Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appelllate Jurisdiction)
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2015
Mrs. Devi Maya Chettri,
Wife of Late Karna Bahadur Chettri,
Resident of Middle Sichey,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
…
Appellant
Versus
1.
Mr. Mahesh Chettri, aged about 50 years,
Son of Late Lal Bahadur Chettri,
Resident of Ipsing, Samdong,
P.O. Makha & P.S. Singtam,
East Sikkim.
2.
Mr. Naresh Chettri, aged about 46 years
Son of Late Lal Bahadur Chettri,
Resident of Ipsing, Samdong,
P.O. Makha & P.S. Singtam,
East Sikkim.
3.
Shri Rajendra Chhetri,
Son of Late K.B. Chettri,
Resident of Middle Sichey Busty,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
…
Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ.
For the appellant :
For the respondent
No. 1 & 2
:
Mr. T.B. Thapa, Senior Advocate with Mr. B.K. Gupta,
Advocate.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Malati Sharma,
Advocate.
For the respondent
No.3
:
None appears
Date of hearing
20.10.2020 and 21.10.2010
:
Date of judgment :
23.11.2020
JUDGMENT
(Arup Kumar Goswami, CJ)
This appeal is preferred against the judgment and decree dated
30.07.2015 passed by the learned District Judge, Special Division-II, at
Gangtok in Title Suit No.10/2014 dismissing the suit, which was filed for
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
declaration of right , title and interest in respect of the suit properties
described in the Schedule- A,B and C to the plaint and for recovery of khas
possession of the suit properties by evicting the defendant and his family
members, agents, etc., for permanent injunction and for compensation of
Rs.10,000/- per annum from the date of filing of
the suit till recovery of
possession.
2.
The Schedule of the plaint reads as follows:
“(A) All that land measuring .7440 hectares being Plot No.1077 of Samdong
Block (East Sikkim) with two storied building (new house) puja ghar,
servant‟s quarter and cow shed, latrine etc. recorded in Khatian No.103 in
the name of the Plaintiff.
(B)
All that piece or parcel of land measuring .320 hectares in Plot
No.1068 with one kacha house standing thereon in Samdong Block (East
Sikkim) recorded in Khatian No.103 in the name of the Plaintiff.
(C)
All that land measuring .1700 Hectares in Plot No.1076 in Samdong
Block (East Sikkim) recorded in Khatian No.103 in the name of the Plaintiff.
All the above properties are in Samdong Block Khatian, Samdong Elaka, East
Sikkim and are recorded in Khatian No.103 in the name of Plaintiff.”
3.
The suit was filed by Karna Bahadur Chhetri, husband of the
appellant, against Lall Bahadur Chettri in the court of District Judge, East
and North Sikkim, wherein the same was registered as Title Suit No
12/2008. Subsequently, the suit was numbered as Title Suit No 10/2014 on
being transferred to the Court of District Judge, Special Division-II, at
Gangtok. The plaintiff had earlier filed a suit being Civil Suit No.28/1997 in
the Court of Civil Judge, East Sikkim. The suit was valued at Rs.1501/-. It
appears from an order dated 30.05.1998 passed in the suit that the
defendant had raised a preliminary objection with regard to the valuation of
suit and had filed a petition for rejection of the plaint. However, by the order
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
dated 30.05.1998, the learned Court returned the plaint with a direction that
suit be valued correctly and filed in an appropriate forum.
4.
The subsequent suit came to be filed on 29.08.2008 and it is stated
that the plaint was not returned with necessary endorsement as required
under Order VII Rule 10 CPC and only after an application dated 28.02.2008
was filed before the learned Civil Judge, East Sikkim to return the plaint, by
an order dated 29.08.2008 the plaint was returned to the plaintiff on
29.08.2008 with necessary endorsement.
5.
The pleaded case as set out by the husband of the appellant is that
Purna Bahadur Chettri, who had considerable landed properties in Samdong
Block in East district, had three sons, namely, Jangbir Chettri, Lall Bahadur
Chettri (defendant no.1) and the plaintiff, who was the youngest. During the
minority of plaintiff and Lall Bahadur Chettri, Jangbir Chettri had taken his
share by separating from his father in the year 1951. The plaintiff and Lall
Bahadur remained joint in mess and properties with their father till his death
in 1975 and after about one year of his demise, they mutually partitioned
the properties left behind by their father and started possessing the
properties which fell in their respective shares.
