Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
wp9750.23 judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 9750 OF 2023
1)
Dadarao s/o Laxman Khandalwad,
Age; 58 years, Occ; Nil,
2)
Kausalyabai w/o Gangadhar Parashwad,
Age; 52 years, Occ; Household,
3)
Shantabai w/o Vijaykumar Kalyanpad,
Age; 51 years, Occ; Household,
4)
Neelabai w/o Nagorao Parashwad,
Age; 48 years, Occ; Household,
All R/o Sawargaon Tanda
Tq.Kinwad, District; Nanded.
...PETITIONERS
VERSUS
1)
Nyalsingh s/o Mahadu Pandhare,
Age; 63 years, Occ; Agri.,
R/o; Sawargaon Tanda,
Tq.Kinwat Dist. Nanded.
2)
The Additional Collector,
District Collector Office, Nanded
District; Nanded.
3)
The Tahsildar, Kinwat,
Tq. Kinwat, District; Nanded.
...RESPONDENTS
wp9750.23 judgment
…………………….…
Advocate for the Petitioners : Mr. Sachin Deshmukh h/f Mr. Amol
G. Vasmatkar
Advocate for Respondent No. 1 : Mr V.D.Salunke i/by Mr. Avishkar
S. Shelke & Mr. Ganesh R. Jadhav
A.G.P. for the Respondent Nos. 2 & 3/State : Mr. B.K.Jadhavar
……………………….
CORAM : KISHORE C. SANT, J.
Date of Reservation :
09.08.2023.
Date of Pronouncement : 03.10.2023.
JUDGMENT [ PER : KISHORE C. SANT, J. ] :
1.
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith with the consent
of the parties.
2.
This petition is filed against the judgment and order
dated 26.07.2022 passed by the learned Member, Maharashtra
Revenue Tribunal (for short “MRT”) in Revision Petition filed by
Respondent No. 1 bearing no. 40/B of 2022 allowing the same,
whereby the judgment and order passed by the Additional Collector,
Nanded dated 20.06.2022 is quashed and set aside, consequently
an order passed by the Tahsildar Kinwat dated 20.01.2020 is
confirmed. The Tahsildar had passed an order directing to cancel
the mutation entry No. 112 in the name of the petitioner after the
wp9750.23 judgment
receipt of the order from the superior officer by keeping it open to
the parties to approach to the Competent Authority.
3.
Respondent No. 1 had filed a proceeding before the
Tahsildar. It was his case that one Gonderao Dattaram was the
owner of land Survey No. 98 from Savargaon Tanda. The name of
elder brother of the grand-father of the respondent No. 1 i.e. Tayam
Jalva Mansa Pandhare was mutated as protected tenant. An
application was, therefore, filed for declaration as protected tenant
as per Section 38 (4) the Hyderabad Tenancy and Agriculture Lands
Act, 1950 (for short “the Act).
The said land was transferred in
favour of the grand-father of the respondent No. 1. Jalva Mansa
Pandhare deposited the price of the land for the area 28 Acre &
4 Guntha and pursuant thereto the name of Jalva Mansa Pandhare
was shown as owner in the 7/12 extract and in the revenue record.
It is the case of the father of the present petitioners that by taking
mutation entry No. 111, the respondents got mutation entry in the
name of the State, without holding any inquiry and without issuing
any notice to them. There was a civil proceedings pending between
the parties.
4.
The facts as appearing on record are that one Gonderao
wp9750.23 judgment
Dattaram was the original owner of new Survey No. 98. Jalva
Mansa Pandhare was shown as protected tenant in the year 1954.
On 28.05.1959, a notice was issued to Jalva Mansa Pandhare
under Section 38 (4) of the Act. Pursuant to the said notice he
deposited an amount on 09.03.1960 and his name came to be
shown as owner. Till 1980 the name of Jalva Mansa Pandhare was
intact. When the name was taken in the revenue record, one
Laxman Kandalwad was shown to be the owner, therefore, the
tenant filed proceedings for possession. In the year 1960 an entry
as protected tenant is not shown but it was shown as ‘Inam’ land.
The mutation entry No. 111 was taken on 27.06.1961 in the name
of the State of Maharashtra, without giving notice to the tenant and
vide mutation entry No. 112 the land was given to Laxman Narayan
as ‘Inam’ land. In view of this Mahadu Pandhare, the father of the
respondent No. 1 had filed an appeal in 1975 under the Bombay
Inferior Village Watans Abolition Act, 1958, in which, the learned
Deputy Collector passed an order in favour of the respondent No. 1
canceling the mutation entry No. 111.
It was thus, prayed for
declaration that the respondent No. 1 is protected tenant and for
effecting mutation as such.
5.
wp9750.23 judgment
It is the case of the petitioners that an appeal was
decided in favour of the father of the petitioners. The judgment in
appeal was challenged by Laxman Narayan Kalandwad before the
Commissioner, Aurangabad. The Commissioner decided against the
Laxman Narayan Kalandwad and thereafter, a Special Civil
Application No. 2845 of 1975 was filed. The High Court by
judgment and order dated 17.01.1980 allowed the Special Civil
application in favour of Laxman Narayan Kalandwad.
