Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
LAIREN
MAYUM Digitally signed by
LAIRENMAYUM
SINGH
INDRAJ INDRAJEET
Date: 2026.03.10
18:22:44 +05'30'
EET
SINGH
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
Devi Datt Joshi, aged about 51 years, S/o (Late) Dayakishan Joshi,
having permanent resident of Village and Post Barabey (Alallani) DistrictPhithoragarh, Uttarakhand, at present residing at Institute of
Bioresources & Sustainable Development (IBSD), Gust House, Room No.
21, Uripok, Imphal West, P.O. & P.S. Imphal West District, Manipur.
... Petitioner
Vrs.
1. The Union of India, represented by the Secretary, Department of BioTechnology, Ministry of Science & Technology, Government of India,
New Delhi – 110003;
2. The Director, Institute of Bioresources & Sustainable Development
(IBSD) Department of Biotechnology, Government of India,
Takyelpat, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
... Respondents
BEFORE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the petitioner
For the respondents
:
:
Date of Hearing
Date of Judgment
:
:
Mr. Murari Tiwari, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, DSGI; and
Mr. L. Anand, Sr. Advocate
25.09.2025
10.03.2026
JUDGMENT
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. Murari Tiwari, learned senior counsel appearing for
the petitioner; Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI appearing for respondent No.
1; and Mr. L. Anand, learned senior counsel appearing for respondent No. 2.
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
[2]
The present writ petition has been filed challenging the order
dated 06.07.2018 issued by the Senior Administrative Officer, Institute of
Bioresources & Sustainable Development (hereinafter referred to as ‘IBSD’ for
short) terminating the service of the petitioner, letter dated 13.07.2018 from
the Under Secretary to the Govt. of India, Ministry of Science & Technology,
Department of Biotechnology disposing of the representation submitted by
the petitioner by declining to cancel the order terminating the service of the
petitioner and order dated 27.09.2018 issued by the Secretary, Department
of Biotechnology, Government of India, Ministry of Science & Technology,
Department of Biotechnology, rejecting the appeal filed by the petitioner
against the said termination order (hereinafter collectively referred to as ‘the
impugned orders’).
[3]
The brief facts which culminates in filing of the present writ
petition are that the Director, IBSD issued an advertisement dated 20.04.2011
inviting applications for appointment against various posts, including 1(one)
post of Scientist – E (Natural Product Chemistry). As per the said
advertisement, the essential qualification for the said post of Scientist – E
(Natural
Product
Chemistry)
Biochemistry/Phytochemistry/Organic
are
1st
Chemistry
class
or
M.Sc.
in
equivalent
with
specialization in natural product chemistry having at least eleven years
research experience or Ph.D in the above subjects with at least ten years
research experience. The petitioner having the qualification of M.Sc. and Ph.D
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
in Organic Chemistry applied for the said post of Scientist – E (Natural Product
Chemistry).
[4]
The petitioner, having been selected and recommended by the
Selection Committee for appointment as Scientist – E (Natural Product
Chemistry), was informed, inter alia, by the Director (I/C), IBSD under its
letter dated 20.03.2013 that the petitioner will be appointed initially for a
period of 5(five) years which can later be regularized on satisfactory
performance and that his appointment to the post will be as per the terms
and conditions of the contract agreement. The petitioner was also directed to
intimate and submit his acceptance of the offered post along with the signed
Contract Agreement and other related documents within 10th April, 2013,
failing which the said offer will be treated as cancelled.
[5]
The petitioner accepted the offer of appointment by signing an
agreement executed on 03.04.2013 between the IBSD and the petitioner and
the petitioner joined his service on the same day by submitting a joining
report dated 03.04.2013. The said agreement contains the following terms
and conditions:“1. Period of Employment :
IBSD hereby appoints the party of the FIRST PART for a term of five years
on contract basis from the date of his/her joining the institute.
The party of the first part will be on the probation during the first years
of the period of five years service. The party of the second part can extend
or curtail the period of probation at its discretion.
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
The Service of the party of the FIRST PART can be continued on regular
basis on completion of the term of five years, if found suitable after review
to be carried out by the party of the Second Part. Such review will normally
be completed before the expiry of the five years period. If due to some
administrative reasons or otherwise the party of the Second Part is unable
to decide about offering regular service after completion of five years, the
terms of five years may be extended for such terms as may be mutually
agreed to between the parties.