6.
Further case of the plaintiff is that on partition, he became the
owner of 5.0280 hectares of land in Plot nos.1035, 1036, 1064, 1065, 1066,
1067, 1068, 1069, 1071, 1076 and 1077 recorded in Khatian no.103 and the
defendant became the owner of 6.0920 hectares in Plot nos.1006, 1007,
1011, 1031, 1032, 1034, 1073, 1074, 1075, 1096, 1097, 1098, 1099 and
1100. During the survey of 1979, properties were recorded in the name of
the plaintiff and Lall Bahadur based on partition and possession and the
same was accepted by the parties as final. Accordingly, Daddha/Parcha was
issued in the name of the plaintiff and defendant separately. Though Jangbir
Chettri had made some untenable claim about the partition, such claim was
rejected.
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
7.
It is pleaded that two old and dilapidated dwelling houses adjacent
to each other, constructed by their father in Plot nos.1068 and 1069 , had
fallen in the share of the plaintiff. The plaintiff and the defendant being in
government service were residing in other places and their mother used to
live in the said dwelling houses and they had contributed equally for
maintenance of their mother.
8.
The plaintiff also stated that he had an orange nursery in part of the
Plot nos.1076 and 1077 and the rest portion was under paddy cultivation. As
the aforesaid two buildings had become very old and were not comfortable
for their mother, the plaintiff agreed to construct a new house in the
northern portion of Plot no.1077 with the defendant as he said that he would
not like to construct a house in the village but had expressed a desire to live
with the mother till her death under the same roof. Accordingly, a new
building measuring about 55 ft.X 60 ft. was constructed for which expenses
were jointly incurred by them. After construction of the ground floor was
completed, the defendant again requested the plaintiff to construct one more
floor jointly so that the members of the families do not feel crammed for
space. It was agreed that after death of the mother, new house in Plot
no.1077 with other structures will remain the exclusive property of the
plaintiff and the defendant will have no claim over the same.
9.
Construction was started in the year 1985 and completed in the
year 1988 and after such completion, they occupied one suit each in the first
floor whenever they used to visit the village. A small flower garden, a
courtyard and a vehicular road from the PWD road up to the new residential
house were made in a part of Plot no. 1077. More than 50 numbers of fruit
bearing orange trees came to be uprooted in the process as a result of which
plaintiff suffered loss of income and to partly compensate the plaintiff, the
defendant gave his Plot no.1074 to the plaintiff and accordingly, he started
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
cardamom cultivation through Sri Lall Bahadur Dahal in the said plot of land
from the year 1989.
10.
Their elder brother Jangbir Chettri tried to create rift between them
and had also succeeded in gaining some control over their mother. In the
months of October and November, 1995, the defendant requested the
plaintiff to shift to the guest room in the ground floor of the new house on
account of wedding of his son and accordingly, he shifted to the ground floor
and the same continued to be in his exclusive possession.
11.
However, on 21.10.1996, i.e., on the day of Viajaya Dashmi and
Tika, the defendant, along with some of his men, had thrown out his
belongings from the said room, cut down half-ripened paddy plants from Plot
no.1067 and broken open the old dwelling house of the plaintiff in Plot
no.1068 where plaintiff had stored paddy and other food grains and had
taken forcible possession of the same. A meeting was convened by the
defendant on 25.10.1996 with the help of Jangbir Chettri where they had
obtained the signature of their mother in some documents. In view of the
above, the plaintiff had lodged a complaint on 31.10.1996.
12.
Emboldened by the order dated 30.05.1998 passed in Civil Suit
No.28/1997, defendant dispossessed the plaintiff from the entire land of Plot
no.1077 including the new house, Plot no.1076 and the old house in Plot
no.1068. Attempt was also made to dispossess the plaintiff from other house
in plot no.1069. However, the defendant had not succeeded in his attempt.
13.
