Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)(PIL) 14 OF 2022
Court on its own motion Vrs. The State of Tripura
Present:
For Court on its own
motion
For the respondent (s)
: None.
: Mr. S. S. Dey, Advocate General,
Ms. Ayantika Chakraborty, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
16.05.2023
Order
Reference is made to the order dated 1st May, 2023 which
reads as under:
“The present public interest litigation was instituted in view of
the directions passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Satender
Kumar Antil vrs. Central Bureau of Investigation & another in
Miscellaneous Application No.1849/2021 arising out of Special Leave
Petition (Crl.) No.5191 of 2021 along with other petition dated
11.07.2022.
The Coordinate Bench of this Court presided over by the then
Hon'ble Chief Justice vide order dated 21.09.2022 had issued directions
upon the Registrar General of this Court to seek information from all the
District & Sessions Judges of the respective districts of the State of
Tripura detailing therein the period of custody of each of the Under Trial
Prisoners and the provisions of law under which their custody has been
directed and also to see whether any of these persons come under the
category as per the decisions in Bhim Singh vrs. Union of India &
others reported in (2015) 13 SCC 605 or not. In all such cases, the
learned District & Sessions Judges and the trial Courts were asked to
consider each case on its own merit under the mandate vested under
Section 436A of the Cr.P.C. and take necessary steps in that regard as
per the directions of the Apex Court in Bhim Singh (supra). Learned
Advocate General was also directed to request the Public Prosecutors of
all the districts as well as the officials to cooperate in the matter and the
prison authorities of the State to provide all necessary details of the
period for which the UTPs are in custody to the respective Courts. Such
details have been received and collated by the learned Registrar General
of this Court pursuant to the order dated 15.11.2022. The report is at
Flag-X which reads as under:
"The report as asked for is as follows:
1. District & Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala:As per report of the District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala there
are in total 47 numbers of UTPs in the district. However, no
report has been given regarding any of the UTPs to have come
under the mandate of 436A of CrPC, that is none of the UTPs is
reported to have served more than half of the maximum
punishment of the offence for which they are charged with.
(Report enclosed at Flag-A)
2. District & Sessions Judge, Dhalai, Ambassa:- As per
report of the District Judge, Dhalai, Ambassa there are in total
32 numbers of UTPs in the district and the highest period of
detention amongst them is 03 years 03 months and 15 days.
However, no report has been given regarding any of the UTPs to
have come under the mandate of 436A of CrPC, that is none of
the UTPs is reported to have served more than half of the
maximum punishment of the offence for which they are
charged with. (Report enclosed at Flag-B)
3. District & Sessions Judge, Sepahijala, Sonamura:- As
per report of the District Judge, Sepahijala, Sonamura there are
in total 38 numbers of UTPs in the district and the highest period
of detention amongst them is 02 years 06 months and 20 days.
However, no report has been given regarding any of the UTPs to
have come under the mandate of 436A of CrPC, that is none of
the UTPs is reported to have served more than half of the
maximum punishment of the offence for which they are
charged with. (Report enclosed at Flag-C)
4. District & Sessions Judge, Belonia, South Tripura:As per report of the District Judge, Belonia, South Tripura there
are in total 09 numbers of UTPs in the district and the highest
period of detention amongst them is 01 year 02 months and 02
days. However, no report has been given regarding any of the
UTPs to have come under the mandate of 436A of CrPC, that is
none of the UTPs is reported to have served more than half of
the maximum punishment of the offence for which they are
charged with. (Report enclosed at Flag-D)
5. District & Sessions Judge, Dharmanagar, North
Tripura:- The District & Sessions Judge reported that on receipt
of the above said order he has done the exercise of finding out
such UTPs who may come under the purview of Section 436A of
CrPC and found that there is no such case pending. (Report
enclosed at Flag-E)
6. District & Sessions Judge, Khowai:- As per report of
the District Judge, Khowai there are in total 81 numbers of UTPs
in the district. However, no report has been given regarding any
of the UTPs to have come under the mandate of 436A of CrPC,
that is none of the UTPs is reported to have served more than
half of the maximum punishment of the offence for which they
are charged with. (Report enclosed at Flag-F)
7. District & Sessions Judge, Unakoti, Kailashahar:- As
per report of the District Judge, Unakoti, Kailashahar there are
in total 34 numbers of UTPs in the district and the highest period
of detention amongst them is 802 days. However, no report has
been given regarding any of the UTPs to have come under the
mandate of 436A of CrPC, that is none of the UTPs is reported
to have served more than half of the maximum punishment of
the offence for which they are charged with. (Report enclosed at
Flag-G)
8. District & Sessions Judge, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura:As per report of the District Judge, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura
there are in total 09 numbers of UTPs in the district. However, no
report has been given regarding any of the UTPs to have come
under the mandate of 436A of CrPC, that is none of the UTPs is
reported to have served more than half of the maximum
punishment of the offence for which they are charged with.
