Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE GURPAL SINGH AHLUWALIA
ON THE 17th OF JANUARY, 2023
SECOND APPEAL No. 1326 of 2022
BETWEEN:1.
DARASINGH S/O LATE PANCHAM SINGH
RAGHUVANSHI, AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: NIL DISTRICT CHHINDWARA M.P.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
RAJKUMAR S/O LATE PANCHAM SINGH, AGED
ABOUT 36 YEARS, R/O VILLAGE GRETIA TAHSIL
CHOURAI, DISTRICT CHHINDWARACHOURAI
DISTRICT
CHHINDWARA(DEAD)
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
3.
RAJU S/O LATE PANCHAM SINGH, AGED ABOUT
YEARS, R/O VILLAGE GRETIA TAHSIL
CHOURAI, DISTRICT CHHINDWARACHOURAI
DISTRICT
CHHINDWARA(DEAD)
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
4.
ROOPWATI BAI W/O LATE PANCHAM SINGH,
AGED ABOUT 86 YEARS, R/O VILLAGE GRETIA
TAHSIL
CHOURAI,
DISTRICT
CHHINDWARACHOURAI
DISTRICT
CHHINDWARA(DEAD) (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI MUKESH KUMAR AGARWAL - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
SMT. SHIVKUMARI BAI DEAD THROUGH LRS
SMT.
DAYA RAGHUVANSHI
W/O ASHOK
RAGHUVANSHI, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: NIL R/O VILLAGE GRETIA TAHSIL
CHOURAI, DISTRICT CHHINDWARACHOURAI
DISTRICT
CHHINDWARA(DEAD)
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
SHIVPRASAD
RAGHUVANSHI
S/O
SHRI
PARASRAM RAGHUVANSHI, AGED ABOUT 37
YEAR S, R/O WARD NO. 10 OLD BAIEL BAZAR
BESIDE DUBEY LODGE NEAR SAI MANDIR
CHHINDWARA TESHIL CHOURAI DISTRICT
CHHINDWARA (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
NARESH RAGHUVANSHI S/O SHRI PARASRAM
RAGHUVANSHI, AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS, R/O
WARD NO. 10 OLD BAIEL BAZAR BESIDE DUBEY
LODGE NEAR SAI MANDIR CHHINDWARA
TESHIL CHOURAI DISTRICT CHHINDWARA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
KU. GEETA RAGHUVANSHI D/O SHRI PARASRAM
RAGHUVANSHI, AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS, R/O
WARD NO. 10 OLD BAIEL BAZAR BESIDE DUBEY
LODGE NEAR SAI MANDIR CHHINDWARA
TESHIL CHOURAI DISTRICT CHHINDWARA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
THE STATE OF M.P THROUGH THE COLLECTOR
DISTRICT CHHINDWARA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(RESPONDENT NO.1 BY SHRI YASH NITIN NASERY - ADVOCATE)
(RESPONDENT NO.5/STATE BY MS.PAPIYA GHOSE - PANEL LAWYER)
This appeal coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
JUDGMENT
1.
This appeal under Section 100 CPC has been filed against the
judgment and decree dated 03/03/2022 passed by District Judge, Chourai,
District Chhindwara in RCA No.19/2020 and 20/2020 arising out of judgment
and decree dated 30/08/2019 passed by Civil Judge, Senior Division, Chourai,
District Chhindwara in Civil Suit No.400120/2016.
2.
According to the plaintiffs/ respondents, the property in dispute is
khasra No.266/4, 267/4 and 268/4 area 2.091 hectares situated in Village
Grethiya. The said property was purchased by the husband of the plaintiff from
his salary on 25/05/1981. The husband of the plaintiff was posted as Constable
in ASF Battalion. Thereafter, he was deputed in GRP department and during his
service period, he was posted in different cities like Indore, Bhopal, Gwalior,
Itarsi etc. Thereafter, in the year 2005, he was posted in Civil District Police
Force and he retired on 21/07/2012. After his retirement, he is residing in
Chourai in his own house. Since her husband was in Government job, therefore
he was not in a position to regularly cultivate the land and accordingly, the
plaintiff authorized her father Pancham Singh and brothers to look after his land
as well as to cultivate the same. Father of the plaintiff had assured that after the
retirement of her husband, the land would be returned back. After the death of
her father, her brothers are cultivating the land in dispute. In the year 2013, when
the plaintiff came to cultivate the land, then defendants picked up quarrel with
her and objected to the cultivation of the land by the plaintiff. On a report
lodged by the plaintiff, a criminal case is also pending before the Court against
the respondents. Earlier, the plaintiff had filed a suit for declaration of title and
for her share in the property belonging to her father as well as the property
purchased by her father out of the income of joint Hindu family property, which
was registered as CS No.82-A/2013 and the same was dismissed. An appeal is
pending against the said judgment. It was further pleaded that the defendants are
not giving the possession of the land in dispute to the plaintiff which was
purchased by her husband in her name and accordingly the suit was filed.
