Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.B.SURESH KUMAR
WEDNESDAY,THE 09TH DAY OF JANUARY 2019 / 19TH POUSHA, 1940
SA.No. 294 of 1996
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN AS 63/1988 of DISTRICT COURT,
PALAKKAD DATED 02-02-1995
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN OS 79/1984 of SUB COURT,
OTTAPPALAM DATED 17-12-1987
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF:
DEVAKI AMMAL,
AGED 64,W/O.APPU GUPTHAN, CHUNDATH PALOTTIL, RESIDING
AT THACHANATTUKARA, MANNARKKAD, PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
BY ADV. SRI.T.M.MOHAMMED YOUSUFF(SR.)
AYSHA YOUSUFF, MOLLY JACOB,
ABDUL SAMAD AND UMA.K.CHETTUNCHERIL
RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS/DEFENDANTS:
*1
MOHAMMED ALIAS VAPPU (DIED -LEGAL HEIRS IMPLEADED)
S/O.KUNNATH VEERAPPU, AGED 55 YEARS,RESIDING AT
THACHANATTUKARA, MANNARGHAT, PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
**2
KHADSEEJAKUTTY UMMA, (DIED -LEGAL HEIRS IMPLEADED)
AGED 65, D/O.KUNNANATH KUNHUNNY,
RESIDING AT .DO.
(IT IS RECORDED THAT THE 2ND RESPONDENT IS DEAD AS
PER ORDER DATED 03.01.2013 IN MEMO DATED 07.11.2012
BEARING CF.NO.8726/2012)
***3
KUNHUNNI, (DIED -LEGAL HEIRS IMPLEADED)
S/O.KHADEEJAKUTTY UMMA, AGED 40, -DO-
BEEKUTTY,
W/O.LATE ALI, AGED 43,
RESIDING AT THACHANATTUKARA, MANNARKKAD, PALAKKAD
DISTRICT.
JAMEELA,
AGED 23 YEARS, -DO-
AYISHA,
AGED 21 YEARS, -DO-
SA.No. 294 of 1996
***
VEERAPPU,
AGED 19 YEARS, -DO-
MOHAMMED,
AGED 18 YEARS, -DO-
NAZAR,
AGED 16 YEARS, -DO-
HAMEED,
AGED 12 YEARS, -DO-
RAZAK,
AGED 10 YEARS, -DO-
MUJEEB,
AGED 8 YEARS, -DO-
ADDL. PATHUKUTTY,
R13
AGED 50, W/O.PUTHUPARAMBIL KUNHUNNI,KUNNATHUNADU
VEEDU,PALOD P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA),
PALAKKAD 678 583.
ADDL. SULEKHA P.,
R14
AGED 35, W/O.HAMSA, KALAMBARAMBIL HOUSE, PALOD
P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA) PALAKKAD-678 583.
ADDL. SOUDHA P.,
R15
AGED 33, W/O.SULAIMAN, KOLPPADAM,PALOD P.O.,
MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA) PALAKKAD-678 583.
ADDL. P.RAMLA,
R16
AGED 30,PUTHUPARAMBIL,PALOD P.O., MANNARKKAD
COLLEGE (VIA) PALAKKAD-678 583.
ADDL. P.RASSIYA,
R17
AGED 28, W/O.PUTHUPARAMBIL YOUSEFF,KOTTAPPADAM
P.O.,MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA) PALAKKAD-678 583.
ADDL. P.SUMMAYYA,
R18
AGED 26,W/O.ALI,THETTUMMAL HOUSE,PALOD P.O.,
MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA) PALAKKAD-678 583.
ADDL. P.JAMSHEENA,
R19
AGED 25,W/O.MUBARAK,AALIPARAMBU,PERINTHALMANNA
(VIA), MALAPPURAM-678 583.
ADDL. MOHAMMED ALI,
SA.No. 294 of 1996
R20
AGED 22, S/O.KUNHUNNI,KUNNATHUNADU VEEDU, PALOD
P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA) PALAKKAD-678 583.
