The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. In that view of the matter, I find that the order passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class was just and proper, and the same rate of maintenance shall continue to be granted to the applicants from the date of the impugned order i.e. 23/07/2019. Therefore, the (10)
237. 19revn etc impugned order dated 23/07/2019 is hereby quashed and set aside to the extent of reducing the amount from Rs.5,000/- to Rs.3,000/-. The rest of the order is maintained.
13. Accordingly, Criminal Revision Application No.237 of 2019 is allowed and the criminal revision application preferred by respondent/Deepak, i.e. Criminal Revision Application No.295/2019, is dismissed. [SUSHIL M. GHODESWAR, J.] sjk
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:47724
(1)
237.19revn etc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION NO.237 OF 2019
1.
2.
Janabai Laxman Dawkhar
Sushila Laxman Dawkhar
….APPLICANTS
VERSUS
Deepak Laxman Dawkhar
…..
….RESPONDENT
Mr Navin S. Shah, Advocate h/f Mr R. B. Narwade Patil, Advocate for
Applicants
Mr Rahul B. Temak, Advocate for Respondent
AND
CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION NO.295 OF 2019
Deepak Laxman Davkhar
….APPLICANT
VERSUS
1.
2.
Smt. Janabai Laxman Davkhar
Smt. Sushila Laxman Dawkhar
…..
….RESPONDENTS
Mr Rahul B. Temak, Advocate for Applicants
Mr Navin S. Shah, Advocate h/f Mr R. B. Narwade Patil, Advocate for
Respondents
…..
CORAM : SUSHIL M. GHODESWAR, J.
DATE : 06th OCTOBER 2026
ORDER :1.
Criminal Revision Application No.237/2019 is filed by
applicants Janabai Laxman Dawkhar, aged about 80 years, and Sushila
237.19revn etc
(2)
Laxman Dawkhar, aged about 70 years, against respondent Deepak
Laxman Dawkhar, who is admittedly their son, for setting aside the
impugned judgment and order dated 23/07/2019, passed by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge in Criminal Appeal No.20/2019 to the
extent of reduction in monthly maintenance amount from Rs.5,000/- to
Rs.3,000/- to applicants. Criminal Revision Application No.295/2019
is filed by Deepak Laxman Dawkhar against the applicants in Criminal
Revision Application No.237/2019 for setting aside the judgment and
order dated 23/07/2019, passed by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Shrirampur in Criminal Appeal No.20/2019 as well as for
setting aside the impugned judgment and order dated 29/03/2019,
passed by the learned JMFC in Criminal Misc. Application
No.285/2015, thereby granting maintenance to the applicants (his
mothers).
2.
Since both the applicants in both the revision applications
are challenging the order dated 23/07/2019, passed by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge, Shrirampur, Dist. Ahmednagar, both the
revision applications are being disposed of by this common judgment.
3.
The
applicants
in
Criminal
Revision
Application
No.237/2019, namely, applicant No.1/Janabai Laxman Dawkhar is the
237.19revn etc
(3)
stepmother of the respondent/Deepak, whereas applicant No.2/Sushila
Laxman Dawkhar is the biological mother of the respondent/Deepak.
They had filed Criminal Miscellaneous Application No.285/2015
before the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Shrirampur, District
Ahmednagar, seeking reliefs under Sections 12, 18E(F), 19, 20 and 22
of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005
(hereinafter referred to as “the D.V. Act”). The applicants claimed
various reliefs including monetary reliefs under the provisions of the
D.V.Act against respondent/Deepak, who is their son.
It was
contended
of
in
the
said
application
that
the
father
the
respondent/Deepak, namely, Laxmanrao Dawkhar, who was the
husband of the applicants, died on 15/07/2013.
The applicants,
respondent/Deepak and deceased Laxman Dawkhar were living
together. It was also contended that after death of Laxman Dawkhar,
respondent/Deepak was harassing the applicants and demanding their
‘stridhan’. Consequently, on 20/05/2015, respondent/Deepak drove
the applicants from house.
