Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 9TH PHALGUNA, 1946
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017
AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED 10.01.2017 IN OPMV NO.1156
OF 2014 OF ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT & MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS
TRIBUNAL ,PATHANAMTHITTA/ I ADDL. M.A.C.T. /M.A.C.T.,
PATHANAMTHITTA
APPELLANT/3RD RESPONDENT:
NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO.LTD
T.P.HUB, KHAISE BUILDING, BEACH ROAD, OPP.BENZIGAR
HOSPITAL,KOLLAM, REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER,
REGIONAL OFFICE, ERNAKULAM
BY ADV SRI.P.G.GANAPPAN
RESPONDENTS/CLAIMANT & RESPONDENTS 1 & 2:
DEVADASAN PILLAI.P
AGED 64 YEARS
AGED 64 YEARS, S/O.PARAMESWARAN PILLAI, MYLOTTU
VEEDU,ELANGAMANGALAM, ENATHU P.O.
JOSEPAUL
S/O.PAUL JOSEPH, THEKUEMMATTATHIL HOUSE,
PUTHUPPADI P.O.,MUVATTUPUZHA
INDUS MOTORS CO. PVT. LIMITED
INDUS HOUSE, P.B.NO.923, CHAKKRATHUKULAM, WEST
HILL(P.O),CALICUT
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
BY ADVS.
SRI.A.N.SANTHOSH
SRI.P.K.ABOOBACKEREDAPPALLY
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR
ADMISSION ON 28.02.2025, ALONG WITH CO.26/2024, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 9TH PHALGUNA, 1946
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED IN MACA NO.760 OF 2017 OF
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
CROSS OBJECTOR/RESPONDENT:
DEVADASAN PILLAI,
AGED 73 YEARS
S/O. PARAMESWARAN PILLAI, AGED 73 YEARS, MYLOTTU
VEEDU, ENADIMANGALAM, ENATHU P.O, PATHANAMTHITTA
DISTRICT, PIN - 691526
BY ADV A.N.SANTHOSH
RESPONDENT/APPELLANT:
THE BRANCH MANGER, NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LTD
TP HUB, KHAISE BUILDING, BEACH ROAD, OPP. BENZIGAR
HOSPITAL, KOLLAM, PIN - 691001
THIS CROSS OBJECTION/CROSS APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR
ADMISSION ON 28.02.2025, ALONG WITH MACA.760/2017, THE COURT
ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
JUDGMENT
The 3rd respondent in OP (MV) No.1156/2014 on the files of Motor
Accident Claims, Pathanamthitta, is the appellant in MACA No.760/2017 and
the petitioner in the above OP is the cross objector. (For the purpose of
convenience, the parties are hereafter referred to as per their rank before the
Tribunal).
2. The petitioner filed the above O.P. under Section 166 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, claiming compensation for the injuries sustained
in a motor vehicle accident that occurred on 26.06.2014. According to the
petitioner, on 26.06.2014 at about 10:30pm., while he was riding a scooter,
along Adoor-Kottarakkara MC road, a Maruti car bearing registration No.KL17-TC-2011, driven by the 1st respondent in a rash and negligent manner hit
against the scooter and as a result of which he fell down and sustained serious
injuries.
3. The 1st respondent is the driver, the 2nd respondent is the owner
and 3rd respondent is the insurer of the offending vehicle.
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
4. According to the petitioner, the accident occurred due to the
negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle. The quantum of
compensation claimed in the O.P. is Rs.58,75,000/- limited to Rs.40,00,000/5. The insurance company filed a written statement, admitting the
accident as well as policy, but disputing the negligence on the part of the
driver of the offending vehicle.
6. The evidence in the case consists of the oral testimony of PW1
and documentary evidence Exts.A1 to A15. No evidence was adduced by the
respondents.
7.
After evaluating the evidence on record, the Tribunal found
negligence on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle, awarded a total
compensation of Rs.29,99,900 rounded off to Rs.30,00,000/- and directed the
insurer to pay the same.
8. Aggrieved by the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal, the Respondent No.3 preferred this appeal.
9. Now the point that arises for consideration is the following:
Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal is just and reasonable?
