The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. In view of the same, the charge framed against the petitioner under Page No.# 7/7 Section 302/120B/201 IPC is interfered with and the order dated 17/9/2024 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Jorhat in Sessions Case No. 4 of 2024 is set aside and quashed, qua only the petitioner, namely, Dhyanjeet Dutta for the ends of justice.
21. Accordingly, this criminal petition stands disposed of. Comparing Assistant
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/7
GAHC010234542024
2026:GAU-AS:2675
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.Pet./1360/2024
DHYANJEET DUTTA
S/O SRI RANJAN DUTTA
R/O MILAN NAGAR, P.S. AND DIST. JORHAT, ASSAM, PIN-785001.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ANR
REPRESENTED BY THE PP, ASSAM
2:SRI BASTAB TAMULI
S/O LATE PABITRA TAMULI
R/O TILLIKIAM BEZGAON
P.S. PULIBOR
DIST. JORHAT
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR P KATAKI, MS. A LALA,MS S BARPUJARI,MRS R BEGUM
Advocate for the Respondent : PP, ASSAM, MR. DARAK ULLAH, AMICUS CURIAE (R-2)
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHAMIMA JAHAN
ORDER
23.02.2026
1.
Heard Mr. P. Kataki, learning counsel for the petitioner and Mr. M. P.
Goswami, learning Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the state and Mr.
Darak Ullah, learned Amicus Curiae appearing for respondent No. 2.
Page No.# 2/7
2.
By this application, the petitioner has challenged the legality and validity of
the order dated 17/9/2024 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Jorhat in
Sessions Case No. 4 of 2024 by which the charges were framed against the
petitioner under Section 302/201/120(B) of IPC. The petitioner has also
challenged the proceedings of Sessions Case No. 4 of 2024 pending in the
aforesaid court.
3.
The petitioner has challenged the said order of framing of charge as well
as the proceedings initiated by the learned Sessions Judge in the said case on
the ground that there are no materials against him been collected by the
Prosecution during the investigation and that the charges were framed without
there being any materials on record.
4.
The case started with the lodging of the ejahar on 01/08/2022 by the wife
of the deceased wherein it was revealed that the deceased, who was working
for 2 years in a dhaba was found in an unconscious state lying in a bed inside
the dhaba with injuries on his body being caused by iron rod. Thereafter, a local
doctor was called who administered an injection and on being asked, the owner
that is Mr. Debraj Dutta said that her husband was fine before she came. It was
also alleged in the FIR that Mr. Debraj Dutta brought a cream to apply on her
husband. On suspicion, that the owner is involved in the incident that the FIR
was lodged against the owner.
5.
Police registered the case under Section 324 and investigated the case. A
day next, the son of the deceased lodged an ejahar, stating inter alia that the
owner of the dhaba poured hot water on the body of the deceased due to
which, the deceased received injuries and that the deceased died at 1 PM on
02/08/2022. It was also alleged therein that the deceased died due to physical
assault made by the owner of the dhaba.
Page No.# 3/7
6.
On completion of the investigation, submitted charge-sheet on 11/6/2023
both against the owner of the dhaba under Section 302 IPC with Section
120B/201 IPC and the petitioner under the same Sections.
7.
Mr. Kataki, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the police while
submitting the charge-sheet had stipulated therein that the petitioner has been
arrested and forwarded to judicial custody who helped the main accused to
escape. The learned counsel submits that apart from the said statement, there
is no material against the petitioner in the charge-sheet or in the FIR or in the
statement of the witnesses recorded under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. In absence
of any material whatsoever, the learner counsel submits that the court of
Sessions Judge, Jorhat framed charges against the petitioner under Section
302/120B/201 IPC.
8.
Mr. M. P. Goswami, learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the
state submitted that in the statement of the driver recorded under Section 161
of the Cr.P.C. it finds mention that the main accused person i.e. the owner of the
dhaba spoke with the petitioner while he left Jorhat and was going towards
Numuligarh. He has also pointed out that after speaking with the petitioner by
the owner of the dhaba, the petitioner also called him up in the cell phone of
the driver of the vehicle which was hired by the owner of the dhaba and spoke
with him as to where he is and where he was going.
9.
Mr. Goswami has placed the note made by the police officer wherein it was
stated that the petitioner had helped the owner of the dhaba in fleeing from the
place of occurrence.
10.
Mr. Darak Ulla, the learned Amicus Curiae appearing for respondent No. 2
also submits that the petitioner and the owner of the dhaba are cousin brothers
Page No.# 4/7
and they spoke with each other while the owner was fleeing from the place of
occurrence after the occurrence took place.
11.
I have heard the counsels and have gone through the records.
