Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:44052
*1*
appln3476o18
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO.3476 OF 2018
IN
CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION NO.65 OF 2017
Devesh s/o Dattabhau Pathrikar,
Age : 29 years, Occu : Associate Professor,
R/o 490, N-3, CIDCO, Aurangabad.
...APPLICANT
(Orig. accused)
-VERSUSThe State of Maharashtra.
Through the Police Station,
Mukundwadi, Aurangabad.
...RESPONDENT
…
Shri R.S. Deshmukh, Senior Advocate a/w Ms. Shital S. Karle,
Shri Harshal Nandre, advocates i/by Shri Vishal A. Chavan,
Advocate for the applicant.
Shri V.M. Lomte, APP for the respondents/ State.
Mrs. Rashmi S. Kulkarni along with S.T. Bhimale, advocates for
the original complainant.
…
CORAM : SUSHIL M. GHODESWAR, J.
Reserved on : 10 September 2026
Pronounced on : 28 September 2026
JUDGMENT :1.
The applicant, in the revision, has challenged the
*2*
appln3476o18
judgment and order dated 28.02.2017 passed in Criminal Appeal
No.24/2013
by
the
learned Additional
Sessions
Judge,
Aurangabad, whereby, the said criminal appeal came to be
dismissed and the judgment and order of conviction dated
15.01.2013 passed by the learned Assistant Sessions Judge,
Aurangabad, in Sessions Case No.225/2006, thereby convicting
the applicant under section 306 of Indian Penal Code and
sentencing him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 3 years and
to pay fine of Rs.5000/-, in default, to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for three months, is confirmed.
2.
This Criminal Application No.3476/2018 has been
filed in Criminal Revision Application No.65/2017 by the
applicant/accused under Sections 391, 482 r/w 401 of the
Criminal Procedure Code, 1973, for the following reliefs:-
“(A)
Criminal Application may kindly be allowed.
(B)
That this Hon'ble Court may graciously be
pleased to allow the present Applicant to place
on record the additional evidences/documents
in form of photographs and call records marked
as Annexure-A to B in the present Application,
in the interest of justice.
(C)
The state board and Dr. B.A.M. University be
directed to produce original examination
answer sheet of the deceased and Examiner of
*3*
appln3476o18
Handwriting be directed to submit report by
comparing original handwriting of the
deceased.
(D)
3.
Any other relief, to which the Applicant may be
found entitled to, under the law and in the
interest of justice, be kindly granted.”
By aforesaid prayers, the applicant is seeking
permission to file additional evidence on record under section
391 of Criminal Procedure Code. The present applicant
convicted under section 306 of Indian Penal Code. According to
the applicant, he had previously provided the documents to the
investigation officer at the time of investigation. However, it is
unknown to the present applicant as to why the prosecution
chose not to use the said documents before the learned Trial
Court. It is stated that the applicant had prepared an application
for permission to produce the additional evidence at the stage of
appeal before the learned Additional Sessions Judge, however,
the said request was declined. According to the applicant, since
the documents have not been accepted by the appellate court,
therefore, it has caused major prejudice to him. The documents
which he is trying to produce before the court are vital and form
important part of the applicant’s defence. Therefore, the applicant
*4*
appln3476o18
through the provisions of section 391 of CrPC, is praying for
adducing fresh evidence in view of these documents.
4.
According to the applicant, there are various
photographs which are required to be produced before the
learned Trial Court so that same can be considered for the
purpose of recording evidence additionally. In the said
photographs, the deceased was seen with the applicant and the
said photographs disclose that she was very much happy with the
applicant and as such, the applicant cannot be held guilty for the
offence punishable under section 306. The entire photographs
were earlier presented before the police during the investigation,
however, the prosecution deliberately decided to use only few of
them. The same set of photographs was tried to be presented
before the learned Sessions Judge through an application for
additional evidence, but the learned Sessions Judge declined the
plea of the applicant. The applicant seeks the admission of these
photographs as evidence in the present case as these photographs
are crucial part of the trial as these photographs are the alibi tool
in the hands of the present applicant to prove his innocence. It is
specifically stated that the aforesaid photographs clearly show
*5*
appln3476o18
that the said photographs do not possess any objectionable
content and are normal photographs of individual who are in love
with each other. There is nothing that can be termed as
objectionable to a reasonable man. Since the said photographs do
not have any objectionable content, it is difficult to assume that
the said photographs would have been used by the present
applicant to threaten the deceased thereby resulting in her
suicide.
