Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.02.28
TELEN KOM Date:
16:56:53 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.753 of 2022
Shri David Purum, aged 49 years, S/o (L) Sh. Athang Purum, permanent
resident of Purum Khullen Village, PO-Pangei, PS Sagolmang, Kangpokpi
District, Manipur-795129.
…Petitioner
– Versus –
1. The State of Manipur, represented by the Addl. Chief Secretary(Forest),
New Secretariat, Babubara, Manipur-795001.
2. The Principal Chief Conservator of Forests & HoFF, Govt. of Manipur,
Sajenthong, Imphal, Manipur-795005.
3. The Chief Conservator of Forests, TP-I, Government of Manipur,
Sajenthong, Imphal, Manipur-795005.
4. The Conservator of Forests, Central Forest Circle, Govt. of Manipur,
Sajenthong, Imphal, Manipur-795005.
5. The
Divisional
Forest
Officer(DFO),
Central
Forest
Division,
Government of Manipur, PO Mantripukhri, P.S. Heingang, Imphal East,
Manipur-795002.
6. The DFO, Kangpokpi, PO & PS – Kangpokpi Hq, Kangpokpi District795129.
7. The Deputy Secretary(Revenue), Bapubara, Old Secretariat, South
Block, Imphal-795001.
8. The
Deputy
Secretary,
HAC,
Manipur
Legislative
Assembly,
Chingmeirong, Imphal, Manipur-795004.
9. The Addl. Chief Secretary(TA&Hills), Old Secretariat, Babubara,
Imphal, Manipur-795001.
10. The Deputy Commissioner, Kangpokpi, PO & PS- Kangpokpi, Hq,
Kangpokpi District-795129.
…Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
:
Ms. H. Bisheshwari, Adv.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned AG.
Date of reserved.
:
08.02.2023
Date of Judgment & Order :
27.02.2023.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner to quash the impugned
letter dated 13.11.2020 and to uphold the order of SDM/Sadar Hills, dated
18.6.1971 passed in Misc. Case No.23/71.
2. Brief facts are as follows:
Purum Khullen village was established since the time of their forefathers
and in 1612, during the period of Maharaja Khagemba, the settlement of Purum
Khullen village was declared and recorded on stone tablet. Again, in 1723 during
the period of Maharaja Pamheiba, the settlement of Purum Khullen village was
also recorded on stone tablet during the tenure of Telheiba, the then Chief of
Purum Khullen and again in 1748. The villagers have been paying their hill
house tax through the Deputy Commissioner even before the establishment of
the State and subsequently under the Manipur Hill Areas (House Tax) Act, 1966
without any break till date for the land they use.
3. Purum Khullen village was recognized under the Manipur State Hill
Peoples (Administration) Regulation, 1947 and subsequently, by the State
Government and the village constituted their own Village Authorities under the
Manipur (Village Authorities in Hill Areas) Act, 1956. Purum Khullen village has
its own distinct and independent boundaries as the title is perfected and it has
two colonies, namely Happy Valley towards the north, P. Gelyang towards the
south and Purum Khullen in the middle and the aforesaid two colonies were form
within the land of Purum Khullen village since 1969.The Court of SDM/Sadar
Hills, by an order dated 18.6.1971 in Misc. Case No.23/71, recognized the
settlement land area of Purum Khullen demarcated and issued a Map in
recognition of the said land.
4. In continuation of the State’s developmental project, construction for
Manipur International University at Purum Khullen has been underway. As such,
on 17.11.2020, the villagers employed workers for leveling of land. However,
some officials alleged to be from DFO, Central Range, Mantripukhri, intervened
and forcefully stopped the ongoing construction work saying that the said land is
situated within Sambei Purum Reserve Forest and not to continue any activity
without their permission. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner submitted a
representation to the Hon’ble Minister (Forest) on 24.10.2020 for upholding the
order passed by the SDM/Sadar dated 18.6.1971. However, surprisingly, the
Chief Conservator showed the impugned letter dated 13.11.2020 with Map
cancelling the order passed by the SDM/Sadar dated 18.6.1971. Challenging
the order dated 13.11.2020, the petitioner has filed the writ petition.
