions,
the
Writ
Petitions
were
clubbed together by the Court.
Further, finding that
an
the
important
issue
concerning
status
of
large
number of persons would be involved, the Court has
requested
Shri
S.B.
Talekar,
learned
Advocate,
to
appear as an Amicus Curiae, to assist the Court in
the matters.
Shri Talekar has graciously accepted to
act as such and the submissions made by him bear out
our expectations.
6.
The
common
reasons
given
by
the
Scrutiny
Committee in each of the matter, on this aspect, in
short, are as under:
.
That
Thakur,
Thakar,
KaThakur,
MaThakur,
MaThakar
are
Scheduled
Tribes
Maharashtra
of
included
in
at
KaThakar,
the
serial
list
of
no.44.
Further, Thakar is included in the list of Nomadic
Tribes at serial no.22.
These people lead nomadic
way of life, who move from village to village and are
mainly found in Ratnigiri and Sindhudurg districts.
Thakur
is
an
advanced
caste,
known
as
Thakur,
(6)
KshatriyaThakur,
RajputThakur,
PardeshiThakur,
Thakur
is
also
wp9627779611
VaishyaThakur,
found
Grambhat, Bramhabhat.
in
SindhiThakur,
etc.
Balutadar
Further,
castes
such
as
Therefore, it is important to
verify whether each of the applicants had proved his
claim as belonging to Thakur, i.e. a Scheduled Tribe,
listed at serial no. 44 in the list of Scheduled
Tribes
of
Maharashtra.
Merely
because
the
caste
Thakur appeared in the documents would not clearly
distinguish
the
social
status
of
Therefore,
besides
necessity
considering
traits,
characteristics
of
the
incumbent.
affinity
and
tests
by
traditional
customs of the claimant, it is also necessary to find
out as to whether the claimants or their ancestors
have migrated from any place situated in 25 Tahsils
of
five
districts
of
Western
Maharashtra
as
were
listed in the list of Scheduled Tribes prior to the
removal of area restriction of 1976 i.e. between 1956
and
1976.
The
intention
behind
removal
of
area
restriction was to entitle the tribal persons who are
migrated and staying outside the restricted area to
claim
Scheduled
belonged
to
Tribe
status.
different
However,
communities
those
who
do
not
(7)
wp9627779611
automatically become eligible to claim such status of
Scheduled Tribe.
7.
On the basis of these reasonings and finding
that neither the petitioners nor their ancestors had
migrated from 25 Tahsils alongwith other grounds and
reasons
claims
recorded
of
these
by
the
Scrutiny
petitioners,
that
Committee,
the
they
to
belong
Thakur Scheduled Tribe were negativated.
8.
Before adverting to the arguments advanced
by learned counsel for the parties, the history as
regards the status of Thakur as Scheduled Tribe qua
restricted area is necessary to be borne in mind.
9.
The President had initially promulgated the
Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950 on 6th
September, 1950, in exercise of the powers conferred
by Clause (1) of Article 342 of the Constitution.
As
regards the then State of Bombay, in Part III of the
Schedule of the Presidential Order of 1950, entry no.
was
dealing
with
"Thakur".
Thus,
sofar
as
erstwhile Bombay State was concerned, Thakurs were
declared to be the Scheduled Tribes.
(8)
10.
On
25th
enacted
the
Scheduled
wp9627779611
September,
1956,
Castes
and
the
Parliament
Scheduled
Tribes
Order (Amendment) Act, 1956 interalia to amend the
said Order of 1950 and certain areas of 25 Tahsils
from six districts like Ahmednagar, Sindhudurg etc.
were declared as areas for Thakur or Thakar including
KaThakur, KaThakar, MaThakur, MaThakur.
11.
After two decades thereafter, the Advisory
Committee
appointed
by
the
Department
of
Social
Security, Government of India has made its report on
the
question
Scheduled
of
Castes
revision
and
of
Scheduled
the
lists
Tribes
in
of
the
various
other States, including the State of Mahrashtra.
