Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. A.J.DESAI
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE V.G.ARUN
MONDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF JUNE 2024 / 20TH JYAISHTA, 1946
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 19.03.2024 IN WP(C) NO.10411 OF 2024 OF
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT(S)/PETITIONER:
DEEKSHITH V.R
AGED 36 YEARS
S/O.RAM MOHAN, RESIDING AT 14/143, KALLAMKAI, MOGRAL
PUTHUR P.O., KASARAGOD DISTRICT, PIN - 671124
BY ADVS.
T.MADHU
AISWARYA JAYAPAL
C.R.SARADAMANI
RENJISH S. MENON
VRINDA T.S.
RESPONDENT(S)/RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, LOCAL SELF
GOVERNMENT INSTITUTIONS DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT
SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
THE DIRECTOR OF PANCHAYATS
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF PANCHAYATS
KASARAGOD, PIN - 671121
THE MOGRAL PUTHUR GRAMA PANCHAYAT
MOGRAL PUTHUR P.O., KASARAGOD DISTRICT, REPRESENTED BY
ITS SECRETARY., PIN - 671121
THE SECRETARY
MOGRAL PUTHUR GRAMA PANCHAYAT, MOGRAL PUTHUR P.O.,
KASARAGOD DISTRICT, PIN - 671124
THE KERALA STATE ELECTION COMMISSION
JANAHITHAM, T.C.27/6(2), VIKAS BHAVAN P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695033
THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER
KASARAGOD POLICE STATION, KASARAGOD DISTRICT, PIN 671121
BY ADV DEEPU LAL MOHAN, SC FOR R6
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-2SRI.V.TEKCHAND, SR.GP
THIS
WRIT
10.06.2024,
FOLLOWING:
THE
APPEAL
COURT
HAVING
ON
THE
COME
UP
SAME
FOR
DAY
ADMISSION
DELIVERED
ON
THE
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-3-
JUDGMENT
A.J.DESAI, CJ.
By way of the present appeal filed under Section 5 of the Kerala
High Court Act, 1958, the original petitioner has challenged the
judgment dated 19.03.2024, delivered by the learned Single Judge,
by which, the petition filed by the present appellant challenging
Ext.P12 order dated 01.03.2024, passed by the Kerala State Election
Commission with regard to the validity of his resignation as member
of the Mogral Puthur Grama Panchayat, came to be dismissed.
2. It is the case of the appellant
that he does not know
‘Malayalam’ and he had signed a letter which was written in
Malayalam, which happened to be his resignation letter from the
post of member of Mogral Puthur Grama Panchayat. It is the case of
the appellant that, under Section 115 of the Panchayat Raj Act, the
resignation is to be written by the concerned member in his own
handwriting. The appellant has a further case that he had signed
and presented the resignation letter under threat and coercion. The
appellant therefore contended that the resignation letter signed by
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-4-
him should have been quashed and set aside.
3. On the other hand, the learned Counsel appearing for the
Kerala State Election Commission took us through Ext.P11
deposition made by the appellant before the State Election
Commission as well as Ext.P12 order passed by the State Election
Commission and submitted that the appellant himself has accepted
that he was aware about the name and contents of the resignation
letter. All these aspects were considered by the State Election
Commission to hold that the Secretary of the Panchayat had
committed no error in accepting the resignation letter submitted by
the appellant.
4. We heard the learned Counsel appearing for respective
parties.
5. It is the case of the appellant that he had signed a document
written in Malayalam under threat and was not aware of its
contents. The said issue was examined by the Kerala State Election
Commission. Ext.P11, i.e., the deposition made by the appellant
makes it clear that he is able to understand and speak Malayalam.
The deposition of the appellant reads as under:
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-5-
Kerala State Election Commission
Deposition of Sri. Deekshith V R, recorded under solemn
affirmation before the Election Commission / on this 8th day
of November, 2023.
Name
: Deekshith V R
Name of father
: Ram Mohan
Age
: 35
Occupation
: Coolie
Address
: 14/143, Mogral Puthur, 671124.