5. The fifth respondent raising preliminary objection as to the
maintainability of the writ petition has filed affidavit-in-opposition stating that
Sambei Purum Reserved Forest came into effect in the year 1936 after a
resolution of the Manipur State Darbar being Resolution No.4(A) dated
7.10.1936. The said Darbar Resolution spelt out clearly the boundary of Sambei
Purum Reserved Forest. Since 7.10.1936, Sambei Purum Hill Range has been
a full-fledged Reserved Forest owned by the then Princely State of Manipur
under British Rule. Later, after Manipur was merged into the Union of India, the
Reserved Forest has been legally protected under the Indian Forest Act, 1927
through the Manipur Administration Order, 1949, the Merged States (Laws) Act,
1949 and the Part C State’s Act, 1950. Now, the Sembei Purum Reserved
Forest is under the control and regulations of the Forest Department,
Government of Manipur. Purum Khullen village is made in the Darbar Resolution
No.4(A) dated 7.10.1936 on one hand and on the other, Purum Khullen is a very
old village which came into being during the olden Kings time.
6. It is stated that no mention is made of Purum Khullen village in the
Darbar Resolution, which confirms that Puurum Khullen village is outside the
boundary limit of the Sambei Purum Reserved Forest. Present day, Purum
Khullen village barring few households in the nearby hills is situated at the
foothills away from the boundary of the Sambei Purum Reserved Forest. The
area presently occupied by the main Purum Khullen village is covered by the
cadastral survey map of 1960.
7. It is stated that the order of the SDM, Sadar Hills dated 18.6.1971
passed in Misc. Case No.23/71 recognizing settlement land area of Purum
Khullen within the Sambei Purum Reserved Forest is unfortunate if it were done
so. The subsequent map prepared by the Sub Deputy Collector, Saikul from the
description of boundary by the SDM in his order dated 18.6.1971 shall cease to
stand as it violates the provisions of the Indian Forest Act, 1927.
8. It is stated that the attempt to construct and establish the Manipur
International University within the Sambei Purum Reserved Forest near Purum
Khullen is clearly in violation of Section 26 of the Indian Forest Act, 1927. The
Chief of Purum Khullen village, in deliberate disobedience, started excavating
huge amount of hill earth by felling the slope of the hills and removing the hill
earth without authority and violating Section 26 of the Act.
9. It is stated that there are few households of Purum Khullen village in
the Reserved Forest Area near the site where the Chief had tried to construct
and establish the Manipur International University. The vesting rights of the
households shall be only after the fulfillment of the provisions of the Act and the
villagers residing within the Reserved Forest should apply in the prescribed
methods as given in the Indian Forest Act. Hence, it is prayed for dismissal of
the writ petition.
10. Assailing the impugned letter, the learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the petitioner who is the Chief of Purum Khullen village has
established and occupied the land in question since the time of his forefathers
till date without any interference and the village has its own distinct and
independent boundaries.
He would submit that at present the housing
settlement of Purum Khullen village is described north by Sagolmang
Lingpikhong and Lok; south by Geijang Khongjaiching; east by Iril river and west
by Purum Khuman Chingsang. As such the villagers are the absolute land
owners of the land in question, as it has been inherited from their forefathers and
has been settling upon the said land peacefully.
11. The learned counsel further submitted that the villagers have been
paying hill house tax even before establishment of the State and after becoming
State, they are paying tax under the Manipur Hill Areas (House Tax) Act, 1966
to the State through the Chief/Headman without any break till date for the land
they use. The villagers have been enjoying the products of the land by way of
planting paddy fields, growing seasonal crops openly without any interference
from any quarter.