5.
It is further submitted on behalf of the applicant that
the failure on the part of prosecution in adducing the entire set of
photographs which are stated to be the crux of the abatement on
the part of the present applicant clearly indicates towards the
deliberate intention on the part of prosecution to conceal relevant
evidence which could have gone in favour of the present
applicant.
6.
The another ground raised in the instant application
is regarding bringing on record of the trial the call logs and
details of the deceased father mobile phone for the period
immediately prior to the death of deceased. According to the
applicant, he was not in touch in any manner with the deceased.
*6*
appln3476o18
The call records of the deceased and her father are vital piece of
evidence in the present trial as it makes clear that the present
applicant has not been in any proximity with the deceased
immediately prior to her death. Therefore, the neglect on the part
of prosecution in producing the call records is fatal and it is clear
that the prosecution has not conducted trial in fair manner. The
aforesaid mentioned called records signify the fact that there was
no contact or proximity between the deceased and the applicant.
Without any contact being established between the applicant and
the deceased for a substantial period of time prior to unfortunate
death of deceased, it cannot be assumed that the present applicant
ever got an opportunity to threaten the deceased leading to
commission of suicide by the deceased. As such, the applicant
seeks permission to file on record the additional evidence in the
form of photographs and call records before this court, as
according to him same is necessary for the purpose of
adjudication of the matter pending before this court. In support of
his submissions, the learned Senior Counsel Shri Deshmukh
appearing on behalf of the applicant, has placed reliance upon the
following judgments:-
*7*
(a)
appln3476o18
Smt. Snehal Sudhakar Vispute vs. The State of
Maharashtra, Criminal Application No.202/2020 in Criminal
Appeal No.1135/2019 (Aurangabad Bench) dated 23.08.2024.
(b)
Brig. Sukhjeet Singh (Retd.) Vs. State of Uttar
Pradesh and others, 2019 (16) SCC 712.
7.
The aforesaid application came to be resisted by the
prosecution as well as the original informant. They have filed
their separate replies to this application. According to the
prosecution/ State, the applicant was very much in possession of
all those photographs and call reports. However, during the
pendency of the trial, he did not take any effort to produce the
said data before the learned trial court or before the appellate
court. According to the State, the applicant did not mention
anything regarding the said photographs and call records in his
statement under section 313 of the CrPC or even his written
statement. There is also no whisper regarding these documents.
The documents are not at all relevant in this revision application.
Accordingly, the State has prayed for rejection of the instant
application.
8.
The original informant has also filed his reply,
*8*
appln3476o18
thereby heavily opposed the instant application. According to the
informant, the applicant has filed this application under section
391 of CrPC. However, in the entire application, there is no
averment to show that as to why the additional evidence could
not have been brought before the trial court by the applicant or
before the appellate court. The essential ingredient of the
provision is lacking and hence, the application for adducing the
additional evidence is not maintainable in the eyes of law. The
informant further stated in his reply that the present application is
not maintainable, wherein the accused had given written
statement under section 233(2) of the CrPC, wherein he had
claimed to be in possession of photographs which he had also
presented before the learned trial court. The written statement
further reveals that the call details have already been annexed by
the prosecution to the charge-sheet. These are very same
documents and evidence which are sought to be adduced by the
present applicant. Hence, the informant prayed for dismissing the
instant application with exemplary cost.
9.
The informant respectfully submitted that the
photographs annexed to the instant application, if compared with
*9*
appln3476o18
the photographs annexed to the paper book, it can be revealed
that these are very same photographs which are part and parcel of
the paper book. Therefore, the very same documents are sought
to be adduced again by the applicant. There is nothing but a
tactic and mischief played by the present applicant to delay the
hearing of the present revision application, which has been
expedited by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
10.
The informant further submitted that in paragraph
No.69 of the judgment and order passed by the learned Assistant
Sessions Judge, Aurangabad, in Sessions case No.225 of 2006 on
15.01.2013, it has been specifically stated that the applicant/
accused had produced several photographs on record. This fact is
itself evident that the photographs that are sought to be brought
on record are already part and parcel of the trial and therefore,
the said evidence is already discussed by the learned Trial Court.
11.
