Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 6th March, 2020
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
M.A.C. App. No.02 of 2019
Appellant
:
Branch Manager,
United India Insurance Company
Limited
versus
Respondent
:
Dhan Bdr. Chhetri and Others
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Pema Ongchu Bhutia, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Mr. Rahul Rathi, Ms. Tashi Doma Bhutia, Ms.
Pritima Sunam and Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa, Advocates for the
Respondents No.1 to 4.
None present for Respondents No.5 and 6.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
C.O. No.01 of 2019
Petitioners
:
Dhan Bdr. Chhetri and Others
versus
Respondents
:
Branch Manager,
United India Insurance Company
Limited and Others
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Ms. Tashi Doma Bhutia and Ms. Pritima Sunam, Advocates for
the Petitioners.
Mr. Pema Ongchu Bhutia, Advocate for the Respondent No.1.
None present for Respondents No.2 and 3.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The grievances expressed in this Appeal pertain to
computation of the income of the deceased by the learned Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal (for short “Tribunal), West Sikkim at
MAC App.No.02 of 2019 and C.O. No.01 of 2019
Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors
and
Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors. v. Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors.
Gyalshing and the choice of Multiplier adopted. The CrossObjection also questions the income of the deceased computed
by the learned Tribunal however on a different ground viz. that
the monthly income of the deceased ought to have been higher
than computed by the learned Tribunal. The Future Prospects
granted by the learned Tribunal stands impugned as being lower
than what ought to have been computed.
2.
The learned Tribunal in MACT Case No.07 of 2018
(Shri Dhan Bdr. Chhetri and Others v. Shri Bikram Tamang and
Others),
dated
Rs.17,67,000/thousand)
only,
29.09.2018,
awarded
a
compensation
(Rupees
seventeen
lakhs
and
on
death
the
deceased,
the
of
sixty
of
seven
to
the
Respondents No.1 and 2 his parents and Respondents No.3 and
4, his siblings. The deceased was travelling in the vehicle bearing
Registration No.SK-02J/0095 (Mahindra Maxx), which met with
an accident at “Tafel Bhir,” Rinchenpong, West Sikkim on
20.04.2016, where he succumbed to his injuries at the place of
accident.
3.
The Appellant questions the income of the deceased
placed at Rs.10,000/- (Rupee ten thousand) only, per month by
the learned Tribunal, on grounds of absence of documentary
evidence to establish the monthly income of the deceased. That
the income assessed by the learned Tribunal has no rational
basis as evident from the impugned Judgment and was a
random figure arrived at for such assessment. That the income
could have been based on the rates of skilled labourers as
Rs.275/- (Rupees two hundred and seventy five) only, per day,
in terms of the Notification of the Department of Labour,
Government of Sikkim bearing No.4/DL, dated 01.11.2014.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant also submitted that the
Multiplier of “18” adopted by the learned Tribunal to calculate
the quantum of compensation was erroneous as the deceased
was 26 years of age and hence the correct Multiplier is “17.”
4.
Per
contra,
repudiating
the
arguments
of
the
Appellant, learned Counsel for the Respondents No.1 to 4
submitted that in fact the income of the deceased was
MAC App.No.02 of 2019 and C.O. No.01 of 2019
Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors
and
Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors. v. Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors.
Rs.30,000/- (Rupee thirty thousand) only, per month, and not
Rs.10,000/- (Rupee ten thousand) only, as arrived at by the
learned Tribunal owning as he did two taxi vehicles and not one
from which he derived his income. That, the Future Prospects
placed at Rs.4,000/- (Rupees four thousand) only, ought to have
been Rs.16,32,000/- (Rupees sixteen lakhs and thirty two
thousand) only.
5.
I have heard and considered the rival submissions of
learned Counsel for the parties. I have also perused all
documents and evidence on record and the impugned Judgment.
6.
