Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) 166/2026
Dhyan Foundation Goushala, registration No. Doc. No. 2235, AWBI
Reg. No. ND054/2019, Having registered address at A-80, South Extension
Part 2, New Delhi-110049, local address- Debipur Goushala, Bishalgarh,
P.O.& P.S.- Madhupur, District- Sepahijala, Tripura, through its authorized
representative Gaurav Yadav, son of Rajkumar Yadav, resident of Jakhani,
Purani Basti, Basti, Uttar Pradesh-272002.
----Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, through the Chief Secretary, Government
of Tripura, Agartala-799010, Tripura;
2. The Secretary, Animal Resource Development Department,
Government of Tripura;
3. The Director, Animal Resource Development Department,
Government of Tripura, New Civil Secretariat, Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura-799010;
4. The State of Assam, through the Chief Secretary, Government
of Assam, Dispur, Guwahati-781006, Assam;
5.
The Commissioner & Secretary, Animal Husbandry &
Veterinary Department, Government of Assam, Dispur, Guwahati781006, Assam;
6. The Director, Animal Husbandry & Veterinary Department,
Government of Assam, Chenikuthi, Guwahati-781003, Assam;
7.
The Chief Secretary, Government of Meghalaya, Main
Secretariat Building, Shillong-793001, Meghalaya;
8. The Principal Secretary, Animal Husbandry & Veterinary
Department, Government of Meghalaya, Rilang Building, Secretariat
Hill, Main Secretariat Building, Shillong-793001, Meghalaya;
9. The Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Bihar Secretariat
(Vikas Bhawan), Patna-800015, Bihar;
10. The Principal Secretary, Department of Animal and Fishery
Resources (Veterinary Department), Government of Bihar, Bihar
Veterinary College Campus, Patna-800014, Bihar, India;
11. The Chief Secretary, Government of Jharkhand, First Floor,
Project Building, Dhurwa, Ranchi-834004, Jharkhand;
12. The Principal Secretary, Animal Husbandry (Veterinary
Department), Government of Jharkhand, Project Bhawan, Dhurwa,
Ranchi-834004, Jharkhand;
Page 2
13. The Chief Secretary, Government of West Bengal, Nabanna
(13th Floor), 325, Sarat Chatterjee Road, Shibpur, Howrah-711102,
West Bengal;
14. The Principal Secretary, Animal Husbandry (Veterinary
Department), Government of West Bengal, Prani Sampad Bhavan,
LB-2, Sector-III, Salt Lake, Kolkata-7000106, West Bengal;
15. The Home Secretary, Home Department, Government of
Meghalaya, Main Secretariat Building, Shillong-793001, Meghalaya;
16. The Secretary, Home Department, Government of Bihar, Main
Main Secretariat, Patna-800015, Bihar;
17. The Secretary, Home and Hill Affairs Department, Government
of West Bengal, 325, Sarat Chatterjee Road, Shibpur, Mandirtala,
Howrah-711102, West Bengal;
18. The Home Secretary, Government of Jharkhand, Home
Department, Project Building, Dhurwa, Ranchi-834004, Jharkhand;
19. The Secretary, Home Department, Government of Tripura,
Secretariat Building, Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura;
20. The Secretary, Home Department, Government of Assam, Main
2nd Floor, ‘I’ Block, Janata Bhawan, Dispur, Guwahati-781006, Assam;
21. The Inspector General, Border Security Force, Frontier
Headquarters BSF Tripura, Salbagan, Agartala-799012, Tripura;
----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. H. Pandeya, Advocate
Mr. S. Agarwal, Advocate
Mr. A. Acharjee, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. GA
Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment
:
23.03.2026
Whether fit for reporting :
Yes
BEFORE
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order (ORAL)
Heard Mr. H.Pandeya, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner. Also heard Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Additional
GA appearing for the State-respondents, and Mr. B. Majumder,
learned Deputy SGI appearing for the respondent-Union of India.
Page 3
By means of filing this writ petition, the petitioners
2.
have prayed for the following reliefs:
“a) Issue Notice upon the respondents and call for the records appertaining to the writ petition:
b) Issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order or direction directing the
Respondents to issue permits for transportation of 1800 cattle from Tripura to Jharkhand:
c) Direct the respondents and the concerned authorities of the State of Tripura, Assam, Meghalaya,
Bihar and Jharkhand to facilitate safe, unobstructed and priority passage of the said cattle during
transit ,including necessary inter-state coordination among the concerned authorities, considering
the long transit route and frequent road restrictions so as to ensure timely, safe and humane
transportation of the cattle;
d) Pass such other and further order(s) as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts
and circumstances of the case.”
