The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Hence, this appeal FMA 114 of 2021 stands disposed. The judgment and award dated 28th July, 2020 passed by learned Special Court-CumAdditional District Judge, Hooghly, in MAC Case No. 163 of 2013 stands modified to the extent that the appellants/claimants are entitled to compensation of Rs.22,50,000/- from respondent No.2 Insurance Company. The respondent No. 2 Insurance Company shall deposit before the learned Registrar General, High Court, Calcutta, Rs.22,50,000/- along with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing claim case till today. Such deposit shall be made within eight weeks from the date communication of this order. In the event the compensation awarded by the learned Trial Court is already deposited the balance amount be deposited. The appellants/claimants are permitted to withdraw the compensation amount in equal shares upon compliance of necessary formalities.
14. This appeal FMA 795 of 2023 stands disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
22.07.2026
Item No.8
Ali
ct. no.9
FMA 114 of 2021
Dharma Shila Debi @ Dharam Shila Debi & Ors.
Vs.
Anjana Biswas & Anr.
Mr. Soujanya Bandyopadhyay
….for the appellants.
Mr. Parimal Kumar Pahari
…….for the respondents.
1. Learned advocates for the parties are present.
2. Heard the learned advocates for the parties.
3. The appellant before this Court were claimants in
a case under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 and is aggrieved by the judgment and
award passed by learned Special Court-CumAdditional District Judge, Hooghly, in MAC Case
No. 163 of 2013.
4. The case of the claimants before the learned Trial
Court may be summed up thus:
“On 03.04.2013 Santosh Roy, since deceased,
was proceeding by a taxi bearing no. WB-19A8432 in a rash and negligent manner with high
speed and when he reached at Bally Toll Tax
Area, Police Station Nischinda, Howrah, he met
with a motor accident endangering human life and
safety for which Santosh Roy sustained severe
injuries on his person and he was admitted to the
Sun Flower Nursing Home where he died on
06.04.2013 at about 1.25 a.m. The driver of the
aforesaid vehicle drove the vehicle with high
speed and in a rash and negligent manner. The
victim was aged about 26 years and he was a
business man by occupation and used to earn
Rs.10,000/- per month. The claimants have been
suffering from financial and mental pain due to
premature accident of Santosh Roy. Pursuant to
filing of this case notice was issued upon the
opposite parties. Although opposite party vehicle
owner appeared but did not contest the case till
final hearing. Opposite party Insurance Company
contested the case by filing written statement.
Issues were framed and evidences were adduced.
Learned
Trial
Judge
upon
considering
the
evidence adduced and upon hearing the learned
advocate was pleased to dispose of the claim case
by observing and directing as follows:
“Hence, it is,
ORDERED
That the instant case be and the same is
allowed on contest against the Opposite Party No. 2,
the United India Insurance Company Ltd. and ex-
parte against the OP No. 1, owner of the offending
vehicle having its No. WB-19A/8432.
The
petitioners
are
entitled
to
get
compensation of Rs. 10,80,500/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs
eighty Thousand five hundred Only) from the OP No.
2. Opposite Party No. 2, the United India Insurance
Company Ltd. along with interest at the rate of Rs.
4% per annum from the date of filing of this case.
The Opposite Party No. 2 is directed to issue
five account payee cheques of Rs. 1,80,000/(Rupees one lakh eighty thousand only) each in
favour of 1. Kailash Roy 2. Dharmashila Devi 3. Kalu
Kumar 4. Anshu Kumari and 5. Sumit Kumar along
with interest at the rate of 4% per annum from the
date of filing of this case and also issue another
account payee cheque in favour of Raj Kumari Devi
amounting to Rs. 1,80,500/- (Rupees one Lakh
eighty Thousand and five hundred Only) along with
interest at the rate of 4% per annum from the date
of filing of this case within 90 days from this day.
The petitioner No. 3 namely, Raj Kumari Devi
is directed to deposit Rs. 1,50,000/- (Rupees One
Lakh and Fifty Thousand Only) each in the name of
her minor children, namely, Kalu Kumar, Sumit
Kumar and Anshu Kumari in any Nationalized Bank
or Post Office in the nature of Term Deposit till
attainment of their majority and she will be at
liberty to withdraw the interest for the maintenance
of their minor children.”
5. The appellants/claimants being aggrieved by the
judgment and award passed by the learned Trial
Judge has come up with the instant appeal. Heard
learned advocate for the appellants/claimants and
learned
advocate
for
the
respondent
No.
Insurance
Company.
Perused
the
evidence
adduced and materials on record.
6. Learned advocate for the appellants submits that
the learned Trial Judge erred in considering the
monthly income of the victim as Rs.5,000/although the victim was a driver and documents
with regard to driving, namely, the registration of
commercial vehicle in his name and the driving
licence was proved before the learned Trial Court.
7. Learned advocate further submits that the learned
Trial Judge erred in not awarding the medical
expenses incurred during the victim’s stay in
hospital prior to his death. It is also submitted by
the learned advocate that the interest awarded by
the Trial Court should be at least 6% per annum
instead of 4% per annum.
8. Learned advocate appearing for the insurance
Company disputes the submission of learned
advocate for the appellants/claimants.
9. Learned advocate for the claimants/appellants
relies upon by following decisions:
V. Pathmavathi and Others Versus Bharthi
AXA General Insurance Co. Ltd. and Another
reported
in
(1)
T.A.C.
(S.C.).
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co.
Ltd. Versus Dipali and Others reported in FMA
462 of 2025, High Court, Calcutta.
