Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OSA No.77 of 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 30-03-2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE P.VELMURUGAN
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.SENTHILKUMAR
OSA No.77 of 2019
D.Gnanasekaran
S/o. Late Devaraja Naicker
1, Ramswamy Reddy Street
Thiruvayarpady
Ponneri Post and Taluk, Tiruvallur Dist.
Appellant
Vs
1. Viswanathan Ramachandran
S/o. R.B.Viswanathan
No.30/6, 2nd Street, 1st Floor
South Gopalapuram, Chennai 600 086
2. Dr.Rajyalakhsmi Ramachandran
W/o.Viswanathan Ramachandran
No.30/6, 2nd Street, 1st Floor
South Gopalapuram, Chennai 600 086
3. Kannabiran
2083, E.W.S Colony, Anna Nagar
Chennai 600 040
4. K.Kamalanathan
S/o. Kanniah Naidu
Carrying in business at 5,
Jambulingam Street, Nungambakkam
Chennai 600 034
Respondents
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
Memorandum of Grounds of Original Side Appeal filed under Clause 15
of the Letters Patent read with Order XXXVI, Rule 1 of the Original Side Rules
against the order and decretal order dated 03.01.2018 passed in C.S.No.37 of
2009.
For Appellant:
Mr.V.Raghavachari
Senior Counsel for
Mrs.V.Srimathi
For Respondents:
Mr.B.Arvind Srevatsa for R1 & R2
R3 & R4 - No Appearance
JUDGMENT
(Judgment of the Court was made by P.Velmurugan J.)
The 1st plaintiff in the suit, C.S.No.37 of 2009 has filed the instant
original side appeal challenging the judgment and decree dated 03.01.2018
passed by the learned single Judge in the above suit.
2. The appellant/1st plaintiff along with the 4th respondent/2nd plaintiff filed
the above suit under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act for possession of the
suit property claiming that the ancestors of the 1 st plaintiff had purchased vast
extents of lands in Zamin Mambalam and Mylapore Villages in the year 1923
and they had acquired the lands in Paimash Nos.669 and 670 in Zamin
Mambalam Village. Since the Corporation of Madras had acquired vast extent
of lands in Zamin Mambalam Village for development of road and other
infrastructural facilities, certain lands belonging to the ancestors of the 1 st
plaintiff were also acquired during the said acquisition. According to the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
plaintiffs, by G.O.Ms.No.735 dated 28.08.1923, certain lands belonging to the
ancestors of the 1st plaintiff were excluded from the acquisition, more
particularly, Survey Nos.39 to 76 in Zamin Mambalam Village (Old Survey
No.55/3 and 54) are concerned. It was further claimed that Old Survey No.55/3
was assigned new Survey No.4867 in the year 1956 and subsequently Old
Survey No.55/3 was assigned Survey No.7039/2 of Zamin Mambalam Village.
The claim of the plaintiffs is that the northern boundary of the land that
belonged to the 1st plaintiff’s ancestors, belonged to the predecessors-in-title of
the defendants 1 and 2 herein, one Meenambal. The said Meenambal’s land was
originally comprised in Survey No.7039 and later sub-divided and assigned
Survey No.7039/1. The defendants 1 and 2 herein appear to have purchased the
properties in Survey No.7039/1 in Zamin Mambalam Village of an extent of 2
grounds and odd from the said Meenambal. It is also claimed that an extent of
5460 sq.ft. or thereabouts belonged to the family of the 1 st plaintiff comprised in
Survey No.7039/2, which has been enjoyed by the family of the plaintiffs and
the defendants had nothing to do with the property.