Facts of the case, in a narrow compass, is that the
3.
petitioner, Dhyan Foundation is a NGO, which has been working
across the country for rescue, care, treatment and rehabilitation
of
animals/cattle,
more
particularly,
rescuing
them
from
slaughter houses. It has several branches all over the country
and couple of them is also in Tripura. It operates 44 large
Gaushalas/Animal Welfare centres across India. By this writ
petition, the petitioner sought for a direction from this Court in
obtaining
transit
permission
from
the
respondents
for
transportation of cattle rescued from illegal slaughter house and
animal traffickers on International and State Border from the
State of Tripura to the Gaushala of the petitioner. It is further
case of the petitioner that the respondent no.3 herein, earlier
accorded permission to the petitioner and issued transit permit in
favour of the petitioner vide Applications dated 30.08.2024,
10.09.2024 and 26.08.2021 for transportation of total 1700
cattle, and the subsequent applications seeking fresh transit
permit with regard to 1953 cattles remained unaddressed. Thus,
by means of this writ petition the petitioner has sought for a
direction.
Page 4
4.
The contention of Mr. Pandeya, learned senior counsel
appearing for the petitioner is that since the respondent no. 3
earlier had granted permission for transit of cattles from the
State of Tripura to the Gaushala of the petitioner, but the
subsequent applications remained unaddressed without any valid
reason. Learned counsel has further argued that currently
approximately 1,953 cattles in Tripura are under challenging
condition with severe fodder shortage and also threat of being
smuggled by mafias. It has further been argued that the fodder
cost in the Gaughalas of the petitioner is only Rs.1 per kg.
wherein the cost of fodder in Tripura is much higher i.e. around
Rs.25/- per kg.. It has further been argued that ARDD, Tripura,
has not provided any or sufficient green or dry fodder or
concentrated feed to the Gaushalas in Tripura for proper feeding
of the cattle. Learned counsel has urged that if the cattles are
handed over to the petitioner, the cattles will be safe from any
threat, smuggle and natural calamities. It has also been urged
that the petitioner will comply all the provisions of Prevention of
Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960 and Transport of Animals Rules,
1978 with lawful transportation.
5.
Per contra, Mr. Debbarma, learned Additional GA
appearing for the State-respondents has submitted that a
Memorandum of Agreement was executed between the petitioner
and the respondent-State which was valid for a period of three
years and the said Agreement expired on 24.02.2024. It has
further been argued that without renewal of extending the period
Page 5
of the Agreement, the petitioner has no right to obtain any
permission from the respondent-State. Learned Additional GA
has further submitted that there is no shortage of fodder in the
State and all sorts of care and caution has been adopted by the
respondent-State for the welfare of the cattle. Learned Additional
GA
has
also
submitted
that
the
State
Government
had
constituted expert committed who have inspected and after
inspection nothing immaterial had been detected so as to grant
permission to the petitioner, as aforestated. He further submitted
on the strength of written instructions of Animal Husbandry
Department, that the petitioner can donate the cattle to the
interested persons in Tripura. As per argument with the State
shifting is permitted without any intimation, but if its interstate
permission is required.
6.
This court has perused the record and also has gone
through
the
correspondences
made
therein.
