Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 609 of 2023
Debashish Datta Roy,
son of late Dinesh Chandra Datta Roy,
resident of Boulapasha, Mother Teresa Sarani,
P.O. & P.S. Kailashahar, District- Unakoti Tripura,
Age- 61 years.
…………… Petitioner(s)
Versus
1.
The State of Tripura
To be represented by the Principal Secretary,
Department of Finance, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN- 799010.
2.
The Secretary,
Department of Panchayet, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN-799010.
3.
The Director,
office of the Directorate of Panchayats,
Government of Tripura, Pandit Nehru Complex,
Gurkhabasti, P.O. Kunjaban, West Tripura,
PIN- 799006.
4.
The Block Development Officer,
Kumarghat RD Block, Government of Tripura,
Unakoti District, Tripura,
5.
The Accountant General (A & E),
Tripura, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban, West Tripura,
PIN- 799006.
.………….. Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Ms. A. Debbarma, Advocate
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. SGI
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing
:
08.02.2024.
Date of pronouncement
of Judgment and order :
09.02.2024
Whether fit for reporting:
YES.
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment and Order
Heard Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner. Also heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI for the
respondent Union of India and Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A.
representing the State respondents.
[2]
The present writ petition has been filed under Article 226 and
Article 14 of the Constitution of India for quashing and cancelling the
impugned memorandum dated, 23.08.2023 issued by the Directorate of
Panchayet, Government of Tripura in consequence thereto directing the
respondents to sanction and release regular monthly pension under CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972 alongwith other benefits.
[3]
The case of the petitioner in brief is that the petitioner joined
service on 15.09.1989 by submitting joining report to the BDO,
Kumarghat RD Block, North Tripura District, respondent No.4 temporarily
as Panchayat Extension Officer on ad-hoc basis and on attaining
superannuation, retired on 28.02.2022.
[4]
The Deputy Secretary to the Government of Tripura, GA (P&T)
Department,
vide
memo,
dated
28.04.2003
communicated
to
all
concerned, the decision, taken by the Government that all ad-hoc
appointees were required to be regularized within 31.07.2003 positively.
All Heads of Departments were asked to take necessary steps in this
regard immediately, so that, ad-hoc appointment under the concerned
Department might be regularized within the time frame. Thereafter, BDO,
Kumarghat RD Block, vide letter dated 12.06.2003, communicated to the
Director of Panchayet, Government of Tripura i.e. respondent No.3
seeking necessary action on the part of Director of Panchayet for
regularization of service of the petitioner in terms of the memo dated,
28.04.2003. The petitioner by his applications dated, 17.03.2010,
07.11.2011 & 21.09.2012 appealed to the Director of Panchayet for
regularization of his service stating that since his appointment as PEO on
ad-hoc basis in the year 1989, he has completed 21 years service to the
satisfaction of his authority. The petitioner was allowed benefit of revised
pay structure under ROP Rules, 2015.
[5]
The petitioner by representations dated 20.06.2018, 17.12.2019
approached
to
the
respondent(s)
through
proper
channel
for
regularization of his service and allowing him the benefit of gradation on
completion of 10 years, 17 years & 25 years of continuous and
satisfactory
service
in
the
same
grade
without
promotion.
The
representations of the petitioner were forwarded by the BDO, Kumarghat
RD Block to the concerned respondent vide forwarding letter dated,
21.12.2019. Finally, he was released from service w.e.f. 28.02.2022 on
attaining the age of superannuation.
[6]
The
petitioner
by
his
representation
dated,
06.06.2022,
approached the BDO, Kumarghat RD Block, respondent no.3 herein
seeking pensionary benefits treating him as a regular employee but, the
respondents did not consider the same. Thus, he approached this Court
on earlier occasion by filing WP(C) 570 of 2022 and the same was
disposed of directing the respondents to consider the representation
made by the petitioner in accordance with law. The relevant portion of
the order dated 16.05.2023 passed by this Court in WP (C) 570 of 2022
is quoted herein-under:
“……3. It is seen from the record that vide
representation dated 06.06.2022, the petitioner has
ventilated his grievance before the respondents but the
same is still pending till today. In view of the same,
without expressing any opinion on its merit, this present
writ petition is disposed of with a direction upon the
respondents to consider the representation dated
06.06.2022 submitted by the petitioner herein in
accordance with law. This exercise shall be completed
within a period of 3(three) months from the date of
receipt of the copy of this order.
