Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADES
H
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 5th OF JANUARY, 2024
SECOND APPEAL No. 173 of 2016
BETWEEN:1.
DECED.
RATANLAL
THRU.
LRS.
SHRI
KAILASHCHAND S/O RATANLAL 84, SIYAGANJ,
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
DECED.
RATANLAL
THRU.
LRS.
SHRI
CHIMANLAL S/O RATANLAL 84 SIYAGANJ
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
DECED. RATANLAL THRU. LRS. SHRI RAJMAL
S/O RATANLAL 84 SIYAGANJ INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
4.
DECED. RATANLAL THRU. LRS. SHRI ASHOK
KUMAR S/O RATANLAL 84 SIYAGANJ INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
( SHRI V.K. JAIN SENIOR ADVOCATE ALONGWITH MS. VAISHALI JAINADVOCATE)
AND
SHRI SHRIKANT S/O LATE SHRI RAWNIHALKARAN
JAMINDAR, AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
SUKHVASTU KRISHI JAMIDAR RAWLA, 26, RAOJI
BAZAR, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
( BY SHRI SUNIL JAIN SENIOR ADVOCATE SHRI KUSHAGRA JAIN-
-2ADVOCATE)
This appeal coming on for orders this day, the court passed the
following:
JUDGMENT
This Second Appeal is filed by the defendant: late Ratan Lal
through legal heirs /appellants against the decree of eviction passed by
10th Civil Judge Class-II, Indore and confirmed by 5th Additional
Sessions Judge, Indore in the following cases:(i). Civil Suit No.124-A/2013, dated 17.05.2014.
(ii). First Appeal No.30/2014, dated 18.12.2015.
The facts of the case in short are as under:2.
The plaintiff is the owner of house No.84, Siyaganj, Indore in
which part of the area comprising three rooms on the first floor was
given to the defendants for residential and office purposes @ Rs.350/per month. A rent agreement dated 19.03.1997 was executed between
them which is not in dispute. According to the plaintiff, the defendants
were neglectful and irregular in payment of monthly rent. He did not
pay monthly rent from 01.12.2006 to 28.02.2007 @ Rs. 350/- total
Rs.1050/-. The plaintiff has also alleged that on 28.02.2007, the
defendants removed the partition wall between the rooms and made it
one hall, made RCC construction on the room and raised the wall upto
10 feet illegally without his written permission. According to the
-3-
plaintiff, the defendants substantially caused damage to the property,
hence, the defendants violated the terms and conditions of the rent
agreement causing the nuisance. It is further pleaded that the plaintiff
sent his employees and officers for recovery of the rent but the
defendants misbehaved with them and caused the nuisance. The report
to that effect was lodged on 07.03.2007. In such premises, now he does
not want to continue the tenancy and terminated the tenancy, thereafter
filed a Civil Suit for eviction under Section 12(1) (a) (c) and (m) of
M.P. Accommodation Control Act, 1961 (for the sake of convenience ''
the Act, of 1961'').
3.
The defendant died during the pendency of the suit hence his
legal heirs were brought on record. They filed a written statement
through defendant No.5 being power of attorney holder defendant No.1
to 4. Defendant No.5 uses the premises in the name of Rajratan
Concept which is a registered partnership firm. According to the
defendants, the P. Rashmi & Company tenant on the ground floor
removed the wall in the year 1999, therefore, as a consequence, the
plaintiff orally permitted him to remove the wall on the first floor.
Since the two walls of the ground floor were removed which were
load-bearing walls therefore the defendants had to remove the
aforesaid wall of the first floor. The defendants spent Rs.5,02,379/-
-4-
from April 2002 to April, 2003 and for which entries were made in the
ledger and account. The plaintiff used to give permission for
renovation and modification of the premises for the business purpose.
The plaintiff earlier has also filed Civil Suit No.161-A/2007 for
permanent injunction which is still pending. The plaintiff is in the habit
of increasing the rent. The defendants sent the rent by money order
which the plaintiff refused. It is pleaded that from 01.01.1997, the rent
was enhanced from Rs. 200/- to Rs. 350/-.The defendants filed an
application under Section 25 of Act, 1961 on 01.09.2007 in which rent
was fixed of Rs.3500/- which was deposited in the Court. The
defendants denied the misbehavior with the employees and officers of
the plaintiff and they have not changed the outer structure of the
premises. The allegations of nuisance have specifically been denied.