From
the
communications dated 30.08.2024, 10.09.2024 and 26.08.2021
(Annexure 2 to the writ petition) it is evident that the
respondent-State has accorded permission to the petitioner to
shift total 1700 cattle from Gaushala of Tripura to Gaushala at
Jharkhand by adhering all the Act and Rules. It is also evident
that the MoU had expired and as per submission of learned
Additional GA, without renew or extending the period, the State
Government cannot pass any direction in favour of the petitioner,
but considering the benefit, safety and security of animals, the
expiration
of
a
Memorandum
of
Understanding
generally
Page 6
does not debar a State Government from issuing permission for
shifting cattle from one gaushala to another. Further none of the
parties to the Agreement has undertaken any step for its renewal
or extending the period. Thus, shifting the liability solely upon
the petitioner is not accepted at this juncture. That apart, there
is no provision under law where the respondent-State can
prevent without any reason, except relying on the MoU, in
shifting the cattle from one Goushala to another. Furthermore,
State of Tripura shares border with Bangladesh in north, west
and south. Day in and day out it is experienced that number of
cattle are being smuggled unauthorizedly from the State of
Tripura to the neighbouring country Bangladesh. And they are
taken away to the slaughter house. It is unfortunate that despite
efforts put in by the State or its agencies, the protection and
rescue is not coming to end. Section 2 of the Prevention of
Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960, provides essential definitions for
the Act's interpretation, including "animal" (any living creature
other than a human being), "captive animal," "domestic animal,"
"local authority," "owner," and specifically defines inhumane
practices like "phooka" or "doom dev". Section 2 of the
Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960, reads as under:
“2. Definitions.―In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,―
(a) “animal” means any living creature other than a human being;
(b) “Board” means the Board established under section 4, and as reconstituted from time to
time under section 5A;]
(c) “captive animal” means any animal (not being a domestic animal) which is in captivity or
confinement, whether permanent or temporary, or which is subjected to any appliance or
contrivance for the purpose of hindering or preventing its escape from captivity or
confinement or which is pinioned or which is or appears to be maimed;
(d) “domestic animal” means any animal which is tamed or which has been or is being
sufficiently tamed to serve some purpose for the use of man or which, although it neither has
been nor is being nor is intended to be so tamed, is or has become in fact wholly or partly
tamed;
Page 7
(e) “local authority” means a municipal committee, district board or other authority for the
time being invested by law with the control and administration of any matters within a
specified local area;
(f) “owner”, used with reference to an animal, includes not only the owner but also any other
person for the time being in possession or custody of the animal, whether with or without the
consent of the owner;
(g) “phooka” or “doom dev” includes any process of introducing air or any substance into the
female organ of a milch animal with the object of drawing off from the animal any secretion of
milk;
(h) “prescribed” means prescribed by rules made under this Act;
(i) “street” includes any way, road, lane, square, court, alley, passage or open space, whether a
thoroughfare or not, to which the public have access.”
Section 11 of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act,
1960, defines various forms of cruelty to animals, such as
beating, overloading, starving, abandoning, or killing them
inhumanely. Section 11 of the Act, reads as under:
“11. Treating animals cruelly.— (1)If any person—
(a)beats, kicks, over-rides, over-drives, over-loads, tortures or otherwise treats any animal so as to
subject it to unnecessary pain or suffering or causes or, being the owner permits, any animals to be so
treated; or
(b)employs in any work or labour or for any purpose any animal which, by reason of its age or any
disease, infirmity, wound, sore or other cause, is unfit to be so employed or, being the owner, permits
any such unfit animal to be so employed; or
(c)wilfully and unreasonably administers any injurious drug or injurious substance to any animal or
wilfully and unreasonably causes or attempts to cause any such drug or substance to be taken by any
animal; or
(d)conveys or carries, whether in or upon any vehicle or not, any animal in such a manner or position as
to subject it to unnecessary pain or suffering; or
(e)keeps or confines any animal in any cage or other receptacle which does not measure sufficiently in
height, length and breadth to permit the animal a reasonable opportunity for movement; or
(f)keeps for an unreasonable time any animal chained or tethered upon an unreasonably short or
unreasonably heavy chain or cord; or
(g)being the owner, neglects to exercise or cause to be exercised reasonably any dog habitually chained
up or kept in close confinement; or
(h)being the owner of any animal, fails to provide such animal with sufficient food, drink or shelter; or
(i)without reasonable cause, abandons any animal in circumstances which render it likely that it will
suffer pain by reason of starvation or thirst; or
(j)wilfully permits any animal, of which he is the owner to go at large in any street while the animal is
affected with contagious or infectious disease or, without reasonable excuse permits any diseased or
disabled animal, of which he is the owner, to die in any street; or
(k)offers for sale or, without reasonable cause, has in his possession any animal which is suffering pain by
reason of mutilation, starvation, thirst, overcrowding or other ill-treatment; or
(l)mutilates any animal or kills any animal (including stray dogs) by using the method of strychnine
injections in the heart or in any other unnecessarily cruel manner; or;
m) solely with a view to providing entertainment—
(i)confines or causes to be confined any animal (including tying of an animal as a bait in a tiger or
other sanctuary) so as to make it an object of prey for any other animal; or
(ii)incites any animal to fight or bait any other animal; or
(n)organises, keeps, uses or acts in the management of, any place for animal fighting or for the purpose of
baiting any animal or permits or offers any place to be so used or receives money for the admission of
any other person to any place kept or used for any such purposes; or
(o)promotes or takes part in any shooting match or competition wherein animals are released from
captivity for the purpose of such shooting;
he shall be punishable, in the case of a first offence, with fine which shall not be less than ten
rupees but which may extend to fifty rupees, and in the case of a second or subsequent offence
committed within three years of the previous offence, with fine which shall not be less than twenty-five
rupees but which may extend to one hundred rupees or with imprisonment for a term which may extend
to three months, or with both.
