Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.333 of 2024
Debasish Sen,
S/O. Late Manik Lal Sen,
Resident of Police Line, P.O. Gokulpur,
Udaipur, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura, PIN:799 120
Aged:53 years
----Petitioner (s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
to be represented by the Secretary,
Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN: 799 010
2. The Secretary,
Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN:799 010
3. The Joint Secretary,
Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN:799 010
4. The Deputy Secretary,
Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN:799 010
5. The District Magistrate & Collector,
Gomati District, Udaipur,
Office of the District Magistrate & Collector,
Gomati District, Udaipur, PIN:799 101
6. The Block Development Officer,
Tepania R.D. Block,
Office of the Block Development Officer,
Tepania R.D. Block, Gomati District,
PIN:799 114
---- Respondents (s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of Hearing &
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
10.01.2025
NO
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order (Oral)
Heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr. P. Roy Barman
assisted by Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Learned counsel appearing
on behalf of the petitioner and also heard Mr. M. Debbarma,
Learned Addl. G.A. appearing on behalf of the Staterespondents.
02.
By means of filing this writ petition, the present
petitioner has sought for the following reliefs:
(i) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why Writ in the nature of mandamus
and/or
Order/direction
shall
not
be
issued
whereby quashing and cancelling the letter,
dated,
20.02.2024,
issued
by
the
Block
Development Officer, Tepania RD Block, Gomati
District.
(ii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why Writ in the nature of mandamus
and/or
Order/direction
shall
not
be
issued
whereby directing the Respondents not to cause
any recovery from the Petitioner in terms of the
impugned Memo, dated 17.01.2024.
(iii) Make the rules absolute.
(iv) Call for records.
(v) Pass any further order/orders as this Hon’ble
High Court considered fit and proper.
03.
The brief facts of this writ petition is that, in the
year 2002 the petitioner was appointed to the post of
Computer Operator in Community Information Centre,
under
the
Directorate
of
Information
Technology
(Department of Industries and Commerce) on fixed pay
basis. Thereafter, vide memorandum dated 29.12.2008
issued
by
the
Commissioner
&
Secretary,
Rural
Development Department, Government of Tripura, the
petitioner was issued offer-cum-appointment to the post of
Computer
Operator
(CIC)(Group-C,
Non-Gazetted)
on
regular pay scale of Rs.4200-8650/- per month plus other
admissible
allowances
under
R.D.
Department
w.e.f.
01.12.2008 on completion of six years of service on fixed
pay basis on the terms and conditions mentioned in the said
memorandum
Operator
and
(CIC)
the
under
petitioner
the
joined
respondents.
memorandum dated 29.12.2008
as
Computer
Copy
of
the
is annexed with this
petition marked as Annexure-1.
04.
issued
Thereafter vide notification dated 27.06.2009
by
the
Joint
Secretary,
Rural
Development
Department, Government of Tripura, the Governor was
pleased to grant regular scale of pay of Rs.4200-8650/- to
52 Computer Operators (CIC) (Group-C, Non-Gazetted),
including the petitioner after completion of six years of
continuous service without break on fixed pay basis. It was
also mentioned that the past services of those 52 nos.
Computer
Operators
under
CIC
rendered
in
the
IT
Department would be taken into consideration for future
service
benefit.
The
notification
dated
27.06.2009
is
annexed with this petition marked as Annexure-2.
05.
After that the petitioner was allowed benefit of
ACP-I in the year 2012, on completion of his ten years of
regular and satisfactory service from the date of his entry
into Govt. service. As such the petitioner was allowed one
increment @ 3% on the pay of existing pay Band and Grade
pay plus next available grade pay as benefit of financial upgradation under the ACP scheme. It was also further stated
that the Deputy Secretary, Government of Tripura, Rural
Development Department vide letter dated 20.09.2014
informed the District Magistrate & Collector, West Tripura
that contractual service period is not taken into account for
computing the required period of service for ACP as per
reference Computer Operators (CIC) has been allowed ACP
taking the contract period of service into consideration and
it should be cancelled immediately and excess amount paid
to the incumbents shall be recovered at the earliest.