4.
On the basis of pleadings, the Trial Court has framed the
following issues for adjudication, which are reproduced below:1- D; k i zfr okn hx . k u s okn h } kj k cd k; k fd j k; s d h /ku j kf/k d s l a
ca
/ k esa fn ; s x ; s
eka
x u ksfVl
i = d s fn u ka
d l s n ks ekg d s Hkhr j cd k; k fd j k; s d h j kf' k d k u r ks Hkq
x r ku
fd ; k v kS
j u gh Hkq
x r ku d s fy ; s i L
zr q
r fd ; k\
& gkW
] fd Ur q i zfr okn hx . k bl
v k/kkj i j
fu "d kl u d si k= u gha
A
2- D; k i zfr okn hx . k d s } kj k okn h d s l kFk y M kbZ> x M k d j U; w
l sa
l d kfj r fd ; k
x ; k gS
\ & gkW
]
3- D; k i zfr okn hx . k u s okn h d h fy f[ kr v u q
e fr d s fcu k on x zLr LFkku esa fu ekZ
.k
d k; Zd j okn h d sfgr ka
sd ksgkfu i gq
W
p kr sgq
; sl kj Hkw
r : i l si fj ofr Z
r d j fn ; k gS
\ & gkW
4- D; k okn h] i fzr okn hx . k l s1050@& : i ; sv o' ks"k fd j k; k i zkIr d j u sd k v f/d kj h
gS
\ & gkW
5- D; k okn h] i fzr okn hx . k l s 350@& : i ; s i fzr ekg d h n j l s v a
r fj e y kHk i zkIr
d j u sd k v f/kd kj h gS
\ & va
fr e i S
j k v uq
l kj A
-56- D; k okn h u s; g okn v l R; v k/kkj ka
si j i L
zr q
r fd ; k gS
\ &v i ze kf. kr A
7- l gk; r k , oaO; ; \ & v a
fr e i S
j k v uq
l kj A
5.
The plaintiff examined himself as PW-1, Ravindra Dixit (PW-2)
and Jagannath Verma (PW-3), all have duly supported averments made
in the plaint. The defendant examined Ashok Jain (DW-1).
6.
After appreciating the evidence that came on record, vide
judgment dated 17.05.2014, the learned Civil Judge granted the decree
under Section 12 (1) (a) (c) and (m) of the Act, of 1961.
7.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree, the
defendants preferred First Appeal No.30/2014 before the 5th
Additional District, Indore. Vide judgment dated 18.12.2015 set aside
the judgment and decree under Section 12(1) (a) but maintained under
Section 12(1) (c) and (m) of the Act, of 1961, hence, the present
Second Appeal before this Court.
8.
Shri
V.K.
Jain,
learned
Senior
counsel
for
the
appellants/defendants submits that the learned Trial Court granted a
decree under Section 12(1) (a) of the Act, of 1961 which has been set
aside by the learned Appellate Court, however, judgment and decree
under Section 12(1) (c) (m) of the Act, of 1961 has wrongly been
affirmed. Shri Jain, learned Senior Counsel further submits that the
decree under Section 12(1) (c) of the Act, of 1961 is not sustainable as
the defendants did not create any nuisance by denying the title of the
-6-
plaintiff. The decree under Section 12(1) (c) of the Act, of 1961 can be
granted only on three grounds i.e. firstly, the tenant created a nuisance,
secondly, has done any act which is inconsistent with the purpose for
which he was admitted to the tenancy, thirdly which is likely to affect
adversely and substantially the interest of the landlord. None of the
aforesaid requirements are fulfilled in the present case. The plaintiff
sought the decree under Section 12(1) (c) only on the ground that the
defendants misbehaved with the staff of the plaintiff when they went to
collect the rent however the first Appellate Court has set aside the said
findings. So far as denial of title is concerned, the defendants in
examination-in-chief have only stated that the plaintiff is claiming
himself to be Zamidar but the system has been abolished which cannot
be treated as the defendants denied the title of the plaintiff, therefore,
the decree under Section 12(1) (c) of the Act, of 1961 is unsustainable.