(2)For the purposes of sub-section (1), an owner shall be deemed to have committed an offence if he has
failed to exercise reasonable care and supervision with a view to the prevention of such offence:
Provided that where an owner is convicted of permitting cruelty by reason only of having failed
to exercise such care and supervision, he shall not be liable to imprisonment without the option of a fine.
(3)Nothing in this section shall apply to—
Page 8
(a)the dehorning of cattle, or the castration or branding or nose-roping of any animal, in the
prescribed manner; or
(b)the destruction of stray dogs in lethal chambers or by such other methods as may be
prescribed; or
(c)the extermination or destruction of any animal under the authority of any law for the time
being in force; or
(d)any matter dealt with in Chapter IV; or
(e)the commission or omission of any act in the course of the destruction or the preparation for
destruction of any animal as food for mankind unless such destruction or preparation was accompanied
by the infliction of unnecessary pain or suffering.”
7.
Here
is
the
petitioner,
without
burdening
the
government exchequer for the last several years is taking care of
the rescued cattle and providing food, shelter and aid and also
looking after the cattle in terms of provisions of Protection of
Animal Acts. In the event if there is surplus of cattle in limited
apace and overcrowded/congested, it also amounts to cruelty.
Again, if proper food, medication and shelter is not provided, the
same comes within the purview of cruelty. In the event, if the
cattle are shifted or transported from one place to another and if
during transportation the cattle are overcrowded in a truck/
transport vehicle, then also it amounts to cruelty under the
statute, and in the process of shifting the cattle to a distant place
and, for any reason, if there is any stoppage for undue period
and for prolong hours by any authority or any officers, it is
needless to say, the same amounts to cruelty because during the
course of transportation sufficient fodder only would be provided
by the petitioner-cum-owner of the cattle during the transit
period.
8.
The respondents in their counter affidavit except
relying the clauses under the expired MoU, which is not
recognized by any statute, are placing their reliance and without
Page 9
any authority of law, denying the request of the petitioner
through the present counter affidavit is also of no basis.
9.
In view of the above, this court feels that facilitation
has to be given to the petitioner by the respondents herein
during transportation of the cattle from the State of Tripura to
the place of destination, as earlier it was done in the year 2023
by granting permission by the respondent-State.
10.
The petitioner only has sought permission from the
State-respondent for issuance of transit permit to take the cattle
to its Goushala at Jharkhand from Tripura and for that purpose
the petitioner has not claimed any financial assistance from the
respondents. The petitioner herein has shown its voluntary
willingness to
accept
the custody of the cattle
and
had
undertaken comprehensive, nurturing, and attentive approach
towards the cattle. The entire service rendered by the petitioner
is gratuitous in nature.
11.
Sub-rule 9 of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
(Care and Maintenance of Case Property Animals) Rules, 2017,
focuses on the adoption or rehabilitation of animals after a
magistrate hands them over. It stipulates that the person
adopting the animal is not the permanent owner, but rather its
guardian, responsible for its well-being. Sub-rule 9 of the Rules,
2017, reads as under:
“(9) Process of adoption or other disposition (1) The infirmary, pinjrapole, SPCA, Animal Welfare
Organisation or Gaushala having custody of the animal during the litigation or post litigation may
euthanize the animal in its custody as per section 13 of the Act.
(2) Where the animal has been forfeited to the infirmary, pinjrapole, SPCA, Animal Welfare Organisation
or Gaushala after conviction, abandonment or voluntary relinquishment, as the case may be, the animal
shall be put up for adoption.
Page 10
(3) A person who has been charged under the Act or any cattle preservation law made by the State
Government shall be prohibited from adopting animals from the infirmary, pinjrapole, SPCA, Animal
Welfare Organisation or Gaushala.
(4) The infirmary, pinjrapole, SPCA, Animal Welfare Organisation or Gaushala prior to giving the animal
for adoption shall,(a) in case of cattle, take an undertaking in form of an affidavit that the animals are adopted for
agriculture purposes and not for slaughter, and verify that the person adopting the animal is an
agriculturist by seeing the relevant revenue document;
(b) in case of draught and pack animals, take an undertaking in the form of an affidavit that the animals
are adopted for draught and pack purposes and not for slaughter;
(c) in case of dogs and cats, ensure that the animal is spayed or neutered before adoption;
(d) keep a record of name and address of the person adopting the animal and procure an identity proof
and address proof of the person adopting the animal;
(e) obtain from the person adopting the animal a declaration in the form of an affidavit that he shall not
alienate the animal up to six months from the date of adoption and shall abide by the rules for transport
framed under the Act or any other law for the time being in force and shall get regular veterinary checkup
done for the animal.