3. They further pleaded that the 2nd plaintiff entered into a registered
agreement of sale with the 1 st plaintiff and his family members on 27.11.2006 in
respect of the properties situate in Survey No.7039/2 and on the date of
agreement, the 2nd plaintiff was put in possession of the property. Since the 1 st
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
plaintiff did not comply with the terms of the agreement dated 27.11.2006, the
2nd plaintiff had filed a suit for specific performance in C.S.No.701 of 2008 and
the same ended in a compromise on 12.09.2008. On 26.11.2006, the 2 nd
plaintiff had put up a board in the property mentioning about the decree passed
in C.S.No.701 of 2008. Thereafter, the 2nd plaintiff removed bushes and cleaned
the property and put up a small shed in October 2008. The 2 nd plaintiff had also
borne the salaries of security personnel appointed to guard the property. The 2 nd
plaintiff applied for and obtained a landline telephone connection to the shed on
11.11.2008 and also the electricity service connection on 26.11.2008 in his
name for the said shed. While so, according to the plaintiffs, on 16.12.2008, the
2nd defendant visited the property and quarrelled with the security personnel
deployed by the 2nd plaintiff. He also lodged a police complaint before R4Pondy Bazaar Police Station. It was also claimed that the 2 nd defendant had
lodged a police complaint with a wrong description of the property and laid
claim for the present suit. It was also contended that the 3 rd defendant, who as a
higher police officer in the rank of Assistant Commissioner of Police took
personal interest in the complaint lodged by the 2nd defendant and by stepping
into the shoes of the Station House Officer, registered a case against the 2nd
plaintiff under Section 448 of I.P.C. It appears that the 2 nd plaintiff had filed a
suit for injunction against the defendants 1 and 2 before the City Civil Court on
17.12.2008 itself and notice was ordered by the learned VI Assistant Judge, City
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
Civil Court returnable by 06.01.2009. However, the 3 rd defendant, being Police
Officer, took the law into his own hands and dispossessed the plaintiffs on
18.12.2008 by pulling down the notice board put up by the 2 nd plaintiff and
posted two securities for the suit property. Complaining that the 2 nd plaintiff was
dispossessed illegally by the defendants, the suit came to be filed seeking
recovery of possession.
4. The respondents 1 & 2/defendants 1 and 2 filed a written statement
contending that the plaintiffs were never in possession of the suit property so as
to be dispossessed on 18.12.2008 as alleged by them. According to them, the
survey number of the suit property is 7039/1 and not 7039/2 as claimed by the
plaintiffs. It was also stated that the property of the defendants 1 and 2 measures
2 grounds and 1644 sq.ft. (6444 sq.ft.), while the measurement given in the
plaint schedule is only 5460 sq.ft. i.e., 2 grounds and 660 sq.ft. The defendants 1
and 2 would also assert title to the property claiming that the property originally
belonged to one Karuppan Chettiar, who sold the same to one Mrs.Meenambal
on 14.03.1946. The said Meenambal had sold the entire extent of property, 4
grounds 1600 sq.ft. comprised in Survey Nos.55/2 and 55/3 to Mrs.Jayant
Iswrlal Choksey and Jayntilal Ratilal Shah vide sale deed dated 26.03.1951. The
said purchasers under the sale deed dated 26.03.1951 had sold a portion
measuring 2 grounds and 1644 sq.ft. which is the back side portion of the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
property with a strip of land serving as pathway from Venkataraman Street to
one Putcha Viswanatha Sastry under the Sale Deed dated 06.09.1957. The said
Putcha Viswanatha Sastry had put up construction as per the plan sanctioned by
the Corporation of Madras. With a view to discharge the mortgage, which was
created by Putcha Viswanatha Sastry with Mylapore Hindu Permanent Fund
Ltd., he sold the property to the vendor of the defendants 1 and 2 under the sale
deed dated 26.08.1966. The purchaser under the sale deed dated 26.08.1966
viz., one Jalma Nachia, in the year 1977 sold the property purchased by her
under the sale deed dated 26.08.1966 to the defendants on 07.04.1997. Thus, the
defendants had purchased the property for a valuable consideration of
Rs.1,00,00,000/- (Rupees one crore only) after obtaining necessary No
Objection certificate from the appropriate Authority under the Income Tax Act
under Section 269-UL(1). Ever since the purchase, the defendants 1 and 2 have
been in possession of the property paying all public charges. The patta for the
property has also been transferred in the names of the defendants from their
predecessors-in-title. Subsequent to the purchase, they had let it out to various
persons including the Chennai Mathematical Institute, which was a tenant in the
suit property from November 2000 to April 2003. The defendants, who are Non
Resident Indians residing in Nigeria, wanted to settle down in Chennai.