“2. Duties/Job Profile :
The party of the FIRST PART shall submit himself to the orders of the
IBSD under whom he may from time to time be placed by IBSD and shall
hold the said appointment for the term up to 02.04.2018 from the date
of joining i.e. 03.04.2013 subject to the provisions as herein contained.
The Party of the FIRST PART shall devote his whole time to his duties
assigned by the Director, IBSD and shall at all times obey the Rules and
Bye-laws of the Society of IBSD prescribed from time to time.
“4. Termination :
During the probation period, extended or otherwise, the contracts can be
terminated by giving one calendar month’s notice in writing or one
month’s salary in lieu of notice as termination simplicitor by either party
without assigning any reason. In the event a shorter notice is given by
either party, a sum equivalent to the salary of the period, notice period
falls short of one month shall be payable by the concerned party to the
other party.
Any time after completion of the probation and within five years or its
extensions the contract can be terminated by giving three calendar
month’s notice in writing or three months salary in lieu of notice as
termination simplicitor by either party without assigning any reason. In
the event a shorter notice is given by either party, a sum equivalent to
the salary of the period, notice falls short of three months, shall be
payable by the concerned party to the other party.”
[6]
Before expiry of the period of service of 5(five) years, the
petitioner filed a writ petition in this Court registered as WP(C) No. 195 of
2018 seeking for a direction to the respondents to regularize his service to
the post of Scientist – E (Natural Product Chemistry). The said writ petition
was disposed of on 04.05.2018 by issuing a directions to the respondents to
undertake the aforesaid exercise of review for considering regularisation of
the service of the petitioner and that till such exercise is completed, the
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
petitioner will continue to remain and function as Scientist – E (Natural
Product Chemistry) with all the attending service benefits including pay and
allowances.
[7]
Pursuant to the aforesaid directions given by this Court in its
order dated 04.05.2018 passed in WP(C) No. 195 of 2018, the Senior
Administrative Officer, IBSD, wrote a letter dated 11.05.2018 requesting the
petitioner to submit his self assessment report for the last 5(five) years to the
competent authority of the institute on or before 16th May, 2018 and also
informing the petitioner that his performance shall be evaluated by an
Assessment Committee in the last week of May, 2018 or first week of June,
2018. In the said letter, the petitioner was further informed that based on the
recommendation of the Assessment Committee after evaluation of his 5(five)
years performance followed by a power point presentation and a personal
interview, the competent authority of the institute shall decide for either
regularization of his service or extension of the contract period or termination
of the contract agreement.
[8]
By an office order dated 15.05.2018 issued by the Senior
Administrative Officer, IBSD, an Assessment Committee consisting of 9(nine)
persons was constituted to assess the performance of the 3(three)
contractual
scientists
including
the
present
petitioner
for
their
regularization/extension/termination. It was also mentioned in the said order
that the committee shall meet on 28th May, 2018 at 9:30 A.M. in the institute
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
conference hall at Takyelpat, Imphal. For ready reference, a scanned copy of
the said office order dated 15.05.2018 is reproduced hereunder:-
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
[9]
The said Assessment Committee held its meeting on the
scheduled date, i.e. on 28th May, 2018 and after assessing the self appraisal
report of the petitioner, his power point presentation, personal interview, the
Assessment Committee found the petitioner’s performance to be below
average and hence, not recommended for regularization. For ready reference,
a scanned copy of the minutes of the Assessment Committee meeting held
on 28th May, 2018 are reproduced hereunder:-
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
[10]
In pursuance of the aforesaid recommendation made by the
Assessment Committee regarding the performance of the petitioner as below
average and not recommended for regularization of his service and in terms
of the agreement dated 03.04.2013 executed between the petitioner and
IBSD and after obtaining the approval of the Director, IBSD, the Senior
Administrative Officer issued an order dated 06.07.2017 terminating the
service of the petitioner w.e.f. 06.07.2018. Against the said termination order,
the petitioner submitted a representation dated 09.07.2018 to the Secretary,
Department of Biotechnology, Government of India, with a request to cancel
his termination order. However, the said representation was disposed of by
the authority by declining to interfere with the termination order and the same
was duly communicated to the petitioner under the letter dated 13.07.2018
from the Under Secretary to the Govt. of India, Ministry of Science &
Technology, Department of Biotechnology. In the said letter, it was also
mentioned that as per the said agreement dated 03.04.2013, the petitioner’s
advance salary of 3(three) months has already been released.