I, Deekshith V R, contested in the December 2020
election for the 14th ward member position of Mogral
Puthur Grama Panchayat. I contested in the election as
the candidate of the SDPI political party in the Spectacles
symbol and I successfully won the election. The same is
recorded in the sworn affidavit presented before the
Panchayat Secretary.
I have appeared today for the
examination as instructed in the letter from the State
Election Commission.
On 16/10/2023, I submitted representation regarding my
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-6-
resignation
to
the
Secretary
and
State
Election
Commission. In this representation, I explained that I
resigned due to pressure and threats from certain
residents of Kallangai, namely Irshad, Sidique, Jilani,
Mujeeb Kambar. They have, on many occasions,
threatened me into resigning from my post. One week
prior, they handed over to me a letter typed in Malayalam
and directed me to sign it. I do not know how to read or
write in Malayalam. I submitted the said letter to the
Panchayat Secretary on 12/10/2023 without realising the
same was a resignation letter. I only submitted the letter
out of fear for the safety of my family and my own. When
the Secretary informed me after reading the letter that I
had not signed the same, I wrote my name in English as
Deekshith Kallangai and affixed my signature in the
presence of the Secretary. The acknowledgment receipt
was given by the Secretary. The acknowledgment receipt
given is with the Vice President who was present with me
at the time of submitting the letter. The applications
submitted
before
the
Panchayat
Secretary
and
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-7-
Commission by me are signed in Malayalam.
I have no dispute regarding the name, sign, address, time
and date present in the original resignation letter. My
name in the voter’s list is DEEKSHITH V R and my
father’s name is Ram Mohan. However, my name in the
resignation letter is Deekshith Kallangai, S/o Rama
Mohan. Deekshith V R is the name given in the official
nomination form submitted for the election of Gram
Panchayat member.
However, as per my request the
name given in the ballot paper was Deekshit Kallangai as
it is the name I am known by in the locality. When I
submitted the resignation letter on 12/10/2023 before the
Secretary, I did not disclose my reason for resigning or
the threat I received to the Secretary. It is when the
information about the resignation came out, I approached
the Secretary on 16/10/2023. After 12/10/2023, I went to
the Grama Panchayat office only on 16/10/2023, after
that I had not visited the Grama Panchayat. I did not
communicate about the incident to my party members on
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-8-
12/10/2023. I have submitted my compliant to the Police
Station, Kasargod and DYSP on 15/10/2023. However, I
did not receive any copy of the FIR. I can understand and
speak in Malayalam. The complaints which were written
in Malayalam by another person were read over to me
and I signed it after understanding the same. I applied
for and received the copy of my resignation letter from
the Panchayat officer via RTI. From the so received copy
of my resignation, it is not clear from the latter part of the
second line that I am resigning from the position of Gram
Panchayat.
I have not resigned from the position of a member and it
is my request to continue in this position.
The deposition was read over to me and the same is
correct.
Signed
8/11/2023
Deekshith V R
S/o Ram Mohan
(House) Kallangai
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-9-
6. All the relevant aspects were considered by the State
Election Commission in paragraph Nos.6 to 12 of Ext.P12,
reproduced below:
6. In his statement to the commission, Sri. Deekshith V
stated, “I handed over the paper to the Panchayat
Secretary on 12.10.2023 without knowing it was a
resignation letter. When the Panchayat Secretary read the
paper and said that I had not signed it, I wrote “Deekshith
Kallankai” in English in front of the Secretary. The receipt
was also given by the Panchayat Secretary.” During the
cross-examination,
the
secretary
testified
that
Mr.
Deekshith signed the resignation in his presence, but there
was no further cross-examination on this aspect.
This
indicates that the petitioner does not dispute that the
petitioner signed the document in front of the secretary.
7. Also, in the Panchayat Secretary’s statement, it is stated
that “Deekshith Kallankai signed the resignation knowing
that he was resigning and received the receipt of the
resignation.