3.
Defendants No.1 to 4 filed their written statement and claimed that
Pancham Singh had purchased the land in dispute from the income of the
ancestral property for a consideration of Rs.18,000/-. The said land was
purchased in the name of defendant No.3 during his minority. The plaintiff had
not contributed any consideration amount for the purchase of the land in
dispute and Pancham Singh was placed in possession from the date of
purchase. Since there was a ban on the sale of land, therefore, Pancham Singh
could not execute the sale deed in favour of the defendant No.3 and the name
of the plaintiff remained in the revenue records but the actual possession and
ownership was with Pancham Singh. The said land was purchased out of the
income from the joint Hindu family property. Pancham Singh expired without
executing any Will and accordingly, after the death of Pancham Singh, the
defendants No.1 and 2 have succeeded the property in accordance with the
Hindu Succession Act. Accordingly, defendants also filed a counter-claim for
declaration of their title as well as that they have perfected their title by way of
adverse possession as they are in possession from 16/05/1981.
4.
The Trial Court by judgment dated 30/08/2019 decreed the suit
filed by plaintiff/ respondent No.1 and dismissed the counter claim filed by the
appellants/ defendants.
5.
Being aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed by the Trial
Court, the appellants filed two civil appeals, i.e. C.A.No.19/2020 and 20/2020
against the judgment and decree passed against them and against the dismissal
of their counter claim on the ground that the appellants had perfected their title
by way of adverse possession. The appeals filed by the appellants have been
dismissed by the appellate court, therefore, this appeal has been filed on the
following proposed substantial questions of law:"A: Whether the learned lower Appellate Court was gravely
and substantially erred in confirming the Judgment and
Decree of the learned trial Court, being unreasonable,
perverse and based upon wrong conclusions without
appreciation of law of evidence?
B: Whether the learned Lower Courts below are legally
justified in holding that the plaintiff has the right to recover
the possession without proving Title and ownership-rights
over the disputed land?
C: Whether the learned Courts below have erred in law in
placing the burden of prove upon the defendants FOR
proving that the property is not the self-earned by the
plaintiff?
D: Whether the impugned Judgment and Decree of the
learned Courts below are legally sustainable as are not based
upon cogent findings because the conclusion drawn on
conjectures, surmises and inferences?
E: Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case the
learned lower appellate Court is justified in confirming the
findings ignoring the provisions of Section 102 of the
Evidence Act?"
6.
It is submitted by the counsel for the appellants that the suit
simplicitor for possession without seeking declaration of title is not maintainable
specifically when the title of the plaintiff was disputed by the appellants. The
defendants/ appellants in their written statement had admitted that the name of
the plaintiff was mutated in the revenue record. They have also admitted that the
sale deed was executed in the name of the plaintiff. On the contrary, it was their
contention that in fact the property in dispute was purchased by Pancham Singh
in the name of defendant No.3 but admitted that the said sale deed was not
executed because of ban on the execution of the sale deed and only an
agreement was executed in favour of defendant No.3, exhibit D-1. Thus, the
execution of sale deed in the name of the plaintiffs was not under challenge but,
on the contrary, the defendants/ appellants were claiming their title by virtue of a
sale which could not culminated into sale deed.
7.
The Supreme Court in the case of Muddasani Vendata
Narsaiah Vs. Muddasani Sarojana reported in (2016)12 SCC 288 has held
as under :"12. We are fortified in our aforesaid conclusion by a
decision in Kurella Naga Druva Vudaya Bhaskara Rao v.
Galla Jani Kamma [Kurella Naga Druva Vudaya Bhaskara
Rao v. Galla Jani Kamma, (2008) 15 SCC 150] , wherein this
Court has examined the question of maintainability of suit for
possession without prayer for declaration of title. This Court
has referred to its earlier decision in Anathula Sudhakar v. P.
Buchi Reddy [Anathula Sudhakar v. P. Buchi Reddy, (2008)
4 SCC 594] , wherein the plaintiff had purchased the suit land
under registered sale deed dated 10-4-1957 and the defendant
did not claim the title with reference to any document but
claimed to have perfected title by adverse possession. It was
held by this Court that the said plea did not prima facie put
any cloud over the plaintiff's title calling him to file suit for
declaration of title. Unless there is serious cloud over the title
of the plaintiff there is no need to file suit for declaration of
title. The suit for possession was maintainable. This Court
laid down as follows : (Galla Jani Kamma case [Kurella Naga
Druva Vudaya Bhaskara Rao v. Galla Jani Kamma, (2008) 15
SCC 150] , SCC p. 157, para 16)
"16. The plaintiff had purchased the suit land under registered
sale deed dated 10-4-1957. Defendant did not claim title with
reference to any document but claimed to have perfected title
by adverse possession. A mere claim by the defendant that
he had perfected his title by adverse possession, does not
mean that a cloud is raised over the plaintiff's title and that the
plaintiff who is the owner, should file a suit for declaration of
title. Unless the defendant raises a serious cloud over the title
of the plaintiff, there is no need to file a suit for declaration.
