Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page - 1 of 18
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) (PIL) No.25 of 2021
Court on its own motion
----- Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Chief Secretary,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex, P.O. Secretariat,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN- 799010.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary, Government
of Tripura, Department of Home, Civil Secretariat, New Capital
Complex, Agartala, PIN- 799010.
3. Director General of Police, Government of Tripura, Police Head
Quarters, Fire Brigade Chowmohani, P.O. Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN- 799001.
----- Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. A. Debbarma, Amicus Curiae
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Government Advocate
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate
Date of Hearing
:
31st August, 2022.
Date of Pronouncement :
21st September, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting :
YES
_B_E_F_O_R_E_
HON‟BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. INDRAJIT MAHANTY
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[Per S.G. Chattopadhyay], J
On October 28, 20021, a news item came to be published in a local
daily namely, Pratibadi Kalam reporting custodial torture on a 28 years’
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 2 of 18
old woman namely, Smt. Priyashi Datta (Debnath) of Chanmari in the
police lockup of GB TOP on 26.10.2021 as a result of which she was
admitted in AGMC & GBP Hospital at Agartala. The Chief Justice took suo
motu notice of this grave and serious issue on the basis of the said
newspaper report and pursuant to his direction this Public Interest
Litigation came to be registered. Notices were issued to the Staterespondents including the Secretary, Home Department, Government of
Tripura and Director General of Police.
[2]
On
18.12.2021,
the
Under
Secretary
to
the
Home
Department filed an affidavit contending as under:
“2.
That, this affidavit is prepared to apprise the Hon‟ble
Court by furnishing facts in regards to the present situation of
the aforementioned case as stated below:
On 23.10.2021 at about 1600 hrs a telephonic information was
received by GB TOP as well as OC NCC P.S regarding missing of
8 (eight) bhori Gold ornaments from the house of one Laxmi
Rani Ghosh of East Chanmari and there was a strong suspicion
that her immediate neighbours Babul Debnath 37 years, S/o
Lt. Jagadish Debnath of East Chanmari and his wife Smt. Piyusi
Datta (Debnath) 28 years were involved in the matter.
On 26.10.2021 at 1155 hrs while Smt. Piyushi Datta (Debnath)
was examined at GB TOP by women officer and staff namely
W/ASI Hemlata Debbarma and W/C Pushpa Rani Sarkar in
connection with the matter. This refers to GB TOP GDE No 10,
dated-26-10-2021. Suddenly during examination at about
1215 hrs she reported that she was not feeling well.
Thereafter, she was immediately shifted to GBP Hospital. This
refers to GB TOP GDE No.12, dated-26-10-2021. After careful
medical examination the attending doctor of Emergency OPD
namely Dr. Anish Majumder had opined that she was fit,
healthy and mentally alert. After completion of medical
examination, she was allowed to go home at about 1240 hrs.
This refers to GB TOP GDE No.13 dated-26-10-2021. It is also
to mention here that no CCTV camera is available at GB TOP.
Again, on the same day at about 2240 hrs, a group of local
people of East Chanmari under the leadership of one Sri Mithun
Das Baishnab appeared at NCC P.S and alleged that Smt.
Piyushi Datta (Debnath) was called at GBP outpost and she
was beaten by W/ASI Hemlata Debbarma and W/C Pushpa
Rani Sarkar on 26.10.2021. The matter was entered in the GD
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 3 of 18
of NCC P.S vide No-38 dated 26.10.2021 and an enquiry was
initiated.
During enquiry, it was learnt from the family members of Smt.
Piyushi Datta that on 26.10.2021 in the evening time Smt.
Piyushi Datta was admitted to GB Hospital by her family
members due to some health complications. She was under
treatment at GB Hospital w.e.f 26.10.2011 and discharged
from the Hospital on 01.11.2021. During her treatment, Police
talked to her attending doctors of Female Surgical Ward-II and
it was learnt that Smt. Piyushi Datta was suffering from
deficiency of hemoglobin for which 2(two) units blood was
given to her along with other medicines. No other medical
report is available with police. For this, a requisition has been
submitted to the Medical Superintendent of AGMC & GBP
Hospital to provide the “Bed Head Ticket” of Smt. Piyushi
Datta, which is not yet received.”