10. Upon
hearing
the
learned
advocates
and
considering the facts of the case and the materials
on record it appears that the claimants were able
to prove the driving licence of the victim as well
as the registration of commercial vehicle in his
name. As the claimants were able to prove the
occupation of the victim it is necessary to consider
the monthly income of the persons in the said
occupation. In considering the monthly income of
a particular category of employees Court can
consider the income which is provided under the
Minimum Wages Act or the income in general
earned by the person of such categories. As the
victim was not employed under any person and it
was own business there was no scope to apply the
Minimum Wages Act. Thus, considering the price
index the nature of occupation and the income of
occupation of the income which is usually earned
in such occupation the monthly income of the
victim
could
have
also
been
assessed
at
Rs.10,000/- as claimed by the claimants. In the
case of V.Pathmavathi and Others Versus
Bharthi
AXA
General
Insurance
Co.
Ltd.
(supra). The Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as
follows:
“16.
In
the
present
case,
the
MACT
proceeded on the premise that the monthly
income of the victim was Rs. 6,000/-. This
was subsequently enhanced by the High
Court
to
Rs.
recording
any
7,000/-,
reason.
albeit
without
However,
learned
counsel appearing for the claimants has
rightly drawn our attention to the salary
certificate issued by the employer of the
victim,
marked
Exhibit
P-
14,
which
unequivocally records that the victim was
employed as a driver on a fixed monthly
salary of Rs. 10,000/-. This documentary
evidence
is
further
corroborated
by
the
affidavit sworn by the victim’s employer
(PW-3). On the face of such cogent and
relevant evidence, which was not impeached
by
the
insurer,
it
would
be
wholly
impermissible to assess the income at a
lower figure. The determination of income
must be founded on proof placed on record
and
cannot
rest
assumptions
on
divorced
Accordingly,
for
the
conjecture
or
from evidence.
purposes
of
re-
computation, the monthly income of the
victim has to be reckoned as Rs. 10,000/-”.
11. In the case of Cholamandalam MS General
Insurance Co. Ltd. Versus Dipali and Others
it was observed as follows:
“Now with regard to the occupation of the
victim the claimant/ respondent no. 1, 2 & 3
have been able to establish by giving specific
evidence
that
the
victim
was
driver
of
vehicle bearing no. WB-37/6621 which was
a bus and the name of the owner and his
address
is
also
mentioned.
Thus,
the
claimants/respondents have been able to
prove that the victim was a bus driver. With
regard to the salary of the victim although
the claimants did not filed the salary slip or
examine the owner of the vehicle, but the
Learned Trial Judge accepted the evidence of
PW1 and considered the income of the victim
to
be Rs. 10,000/-. Now the point
for
consideration is whether the Ld. Trial Judge
erred in accepting the evidence of claimants
without corroboration. Learned Advocates
have relied upon decisions where income of
driver was considered as Rs. 7,500/- as well
as Rs. 10,000/-. Learned Advocate for the
appellant Insurance Company has also relied
upon
the
minimum
notification
wages
of
with
driver
regard
of
to
transport
vehicle. It is true that when the minimum
wages
of
driver
of
transport
vehicle
is
prescribed, drivers cannot be paid less than
the said wages but there is no bar in making
payment of wages more than the minimum
wages.
While
considering
the
issue
of
income of a victim with regard to particular
employment Courts may not only confine to
what is the minimum wages but may also
take
into
prevailing
consideration
with
particular employment
and
market
rate
regard
to
the
income
reasonably required for a person to maintain
his family, for which a person accepts any
work/employment. Upon considering such
factors Motor Accidents Claim Tribunal can
decide the issue of income on the basis of
evidence of claimants even if there is no
corroboration. Now so far as income of
driver is concerned it is found in reality that
even car drivers are also paid more than Rs.
10,000/-. Thus the evidence of the claimant
that victim who was a bus driver was
earning Rs 10,000/- per month as salary can
be relied upon. Thus the Ld. Trial Judge did
not err in considering the monthly income of
the victim to be Rs. 10,000/-. Hence there is
nothing to interfere in the Judgment and
award of the Learned Trial Judge”.
12. In the event the monthly income of the victim is
considered at Rs.10,000/- the annual income
comes to Rs.1,20,000/- 40% of future prospect
added which is Rs.48,000/- the total annual
income comes to Rs.1,58,000/- 1/4th should be
deducted on account of personal expenses and
the
net
annual
dependency
loss
comes
to
Rs.1,26,000/-. Applying the multiplier of 17 the
total dependency loss comes to Rs.21,42,000/-.
Further
the
claimants
are
entitled
to
get
Rs.84,000/- on account of loss of consortium and
loss of estate and funeral expenses. Thus the total
compensation
comes
to
Rs.22,26,000/-
by
arithmetical calculation. However as the victim
was in hospital for three days it would be
reasonable
to
add
Rs.24,000/-
and
thus
reasonable compensation shall be Rs.22,50,000/which the claimants/appellants shall be awarded.
13. Hence, this appeal FMA 114 of 2021 stands
disposed. The judgment and award dated 28th
July, 2020 passed by learned Special Court-CumAdditional District Judge, Hooghly, in MAC Case
No. 163 of 2013 stands modified to the extent
that
the
appellants/claimants
are
entitled
to
compensation of Rs.22,50,000/- from respondent
No.2 Insurance Company. The respondent No. 2
Insurance
Company
shall
deposit
before
the
learned Registrar General, High Court, Calcutta,
Rs.22,50,000/- along with interest @ 6% per
annum from the date of filing claim case till today.
Such deposit shall be made within eight weeks
from the date communication of this order. In the
event the compensation awarded by the learned
Trial Court is already deposited the balance
amount be deposited. The appellants/claimants
are permitted to withdraw the compensation
amount in equal shares upon compliance of
necessary formalities.
14. This appeal FMA 795 of 2023 stands disposed
of.
15. Urgent photostat certified copies of this order, if
applied for, be supplied to the parties upon
compliance of all necessary formalities.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review