12. The learned counsel then submitted that during the administration in
the Union Territory of Manipur, the Chief Commissioner, Manipur bifurcated the
territory of Manipur into Districts and Administrative Units on 12.11.1969. As
such, the village of Purum Khullen was included as Serial No.40 of the Sadar
Hills Sub-Division, Manipur North District. He would submit that in the Court of
SDM/Sadar Hills, an order dated 18.6.1971 was passed in Misc. Case No.23 of
1971 recognizing the settlement land area of Purum Khullen thereby
demarcating the land and issued map in recognition of the said land.
13. The leaned counsel next submitted that with the support of the State
Government,
the
village
authorities
have
also
undertaken
different
developmental projects in the village such as Government Primary Schools,
Anganwadi Centres, Water Supply Scheme, Plantation of Trees etc. In
continuation of the State’s developmental project, the construction for Manipur
International University at Purum Khullen has been underway and, as such, on
17.9.2020, the villagers employed workers for levelling of land. However, the
officials alleged to be from DFO, Central Range, Mantripukhri intervened and
forcefully stopped the ongoing construction work saying that the said land is
situated within Sambei Purum Reserve Forest and not to continue any activity
without their permission.
14. The learned counsel further submitted that when the petitioner went
to the Forest Office to enquire about the matter, the Chief Conservator showed
the impugned letter dated 13.11.2020 addressed to the Principal Chief
Conservator of Forests & HoFF with regard to cancellation of the order dated
18.6.1971 passed by the SDM/Sadar.
Aggrieved by the said letter dated
13.11.2020, the petitioner submitted a representation on 5.4.2021 to the DFO,
Central Forest Division for cancellation of the impugned letter. However, no
action was taken till date.
15. The learned counsel urged that the villagers have been settled since
the time of forefathers and depended on the forest products for their daily
livelihood and, as usual, on 12.6.2022, when some of the villagers were cutting
the firewood for their daily consumption, the officials from RO, Pangei came over
and stopped the villagers from such activity and, thereafter, also some officials
entered the village without any prior notice and stopped the villagers from taking
up any activity accusing the villagers stating that they are residing within Sambei
Reserve Forest and threatened with dire consequences.
16. The learned counsel for the petitioner contended that with respect to
the creation of Sambei Purum Reserved Forest, no letter specifying land area or
land schedule was issued to the petitioner or his forefathers with respect to
declaring the land of the petitioner as Reserved Forest which is in clear violation
of Sections 4 and 6 of the Indian Forest Act, 1927. The act of the respondents
has caused apprehension to the villagers that they might be evicted anytime from
the land they are presently residing without due process of law. Hence, the
petitioner
has
been
advised
to
file
the
present
writ
petition.
17. Raising a preliminary objection as to the maintainability of the writ
petition, the learned Advocate General submitted that Sembei Purum Reserved
Forest came into existence in the year 1936 after a resolution of the Manipur
State Darbar being Resolution No.4(A) dated 7.10.1936.
The said Darbar
resolution clearly shows the boundary of Sembei Purum Reserved Forest and
since 7.10.1936, Sambei Purum Hill Range has been a full-fledged Reserved
Forest owned by the then Princely State of Manipur under the British Rule. He
would submit that after Manipur was merged into the Union of India, the
Reserved Forest has been legally protected under the Indian Forest Act, 1927
and no mention of the Purum Khullen village is made in the Darbar Resolution
No.4(A) dated 7.10.1936.
18. The learned Advocate General further submitted that Purum Khullen
village, barring few households in the nearby hills, is situated at the foothills away
from the boundary of Sambei Purum Reserved Forest and the area currently
occupied by the main Purum Khullen village is covered by the cadastral survey
map of 1960. In fact, the land of Purum Khullen village claimed by the petitioner
corresponds the Reserved Forest area covered by Compartment No.1 and 3 of
the Sambei Purum Reserved Forest.
19. The learned Advocate General urged that the attempt to construct the
Manipur International University within the Sambei Purum Reserved Forest near
Purum Khullen is clear violation of Section 26 of the Indian Forest Act, 1927,
Section 2 of the Forest Conservation Act, 1980 and also the decisions of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court as well as this Court in PIL No.25 of 2017. Arguing so,
the learned Advocate General submitted that the writ petition is not maintainable
and the same is liable to be dismissed.