[3]
In view of the statements in paragraph 2 of the affidavit, the
following order was passed by this Court on 20.12.2021:
“
Perused the reply affidavit filed by the State. In
pagraph-2 at running page-9, it is stated that though a
requisition has been made to the Medical Superintendent of
AGMC & GBP Hospital to provide the bed head ticket of Smt.
Piyushi Datta, the same has not yet been received. In view of
such statement, we direct the Medical Superintendent of AGMC
& GBP Hospital to provide the bed head ticket as well as the
report of the doctors who had examined Smt. Piyushi Datta
from 26.10.2021 till her discharge on 01.11.2021. We call upon
the Superintendent also to inform this Court by affidavit the
names of the doctors who supervised Smt. Piyushi Datta‟s
treatment by the next date.
Matter shall be taken up on 04.01.2022.
In the meantime, if the police received a copy of the
bed head ticket, they are at liberty to file further affidavit to
bring the same on record.”
[4]
Ms. A. Debbarma, learned advocate was appointed as amicus
curiae to appear and assist the Court in the matter.
[5]
On
07.01.2022,
the
Under
Secretary
to
the
Home
Department, Government of Tripura filed an additional affidavit asserting
as under:
“2.
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
That, this additional affidavit is prepared to apprise the
Hon‟ble Court by furnishing facts in regards to the
present situation of the afore mentioned case as state
below:
Page - 4 of 18
3.
That, the S.P, West Tripura District furnished detail
information as directed by the Hon‟ble High Court vide
order
dated-20.12.2021
along
with
supporting
documents.
(i)
OC NCC PS has collected photocopies of the Bed
Head Ticket of Smt. Piyushi Datta (Debnath)
containing total 20 (twenty) sheets from the
Medical Superintendent of AGMC & GBP
Hospital.
(ii)
On 26-10-2021 while Police took Smt. Piyushi
Datta to AGMC & GBP Hospital for treatment at
about 12.30 pm, at that time Dr. Anish
Majumder of AGMC & GBP Hospital medically
examined her.
(iii)
On 2nd occasion i.e. on 26-10-2021 evening she
was again admitted to the same hospital at
Female Surgical Ward, Unit-II, by her family
members and undergone treatment w.e.f. 2610-2021 to 01-11-2021 reportedly by the
internship doctors of the said hospital under the
supervision of Dr. Mani Ranjan Debbarma,
MBBS, M.S, Associate Professor, Dept. of
General Surgery of AGMC & GBP Hospital. A
requisition also submitted by the OC NCC PS to
the In-Charge of Female Surgical Unit-II of
AGMC & GBP Hospital to identify the signatures
of the medical officers in the collected Bed Head
Ticket of Smt. Piyushi Datta and to provide their
details which is not yet received.
(iv)
The details of treatment provided to the patient
Smt. Piyushi Datta is also mentioned in her Bed
Head Ticket.
A copy of the letter dated 22.12.2021 submitted
by SP(West) alongwith photocopy of Bed Head Ticket
containing other medical documents are annexed
hereto and marked as Annexure- R/7
A copy of the letter dated 21.12.2021 submitted
by O/C NCC PS is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure- R/8”
[6]
Thereafter, the Medical Superintendent, AGMC and GBP
Hospital submitted an additional affidavit on 05.05.2022 in which he
stated as under:
“1.
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
That, I am holding the post of Medical
Superintendent,
AGMC
&
GBP
Hospital,
Government of Tripura, and as such I am
competent to affirm this affidavit. Accordingly, I
am affirming this affidavit in pursuance to the
Order dated 20-12-2021 passed in W.P.(C) (PIL)
25 OF 2021.
Page - 5 of 18
2.
That, the affidavit is prepared to furnish some
facts before the Hon‟ble Court in pursuance to
the Order dated 20.12.2021 passed in W.P.(C)
(PIL) 25 OF 2021.
3.
That, the name of doctors who supervised Smti.
Piyushi Dutta‟s treatment is also to be mention
in this Court by affidavit. The Medical Report of
Smt. Piyushi Dutta has been prepared by the
Deptt. of General Surgery, AGMC & GBP
Hospital, Agartala.
A copy of the Medical Report of Smt. Piyushi
Dutta is annexed herewith and marked as
Annexure- R/1.”