[11]
After rejection of his representation, the petitioner again filed an
appeal dated 20.07.2018 to the Secretary, Dept. of Biotechnology, Govt. of
India requesting to quash his termination order dated 06.07.2018, to review
the letter dated 13.07.2018 and to allow him to continue in service. The
petitioner also filed a writ petition in this Court registered as WP(C) No. 772
of 2018 challenging his termination order. The said writ petition was disposed
of by an order dated 23.08.2018 by directing respondent No. 1 to consider
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
and dispose of the appeal filed by the petitioner against his termination order
within a period of 1(one) month from the date of receipt of a copy of the
order by issuing a speaking order. This Court also made it clear that it was
open to the petitioner to approach this Court again in case he is aggrieved by
any order passed by the respondents while disposing of the said appeal.
In compliance with the direction given by this Court, the Secretary,
Department of Biotechnology, Government of India considered the appeal
submitted by the petitioner and disposed of the same by issuing an order
dated 27.09.2018 declining to accept the plea and request made by the
petitioner in his appeal. Having been aggrieved, the petitioner again
approached this Court by filing the present writ petition for redressing his
grievances.
[12]
Mr. Murari Tiwari, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner raised before this Court only 2(two) grounds in assailing the
impugned orders. It has been submitted on behalf of the petitioner that in
the advertisement dated 20.04.2011, it is nowhere stipulated that the
advertised post and applied for by the petitioner was contractual in nature
and that the petitioner’s employment as Scientist – E (Natural Product
Chemistry) was a permanent employment which was to be regularized after
competition of 5(five) years as clearly stipulated in the advertisement dated
20.04.2011 and offer of appointment letter dated 20.03.2013. It has also
been submitted on behalf of the petitioner that the alleged contractual
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
agreement was executed by the petitioner under the instructions of
respondent No. 2 and assurance given at that time that the same is merely a
formality. The learned senior counsel also submitted that the petitioner had
already completed his probation period and only days before his assessment
for regularization, his service was terminated by respondent No. 2 on the
basis of false, frivolous and baseless grounds as well as on the basis of a
frivolous assessment report. The learned senior counsel further submitted
that the termination of the petitioner’s service by invoking clause 4 of the
agreement dated 03.04.2013 is illegal and such termination is not sustainable
in the eyes of law.
[13]
The second ground raised by the learned senior counsel on
behalf of the petitioner is that the said Assessment Committee was not
constituted as provided under Schedule IV appended to the NII Group
‘I’,’II’,’III’, and ‘IV’ (Administrative, Technical and Scientific) Recruitment
Rules, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Recruitment Rules’ for short).
The composition of the Selection/Assessment Committee as provided under
Schedule IV of the Recruitment Rules in respect of ‘Scientific Cadre’ are :1. Director or his nominee from outside the Institute –
Chairman
2. Nominee of the Director from Senior Faculty – Member
3. Two outside experts for each discipline in which the
selection or assessment of a scientist is to be made, to
be nominated by the Director – Member
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
4. Senior Manager – Non-Member (Secretary).
[14]
It has been submitted by the learned senior counsel that the said
Assessment Committee formed by respondent No. 2 did not have any expert
in the petitioner’s discipline i.e., Natural Product Chemistry. It is the case of
the petitioner that the 2(two) outside experts namely Dr. Amulya K. Panda is
a Chemical Engineer and Dr. Shekhar C. Mande completed his Master’s
Degree in Physics and Doctorate in Molecular Biophysics, which is nowhere
related to Natural Product Chemistry, which is a branch of Organic Chemistry.
[15]
It has been submitted on behalf of the petitioner that Natural
Product Chemistry is the study of chemical compounds found in the nature
and it involves the process of isolation, identification, structure elucidation
and biosynthesis of natural compounds and that Natural Product Chemistry is
a research focused discipline and academic in nature wherein even after
obtaining a Doctorate there is further laboratory training involved as opposed
to Chemical Engineering which is an applied science focused on industrial
processes, practical implementations etc. hence, vastly different in practical
approach as that of Natural Product Chemistry. Accordingly, it has been
submitted that Dr. Amulya K. Panda is not an expert in the field/discipline of
the Natural Product Chemistry.