20. In reply, the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
question of non-maintainability of the writ petition as preliminary objection does
not arise, in view of the fact that on the strength of the impugned letter, the
Conservator of Forest or its officials has no power to stop the ongoing
construction work alleging that the land in question is situated within the Sambei
Purum Reserve Forest. In fact, Purum Khullen does not fall within the Sambei
Purum Reserve Forest. Further, the villagers are not residing within the Purum
Reserved Forest area alleged by the respondents. In fact, the Purum Khullen
village has its own boundaries as per the Darbar Resolution No.4(A) dated
7.10.1936 and, as such, there is no violation of Section 26 of the Act.
21. This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused the
materials available on record.
22. The grievance of the petitioner is that Purum Khullen village was
established since the time of their forefathers and the village was also recognized
under the Manipur State Hill Peoples (Administration) Regulation, 1947 and
subsequently by the State Government. The village constituted their own Village
Authorities under the Manipur (Village Authorities in Hill Areas) Act, 1956 and
the Purum Khullen village has its own distinct and independent boundaries and
the title is perfected.
In fact, in the Court of SDM/Sadar Hills, an order dated
18.6.1971 was passed in Misc. Case No.23 of 1971 recognizing the settlement
land area of Purum Khullen demarcated under the Land Schedule B and issued
a map in recognition of the said land. Therefore, the forest officials have no right
to prevent the villagers from doing the developmental project at Purum Khullen.
23. The petitioner challenged the impugned letter dated 13.11.2020
stating that the Conservator of Forest, Central Forest Circle, Government of
Manipur has no authority to cancel the order dated 18.6.1971 and maps issued
by the SDM. It would be appropriate to quote the impugned letter for ready
reference:
“I have to honor to forward herewith letter No.4/11/2020-21/DFO/CFD
dt. 16.10.2020 of the DFO, Central Division on the above subject
requesting for cancellation of order dated 18.06.1971 and maps
issued by the SDM/SDC, Sadar Hills, Saikul allotting/demarcating
land in Sambei Purum RF in favour of the Chief of Purum Khullen
village.
The Sambei Purum Reserved Forest was notified as a reserved
forest vide Darbar Resolution No.4(A) dated 07.10.1936 of the then
President of Manipur State Darbar and the said resolution was also
published vide Notice No.23 dt. 25.03.1937 of the Forest Member,
Manipur State Darbar. Copy of the Darbar Resolution dt. 07.10.1937
and Notice dt. 25.03.1937 are also enclosed for ready reference.
The SDM/SDC, Saikul has no authority to issue such order and maps
within the reserved forest land and the same is in gross violation of
the provision of Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980,
Section 20 and 26 of the Indian Forest Act, 1927 and Hon’ble
Supreme Court Order dated 12.12.1996 in WP(C) 202 of 1995. The
said order is also null and void in view of the state Government’s
standing order No.55/12/8-For dt. 31.05.1994.
It is, therefore, requested to cancel the order dated 18.06.1971 and
maps issued by the SDC/SDM as the same violates Act, Rules and
Hon’ble Supreme Court order and also to avoid legal complicacies.”
24. The petitioner claims right over the land in question based on the order
dated 18.6.1971 passed in Misc. Case No.23/1971 by the SDM/Sadar Hills,
Saikul. The respondents claim that the land claimed by the petitioner relates to
Reserved Forest area covered by Compartment No.1 and 3 of Sambei Purum
Reserved Forest and Sambei Purum Reserved Forest came into effect in the
year 1936 after a resolution of the Manipur State Darbar being Resolution
No.4(A) dated 07.10.1936.
25. Prima facie, there appears to be dispute qua right over the land in
question between the parties. As stated supra, the petitioner claims right over
the land in question based on the order dated 18.6.1971 passed in Misc. Case
No.23 of 1971. On the other hand, the respondents claim that the land in
question is a Reserved Forest. Nothing has been produced by the petitioner to
establish that Purum Khullen village is outside the boundary limits of Sambei
Purum Reserved Forest. When the petitioner claims that Purum Khullen village
is not coming under the Reserved Forest, it is his bounden duty to prove the
same and the onus is heavily on the petitioner.