[7]
Thereafter, pursuant to the request made by learned amicus
curiae, Smt. Priyashi Datta, victim was allowed to file an affidavit. She
filed the affidavit on 27.06.2022 in which she asserted as under:
“1. That, on 24.10.2021, one police constable
namely Biswajit Das and another police official
of G.B outpost came to my house at around
6.30/7 pm and took my husband Babul
Debnath to G.B Outpost for inquiry regarding
theft in the house of Laxmi Rani Ghosh. In the
outpost Biswajit Das, severely beaten and
tortured my husband as a result he was unable
to walk. At about 3.30/9 pm as my husband
was not coming home, I along with Kartik
Debnath, S/o: Nani Gopal Debnath, Mira
Debnath, W/o: Kartik Debnath, Rita Deb, W/O:
Swagatam Deb, Rina Das, W/o: Babul Das,
Sabitri Debnath, W/o: Kanu Debnath to make
inquiry about my husband. At that time my
husband was in lockup he was crying in pain
but we were not allowed to talk to him.
Thereafter at around 10/10:30 pm my husband
was taken to AGMC and GBP Hospital for
Medical checkup and from there he was
brought back to the G.B Outpost and was
released.
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
2.
That, thereafter on 25.10.2021, I along with my
husband was called to G.B outpost. We went
there at around 10.30 am, where we were
again inquired about the incident of theft in the
house of Laxmi Rani Ghosh. After inquiry we
were released. Again on the same day at
around 3 pm we were called and after
questioning, we were asked to visit on the next
day at around 10 am.
3.
That, on 26.10.2021, at around 10 am, I along
with my husband went to the G.B. outpost. On
that day, I was inquired by W/ASI Hemlata
Debbarma and W/C Pushpa Rani Sarkar. Smt
Page - 6 of 18
Hemlata Debbarma and Pushpa Rani Sarkar
took me into a room inside the outpost and
forced me to take the liability of the incident of
theft in the house of Laxmi Rani Ghosh and
when I did not agree with their proposal they
have ripped off my saree and started have
beating me with a wooden stick and as a result
of that, I was not able to stand. They have also
assaulted me and abused me in filthy language.
Thereafter, Hemlata Debbarma and Pushpa
Rani Sarkar took me to the AGMC & GBP
Hospital for Medical checkup. I was threatened
by them, that, if I utter anything about the
torture/assault, I will again be brought to the
Outpost and will be beaten. After medical
checkup, I was brought back to the G.B outpost
at around 4/4.30 pm. From there after putting
signature in the ledger book, I was released.
4.
That, after going home, I was feeling ill and I
fainted several times. Seeing my condition, my
family members took me to the Emergency
Ward of AGMC and GBP Hospital and after
checkup, I was admitted at the Female Surgical
Ward from 26.10.2021 to 01.11.2021 and was
treated there.
A copy discharge Certificate, dated
01.11.2021, is annexed herewith and is marked
as Annexure: P/1
5.
That, on 26.10.2021, my husband along with
almost 40 neighbours went to NCC P.S for
submitting complaint regarding the torture
made by ASI Smt. Hemlata Debbarma and
Constable Pushpa Rani Sarkar.
A copy of the Complaint, dated,
26.10.2021, is annexed herewith and is marked
as Annexure: P/2
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
6.
That, Laxmi Rani Ghosh is my next neighbor.
From past 2 years there has been dispute
regarding the boundary wall. We have no other
dispute with Laxmi Rani Ghosh and her family.
Laxmi Rani Ghosh is an influential person.
7.
That, lastly on 14.05.2022, at around 10 pm
Babul Debnath and Sabitri Debnath were
talking infront of our gate suddently Laxmi
Rani Ghosh and her daughter Sukla Ghosh
approached furiously towards my husband as
to why they were chatting at such late hours.
Hearing the commotion, when I went there to
stop the argument Laxmi Rani Ghosh and Sukla
Ghosh both have beaten me and then I was
rescued by my husband. Subsequently on that
night at around 11 pm I was taken to the AGMC
and GBP Hospital for treatment. In the
Hospital, I was suggested Xrays and CT Scan
but due to monetary issue I was not able run
the tests.