After mother of the parties had died in the month of March, 2001,
the plaintiff requested the defendant to give back possession of the new
house in Plot no.1077 by honoring his commitment, but the defendant
refused to deliver possession and as such the suit came to be filed..
14.
In the written statement, the defendant, apart from taking usual
pleas such as the suit is barred by law of limitation, etc., stated that suit is
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
grossly under-valued as the value of property cannot be less then
Rs.3,05,95,165/-. It is stated that after demise of his father, the land in
Ipsing (area where the land is situated) was divided in two parts along the
village road starting from „Bar Pipal‟ trees to “Dhar Ghar”, the house of the
grandfather. The plaintiff being younger in age was given the first option to
choose his share and he had opted to take up the land above the village
road which was to the east of the village road and the land below was left for
the defendant. It was mutually agreed that the inheritance will take place on
the basis of such division only after the death of their mother. Though there
was neither any formal partition nor any written document, the partition was
made by the boundary of the road and not by distribution of specific plots of
land and Plot nos.1076 and 1077 being below the village road i.e. west of
the Road, did not fall in the share of the plaintiff and the same fell in the
share of the defendant and accordingly he was in possession of the same. It
is stated that the plaintiff concocted the story of cultivating the same
through Adhiadars/Kutiadars.
15.
It is pleaded that survey of 1978 was conducted in absence of the
parties and Plot nos.1074, 1076 and 1077 were wrongly surveyed in favour
of the plaintiff. He had nowhere admitted that the aforesaid plots fell in the
share of plaintiff. It is denied that Parcha was issued in favour of defendant
and plaintiff separately. It is stated that their father had decided that both of
them will have one house each, built over Plot nos.1068 and 1069 , and
while the defendant possessed the old house in Plot no.1968, the plaintiff
demolished his old house and built a new house in the same place. It is
denied that the new house in Plot no.1077 was built jointly and it is asserted
that he had started construction in the year 1983, by initially constructing
approach road, leveling ground etc. and completed the house having two
floors by engaging 3 contractors incurring an expenditure of more than 3.5
crores. The plaintiff had not contributed any amount for the construction of
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
the house. While denying the statements made by the plaintiff with regard
to the two-storied building, defendant stated that being his younger brother
he was allowed to stay in that house whenever he visited the village. While
denying that he ever proposed to give up Plot no.1074 as compensation to
the plaintiff, it is stated that in the said plot he had planted Chinese teak
trees.
16.
While denying that the plaintiff was dispossessed from the Plot nos.
1068, 1074, 1076 and 1077 after 30.05.1998, it is pleaded that the
defendant is in possession of Plot nos. 1068, 1074, 1076 and 1077 as owner
from 1984 and he also claims to be the owner by way of adverse possession
from the time of partition if the above plots had been recorded in the name
of the plaintiff. The mother of the parties desired that both plaintiff and
defendant live in peace and harmony and accordingly, had left behind a
sworn affidavit stating the factual aspects which belie the claims of the
plaintiff.
17.
It appears that on the death of the original plaintiff, i.e. Karna
Bahadur Chettri, the appellant, her son, Rajendra Chettri, and daughters,
namely, Mamta Chettri, Gitanjali Chettri, Maheshwari Chettri had filed an
application under Order XXII Rule 3 read with Section 151 CPC for
substitution and it is seen that by an order dated 20.04.2011 Rajendra
Chettri alone was substituted. On an application filed by the present
appellant under Order 1 Rule 10 read with Section 151 CPC, by an order
dated 06.06.2012, she was impleaded as plaintiff. It is further seen that by a
subsequent order dated 15.10.2012, Rajendra Chettri was transposed as Pro
forma defendant no.2.
18.
By an order dated 25.09.2014, the appellant was given an
opportunity by the learned trial court to file additional pleading. Thereafter,
the appellant filed additional pleading stating that she wants to continue with
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
the suit filed by her deceased husband and verified the pleadings filed by her
husband.
19.
After the appellant had filed additional pleading on 29.09.2014, the
defendant had filed another written statement which is more or less replica
of the earlier written statement. Additionally, it is stated that after return of
the plaint for presenting before the appropriate Court after rectification of
valuation of the suit, the original plaintiff made changes in the plaint for
which it cannot be taken to have been filed in the same suit. It is also stated
that additional pleading filed is no pleading in the eye of law and the suit is
liable to be dismissed as the present plaintiff filed no plaint.