Evidently the Respondents No.1 to 4 did not furnish
any Certificate of Income of the deceased or any reliable
document before the learned Tribunal to indicate his income. The
learned Tribunal while assuming that Rs.10,000/- (Rupee ten
thousand) only, was the monthly income of the deceased has not
given any ground for such assessment except the fact that the
deceased was a Driver by profession and used to drive his own
taxi vehicle. The arguments of the Respondents No.1 to 4 that
the income ought to be Rs.30,000/- (Rupee thirty thousand)
only, cannot be countenanced without supporting documentary
evidence. Besides the fact that even if he owned two vehicles it
was not possible, as rightly pointed out by the learned Tribunal,
for him to drive two vehicles at the same time. Hence
considering
this
circumstance,
in
the
absence
of
any
documentary evidence substantiating the monthly income of the
deceased, it is but rational to compute the income of the
deceased at the rate of Rs.275/- (Rupees two hundred and
seventy five) only, per day, being the income notified by the
Department of Labour, Government of Sikkim for “Skilled
Workers,” vide Notification No.4/DL, dated 01.11.2014.
7.
In terms of the decision in Sarla Verma (Smt.) and
Others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another
the Multiplier of
“17” is adopted instead of “18” as the victim was approximately
26 years of age on the date of accident.
(2009) 6 SCC 121
MAC App.No.02 of 2019 and C.O. No.01 of 2019
Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors
and
Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors. v. Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors.
8.
In National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi
and Others2
while discussing Future Prospects, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held as under;
“59.3 While determining the
income, an addition of 50% of actual
salary to the income of the deceased
towards future prospects, where the
deceased had a permanent job and
was below the age of 40 years,
should be made. The addition should
be 30%, if the age of the deceased
was between 40 to 50 years. In case
the deceased was between the age
of 50 to 60 years, the addition
should be 15%. Actual salary should
be read as actual salary less tax.
59.4 In case the deceased was
self-employed or on a fixed salary, an
addition of 40% of the established
income should be the warrant where
the deceased was below the age of 40
years. An addition of 25% where the
deceased was between the age of 40 to
50 years and 10% where the deceased
was between the age of 50 to 60 years
should be regarded as the necessary
method of computation. The established
income means the income minus the
tax component.”
(Emphasis supplied)
Hence, the learned Tribunal has correctly placed the Future
Prospects of the deceased at 40% as he was 26 years of age and
self-employed. However, in view of the change in Multiplier and
monthly income of the deceased a fresh calculation of “40%” is
required to be made.
9.
It is evident from the compensation computed by the
learned Tribunal that although Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees two lakhs)
only, was given for loss of love and affection however no
calculation was made for loss of Filial Consortium. In Magma
General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Nanu Ram and Ors.3 while allowing
consortium not only to the spouse but also to the children and
(2017) 16 SCC 680
MANU/SC/1012/2018
MAC App.No.02 of 2019 and C.O. No.01 of 2019
Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors
and
Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors. v. Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors.
parents of the deceased the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as
follows;
“8.7 A Constitution Bench of
this Court in Pranay Sethi (supra) dealt
with the various heads under which
compensation is to be awarded in a
death case. One of these heads is Loss
of Consortium.
In legal parlance, "consortium"
is
a
compendious
term
which
encompasses
'spousal
consortium',
'parental
consortium',
and
'filial
consortium'.
The right to consortium would
include the company, care, help,
comfort, guidance, solace and affection
of the deceased, which is a loss to his
family. With respect to a spouse, it
would include sexual relations with the
deceased spouse.
……………………………………………………………………
Parental consortium is granted
to the child upon the premature death
of a parent, for loss of "parental aid,
protection, affection, society, discipline,
guidance and training."
Filial consortium is the right of
the parents to compensation in the
case of an accidental death of a child.
An accident leading to the death of a
child causes great shock and agony to
the parents and family of the deceased.
The greatest agony for a parent is to
lose their child during their lifetime.
Children are valued for their love,
affection, companionship and their role
in the family unit.
Parental Consortium is awarded
to children who lose their parents in
motor vehicle accidents under the Act.
A few High Courts have
awarded compensation on this count.
However, there was no clarity with
respect to the principles on which
compensation could be awarded on loss
of Filial Consortium.
The amount of compensation to
be awarded as consortium will be
governed by the principles of awarding
compensation
under
'Loss
of
Consortium' as laid down in Pranay
Sethi (supra).
In the present case, we deem it
appropriate to award the father and the
sister of the deceased, an amount of
Rs.40,000 each for loss of Filial
Consortium.”
(Emphasis supplied)
MAC App.No.02 of 2019 and C.O. No.01 of 2019
Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors
and
Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors. v. Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors.
10.
In Rajesh and Ors. vs. Rajbir Singh and Ors.4 the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held as follows;
“17.