Page - 7 of 18
Copies of the prescription, dated,
14.05.2022, CT Scan, Xray requisitions, are
annexed herewith and is marked with as
Annexure:3”
[8]
We have heard Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. appearing
along with Mr. S. Saha, learned advocate for the State-respondents. We
have also heard Ms. A. Debbarma, learned amicus curiae. Perused the
affidavits submitted by the parties and the documents adduced on their
behalf.
[9]
The State-counsel has contended that there is no proof of
custodial torture on Smt. Priyashi Datta in police lockup. Counsel
contends that she was called to GB TOP for interrogation in connection
with a theft case and during interrogation she fell ill for which, she was
taken to AGMC and GBP hospital where she was given adequate medical
treatment. The State-counsel submits that the newspaper report about
custodial torture of the woman in police lockup is not true.
[10]
Ms. Debbarma, learned amicus curiae, on the other hand,
submits that the facts stated by the victim in her affidavit dated
27.06.2022 are shocking which reveal that on the basis of a false and
unverified allegation of theft, Smt. Priyashi Datta was called to GB TOP
where she was physically tortured in the name of interrogation. Counsel
contends that the victim has categorically stated in her affidavit that Smt.
Laxmi Rani Ghosh, an influential neighbour of her maliciously lodged a
false case of theft against her owing to their boundary dispute. Without
even registering any case on such complaint and without verifying the
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 8 of 18
veracity of the allegation, she was called to the police station where she
was physically tortured by two woman constables of police and as a
result of their torture she was hospitalized in AGMC and GBP hospital.
Counsel contends that in the medical report dated 06.04.2022 submitted
along with affidavit dated 05.05.2022 of the Medical Superintendent,
AGMC and GBP hospital, Agartala, it has been clearly stated that
abrasions were found over both buttocks of the victim after she was
brought to the hospital on 26.10.2021 with a history of physical assault.
Counsel further contends that the Indoor Patient Admission Ticket dated
26.10.2021 of the victim which has been submitted by the Staterespondents also revealed that swelling and bruises were found in the
gluteal region of her body when the victim was taken to the hospital on
26.10.2021 with a history of physical assault. Referring to the medical
report dated 06.04.2022 of the Associate Professor of the Department of
Surgery, AGMC & GBP hospital, Agartala, learned amicus curiae submits
that the doctor has clearly opined in his report that the cause of injury
was impact of hard and blunt force. Counsel submits that the materials
available on record are sufficient to establish the fact that this innocent
woman was beaten in police custody, as a result of which, she suffered
those injuries. Counsel, therefore, urges the Court to provide adequate
compensation to the victim besides issuing other directions as the Court
may deem fit and appropriate.
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 9 of 18
[11]
Admittedly, the victim was called to GB TOP on 26.10.2021
at around 11:55 hrs. for her interrogation in connection with a telephonic
information which was received from Smt. Laxmi Rani Ghosh, next door
neighbour of the victim who alleged that her gold-ornaments (measuring
8 bhori) were missing from her home and she suspected the involvement
of the victim and her husband in the matter. Apparently, no case was
registered on the said complaint received from said Smt. Laxmi Rani
Ghosh. The veracity of the facts was not even verified by police. But the
victim was called to the police outpost on 26.10.2021. As per police
version, during police interrogation, she was feeling unwell. Therefore,
she was produced before the Emergency Medical Officer, AGMC and GBP
hospital, Agartala for medical checkup. The Emergency Medical Officer on
examination of Smt. Priyashi Datta opined as under in his report dated
26.10.2021:
“On formal medical examination of the above noted person, brought
by police, it is found that, presently she is fit & healthy & mentally
alert.”
[12]
It is the case of the respondents that, during interrogation at
GB TOP, she felt unwell. She was then taken to the emergency unit of
AGMC and GBP hospital and after primary treatment, she was allowed to
go home along with her family members. Later on the day, her
neighbours appeared in NCC Police Station and complained that the
victim was physically assaulted by police in police custody in GB TOP, as
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 10 of 18
a result of which, she was admitted in hospital on 26.10.2021.
Admittedly, she was in hospital till her discharge on 01.11.2021.
[13]
As stated, when she was examined by a doctor in AGMC and
GBP hospital on 26.10.21 after she was produced in the hospital by
police, she was found completely fit, healthy and mentally alert. But, the
Indoor Patient Admission Ticket dated 26.10.2021 issued from the
Department of Orthopaedics, Unit-II would reveal that the following
injuries were present in her body:
“Diffuse swelling over the gluteal along with bruises mark over both
gluteus ”.