Subsequently, another letter dated 05.05.2018 was issued
by the Addl. Secretary, Rural Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura to all the District Magistrate and Collectors,
requesting them to examine whether any Senior Computer
Assistant (SCA) has been granted ACP benefit by wrongly
counting the contract period of their service, and in case,
the concerned SCA is enjoying the ACP granted wrongly,
request was made by the Addl. Secretary to withdraw the
same immediately and send action taken report to the
Department positively by 15.05.2018. Copies of the letters
dated
20.09.2014
and
05.05.2018
annexed
with
this
petition marked as Annexure-3.
06.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid letters dated
20.09.2014 and 05.05.2018 the present petitioner and
others filed one Writ Petition being W.P.(C) No.536 of 2018
before the High Court. and this High Court by order dated
03.10.2019 stayed the operation of impugned memo dated
08.05.2018 whereby the benefit of ACP-1 was arbitrarily
withdrawn by the DM & Collector, South Tripura, Belonia.
Thereafter, this High Court allowed the writ petition by the
common judgment and order dated 03.01.2019 along with
other
writ
petitions
quashed
the
memorandum
dated
08.05.2018 and directed the respondents to restore and
continue to give benefits of MACP-I to the petitioner. The
State-respondents being aggrieved with the said judgment
preferred one appeal which was numbered as WA 136/2020
and the Division Bench of this High Court quashed the writ
appeal by the judgment and order dated 02.03.2021. But
the Division Bench did not direct the respondents to cause
recovery
of
the
said
benefit
already
given
to
the
incumbents.
07.
Gomati
Thereafter, the District Magistrate & Collector,
District,
Udaipur
issued
B)/ESTT/MACP/DM(G)/2019-20/6352
Order/letter
dated
No.(114-
20.09.2021
whereby it was known that the pay of one Sri Arup Shil
Sharma, Senior Computer Assistant would be re-fixed and
overdrawn amount due to grant of ACP-I benefit should be
recovered from his salary, in suitable monthly installments,
if not deducted earlier. Copy of this order 20.09.2021 is
annexed with this petition marked as Annexure-6. After
that, the Block Development Officer, Tepania RD Block,
Gomati District, issued impugned memo dated 17.01.2024
stating inter alia that in pursuance to the Memo No.F.1(114B)-ESTT/MACP/DM(G)/2019-20/6352
dated
20.09.2021
issued by the District Magistrate & Collector, Gomati
District, Udaipur, the BDO, Tepania RD Block re-fixed pay of
the petitioner w.e.f. 01.12.2018 and overdrawn amount was
calculated at Rs.2,97,209/- up to 31.01.2024 due to grant
of MACT-I in favour of the present petitioner. It is further
mentioned that said overdrawn amount would be recovered
from the monthly salary of the petitioner in 60 monthly
installments @Rs.4954/- per month w.e.f. February 2024.
Copy of the memo dated 17.01.2024 is annexed with this
petition marked as Annexure-7.
08.
The State-respondents have contested the case
by filing counter-affidavit and in the counter-affidavit the
State-authority denied the claim of the petitioner and
submitted that there are several other judgments of the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
regarding
recovery
of
excess
amount which is legally permissible and prayed for dismissal
of this writ petition.
09.
Taking
part
in
Counsel
Mr.
Roy
Barman
P.
the
hearing
Learned
assisted
by
Senior
Mr.
S.