ADDL. P.SAITHALAVI,
R21
AGED 21,S/O.KUNHUNNI, KUNNATHUNATHU VEEDU,PALOD
P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA) PALAKKAD-678 583.
ADDL. MOHAMMED BASHEER,
R22
AGED 19,S/O.KUNHUNNI, KUNNATHUNADU VEEDU,PALOD
P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA) PALAKKAD-678 583.
ADDL. IBRAHIM,
R23
S/O.KUNHUNNI, KUNNATHUNADU VEEDU,PALOD P.O.,
MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA) PALAKKAD-678 583.
*** ARE IMPLEADED AS LRS OF DECEASED R3 AS PER
ORDER DATED 19.02.2013 IN IA.1500/2009.
**
ADDL. PARAKALLI ITHIMMA,
R24
AGED 65 YEARS, W/O.PARAKALLI ITHIMMU, KUNNANATTU
VEETTIL, PALODU POST, MANARCAUD COLLEGE VIA,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
ADDL. PUTHUPARAMBIL YOUSEFF,
R25
AGED 40 YEARS, S/O.KHADEEJAKUTTY, KUNNANATTU
VEETTIL, PALODU POST, MANARCAUD COLLEGE VIA,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
**(THE LEGAL HEIRS OF DECEASED 2ND RESPONDENT ARE
IMPLEADED AS ADDITIONAL RESPONDENTS 24 AND 25 AS
PER ORDER DATED 24.10.2018 IN IA.NO.335/2013.)
*
ADDL. AYISHA,
R26
W/O.LATE MOHAMMED @ BAPPU, AGED 66 YEARS,
KUNNANATTU VEEDU, THACHANATTUKARA, PALOD P.O.,
MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA),
PALAKKAD -678 583.
ADDL. ABDUL MAJEED,
R27
S/O.LATE MOHAMMED @ BAPPU, AGED 45 YEARS,
KUNNANATTU VEEDU, THACHANATTUKARA, PALOD P.O.,
MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA),
PALAKKAD -678 583.
ADDL. MUHAMMED,
R28
S/O.LATE MOHAMMED @ BAPPU, AGED 40 YEARS,
KUNNANATTU VEEDU, THACHANATTUKARA, PALOD P.O.,
MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA),
PALAKKAD -678 583.
SA.No. 294 of 1996
ADDL. NOUPHAL,
R29
S/O.LATE MOHAMMED @ BAPPU, AGED 30 YEARS,
KUNNANATTU VEEDU,
THACHANATTUKARA, PALOD P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE
(VIA),
PALAKKAD -678 583.
ADDL. ABDUL NAZAR,
R30
S/O.LATE MOHAMMED @ BAPPU, AGED 27 YEARS ,
KUNNANATTU VEEDU,
THACHANATTUKARA, PALOD P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE
(VIA),
PALAKKAD -678 583.
**** ADDL. KUNHUNNI PALOD (DELETED)
R31
CHUNTHATHU PALOTTIL PALOD P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE
(VIA), PALAKKAD-678 583.
**** ADDITIONAL RESPONDENT NO.31 IS DELETED FROM
THE ARRAY OF PARTIES AT THE RISK OF THE APPELLANT
AS PER ORDER DATED 09.01.2019 IN I.A NO.1/2018
ADDL. SARA,
R32
W/O.RAYIN PALOD, AGED 25, D/O. MOHAMMED @ BAPPU,
PALOD P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA), PALAKKAD -678
583.
ADDL. FATHIMA,
R33
AGED 27, D/O.LATE MOHAMMED @ BAPPU,, PALOD P.O.,
MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA), PALAKKAD -678 583.
ADDL. SAFIYA,
R34
AGED 24, W/O.IQBAL, D/O.LATE MOHAMMED @ BAPPU,,
PALOD P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA), PALAKKAD -678
583.