4.
With the above observation and direction,
this present writ petition stands disposed of. Stay if any
stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any also stands
closed.”
[7]
In pursuance of the said order dated 16.05.2023 passed by this
Court, the respondents passed the impugned memorandum dated
23.08.2023 rejecting the request of the petitioner for releasing his
pensionary
benefits
treating
him
as
a
regular
employee.
The
representation of the petitioner dated 06.06.2022 was rejected on the
ground that his services were not regularized and accordingly, he is not
entitled to any relief he sought for and the said memorandum dated
23.08.2023 was communicated to the petitioner.
[8]
Aggrieved by the said memorandum dated 23.08.2023, the
petitioner has preferred the present writ petition. The State respondents
(Respondents No. 1 to 4). and the respondent No.5 [the Accountant
General (A & E), Tripura, Agartala] have filed their respective counter
affidavits and also submitted documents in support of their case.
[9]
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner
has
contended
that
the
petitioner
was
appointed
on
15.09.1989 temporarily on ad-hoc basis and thereafter, the petitioner
was treated as a regular employee and as per memo dated 16.04.1992,
issued by the Director of Panchayet, Tentative Seniority List of Panchayet
Extension Officer as on 31.03.1992 was published, wherein, the name of
the petitioner figured at serial number-38. The petitioner was also given
the benefit of revised pay in terms of ROP Rules, 2009 and thereafter,
revised structure
under ROP Rules, 2015. During his service, a
disciplinary proceeding was contemplated and under Sub-Rule (1) of Rule
10 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 he was suspended and disciplinary
action was initiated under Rule 16 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. Thereafter,
the suspension order passed by the respondent was revoked with a
warning to the petitioner. Learned counsel has prayed for release of
pensionary benefits of the petitioner treating him as a regular employee
and placed reliance upon the following judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court:
(i) Rudra Kumar Sain and others v. Union of India and
others reported in (2000) 8 SCC 25.
(ii) K. Anbazhagan and another v. Registrar General,
High Court of Madras and another reported in (2018) 9
SCC 293.
[10]
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the petitioner further
submits that petitioner has served for more than 30 years with the
respondent department and as per the order of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in case No. Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.1109/2022 (The
State of Gujarat & others v. Talsibhai Dhanjibhai Patel), an
employee who has retired after rendering service for more than 30 years,
is entitled to all pensionary benefits. He, therefore, urges this Court to
consider the case of the petitioner in the light of the said order of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and to allow the present writ petition setting
aside the impugned memorandum dated 23.08.2023 passed by the
respondent.
[11]
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. representing the State has
argued that the petitioner is not entitled for any benefit as sought for in
the writ petition and prayed to dismiss the same. He has further
contended that the services of the petitioner was only on ad-hoc on
temporary basis and he was not regularized. Since the petitioner was
working for a long period with the other employees in the respondent
department and if without having any proper information about the
seniority, any monetary benefits were extended to the petitioner, it is not
open for the petitioner to take advantage of the same. Learned Addl.
G.A. has placed reliance upon the Notification dated 5th March, 1980
passed by the Government of Tripura in its Appointment & Services
Department, Civil Secretariat in Clause 3 of the same and contended that
the petitioner unless regularized cannot be entitled for any pensionary
benefits since he is not a regular employee.
[12]
Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI appearing for the respondent
No.5 has also contended that unless the petitioner is regularized, he is
not entitled for pensionary benefits as per Rule 13 & 14 of the
CCS
Pension Rules. He has further submitted that the State respondent is the
employer and in the event, if State respondents forward papers,
they
would only act accordingly and they have no reservation to release or to
deny the pensionary benefits to the petitioner as it is in the domain of the
State.
