Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 607 of 2023
Dibyendu
Chakraborty,
son
of
late
Dwijendra
Chakraborty, resident of Town Gobindapur, PO & PSKailashahar, District- Unakoti Tripura.
…………… Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the
Commissioner & Secretary to the Rural Development
Department, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat
Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala, PO- Kunjaban, PS- New
Capital Complex.Sub-Division- Sadar, District- West
Tripura.
2.
The Director (Projects), State Level Monitoring
Cell of SGSY, Rural Development Department, Government
of Tripura, Agartala, District- West Tripura.
3.
The Chief Executive Officer, Office of the District
Magistrate & Collector, Unakoti Tripura, District Rural
Development Agency, Kailusahar. District- Unakoti Tripura.
4.
The
Project
Director
(Additional
District
Magistrate & Collector, Unakoti Tripura). District Rural
Development Agency, Kailasahar, District- Unakoti Tripura.
.………….. Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. Koomar Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing
:
08.04.2024.
Date of pronouncement
of Judgment and order :
09.04.2024
Whether fit for reporting:
NO.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment and Order
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Koomar Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also
heard Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. representing the State
respondents.
[2]
The present writ petition has been filed under Article 226 and
Article 14 of the Constitution of India for issuance of a writ of mandamus
and/or
in
the
nature
thereof,
for
directing
the
respondents
to
revoke/rescind the impugned order dated 27.07.2023 extending other
benefits as sought for in this writ petition.
[3]
The case of the petitioner in brief is that after retiring from Armed
Forces, the Petitioner joined the post of Accounts Officer, in the District
Rural
Development
Agency
(DRDA
for
short),
North
Tripura
on
10.09.2001. Thereafter, by a memo dated 11.03.2002, issued by the
Chief Executive Officer (District Magistrate & Collector), DRDA, North
Tripura, the salary of the Petitioner was revised and fixed from
Rs.6,000/- to Rs.7,000/- per month, with effect from 01.03.2002. It is
contended in the writ petition that prior to completion of one year of
service of the petitioner, the Chief Executive Officer (District Magistrate &
Collector), DRDA, North Tripura issued a Memo dated 18.06.2002,
thereby extending the tenure of service of the petitioner for a period of
two years with effect from 10.09.2002 to 09.09.2004, and his salary was
revised and fixed from Rs.7,000/- to Rs.7,500/- per month, with effect
from 01.09.2002. In the meantime, the petitioner was called for an
interview for the regular post of Accountant, in the Rajya Sainik Board,
Government of Tripura, Agartala to be held on 21.11.2002 as per
direction of the Army Placement Cell, Office of the Director General of
Resettlement, Government of India, New Delhi and it is submitted that
the petitioner appeared at the said interview for selection to the regular
post of Accountant, in the Rajya Sainik Board whereat, he emerged out
successful and stood first in the merit list.
[4]
Thereafter,
the
petitioner
submitted
a
letter
dated
25.11.2002 to the Chief Executive Officer (District Magistrate & Collector)
DRDA, North Tripura, thereby requesting him for issuance of „No
Objection Certificate‟, in favour of the petitioner to enable him to join the
post of Accountant, in Rajya Sainik Board, Government of Tripura. It is
submitted that before expressing any opinion or decision with regard to
the prayer of the petitioner for issuance of „No Objection Certificate‟, with
the approval of the Chairman, DRDA, the Chief Executive Officer (District
Magistrate & Collector), DRDA, North Tripura issued a memo dated
18.12.2002, by which regular pay scale was sanctioned to the Petitioner.
For the purpose of reference, the relevant contents of the said
memorandum dated 18.12.2002 (placed at Annexure-10 to the writ
petition) is extracted herein-below:
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DISTRICT RURAL DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
NORTH TRIPURA : KAILASHAHAR
Dated 18th December 2002.
No. 4758-59/F.15(9/B)-RD/1998-99
MEMO
Shri Dibyendu Chakraborty, currently working in this Agency as Accounts Officer
on contract basis with consolidated salary of Rs.7500/-(Rupees Seven thousand five
hundred) only per month is here by allowed to draw his salary in the scale of Rs,7,45013,000/- with immediate effect for the period of contract.