20.
During pendency of the appeal, Lall Bahadur Chettri, as respondent
no. 1, had filed a petition under Section 151 CPC supported by his sworn
affidavit for dismissing the appeal as infructuous. It is also stated in the said
petition that the petition has been filed on behalf of respondent no. 2. The
petition was registered as IA No. 02 of 2017. It is stated in the petition that
Karna Bahadur Chettri had executed a Will dated 19.06.2010 whereby he
had bequeathed the suit properties to his son, Rajendra Chettri, arrayed as
respondent no. 2 in the appeal. It is averred that the appellant had filed Civil
Misc. Case (Succession) No. 84 of 2015 in respect of properties mentioned in
the Will. The aforesaid case was disposed on 20.04.2017 by granting Letters
of Administration and therefore, the appellant lost her locus standi to
continue with the appeal.
21.
Reply affidavit was filed by the appellant. It is stated that against
an order dated 10.09.2013 passed by the learned trial court rejecting the
plaint, an appeal was filed before this Court, registered as RFA No. 01 of
2014. While disposing of RFA No. 01 of 2014 by an order dated 26.08.2014,
this Court had observed that the appellant has locus standi and therefore,
the petition is misconceived.
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
22.
When the present appeal was taken up for consideration along with
RFA No. 4 of 2016 and RFA No. 11 of 2017 on 26.02.2020, this Court had
observed that hearing of the appeals may be commenced and at the time of
consideration of RFA No. 5 of 2015, contention advanced in the petition
under Section 151 CPC would be taken into consideration by this Court. As
reflected in the order, learned counsel for the parties had also agreed to the
course of action proposed by the Court and accordingly, hearing of RFA No.
05 of 2015 had commenced. The case was again listed for consideration on
03.03.2020 but the hearing of the cases could not be completed. Because of
lockdown and prayer for adjournment, etc. the cases were subsequently
released from part-heard. The appeals having again been listed on
19.10.2020 before this court, the same were taken up for consideration. The
learned counsel appearing for the parties submitted that hearing of the
cases may be proceeded with in terms of the order dated 26.02.2020.
Though three appeals are listed together, it is to be stated that all the
appeals relate to different properties but involving same parties except in
RFA No. 4 of 2016.
23.
Accordingly, Mr. T.B. Thapa, learned Senior Counsel for the
appellant and Mr. N. Rai, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
substituted legal representatives of respondent no.1, namely, Mahesh
Chettri and Naresh Chettri are heard. None has appeared for Rajendra
Chettri .
24.
IA No.4 of 2019 is an application by which the appellant prays for
bringing on record the certified copy of the application for Letters of
Administration with all the annexures. The same is taken on record and IA
No.4 of 2019 is disposed of.
25.
While arguing the appeal, both the counsel have addressed
arguments on IA No. 02 of 2017. IA No. 02 of 2017 is taken up first.
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
26.
Abiding by the averments made in the petition, Mr. Rai contends
that in view of the judgment rendered in Civil Misc. Case (Succession) No.
84 of 2015, disputed plots of land which are subject matter of Title Suit No.
10 of 2014 having fallen in the share of Rajendra Chettri, the appellant,
Smt. Devi Maya Chettri, has no locus standi to maintain the appeal.
Accordingly, he submits that it is only Rajendra Chettri, to whom the suit
property was bequeathed, who can maintain and continue to proceed with
appeal.
27.
Mr. Thapa submits that right, title and interest in respect of
property cannot be determined in a petition for grant of Letters of
Administration. Relying on the order of this Court dated 26.08.2014 passed
in RFA No. 01 of 2014, he contends that a widow has a right and interest in
the estate of the deceased and this Court had held that the appellant is
possessed of necessary locus to pursue with the suit and therefore, there is
no merit in the petition and accordingly, the same is liable to be dismissed.
28.