Admittedly, there are no
documents to substantiate the case of the petitioner.
26. The learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the fact regarding
existence of Purum Khullen village within the existing boundary for over four
centuries had been deliberately overlooked and some regulations which were
introduced in the 20th Centuries are being applied and they can in no way apply
the Purum Khullen village.
Further submission of the learned counsel for the
petitioner is that Sambei is a settlement which came up a century ago i.e. about
300 years after Purum Khullen was established and the so called Reserved
Forest, namely Sambei Purum Forest after the settlement. Since the village had
existed much earlier, the name itself is derived from this village.
27. Though the petitioner contended that all the forests in the hill areas
are unclassed forests owned by village communities and held in the name of
Chief or Khullakpa and that is the reason why MLR Act could not apply to hill
areas, nothing has been produced by the petitioner to prove the said contention.
28. The existence of order dated 18.6.1971 passed by the SDM/SDC,
Sadar Hills has not been disputed by the respondents. The learned Advocate
General contended that when Sambei Purum Reserved Forest was notified as a
Reserved Forest vide Darbar Resolution No.4(A) on 7.10.1936 of the then
President of Manipur State Darbar and the said resolution was also published
vide Notice No.23 dated 25.3.1937, the SDM has no authority to issue the order
dated 18.6.1971 within the Reserved Forest area. This Court finds some force
in the submission made by learned Advocate General.
29. The provisions of the Indian Forest Act, 1927 clearly provides that dereservation of any portion or whole of a Reserved Forest shall be possible only
through a decision of the State Government and not by any other authority.
Section 27 of the Act was valid upto 15.10.1980 and thereafter, the power to dereserve a portion or whole of a Reserved Forest shall lie with the Central
Government under Section 2 of the Forest Conservation Act, 1980. In view of
the above, the SDM did not enjoy the power to issue such order to give away
portion of Sambei Purum Reserved Forest to Purum Khullen village.
30. The petitioner claims that the villagers are the absolute land owners
of the land in question, as it has been inherited from their forefathers and has
been settling upon the said land peacefully. The respondents denied the claim
made by the petitioner by stating that the land in question is Reserved Forest
land. Since disputed question of fact involved, exercising jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, such disputed question cannot be decided
in this writ petition.
31. On a reading of the averments set out in the writ petition, this Court
finds that though the petitioner is the Chief of Purum Khullen village, he has not
filed the instant writ petition under representative capacity. There is no whisper
about the filing of the present writ petition for himself and on behalf of the villagers
of Purum Khullen.
32. The way in which the instant writ petition filed by the petitioner is not
maintainable. Since the villagers of Purum Khullen are tribals, their life has been
interconnected with the land and forest. That apart, tribal and their forest are
inseparable and the social custom of tribals is guaranteed under the Constitution
of India in respect of their possession upon the land and forest in question. When
the aforesaid is the position, this Court in a writ petition cannot decide and
declare the rights of the villagers of Purum Khullen over the land in question in
their favour.
It is the appropriate Government to decide taking note of the
existing law and the ground situation. It is also the duty of the Government to
safeguard the tribals who are living in the Forest land or nearby the Forest land.
The Government ought to ensure right to life enshrined under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India and also the peaceful co-existence of the poor villagers who
are settling since time immemorial not to be disturbed, as the villagers/tribals are
history of the State.
33. For all the reasons stated above,
(a) The writ petition is not maintainable and, accordingly, the
same is dismissed.
(b) However, liberty is given to the villagers of Purum Khullen to
work
out
their
remedy
before
the
competent
authority/government for redressal of their grievance either for
compensation or alternative place.
(c) On receipt of any representation from the villagers, the
respondents are directed to consider the same sympathetically
and pass appropriate speaking order.
(d) There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review