[14]
Even the medical report dated 06.04.2022 of Smt. Priyashi
Datta issued by Dr. Nilotpal Chakma, Associate Professor and In-charge
of Unit-II, Department of Surgery, clearly indicates that abrasions were
found over both buttocks of the victim on 26.10.2021 and the said doctor
has also opined that cause of injury was impact of hard and blunt force.
As such, injury recorded in the Indoor Patient Admission Ticket dated
26.10.2021 matches with the report of Dr. Nilotpal Chakma.
In these
circumstances, her allegations that she was tortured in GB TOP during
police interrogation on 26.10.2021 stand established.
[15]
From the facts and circumstances presented before us, it is
absolutely clear that merely on the basis of a telephonic information
received from a neighbour of the victim about her involvement in a theft
case, police called her to GB TOP even without registering a case on the
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 11 of 18
complaint received from Smt. Laxmi Rani Ghosh, neighbour of the victim
and without verifying the facts. From the medical reports available on
record, it stands established that she was physically assaulted during
interrogation in police custody.
[16]
In the case of Nilabati Behera (Smt) Alias Lalita Behera
(Through the Supreme Court Legal Aid Committee) vs. State of
Orissa and others reported in (1993) 2 SCC 746, the Hon’ble Apex
Court held that the convicts, prisoners or under-trials must not be
denuded of their fundamental rights under Article 21 and only such
restrictions as are permitted by law can be imposed. The prison authority
and the police would have the responsibility to ensure that the person in
custody is not deprived of his right to life, even if his liberty is
circumscribed by the fact that the person is in confinement. The Hon’ble
Court held that even limited liberty is precious and it is the duty of the
State to ensure that even a person in custody is dealt with in accordance
with the procedure established by law. It was further held by the Hon’ble
Apex Court that the Courts are under an obligation to grant relief in
exercise of its jurisdiction under Articles 32 and 226 of Constitution to the
victim or the heir of the victim whose fundamental rights under Article 21
of the Constitution of India are established to have been infringed by
calling upon the State to repair the damage done by its officers to the
fundamental rights of the citizens. Observations of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in paragraph 35 of the judgment are as under:
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 12 of 18
“35. This Court and the High Courts, being the protectors of the
civil liberties of the citizen, have not only the power and
jurisdiction but also an obligation to grant relief in exercise of its
jurisdiction under Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution to the
victim or the heir of the victim whose fundamental rights under
Article 21 of the Constitution of India are established to have been
flagrantly infringed by calling upon the State to repair the damage
done by its officers to the fundamental rights of the citizen,
notwithstanding the right of the citizen to the remedy by way of a
civil suit or criminal proceedings. The State, of course has the right
to be indemnified by and take such action as may be available to it
against the wrongdoer in accordance with law- through
appropriate proceedings. Of course, relief in exercise of the power
under Article 32 or 226 would be granted only once it is established
that there has been an infringement of the fundamental rights of
the citizen and no other form of appropriate redressal by the court
in the facts and circumstances of the case, is possible. The
decisions of this Court in the line of cases starting with Rudul Sah
v. State of Bihar granted monetary relief to the victims for
deprivation of their fundamental rights in proceedings through
petitions filed under Article 32 or 226 of the Constitution of India,
notwithstanding the rights available under the civil law to the
aggrieved party where the courts found that grant of such relief
was warranted. It is a sound policy to punish the wrongdoer and it
is in that spirit that the courts have moulded the relief by granting
compensation to the victims in exercise of their writ jurisdiction. In
doing so the courts take into account not only the interest of the
applicant and the respondent but also the interests of the public as
a whole with a view to ensure that public bodies or officials do not
act unlawfully and do perform their public duties properly
particularly where the fundamental right of a citizen under Aticle
21 is concerned. Law is in the process of development and the
process necessitates developing separate public law procedures as
also public law principles. It may be necessary to identify the
situations to which separate proceedings and principles apply and
the courts have to act firmly but with certain amount of
circumspection and self-restraint, lest proceedings under Article 32
or 226 are misused as a disguised substitute for civil action in
private law…………”
[17]
In a later decision in the case of Mehmood Nayyar Azam
vs. State of Chhattisgarh and others reported in (2012) 8 SCC 1, it
was held by the Hon’ble Apex Court that the police officers are under
obligations to protect human rights of a person in custody and prevent all
forms of atrocities to him/her. The Hon’ble Apex Court reiterated the
principles laid down in the case of Nilabati Behera (supra) and held as
under:
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 13 of 18
“38. It is imperative to state that it is the sacrosanct duty of
the police authorities to remember that a citizen while in
custody is not denuded of his fundamental right under Article
21 of the Constitution. The restrictions imposed have the
sanction of law by which his enjoyment of fundamental right
is curtailed but his basic human rights are not crippled so that
the police officers can treat him in an inhuman manner. On
the contrary, they are under obligation to protect his human
rights and prevent all forms of atrocities. We may hasten to
add that a balance has to be struck and, in this context, we
may fruitfully quote a passage from D. K. Basu [D.K. Basu V.
