Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MACA.1615/2015
2025:KER:12943
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 14TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 25TH MAGHA, 1946
MACA NO. 1615 OF 2015
OPMV NO.703 OF 2010 OF MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL,
IRINJALAKUDA
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
DEVARAJAN
S/O RANGA SWAMI, NO.20,
DURAI SWAMY STREET LAYOUT,
AVARAMPALAYAM P.O., COIMBATORE DISTRICT.
BY ADV SRI.A.N.SANTHOSH
SRI. P.V. BABY FOR APPELLANT
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENTS 1 & 3:
CHINNAMMA MATHAI
(DELETED)
W/O MATHAI, MEKKATTU HOUSE,
VELLIKULANGARA P.O., 690104.
(RESPONDENT NO. 1 DELETED FROM THE PARTY ARRAY
AT THE RISK OF THE APPELLANT AS PER ORDER DATED
13.10.2022 IN MACA 1615/2015).
THE UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.
IRINJALAKUDA-680121.
BY ADV DEEPA GEORGE, STANDING COUNSEL
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 14.02.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
MACA.1615/2015
2025:KER:12943
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 14th day of February, 2025
The petitioner in O.P.(M.V.) No.703/2010 on the file of the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Irinjalakuda is the appellant herein. (For the
purpose of convenience, the parties are hereafter referred to as per their rank
before the Tribunal)
2. The petitioner filed the above O.P. under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, claiming compensation for the injuries sustained in a
motor vehicle accident that occurred on. 21.8.2007. According to the
petitioner, on 21.8.2007 at about 7.30 a.m., while he was driving his goods
carriage through the national Highway 47 of Paliakkara region, a stage
carriage bearing registration No.KL-8AH-9797 driven by the 2nd respondent
in a rash and negligent manner came from the opposite direction and hit
against the goods carriage and as a result of which he sustained serious
injuries.
3. The 1st respondent is the owner, the 2nd respondent is the driver and
3rd respondent is the insurer of the offending vehicle. According to the
petitioner, the accident occurred due to the negligence of the driver of the
MACA.1615/2015
2025:KER:12943
offending vehicle. The quantum of compensation claimed in the O.P. is
Rs.10,11,000/- (limited to Rs.7,00,000).
4. The insurance company filed a written statement, admitting the
accident as well as policy, but disputing the negligence on the part of the
driver of the offending vehicle.
5. The evidence in the case consists of the oral testimonies of PWs 1 to
3 and documentary evidence Exhibits A1 to A12. No evidence was adduced
by the respondents.
6.
After evaluating the evidence on record, the Tribunal found
negligence on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle, awarded a total
compensation of Rs.2,82,020/- and directed the insurer to pay the same.
7.
Aggrieved by the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal, the petitioner preferred this appeal.
8. Now the point that arises for consideration is the following:
Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal is just and reasonable?
9.
Heard Sri. P.V. Baby, the learned Counsel appearing for the
petitioner/appellant, and Smt.Deepa George, the learned Standing Counsel for
the 3rd respondent.
MACA.1615/2015
2025:KER:12943
10. The Point: In this case the accident as well as valid policy of the
offending vehicle are admitted. One of the contentions raised by the learned
counsel for the petitioner is regarding the income of the petitioner as fixed by
the Tribunal. According to him, the petitioner was working as driver, earning
Rs.10,000/- per month, but the Tribunal fixed his monthly income at
Rs.3,500/-. The learned counsel for the insurer would argue that the income
fixed by the tribunal is reasonable.
11. It is true that the petitioner could not prove his income, as claimed
in the OP. However PW2 was examined to prove that the petitioner was
employed as a driver. From the evidence of PW2 it is proved that the
petitioner was a driver by profession. As per the dictum laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the decision in Ramachandrappa v. Manager,
Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. [2011 (13) SCC 236], the
notional income of a coolie, in the year 2007 will come to Rs.6,000/Therefore, the petitioner being a driver by profession, his notional income is
fixed at Rs.7,500/-, for the purpose of computing the loss of disability.
12. In the accident the petitioner sustained the following injuries:
“dislocation of (R) hip, fracture ischaemic and floor of
accetabulam (R), fracture (L) inferior ramus, comminuted
MACA.1615/2015
2025:KER:12943
fracture of both bones of (R) leg with punctured wound,
dislocation meta tarsal with fracture middle phalanx in the toe
and dislocation 3rd MTP foot.”
13.
As per Exhibit A11 disability certificate issued by PW3, his
permanent disability was assessed as 32%, while the functional disability was
assessed as 79%. However the Tribunal has scaled down the percentage of
disability to 15%. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the petitioner
would argue that the petitioner being a heavy driver by profession, after the
accident, he is unable to do the job of a heavy driver and as such his
functional disability assessed by PW3 is correct and hence the Tribunal was
not justified in scaling down the disability percentage. On the other hand, the
learned counsel for the 3rd respondent would argue that Exhibit A11 was
issued by a private doctor and that though the petitioner is a resident of Tamil
Nadu, PW3 is a resident of Kerala and Exhibits A11 could not be believed.