As regards producing the CDR, it is submitted by
the informant that the CDR is already exhibited in evidence
through the evidence of IO. The applicant/ accused has already
cross-examined the informant in detail about the said phone
numbers. The informant has also denied that the deceased was
*10*
appln3476o18
using any other number and hence, the reference to phone
numbers is now nugatory, as the applicant is trying to bring the
same on record. Even if the judgment of the appellate court is
perused, it can be seen that the arguments that were advanced by
the accused were pointed towards the refusal of the prosecution
to adduce evidence in respect of CDR. The said application could
have been filed by the applicant at the appellate stage, yet the
same was not filed. It is, therefore, necessary to consider that
though the applicant preferred the instant application for
adducing additional evidence in the nature of CDR reports and
phone messages, however, he does not explain as to how the said
phone messages have been recovered by the accused. Further,
when did the accused became aware about the said messages. It
is pertinent to note that the accused under the memorandum
under section 27 of the Evidence Act has brought out two mobile
handsets which were allegedly used by him and the deceased.
However, the said mobile numbers mentioned in the disclosure
memorandum of seized handsets differ from the mobile number
which is sought to be adduced in evidence.
12.
It is further submitted by the informant that the
*11*
appln3476o18
intent of invoking the provisions of section 391 of the CrPC, is
not to fill up any gap in the prosecution, but is to oversee that the
concept of justice does not suffer. The additional evidence cannot
be received so as to cause any prejudice to any party. The
provisions of section 391 are exception to the general rule and
hence, such an exception ought not to be routinely exercised. The
necessity of section 391 can only be ascertained at the stage of
final hearing of the petition, as the court has first to come to the
conclusion that additional evidence is necessary. In order to come
to the said conclusion, the court is required to assess the
available evidence. Therefore, the informant prayed for dismissal
of the instant application praying for permission to adduce
additional documents or evidence. In support of her submissions,
Mrs. Rashmi Kulkarni relied upon the following judgments:(a)
Ajitsinh Chehuji Rathod vs. State of Gujarat and
others, AIR 2024 SC 787.
(b)
Hasanate Teheriyyah Fidayyiah vs. Mahesh, 2014
(3) ALL MR 497 : 2014 (5) BomCR 231.
(c)
Rambhau and others vs. State of Maharashtra, AIR
2001 SC 2120.
*12*
(d)
Mamtadevi
appln3476o18
vs. Vijaykumar Agarwal, 2008(3)
Crimes 62 (Bom.).
(e)
Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh and others vs. State of
Gujarat and others, (2004) 4 SCC 158.
13.
After hearing the learned advocates for the
respective parties at length and with their assistance, after
perusing the available record, it is required to be noted here that
the law is very settled by the catena of judgments rendered by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court that the power to record additional
evidence under section 391 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
can be exercised when the party making such request was
prevented from presenting the said evidence in the trial despite
due diligence being exercised or that the facts giving rise to such
prayer came to light at a later stage during the pendency of the
proceedings and that non-recording of such evidence may lead to
failure of justice.
14.
For deciding this application, it would be apposite to
reproduce paragraph Nos.2, 3 and 4 from the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ramubhau and others versus State of
Maharashtra) reported in AIR 2001 SC 2120, as under:-
*13*
“2.
3.
4.
appln3476o18
A word of caution however, ought to be
introduced for guidance, to wit: that this
additional evidence cannot and ought not to be
received in such a way so as to cause any
prejudice to the accused. It is not a disguise for
a re-trial or to change the nature of the case
against the accused. This Court in the case of
Rajeswar Prasad Misra vs. State of West
Bengal and another, AIR 1965 SC 1887 in no
uncertain terms observed that the order must
not ordinarily be made if the prosecution has
had a fair opportunity and has not availed of it.
This Court was candid enough to record
however, that it is the concept of justice which
ought to prevail and in the event, the same
dictates exercise of power as conferred by the
Code, there ought not to be any hesitation in
that regard.
Be it noted that no set of principles can be set
forth for such an exercise of power under
Section 391, since the same is dependant upon
the fact-situation of the matter and having due
regard to the concept of fair play and justice,
well being of the society.