State of W.B., (1997) 1 SCC 416]: "33. There can be no gainsaying that freedom of an
individual must yield to the security of the State. The
right of preventive detention of individuals in the
interest of security of the State in various situations
prescribed under different statutes has been upheld by
the Courts. The right to interrogate the detenus,
culprits or arrestees in the interest of the nation, must
take precedence over an individual‟s right to personal
liberty….The action of the State, however, must be
„right, just and fair‟. Using any form of torture for
extracting any kind of information would neither be
‟right nor just nor fair‟ and, therefore, would be
impermissible, being offensive to Article 21. Such a
crime suspect must be interrogated - indeed subjected
to sustain and scientific interrogation-determined in
accordance with the provisions of law. He cannot,
however, be tortured or subjected to third degree
methods or eliminated with a view to elicit information,
extract confession or derive knowledge about his
accomplishes, weapons etc. His constitutional right
cannot be abridged [except] in the manner permitted
by law, though in the very nature of things there would
be qualitative difference in the method of interrogation
of such a person as compared to an ordinary criminal."
(emphasis in original)
39. In the case at hand, the appellant, while in custody, was
compelled to hold a placard in which condemning language
was written. He was photographed with the said placard and
the photograph was made public. It was also filed in a
revenue proceeding by the fifth respondent. The High Court
has recorded that the competent authority of the State has
conducted an enquiry and found the erring officers to be
guilty. The High Court has recorded the findings in the favour
of the appellant but left him to submit a representation to the
concerned authorities. This Court, as has been indicated
earlier, granted an opportunity to the State to deal with the
matter in an appropriate manner but it rejected the
representation and stated that it is not a case of defamation.
We may at once clarify that we are not at all concerned with
defamation as postulated under Section 499 of the IPC. We
are really concerned how in a country governed by rule of law
and where Article 21 of the Constitution is treated to be
sacred, the dignity and social reputation of a citizen has been
affected.
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 14 of 18
40. As we perceive, from the admitted facts borne out on
record, the appellant has been humiliated. Such treatment is
basically inhuman and causes mental trauma. In " Kaplan &
Sadock‟s Synopsis of Psychiatry", while dealing with torture,
the learned authors have stated that intentional physical and
psychological torture of one human by another can have
emotionally damaging effects comparable to, and possibly
worse than, those seen with combat and other types of
trauma. Any psychological torture inflicts immense mental
pain. A mental suffering at any age in life can carry the brunt
and may have nightmarish effect on the victim. The hurt
develops a sense of insecurity, helplessness and his selfrespect gets gradually atrophied. We have referred to such
aspects only to highlight that in the case at hand, the police
authorities possibly have some kind of sadistic pleasure or to
"please someone" meted out the appellant with this kind of
treatment.
41. It is not to be forgotten that when dignity is lost, the
breath of life gets into oblivion. In a society governed by rule
of law where humanity has to be a laser beam, as our
compassionate constitution has so emphasized, the police
authorities cannot show the power or prowess to vivisect and
dismember the same. When they pave such path, law cannot
become a silent spectator. As Pithily stated in Jennison v.
Baker [(1972) 2 QB 52]:"The law should not be seen to sit by limply, while
those who defy if go free, and those who seek its
protection lose hope."