[13]
record.
Heard learned counsel for the respective parties. Perused the
[14]
Admittedly, it is seen from the record that the petitioner
was in service from 15.09.1989 to 28.02.2022 and he made several
representations directly and also through proper channel and thereafter,
seeking regularization of his service. The same were not considered, but,
the petitioner did not challenge before any court of law for the said action
of the respondents seeking regularization.
[15]
The petitioner while in service was found fault by the
respondents in not performing his works as obligated and accordingly
Sub-Rule (1) of Rule 10 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 was invoked and
he was placed under suspension and action was initiated against him
under Rule-16 of CCS (CCA) Rules. Thereafter, upon the representation
made by the petitioner, the respondents have taken a lenient view and
by order dated 3rd December 2007 revoked his suspension and allowed
him to continue in service with a warning to him.
[16]
It is also seen from the record that as per memo dated
16.04.1992, issued by the respondents, Tentative Seniority List of
Panchayet Extension Officer as on 31.03.1992 was prepared and
published, wherein, the name of the petitioner figured at serial number38.
[17]
Insofar as, salary and provident fund is concerned, the
financial statements of the account department have considered him on a
par with the regular employees and accordingly CAS/ACP to the extent is
prepared and the same has been reflected in his service records.
[18]
For the sake of testing the case in the light of the CCS
Pension Rules are concerned, Rule 13 & 14 are extracted as under:
“13. Commencement of qualifying service
Subject to the provisions of these rules, qualifying
service of a Government servant shall commence from the date
he takes charge of the post to which he is first appointed either
substantively or in an officiating or temporary capacity:
Provided that officiating or temporary service is
followed without interruption by substantive appointment in
the same or another service or post:
Provided further that(a) in the case of a Government servant in a Group 'D' service
or post who held a lien or a suspended lien on a permanent
pensionable post prior to the 17th April, 1950, service
rendered before attaining the age of sixteen years shall not
count for any purpose, and
(b) in the case of a Government servant not covered by Clause
(a), service rendered before attaining the age of eighteen
years shall not count, except for compensation gratuity.
[(c) the provisions of Clause (b) shall not be applicable in in
the cases of counting of military service for civil pension under
Rule 19.]
14. Conditions subject to which service qualifies
(1) The service of a Government servant shall not quality
unless his duties and pay are regulated by the Government, or
under conditions determined by the Government.
(2) For the purposes of sub-rule (1), the expression
"Service" means service under the Government and paid by
that Government from the Consolidated Fund of India or a
Local Fund administered by that Government but does not
include service in a non-pensionable establishment unless such
service is treated as qualifying service by that Government.
(3) In the case of a Government servant belonging to a
State Government, who is permanently transferred to a service
or post to which these rules apply, the continuous service
rendered under the State Government in an officiating or
temporary capacity, if any, followed without interruption by
substantive appointment, or the continuous service rendered
under the Government in an officiating or temporary capacity,
as the case may be, shall qualify;
Provided that nothing contained in the sub-rule apply to
any such Government servant who is appointed otherwise than
by deputation to the service or post to which these rules
apply.”
[19]
To test the case of the petitioner whether he was treated as
a regular employee or ad-hoc on temporary basis recruitment, the
invocation of Disciplinary Proceedings placing of the petitioner under
suspension under Sub-Rule (1) of Rule 10 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965
by the respondent authority and action initiated against him under Rule-
16 of CCS (CCA) Rules are to be perused. The said Rules are quoted
hereunder:
Sub-Rule (1) of Rule 10 of the CCS (CCA) Rules:
..”10.