This is issued with the approval of Chairman, DRDA and in partial modification of
Memo. No.F.15(9/B)/RD/98-99/955-56 dated 18.6.2002,
(R.K. De Choudhury)
Sd/Chief Executive Officer
District Rural Development Agency
North Tripura: Kailashahar”
[5]
It is further submitted that only after the issuance of the
above mentioned memorandum, negating the prayer of the petitioner
regarding grant of No Objection, the Chief Executive Officer (District
Magistrate & Collector), DRDA, North Tripura issued a letter dated
27.12.2002, thereby intimating the Secretary, Rajya Sainik Board,
Government of Tripura that DRDA was not in a position to spare the
services of the petitioner, at that juncture. After completion of 10 years
of service, on 01.10.2011, the Petitioner was granted the benefit of ACPI. On 20.08.2013, the Respondents indicated the name of the petitioner
under the section of DRDA Borne Employees (Regular). It is contended
that on various occasions, the post of the petitioner was reflected as he
was holding the regular posts. On 03.02.2016, the respondents agitated
that the post held by the Petitioner is regular and thereafter on
11.07.2018, the respondents stated that the post held by the Petitioner is
a Permanent post (and not Contractual).
[6]
On 12.09.2019, the Petitioner was granted the benefit of
MACP-11 (w.e.f. the date of completion of 17 years of service).
Thereafter, on 20.03.2021, the Project Director, DRDA communicated
that retirement benefits, amounting to Rs.19,47,600/- (under the heads
of Gratuity & Leave Encashment) is to be released, in favour of the
Petitioner. On 31.12.2021, the Petitioner proceeded to retirement.
Subsequently, on 15.01.2022, the Petitioner submitted representation,
requesting for releasing his post retiral benefits etc. but, as the same was
not granted to the petitioner, he had earlier filed a writ petition [WP(C)
No.197 of 2022) before this Court, and this Court by an order dated
16.05.2023, directed the respondents to consider the case of the
Petitioner. Thereupon, the respondents issued the impugned Order dated
27.07.2023, regretting the claims of the Petitioner. The said impugned
order issued by the respondents is quoted herein below:
“Government of Tripura
Rural Development Department
Secretariat New Capital Complex
Agartala; West Tripura
No.F.2(24)-RD/SGSY/Part/2022/219-21
Dated. Agartala, the 27th July, 2023
ORDER
WHEREAS, Sri Dibyendu Chakraborty, Ex- Accounts Officer, DRDA, Unakoti has
filed a case before of the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura vide case no. W.P(C) 197
of 2022 seeking justice for (i) release the retirement benefit of the petition such
as gratuity and leave encashment benefit with interest and (ii) to release the
salary of the petitioner for the period of July, 2021 to December, 2021 along with
the enhancement of periodical increment which was due as on 01.07.2021 and
also (iii) to release the arrears of pay from October, 2018 to May, 2020 as per
revision of pay vide TCS (1st Amendment) Rules 2018;
AND
WHEREAS, The Hon'ble High Court of Tripura case No. WP(C) 197 of 2022
passed an Order which was disposed of on 16.05.2023 with the direction that the
case of the Petitioner to considered in accordance with the law within a period of
2 (two) months from the date of receipt of copy of the order;
AND
WHEREAS, the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura passed order dated 16.05.2023 of
the writ petition case No. WP(C) 197 of 2022 and the petitioner have eventually
submitted a representation on 07.06.2023. On examination of the available
records of the petitioners the following points transpire;
Sri Dibyendu Chakraborty. Ex Accounts Officer of DRDA Unakati was engaged on
contractual basis with filling up vacant post of DRDAs with Advertisement vide
Notification No. F.15 (9)/B/RD/98-99/663 dated 27-06-2000 where the post of
the Accounts Officer was purely on contract basis as per the Memo no.
F.15(9/B)/RD/1998-99/1407-1409, dated 6.09.2001 in DRDA, Unakoti District.
The following terms and conditions were attached to his contractual engagement;
(i) The appointment is made on contract basis for one year and purely temporary
basis.
(ii) The period of contract may be extended from time to time if required by this
Agency.