Incidentally, Section 391 forms an exception to
the general rule that an Appeal must be decided
on the evidence which was before the Trial
Court and the powers being an exception shall
always have to be exercised with caution and
circumspection so as to meet the ends of
justice. Be it noted further that the doctrine of
finality of judicial proceedings does not stand
annulled or affected in any way by reason of
exercise of power under Section 391 since the
same avoids a de novo trial. It is not to fill up
the lacuna but to sub-serve the ends of justice.
Needless to record that on an analysis of the
Civil Procedure Code, Section 391 is thus akin
to Order 41 Rule 27 of the C.P. Code.”
*14*
15.
appln3476o18
It would be further useful to refer paragraph Nos.47,
48 and 49 of the judgment in Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh and
other vs. State of Gujarat and others, (2004) 4 SCC 158 as
under:“47.
48.
Section 391 of the Code is another salutary
provision which clothes the Courts with the power
to effectively decide an appeal. Though Section
386 envisages the normal and ordinary manner and
method of disposal of an appeal, yet it does not and
cannot be said to exhaustively enumerate the
modes by which alone the Court can deal with an
appeal. Section 391 is one such exception to the
ordinary rule and if the appellate Court considers
additional evidence to be necessary, the provisions
in Section 386 and Section 391 have to be
harmoniously considered to enable the appeal to be
considered and disposed of also in the light of the
additional evidence as well. For this purpose it is
open to the appellate Court to call for further
evidence before the appeal is disposed of. The
appellate Court can direct the taking up of further
evidence in support of the prosecution; a fortiori it
is open to the Court to direct that the accused
persons may also be given a chance of adducing
further evidence. Section 391 is in the nature of an
exception to the general rule and the powers under
it must also be exercised with great care, specially
on behalf of the prosecution lest the admission of
additional evidence for the prosecution operates in
a manner prejudicial to the defence of the accused.
The primary object of Section 391 is the
prevention of guilty man's escape through some
careless or ignorant proceedings before a Court or
vindication of an innocent person wrongfully
accused. Where the Court through some
carelessness or ignorance has omitted to record the
circumstances essential to elucidation of truth, the
exercise of powers under Section 391 is desirable.
The legislative intent in enacting Section 391
*15*
49.
16.
appln3476o18
appears to be the empowerment of the appellate
court to see that justice is done between the
prosecutor and the persons prosecuted and if the
appellate Court finds that certain evidence is
necessary in order to enable it to give a correct and
proper findings, it would be justified in taking
action under Section 391.
There is no restriction in the wording of Section
391 either as to the nature of the evidence or that it
is to be taken for the prosecution only or that the
provisions of the Section are only to be invoked
when formal proof for the prosecution is necessary.
If the appellate Court thinks that it is necessary in
the interest of justice to take additional evidence it
shall do so. There is nothing in the provision
limiting it to cases where there has been merely
some formal defect. The matter is one of the
discretion of the appellate Court. As re-iterated
supra the ends of justice are not satisfied only
when the accused in a criminal case is acquitted.
The community acting through the State and the
public prosecutor is also entitled to justice. The
cause of the community deserves equal treatment
at the hands of the Court in the discharge of its
judicial functions.”
Thus, with the aforesaid guidelines it is clear that
section 391 is intended to sub-serve the ends of justice by
arriving at the truth and there should not be filling of any lacuna
in the case. If the case of the present applicant is considered, the
present applicant is insisting for taking additional evidence on
record. The additional evidence, according to him, are the
photographs which he is now trying to produce before the court
and the call logs i.e. CDR. Both the aforesaid materials were
*16*
appln3476o18
admittedly in the possession of the applicant, however, he did not
take any steps to produce the same before the learned Trial
Court. The photographs which are sought to be produced before
the court, if compared with the photographs which were already
before the trial court, no difference can be seen from the said
photographs. Though the accused has already produced several
photographs on record, the said photographs and the photographs
which are now sought to be brought on record, if compared,
would reveal that there is not even the slightest difference
between them. As such, the said photographs were the part and
parcel before the trial court. However, why the applicant could
not produce the said photographs before the trial court or the
appellate court, has not been mentioned by him in the instant
application nor even tried to be canvas before this court.
17.
Upon comparison with the record of the trial, once
the photographs sought to be produced are found to be very same
photographs which were already produced and considered during
the trial, their acceptance at this stage cannot be regarded as
‘additional evidence’ within the meaning of Section 391 merely
because the applicant seeks to rely upon the same material for a
*17*
appln3476o18
different purpose. Thus, there is no additional evidence which is
required to be considered by the court now, as regards the
photographs are concerned. The learned Assistant Sessions
Judge, in his order dated 15.01.2013 in paragraph No.69, has
recorded that the accused himself has produced several
photographs on record.