[16]
It has also been submitted on behalf of the petitioner that Dr.
Shekhar C. Mande, the other outside expert has a Master’s Degree in Physics
and that MSc. Physics and MSc. Chemistry are completely distinct from each
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
other. It has further been submitted that since the foundational background
and understanding of pure organic synthesis, biosynthetic pathway
elucidation is crucial to understand the discipline of Natural Product
Chemistry, Dr. Shekhar C. Mande is not an expert in the discipline Natural
Product Chemistry. It has been submitted that the Assessment Committee
was formed of total of 9(nine) members as opposed to 5(five) members as
provided under Schedule IV of the Recruitment Rules. The learned counsel
submitted that in view of the such lapses on the part of the authorities while
constituting the Assessment Committee, the impugned orders are liable to be
quashed and set-aside and the present writ petition be allowed by directing
respondent No. 2 to reinstate the petitioner in service.
[17]
In the light of the submissions advanced on behalf of the
petitioner, the following 3(three) issues arose for consideration by this Court:i.
Whether the appointment of the petitioner as Scientist
– E (Natural Product Chemistry) was contractual in
nature or not?
ii.
Whether
the
Assessment
Committee
was
duly
constituted as provided under Schedule IV of the
Recruitment Rules or not?
iii.
Whether any illegalities have been committed by the
authorities in terminating the service of the petitioner or
not?
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
[18]
Issue No. 1:
Rule 7 of the Recruitment Rules deals with Direct Recruitment
and under 7.2 it is provided as under:‘7.2 The selected candidates, from the date of assuming the
duties will be on contract initially for a maximum period of five years. At
the end of four years of service the candidates performance will be
assessed by an assessment committee to be appointed by the Appointing
Authority to decide if the candidate’s performance during the four years
service has been satisfactory or otherwise. If his/her performance is found
to be satisfactory by the assessment committee, he/she will be offered
regular appointment on completion of five years contract service. In case
his/her performance is not found to be satisfactory, his/her contract
service will stand terminated at the end of five years term of the initial
contract appointment.’
Under Bye-Laws 8.1 of the Bye-Laws for Administration and
Management of the National Institute of Immunology, it is provided as under:‘8.1. Period of Service
The appointment (vide Appendix-I) will be on contract initially for a
period of 5 years. A review will be carried out at the end of 4 years to
assess the suitability of candidate for regular appointment thereafter or
termination of the contract, as the case may be.’
[19]
In the light of the provisions of Rule 7.2 of the Recruitment Rules
and Bye-Laws 8.1 of the Bye-Laws quoted hereinabove, which are applicable
in the case of the petitioner, the following points emerges very clearly:(a) The appointment of a selected candidates will be on
contract initially for a maximum period of 5(five) years;
(b) At the end of 4(four) years of service, the candidates
performance will be reviewed/assessed by an Assessment
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
Committee to decide if the candidate’s performance during the
4(four) years service has been satisfactory or otherwise;
(c) If the candidate’s performance is found to be satisfactory,
the candidate will be offered regular appointment on
completion of 5(five) years contract service;
(d) In case the candidate’s performance is not found to be
satisfactory, the candidate’s contract service will stand
terminated at the end of 5(five) years term of the initial
contract appointment;
(e) There is no provision under the Recruitment Rules and the
Bye-Laws providing for direct recruitment on regular basis.
[20]
In the present case, when the petitioner was selected and
recommended by the Selection Committee for his appointment as Scientist –
E (Natural Product Chemistry), the petitioner was given his offer of
appointment by the Director (I/C), IBSD under his letter dated 20.03.2013.
In the said letter, the petitioner was clearly informed that his appointment
shall be initially for a period of 5(five) years which can later be regularized on
satisfactory performance and that his appointment to the post will be as per
the terms and conditions of the enclosed contract agreement and the
petitioner was requested to intimate and submit his acceptance of the offered
post along with the signed Contract Agreement.