The
Committee opined that due to the area restriction, no
person
could
be
legally
regarded
as
a
Member
of
Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe for the purpose of
Constitution unless he belongs to the listed caste or
tribe and also resided in the specified locality.
In
the opinion of the Committee, this has led to the
anomalous situation as the members of the same caste
or tribe from ethnical or social point of view were
deprived
of
the
special
privileges
and
benefits
(9)
wp9627779611
merely because they resided in different parts of the
same State. Such area restriction was also criticized
within and outside the Parliament as it operated as a
clog
on
social
mobility,
as
the
communities
would
confine themselves to the specified area lest they
lose
the
special
privileges
or
benefits
by
moving
outside the specified areas. In view of the report of
the
Advisory
Committee,
ultimately,
the
bill
was
presented and the Parliament enacted the Act no.108
of 1976 viz. Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
(Amendment) Act, 1976.
provided
for
Section 4 of the said Act of
deletion
of
the
provision
regards entry no.44 in relation to the area.
as
In this
background, since 1976 entry no.44 in the relevant
Scheduled Tribe Order dealing with Maharashtra, now
reads as under:
"44. Thakur, Thakar, KaThakur,
MaThakur, MaThakar...."
12.
While
the
arguments
from
the
KaThakar,
side
of
the
petitioners revolved around the claim that in view of
the removal of area restriction, an enquiry into the
fact as to whether a person or his ancestors belonged
(10)
wp9627779611
to the areas which were earlier specified for the
purposes
of
the
said
Scheduled
Tribes,
would
be
against the mandate of Parliament, learned counsel
for the Scrutiny Committee, Mr. P.S. Patil submitted
that as one of the tests to determine as to whether a
particular person belongs to Thakur Scheduled Tribe,
enquiry in this regard is not impermissible.
13.
Mr.
S.B.
Talekar,
learned
amicus
curiae,
however, submitted that for a considerable period of
time, though there is a stupendous advancement in the
social
and
economic
life
of
the
country,
the
Government has not appointed any Advisory Committee
since
to
look
into
the
various
aspects
of
revision of the lists. He therefore, with his usual
persuasive skill, advanced his submissions and wanted
us to enlarge the scope of the present Writ Petitions
and to issue directions to the Government of India
for appointment of a new Commission, as is provided
by the Constitution of India.
14.
However, in view of the limited issue before
us, we are not inclined to enlarge the scope of the
(11)
wp9627779611
present Petition and would confine ourselves to the
question
involved
in
the
present
Writ
Petitions
including the common question of permissibility or
otherwise of examining the migration or otherwise of
the
petitioners
or
their
ancestors
from
the
area
earlier provided in the list.
15.
False claims of belonging to a particular
caste or tribe, appear to have increased in view of
the special treatment permitted by the Constitution
of India.
The phenomenon though in recent past has
grown tremendously, the same is not unknown.
16.
Mahabharata, the great epic of India gives
an illustration of great mythological figure 'Karna'
in
this
regard.
Feeling
the
dire
technique
of
Brahmastra,
acquisition
of
approaches
Master
Parshuram
necessity
with
a
of
Karna
false
representation that he belongs to Brahmin caste which
solely, according to Parshuram, was qualified to have
the
said
Brahmastra
vidya
(technique).
After
rigorous tutelage under Parshuram for one year, Karna
obtains Brahmastra vidya from him.
However, on the
very last day of his training period, a misfortune
(12)
wp9627779611
occurs, which, according to Parshuram, reveals the
true caste of Karna.
While, Guru Parshuram takes a
nap on the lap of Karna, in a forest, an insect gnaws
the thigh of Karna.
the
Sensing the warmth of the blood
oozing
from
wound,
Guru
Parshuram
suddenly
awakes.