9.
So far as a decree under Section 12(1) (m) of the Act, of 1961 is
concerned, learned senior counsel submits that that has wrongly been
granted in view of section 12(10) of the Act, of 1961which says that no
order for the eviction of a tenant shall be made on the ground specified
in clause (m) of sub-section (1) if the tenant within such time as may
be specified in this behalf by the Court restores the accommodation to
its original condition or pays to the landlord such amount by way of
-7-
compensation as it may direct, therefore without compliance of Section
12(10), the decree under Section 12 (1) (m) of the Act, of 1961 has
wrongly been passed. In support of his contention, Shri V.K. Jain,
learned Senior Counsel has placed reliance on the judgment passed in
the case of J.J. Lal Pvt. Ltd and others Vs. M.R. Murali and another
(2002) 3 SCC 98 in which it has been held that the plea taken by the
defendant/tenant in a written statement about denial of title of the
plaintiff, then the landlord should be given the opportunity to amend
the eviction application incorporating the averments that the plea taken
by the tenant in the written statement amounted to denial of title of the
landlord and such denial is not bonafide. In the case of Babulal V.
Jiwanlal, 1980, Weekly Note 136 in the Division Bench of this Court
has held that alternations or reconstruction made by the tenant not
detrimental to the plaintiffs' interest or diminished the value of the
tenanted premises suit cannot be decreed merely because of alternation
or reconstruction.
10.
Per contra, Shri Sunil Jain, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the plaintiff contends that clause 5 of the rent agreement mandates that
the tenant shall not carry out any minor or major construction without
written permission of the landlord. Admittedly, there is no such written
permission, the defendants have failed to prove the oral permission,
-8-
therefore, there is a violation of the conditions of the rent agreement
and the decree has rightly been granted under under section 12(1) (m)
of the Act, of 1961. So far as compliance with Section 12 (10) is
concerned, this Court in the case of Prem Kaur Ahuja Vs. Sardar
Karam Singh [1995 M.P.L.J. 938] held that the requirement under
section 12, clause (10) of the Act, of 1961is required to be followed
when on the sole ground under section 12(1) (m) of the Act the
ejectment is sought. There is a decree under section 12(1) (c) of the
Act, of 1961 is also granted, therefore, this ground is not sustainable. It
is further submitted that the decree under Section 12(1) (c) has rightly
been granted as the plaintiff by making material construction changed
the premises without written permission of the defendant. Shri Sunil
Jain, learned Senior counsel submits that no substantial question of law
is involved in this Second Appeal hence same is be dismissed.
The appellants have suggested the following substantial question
of law:(a) Whether, the judgments and decrees passed by the learned
Courts below are legally sustainable and the learned Courts
below have legally erred in decreeing the suit and dismissing
the appeal ?
(b) Whether the learned Courts below have failed to properly
appreciate the evidence on record and examine the legal
position in a right perspective and finding are based on
misreading of evidence on record ?
(c) Whether the learned Courts below having held that no
nuisance as alleged in the plaint has been committed by the
-9-
Appellants, still the Courts were right in law in passing the
decree under Section 12(1) (c) of the Act ?
(d) Whether the learned Courts below were right in law in
passing a decree on the ground of disclaimer, which was
never pleaded by the respondents/plaintiffs nor was any
issue framed with regard thereto, could a decree on the
ground of disclaimer under Section 12 (1) (c) of the Act
have been passed ?
(e) Whether, the learned Courts below were right in law that
even without pleading or framing any specific issue that too
when the relationship of landlord and tenant is not denied,
could a decree on the ground of disclaimer under Section 12
(1) (c) of the Act have been passed ?
(f) Whether the learned Courts below were right in law in
passing a decree under Section 12 (1) (m) of the Act without
proving any damage to the tenanted premises ?
(g) Whether the learned Courts below have legally erred in
ignoring the significant requirement of law that a decree can
be passed under Section 12 (1) (m) of the Act only in case
where the construction, which has been made has materially
altered the accommodation to the detriment of landlord's
interest or is likely to diminish its value substantially ?