Bhattacharjee, Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
stated
that
the
petitioner
Debasish
Sen
was
initially
appointed as Computer Operator (Group-C, Non-Gazetted)
in the establishment of R.D. Department in the year 2002
on contractual basis and in the year 2008 his service was
regularized and after completion of ten years of service,
CAS-1(ACP-I) was granted to him. Thereafter in the year
2012 the Department provided him the benefit of CAS-1
after taking into account of his period of contractual service
and regular service both, on completion of ten years of
service. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that on
20.09.2014 the Deputy Secretary to the Government of
Tripura, Rural Development Department in formed the
District Magistrate & Collector, West Tripura that contractual
service period is not taken into account for computing the
required period of service for ACP as per Rule and
subsequently, on 05.05.2018 a letter was issued by the
Addl. Secretary, Rural Development Department, Govt. of
Tripura to all the District Magistrate & Collectors for
withdrawal of benefit of CAS-1(ACP-I) from the petitioner
(Annexure-4) and being aggrieved thereby the petitioner
filed one writ petition before this High Court which was
numbered as WP(C)No.536 of 2018 and a Coordinate Bench
of this High Court allowed the writ petition filed by the
petitioner. After that the Government of Tripura challenged
the said judgment before the Division Bench of this High
Court which was numbered as WA No.136 of 2020 and the
Division Bench of this High Court by judgment dated
02.03.2021 reversed the judgment of the Learned Single
Judge holding that the past service of contractual service
cannot be counted for granting of CAS-1(ACP-I). Learned
Senior Counsel Mr. Roy Barman further submitted that in
the said judgment of the Hon’ble Division Bench there is no
observation or decision made by the Division Bench of this
High Court for recovery of amount already paid to the
petitioner. But despite the same the D.M. & Collector vide
letter dated 20.02.2024 directed the concerned B.D.O. to
recover the said overdrawn amount from the salary of the
petitioner and in compliance of the said direction of the said
D.M. & Collector, Gomati District, Udaipur, the B.D.O.,
Silachari
RD
Block
issued
memorandum
dated
20.02.2024(Annexure-7) directed the Accounts Department
of the Silachari RD Block to recover the excess amount
drawn by the petitioner for the period from 08.07.2012 to
31.01.2024 in 108 nos. of installments @ Rs.6415/- per
month from the month of February, 2024. Learned Senior
Counsel further submitted that as per the decision of this
High Court in connection with Case No.WP(C)1342 of 2016,
WP(C)1345
of
and
WP(C)1346
of
dated
13.07.2017 of a coordinate Bench of this High Court and
also the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of
Punjab & Ors. vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) & Ors.
reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334 that no such deduction is
permissible as per law as there was no false representation
or information from the side of the petitioner who is a
Group-C employee and excess amount, if any, was paid that
was only for the fault of the department not for the fault of
the petitioner. Learned Senior Counsel also submitted that
as per Annexure-7 i.e. communication of DM & Collector,
Gomati District, Udaipur, the BDO, Tepania, RD Block
refixed
pay
of
the
petitioner
w.e.f
01.12.2018
and
overdrawn amount was calculated at Rs.2,97,209/- up to
31.01.2024 to which the period of excess amount of the
petitioner as Computer Operator in view of the judgment of
the Hon’ble Apex Court in aforenoted case Rafiq Masih
(supra), recovery of excess amount beyond five years is not
permissible.
10.
The State has contested the case by filing the
counter-affidavit as already stated denying the assertions of
the writ petitioner rather the State has taken the plea that
there are several judgments in this regard that recovery is
permissible and the State finally by the counter-affidavit
urged for dismissal of this writ petition. However, in course
of hearing Learned Addl. G.A. Mr. M. Debbarma appearing
on behalf of the State has submitted that initially a
Coordinate Bench of this High Court by a judgment dated
03.10.2019 in connection with case Nos. W.P.(C) No.515 of
2018 W.P.(C) No.527 of 2018 W.P.(C) No.528 of 2018
W.P.(C) No.529 of 2018 W.P.(C) No.530 of 2018 W.P.(C)
No.531 of 2018 W.P.(C) No.532 of 2018 W.P.(C) No.533 of
2018 W.P.(C) No.534 of 2018 W.P.(C) No.535 of 2018
W.P.(C) No.536 of 2018 W.P.(C) No.537 of 2018 W.P.(C)
No.538 of 2018 W.P.(C) No.539 of 2018 W.P.(C) No.540 of
2018 W.P.(C) No.541 of 2018 W.P.(C) No.542 of 2018
W.P.(C) No.741 of 2018 allowed the similar claim of those
petitioners. But challenging the said judgment the State of
Tripura preferred an appeal before the Division Bench of this
High Court and the Division Bench of this High Court by the
judgment dated 02.03.2021 delivered in case Nos. W.A. 143
of 2019, W.A. 18 of 2020, W.A. 125 of 2020, W.A. 126 of
2020, W.A. 127 of 2020, W.A. 129 of 2020, W.A. 130 of
2020, W.A. 131 of 2020, W.A.134 of 2020, W.A. No.135 of
2020, W.A. No.136 of 2020, W.A. No.137 of 2020, W.A. 138
of 2020, W.A. 139 of 2020, W.A. 140 of 2020, W.A. 141 of
2020, W.A. 142 of 2020, W.A. 143 of 2020, W.A. 144 of
2020, W.A. 170 of 2020, W.A. 171 of 2019, W.A. 172 of
2019, W.A. 173 of 2019, W.A. 174 of 2019, W.A. No.175 of
2019, W.A. No.176 of 2019, W.A. No.177 of 2019 and W.A.