He starts questioning Karna, as according to
Guru Parshuram, a great tolerance shown by Karna in
remaining steady, though an insect gnawed his thigh,
is
a
sole
Ultimately,
Brahmin.
characteristic
of
Karna
admit
had
to
a
'Kshatriya
Varna'.
that
was
he
not
A curse befalls Karna from Parshuram to the
effect that at the very juncture when Karna would be
in dire need to use BrahmastraVidya, he would forget
the same.
17.
Whether the determination of characteristic
of a Kshatriya by Guru Parshuram, is a scientific or
unscientific method, is not required to be considered
here.
The question as to whether a particular person
belongs to a particular caste or tribe, however, has
vexed the sociologists, legislators and the judges
alike.
In order to fulfill the dream of having an
egalitarian
society,
the
Constitution
of
India
(13)
provided
for
definite
wp9627779611
advancement
of
the
underprivileged section of our society in all walks
of life.
Number of phonyes however started claiming
and still are claiming to be of a particular caste or
tribe for whom the benefits are provided.
18.
The joint committee on the bill interalia
to provide for the inclusion in and exclusion from
the list of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in
its
report
dated
17th
November,
had
vide
paragraph no.20 clause (iv), while dealing with the
recommendations
for
amendment
to
the
Constitution
(Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950, interalia reported
as under :
"(iv)
For
the
specification
of
communities as scheduled tribes, the
Committee
adopted
as
the
criterion
indications
of
primitive
traits,
distinctive
culture,
geographical
isolations, shyness of contact with the
community
at
large
and
backwardness. ....."
19.
In
"Shilpa
Vishnu
Thakur
v.
State
of
Maharashtra and others" 2009 (5) AIR Bom R 478, the
Full Bench of this Court in paragraph 37 has adverted
to
a
monograph
by
Prof.
R.K.
Mutatkar,
Honorary
(14)
wp9627779611
Professor of Anthropology at the University of Pune,
entitled `Tribal Identity: Policy Issues'.
The broad
parameters to be applied in determining the tribal
characteristics
are
given
in
the
said
monograph,
which are as follows :
20.
sides
(i)
Primitive traits;
(ii)
Distinct culture;
(iii)
Geographical isolation;
(iv)
Distinct dialect;
(v)
Animism;
(vi)
Clan systems;
(vii)
Shyness of nature; and
(viii)
Backwardness.
The
was
enquiry
in
on
main
thrust
of
arguments
the
scope
of
and
reference
to
the
of
both
limitation
above
on
the
the
characteristics
could be made in individual cases by the respondent
Scrutiny Committee and consequently the courts. While
battery of the learned counsels for the petitioners
relied in catena of cases as well as the minutes of
(15)
wp9627779611
the discussion held in the Parliament on the subject,
the foremost support was sought from the ratio in
"Palghat Jilla Thandan Samudhaya Samrakshana Samithi
Vs. State of Kerala 1994 (1) S.C.C.
359".
other
Patil
hand,
learned
counsel
respondentScrutiny
judgments
of
this
Committee
Court,
Mr.P.S.
relied
including
on
the
On the
for
the
various
Full
Bench
Judgment in the case of "Shilpa Vishnu Thakur Vs.
State of Maharashtra and ors. 2009(5) A.I.R. BOM (R)
478".
21. I)Palghat
Jilla
Thandan
Samudhaya
Samrakshana
Samithi Vs. State of Kerala 1994 (1) S.C.C. 359.
The
Supreme
question
as
Court
to
of
India
whether
the
was
dealing
claimant
with
the
residing
in
Palghat district of Kerala was belonging to Thundan
Scheduled Caste or not.
The State Government had
asserted
no
that
there
was
Thundan
Community
in
Palghat district, except in certain parts of Chittur
taluka.
The State Government also claimed that when
it had made certain enquiries after the inclusion of
(16)
wp9627779611
the Thundans in the Scheduled Castes Order by reason
of amendment Act of 1976, it was found that some
sections of
Ezhavas of the Malabar area were also
called Thundans but they had nothing common with the
Scheduled
Caste
Thundan.