(h) Whether the learned Courts below have failed to consider
that the plaintiff has failed to plead and prove the fact that
the construction/alteration made by the appellant has
materially altered the accommodation to the detriment of
landlord's interest or has diminished its value substantially ?
In absence of any pleadings, proof and finding in this regard
no decree under Section 12 91) (m) of the Act could have
been passed.
(i) Whether the learned Courts below have ignored the
mandatory provision of law as provided under Section
12(10) of the M.P. Accommodation Control Act, which
prohibits passing of a decree under Section 12(1) (m) of the
Act unless an opportunity to restore the accommodation in
its original condition or to pay such amount by way of
compensation ?
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused
the record.
-10-
11.
It is correct that in the written statement the defendants did not
deny the title of the plaintiff but in the affidavit filed under Order 18
Rule 4 of C.P.C.,by way of evidence D.W.-1
specifically denied the
title of the plaintiff. Para 7 is reproduced below:7-
; g fd ] okn h u s ; g fu "d kl u d k okn i fzr okn h d s fo: )
i zLr q
r fd ; k gS
t cfd okn h t ehn kj gSr Fkk t ehn kj h i zFkk Hkj . k i k"sk. k t ehn kj h , DV 2008 mUeksp u v u q
l kj
l ekIr d h t k p q
d h gS
A bl
d kj . k l n j i d
z j . k i zp y u ; kX
s; u ghagS
A okn h u sn kfo; k LFky
d k LokfeRo i ze kf. kr u gha fd ; k gS
A ek= l Ei fRr d j d h j l hn a
s og Hkh Nk; ki zfr LokfeRo
i ze kf. kr u ghad j r h gS
A okn h l k{kh d h Lohd kj kfsDr bl
l a
ca
/ k esafn u ka
d 18-11-2009 d sp j . k
9 Jhl a
t ; xq
Ir k l kgc d sU; k; ky ; esamYy [s ku h; gS
A
12.
It is clear from the aforesaid para, the D.W.-1 deposed that the
plaintiff is not Zamidar because the said system has been abolished and
the plaintiff has not proved his title merely on the basis of property, the
ownership cannot be established. Para 34 in the cross-examination, he
has admitted that Shrikant Zamindar is the owner of the suit house and
he is a tenant. In para 37, he has admitted that the new construction is
visible in photographs Ex.P/22 to P/30, however, he has stated that he
has not made any change in the outer portion of the suit
accommodation.
13.
The plaintiff also sought a decree of eviction on the ground that
by construction and alteration in the accommodation the detriment of
the landlord's interest diminishing the value of the property contrary to
-11-
Section 12(1)(m) of the Act, of 1961 as grounds for eviction.
According to D.W.-1, he obtained the oral permission for alteration
and construction in the suit accommodation. He has specifically stated
that he has not obtained any written permission. He has also admitted
that he constructed the toilet without permission whereas clause 5 of
the rent agreement specifically provided that without written
permission tenant shall not carry out any construction or alteration to
the suit premises, therefore, decree under Section 12 (1) (c) and 12 (1)
(m) of the Act, of 1961 have rightly been granted as the defendants
made alteration and construction without written permission of
landlord. Therefore, in view of admission by the defendant in evidence
that the construction or alteration was made in the accommodation
without written permission,, thus the decree under 12(1) (c) of the Act,
of 1961 has rightly been granted by both the Courts Below.
13.
So far as compliance of section 12 (10) is concerned, this court
in the case of Prem Kaur Ahuja (supra) had held that if the decree is
only sought under 12(1) (m) then only the compliance of 12 (10) of the
Act, of 1961 is required. In the present case, the decree under section
12(1) (c) has also been granted, therefore, the aforesaid ground taken
by Shri V.K. Jain, learned Senior Counsel is unsustainable. Apart from
-12-
the above, there are concurrent findings recorded by both the Courts
Below while granting the decree of eviction.
14.
In view of above, no case for interference is made out.
Accordingly, the Second Appeal is hereby dismissed.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Praveen
Date: 2024.01.11 10:18:16
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review