Therefore, they required the tenant to vacate, upon the tenant vacating in the
year 2003, the electricity connection was disconnected by applying to the Tamil
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
Nadu Electricity Board. The building in the suit property was also demolished
after obtaining due approval from the Corporation of Madras. However, the
outhouse which was an old structure of 40 years has been retained by the
defendants and it is in their possession. In fact, the defendants had opportunity
in August 2008 to come to India and consulted an Architect for construction of a
new building and performed Boomi Pooja in the month of August 2008. They
had also submitted the building plans to the Corporation of Madras. It was
during the interregnum between August 2008 and January 2009, the 2 nd plaintiff
attempted to trespass over the property by putting up a board claiming title to
the property. The attempted trespass by the 2 nd plaintiff was prevented by the
defendants with the timely intervention of the Police Officers and a case was
registered against the 2nd plaintiff under Section 448 of Cr.P.C. Therefore,
according to the defendants, the plaintiffs were never in possession of the
property to enable them to file the suit under Section 6 based upon their
previous possession. They would also attack the compromise decree said to
have been obtained by the 2nd plaintiff on 12.09.2008 as collusive one, stage
managed to create title over the property. The very filing of the suit is termed as
abuse of process of court by the defendants 1 and 2. On the above allegations,
the defendants 1 and 2 sought for dismissal of the suit.
5. The 3rd defendant filed a separate written statement narrating the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
incidents after which the FIR was registered on 19.12.2008. It was also
contended that the 3rd defendant was assigned the job of investigating the case
only on 29.12.2008 by the Deputy Commissioner of Police by his memo in
C.No.51/DC TNR/memo/Genl/08. Therefore, according to the 3 rd defendant, he
had nothing to do with the investigation till 29.12.2008. Only upon the receipt
of memo dated 29.12.2008 from the Deputy Commissioner of Police, the 3rd
defendant had taken up further investigation of the case from 30.12.2008. He
would also narrate as to how the defendants had obtained title to the property
and had demolished the house after obtaining necessary permission from the
Corporation vide order No.DE/Da/92/05 dated15.03.2005. He would also deny
the claim of the plaintiffs that the suit property formed part of the property that
belonged to the ancestors of the 1st plaintiff which were exempted under
G.O.Ms.No.735 dated 28.08.1923. The sum and substance of the written
statement of the 3rd defendant would disclose that the plaintiffs were never in
possession of the property at any point of time and therefore, there is no
question of plaintiffs having been dispossessed illegally by the defendants 1 to
3. It is also contended by him that what was done by the police was to
effectively prevent the attempted trespass by the plaintiffs. On the above
contentions, the 3rd defendant sought for dismissal of the suit.
6. The learned single Judge, based on the above pleadings, framed the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
following issues for consideration:“1. Whether the above suit is maintainable against the
defendants when the description of the suit schedule property is
different from the property owned and possessed by the 1 st and
2nd defendants in respect of survey number and measurements?
2. Whether the plaintiffs had any possessory right over
the suit property to seek relief under Section 6 of Specific Relief
Act, 1963?
3. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for the relief as
prayed for under Section 6 of Specific Relief Act,1963?
4. To what other relief the plaintiffs are entitled to?”
7. During the trial, the 1st plaintiff was examined as PW1, the 2nd plaintiff
was examined as PW2 and Exs.P1 to P13 were marked on their side. The 2 nd
defendant was examined as DW1. One Sripathi, who is the Registrar of Chennai
Mathematical Institute, which is a deemed University under Section 3 of UGC
Act, was examined as DW2. The 3rd defendant was examined as DW3. Exs.D1
to D21 were marked on the side of the defendants.
