Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Pronounced on :
Uploaded on :
11.02.2026.
12.02.2026.
Arb P. No. 54/2025
M/s D.S. Constructions
…..Petitioner
Through: Mr. Jugal Kishore Gupta, Advocate
Vs
Union of India & Ors.
.….Respondents
Through: Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Sumant Sudan, Advocate
CORAM:
01.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
(11.02.2026)
Through the medium of the present petition, the
petitioner has invoked jurisdiction of this Court under
Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996, seeking appointment of an Arbitrator.
02.
As per case of the petitioner, it is a partnership firm
enlisted with MES Department as ‘A’ Class contractor. It
has been submitted that the petitioner’s firm is engaged
in the business of execution of civil and other allied
works for the last more than 15 years and that the firm is
Arb P. No. 54/2025
duly registered with the Registrar of Firms. The petition
has been filed through Sh. Diljeet Singh Sachdeva, who
happens to be one of the partners of the firm.
03.
It has been submitted that contract work bearing CA No.
CEAFU-12/2018-19: Provn. Of Watch Towers and
Other Security Infrastructure at Air Force Station
Thoise came to be allotted to the petitioner firm by
respondent No. 3-The Chief Engineer, HQ CE (AF)
Udhampur Zone, Air Force Station, Udhampur, vide
Sanction
Letter
No.
85019/CEAFU-36/88/E8
dated
30.07.2018 and the cost of work was estimated at Rs.
1,74,76,913/-. Work order No. 8190/CEAFU-12/201819/06/E8 dated 10.08.2018 was issued in favour of the
petitioner firm and the date of commencement of the
work was fixed as 20.08.2018 with date of completion as
19.04.2020.
04.
It is case of the petitioner that after the issuance of work
order, the petitioner firm marshalled its resources, labour
and machinery in the right earnest and was able to raise
construction of the towers upto the slab level of 1st floor
within two months of the commencement of the work. It
is submitted that on the commencement of the next
Arb P. No. 54/2025
working season in April, 2019 when the work had just
started, the petitioner firm was asked by respondent No.
4-Garrison Engineer (AF) Thoise, Military Engineering
Services, to withhold further construction at site as the
said respondent had received instructions from the Air
Force Authorities for change of design of the Watch
Towers.
These
instructions
were
contained
in
a
communication No. 21007/AF/Leh/Thoise/159/E2(DES)
dated 05.01.2019. Accordingly, the petitioner firm was
asked by Garrison Engineer, (AF) Thoise, to withhold
further execution of the contract work.
05.
It has been submitted that vide communication dated
14.08.2019, respondent No. 4 forwarded the revised
drawings to the petitioner which were received by the
petitioner on 03.03.2020. Vide communication dated
17.02.2021, the petitioner firm informed respondent No.
4 about the hurdles which it was facing in the execution
of the contract work. The petitioner firm is stated to have
addressed a number of communications to respondent
No. 4 seeking permission to go ahead with execution of
the work, however, no response was received to these
communications.
Arb P. No. 54/2025
06.
Vide communication dated 19.04.2022, respondent No. 4
is stated to have informed the petitioner firm that Revised
Administrative Approval (RAA) is in process. In terms of
Communication dated 25.07.2022, the petitioner firm
was informed by the respondent No. 4 that requirement
of extra funds for the changed design has not been
approved and therefore, the work may be continued as
per the original drawings only and the petitioner firm was
asked
to
proceed
ahead
with
the
original
designs/drawings. In the process, about three and a half
years were lost.
07.
It is further case of the petitioner that during the
execution of the work, it had purchased, collected and
brought the entire building material at site which was
duly recorded in the measurement book and this material
remained lying at the site unused because of the nonfinalization of drawings and the instructions from the end
of the respondents. On 25.07.2022, respondent No. 4
asked the petitioner firm to resume the construction as
per the original designs but when one of the partners of
the firm visited the site it was observed that the material
which had been dumped at the site in the year 2018-19
Arb P. No. 54/2025
had
been
removed.
The
petitioner
firm
requested
respondent No. 4 to lodge an FIR in this regard but no
action was taken in the matter which resulted in further
delay in the execution of the work. The material worth
more than Rs. 40 lakhs is stated to have been stolen from
the site.
08.
The respondents convened a Board of Officers to enquire
or investigate with regard to the theft/missing of dumped
material at site and the petitioner firm participated in the
said process but no findings were supplied to the
petitioner by the Board of Officers. It has been submitted
that the Board of Officers in its report dated 09.01.2025
has recorded the value of the material in June, 2019 as
Rs. 44,86,372/- and value of the material lying at site as
Rs. 1,12,268/-.
09.
The contract ultimately came to be terminated by the
respondents
in
terms
of
communication
dated
13.02.2025 which was received by the petitioner on
14.02.2025
through
e-mail.