18.
Another additional evidence which the applicant
accused is trying to produce on record is the call records (CDR)
which are of same registered number in the name of the
informant. This CDR which he is now trying to produce is
already exhibited in evidence through the evidence of IO. The
accused had already cross-examined the informant in detail about
the said phone numbers. The informant has also denied that the
deceased was using any other number and hence, the reference to
phone numbers is now nugatory, as the applicant accused is
trying to bring the same on record.
19.
The evidence which is now sought to be brought on
record in revision, was in fact also tried to be brought before the
appellate court, however, according to the judgment of the
appellate court, it can be seen that the arguments that were
*18*
appln3476o18
advanced by the accused were pointed towards the refusal of
prosecution to adduce evidence in respect of CDR. Though it is
stated that the applicant tried to produce additional evidence at
the appeal stage, however, the said request was refused.
However, the applicant has not produced any order passed by the
Appellate Court rejecting the application to produce additional
evidence on record. Be that as it may, the rejection of the said
request by the appellate Court does not, by itself, dispense with
the requirement of demonstrating before this Court as to why the
proposed additional evidence is necessary for adjudication of the
present revision. No satisfactory explanation is forthcoming as to
the relevance, authenticity or necessity of the material now
sought to be relied upon.
20.
Now, it is necessary to consider that the application
filed by the present applicant for adducing the additional
evidence in the nature of CDR reports and phone messages does
not explain as to how the said phone messages have been
recovered by the accused. Further, when did the accused become
aware about the said messages. The accused under the
memorandum under section 27 of the Evidence Act has brought
*19*
appln3476o18
out two mobile handsets which were allegedly used by him and
the deceased. The said mobile numbers have been mentioned in
the disclosure memorandum of seized mobile handsets, differ
from the mobile number which is sought to be adduced as
additional evidence. The accused had confronted the informant in
cross-examination of a different mobile number and hence, the
authenticity of the said mobile numbers is questionable and
therefore, the application is also not tenable on this count also.
21.
It is settled position of law that section 391 is not
intended to enable a party to fill up a lacuna in its case or to
introduce evidence which, having regard to the facts and
circumstances of the case, is not necessary for a just adjudication
of the proceedings. The additional evidence cannot be received
so as to cause any prejudice to any party. Therefore, with the
aforesaid observations, I find that there is no substance in the
instant application. The evidence which is now sought to be
adduced by the applicant was very much available before the
trial court itself and no purpose will be served even after
permitting the applicant to adduce the same material again.
Moreover, the applicant has not stated as to why he could not
*20*
appln3476o18
produce the said evidence before the Trial Court which was very
much in his possession.
22.
The decisions relied upon by the learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the applicant do not advance the case of
the applicant in the facts and circumstances of the present matter.
The said decisions, however, do not lay down that additional
evidence must be received as a matter of course whenever an
accused seeks to introduce further material. The exercise of
power remains dependent upon the Court being satisfied that the
proposed evidence is genuinely additional, relevant and
necessary for just adjudication. In the present case, as noticed
hereinabove, the photographs sought to be produced are already
available on the record and the CDR relied upon is also stated to
have already been exhibited, while no satisfactory explanation
has been furnished demonstrating the necessity, authenticity or
distinct evidentiary value of further material sought to be
introduced. The factual foundation which warranted exercise of
power under Section 391 in the aforesaid decisions is, therefore,
absent in the present case.
23.
In the aforesaid circumstances, this Court is of the
*21*
appln3476o18
view that the present application does not disclose any sufficient
ground for exercise of the discretionary jurisdiction under
Section 391 of the Code. It appears that the applicant is trying to
prolong the hearing of the instant criminal revision application.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has already directed to expedite the
hearing of the instant criminal revision application, however, the
learned senior counsel appearing for the applicant insisted this
court to decide this application for permitting to bring on record
the additional evidence. For the reasons recorded above, the
instant application does not have any merit, therefore, the same is
dismissed. No order as to costs.
24.
The Criminal Revision Application be listed for
hearing on 05.10.2026.
kps
(SUSHIL M. GHODESWAR, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review