4.
The learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Shrirampur,
vide his order dated 29/03/2019 in Criminal Miscellaneous Application
No.285/2015, partially allowed the application filed by the applicants
(mothers),
thereby
granting
them
monetary
relief
(monthly
(4)
237.19revn etc
maintenance) of Rs.5,000/- each from respondent/Deepak from the
date of the said order. Apart from the said monetary relief, the learned
Magistrate also directed respondent/Deepak to make available two
rooms in Municipal House No.4111/8056, situated at Dawkhar Chawl,
Ward No.3, along with all necessary arrangements for the applicants.
5.
The aforesaid order dated 29/03/2019, passed by the
learned JMFC was challenged by respondent/Deepak before the
learned Additional Sessions Judge, Shrirampur in Criminal Appeal
No.20/2019 under Section 29 of the D.V. Act. Respondent/Deepak
contended in his appeal that the applicants (his mothers) are the real
sisters and that both of them have been recognized as wives of
deceased Laxman Parashram Dawkhar (his father).
It was also
contended that respondent/Deepak is the agriculturist, having no
source of income and not capable to provide maintenance to
applicants. It was also contended that the applicants (mother) have
huge source of income. It was also contended by respondent/Deepak
that he has two sisters, namely, Vaishali, Archana and one stepsister,
namely, Meena. One of the sisters, Vaishali, had filed a suit bearing
Special Civil Suit No.37/2015 against him and other members for
partition and declaration in respect of the family properties. The said
civil suit is subjudice before the learned Civil Judge Senior Division,
(5)
237.19revn etc
Shrirampur. The applicants, i.e. his mothers, are staying with the said
sister Vaishali.
6.
After hearing the learned Advocates for the respective
parties, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Srirampur, vide his
impugned order dated 23/07/2019, partly allowed the appeal. The
judgment and order dated 29/03/2019, passed by the learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Shrirampur, in Criminal Miscellaneous
Application No.285/2015 came to be modified, thereby directing the
respondent/Deepak to pay Rs.3,000/- per month to each applicants
towards their maintenance from the date of the impugned order i.e.
29/03/2019.
7.
Being aggrieved by the said judgment and order of the
learned Additional Sessions Judge, the applicants, who are the
mothers, have approached this Court by filing the Criminal Revision
Application No.237/2019, thereby challenging the reduction of the
monthly maintenance amount from Rs.5000/- to Rs.3000/- each.
Respondent Deepak has also approached this Court by filing Criminal
Revision Application No.295/2019, challenging the grant of Rs.3,000/per month as maintenance to each of the applicants.
237.19revn etc
(6)
8.
Learned Advocate for the applicants in Criminal Revision
No.237/2019
(respondents
in
Criminal
Revision
Application
No.295/2019) submits that impugned judgment and order passed by
learned Additional Sessions Judge is against well settled law and
shows non application of mind of the learned Judge. According to
him, learned Judge has failed to appreciate that the applicants are old
aged ladies, suffering from various ailments and require constant
medication, for which learned JMFC had rightly awarded monthly
maintenance of Rs.5000/- each. However, learned Additional Sessions
Judge has erred in reducing the said maintenance to Rs.3000/-. He
then submits that respondent/Deepak had not laid any evidence to
show that the applicants are getting any income from interest or
dividend, and considering the increased cost of living, learned
Additional Sessions Judge ought not to have reduced the quantum of
monthly maintenance. He therefore, prays for allowing the Criminal
Revision Application No.237/2019 and dismissing Criminal Revision
Application No.295/2019.
9.
Per contra, learned Advocate for respondent/Deepak in
Criminal Revision Application No.237/2019 (who is applicant in
Criminal Revision Application No.295/2019) vehemently opposes
(7)
Criminal Revision Application No.237/2019.