Suspension
(1)
The Appointing Authority or any authority to which it is
subordinate or the Disciplinary Authority or any other authority
empowered in that behalf by the President, by general or
special order, may place a Government servant under
suspension(a)
where a disciplinary
contemplated or is pending; or
proceeding
against
him
is
(aa)
where, in the opinion of the authority aforesaid, he has
engaged himself in activities prejudicial to the interest of the
security of the State; or
(b)
where a case against him in respect of any criminal
offence is under investigation, inquiry or trial:
Provided that, except in case of an order of suspension
made by the Comptroller and Auditor -General in regard to a
member of the Indian Audit and Accounts Service and in
regard to an Assistant Accountant-General or equivalent (other
than a regular member of the Indian Audit and Accounts
Service), where the order of suspension is made by an
authority lower than the Appointing Authority, such authority
shall forthwith report to the Appointing Authority the
circumstances in which the order was made…..”
Rule-16 of CCS (CCA) Rules:
“16. Procedure for imposing minor penalties
(1) Subject to the provisions of sub-rule (5) of rule 15, no
order imposing on a Government servant any of the penalties
specified in clause (i) to (iv) of rule 11 shall be made except
after(a) informing the Government servant in writing of the
proposal to take action against him and of the imputations of
misconduct or misbehaviour on which it is proposed to be
taken, and giving him reasonable opportunity of making such
representation as he may wish to make against the proposal;
(b) holding an inquiry in the manner laid down in sub-rules (3)
to (24) of rule 14, in every case in which the disciplinary
authority is of the opinion that such inquiry is necessary;
(c) taking the representation, if any, submitted by the
Government servant under clause (a) and the record of inquiry,
if any, held under clause (b) into consideration;
(d) consulting the Commission where such consultation is
necessary. The Disciplinary Authority shall forward or cause to
be forwarded a copy of the advice of the Commission to the
Government servant, who shall be required to submit, if he so
desires, his written representation or submission on the advice
of the Commission, to the Disciplinary Authority within fifteen
days; and
(e) recording a finding on each imputation or misconduct or
misbehavior.
(1-A) Notwithstanding anything contained in clause (b) of subrule (1), if in a case it is proposed after considering the
representation, if any, made by the Government servant under
clause (a) of that sub-rule, to withhold increments of pay and
such withholding of increments is likely to affect adversely the
amount of pension payable to the Government servant or to
withhold increments of pay for a period exceeding three years
or to withhold increments of pay with cumulative effect for any
period, an inquiry shall be held in the manner laid down in subrules (3) to (24) of Rule 14, before making any order imposing
on the Government servant any such penalty.
(2) The record of the proceedings in such cases shall include(i) a copy of the intimation to the Government servant of the
proposal to take action against him;
(ii) a copy of the statement of imputations of misconduct or
misbehavior delivered to him;
(iii) his representation, if any;
(iv) the evidence produced during the inquiry;
(v) the advice of the Commission, if any;
[(vi) representation, if any, of the Government servant on the
advice of the Commission;
(vii) the findings
misbehavior; and
on
each
imputation
of
misconduct
or
(viii) the orders on the case together with the reasons
therefor.]”
[20]
The reliance placed by the Addl. G.A. on Notification dated
5th March, 1980 passed by the Government of Tripura in its Appointment
& Services Department, Civil Secretariat in Clause 3, is quoted below:
“ ……3. for rule 3 of the principal rules the following shall
be substituted namely:Substitution of rule 3.
(3) A Government servant who has completed three
years continuous regular service satisfactorily shall
be deemed to be in quasi-permanent service.
Note:- For the purpose of this Rule, „regular service‟ shall mean
service in a pensionable post having prescribed scales of pay
and the post is sanctioned by the competent authority of the
Govt. but shall not include ad-hoc appointments….”.