42. Presently, we shall advert to the aspect of grant of
compensation. The learned counsel for the State, as has been
indicated earlier, has submitted with immense vehemence
that the appellant should sue for defamation. Our analysis
would clearly show that the appellant was tortured while he
was in custody. When there is contravention of human rights,
the inherent concern as envisaged in Article 21 springs to life
and enables the citizen to seek relief by taking recourse to
public law remedy.
43. In this regard, we may fruitfully refer to Nilabati Behera
v. State or Orissa [(1993) 2 SCC 746] wherein it has been
held thus: "17……A claim in public law for compensation for
contravention of human rights and fundamental
freedoms, the protection of which is guaranteed in the
Constitution, is an acknowledged remedy for
enforcement and protection of such rights, and such a
claim based on strict liability made by resorting to a
constitutional remedy provided for the enforcement of
a fundamental right is ‟distinct from, and in addition to,
the remedy in private law for damages for the tort‟
resulting from the contravention of the fundamental
right. The defence of sovereign immunity being
inapplicable, and alien to the concept of guarantee of
fundamental rights, there can be no question of such a
defence being available in the constitutional remedy. It
is this principle which justifies award of monetary
compensation for contravention of fundamental rights
guaranteed by the Constitution, when that is the only
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 15 of 18
practicable mode of redress available for the
contravention made by the State or its servants in the
purported exercise of their powers, and enforcement of
the fundamental right is claimed by resort to the
remedy in public law under the Constitution by
recourse to Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution.””
[18]
In the case of Dr. Ashwani Kumar vs. Union of India
and another reported in (2020) 13 SCC 585, the Hon’ble Apex Court
reiterated that a person detained in custody is entitled to live with human
dignity and any form of torture would violate the right to life and is
prohibited under Article 21 of the Constitution. The Apex Court observed
as under:
“37. However, this is not to state that the courts would not step
in, when required, to protect fundamental rights. It is
indisputable that the right to life and the right to liberty are
of foremost importance in a democratic state and, therefore,
any form of torture would violate the right to life and is
prohibited by Article 21 of the Constitution. Such action
would be unconstitutional under Article 21 and would fail
the test of non-arbitrariness under Article 14 of the
Constitution. Indeed, the courts have been at the forefront
in protecting and safeguarding individual rights. In 1982, on
the basis of a letter written by a journalist complaining of
custodial violence suffered by women prisoners in police
lock-ups in the city of Bombay, this Court in Sheela Barse v.
State of Maharashtra [(1983) 2 SCC 96] had issued the
guidelines to safeguard the rights of arrested persons
including female prisoners to afford them protection in
police lock-ups from possible torture or ill-treatment. A
person detained in a prison is entitled to live with human
dignity and his detention in prison should be regulated by a
procedure established by law which must be reasonable,
fair and just. This can be done by applying, elucidating and
even creatively expanding existing laws and principles on
case to case basis. Judiciary while exercising its jurisdiction
in this manner is not enacting or legislating but applying the
Constitution and protecting fundamental rights under
Article 21 of the Constitution.
38. This human right aspect was again highlighted in Nilabati
Behera v. State of Orissa [(19930 2 SCC 746] to state that
the convicts, prisoners or under-trials must not be denuded
of their fundamental rights under Article 21 and only such
restrictions as are permitted by law can be imposed. It is
the responsibility of the prison authority and the police to
ensure that the person in custody is not deprived of his right
to life, even if his liberty is circumscribed by the fact that
the person is in confinement. Even limited liberty is precious
and it is the duty of the State to ensure that even a person
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 16 of 18
in custody is dealt with in accordance with the procedure
established by law. In the State of Madhya Pradesh v.
Shyamsunder Trivedi [(1995) 4 SCC 262] this Court had
highlighted that a sensitive and realistic rather than a
narrow technical approach is required while dealing with
cases of custodial crime. The court must act within its
powers and as far as possible try that the guilty should not
escape to ensure that the rule of law prevails.”
[19]
In D.K. Basu vs. State of West Bengal reported in
(1997) 1 SCC 416, the Hon’ble Apex Court laid down the following
directions/guidelines with respect to rights of persons arrested/detained
in police custody for interrogation:
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
“(1)
The police personnel carrying out the arrest and handling
the interrogation of the arrestee should bear accurate,
visible and clear identification and name tags with their
designations. The particulars of all such police personnel
who handle interrogation of the arrestee must be recorded
in a register.