8. The learned single Judge, after considering the materials and on
hearing the contentions of the parties, dismissed the suit with costs of the
defendants 1 to 3 by the judgment and decree dated 03.01.2018. Aggrieved
thereby, the present appeal has been filed before us.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
9. The learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant would
submit that since there is no specific bar in the Specific Relief Act, the present
appeal is maintainable under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent against the order
passed by the learned single Judge on the Original Side. In other words, when
there is no statutory bar or express provision in the statute excluding appeals
under Letters Patent, the present appeal lies against the judgment and decree
passed by the learned single Judge exercising original jurisdiction. Though
Section 6(3) of the Specific Relief Act bars the filing of appeal, that will not
whittle down the power of the Chartered High Court to entertain an appeal
under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent against the order passed by the learned
single Judge on the Original Side. Therefore, the present appeal is maintainable.
He would further submit that since the plaintiffs were in possession of the
property and the respondents 1 & 2, on their confusion in identifying their
property, have not established that they are in possession of the property.
However, the plaintiffs were in possession of the property even six months prior
to filing of the suit. However, the learned single Judge failed to appreciate the
oral and documentary evidence and dismissed the suit, as if the plaintiffs failed
to prove their possession. He would also submit that when the plaintiffs were
the rightful owners of the property and enjoyed the property by putting up a
shed in the vacant site and also obtained electricity connection and telephone
connection and that the property was also maintained by engaging security
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
personnel by paying their salary and the documents in proof of their possession
were also marked and adduced evidence, the learned single Judge failed to
consider those documents and dismissed the suit. Therefore, the learned Senior
Counsel sought for setting aside the judgment and decree passed by the learned
single Judge by allowing the appeal.
10. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents 1 & 2
would submit that the appeal itself is not maintainable, which is barred under
Section 6(3) of the Specific Relief Act. The proceedings under Section 6 are
summary in nature and hence the appeal is not maintainable. He would further
submit that the plaintiffs have not produced any document to show that they
were in possession of the property six months prior to filing of the suit and were
dispossessed illegally without following due process of law. The scope of
Section 6 itself is that the Court need not go into the right and title of the
property and while invoking Section 6, the Court has to consider with regard to
the possession of the property, as even a trespasser, who is in settled possession,
can only be dispossessed under due process of law and not illegally or forcibly.
Therefore, the relief under Section 6 is very limited that if anybody’s possession
is illegally or forcibly removed without due process of law, he/she can seek the
relief under Section 6 for protection, if he/she was dispossessed in the
interregnum without due process of law and in that process, the Court can
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
restore his/her possession and whereas the plaintiffs, who filed the suit under
Section 6, have not proved the possession under the ambit of Section 6 of the
Specific Relief Act. Therefore, the learned single Judge rightly dismissed the
suit. Hence, he would submit that there is no merit in the appeal and the same is
liable to be dismissed.
11. We have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel on
either side and perused the materials available on record.