In
view
of
the
Scheduled
Castes and Scheduled Tribes Order (Amendment) Act,
1976, the Thundan Community throughout the State of
Kerala came to be included in the list of Scheduled
Castes.
issued
In 1984, the State Government of Kerala had
an
Order
that
all
its
earlier
Orders
were
cancelled and Thundans throughout the State of Kerala
would be treated as members of the Scheduled Castes.
This Order was, however, modified by another Order
dated 24th November, 1987, specifying that though a
person from the Thundan Caste throughout the State of
Kerala would be treated as member of Scheduled Caste,
while
issuing
authorities
verification
such
caste
should
that
the
certificate,
ascertain
person
the
after
concerned
revenue
proper
belongs
to
Thundan caste and not Ezhavas/Thiyyas.
.
In
the
circumstances,
the
Supreme
Court
(17)
wp9627779611
noted that once in view of the provisions of the
Constitution
(Scheduled
Castes)
Order,
Thundans
throughout the State of Kerala were entitled to be
treated as Scheduled Caste, it was not open to the
State
Government
purported
to
do
to
in
say
the
otherwise,
Order.
as
it
had
It
was
also
further declared that it was not open to the State
Government
enquiry
or
to
indeed
to
courts
determine
Ezhavas/Thiyyas
which
to
whether
was
Malabar area of the State,
called
embark
a
upon
section
Thundan
in
an
of
the
was excluded from the
benefits given to Thundan Scheduled Castes.
II)
Nityanand Sharma and anr. Vs. State of Bihar
and others (1996) 3 S.C.C. 576
The Supreme Court in this case also held that it was
not permissible for the Courts to consider whether
Lohars or Lohras are declared to be Scheduled Tribes.
III) Kumari Madhuri Patil Vs.Additional Commissioner,
Tribal Development 1994 (6) S.C.C. 241
In
this
case,
the
Supreme
Court
was
whether
Kolis,
a
backward
class
in
considering
the
State
(18)
Maharashtra
could
be
wp9627779611
declared
as
Mahadeo
Kolisa
Scheduled Tribe in the State of Maharashtra.
The
Supreme Court held that it had no power to declare
them
synonymous
or
as
equivalent
to
the
tribes
specified in the Order.
IV)
Heikham Surchandra Singh and others. Vs.
Representative of "LOIS" Kakching, Manipur
(A Scheduled Caste Uplift Body) and others (1997)
2 S.C.C. 523
It was again reiterated in this case that for the
purposes
under
of
Constitution,
Article
(25)
Scheduled
as
Tribes
substituted
defined
by
the
subsequent Act and the II Schedule thereunder, are
conclusive
by
adding
"though
evidence
may
be
admissible to a limited extent of finding out whether
the community which claims the status of Scheduled
Caste or Scheduled Tribe was, in fact, included in
the Scheduled concerned, the Court is devoid of power
to
include
declare
in
or
synonymous
exclude
a
from
Scheduled
or
Caste
substitute
or
or
Scheduled
Tribe or parts thereof or a group of such caste or
(19)
wp9627779611
tribe."
V)
State of Maharashtra Vs. Milind Katware
and others 2001 (1) Mh.L.J. 1
In this case, the same principle was reiterated when
the claimant therein claimed that his tribe as Halba
Koshti also stands included in entry no.19 which has
listed Halba, Halbi as Scheduled Tribe.
VI)
Shilpa Vishnu Thakur Vs. State of Maharashtra
and ors. 2009(5) A.I.R. BOM (R) 478
The
Full
required
Bench
to
of
this
Court,
in
decide
the
question
this
case,
relating
to
was
the
standards which have to be applied for determining
whether or not a claimant belongs to a designated
Scheduled Tribe.
The Full Bench took notice of the
fact that attempts were made over a period of time by
certain persons belonging to nontribal communities
to claim tribe status on the assertion that their
community
being
synonymous
with
a
tribe
or
group
which is specified in the notification or the list.