(2)
That the police officer carrying out the arrest of the arrestee
shall prepare a memo of arrest at the time of arrest and
such memo shall be attested by at least one witness, who
may be either a member of the family of the arrestee or a
respectable person of the locality from where the arrest is
made. It shall also be counter signed by the arrestee and
shall contain the time and date of arrest.
(3)
A person who has been arrested or detained and is being
held in custody in a police station or interrogation center or
other lock-up, shall be entitled to have one friend or relative
or other person known to him or having interest in his
welfare being informed, as soon as practicable, that he has
been arrested and is being detained at the particular place,
unless the attesting witness of the memo of arrest is himself
such a friend or a relative of the arrestee.
(4)
The time, place of arrest and venue of custody of an
arrestee must be notified by the police where the next
friend or relative of the arrestee lives outside the district or
town through the Legal Aid Organisation in the District and
the police station of the area concerned telegraphically
within a period of 8 to 12 hours after the arrest.
(5)
The person arrested must be made aware of this right to
have someone informed of his arrest or detention as soon as
he is put under arrest or is detained.
(6)
An entry must be made in the diary at the place of detention
regarding the arrest of the person which shall also disclose
the name of the next friend of the person who has been
informed of the arrest and the names and particulars of the
police officials in whose custody the arrestee is.
(7)
The arrestee should, where he so requests, be also
examined at the time of his arrest and major and minor
Page - 17 of 18
injuries, if any present on his/her body, must be recorded at
that time. The "Inspection Memo" must be signed both by
the arrestee and the police officer effecting the arrest and
its copy provided to the arrestee.
[20]
(8)
The arrestee should be subjected to medical examination by
a trained doctor every 48 hours during his detention in
custody by a doctor on the panel of approved doctors
appointed by Director, Health Services of the concerned
State or Union Territory concerned. Director, Health
Services should prepare such a penal for all tehsils and
districts as well.
(9)
Copies of all the documents including the memo of arrest,
referred to above, should be sent to the Illaqa Magistrate
for his record.
(10)
The arrestee may be permitted to meet his lawyer during
interrogation, though not throughout the interrogation.
(11)
A police control room should be provided at all district and
state headquarters, where information regarding the arrest
and the place of custody of the arrestee shall be
communicated by the officer causing the arrest, within 12
hours of effecting the arrest and at the police control room
it should be displayed on a conspicuous notice board.”
In the instant case, admittedly, the victim was not formally
arrested by police but, undisputedly, she was detained in the police
custody for a considerable period of time for the purpose of interrogation.
She was therefore entitled to all the safeguards provided under the
guidelines issued in the case of D.K. Basu (supra). But, apparently, she
was deprived of those safeguards and she was tortured and maltreated in
police custody.
[21]
Having observed thus, we are of the considered view that
she is entitled to monetary compensation for the wrongs done to her. In
view of the given facts and circumstances of the case, we direct the
State-respondents to pay a sum of Rs.2,50,000/- (Two Lakh Fifty
Thousand) to the victim namely, Smt. Priyashi Datta (Debnath). The said
amount of compensation be deposited by the respondents with the
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
Page - 18 of 18
Registry of this Court within one month from today. On deposit of the
said compensation, Registry shall disburse the whole amount to Smt.
Priyashi Datta, wife of Babul Debnath of East Chanmari, P.S. NCC,
Agartala, Tripura.
[22]
We make it clear that the observations made herein-above,
shall not have any bearing on any prosecution/proceeding, if any, in
connection with the alleged incident.
[23]
At the end, we record our appreciation for Ms. A. Debbarma,
learned amicus curiae appointed by us for her sincere assistance in the
matter. She will be paid a sum of Rs. 12,000/- (Twelve Thousand) by the
High Court Legal Services Committee as honourarium. A copy of this
order be communicated to the Secretary to the High Court Legal Services
Committee immediately. A copy of this order shall also be communicated
to the Director General of Police to ensure strict compliance of the
directions/guidelines issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
D.K. Basu (supra) with respect to the rights of the persons arrested or
detained and held up in police custody or interrogation-center or other
lockups.
In terms of the above, the matter stands disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY), J
Sabyasachi G.
W.P.(C) (PIL) No. 25/2021
(INDRAJIT MAHANTY), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review