No.178 of 2019 reversed the judgment of the Learned
Single Judge of this High Court and the said fact is narrated
in the counter-affidavit filed by the state-respondents.
11.
I have heard rival submissions of both the parties
and perused the writ petition filed by the petitioner as well
as the counter-affidavit filed by the State-respondents.
There is no dispute on record that the present petitioner
was initially appointed as Computer Operator (Group-C) in
the establishment of RD Department in the year 2002 on
contractual basis and thereafter in the year 2008 his service
got regularized and after completion of ten years of service
he was given CAS-1 (ACP-I) by the department after taking
into account of his period of contractual service and regular
service. But the dispute started after issuing memorandum
by DM & Collector, South Tripura on 08.05.2018 regarding
withdrawal of ACP-1 benefit provided to the present
petitioner along with others and after that the petitioner
challenged the same before this High Court as discussed
earlier.
12.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in State of
Punjab and Others vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer)
and Others reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334 in para No.18
observed as under:
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship, which would govern employees on the issue of
recovery, where payments have mistakenly been made by
the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it
may, based on the decisions referred to herein above, we
may, as a ready reference, summarise the following few
situations, wherein recoveries by the employers, would
be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class-III and
Class-IV service (or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees who
are due to retire within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess payment
has been made for a period in excess of five years, before
the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully
been required to discharge duties of a higher post, and
has been paid accordingly, even though he should have
rightfully been required to work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at the
conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee,
would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an
extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of
the employer's right to recover.”
Referring the same Learned Senior Counsel
submitted that in view of the principle of law laid down by
the Hon’ble Apex court in the said case there is no scope to
recover the excess amount already paid by the respondents
to the petitioner. It was also submitted that the aforesaid
clause-i and clause-ii of the said judgment would be applied
in this case.
13.
The
petitioner
also
relied
upon
another
judgment of this High Court in WP(C) No.1342 of 2016
dated 13.07.2017 in para Nos.5, 6, 7, 8 and 9, wherein this
High Court observed as under:
“5. The grievance of the petitioners is thus confined to
the recovery as directed by the order dated 15.11.2016.
Mr. Pal, learned counsel has fairly submitted that in terms
of the said memorandum dated 21.06.2013 if the pay of
the petitioners is refixed, the said arrears as calculated
by the Head of Office, can be shown as the excess drawn
by the petitioners, but after five years when the
petitioners have consumed that sum whether the
recovery should be permitted. This is the sole question
that has fallen for consideration of this court. Mr. Pal,
learned counsel has asserted that in view of Rafiq Masih
(supra) such recovery cannot be permitted as the Apex
Court has clearly laid the guideline that recovery from the
employees belonging to the class III and class IV
services or Group „C‟ and Group „D‟ services whose excess
payment has been made for a period in excess of five
years before the order of recovery was issued cannot be
made.
6. In the present case, the petitioners have enjoyed the
said excess amount for five years when the order of
recovery was issued and hence following the guidelines
as laid down by the Apex Court in Rafiq Masih (supra),
the respondents be prohibited from recovering any
amount from the petitioners. For purpose of reference,
the relevant paragraph where the guidelines are laid
down has been extracted hereunder:
“It is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship, which would govern employees on the
issue
of
recovery,
where
payments
have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess
of their entitlement. Be that as it may, based on
the decisions referred to herein above, we may, as
a ready reference, summarise the following few
situations, wherein recoveries by the employers,
would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to ClassIII and Class-IV service (or Group 'C' and Group 'D'
service).
(ii)
Recovery
from
retired
employees,
or
employees who are due to retire within one year,
of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess
payment has been made for a period in excess of
five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a
higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at
the conclusion, that recovery if made from the
employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh
the equitable balance of the employer's right to
recover.”
7. Mr. Chakraborty, learned Additional Government
Advocate has fairly admitted that on the day of issuing
the impugned order dated 15.11.2016 (Annexure P-7 to
the writ petition) the time frame of five years had
expired, but the notice was issued to the petitioner much
before that, i.e. on 22.09.2016. That apart, Mr.
Chakraborty, learned Additional Government Advocate
has submitted that an undertaking was taken from the
petitioner at the time of making payment on refixation of
pay in the promotional post that had they received any
amount in excess they would refund the said amount. Mr.