[21]
Subsequently, the petitioner accepted his offer of appointment
by signing and executing an agreement on 03.04.2013 and joined his service
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
on the same date by submitting a joining report. In the said agreement, the
following terms and conditions are clearly mentioned:(a) The petitioner was appointed on contract basis for the terms
of 5(five) years from the date of his joining the institute, i.e.,
w.e.f. 03.04.2013 till 02.04.2018;
(b) The petitioner’s service can be continued on regular basis on
completion of the terms of 5(five) years, if found suitable after
review to be carried by the institute and such review will
normally be completed before the expiry of 5(five) years
period.
[22]
In view of the narratives and findings given above, there is no
escaping from the fact that the appointment of the petitioner as Scientist – E
(Natural Product Chemistry) in IBSD is purely on contract basis and therefore
this Court is of the considered view that there is no substance and merit in
the submission made on behalf of the petitioner that the petitioner’s
appointment as Scientist – E (Natural Product Chemistry) was a permanent
or regular appointment.
[23]
Issue No. 2:In the Office Order dated 15.05.2018 issued by the Senior
Administrative Officer, IBSD, it is clearly mentioned that the Competent
authority of the Institute constituted the Assessment Committee of 9(nine)
members to assess the performance of altogether 5 Scientist in different
fields/subjects, including the present petitioner, to assess their performance
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
for their regularization/extension/termination/promotion. A scanned copy of
the said order has already been reproduced hereinabove. Schedule IV of the
Recruitment Rules provides for composition of the Selection/Assessment
Committee consisting of only 5(five) members (including two outside subject
experts in each discipline) in respect of scientific cadre. Since the Assessment
Committee in question has been constituted to assess the performance of
altogether 5(five) scientists in different fields/subjects, the enlargement of
the composition of the Assessment Committee to 9(nine) to include subject
experts in the field is reasonable and rational and this Court did not find any
infirmity in constituting such an Assessment Committee.
[24]
So far as the submissions made on behalf of the petitioner that
the Assessment Committee formed by respondent No. 2 did not have any
expert in Natural Product Chemistry and that the 2(two) alleged outside
experts namely Dr. Amulya K. Panda and Dr. Shekhar C. Mande are not
subject experts in Natural Product Chemistry is concerned, it is the case of
the respondents that Dr. Amulya K. Panda has been working on different
areas of bioprocess engineering for the last 30 years. He has experiences on
all the three areas on biological manufacturing namely fermentation,
downstream processing and formulation of biologicals. He does innovative
bioprocess engineering utilizing basic fundamental rules of biology. He has
significantly contributed towards the growth of plant cells in bioreactor for
the production of secondary metabolites and have reported the very first
study on high cell density recombinant fermentation from India. He has
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
reported the highest amount of recombinant protein expression among the
earliest Indian studies. Novel protein refolding methods developed by him has
been accepted worldwide for high throughput recovery of bioactive protein
from inclusion bodies of E. coli. He has the credentials of generating highest
numbers of IPRs while working at National Institute of Immunology.
[25]
It has been submitted on behalf of the respondents that Dr.
Shekhar C. Mande is a Structural and Computational Biologist. He was the
Director General of the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR),
India, and the Secretary of the Department of Scientific and Industrial
Research (DSIR), Ministry of Science and Technology. Prior to this, he was
the Director of National Centre for Cell Science, Pune. As a scientist of global
repute his areas of research and academic interest include- Proteins structure
and function, biology of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, probed through
structural analysis of proteins, various biophysical and biochemical
approaches, Applications of Graph Theory to large scale protein interaction
networks, and Computational methods to analyze large-scale biological data.
[26]
It has been submitted on behalf of the respondents that the
above mentioned 2(two) outside experts namely Dr. Amulya K. Panda and
Dr. Shekhar C. Mande, are eminent scientists and even though they may have
different academic backgrounds, their research interests, research highlights
and the scientific contributions have a direct applicability and connection with
the border and vast spectrum of Natural Product Chemistry. It has also been
submitted that the petitioner cannot question the expertise of the said 2(two)
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
outside subject experts at this point of time after he have participated in the
assessment process without any demur or protest.
[27]
Upon consideration of the rival submissions addressed before
this Court, this Court is of the considered view that the issue as to whether
Dr. Amulya K. Panda and Dr. Shekhar C. Mande are subject experts in Natural
Product Chemistry or not is a disputed question of fact. The said disputed
question is in the realm of academic field and this Court has no expertise to
decide the same.