ADDL. NAZRATH,
R35
W/O.NAZAR, AGED 21, D/O.LATE MOHAMMED @ BAPPU,,
PALOD P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA), PALAKKAD -678
583.
ADDL. RAMLA,
R36
W/O.HAMEED, AGED 20, D/O.LATE MOHAMMED @ BAPPU,,
PALOD P.O., MANNARKKAD COLLEGE (VIA), PALAKKAD -678
583.
ADDL. RAHIYA,
R37
D/O.LATE MOHAMMED @ BAPPU,, PALOD P.O., MANNARKKAD
COLLEGE (VIA), PALAKKAD -678 583.
SA.No. 294 of 1996
*(LEGAL HEIRS OF DECEASED 1ST RESPONDENT ARE
IMPLEADED AS ADDL.RESPONDENTS 26 TO 37 AS PER ORDER
DATED 24.10.2018 IN IA.3315/2017).
BY ADVS.
SRI.D.KRISHNA PRASAD
SRI.V.R.KESAVA KAIMAL
SMT.A.R.PRAVITHA
SMT.S.SANTHY
SRI.ABDUL SAMAD
SRI.JOJI VARGHESE
SRI.K.MOHANAKANNAN
SRI.M.HARISHARMA
THIS SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 09.01.2019, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
SA.No. 294 of 1996
JUDGMENT
The plaintiff in the suit is the appellant in the
second appeal.
2.
The plaint B schedule property is part of
the plaint A schedule property. A road is passing through
the plaint A schedule property in the north-south
direction. That portion of the plaint A schedule property
which lies on the east of the road is the plaint B schedule
property. The case of the plaintiff is that she obtained the
plaint A schedule property in terms of Ext.A1 assignment
deed
executed
by
Kalamparambil
Kunhayamu
on
10.10.1957; that the plaint B schedule property is in her
possession; that the suit filed by the plaintiff against the
defendants earlier when the defendants attempted to
trespass
into
the
plaint
B
schedule
property
was
dismissed by the court holding that the plaintiff has not
established
possession
over
the
plaint
B
schedule
property and hence the suit for recovery of possession of
the plaint B schedule property from the defendants on
the strength of the title of the plaintiff. The defendants
SA.No. 294 of 1996
contested the suit contending that the plaint B schedule
property is in their possession as obtained by them in
terms of Ext.B1 lease; that the plaintiff has no rights,
whatsoever in the said property and that even if it is
found that the plaintiff has any right in the plaint B
schedule property, the same is lost by the adverse
possession of the defendants. The defendants have also
contended that they have obtained purchase certificates
in respect of the plaint B schedule property on the basis
of Ext.B1 lease, under the Kerala Land Reforms Act (the
Act).
3. The trial court noticed that the orders of the
Land Tribunal based on which purchase certificates were
issued to the defendants in respect of the plaint B
schedule property were set aside by the appellate
authority under the Act and the matter is still pending
adjudication before the Land Tribunal. The court found
that the plea of adverse possession taken by the
defendants is unsustainable.
The court also found that
the plaint B schedule property is a part of the property
covered by Ext.A1 assignment deed and that the same is
SA.No. 294 of 1996
not covered by Ext.B1 lease deed. In the light of the said
findings, the trial court decreed the suit as prayed for.
The decree passed by the trial court was, however,
subject to the orders to be passed by the Land Tribunal in
the proceedings pending before it. The defendants
challenged the decision of the trial court in appeal. In the
appeal, they have also produced the orders passed by the
Land Tribunal in their favour. It is seen that when the
appeal was taken up, the learned counsel for the plaintiff
conceded that in the light of decisions taken by the Land
Tribunal, the appeal is only to be allowed in favour of the
defendants. Consequently, the appellate court set aside
the decision of the trial court and dismissed the suit. The
plaintiff is aggrieved by the said decision of the appellate
court. Hence the second appeal.
4.
Heard the learned senior counsel for the
appellant as also the learned counsel for the contesting
respondents.