The said
judgment attained finality and thus the respondent No. 1 has no
right. The father of the respondent No. 1 had also filed a suit for
declaration, ownership and possession bearing Special Civil Suit
No. 5 of 1980 against said Laxman Narayan Kalandwad. The said
suit was decided against one Mahadu Pandhare. Against which an
appeal was filed, the same also came to be dismissed. Thereafter,
Second Appeal was filed by Mahadu Pandhare. During pendency of
the appeal, Mahadu Pandhare as well as Laxman Kalandwad died,
therefore, their legal representatives were brought on record. The
Second Appeal also came to be dismissed. The judgment in Second
Appeal also thus became final. Thus, no right of the respondent
No. 1 is in existence.
Thereafter, again suits were filed by the
respondents bearing No. 51 of 2010 and 16 of 2012. In both the
wp9750.23 judgment
proceedings, the High Court has decided against the respondent
No. 1 and thus, he has no right to file the present proceedings.
6.
An appeal was filed against that proceedings. The said
was decided against Mahadu Lalu.
He therefore, filed Second
Appeal in the High Court bearing No. 17 of 1983. During pendency
of the said appeal, father of the respondent Mahadu Lalu died.
Said Laxman also died. Lateron, the Second Appeal was decided
against the respondent No. 1.
7.
It was the case of the present petitioners that the
respondent No. 1 does not have any right.
Jalva Mansa is not
related to the present respondent No. 1 by blood. The surname of
Jalva
Mansa
was
Padval
and
not
Pandhare.
There
is
no
documentary proof to show the relation between the said Jalva
Mansa and
respondent No. 1.
Jalva Mansa had no issue.
The
Tahsildar, Kinwat had cancelled the certificate under Section 78 (4)
of the Act and declared one Laxman Narayan Kalandwad i.e. the
husband of the present petitioner No. 1 as ‘Inamdar’
by taking
occupation price of Rs. 92 and 43 ps. The said order was challenged
by one Bhalji Mansa before the Deputy Collector, Nanded. The said
appeal came to be rejected by order dated 28.02.1967.
Against
wp9750.23 judgment
which an appeal was preferred by Bhalji Mansa in MRT,
Aurangabad. The said appeal also came to be rejected. Thus, the
tenancy claim of Jalva Mansa or Bhalji Mansa is already rejected
and hence no fresh inquiry can be held.
8.
However, in the final record Jalva Mansa is shown as
protected tenant on the suit land.
Since 1980 Laxman Narayan
Kalandwad is shown as owner of the Inam land. The High Court
also in Second Appeal has held that it is for the Tahsildar to decide
as to whether the said land is under Inam Aboloation Act or the
Tenancy Act. On this, the learned Tahsildar passed an order that
one Jalva Mansa Pandhare is shown as protected tenant under the
Hyderabad Tanancy Land Act, 1950.
In the certificate issued by
the Circle Officer, there is no mention of the relationship of the
respondent No. 1 with said Jalva Mansa Pandhare. It is directed
that the Tahsildar has no authority to cancel the entry No. 112 and
the said is done after the orders passed by the superior authority.
The rights of the parties were kept open to be agitated before the
proper authority.
9.
The said order was challenged by the present petitioners
before the Additional Collector (Revenue), Nanded. The Additional
wp9750.23 judgment
Collector allowed an appeal of the petitioners canceling an order
passed by the Tahsildar by its judgment and order dated
20.06.2022. It is clearly held that the original owner was one
Gundewar Dattaram and the name of Laxman Narayan Kandalwad
is shown in the cultivation column. This order was challenged by
the respondent No. 1 by filing revision before the learned MRT. The
learned MRT decided the revision as stated above, confirming the
order passed by the learned Tahsildar. It is submitted that the
order of learned MRT is illegal and needs to be quashed and set
aside.
10.
The
learned
Advocate
Mr.
Sachin
Deshmukh
for
petitioners vehemently argued that the issue of tenancy could not
have been re-opened as the same is not permissible. Respondent
No. 1 had failed every where in the Civil Court as well as in the
Revenue Court. All his challenges were rejected. An order passed
by the Tahsildar itself was without jurisdiction.
In the Second
Appeal the rights of the parties were finally decided as the said
order has attained finality. He relied upon the following judgments :
(a)
2014 (6) SCC 351 – Union of India Vs. Major S.P.Sharma
(b)
AIR 1965 SC 1150 – Devilal Modi Vs. Sales Tax Officer,
wp9750.23 judgment
Ratlam and others.
11.
The learned Senior Advocate Mr.Salunke for respondent
No. 1 opposes the petition submitting that grand-father of
respondent No. 1 was declared as protected tenant. He had even
paid the price of the land and thereafter his name was recorded in
the revenue record.