Mr. Karna Bahadur Chettri had died on 22.11.2010. The Will was
executed on 09.06.2010. The learned District Judge, East at Gangtok at
paragraph 63 of the judgment dated 20.04.2017 passed in Civil Misc. Case
(Succession) No. 84 of 2015 had recorded that she found no reason to
disbelieve the authenticity of the Will. It is submitted at the Bar that the
judgment dated 20.04.2017 passed in Civil Misc. Case (Succession) No. 84
of 2015 had not been put to challenge and has attained finality.
29.
Paragraph 10 of the Will reads as follows:
That I have got the landed properties at Samdong Block in the East
District of Sikkim as share to my ancestral property comprising Plot Nos.
1035, 1036, 1064, 1065, 1066, 1067, 1068, 1069, 1071, 1076 and 1077
recorded under Khatian No. 103.
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
In Plot No.1077, there is a building jointly constructed by me and my
brother Shri Lall Bahadur Chettri with an understanding that after the death
of our mother, the house constructed in Plot No. 1077 with other structures
will remain my exclusive property and my brother Shri Lall Bahadur Chettri
will not lay any claim in the said house. The said house was constructed for
beneficial and comfortable living with the mother as my brother did not want
to construct a house in the village and would like to live with mother till the
mother’s death. However, my brother Lall Bahadur Chettri forcefully took
possession of Plot No. 1077 with two storied building, Plot No. 1068 with one
kutchha house therein and Plot No. 1076 and illegally dispossessed me from
the above plots of land. On such illegal dispossession I have filed a civil suit
claiming for declaration, recovery of possession, compensation and for other
consequential reliefs before the Court of District Judge, East at Sikkim, which
is registered as Title Suit No. 12 of 2008 and pending disposal.
30.
It is to be noted that Title Suit No. 12 of 2008, referred to in the
above order, came to be subsequently registered as Title Suit No. 10 of
2014 in the Court of District Judge, Special Division-II at Gangtok.
31.
The relevant portion of paragraph 13 of the Will reads as follows:
“13. Whereas, I hereby depose and bequeath that the above said
properties are under to my wife, daughters and son which will take effect
only after my death:……….
(E)
…………
………..
…………
That I have got the landed properties at Samdong Block, East
District of Sikkim which I have inherited and are my ancestral properties. I
hereby bequeath all my share/interest on the said landed properties
together with cottage type house constructed by me and all other
structures/houses therein to my son Shri Rajendra Kumar Chettri. The
details of the properties are given in paragraph ten (10) above.
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
32.
In the order dated 26.08.2014 passed by this Court in RFA No. 01
of 2014, this Court had observed that there can be no manner of doubt that
a widow has a right and interest in the estate of the deceased and the
appellant was possessed of all necessary locus to pursue with the suit.
However, the observations made have to be understood in the context in
which the same were made. When the said order was passed, the
application for grant of Letters of Administration in respect of the Will was
not even filed. The position in law changed drastically with the grant of
Letters of Administration in Civil Misc. Case (Succession) No. 84 of 2015 filed
at the instance of the appellant. The appellant in the application for grant of
Letters of Administration had stated that Schedule D property was given to
Rajendra Chettri. Schedule D properties included the suit properties of Title
Suit No. 10 of 2014 and presently of RFA No. 05 of 2015. Letters of
Administration was granted in respect of suit properties along with some
other properties. However, the learned District Judge had declined to grant
Letters of Administration in respect of certain properties which were sought
to be bequeathed by the testator but which were not recorded in his name.
With the grant of Letters of Administration, the appellant ceases to have any
right or interest in respect of suit properties. It is worthwhile to recapitulate
that Rajendra Chettri, who was substituted as plaintiff, had transposed
himself as defendant and was not contesting the suit subsequent to the
impleadment of the appellant as plaintiff in the suit.
33.
In view of the above discussion, I am of the considered opinion
that the appellant presently has no locus standi to pursue the present
appeal.
34.
In view of the above determination, discussion on the merit of the
appeal is not called for.
35.
IA No. 02 of 2017 is allowed.
RFA No. 05 of 2015
Devi Maya Chettri vs. Mahesh Chettri & Ors.
36.
Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed as not maintainable at the
instance of the present appellant. No cost.
37.
LCRs be sent back.
Chief Justice
jk
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review