Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Revisional Jurisdiction)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
C.R.P. No. 01 of 2024
Mrs. Dhan Kumari Pradhan,
Wife of Late Binay Kumar Pradhan,
Aged about 79 years,
Resident of Sichey, Sukha-Pool,
Gangtok District,
Sikkim– 737 101
….. Revisionist
Versus
1.
Mr. Bigyan Pradhan,
Son of Late Surjyaman @ Suryaman Pradhan,
Resident of Rung-Dung, Mata Golai,
Rhenock, Pakyong District,
Sikkim-737 133.
2.
Mrs. Neeru Pradhan,
Wife of Late Anup Pradhan,
Resident of Rung-Dung, Mata Golai,
Rhenock, Pakyong District,
Sikkim-737 133.
3.
Mr. Arun Pradhan,
Son of Late Surjyaman @ Suryaman Pradhan,
Resident of Rung-Dung, Mata Golai,
Rhenock, Pakyong District,
Sikkim-737 133.
4.
The Secretary,
Land Revenue Department,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok-737 101.
5.
The District Collector (Pakyong District),
Office of the District Collectorate,
Government of Sikkim, Pakyong-737 106.
6.
Sub Divisional Magistrate (Rongli),
District Administrative Centre,
Rongli, Pakyong District-737 131.
C.R.P. No.01 of 2024
Dhan Kumari Pradhan vs. Bigyan Pradhan & Ors.
7.
Mr. Manish Pradhan,
Son of Late Ashok Kumar Pradhan,
Resident of Bhutia Busty, Darjeeling,
West Bengal-734 101.
….. Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------------Application under section 115 read with section 151 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
(Impugned order dated 20.12.2023 passed by the learned Civil Judge,
Rongli, Sub-Division, Pakyong District, Sikkim rejecting the application
of the Revisionist under Order VII Rule 11 read with section 151 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 of the Revisionist for rejection of the
plaint in Title Suit No.01 of 2023).
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
Mr. S. S. Hamal, Senior Advocate (Legal Aid Counsel)
with Mr. L. B. Gurung, Legal Aid Counsel, Mr.
Pradeep Sharma, Mr. Anirudh Gupta, Mr. Ram Devi
Chettri and Ms. Beneeta Gurung, Advocates for the
Revisionist.
Mr. Sushant Subba, Advocate for the Respondent Nos.
1 to 3.
Mr. S. K. Chettri, Government Advocate for the
Respondent Nos. 4 to 6.
None for the Respondent No. 7.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of hearing
:
03.06.2024 & 04.06.2024
Date of Order
:
04.06.2024
ORDER
(ORAL)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
The present revision petition has been filed by the
defendant no.4 impugning an Order dated 20.12.2023
passed by the learned Civil Judge, Rongli Sub-Division,
Pakyong, Sikkim (the learned Civil Judge) rejecting an
C.R.P. No.01 of 2024
Dhan Kumari Pradhan vs. Bigyan Pradhan & Ors.
application under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (CPC) filed by the revisionist (defendant
no.4) for rejecting the plaint on two grounds i.e. lack of
cause of action and that the suit was barred by limitation.
The learned Civil Judge rejected both the issues raised by
the defendant no.4 and held that the plaint did disclose a
cause of action and that the suit was not barred by
limitation.
2.
Title Suit No.01 of 2023 were filed by respondent
nos. 1 to 3 (the plaintiffs) against the Secretary, Land
Revenue Department, District Collector, Pakyong, SubDivisional Magistrate, Rongli, Pakyong, the defendant no.4
and respondent no.7 (defendant no.5). The suit was styled
as
a
suit
for
declaration,
recovery
of
cancellation
of
documents,
injunction
possession,
and
other
consequential reliefs.
3.
It was the case of the plaintiffs that they along
with defendant no.5 are the legal heirs of late Surjyaman
Pradhan @ Suryaman Pradhan (Surjyaman Pradhan) and
late Damyanti Pradhan and that the defendant no.4 is the
legal heir of late Surjyaman Pradhan and late Padma
Kumari Pradhan. According to the plaint late Surjyaman
Pradhan had two wives in his lifetime i.e. late Padma
Kumari Pradhan and late Damyanti Pradhan and both were
C.R.P. No.01 of 2024
Dhan Kumari Pradhan vs. Bigyan Pradhan & Ors.
sisters and legal/biological daughters of late Rai Sahab
Ratna Bahadur Pradhan.