12.
It is noticed that in the FIR i.e. in two numbers of FIR, one lodged by the
wife of the deceased and the other lodged by the son of the deceased, only the
owner of the dhaba was stated to be the accused person. The owner is stated
to have poured hot water as well as assaulted the deceased in the dhaba.
Although, the FIRs need not be encyclopedia of the offense, the police during
investigation are entitled to find out the evidence in connection with the case as
well as the accused persons connected with the case. But in the instant case,
apart from the statement that the petitioner, who helped the main accused to
escape, nothing further has been stipulated in the charge-sheet barring the
charge found against him.
13.
It is provided under Section 173(5) of the Cr.P.C. that the report of the
police officer forwarded to the Magistrate should contain all documents which
the prosecution proposes to rely, as well as the statements recorded under
Section 161 of all the persons whom the prosecution proposes to examine as its
witnesses. Section 173(5) is quoted here in below:
“Section 173(5) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), 1973, requires
police to submit specific documents to the Magistrate when filing a final
report (charge sheet) in cases requiring arrest (Section 170). This includes
all relevant documents the prosecution relies on and statements of
witnesses under Section 161, ensuring the accused has access to
evidence.”
14.
Further, under Section 227 of the Cr.P.C, it is provided that upon
consideration of the record of the case and the document submitted therewith
and after hearing the submissions, if the Judge considers that there is no
Page No.# 5/7
sufficient ground for proceeding, the Judge can discharge the accused. And
under Section 228 of the Cr.P.C. if upon consideration and hearing of as
aforesaid, if the Judge founds that there is ground for presuming that accused
has committed an offense would frame charge there under which will be read
and explained to the accused.
15.
In the instant case, the statement of the witnesses examined under
Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. by the police, none of them have stated anything
against the present petitioner. The only statement against the present petitioner
is in the statement of the driver of the vehicle which was hired by the owner of
the dhaba, who stated that on 02/08/2022, in the afternoon at around 3 o'clock,
the owner of the dhaba hired his vehicle to take him towards Golaghat and that
at around 7:30 PM, the owner of the dhaba used the cell phone of the driver
and spoke to the petitioner. The driver stated that the owner of the dhaba spoke
with the petitioner about something without specifying as to what they spoke
about.
16.
The driver further stated that the petitioner called the in his mobile phone
again and asked the driver as to where he is and where he is going to which he
replied to the petitioner. The driver further stated that he told everything to the
petitioner to the effect that the owner of the dhaba wanted initially to go to
Golaghat but he changed his mind and he wanted to go to Numuligarh for
which he got in touch with another driver with another vehicle and let the
owner of the dhaba go in the said vehicle.
When the accused person i.e. the owner of the dhaba was examined by the
police under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C., the owner of the dhaba said that on the
day when he fled from the place of occurrence, he spoke with the petitioner and
that after he came to know that the petitioner got arrested, the owner of the
Page No.# 6/7
dhaba surrendered himself before the police station.
17.
Although, it is provided that under Section 228 of the Cr.P.C. the Judge
upon consideration of materials on record can frame charge against the accused
person which would include both statement of the witnesses arrayed by the
Prosecution as well as the statement of the accused recorded under Section 161
of the Cr.P.C, however, in the present case, there is prima facie no material
against the petitioner, inasmuch as neither the driver nor the accused person
had said as to what the owner of the dhaba spoke with the petitioner. In
absence of the said materials, framing charge under Section 201 or 302 or
120(B) is not made out.
18.
Under Section 201 of the IPC it is provided that if someone has knowledge
to believe that offense has been committed causes any evidence to disappear
with the intention to screen the offender from legal punishment is stated to
have committed the offence under Section 201. Section 201 is quoted here in
below:“Section
19.
201 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) penalizes anyone who,
knowing or believing an offense was committed, causes evidence to
disappear or gives false information to shield the offender. It aims to
prevent the obstruction of justice and applies even if the person helping is
not the main perpetrator.”
In the instant case, it is seen that the petitioner although spoke with the
owner of the dhaba, who is stated to be the main accused in the instant case
but in what way he had rendered evidence to disappear or in what way he had
tried to screen the offender from legal punishment is not discernible from the
materials on record. Only one sentence that the petitioner has helped the main
accused would not be sufficient without any substantive materials to that effect.
20.
In view of the same, the charge framed against the petitioner under
Page No.# 7/7
Section 302/120B/201 IPC is interfered with and the order dated 17/9/2024
passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Jorhat in Sessions Case No. 4 of 2024 is
set aside and quashed, qua only the petitioner, namely, Dhyanjeet Dutta for the
ends of justice.
21.
Accordingly, this criminal petition stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review