…………………In
legal
parlance, “consortium” is the right of
the spouse to the company, care, help,
comfort, guidance, society, solace,
affection and sexual relations with his or
her mate. That non-pecuniary head of
damages has not been properly
understood by our courts. The loss of
companionship,
love,
care
and
protection, etc., the spouse is entitled
to get, has to be compensated
appropriately. The concept of nonpecuniary
damage
for
loss
of
consortium is one of the major heads of
award of compensation in other parts of
the world more particularly in the
United States of America, Australia, etc.
English courts have also recognised the
right of a spouse to get compensation
even during the period of temporary
disablement. By loss of consortium, the
courts have made an attempt to
compensate the loss of spouse's
affection,
comfort,
solace,
companionship,
society,
assistance,
protection, care and sexual relations
during the future years. Unlike the
compensation
awarded
in
other
countries and other jurisdictions, since
the legal heirs are otherwise adequately
compensated for the pecuniary loss, it
would not be proper to award a major
amount under this head. ………”
Hence, on the anvil of the aforestated ratio in Magma General
Insurance Co. Ltd.
(supra) and Rajesh and Ors. (supra) the
Respondents No.1 to 4 are entitled to Filial compensation. In my
considered opinion, there is no requirement for computing loss of
love and affection in the Award in view of compensation granted
by way of Filial Consortium.
11.
The Litigation Costs awarded by the learned Tribunal
being undisputed are allowed.
(2013) 9 SCC 54
MAC App.No.02 of 2019 and C.O. No.01 of 2019
Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors
and
Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors. v. Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors.
12.
Consequently, in light of the aforesaid facts and
circumstances, the Judgment of the learned trial Court stands
modified to the extent below;
Annual Income of the deceased
Rs.99,000.00
(Rs.275/-x30x12)
Add 40% of Rs.99,000/- as future prospects
Rs.39,600.00
Yearly income of the deceased
Rs.1,38,600.00
Less 1/2 of Rs.1,38,600.00
Rs.69,300.00
[deducted from the said amount as expenses
that the victim would have incurred
towards maintenance had he been alive.]
Net yearly income
Rs.69,300.00
Multiplier of ‘17’ adopted in terms of
Sarla Verma’s case (Rs.69,300 x 17)
Add Loss of Filial Consortium [Rs.40,000/each, payable to Respondents No. 1 to 4,
respectively]
Rs.11,78,100.00
Rs.1,60,000.00
Add Funeral expenses
Rs.15,000.00
Add Loss of estate
Rs.15,000.00
Add Litigation costs
Rs.25,000.00
Total
Rs.13,93,100.00
(Rupees thirteen lakhs, ninety three thousand and one hundred) only.
13.
The Respondents No.1 to 4 shall be entitled to
simple interest @ 9% per annum on the above amount instead
of 10% granted by the learned Tribunal, with effect from the
date of filing of the Claim Petition before the learned Tribunal till
full realisation.
14.
The awarded amount shall be paid by the Appellant
to the Respondents No.1 to 4 within one month from today,
failing which, the Appellant shall pay simple interest @ 12%
from the date of filing of the Claim Petition till realisation, duly
deducting the amounts, if any, already paid by it to the
Respondents No.1 to 4.
15.
Considering the age of the Respondent No.1 and
Respondent No. 2, the parents of the deceased being 64 years
and 55 years respectively while the Respondent No.3 and
Respondent No. 4 his siblings being 26 years and 32 years
MAC App.No.02 of 2019 and C.O. No.01 of 2019
Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors
and
Dhan Bdr. Chhetri & Ors. v. Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors.
respectively and are thereby in a position to fend for themselves,
the awarded amount of compensation shall be divided as
follows;
(i) 70% to Respondents No.1 and 2 (35% each),
the parents of the deceased.
(ii) 30% to Respondents No.3 and 4 (15% each),
the siblings of the deceased.
16.
Appeal allowed to the extent above.
17.
MAC
accordingly.
App.
No.02
of
stands
disposed
of
18.
Cross-objection stands rejected and disposed of.
19.
No order as to costs.
20.
A copy of this Judgment be placed in the file of C.O.
No.01 of 2019, for record.
21.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the learned
Tribunal for information.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
06.03.2020
Approved for reporting : Yes
ml
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review