The
Full
Bench
again
took
the
survey
of
all
the
(20)
wp9627779611
authorities on the issue. The problems of fraudulent
claims were also adverted to and it was ultimately
held that in the course of verifying the correctness
of a caste certificate, the Scrutiny Committee is not
precluded from inquiring into whether the applicant
has indeed
established his membership of a notified
tribe
for
and
this
purpose
the
enquiry
is
not
confined merely to consideration of the documentary
evidence, relied by the claimants.
VII)
State of Maharashtra & others v.Ravi
Prakash
Babulasing Parmar & another, 2006 AIR SCW
This case had arisen out of a direction by a Division
Bench of this Court to the Tribe Scrutiny Committee
for
according
greater
credence
to
the
documentary
evidence as against the oral evidence. The Supreme
Court held that the Scrutiny Committee is a quasi
judicial body and it was constituted to prevent fraud
on
Constitution
and
the
Scrutiny
Committee
is
not
precluded from inquiring into whether the claimant
has,
in
fact,
notified tribe.
established
his
membership
of
a
(21)
22.
wp9627779611
In "Shilpa Vishnu Thakur" (supra), the survey
of judgements delivered by various Division Benchs of
this Court was also taken by the Full Bench and it
was ultimately concluded that the information given
during
the
course
of
personal
hearing
from
the
candidate regarding the traditional occupation of his
family, deities worshiped, surnames in the community,
the place of residence, diet and the attire of the
women, is also required to be considered.
23.
The
Full
Bench
in
its
conclusion
at
requirements
as
paragraph
has
approved
the
prescribed
by
Rule
Maharashtra
of
the
Scheduled
Tribes (Regulation of Issuance and Verification of)
Certificate
Rules,
2003,
which
interalia
provides
for disclosure of the information by the claimant of
the place from which he originally hailed.
24.
Specifically sofar as the present issue is
concerned,
the
Full
Bench
adverted
to
series
of
decisions of the Division Benches of this Court, and
quoted
the
observations
made
in
"Shri
Murlidhar
Ramkrishna Gathe v. State of Maharashtra", 2007 (4)
(22)
wp9627779611
AIR Bom R 103, supplemented by comments, as under :
"This court has judicially recognised, that
the word or surname "Thakur" is shared by
both forward and backward communities. The
burden of proving that the person belongs to
a S.T./S.C./O.B.C. lies heavily on the
person seeking the certificate. The role of
the Vigilance Committee is to conduct an
enquiry to ascertain and verify the material
produced by the candidate including as to
traits and characteristics claimed. If the
material
and
information
on
traits,
characteristics, customs, deities and other
information did not relate to Thakur S.T.
further
verification
of
that
material
normally would be uncalled for. The law as
declared in Madhuri Patil (supra) would
require verification of the information
given. If that information was associated
with the Thakur S.T. then to rule out that
the information given was based on bookish
knowledge, the vigilance enquiry is required
to be conducted to establish that the
evidence produced is genuine. Once the
committee with whom are associated experts,
conversant with the anthropological and
ethnological
traits
and
other
characteristics of the community, rule out
the association of the Petitioner to that
community, the burden is on the Petitioner
to establish otherwise. That burden has not
been discharged.
From the affidavit in reply filed by the
Research Officer, the Court noted that the
petitioner hailed from Khamgaon in Buldhana
District. Before the area restrictions were
removed in 1976, the Thakur Scheduled Tribe
was restricted only to five Districts,
namely (a) Ahmednagar District in Akola,
Rahuri and Sangamner Taluka, (b) in Kolaba
District (now Raigad), Karjat, Khalapur,
Pen,
Panvel
and
Sudhagad
Talukas
and
Matheran (c) In Nashik District Igatpuri,
Nashik and Sinnar Talukas (d) In Thane
District Thane, Kalyan, Murbad, Bhiwandi,
(23)
wp9627779611
Vasai, Wada, Shahapur, Palghar, Jawhar and
Mokhada talukas. It was not the case of the
petitioner that his family had migrated to
Khamgaon from any of these areas. The
population of the Thakur Scheduled Tribes in
Maharashtra increased from 1,78,805 in the
year 1971 to 3,23,191 in the year 1981.