However,
none
of
the
grievances of the petitioner were addressed by the
respondents.
Arb P. No. 54/2025
10.
The petitioner is stated to have approached the Court by
filing a petition under Section 9 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, upon feeling aggrieved by letter
of
termination dated
13.02.2025.
In
the
aforesaid
petition, an interim order came to be passed by the Court
on 18.03.2025 whereby the respondents were permitted
to go ahead with the completion of the balance work
through
another
contractor,
however,
it
has
been
provided that the condition of execution of balance work
at the risk and cost of the petitioner would remain
subject
to
outcome
of
the
proposed
Arbitration
proceedings.
11.
It has been submitted that the work could not be
completed
because
of
the
defaults
and
inaction
committed by the respondents and that the contract work
has been illegally terminated which has given rise to
disputes between the parties. Accordingly, legal notice
dated 07.03.2025 is stated to have been served by the
petitioner firm upon the respondents with a view to
invoke Clause-70 of
IAFW-2249 General Conditions of
the Contract making a request to the respondent No. 2Engineer-in-Chief, E-in-C’s Branch, Directorate of
Arb P. No. 54/2025
Contract Management, Integrated HQ of Ministry of
Defence Army, Kashmir House Rajaji Marg, New
Delhi, to refer the disputes to a mutually acceptable
Independent Sole Arbitrator. However, respondent No. 3
has declined the request of the petitioner firm for
reference of disputes on the ground that the same cannot
be done until alternative arrangements have been
finalized by the Government to get the work completed by
or through another contractor.
12.
It has been contended by the petitioner that the stand
taken by the respondents is wholly illegal and arbitrary
and that the same is not sustainable in the eyes of the
law. It has been further contended that the stand taken
by
the
respondents
renders
the
petitioner
firm
remediless.
13.
Notice of this petition was issued to the respondents on
11.07.2025 and learned counsel appearing for the
respondents had sought time to have instructions in the
matter and to file response to the petition. However, no
response has been filed by the respondents.
14.
Heard and considered.
Arb P. No. 54/2025
15.
So far as the existence of Arbitration agreement vide
Clause 70 of the General Conditions of the Contract is
concerned, the same is not in dispute. As per this Clause,
all disputes between the parties to the contract excepting
those for which decision of the C.W.E. or any other
person is by the contract expressed to be final and
binding, have to be referred to sole arbitration after
written notice by either party to the contract. The
arbitrator so appointed has to be a Serving Officer having
degree in Engineering or equivalent or having passed
final/direct final Examination of Sub-Division II of
Institution
of
Surveyor
(India)
recognized
by
the
Government of India, to be appointed by the authority
mentioned in the tender documents.
16.
The invocation of arbitration clause by the petitioner is
not disputed.
17.
It is also an admitted fact that disputes have arisen
between the parties during the execution of the contract
work. Therefore, in order to determine these disputes, an
arbitrator is required to be appointed, particularly, when
the appointing authority has failed to appoint the
Arb P. No. 54/2025
arbitrator in terms of the covenants of the Arbitration
Clause.
18.
During the course of the arguments, it has come to the
fore that disputes between the parties arising out of two
more contracts have already been referred to arbitration
by this Court in terms of the order dated 28.11.2025
passed in the Arbitration Petition No. 52/2025 and in
terms of another order of the same date passed in
Arbitration Petition No. 53/2025. In both those cases,
Mr. Satish Chandra, Additional Director General (Retd.),
has been appointed as the sole arbitrator.
19.
In view of the above, the petition is allowed and with the
consent of the learned counsel for the parties, Mr. Satish
Chandra, Additional Director General (Retd.), R/o H.
No. 89, Lane No. 4, Greater Kailash, Jammu-180011,
is appointed as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate upon
the disputes and differences between the parties arising
out of and in connection with the agreement referred to
above.
20.
A copy of this order shall be communicated to the learned
Sole Arbitrator by the Registry of this Court within a
Arb P. No. 54/2025
period of ten (10) days from today and the learned
Arbitrator
is
requested
to
forward
the
‘Statutory
Statement of Disclosures’ under Section 11(8) read with
Section 12(1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996, to the parties within a period of two weeks from
the date of receipt of this order.
21.
The
parties
shall
appear
before
the
learned
Sole
Arbitrator on the date and place, to be fixed by the
learned Sole Arbitrator. It is further directed that all the
arbitration costs and fees of the Arbitral Tribunal shall be
borne by the parties equally and shall be subject to the
final award that may be passed by the learned Arbitrator
in relation to the costs.
22.
Disposed of.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
11.02.2026
SUNIL
Whether the order is speaking ?
Whether the order is reportable ?
Arb P. No. 54/2025
:
:
Yes
No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review