(Report enclosed at Flag-H)"
Vide order dated 29.11.2022, learned Registrar General was
again directed to obtain a detailed report from the State Legal Services
Authority for supplementing the report filed by the Registrar General of
this Court.
The Member Secretary, Tripura State Legal Services Authority,
has submitted a report which is through letter dated 09.12.2022 at FlagA. It only encloses the detailed report furnished by the Secretary of
District Legal Services Authority of all the 8(eight) districts.
The Member Secretary, Tripura State Legal Services Authority, is
directed to compile the reports received from the concerned District
Legal Services Authorities and update it with the latest information as to
the status of custody of all under trial prisoners within the mandate of
Section 436A of the Cr.P.C. within a period of 2(two) weeks.
Let a comprehensive and updated report be furnished by the
Member Secretary, Tripura State Legal Services Authority, by the next
date.
Let the matter may appear on 16.05.2023.
A report has been submitted by the Deputy Secretary, Tripura
State Legal Services Authority bearing letter No.3031, dated 15 th May,2023
which is a compiled report with latest information received from the
Secretaries of DLSAs enclosed as Annexure-A as to the status of custody
of all the under trial prisoners within the mandate of Section 436A of the
CrPC.
The report is extracted hereunder:
“Report in Compliance of Order dated 01.05.2023 passed by the High
Court of Tripura in WP (C) (PIL) 14 of 2022.
By the Order dated 01.05.2023, the Hon’ble High Court directed the
undersigned to compile the reports received from the concerned District
Legal Services Authorities and update it with latest information as to the
status of custody of all the Under trial Prisoners within the mandate of
Section 436A of Cr.P.C.
After receiving the order of Hon’ble Court, the same was communicated
to all the 08 (Eight) Secretaries of District Legal Services Authorities and
reports are collected. Besides, I have also compiled the previous reports
sent by the Secretaries, District Legal Services Authorities and updated it
with latest information (Compiled report enclosed at Annexure- A).
After compiling the reports as received from concerned District Legal
Services Authorities with latest information as to the status of custody of all
under trial prisoners within the mandate of Sec. 436A of Cr.P.C the
following report is prepared.
01. North Tripura District:- As per report dated 07.12.2022 as submitted by
the Secretary, District Legal Services Authority, North Tripura, there were
total 09 numbers of UTPs in custody. But none of the UTPs is reported to
come under the mandate of Section 436A of Cr.P.C.
From the updated report of the Secretary, District Legal Services
Authority, North Tripura sent to us on 08.05.2023, it appears that out of
those 09 numbers of UTPs, 03 nos. UTPs are released on bail and 01 no.
UTP is convicted in another case. And the rest 05 Nos. of UTPs do not come
under the mandate of 436A Cr. P.C.
Further from the updated report, it appears that at present there are
16 nos. of UTPs in North Tripura District and none of the UTPs comes
under the mandate of 436A Cr. P.C.
02. South Tripura District:- As per report dated 07.12.2022 as submitted by
the Secretary, District Legal Services Authority, South Tripura, there were
total 12 numbers of UTPs in custody. But none of the UTPs is reported to
come under the mandate of Section 436A of Cr.P.C.
From the updated report of the Secretary, District Legal Services
Authority, South Tripura sent to us on 12.05.2023, it appears that out of
those 12 numbers of UTPs, 04 nos. UTPs are released on bail and 06 nos.
UTPs are convicted in another case and 02 UTPs are acquitted and they do
not come under the mandate of 436A Cr.P.C.
Further from the updated report, it appears that at present there are
42 nos. of UTPs in South Tripura District and none of the UTPs comes
under the mandate of 436A Cr. P.C.
03. Unakoti District:- As per report dated 07.12.2022 as submitted by the
Secretary, District Legal Services Authority, Unakoti District there were
total 46 numbers of UTPs in custody. But none of the UTPs is reported to
come under the mandate of Section 436A of Cr.P.C.