Dealing with this, the Division Bench
observed as follows:
"This cannot be explained as a normal
reproduction process leading to the
increase in the population of S.T.
within 10 years. Scheduled Tribes by
their very nature stay close to their
original habitat unless they have
migrated for work or education which
very few still do. This sudden spurt,
can reasonably be explained, that
persons who did not belong to Thakur
S.T. because they also bore a surname
Thakur made false claims as belonging
to Thakur S.T. though they did not
belong to Thakur S.T."
The
Court
observed
that
the
Scrutiny
Committee was justified in applying the
affinity test. The petition was accordingly
dismissed."
25.
Ultimately, the Full Bench observed in paragraph
35 as under :
"We have adverted to the Judgments of the
Division Benches of this Court in order to
emphasise that the line of reasoning that
has
been
followed
is
that
before
an
applicant can be validly regarded as being
eligible to receive the benefits attached to
being a member of a Scheduled Tribe, the
burden lies on the applicant to establish
membership of the tribe. An inquiry into
whether the applicant belongs to a Scheduled
Tribe is not precluded by the Presidential
(24)
wp9627779611
Order or by the Judgments of the Supreme
Court in Palghat Jilla Thandan and Milind
Katware. For the purposes of determining as
to whether an applicant belongs to a
Scheduled Tribe, the Scrutiny Committee has
to be satisfied on the basis of all the
available material on the record that such
is the position. The material on the record
would include documentary evidence and oral
evidence and comprehend the application of
the affinity test."
26.
be
It can thus be found that while the enquiry to
made
by
the
Scheduled
Tribe
Scrutiny
Committee
is
having a wider scope, the specific question as to whether
the place of residence of the claimant or his ancestor can
be the subject of the enquiry, is dealt with in the case
of
"Shri
Murlidhar
Ramkrishna
Gathe"
(supra)
and
approved by the Full Bench.
The Supreme Court in "Palghat Jilla Thandan
27.
Samudhaya
referred
Samrakshana
above,
Samithi"
declared
that
and
the
other
courts
cases,
have
no
power to add, delete, or read anything more in the
lists.
The issue before us is radically different
i.e. whether a Tribe Scrutiny Committee is competent
to
inquire,
interalia,
into
original
place
of
residence of a particular person who claims to be a
member of the Scheduled Tribe.
This inquiry is not
(25)
wp9627779611
prohibited, as is clear from the Full Bench decision
of this Court in "Shilpa Vishnu Thakur" (supra) .
28.
for
Mr.
the
P.S.
Patil,
Respondent
learned
Scrutiny
counsel
appearing
Committee,
further
relied on a decision in "Deepika Subhash More v. the
State of Maharashtra and others"
(Writ Petition No.
1953/2007, decided by a Division Bench of this Court
on 22nd March, 2007), "Dattu Namdeo Thakur vs. the
State of Maharashtra and others" (a group of writ
petitions
bearing
Writ
Petition
No.
7813/2009
and
others, decided by a Division Bench of this Court on
14th
December,
2009),
as
well
in
"Chetan
Yuvaraj
Thakur vs. the State of Maharashtra and others" (Writ
Petition No. 2791/2011, decided on 21st April, 2011
by a Division Bench of this Court to which one of us
(M.T. Joshi, J.) was a party.
29.
State
In the case of "Deepika Subhash More v. the
of
Maharashtra
and
others"
(supra),
the
petitioner therein claimed to be belonging to Thakur
Scheduled Tribe.