The plaintiff had title and she only wanted possession and
therefore a suit for possession was maintainable. We are
fortified in this view by the following observations of this
Court in Anathula Sudhakar v. P. Buchi Reddy [Anathula
Sudhakar v. P. Buchi Reddy, (2008) 4 SCC 594] : (SCC p.
604, para 14)
'14. We may however clarify that a prayer for declaration will
b e necessary only if the denial of title by the defendant or
challenge to the plaintiff's title raises a cloud on the title of the
plaintiff to the property. A cloud is said to raise over a
person's title, when some apparent defect in his title to a
property, or when some prima facie right of a third party over
it, is made out or shown. An action for declaration, is the
remedy to remove the cloud on the title to the property. On
the other hand, where the plaintiff has clear title supported by
documents, if a trespasser without any claim to title or an
interloper without any apparent title, merely denies the
plaintiff's title, it does not amount to raising a cloud over the
title of the plaintiff and it will not be necessary for the plaintiff
to sue for declaration.
8.
Supreme court in the case of Kurella Naga Druva Vudaya
Bhaskara Rao Vs. Galla Jani Kamma, reported in (2008)15 SCC 150 has
held as under :"16. The plaintiff had purchased the suit land under registered
sale deed dated 10-4-1957. The defendant did not claim title
with reference to any document but claimed to have perfected
title by adverse possession. A mere claim by the defendant that
he had perfected his title by adverse possession, does not mean
that a cloud is raised over the plaintiff's title and that the plaintiff
who is the owner, should file a suit for declaration of title.
Unless the defendant raises a serious cloud over the title of the
plaintiff, there is no need to file a suit for declaration. The
plaintiff had title and she only wanted possession and therefore
a suit for possession was maintainable. We are fortified in this
view by the following observations of this Court in Anathula
Sudhakar v. P. Buchi Reddy [(2008) 4 SCC 594] : (SCC p.
604, para 14) "14. We may, however, clarify that a prayer for
declaration will be necessary only if the denial of title by the
defendant or challenge to plaintiff's title raises a cloud on the
title of plaintiff to the property. A cloud is said to raise over a
person's title, when some apparent defect in his title to a
property, or when some prima facie right of a third party over it,
is made out or shown. An action for declaration, is the remedy
to remove the cloud on the title to the property. On the other
hand, where the plaintiff has clear title supported by documents,
if a trespasser without any claim to title or an interloper without
any apparent title, merely denies the plaintiff's title, it does not
amount to raising a cloud over the title of the plaintiff and it will
not be necessary for the plaintiff to sue for declaration."Â
9.
Since the sale deed is in the name of the plaintiff, who is the real
sister of the appellants and the appellants have also not denied the execution of
the sale deed in the name of their sister coupled with the fact that they have
failed to show that the land in dispute was purchased by Pancham Singh in the
name of defendant No.3 and the appellants have also failed to prove the
agreement to sell, as no attesting witness was examined and it was typed only
on a stamp paper without getting it even notarized, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the suit for possession without seeking declaration of
title was maintainable.
10.
So far as the question of adverse possession is concerned it is
suffice to mention here that the person claiming his adverse possession must
prove that his possession was in continuity for a statutory period and it was
open in public. Mere possession for 12 years or more would not confer title by
way of adverse possession unless and until the person claiming possession
succeeds in proving animus possedendi and hostile possession and enjoyment
of the property against the person(s) who owned the property, for a statutory
period. A person claiming adverse possession must admit the ownership of the
true owner.
11.
If the case of the plaintiff is considered then it is her case that
since her husband was in service and was posted at different places and it was
not possible to cultivate the land during his service period, therefore, she had
requested and permitted her father Pancham Singh to cultivate and look after the
land.
12.
Thus, it was claimed that the possession of the plaintiffs/
appellants and her/ their father was permissible. The appellants were claiming
their possession on the basis of their own title, therefore they did not admit the
ownership of the plaintiffs who is their real sister. Mere long possession is not
sufficient to hold that the person claiming possession has perfected his title by
adverse possession.
13.
As no substantial question of law arises in the present appeal, the
judgment and decree dated 03/03/2022 passed by District Judge, Chourai,
District Chhindwara in RCA No.19/2020 and 20/2020 so also judgment and
decree dated 30/08/2019 passed by Civil Judge, Senior Division, Chourai,
District Chhindwara in Civil Suit No.400120/2016 are hereby affirmed.
14.
The appeal fails and is hereby dismissed.
(G.S. AHLUWALIA)
JUDGE
HS
HEMANT SARAF
2023.01.25 17:37:02
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review