(ii) The appointee shall not have any right for permanent absorption in the post
of Accounts Officer;
AND
WHEREAS, Sri Dibyendu Chakraborty. Ex-Accounts Officer of DRDA Unakoti was
discharging his duties as purely contractual employee with the contract period
valid upto 05.12.2019. But, it has come to the notice of DRDA, Unakoti that Sri
Chakraborty have been drawing monthly remuneration up to the month of June,
2021 i.e. excess monthly remuneration drawn for 18 monthly 27 days. As the
services of Sri Chakraborty has not been rendered by the Unakoti, DRDA for the
period of July, 2021 to December, 2021, the tour cum working report submitted
by Sri Chakraborty for the same period has not been accepted by the Project
Director, DRDA, Unakoti;
AND
WHEREAS, The Department has notified the "District Rural Development
Employee Death Cum Retirement and Leave Encashment Regulations of Tripura,
2014" vide No.F.I(154)-RD- SGSY/88/3485-3529 dated 07.11.2014 for extending
the benefit of Death Cum Retirement and Leave Encashment only to the DRDA
regular employee on the basis of central and state share in the ratio of 90:10,
subject to the availability of fund;
AND
WHEREAS, Sri Chakraborty. Ex Account Officer, DRDA was appointed as a purely
contractual employee as mentioned aforesaid and the period of contract was
expired on 05/12/2019, the benefit of revision of pay vide TCS (1st Amendment)
Rules, 2018 is only applicable to the regular employees of DRDA, subject to the
availability of fund and the same has not been extended to the contractual staff;
AND
WHEREAS, There was no order of regularization or absorption of Sri Chakraborty
to the sanctioned post of accounts Officer, DRDA, Unakoti under the approval of
the Government/ competent authority;
AND
WHEREAS, Sri Chakraborty, Ex Account Officer, DRDA, Unakoti, is a contractual
employee demanded to release the retirement benefit of the petition such as
gratuity and leave encashment benefit with interest and to release the arrears of
pay as per revision of pay vide TCS (1st Amendment) Rules, 2018 but it has not
enumerated in the terms & condition of the contract of Sri Chakrabory to entitling
him such benefits;
NOW, THEREFORE, The demands i.e. (i) To release the retirement benefit of the
petitioner such as gratuity and leave encashment benefit with interest and (ii) To
release the salary of the petitioner for the period of July, 2021 to December,
2021 along with the enhancement of periodical increment which was due as on
01.07.2021 and also (iii) To release the arrears of pay from October, 2018 to
May, 2020 as per revision of pay vide TCS (1st Amendment) Rules, 2018 of Sri
Chakraborty is not considered as because of the nature of service as well as
terms and conditions specified during engagement on contractual basis does not
conform for granting the benefit as demanded. Therefore, the petition of Sri
Chakraborty is hereby regretted/rejected.
Sd/(Dr. Sandeep R. Rathod, IAS)
Secretary to the Government of
Tripura”
[7]
Aggrieved by the above-quoted impugned order dated
27.07.23, the petitioner has preferred this present writ petition seeking
following reliefs:
“(i) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, mandating/directing them, to revoke/rescind the impugned Order dated
27.07.2023 (Annexure-38 supra);
(ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, mandating/directing them, to make payment of Gratuity @
Rs.10,00,000/- and Leave Encashment @ Rs.9,47,600/-, totaling to
Rs.19,47,600/-, along with Interest thereon (due to belated payment thereof), in
favour of the Petitioner;
(iii) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, mandating/directing them, to make payment of the arrears of pay, from
October, 2018 to May, 2020, as per revision of pay made vide Tripura State Civil
Services (1st Amendment) Rules, 2018, in favour of the Petitioner;
(iv) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, mandating/directing them, to make payment of the outstanding salary,
for the period, from July, 2021 to December, 2021, along with the enhancement
of periodical increment, which fell due as on 01.07.2021, but has not been
released, though the Petitioner served for the said period;
(v)
Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued,
mandating/directing
them,
to
upload/record
the
date
of
retirement/release of the Petitioner from DRDA, Unakoti Tripura (i.e.,
31.12.2021), in the EPF portal, so as to enable the Petitioner to receive the
Employees' Provident Fund (EPF), as well as the EPF pension (as admissible);
(vi)
Call for the records, appertaining to this Writ Petition;
(vii)
After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rule absolute in terms
of (i) to (iv) above;
(viii)
[8]
Costs of and incidental to this proceeding…………….”
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Koomar Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that with the approval of the Chairman, DRDA, vide Memo dated
18.12.2002, the Chief Executive Officer (District Magistrate & Collector),
DRDA, North Tripura sanctioned the regular scale of pay of Accounts
Officer in favour of the petitioner. Now, the respondents cannot deny to
extend the post retire benefits to the petitioner. To support his
contention, learned counsel placed reliance on the following judgments of
this Court, wherein the petitioner/appellant were extended the benefits
as sought for in the petition/appeal:
1. Judgment dated 09.02.2024 passed in WP(C) 609 of
2023 of this Court.
2. Judgment dated 06.03.2024 passed in WA No.180 of
2022 by the Division Bench of this High Court.
[9]
He further submits that no regular monthly pension is
admissible to the petitioner as DRDA has not introduced regular monthly
pension to its employees. After retirement, Gratuity & Leave Encashment
benefits are substantive benefits which are admissible to the petitioner. It
is contended that the petitioner is not able to draw his Employees‟
Provident Fund (EPF for short) as well as the EPF pension (as admissible)
due to non-recording of the retirement/release date of the petitioner by
his employer in the EPF portal. Mr. Roy Barman, therefore, urges this
Court to set aside the impugned proceedings dated 27.07.2023 allowing
this writ petition with all the reliefs as sought for.