[21]
For the purpose of reference, the relevant paragraphs from
the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rudra Kumar Sain and
others v. Union of India and others reported in (2000) 8 SCC 25 are
extracted below:
“16. The three terms ad hoc, stop gap and fortuitous are in
frequent use in service jurisprudence. In the absence of
definition of these terms in the rules in question we have to
look to the dictionary meaning of the words and the meaning
commonly assigned to them in service matters. The meaning
given to the expression fortuitous in Strouds Judicial
Dictionary is accident or fortuitous casualty. This should
obviously connote that if an appointment is made accidentally,
because of a particular emergent situation and such
appointment obviously would not continue for a fairly long
period. But an appointment made either under Rule 16 or 17 of
the Recruitment Rules, after due consultation with the High
Court and the appointee possesses the prescribed qualification
for such appointment provided in Rule 7 and continues as such
for a fairly long period, then the same cannot be held to
fortuitous. In Blacks Law dictionary, the expression fortuitous
means occurring by chance, a fortuitous event may be highly
unfortunate. It thus, indicates that it occurs only by chance or
accident, which could not have been reasonably foreseen. The
expression ad hoc in Blacks Law Dictionary, means something
which is formed for a particular purpose. The expression stopgap as per Oxford Dictionary, means a temporary way of
dealing with a problem or satisfying a need.
17. In Oxford Dictionary, the word ad hoc means for a
particular purpose; specially. In the same Dictionary, the word
fortuitous means happening by accident or chance rather than
design.
18. In P. Ramanatha Aiyers Law Lexicon (2nd Edition) the
word ad hoc is described as for particular purpose, Made,
established, acting or concerned with a particular and or
purpose. The meaning of word fortuitous event is given as an
event which happens by a cause which we cannot resist; one
which is unforeseen and caused by superior force, which it is
impossible to resist; a term synonymous with Act of God.
19. The meaning to be assigned to these terms while
interpreting provisions of a Service Rule will depend on the
provisions of that Rule and the context in and the purpose for
which the expressions are used. The meaning of any of these
terms in the context of computation of inter-se seniority of
officers holding cadre post will depend on the facts and
circumstances in which the appointment came to be made. For
that purpose it will be necessary to look into the purpose for
which the post was created and the nature of the appointment
of the officer as stated in the appointment order. If the
appointment order itself indicates that the post is created to
meet a particular temporary contingency and for a period
specified in the order, then the appointment to such a post can
be aptly described as ad hoc or stop-gap. If a post is created to
meet a situation which has suddenly arisen on account of
happening of some event of a temporary nature then the
appointment of such a post can aptly be described as fortuitous
in nature. If an appointment is made to meet the contingency
arising on account of delay in completing the process of
regular recruitment to the post due to any reason and it is not
possible to leave the post vacant till then, and to meet this
contingency an appointment is made then it can appropriately
be called as a stop-gap arrangement and appointment in the
post as ad hoc appointment. It is not possible to lay down any
straight-jacket formula nor give an exhaustive list of
circumstances and situation in which such an appointment (ad
hoc, fortuitous or stop-gap) can be made. As such, this
discussion is not intended to enumerate the circumstances or
situations in which appointments of officers can be said to
come within the scope of any of these terms. It is only to
indicate how the matter should be approached while dealing
with the question of inter se seniority of officers in the cadre.
20. In Service Jurisprudence, a person who possesses the
requisite qualification for being appointed to a particular post
and then he is appointed with the approval and consultation of
the appropriate authority and continues in the post for a fairly
long period, then such appointment cannot be held to be stopgap or fortuitous or purely ad hoc. In this view of the matter,
the reasoning and basis on which, the appointment of the
promotees in the Delhi Higher Judicial Service in the case in
hand was held by the High Court to be fortuitous/ad hoc/stopgap are wholly erroneous and, therefore, exclusion of those
appointees to have their continuous length of service for
seniority is erroneous.”
[22]
For examining the present case, the relevant paragraphs
from the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court passed in K.
Anbazhagan and another v. Registrar General, High Court of
Madras and another reported in (2018) 9 SCC 293 are extracted
below:
“62. Now
we come to the entitlement of gratuity by
the appellants. The definition of pension as given under Rule
3(1)(m) provides as follows:
“3.(1) (m) „pension‟ includes gratuity except when the
pension
is
used
in
contradistinction
gratuity but does not include dearness allowance.”
term
to
63. When
the
appellants
are
entitled
for
grant
of
pension, they are obviously entitled for grant of gratuity. Rule
45 of the 1978
Rules
provided
that
a
Government
servant, who has completed five years‟ qualifying service
and
has
become eligible for service gratuity or pension
under Rule 43, shall be granted gratuity. Rule 45 sub-rule
(1)(a) is as follows:
“45. Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity.-(1)(a) A government
servant, who has completed five years‟ qualifying
service
and has become eligible for service gratuity or pension
under rule 43, shall, on his retirement be granted death-cumretirement gratuity as in the table below for each completed
six monthly period of qualifying service, subject to a maximum
of fifteen times the emoluments….”,.