That mutation entry was cancelled and the
name of the petitioners was entered. In Special Civil Application it
is held that declaration in favour of respondent No. 1 was under the
wrong Act and therefore, notices were set aside. That will not take
away the right of the respondent No.1.
It is in that view the
proceeding was filed before the Tahsildar under Section 8 of the
HTAL Act. The Tahsildar has rightly held that grand-father of the
respondent No.1 was the protected tenant.
Since an appeal was
filed by the petitioners and the same was allowed, the respondent
No. 1 had approached the MRT. The MRT has rightly passed an
order. He submits in fairness that the impugned order be set aside
and the matter be remanded back for giving fresh hearing to the
parties. The proceeding is necessarily under Section 8 of the HTAL
Act. He further submits that he has no objection for remanding the
matter for dealing with all issues afresh.
12.
wp9750.23 judgment
The learned Advocate for the petitioners in rejoinder
submits that when the respondent No. 1 could not establish their
relations with Jalva Mansa the original tenant, there is no question
of approaching this Court that too after 50 to 60 years.
13.
The learned AGP supports the order passed by the
learned Member, MRT. Coming to the legal position, this Court
finds that the Tahsildar in his order has held that respondent No. 1
could not prove his relationship with the original tenant namely
Jalva Mansa and that point is crucial for deciding this petition. This
Court in Special Civil Application No. 2845 of 1975 by considering
Section 8 of the Bombay Inferior Village Watans Abolition Act, 1958
held in favour of father of the present petitioners.
The orders
passed by the Deputy Collector and the Commissioner declaring
Mahadu Lalu as occupant of the field were quashed and set aside.
In the second Appeal filed by the successor of Mahadu Pandhari
also this Court decided in favour of the present petitioners. There is
clear finding in the judgment of Second Appeal No. 117 of 1983 in
paragraph No. 11 that Mahadu was never declared as statutory
owner as tenant of the suit land under the provisions of the
Hyderabad Tenancy and Agriculture Lands Act 1950.
It is
wp9750.23 judgment
specifically recorded that the declaration of ownership lies in the
name of Laxman i.e. the father of the present petitioners duly
corroborated by the entries in the Inam Land Patrak. This Court
has also treated the judgment in the Special Civil Application No.
2845 of 1975 as constructive res-judicata. It was also held that the
Civil Court was incompetent to decide the issue in favour of the
deceased plaintiffs and the second appeal was dismissed.
14.
The learned Tahsildar by order dated 22.05.2020 has
rightly rejected an application of the respondents. The learned SDO
had remanded the matter back to the Tahsildar.
The Tahsildar
lateron has wrongly come to the conclusion that the respondents
get right as brother of grand father of the respondent No. 1 was
shown to be protected tenant. In the same operative order in Clause
2 it is clearly stated that in the succession certificate there is no
mention of the relationship of the respondents with original
protected tenant Jalva Mansa Pandhare, still directed to cancel the
entries in the names of petitioners.
15.
The learned Additional Collector, Nanded thereafter, by
considering all the relevant factors in detail allowed the appeal of
the petitioners by cancelling the order dated 20.01.2020 passed by
wp9750.23 judgment
the Tahsildar. It is specifically recorded that in the Khasara Pahani
Patrak in respect of suit land Gonderao Dattaram is shown to be
the owner. In the record of 1955-56, 1956-57, 1957-58 and 195960 shows Gonderao Dattaram is owner and the name of Laxman
Narayan Kandalwad is shown in the cultivation column. The
learned MRT, however, without considering this factual position has
set aside the judgment of the learned Additional Collector.
This
Court finds that the findings of the learned MRT are thus, without
any basis. As observed, the crucial aspect was to see as to whether
the respondent No.1 has proved the relation with Jalva Mansa. The
second crucial point is that as per the Khasara Patrak and Pahani
Patrak the name of Laxman Narayan Kandalwad is shown in the
cultivation column.
16.
The learned Advocate Mr. Salunke relied upon the
judgment reported in Devilal Modi (supra) to show that doctrine of
constructive res-judicata would not apply to the writ proceedings.
The Hon’ble Apex Court has also considered the doctrine of finality
of judgment. The above case law of the Hon’ble Apex Court is not
applicable to the present case, as the finding was recorded even by
the Hon’ble High Court in Special Civil application and later on
wp9750.23 judgment
even in the second appeal, are binding on the authorities.
Considering the judgment in the case of Union of India (supra), this
case was in respect of scope of judicial review in the matter of
termination of employee.
In view of article 309, 310, 311 of the
Constitution of India and pleasure doctrine, this Court finds that
said judgment is also not applicable to the present case.
17.
This Court finds that considering the material and facts
of the case a clear case is made out to allow the petition by
quashing and setting aside the judgment of the learned MRT. The
petition is, therefore, allowed in terms of prayer clause (B). The Rule
is made absolute.
( KISHORE C. CHANT )
JUDGE
mahajansb/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review