The ordinary place of residence of
the petitioner's family was Upkhed, Taluka Chalisgaon
(26)
in Jalgaon district.
the said place
wp9627779611
The Division Bench noted that
was not a scheduled area for Thakur
tribe as provided earlier from 1956 till 1976.
The
Court,
was
therefore,
observed
that
it
incomprehensible that only one family of the Thakurs
is
residing
at
Upkhed
since
the
time
immemorial.
Therefore, the Division Bench opined that the said
circumstance
is
rightly
held
to
be
against
the
petitioner by the Tribe Scrutiny Committee.
30.
In paragraph no.5 of the said Judgement, the
Division
Bench
has
observed
that
removal
of
area
restriction by the Act of 1976 meant that the persons
coming from Thakur community would have to establish
that they or their predecessors have migrated from a
scheduled
area
restrictions.
after
the
removal
of
the
area
In review application, these specific
observations were, however, deleted.
31.
State
In the case of "Dattu Namdeo Thakur vs. the
of
petitioners
Maharashtra
therein
and
were
others"
(supra),
the
ordinary
residents
of
various villages in Jalgaon district.
The Division
(27)
wp9627779611
Bench of this court relying in "Shilpa Vishnu Thakur"
(supra), has declared that the consequence flowing
from such removal of area restriction by itself would
not allow a person to stake a claim to be belonging
to
Thakur,
Scheduled
Tribe,
unless
such
person
establishes that his forefathers have migrated from
hilly area/tribal area or that they form group of
tribals
in
the
particular
area.
This
decision,
however, is admittedly a subject matter in a
Special
Leave Petition pending before the Supreme Court of
India, for consideration.
In the case of "Chetan Yuvaraj Thakur vs.
32.
the State of Maharashtra and others" (supra), finding
that
the
petitioner
therein
failed
in
one
of
the
tests i.e. he or his ancestors hailed from the hilly
area,
the
ultimate
finding
of
the
Tribe
Scrutiny
Committee, dismissing the claim of the petitioner,
was held valid. This judgement was also subject of
Special Leave Petition before the Supreme Court. The
learned counsel for the petitioners, however, pointed
out that the order of the Supreme Court in the said
Special Leave Petition 14193/2011 would show that the
(28)
wp9627779611
said findings regarding migration from a particular
hilly
area
was
not
assailed
in
the
Special
Leave
Petition.
33.
The petitioners, on the other hand, relied
on another judgement of the Division Bench of this
Court in the case of "Prakash s/o Rambhau Thakur v.
The State of Maharashtra and another (Writ Petition
No. 2016/2007, decided on 10th September, 2009), to
which one of us (B.R. Gavai, J.) was a party.
In
that case, though the Tribe Scrutiny Committee had
already
validated
relations
of
the
the
tribe
certificate
petitioner,
namely,
of
blood
Angadh
petitioner's real brother, Arun petitioner's son
and
petitioner's
two
daughters
Bhagyashali
and
Swapna, applying the affinity test and conducting the
home enquiry, the claim of the petitioner Prakash
was
invalidated
however,
allowed
lateron.
The
writ
basically
on
the
petition
ground
that
was,
the
petitioner cannot be failed in the affinity test once
his
blood
relations
including
his
son
and
real
brother are already held to be belonging to Thakur
Scheduled Tribe.
(29)
wp9627779611
In the case of "Vaibhav s/o Subhash Thakur
34.
v. The State of Maharashtra and others (Writ Petition
No. 5940/2008,
decided
on
9th
October,
by
a
Division Bench of this Court, to which one of us
(B.R. Gavai, J.) was a party), one of the issues was
that the ordinary residence of the petitioner was not
from
hilly
sister's
area.
tribe
Finding
claim
was
that
the
already
petitioner's
validated
by
the
Scrutiny Committee, his petition was also allowed.
35.
vs.