4.
It was pleaded that late Surjyaman Pradhan did
not inherit any ancestral property from his paternal lineage
and only plots of lands inherited by the present legal heirs
of late Surjyaman Pradhan are the plots of lands gifted by
late Rai Sahab Ratna Bahadur to his two daughters i.e. late
Padma Kumari Pradhan and late Damyanti Pradhan.
5.
According to the plaintiffs in the year 1995 the
entire plots of land recorded under Parcha Khatiyan No.54
which were gifted by late Rai Sahab Ratna Bahadur
Pradhan to his two daughters were mutated in the name of
her son late Binay Kumar Pradhan vide Parcha Khatiyan
No.89 as all the sons of late Damyanti Pradhan were minor
but it was promised by late Padma Kumari Pradhan that
once the sons of late Damyanti Pradhan attained the age of
majority the said plots of land shall be equally distributed
between the sons of late Padma Kumari Pradhan and late
Damyanti Pradhan.
6.
Paragraph nos. 07 to 13 and 17 of the plaint are
relevant to the present issue and therefore extracted
verbatim below.
“7. That Late Binay Kumar Pradhan husband of
defendant no.4 died on 28.04.1988 and after his demise
the plaintiff defendant no.4 and father of defendant no.5
C.R.P. No.01 of 2024
Dhan Kumari Pradhan vs. Bigyan Pradhan & Ors.
jointly became the legal, rightful and actual owner of
Khatiyan No.90/204 bearing plot nos. 408, 700, 702, 843,
844, 845, 849 and 868, measuring an area of 1.5640,
0.8920, 0.0880, 2.0520, 0.8600, 0.0860, 0.2560 and
1.1040 Hectares, situated at Rhenock Block, Rongli
Mahkuma, Pakyong District of Sikkim. The said plots of
land are more fully described in the Schedule below and
are hereafter referred to as “suit property” for the present
suit. (An acceptance/acknowledgement letter of defendant
no.4 dated 02.04.1986 is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure-2).
8.
That accordingly, the suit property was mutated in
the joint name of Plaintiffs, defendant no.4 and father of
defendant no.5 vide O.O. No.8547/SDM (R) dated
13.08.1997 (A parcha Khatiyan and map of the suit
property in the joint names of the legal heirs and search
report vide Memo No. 200/SDM/R/E, dated 04.05.2022
are annexed hereto and marked as Annexure-3 Annexure4 and Annexure-5 respectively).
9.
That however, during the digitization of land
records, the suit property was found to be only recorded in
the names of Late Ashok Pradhan, son of Late Surjyaman
@ Suryaman Pradhan (father of defendant no.5) and Smt.
Dhan Kumari Pradhan, wife of Late Binoy Kumar Pradhan
(defendant No.4). (A certified copy of computerized parcha
of suit property is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure-6).
10. That the names of the Plaintiff were wrongfully,
illegally and without adherence to the legal procedure
were removed from the land record of the abovementioned
properties during the digitization of land records by the
defendant No.1, 2 and 3.
11. That the suit property is an unpartitioned ancestral
property of the plaintiffs, defendant no.4 and father of
defendant no.5. The defendant nos. 1, 2 and 3 has no
right to delete the names of the plaintiffs from the
computerized records of rights without first obtaining the
NOC of the other coparceners i.e. Plaintiffs.
12. That when the son of the plaintiff no.3 viz. Shri
Nishek Pradhan filed an RTI application under Right to
Information Act, 2005 with the office of defendant no.3, it
is pertinent to mention that R.O. cum Assistant Director,
Sub-Divisional Office, Rongli, Pakyong District of Sikkim
gave a reply to the said RTI application stating that
conceivably the name of the Plaintiffs have missed out
inadvertently during the process of digitization of land
record. (A RTI reply from R.O. cum Assistant Director,
Sub-Divisional Office, Rongli, Pakyong District of Sikkim
vide Memo No.188/SDM/R/E, dated 05.05.2022 is
annexed hereto and marked a Annexure-7).