(5) The person adopting the animal shall(a) not sell the animal;
(b) not abandon the animal;
(c) follow the State cattle protection and preservation law;
(d) not sacrifice the animal for any religious purpose;
(e) not sell the cattle to a person outside the State without permission as per the State cattle protection
and preservation law.
(6) Where a cattle or a draught and pack animal has been adopted, before its removal from the premises
of the infirmary, pinjrapole, SPCA, Animal Welfare Organisation or Gaushala, the proof of adoption shall
be issued in five copies, out of which first copy shall be handed over to person adopting the animal,
second copy to infirmary, pinjrapole, SPCA, Animal Welfare Organisation or Gaushala, as the case may be,
third copy to tehsil office of the residence of person adopting the animal, fourth copy to the Chief
Veterinary Officer, Office of District of person adopting the animal and last copy shall be sent to the court
to be filed in the case file.
(7) The adoption of animal shall not create an irrevocable right to the person adopting the animal, and
the înfirmary, pinjrapole, SPCA, Animal Welfare Organisation or Gaushala, as the case may be, may from
time to time inspect the animal and in case it finds that the person who has adopted the animal is not
providing sufficient care or it has reasons to believe that an offence under the Act or any cattle
preservation law is anticipated, then the infirmary, pinjrapole, SPCA, Animal Welfare Organisation or
Gaushala, as the case may be, shall take possession of the animal.
(8) The person adopting the animal shall only be the lawful guardian of the animal and shall not have any
rights bestowed generally to an owner of the animal, but shall have the duty to take all responsible
measures to ensure the well being of such animal and to prevent infliction upon such animal of
unnecessary pain or suffering.”
12.
This Court is to ensure that the cattle would be
properly preserved. It is trite law that the rights of the animals,
welfare of the animals and protection of the animals have to be
taken care of in accordance with law. The Hon'ble Apex Court in
Animal Welfare Board of India v. A. Nagaraja, reported in
(2014) 7 SCC 547 para 26, has observed thus:-"26. PCA Act is a welfare legislation which has to be construed bearing in mind the purpose and object of
the Act and the Directive Principles of State Policy. It is trite law that, in the matters of welfare legislation,
the provisions of law should be liberally construed in favour of the weak and infirm. Court also should be
vigilant to see that benefits conferred by such remedial and welfare legislation are not defeated by subtle
devices. Court has got the duty that, in every case, where ingenuity is expanded to avoid welfare
legislations, to get behind the smoke-screen and discover the true state of affairs. Court can go behind
the form and see the substance of the devise for which it has to pierce the veil and examine whether the
guidelines or the Regulations are framed so as to achieve some other purpose than the welfare of the
animals. Regulations or guidelines, whether statutory or otherwise, if they purport to dilute or defeat the
welfare legislation and the constitutional principles, Court should not hesitate to strike them down so as
to achieve the ultimate object and purpose of the welfare legislation. Court has also a duty under the
doctrine of parents patriae to take care of the rights of animals, since they are unable to take care of
themselves as against human beings."
Page 11
13.
In the spirit of the object of the Act, as enunciated in
A Nagaraja (supra), this Court is of the prima facie view that in
the interest, nurture, care, protection from slaughter house, the
petitioner can have a right to claim to transport its own cattle
from its Gaushala at Tripura to its own Gaushala at Jharkhand. It
can safely be concluded that the cattle would be safe in the
custody of the petitioner.
14.
Accordingly, this Court directs the respondent-State to
issue transit permit in favour of the petitioner to transport the
rescued cattle from the State of Tripura to the State of
Jharkhand, the Gaushala of the petitioner. Thereafter, the
petitioner shall be at liberty to transport the cattle to its
Gaushala at Jharkhand following due care and caution. It is made
clear that in course of such transportation there shall be no
violation of any of the provision under the Act, 1960 and Rules,
2017 by the respondents and their subordinates and shall cooperate and assist in shifting the cattle from Tripura to Jharkhand
via Assam, Meghalaya, West Bengal and Bihar.
15.
In the above conspectus, the instant writ petition
stands allowed to the extent as indicated above. As a sequel,
pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE
SAIKAT KAR
SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2026.03.26
14:55:15 -04'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review