237.19revn etc
He submits that the
applicants (mother of respondent/Deepak) are having huge property on
their name. He further submits that the applicants have invested huge
amount and thus, they have sufficient source of income and need not
require financial support. According to him, both the subordinate
Courts have failed to consider that both the applicants are not eligible
for granting maintenance, and thus, both the Courts have erred in
passing the impugned orders.
He, therefore prays for dismissing
Criminal Revision Application No. 237/2019 and allowing Criminal
Revision Application No.295/2019.
10.
After hearing the learned Advocates for the respective
parties in both the criminal revision application, I have gone through
the record as well as the impugned judgment and order passed by the
learned subordinate Courts. Both the Courts have observed that the
applicants (mothers) have proved that they are in a domestic
relationship with their son i.e. respondent/ Deepak. It is also proved
that the applicants lived with the respondent/Deepak in a domestic
relationship in Municipal House No.4111/8056, situated at Kumbhar
Galli, Ward No.3, Shrirampur. Further, the applicants/mothers have
also proved that they have been subjected to domestic violence at the
(8)
237.19revn etc
hands of the respondent/Deepak. Although the applicants/mothers in
Criminal Revision Application No.237/2019 had successfully proved
the said issues before the learned Trial Court and the learned Appellate
Court, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, nonetheless modified the
order passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, reducing
the maintenance amount from Rs.5,000/- to Rs.3,000/- per month for
each applicant. I have examined the impugned order dated 23/07/2019
to ascertain the reasons for the said reduction. Unfortunately, I fail to
find any reasons that justify the learned Additional Sessions Judge,
Shrirampur in reducing the amount of monthly maintenance from
Rs.5,000/- to Rs.3,000/-. The learned Additional Sessions Judge, in
paragraph No.15 of the impugned judgment and order, observed that
the Trial Court has fixed the monthly maintenance amount of
Rs.5,000/- per month for each applicant. Respondent/Deepak, being
the son of the applicants and they being aggrieved ladies, respondent/
Deepak is under an obligation to provide monetary help to them,
despite the established fact that they had sufficient funds in their
accounts. The applicants are getting interest thereupon quarterly, halfyearly and yearly. The amounts deposited in the accounts of the
applicants are not meagre but handsome. Though the respondent/
Deepak has not succeeded in bringing on record what actually the
(9)
237.19revn etc
applicants are getting towards interest or dividend, the fact cannot be
ignored that the applicants have been getting considerable returns on
their investment. In view of this, the learned Sessions Judge came to
the conclusion that the quantum of maintenance determined by the
learned Magistrate be reduced to Rs.3,000/- for each applicant.
11.
After going through the aforesaid discussion, I am of the
view that the reasons given by the learned Additional Sessions Judge
for reducing the maintenance amount are not valid and proper.
Looking to the age of the applicants (mothers), who are aged more
than 75 years, the maintenance amount, irrespective of the fact as to
whatever properties they may be having, is required to be paid by
respondent/Deepak, considering their health issues and old age related
ailments. Reducing the amount of maintenance would necessarily
cause them financial burden. The impugned order was passed in the
year 2019. However, now, certainly, the said amount requires to be
enhanced.
12.
In that view of the matter, I find that the order passed by
the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class was just and proper, and the
same rate of maintenance shall continue to be granted to the applicants
from the date of the impugned order i.e. 23/07/2019. Therefore, the
(10)
237.19revn etc
impugned order dated 23/07/2019 is hereby quashed and set aside to
the extent of reducing the amount from Rs.5,000/- to Rs.3,000/-. The
rest of the order is maintained.
13.
Accordingly, Criminal Revision Application No.237 of
2019 is allowed and the criminal revision application preferred by
respondent/Deepak, i.e. Criminal Revision Application No.295/2019,
is dismissed.
[SUSHIL M. GHODESWAR, J.]
sjk
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review