Chakraborty, learned Additional Government Advocate
did not dispute the fact that after issuance of the
memorandum
dated
21.06.2013
the
clarification
generated a new circumstances when the fact of the
drawal of the excess amount was located as the
petitioners‟ pay in the promotional post was again
refixed. Mr. Chakraborty, learned Additional Government
Advocate has submitted having referred para 11 of the
reply that the Head of Office for reason best known to
him had taken the action after 3 years and 4 months
from the date of issuance of the said memorandum dated
21.06.2013.
8. Having appreciated the submissions made by the
learned counsel appearing for the parties, this court is of
the view that if the recovery is permitted, it would be
inequitous and harsh and it would out-weigh the
equitable balance.
9. In view of this, the impugned order of recovery dated
15.11.2016 (Annexure 7 to the writ petition) is set aside
and quashed. The respondents are directed not to recover
any amount from the petitioner which has been
determined to have drawn by the petitioner in excess of
the pay till their refixation in terms of the memorandum
dated 21.06.2013 (Annexure R-1 to the writ petition).”
Referring the same Learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the petitioner submitted that in view of the
aforesaid citation there is no scope on the part of the State-
respondents to recover the amount from the petitioner
which is already been paid.
14.
Learned
Senior
Counsel
finally
relied
upon
another citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Jagdish
Prasad Singh vs. State of Bihar and Others reported in
2024 SCC OnLine SC 1909 wherein para Nos. 23, 24, 27
and 28 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“23. In the case of State of Punjab and Others v. Rafiq
Masih (White Washer) and Others3, this Court held as
under: “18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship which would govern employees on the
issue
of
recovery,
where
payments
have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess
of their entitlement. Be that as it may, based on
the decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as
a ready reference, summarise the following few
situations, wherein recoveries by the employers,
would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to
Class III and Class IV service (or Group C and
Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the
employees who are due to retire within one year,
of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the
excess payment has been made for a period in
excess of five years, before the order of recovery is
issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a
higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at
the conclusion, that recovery if made from the
employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh
the equitable balance of the employer's right to
recover.”
(emphasis supplied)
24. Recently, this Court in Thomas Daniel v. State of
Kerala and Others: 2022 SCC OnLine SC 536, held that the
State cannot recover excess amount paid to the exemployee after the delay of 10 years.
27. The order dated 8th October, 2009 passed by the
State Government directing reduction in the pay scale of
the appellant from Rs.6500-10500 to Rs.5500-9000 w.e.f.
1st January, 1996 and directing recovery of the excess
amount from him is grossly illegal and arbitrary and is
hereby quashed and set aside. The impugned order dated
27th August, 2012 passed by the Division Bench of the
High Court does not stand to scrutiny and is hereby
quashed. Therefore, the appellant shall continue to
receive the pension in accordance with the pay scale of
Rs.6500-10500.
28. In case, if any reduction in pension and consequential
recovery was effected on account of the impugned
orders, the appellant shall be entitled to the
restoration/reimbursement thereof with interest as
applicable.”
Referring the same Learned Senior Counsel
further drawn the attention of this court that since similar
other matters of other petitioners are also pending and by
this time some amount is already been deducted from the
salary bill of the petitioners so a direction may accordingly
be given to the State-respondents to refund/restore the said
amount to the petitioners if deducted from the salary bill.
15.
So, after hearing detailed submission of Learned
Counsels of both the parties and also after going through
the principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
the aforenoted cases and also after perusal of the judgment
of a coordinate Bench of this High Court, this court is of the
view that if at this stage the recovery is permitted it would
be unjustified and harsh for the petitioner and also would
came under hardships of the petitioner, so in view of the
above, the impugned order of recovery dated 17.01.2024
issued by B.D.O., Tepania RD Block i.e. Annexure-7 of the
writ petition accordingly stand set aside and quashed. The
respondents are directed not to recover any amount from
the petitioner which has been determined to have been
withdrawn by the petitioner, in excess of the pay.
16.
In the result, the writ petition is allowed to the
extent as indicated above. However, if any amount by this
time is deducted from the salary bill of the petitioner that
shall
be
refunded/restored
to
the
petitioner
by
the
respondents immediately.
Pending application, if any, stands disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.01.20
04:58:18 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review