14.
In this case, PW3, the Doctor who issued Exhibit A11 disability
certificate was examined before the Court. He had given detailed description
about the injuries sustained by the petitioner and the observation made by him
at the time of examination and reasons for assessing the permanent physical
disability and functional disability. From the medical records, it appears that
MACA.1615/2015
2025:KER:12943
altogether, the petitioner sustained eight fractures and he was hospitalised for
a period of 28 days. During cross examination PW3 deposed that though all
the fractures were united, there are projections on all those fractures. In the
light of the fact that the petitioner sustained eight fractures to both lower
limbs and hip, and he is a heavy driver by profession, I do not find any
grounds to disbelieve the permanent physical disability assessed by PW3 at
32%. Since the petitioner is a heavy driver his functional disability will be
much more than his permanent physical disability. Therefore, considering the
facts, for the purpose of assessing the loss of disability, I fix the functional
disability of the petitioner at 40%.
15.
On the date of accident, the petitioner was aged 31 years.
Therefore, 40% of the monthly income is to be added towards future
prospects, as held in the decision in National Insurance Co.Ltd v Pranay
Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680] and the multiplier to be applied is 16, as held in
Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation, (2009) 6 SCC 121. In the
above circumstances, the loss of disability will come to Rs.8,06,400/16.
Towards loss of earning, the Tribunal has awarded only
Rs.17,500/- being the income for 5 months @Rs.3,500/-. Learned counsel for
MACA.1615/2015
2025:KER:12943
the petitioner relying upon Exhibit A8 certificate issued by the Consultant
Orthopaedic Surgeon, St. Joseph Hospital, to the effect that the petitioner
requires treatment for a period of 2 years, would argue that the loss of
earnings awarded is on the lower side. Considering the nature of the injuries
sustained and the percentage of disability suffered by the petitioner including
eight fractures and he was treated as inpatient for a period of 28 days and he
is a heavy driver by profession, I hold that the petitioner might have lost
income at least for a period of 12 months. Therefore, towards 'loss of income'
the petitioner is entitled to get a sum of Rs. 90,000/- (7,500 x 12 months).
17. Towards the head ‘pain and sufferings’, the Tribunal has awarded
Rs.20,000/-. Towards 'loss of amenities of life' Rs.20,000/- was awarded,
towards bystander expenses Rs.4200/- and towards 'extra nourishment'
Rs.500/- was awarded. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
compensation awarded on those heads are on the lower side.
18. The petitioner sustained very serious injuries in the accident and
was treated as inpatient for 28 days. Because of the injuries sustained, the
percentage of disability suffered and the length of treatment undergone by the
petitioner, I hold that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal on the heads
MACA.1615/2015
2025:KER:12943
‘pain and sufferings’, 'loss of amenities of life', 'bystander expense' and 'extra
nourishment' are on the lower side and hence they are enhanced to
Rs.75,000/-, Rs.50,000/-, Rs.5,600/- and 5,000/- respectively. Another
Rs.15,000/- awarded by the Tribunal on the head 'loss of earning power' will
be deducted.
19. No change is required, in the amounts awarded on other heads, as
the compensation awarded on those heads appears to be just and reasonable.
20.
Therefore, the petitioners/appellants are entitled to get a total
compensation of Rs.11,29,720/-, as modified and recalculated above and
given in the table below, for easy reference:
Sl.
No.
Head of Claim
Amount awarded by
Tribunal (in Rs.)
Amount Awarded in
Appeal (in Rs.)
Loss of earning
17,500/-
90,000/-
Transportation
2,000/-
2,000/-
Medical Bills
95,220/-
95,220/-
Bystander expenses
4,200/-
5,600/-
Loss of disability
1,07,100/-
8,06,400/-
Pain and sufferings
20,000/-
75,000/-
Loss of amenities
20,000/-
50,000/-
Damage to clothing
500/-
500/-
Extra nourishment
500/-
5,000/-
10 Loss of earning power
15,000/-
Nil
Total
282020
1129720
Amount Enhanced
847700
MACA.1615/2015
2025:KER:12943
21. In the result, this Appeal is allowed in part, and Respondent No. 3
is directed to deposit a total sum of Rs.1129720/- (Rupees eleven lakh twenty
nine thousand seven hundred and twenty only), less the amount already
deposited, if any, along with interest @ 8% per annum, from the date of the
petition till deposit/realisation, with proportionate costs, within a period of
two months from today.
22.
On depositing the aforesaid amount, the Tribunal shall disburse
the entire amount to the petitioner, excluding court fee payable, if any,
without delay, as per rules.
if any, without delay, as per rules.
Sd/C. PRATHEEP KUMAR,
JUDGE
sou.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review