5.
The
learned
senior
counsel
for
the
appellant contended that in so far as it is found by the
trial court that the plaint B schedule property is one
SA.No. 294 of 1996
covered by Ext.A1 assignment deed and not one covered
by Ext.B1 lease deed, the decisions rendered by the Land
Tribunal in the suo motu proceedings initiated at the
instance of the defendants on the basis of Ext.B1 lease
deed would not bind the plaintiff or the plaint B schedule
property. Even otherwise, it was pointed out that in the
light of the finding rendered by the trial court that the
plaint B schedule property is not part of the property
covered by Ext.B1 lease deed, the purchase certificates
obtained by the defendants in respect of the plaint B
schedule property on the basis of Ext.B1 lease deed can
only be a document vitiated by fraud and hence non est
in the eye of law. It was also contended by the learned
senior counsel that, at any rate, the orders obtained by
the defendants from the Land Tribunal being orders
passed during the pendency of the suit, the appellate
court ought to have decided the matter on merits and
ought not to have decided the matter in the light of the
orders passed by the Land Tribunal based on the
concession made by the learned counsel for the plaintiff.
6.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the
SA.No. 294 of 1996
contesting respondents submitted that the decree passed
by the trial court in favour of the appellant was not an
absolute decree. It was a decree with a rider. It was
clarified therein that the same is subject to the decisions
to be taken by the Land Tribunal in the two suo motu
proceedings pending before it viz, S.M No.1941 of 1974
and S.M No.1943 of 1974. It was pointed out by the
learned counsel that in so far as it was conceded that the
said suo motu proceedings have culminated in orders in
favour of the contesting respondents, the appellate court
cannot be found fault with for having allowed the appeal
preferred by the defendants.
7. In reply to the submission made by the
learned counsel for the contesting respondents, the
learned senior counsel for the appellant contended that
since the orders passed by the Land Tribunal are vitiated
by fraud, that part of the decree passed by the trial court
making the decision subject to the outcome of the
proceedings before the Land Tribunal is non est in law and
cannot be said to be a binding decision.
8.
Having heard the learned counsel on
SA.No. 294 of 1996
either side, the following substantial questions of law
have been formulated for decision in the second appeal:
i)
Was
disposing
the
of
appellate
the
court
appeal
justified
preferred
by
in
the
defendants based on the concession made by
the counsel for the plaintiff?
ii)
Is the plaintiff bound by the decisions of the
Land
Tribunal
referred
to
in
the
appellate
judgment?
iii) The effect, if any, of the rider in the judgment
of the trial court that the same is subject to the
outcome of the proceedings pending before the
Land Tribunal?
9.
Question (i) : A close reading of the impugned
decision of the appellate court indicates beyond doubt that
the appellate court was proceeding on the basis that in the
light of the orders passed by the Land Tribunal, the suit is
only to be dismissed as conceded by the counsel for the
plaintiff. According to me, in a case of this nature, in so far
as orders have been passed by the Land Tribunal in favour of
the defendants pending suit, the correctness of the same
ought to have been considered by the appellate court before
SA.No. 294 of 1996
non suiting the plaintiff. In so far as the said course was not
adopted by the appellate court, according to me, the matter
has to go back to the appellate court for fresh consideration.
The question is answered accordingly.
10. In so far as the matter is being remitted to
the appellate court, it is unnecessary to decide the
remaining questions formulated for decision as those are
essentially questions to be answered by the appellate
court at the first instance.
11.
In the circumstances, the impugned
decision of the appellate court is set aside and A.S No.63
of 1988 is remitted to the appellate court for fresh
disposal. In so far as the appeal is one arising from a suit
of the year 1984, it is directed that the appellate court
shall dispose of the appeal as expeditiously as possible,
at any rate, within two months from the date of receipt of
a copy of this judgment. Parties shall appear before the
appellate court on 20.02.2019.
Sd/P.B.SURESH KUMAR
Mn
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review