[10]
On the other hand, Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A.
opposes the contention raised by learned senior counsel for the petitioner
submitting that a communication dated 17th March, 2022 was made
between the Chief Executive Officer (District Magistrate & Collector),
DRDA, Unakoti District, Kailashahar and the Director (Projects), SLMC,
RD Department, Government of Tripura as it is presumed that the
petitioner might have manipulated the records when he was holding the
responsible post of Accounts Officer in DRDA and the nature of
contractual appointment of the petitioner was shown as regular employee
by misleading the authority. He further submits that the matter was not
brought to the notice of this Court on earlier occasion in case No. WP(C)
197 of 2022. Learned Addl. G.A., therefore, urges this Court to dismiss
the present writ petition.
[11]
As discussed earlier, learned counsel for the petitioner
placed reliance on the judgment of this Court in WP(C) 609 of 2023 and
also the judgment in WA No.180 of 2022 by the Division Bench of this
High Court, where the petitioner/appellant were extended the benefits as
sought for in the petition/appeal. But, here the case is different, as it is
seen from the record that as per the arguments of the learned Addl. G.A.,
some mischief has taken place and they presumed that it could be at the
level of petitioner since he was holding a responsible post of Accounts
Officer and most of the proceedings went unnoticed which now create
adverse impression to the case of the petitioner. It is also noticed that
the communication dated 17th March, 2022 between the Chief Executive
Officer
(District
Kailashahar
and
Magistrate
the
&
Collector),
DRDA,
Unakoti
Director
(Projects),
SLMC,
RD
District,
Department,
Government of Tripura is relevant to the case, and for ready reference,
the same may be extracted as under:
“Government of Tripura
State Level Monitoring Cell of SGSY
Rural Development Department
No. F.11(40)-RD/SGSY/Part/2016/266-69
To
The Executive Officer
Dated, Agartala, the 17th March, 2022
(District Magistrate & Collector)
District Rural Development Agency
Unakati District, Kailashahar.
Subject:- Request to enquire into the irregularity in handing of pay matters, Grant of pay scale,
ACP etc in respect of Sin Dibendu Chakraborty, AO, DRDA, Unakoti District- regarding.
Sir
I am to refer to your letter No. F 15 (40)/RD/(D)/2003/3056-57 dated 20.01.2022 and to
state that matter was referred to the Finance Department and the Finance Department has sought
below mentioned quarries"The Finance Department has examined the records, as made available in the concerned
Department's file. It is apparent from those records that there has been gross irregularity in
handling the pay matters of the concerned person. Grant of pay scale, ACP etc, was without any
authority of RD Department or Finance Department. It also appears from those records that the
person concerned was ex-Army personnel who was engaged on contract basis under DRDA,
allowed regular pay scale subsequently and retired from service under DRDA on 05-12 2019. No
records are available in the Department records to indicate whether any action has been taken
against the person(s) involved in those irregularities”.
“.In such circumstance, the Department concerned is requested to enquire the mater at
their own level”
3.
The Original Service Book of Sri Chakraborty is enclosed herewith.
In view of the above, you are kindly requested to enquire the matter and submit factual
report to this office immediately.
MATTER MOST URGENT
Yours faithfully,
Sd/(Dr. T.K. Debnath, IAS)
Director (Projects)
SLMC, RD Department
Government of Tripura”
[12]
It is seen from the above communication that there is a
prima facie opinion of the respondents that the records were manipulated
and accordingly, an enquiry is to be conducted. The said letter dated 17th
March, 2022 is not discussed in the impugned proceeding dated
27.07.2023 and the same is not reflected in the counter affidavit filed by
the respondents in the earlier case being WP(C) 197 of 2022. This has
become a crucial document to know as to how the name of the petitioner
is reflected in the service record as a regular employee in the absence of
any regularization order or proceedings.
[13]
These lapses on the part of the respondents are observed
by this Court and this Court has no hesitation to say that the
administration in the respondent department have to be handled more
diligently.
[14]
The judgments referred by the petitioner-counsel are not
applicable in the present case.
[15]
Thus, it becomes very necessary to go to the grass-root
level of the case. This Court feels that ends of justice would be met, if the
matter be enquired into in terms of the letter dated 17.03.2022 and to
render justice to the petitioner in the event if he is regular employee and
if he is entitled to his benefits in accordance with law.
[16]
For the discussion made above, this Court directs the
respondents to complete the enquiry in terms of the letter dated 17th
March, 2022 if not already completed, as expeditiously as possible and to
take a decision by reviewing the matter in its entirety and to
communicate the said decision to the petitioner.
As a result, the
proceeding dated 27.07.2023 become inoperative.
[17]
In view of the above directions/observations, the matter is
remanded back to the respondents and accordingly, this writ petition
stands disposed of.
As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any,
shall also stand closed.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi G.
SABYASACHI
GHOSH
GHOSH
Date: 2024.04.10 16:28:37 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review