13. That based on the alleged computerized parcha, the
defendant No.4 had applied for transfer of the suit
property from the joint name of herself and that of late
C.R.P. No.01 of 2024
Dhan Kumari Pradhan vs. Bigyan Pradhan & Ors.
Ashok Kumar Pradhan to her sole name by obtaining the
no objection certificate from defendant no.5 and the
alleged mutation process was started by the office of
defendant no.3 vide application No.130104197 dated
17.02.2021.
……….”
“17. That the cause of action for this suit first arose on
05.04.2016 when the defendants illegally deleted the
names of the Plaintiffs during the process of digitization of
land record. The cause of action further arose on
17.02.2021 when the defendant no.4 applied for mutation
of the suit property in her sole name after obtaining the
NOC from defendant no.5. The cause of action again arose
on 20.09.2022 when the defendant no.3 passed an order,
directing the Plaintiffs to approach higher court. The cause
of action again arose on 03.01.2023 when the Plaintiff
had sent a legal notice under section 80 of Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 to the defendant nos. 1, 2 and 3 seeking
relieves for the Plaintiffs in respect of the matters related
to the suit land and the said defendants failed to comply
with it. The cause of action lastly arose and from
19.03.2023 when the statutory period of two months given
in the legal notice issued by the Plaintiffs expired. All the
aforementioned cause of action continue to exist till date
under the territorial jurisdiction of this Hon’ble Court.”
7.
The plaintiffs therefore, prayed for the following
reliefs:“a. A decree declaring that the suit property is the
unpartitioned ancestral property and that its title is jointly
held by the Plaintiffs, defendant no.4 and father of
defendant no.5.
b.
A decree declaring that the deletion of the Plaintiffs
name by the defendant No.1 to 3 during the process of
digitization of land record to be wrong and illegal.
c.
A decree declaring the insertion of the name of
defendant no.4 and father of defendant no.5 only in the
record of right to be null and void and restore the suit
property to its original joint names i.e. the name of the
Plaintiffs, defendant no.4 and father of defendant no.5.
d.
A decree cancelling the computerized records of right
dated 05.04.2016, where the suit property is illegally
recorded in the name of defendant no.4 and father of
defendant no.4 being illegal and void-ab-initio.
e.
A decree cancelling/deregistering all the illegal
mutations/transfers of the suit property in favour of any
persons, after the names of the Plaintiffs were illegally
removed from the land records during the process of
digitization of land record.
C.R.P. No.01 of 2024
Dhan Kumari Pradhan vs. Bigyan Pradhan & Ors.
f.
An Order of injunction against the defendant no.4
from transferring, alienating, encumbering, interfering with
or disposing of any of the suit property and against
commencing any construction on the suit property.
g.
A decree for correction of the computerized records
of rights of the suit property as per the office order
No.8574/SDOP, dated 13.08.1997.
h.
A decree awarding compensation for the
harassment meted out by the defendants to the Plaintiffs
by not restoring the suit property in the joint names, even
after repeated requests and representations; and
I.
Any other relief and reliefs for which the Plaintiffs
are entitled to.”
8.
Heard Mr. S. S. Hamal learned Senior Counsel
for the defendant no.4 as well as Mr. Sushant Subba,
learned counsel for the plaintiffs. The learned Senior
Counsel relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in
C.S. Ramaswamy vs. V. K. Senthil & Ors.1 in this case the
Supreme Court on examining the plaint opined that most of
the cause of actions alleged are much prior to/prior to the
execution of the registered sale deeds and even the
averments and allegations with respect to knowledge of the
plaintiffs averred in paragraph 19 thereof can be said to be
too vague. It was also held that nothing has been mentioned
on which date and how the plaintiffs had the knowledge
that
the
document
was
obtained
by
fraud
and/or
misrepresentation. It was also found that the averments
and allegations in the plaint with respect to fraud are not
1 AIR 2022 SC 4724
C.R.P. No.01 of 2024
Dhan Kumari Pradhan vs. Bigyan Pradhan & Ors.
supported by any further averments and allegations how
the fraud has been committed.