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
10. Heard Sri.A.N. Santhosh, the learned Counsel appearing for the
cross objector/petitioner, and Sri.P.G.Ganappan, the learned Standing Counsel
for the appellant/3rd respondent.
11.
The Point: In this case the accident as well as valid
insurance policy of the offending vehicle are admitted. One of the contentions
raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner is regarding the income of the
petitioner as fixed by the Tribunal. According to him, the petitioner was
running a stationary shop, earning Rs.30,000/- per month, but the Tribunal
fixed his monthly income at Rs.10000/-. In order to prove the fact that the
petitioner was running a stationary shop, he had relied upon Exts.A12 and
A14. Ext.A12 is the Tax receipts issued from Kulakkada Grama Panchayath
for conducting stationary business in the name and style ‘Vijaya Stores
Kulakkada’. Ext.A14 is the telephone bills in the name of the petitioner in the
address ‘Vijaya Stores, Kulakkada’. The petitioner was also examined as
PW1 to substantiate his claim that he was conducting a stationary shop.
Therefore, from the evidence of PW1 and from Exts.A12 and A14, the
petitioner has succeeded in establishing that he was running a stationary shop.
It is true that in order to prove the actual income he derived from the
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
stationary shop, there is no documentary evidence.
12. As per the decision in Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co.
Ltd. [2011 (13) SCC 236], the notional income of a coolie, in the year 2014
will come to Rs.9500/-. Since, from the evidence PW1 and from Exts.A12
and A14, it is revealed that the petitioner was conducting a stationary shop in
which there was also telephone facility, it could be presumed that he had
moderate business in ‘Vijaya Stores, Kulakkada’ and as such the notional
income of the petitioner is fixed as Rs.15,000/-.
13. In the accident the petitioner sustained the following injuries:
(1) lacerated wound 4 X 3 X 1 c.m. over medial thigh, 15 c.m.
above the knee (2) deformity on right thigh, fracture of femur (3)swelling on
left hand dorsum (4)lacerated wound 1 X 1 X 1 c.m. over left hand 5 c.m.
from wrist (5) abrasion 5 X 4 c.m. over left forearm extending from wrist
(6)abrasion 3 X 2 c.m. over right leg 10 c.m. above ankle. Investigation
revealed (1) intertrochanteric fracture right femur (2) Type-III-C compound
fracture right distal femur (3) right femoral artery injury (4) acute kidney
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
injury (5)sepsis (6)systemic hypertension (7) Type-lI diabetes mellitus.
14. His right leg above knee was amputated. As per Exhibit A10
disability certificate the petitioner suffered 80% permanent physical
disability. It was issued by the medical board. The Tribunal, has accepted the
permanent physical disability of the petitioner as such and hence, I do not find
any grounds to disbelieve the same. Therefore, the
permanent physical
disability of the petitioner is accepted as 80%, as fixed by the Tribunal.
15. On the date of accident, the petitioner was aged 64 years.
Therefore, no part of the monthly income can be added towards future
prospects, as held in the decision in National Insurance Co. Ltd v.
Pranay Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680] and the multiplier to be applied is 7, as
held in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation, [(2009) 6 SCC
121]. In the above circumstances, the loss of disability/loss of earning
capacity will come to Rs.10,08,000/-.
16. Towards loss of earning, the tribunal has awarded Rs.50000/being the income for 5 months @Rs.10000/-. Since the notional income of the
petitioner is re-fixed at Rs.15000, towards loss of earning he is entitled to get
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
a sum of Rs.75000/-(15000x5months)
17. The main argument advanced by the learned counsel for the 3rd
respondent is regarding to the compensation awarded by the tribunal on the
head of pain and suffering as well as on the head loss of amenities. It is true
that the tribunal has awarded a sum of Rs.3,00,000/- on the head pain and
suffering and Rs.5,00,000/- on the head loss amenities and enjoyment of life.
In this case the petitioner sustained very serious injuries in the accident and
his right leg above knee was amputated. He was treated as inpatient for a total
period of 30 days. In the meantime, he had underwent 7 major surgeries.