Similarly,
The
Petition
State
No.
in
of
"Vijay
s/o
Maharashtra
2135/2007,
decided
Dayaram
and
on
Sonawane
others
9th
(Writ
September,
2009, by a Division Bench of this Court, to which one
of us (B.R. Gavai, J.) was a party), as the identical
issues were there i.e. validation of the claim of the
petitioner's brother and daughters, the petitioner's
claim was also upheld by the Division Bench.
36.
Besides
the
fact
of
validations
of
the
claims of the kith and kin of the petitioners, as
detailed supra, it was also found that the Committee
(30)
wp9627779611
had also taken into consideration the report of the
Vigilance
Cell
and
had
applied
the
affinity
test
while validating the tribe certificate of those blood
relations.
judgments
Therefore, reliance placed on the said
by
the
petitioners
is
misplaced,
as
the
issue involved in the present cases did not arise
therein.
37.
We need not dilate over the issue as, in our
view, upon removal of the area restriction by the
amending
Act
particular
of
1976,
Scheduled
the
persons
Tribe,
belonging
though
to
residing
a
in
different areas than earlier specified or migrated
from the said area, can also claim to be belonging to
the same Scheduled Tribe.
respondent
Tribe
In our view, however, the
Scrutiny
Committee
is
not
prohibited from applying the test of original place
of residence as one of the factors to be considered
in arriving at a decision of validation of the claim
of the claimant in view of the clear pronouncement of
law in Full Bench decision of this Court in "Shilpa
Vishnu Thakur Vs. State of Maharashtra and others,
quoted supra.
(31)
38.
wp9627779611
Though galaxy of the lawyers, appearing in
the present proceeding, enlightened us on the aspect
of history of the subject, reports of the Commissions
together with the Minutes of the Discussion held in
the Parliament at various points of time, as we have
clear
declaration
of
law
on
the
issue
before
us,
there is no necessity to find material from these
external aids.
39.
In
view
of
above
discussion,
now
it
is
necessary to consider the respective cases before us.
WRIT PETITION NO. 7796 OF 2011 :
The Scrutiny Committee had taken into consideration
the Vigilance Enquiry Report, the oral as well as
documentary
evidence
petitioner.
It was also found that the petitioner
and
his
District
forefathers
Jalgaon
i.e.
placed
before
are
residents
the
area
far
it
of
away
by
the
Amalner,
from
the
Tahsil places from which originally the members of
Thakur Scheduled Tribe hailed.
Further, none of the
blood relations had at any point of time been granted
(32)
any validation certificate.
the
reasoning
recorded
wp9627779611
In view of these facts,
by
the
Tribe
Scrutiny
Committee, which is a quasijudicial forum, cannot be
termed
as
unreasonable.
The
petition,
therefore,
fails.
40.
WRIT PETITION NO. 9627 OF 2011 :
The
present
case
petitioner
also
hail
and
his
from
ancestors
Bhusaval,
in
the
District
Jalgaon. The Scrutiny Committee after applying the
affinity test and also taking into consideration the
Vigilance Cell Report, invalidated the claim of the
petitioner.
The
petitioner
had
relied
on
the
validity certificate of Kalpana d/o Ramdas Thakur.
The photocopy of the affidavit of said Kalpana filed
on record shows that she is a distant relative of the
petitioner Dinesh.
The findings of the respondent
Committee would show that the certificate of validity
was issued to said Kalpana by another Tribe Scrutiny
Committee i.e. the Committee at Nasik, merely on the
basis of ratio in the judgement in Writ Petition No.
2746 of 1998 and two other writ petitions, decided by
the Aurangabad Bench of this High Court.
In that
(33)
wp9627779611
view of the matter, the reasoning recorded by the
Tribe Scrutiny Committee in the present case is based
on relevant material before it and those cannot be
disturbed.
In the circumstances, this petition also
deserves to be dismissed.
41.
In the result, both the writ petitions are
dismissed,
without
any
order
as
to
costs.
stands discharged.
[M.T. JOSHI, J.]
NPJ/wp9627779611
[B.R. GAVAI, J.]
Rule
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review