9.
In such situations the Supreme Court opined
that:
“7.8 ………... Therefore, even if the submission on
behalf of the respondents – original plaintiffs that only the
averments and allegations in the plaints are required to be
considered at the time of deciding the application under
Order VII Rule 11 CPC is accepted, in that case also by
such vague allegations with respect to the date of
knowledge, the plaintiffs cannot be permitted to challenge
the documents after a period of 10 years. By such a clever
drafting and using the word “fraud”, the plaintiffs have
tried to bring the suits within the period of limitation
invoking Section 17 of the limitation Act. The plaintiffs
cannot be permitted to bring the suit within the period of
limitation by clever drafting, which otherwise is barred by
limitation. ……..”
10.
The learned Senior Counsel for the defendant no.4
does not agitate the issue of lack of cause of action as there
are sufficient pleadings which does reflect that the plaintiffs
may have a cause of action. However, the learned Senior
Counsel insist that due to the pleadings in the plaint and
particularly paragraph 17 where the plaintiffs have made a
categorical statement that the cause of action for the suit
first arose on 05.04.2016 when the defendants illegally
deleted the name of the plaintiffs during the process of
digitization of land records it must be held that the suit was
barred by limitation and rejected under Order VII Rule 11
(d) of the CPC.
C.R.P. No.01 of 2024
Dhan Kumari Pradhan vs. Bigyan Pradhan & Ors.
11.
It is now well settled that the plaint must be read
as a whole in a meaningful and purposeful manner. On the
plaint being so read, it does give an impression that it is the
plaintiffs case that the suit property was mutated in the
joint name of the plaintiffs the defendant no.4 and the
defendant no.5 in the year 1997 but however, during the
process of digitization of the land records the suit property
was found to be recorded in the name of the late Ashok
Pradhan,
son
of
late
Surjyaman
Pradhan
(father
of
defendant no.5) and Smt. Dhan Kumari Pradhan wife of late
Binoy Kumar Pradhan. What is also decipherable is that the
plaintiff no.3 may have learned about the deletion of their
names
only
when
he
received
the
information
on
05.05.2022. What has been mentioned in paragraph 17 is
the date on which the plaintiffs allege that the defendants
had illegally deleted their names during the process of
digitization of land records.
12.
The
prayers
in
the
plaint
are
either
for
declaration or cancellation of the mutation records. To
obtain such a declaration the period of limitation provided
under the Limitation Act 1963 is 3 years when the right to
sue first accrues. Right to sue would first accrue only when
the plaintiff learned about the deletion of their names from
the revenue records on receipt of the RTI information vide
reply dated 05.05.2022 and therefore, the suit which was
C.R.P. No.01 of 2024
Dhan Kumari Pradhan vs. Bigyan Pradhan & Ors.
filed on 15.05.2023 would be within time. On a meaningful
and not formal reading of the plaint in its entirety this Court
is of the view that the learned Civil Court had correctly
rejected the application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC
as this is not a case in which an impression can be gathered
that it is manifestly vexatious and meritless in the sense of
not disclosing a clear right to sue. It is also not a case of
clever drafting trying to bring the suit within the period of
limitation or creating an illusory cause of action or
mischievous. It is apparent that the plaintiffs may have
grievance and therefore, the suit must be tested during trial
and all issues raised by the parties must be tried including
the issue of limitation. It is not a case where the suit
appears from the statement in the plaint to be barred by the
law of limitation. The lack of clarity in the pleadings about
the date of knowledge may be tested during trial after issues
are framed.
13.
The impugned order to that extent is modified
leaving all questions of facts and law open to be tested
during trial. The observations made herein is only for the
purpose of disposal of the present revision petition.
C.R.P. No.01 of 2024
Dhan Kumari Pradhan vs. Bigyan Pradhan & Ors.
14.
The revision petition is accordingly disposed.
Pending interim application also stands disposed.
1.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting
Internet
to/
: Yes
: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review