Therefore, it can be seen that because of the injuries sustained in the accident
the petitioner has suffered a lot, both mentally and physically. Because of the
injuries he could not even continue his stationary shop. As PW1 he deposed
that he discontinued his stationary shop because of the injuries sustained in
the accident. Therefore, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal on the
head pain and suffering and loss of amenities cannot be stated to be excessive.
Therefore, I do not find any grounds to interfere with the same.
18. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
Tribunal has awarded only Rs.4,00,000/- towards future medical treatment
including the cost of prosthesis, which according to him, is on the lower side.
The petitioner produced Ext.A11 invoice showing the price of a prosthesis as
Rs.1,86,000/-. He would argue that the maximum life of a prosthesis is five
years and huge amount is also required for it’s periodical maintenance. The
learned counsel for the 3rd respondent contend that Ext.A11 is only a invoice
and not a bill and as such it cannot be relied upon.
19. The learned counsel has handed over the photograph of the
petitioner to convince the Court his present condition. In the said photograph,
it is seen that the petitioner was using a prosthesis, even now. It is true that
Ext.A11 is only a invoice and not a bill. In the decision in Vivek G. vs.
National Insurance Company Ltd. 2023 KHC 2941, in the case of a 12
year old child whose right leg was amputated because of the injuries sustained
in an accident that occurred in the year 2011, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
awarded a sum of Rs.20,00,000/- being the cost of four prosthesis and a
further sum of Rs.6,00,000/- towards the cost of maintenance of the
prosthesis.
20. In the instant case the petitioner is aged 64 and he has claimed
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
only Rs.1,86,000/- being the cost of one prosthesis. Even in the decision in
Vivek (supra), the apex court accepted the argument that the age of a
prosthesis is only five years and it requires huge amount towards periodical
maintenance. Since the petitioner is still alive, even after 11 years of the
accident, he is entitled to get the value of at least three prosthesis. Therefore
Rs.1,86,000/- claimed towards the cost of one prosthesis is not at all on the
higher side. Even at the rate of Rs.1,86,000/- the value of three prosthesis will
come to Rs.5,58,000/-. In addition to the same, he is entitled to get reasonable
compensation towards the cost of maintenance of the prosthesis. Therefore,
considering the facts I hold that. towards further medical treatment the
petitioner is entitled to get a sum of Rs.6,00,000/-.
21. No change is required, in the amounts awarded on other heads,
as the compensation awarded on those heads appears to be just and
reasonable.
22. Therefore, the petitioners/appellants are entitled to get a total
compensation of Rs.35,60,900/-, as modified and recalculated above and given
in the table below, for easy reference:
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
Sl.
No.
Head of Claim
Amount awarded by
Tribunal (in Rs.)
Amount Awarded in
Appeal (in Rs.)
Loss of earning
50000
75000
Transport to hospital
25400
25400
Extra nourishment
10000
10000
Damage to clothing
Medical expenses
1022500
1022500
Bystander expenses
15000
15000
Pain and suffering
300000
300000
Compensation for loss of earning
capacity/loss of disability
672000
10,08,000
Loss of amenities & enjoyment
of life
500000
500000
400000
600000
10 Future medical treatment
including cost of prosthesis
Total
Enhanced
29,99,900
rounded to 30,00,000
3560900
560900
20. In the result, this Appeal is disposed off, and Respondent No.3
is directed to deposit a total sum of Rs.35,60,900/- (Rupees Thirty Five Lakhs
Sixty Thousand Nine Hundred only), less the amount already deposited, if
any, along with interest at the rate ordered by the Tribunal, from the date of
the petition till deposit/realisation, excluding interest for a period of 1746
days, the period of delay in filing the appeal, with proportionate costs, within
a period of two months from today. (Enhanced compensation will carry
2025:KER:21995
MACA NO. 760 OF 2017 &
CO NO. 26 OF 2024
interest @8%)
On depositing the aforesaid amount, the Tribunal shall disburse the
entire amount to the petitioner, excluding court fee payable, if any, without
delay, as per rules.
Sd/C. PRATHEEP KUMAR,
JUDGE
Pvv
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review