The resignation was published on the
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-10-
Panchayat notice board on the same day and the vacancy
was reported along with the resignation”. Further,
Panchayath secretary stated, “I understood from the
resignation that Deekshit Kallankai had voluntarily
resigned, and thus the resignation was obtained from the
resigned
member
and
further
steps
were
taken”.
Additionally, the secretary mentioned, “when asked
whether it was a resignation, he confirmed that it was the
resignation letter”. It was also stated before the
commission that “Shri Deekshith wrote his name and
signature in English”. From this, the petitioner’s claim that
he handed over a paper to the secretary without knowing it
was a resignation does not seem credible. Similarly, the
petitioner’s assertion that he signed the resignation letter
without knowing it was a resignation letter, is also not
credible.
8.In the petitioner’s case, during the cross examination of
the secretary, the secretary stated, “I was never informed
that he did not know how to read and write Malayalam and
I did not understand this matter.
All the applications
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-11-
submitted by Deekshith to the Panchayat are in
Malayalam”. Additionally, the secretary has stated that
petitioner can understand and speak Malayalam, if spoken
to him.
9. Evidence indicates that Mr. Mujeeb Kambar, a resident
of Kallankai, threatened the petitioner. The Vice President,
Mr. Mujeeb Kambar was with the petitioner when the
resignation letter was submitted to the Secretary. There is
nothing unusual about Mr. Mujeeb Kambar being in
Panchayat office as Vice President. And the petitioner did
not state that the Vice President Mr. Mujeeb Kambar
threatened or coerced the petitioner in any way. It has
been established that the resignation letter was signed in
front of the secretary. There is no proof that the petitioner
was subjected to any pressure or threats while signing the
resignation letter. In this case, it can be concluded that the
petitioner voluntarily signed the letter of resignation in
front of the secretary and received a receipt for it.
10. The main argument of the petitioner in crossexamination is that it is not clear from the resignation
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-12-
letter which position he is resigning from. According to
Kerala Panchayat Raj (Resignation of Members of
President or Vice President) Rules, the President, Vice
President and Member of the Panchayat should submit
their resignation in the prescribed form. The resignation
of the President or Vice President, as applicable, should be
submitted by striking out the non-applicable part int his
form. The resigning party must strike out what is not
applicable.
The petitioner does not argue that the
panchayat secretary should have struck out the nonapplicable part. In this regard, the Panchayat Secretary
provided the following statement, “In the first part of the
Resignation letter, ‘President’ and Vice President were
crossed out, but in the second part, I did not bring to the
attention of the member that the strike was not done in
that manner due to my oversight”.
11. It is not difficult to understand from the resignation
letter that Shri Deekshith is a member of Mogral Puthur
Gram Panchayat and is resigning his membership. The
petitioner does not claim that he is the Panchayat
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-13-
President or Vice President or that the resignation letter is
unclear about the position from which he is resigning.
Since Shri Deekshith was only a member of the panchayat,
it is evident that he was resigning from his membership.
There is no fault in the Secretary’s action in this regard.
12. The petitioner was a member of the Standing
Committee. According to the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act,
the tenure of the Standing Committee member shall be
concurrent with the tenure of the Panchayat Member.
There is no reason to doubt that the petitioner has
resigned from the standing committee as the petitioner
submitted his resignation in Form 3 annexed to the Kerala
Panchayat Raj (Standing Committee) Rules and not in the
prescribed form.
7. Apart from the above, the very submission of the appellant
that a member of Panchayat would sign any document without
understanding the contents thereon, is unbelievable. Hence we find
that the authorities, including the learned Single Judge, have
committed no error in rejecting the case put forward by the
WA NO. 773 OF 2024
-14-
appellant.
Consequently, we do not find any reason to interfere with the
impugned judgment and the appeal is dismissed accordingly.
Sd/A.J.DESAI
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/V.G.ARUN
JUDGE
uu
10.06.2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review