12. The specific case of the appellant is that the northern boundary of the
land that belonged to the 1st plaintiff’s ancestors, belonged to the predecessorsin-title of the defendants 1 and 2 herein, one Meenambal. The said Meenambal’s
land was originally comprised in Survey No.7039 and later sub-divided and
assigned Survey No.7039/1. The respondents 1 and 2 herein appear to have
purchased the properties in Survey No.7039/1 in Zamin Mambalam Village of
an extent of 2 grounds and odd from the said Meenambal. It is further claimed
that an extent of 5460 sq.ft. or thereabouts belonged to the family of the
appellant comprised in Survey No.7039/2, has been enjoyed by the family of the
plaintiffs and the defendants had nothing to do with the property. It was further
pleaded that the 2nd plaintiff entered into a registered agreement of sale with the
appellant and his family members on 27.11.2006 in respect of the properties
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
situate in Survey No.7039/2 and on the date of agreement, the 2 nd plaintiff was
put in possession of the property. Since the appellant did not comply with the
terms of the agreement dated 27.11.2006, the 2 nd plaintiff had filed a suit for
specific performance in C.S.No.701 of 2008 and the same ended in a
compromise on 12.09.2008 and that the 2nd plaintiff had put up a board in the
property mentioning about the decree passed in C.S.No.701 of 2008. Thereafter,
the 2nd plaintiff removed bushes and cleaned the property and put up a small
shed in October 2008. The 2nd plaintiff had also borne the salaries of security
personnel appointed to guard the property. The 2nd plaintiff applied for and
obtained a landline telephone connection to the shed on 11.11.2008 and also the
electricity service connection on 26.11.2008 in his name for the said shed.
While so, on 16.12.2008, the 2nd defendant visited the property and quarrelled
with the security personnel deployed by the 2nd plaintiff, for which a police
complaint was lodged before R4-Pondy Bazaar Police Station. It was also
pleaded that the 2nd defendant had lodged a police complaint with a wrong
description of the property and laid claim for the present suit and that the 3 rd
defendant, who as a higher police officer in the rank of Assistant Commissioner
of Police took personal interest in the complaint lodged by the 2 nd defendant and
by stepping into the shoes of the Station House Officer, registered a case against
the 2nd plaintiff under Section 448 of I.P.C. Even though the 2 nd plaintiff had
filed a suit for injunction against the defendants 1 and 2 before the City Civil
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
Court on 17.12.2008 itself and notice was ordered by the learned VI Assistant
Judge, City Civil Court returnable by 06.01.2009, the 3 rd defendant, being
Police Officer, took the law into his own hands and dispossessed the plaintiffs
on 18.12.2008 by pulling down the notice board put up by the 2 nd plaintiff and
posted two securities for the suit property. On the ground that the 2 nd plaintiff
was dispossessed illegally by the defendants, the suit came to be filed seeking
recovery of possession.
13. The case of the respondents 1 & 2 is that though the plaintiffs claim
their right over the property in Survey No.7039/2 by tracing the title from the
ancestors of the 1st plaintiff, they were never in possession of the suit property
so as to be dispossessed on 18.12.2008 as alleged by them. According to them,
the survey number of the suit property is 7039/1 and not 7039/2 as claimed by
the plaintiffs. It was also stated that the property of the defendants 1 and 2
measures 2 grounds and 1644 sq.ft. (6444 sq.ft.), while the measurement given
in the plaint schedule is only 5460 sq.ft. i.e., 2 grounds and 660 sq.ft. The
respondents 1 and 2 assert title to the property claiming that the property
originally belonged to one Karuppan Chettiar, who sold the same to one
Mrs.Meenambal on 14.03.1946. The said Meenambal had sold the entire extent
of property, 4 grounds 1600 sq.ft. comprised in Survey Nos.55/2 and 55/3 to
Mrs.Jayant Iswrlal Choksey and Jayntilal Ratilal Shah vide sale deed dated
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
26.03.1951. The said purchasers under the sale deed dated 26.03.1951 had sold
a portion measuring 2 grounds and 1644 sq.ft., which is the back side portion of
the property with a strip of land serving as pathway from Venkataraman Street
to one Putcha Viswanatha Sastry under the Sale Deed dated 06.09.1957. The
said Putcha Viswanatha Sastry had put up construction as per the plan
sanctioned by the Corporation of Madras. With a view to discharge the
mortgage, which was created by Putcha Viswanatha Sastry with Mylapore
Hindu Permanent Fund Ltd., he sold the property to the vendor of the
respondents 1 and 2 under the sale deed dated 26.08.1966. The purchaser under
the sale deed dated 26.08.1966 viz., one Jalma Nachia, in the year 1977 sold the
property purchased by her under the sale deed dated 26.08.1966 to the
defendants on 07.04.1997. Thus, the defendants had purchased the property for