64. We, thus, are of the view that appellants are
also entitled for gratuity which may be computed in
accordance with 1978 Rules."
[23]
In the light of the above, admittedly, the petitioner served
around 30 years i.e. from 15.09.1989 to 28.02.2022 with the respondent
organization in the Panchayet department and he made repeated
requests to the respondents directly and also through proper channel
during his service requesting them to consider his case for regularization
of his services as he has completed more than 10 years without any gap.
The respondents during the tenure of the petitioner, initiated the
disciplinary proceedings as they were treating his services as regular
employee and placed him under suspension and thereafter conducted an
enquiry and subsequently, the same was revoked. The seniority list has
also been prepared where the name of the petitioner was reflected and
thereafter, also objections were called for. The change in his salary and
the other benefits were also reflected on record as the petitioner is a
regular employee.
[24]
Though it is a settled principle of law that if a citizen is not
entitled for a lawful benefit, he cannot have a legally enforceable claim
and cannot enrich himself to which he is not entitled to. But, here is a
case where the petitioner is all through making the request to consider
his case for regularization and the respondents were not acted upon and
allowed him to work for 30 years and obtained his services and all their
actions towards the petitioner was treating him as a regular employee.
[25]
Though there is no express order of regularization of
services of the petitioner, the expressed and implied actions of the
respondents towards the petitioner need to be treated as if the petitioner
is a regular employee.
[26]
For the laches of the respondents in not acted upon to
regularize the petitioner and allowing him to retire from services, when
the petitioner raised his voice for pensionary benefits, respondents
declined the request of the petitioner on the ground that his services
were not regularized and have no weightage, as the petitioner is not at
fault but it is the inaction of the respondents for sleeping over the matter
all through. Recently, Hon’ble Supreme Court in case No. Special Leave
to Appeal (C) No.1109/2022 (The State of Gujarat & others v.
Talsibhai Dhanjibhai Patel) affirming the order of the Hon’ble High
Court of Gujarat has held that after rendering service for 30 years, an
employee cannot be deprived of his pension. For the purpose of
reference, the said order of the Hon’ble Apex Court is quoted hereinunder:
“O R D E R
It is unfortunate that the State continued to take the
services of the respondent as an ad-hoc for 30 years and
thereafter now to contend that as the services rendered
by the respondent are ad-hoc, he is not entitled to
pension/pensionary benefit. The State cannot be
permitted to take the benefit of its own wrong. To take
the Services continuously for 30 years and thereafter to
contend that an employee who has rendered 30 years
continues service shall not be eligible for pension is
nothing but unreasonable. As a welfare State, the State
as such ought not to have taken such a stand.
In the present case, the High Court has not committed
any error in directing the State to pay pensionary benefits
to the respondent who has retired after rendering more
than 30 years service.
Hence, the Special Leave Petition stands dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed
of."
[27]
In view of the above discussion and the observation as cited
(supra), this Court has no hesitation to say that the petitioner is entitled
for pensionary benefits and accordingly the impugned memorandum
dated 23rd August, 2023 passed by the respondent is set aside. The
petitioner is permitted to approach the respondent(s) and file all his
relevant
documents
seeking
pensionary
benefits.
The
respondents
concerned shall take steps for releasing the pensionary benefits in
accordance with law treating the petitioner’s service as a regular
employee within a period of 4(four) months from the date of receipt of
the such relevant documents from the petitioner.
In view of the above, the present writ petition is allowed and the
same is accordingly disposed of.
As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall
also stand closed.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi G.
SABYASACHI
GHOSH
SABYASACHI GHOSH
Date: 2024.02.12 16:36:34
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review