[28]
Looking from another angle, as the petitioner has not assailed
the composition of the said Assessment Committee under the Officer Order
dated 15.05.2018 or the recommendation made by the said Assessment
Committee in its meeting held on 28.05.2018, this Court cannot consider and
examine the legality or otherwise of the composition of the said Selection
Committee or the recommendation made by it in respect of the present
petitioner. This court respectfully followed the principles of law laid down by
the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of ”Basavaiah (Dr.) Vrs. Dr. H.L.
Ramesh & ors.” reported in (2010) 8 SCC 372 wherein, it has been held
as under:‘21.
It is the settled legal position that the courts have to show
deference and consideration to the recommendation of an Expert
Committee consisting of distinguished experts in the field. In the instant
case, the experts had evaluated the qualification, experience and
published work of the appellants and thereafter recommendations for
their appointments were made. The Division Bench of the High Court
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
ought not to have sat as an appellate court on the recommendations made
by the country’s leading experts in the field of Sericulture.’
‘38.
We have dealt with the aforesaid judgments to reiterate and
reaffirm the legal position that in the academic matters, the courts have
a very limited role particularly when no mala fides have been alleged
against the experts constituting the Selection Committee. It would
normally be prudent, wholesome and safe for the courts to leave the
decisions to the academicians and experts. As a matter of principle, the
courts should never make an endeavor to sit in appeal over the decisions
of the experts. The courts must realize and appreciate its constraints and
limitations in academic matters.’
[29]
In view of the narratives and findings given above, this Court is
not inclined to interfere with the impugned orders on the grounds raised by
the petitioner that the composition of the Assessment Committee was not as
provided under Schedule IV of the Recruitment Rules.
[30]
Issue No. 3:This Court has given a finding with regard to issue No. 1 in the
preceding paragraph that the nature of appointment of the petitioner as
Scientist – E (Natural Product Chemistry) was on contract basis in terms of
the agreement dated 03.04.2013. In para No. 4 of the said agreement it was
agreed upon between the petitioner and IBSD that any time after completion
of the probation and within five years or its extensions the contract can be
terminated by giving three calendar month’s notice in writing or three months
salary in lieu of the notice as termination simplicitor by either party without
assigning any reason. In the event of a shorter notice is given by either party,
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
a sum equivalent to the salary of the period, notice falls short of three months,
shall be payable by the concerned party to the other party.
[31]
Under Rule 7.2 of the Recruitment rules and Bye-Law 8.1 of the
Bye-Laws, it is provided that the contract appointment can be terminated in
case the candidate’s performance is not found to be satisfactory on being
assessed by an Assessment Committee.
[32]
In the present case, the petitioner was duly informed by the
authorities under a letter dated 11.05. 2018 that his performance shall be
evaluated
by
an Assessment Committee
and
that
based
on the
recommendation of the Assessment Committee after evaluation of his 5(five)
years performance followed by a power point presentation and a personal
interview, the competent authority of the institute shall decide for either
regularization of his service or extension of the contract period or termination
of the contract agreement. Thereafter, the duly constituted Assessment
Committee considered the case of the petitioner in its meeting held on
28.05.2018 and after assessing the self appraisal report of the petitioner, his
power point presentation and personal interview, the Assessment Committee
found his performance to be below average and did not recommended for
regularization.
[33]
Pursuant to the said appraisal report of the Assessment
Committee and in terms of the agreement dated 03.04.2013 executed
between the petitioner and the IBSD and also as provided under Rule 7.2 of
the Recruitment Rules and Bye-Law 8.1 of the Bye-Laws, the authorities
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
terminated the contractual service of the petitioner by issuing the impugned
orders after paying to the petitioner his advance salary of 3(three) months.
In view of the above factual positions, this Court did not find any illegalities
being committed by the respondents in issuing the impugned orders thereby
terminating the service of the petitioner.
[34]
In view of the findings given by this Court in connection with
Issue Nos. 1, 2 & 3, this Court did not find any merit in the present writ
petition and accordingly, the same is hereby dismissed as being devoid of
merit, however, without any order as to costs. All connected applications also
stand closed.
JUDGE
Indrajeet
FR/NFR
WP(C) No. 924 of 2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review