a valuable consideration of Rs.1,00,00,000/- (Rupees one crore only) after
obtaining necessary NOC from the appropriate authority under the Income Tax
Act under Section 269-UL(1). Ever since the purchase, the respondents 1 and 2
have been in possession of the property paying all public charges. The patta for
the property has also been transferred in the names of the defendants from their
predecessors-in-title. Subsequent to the purchase, they had let it out to various
persons including the Chennai Mathematical Institute, which was a tenant in the
suit property from November 2000 to April 2003. Since the defendants, who are
Non Resident Indians residing in Nigeria, wanted to settle down in Chennai,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
they required the tenant to vacate, upon the tenant vacating in the year 2003, the
electricity connection was disconnected by applying to the Tamil Nadu
Electricity Board. The building in the suit property was also demolished after
obtaining due approval from the Corporation of Madras. The outhouse which
was an old structure of 40 years has been retained by the defendants and it is in
their possession. In fact, the defendants had opportunity in August 2008 to come
to India and consulted an Architect for construction of a new building and
performed Boomi Pooja in the month of August 2008. They had also submitted
the building plans to the Corporation of Madras. It was during the interregnum
between August 2008 and January 2009, the 2 nd plaintiff attempted to trespass
over the property by putting up a board claiming title to the property. The
attempted trespass by the 2nd plaintiff was prevented by the defendants with the
timely intervention of the Police Officers and a case was registered against the
2nd plaintiff under Section 448 of Cr.P.C. According to the respondents 1 & 2,
the plaintiffs were never in possession of the property to enable them to file the
suit under Section 6.
14. As far as the preliminary objection raised by the learned counsel for
the respondents 1 & 2 as to the maintainability of the appeal is concerned, it is
pertinent to refer to the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Vinita M.Khanolkar v. Pragna M.Pai and others, (1998) 1 SCC 500, wherein it
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
has been observed as follows:“3. Now it is well settled that any statutory provision
barring an appeal or revision cannot cut across the constitutional
power of a High Court. Even the power flowing from the
paramount charter under which the High Court functions would
not get excluded unless the statutory enactment concerned
expressly excludes appeals under letters patent. No such bar is
discernible from Section 6(3) of the Act. It could not be seriously
contended by learned counsel for the respondents that if clause
15 of the Letters Patent is invoked then the order would be
appealable. Consequently, in our view, on the clear language of
clause 15 of the Letters Patent which is applicable to Bombay
High Court, the said appeal was maintainable as the order under
appeal was passed by learned Single Judge of the High Court
exercising original jurisdiction of the court. Only on that short
ground the appeal is required to be allowed.”
In the light of the above dictum, we hold that the present appeal is maintainable
against the judgment and decree passed by the learned single Judge exercising
original jurisdiction.
15. As far as the possession is concerned, though the appellant has stated
that an agreement of sale was entered into between the appellant and the 2 nd
plaintiff in respect of the properties situate in Survey No.7039/2 on 27.11.2006
and subsequently based on the compromise decree passed in the suit for specific
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
performance on 12.09.2008, the 2nd plaintiff put up a shed in the property, the
respondents 1 & 2 have denied the same by stating that they purchased the
property from their vendor on 07.04.1997 and ever since the purchase, they
have been in possession and the patta has also been transferred in their name.
Though the appellant filed the suit under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act as
if the 2nd plaintiff was in possession and the 3rd respondent dispossessed him
illegally, the scope and object of Section 6 is very clear that the ownership or
title of the property cannot be decided. In a suit under Section 6, the Court has
to consider as to who was in possession of the property six months preceding
the date of filing of the suit and when the Court finds that someone has been
removed illegally or dispossessed without following due process of law, the
Court can protect his/her possession under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act
and restore back possession. Since the nature of suit under Section 6 is only
summary in nature, the Court can only look into the aspect of possession and
not the right and title, which have to be established independently in the manner
known to law. In this regard, it is pertinent to refer to the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Mohd.Mehtab Khan and others v.
Khushnuma Ibrahim Khan and others, (2013) 9 SCC 221, wherein it has been
observed as follows:“16. A proceeding under Section 6 of the Specific
Relief Act, 1963 is intended to be a summary proceeding
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
the object of which is to afford an immediate remedy to an
aggrieved party to reclaim possession of which he may
have been unjustly denied by an illegal act of
dispossession. Questions of title or better rights of
possession does not arise for adjudication in a suit under
Section 6 where the only issue required to be decided is as
to whether the plaintiff was in possession at any time six
months’ prior to the date of filing of the suit. The
legislative concern underlying Section 6 of the SR Act is to
provide a quick remedy in cases of illegal dispossession so
as to discourage litigants from seeking remedies outside
the arena of law. The same is evident from the provisions
of Section 6(3) which bars the remedy of an appeal or even
a review against a decree passed in such a suit.”
16. In this case, though the appellant has stated that the 2nd plaintiff was in
possession and he obtained the electricity service connection and also the
telephone connection in his name, the said documents may not be sufficient to
establish the possession under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act. Though the
appellant has stated that the 2nd plaintiff engaged security personnel and also
paid their salary and has also marked the document, Ex.P7 in support thereof,
the same has been denied by the respondents 1 & 2 stating that the building was
demolished and the shed alone has been maintained. It is also to be seen that
though the appellant claimed that the 2 nd plaintiff engaged security personnel to
safeguard the property by paying their salary, the respondents 1 & 2 denied the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
same on the ground that the security personnel said to have been engaged by the
2nd plaintiff have not been examined to establish that the 2 nd plaintiff was in
possession of the property. Even during the cross examination, when a
suggestion was put before the appellant whether there was a building in the
property prior to his purchase, for which he has stated that he did not know that
there was a house in the suit property and the same was rented out to the tenant
and also did not know when the building was constructed and when the property
was originally purchased by the respondents 1 & 2 from one Jalma Nachia
under the sale deed dated 07.04.1997. Except stating that he did not know the
above said facts, he has not denied the same. Further, when there is a dispute
regarding the identification of the property, whether it is situate in Survey
No.7039/1 or 7039/2, the same has to be established before the competent Court
in accordance with law and the said dispute cannot be decided in the suit under
Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act. Even the electricity service connection and
the telephone connection obtained in the name of the 2 nd plaintiff have also been
disconnected. The fact remains that there was a building in the suit property
purchased by the respondents 1 & 2 in the year 1997 and the same was
demolished after obtaining NOC. From a reading of the entire materials, this
Court finds that the appellant has not proved the factum of possession of the
property six months prior to the date of filing of the suit and if at all the
appellant has got any right and title over the property, he can establish the same
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
by filing a suit before the competent Court. As held by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, since the suit under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act is summary in
nature, the right and title or the ownership of property cannot be gone into in the
said proceedings.
When the plaintiffs filed the suit for recovery of
possession/restoration/protection under Section 6, it is for them to prove that
they were in possession of the suit property at any time within six months prior
to the date of filing of the suit or within six months from the date of their
dispossession. In this case, this Court finds that the appellant or the plaintiffs
failed to prove the possession. Therefore, finding no merits whatsoever, the
original side appeal is dismissed. However, the parties are at liberty to work out
their remedy in the manner known to law before the competent Court. No order
as to costs.
(P.VELMURUGAN J.) (N.SENTHILKUMAR J.)
30-03-2026
Index:Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Internet:Yes
ss
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No.77 of 2019
P.VELMURUGAN J.
AND
N.SENTHILKUMAR J.
ss
OSA No.77 of 2019
30-03-2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review