From the updated report of the Secretary, District Legal Services
Authority, Unakoti District sent to us on 10.05.2023, it appears that out of
those 46 numbers of UTPs, 25 nos. UTPs are released on bail and 12 nos.
UTPs are convicted in another case, 03 UTPs are acquitted and 06 Nos. of
UTPs are still in Jail Custody. None of them comes under the mandate of
436A Cr. P.C.
Further for the updated report it appears that at present there are
53 nos. of UTPs in Unakoti District and none of the UTPs comes under the
mandate of 436A Cr. P.C.
04. Gomati District:- As per report dated 07.12.2022 as submitted by the
Secretary, District Legal Services Authority, South Tripura, there were
total 58 numbers of UTPs in custody. But none of the UTPs is reported to
come under the mandate of Section 436A of Cr.P.C.
From the updated report of the Secretary, District Legal Services
Authority, Gomati Tripura sent to us on 10.05.2023, it appears that out of
those 58 numbers of UTPs, 30 nos. UTPs are released on bail and 05 nos.
UTPs are convicted in another case, 01 no.UTP is acquitted and 22 Nos. of
UTPs are still in Jail Custody. None of them comes under the mandate of
436A Cr. P.C
Further from the updated report, it appears that at present there
are 39 nos. of UTPs in Gomati District and none of the UTPs comes under
the mandate of 436A Cr. P.C.
05.West Tripura District:- As per report dated 07.12.2022 as submitted by the
Secretary, District Legal Services Authority, West Tripura, there were total
199 numbers of UTPs in custody. But none of the UTPs is reported to come
under the mandate of Section 436A of Cr.P.C.
From the updated report of the Secretary, District Legal Services
Authority, West Tripura sent to us on 13.05.2023, it appears that out of
those 199 numbers of UTPs, 138 nos. UTPs are released on bail and 03 nos.
UTPs are convicted in another case, 01 no. UTP is acquitted and 56 Nos. of
UTPs are still in Jail Custody and 01 No. of UTP is escaped from AGMC
Hospital on 03.01.2023. None of them comes under the mandate of 436A
Cr. P.C
Further from the updated report, it appears that at present there are
244 nos. of UTPs in West Tripura District and none of the UTPs come
under the mandate of 436A Cr. P.C.
06. Khowai District:- As per report dated 08.12.2022 as submitted by the
Secretary, District Legal Services Authority, Khowai District, there were
total 89 numbers of UTPs in custody. But none of the UTPs is reported to
come under the mandate of Section 436A of Cr.P.C.
From the updated report of the Secretary, District Legal Services
Authority, Khowai District, sent to us on 13.05.2023, it appears that out of
those 89 numbers of UTPs, 59 nos. UTPs are released on bail and 30 Nos.
of UTPs are still in Jail Custody and None of them comes under the
mandate of 436A Cr. P.C
Further from the updated report, it appears that at present there
are 66 nos. of UTPs in Khowai Tripura District and none of the UTPs
comes under the mandate of 436A Cr. P.C.
07.Sepahaijala District:- As per report dated 08.12.2022 as submitted by the
Secretary, District Legal Services Authority, Sepahaijala District, there
were total 64 numbers of UTPs in custody. But none of the UTPs is reported
to come under the mandate of Section 436A of Cr.P.C.
From the updated report of the Secretary, District Legal Services
Authority, Sepahaijala District sent to us on 11.05.2023, it appears that out
of those 64 numbers of UTPs, 41 nos. UTPs are released on bail and 22
Nos. of UTPs are still in Jail Custody and None of them comes under the
mandate of 436A Cr. P.C.
Further from the updated report, it appears that at present there
are 81 nos. of UTPs in Sepahaijala District and none of the UTPs comes
under the mandate of 436A Cr. P.C.
08. Dhalai District: - As per report dated 08.12.2022 as submitted by the
Secretary, District Legal Services Authority, Dhalai District, there were
total 57 numbers of UTPs in custody. But none of the UTPs is reported to
come under the mandate of Section 436A of Cr.P.C.
From the updated report of the Secretary, District Legal Services
Authority, Dhalai District sent to us on 15.05.2023, it appears that out of
those 65 numbers of UTPs, 45 nos. UTPs are released on bail, 07 nos. are
convicted and 13 Nos. of UTPs are still in Jail Custody and none of them
comes under the mandate of 436A Cr. P.C
Further from the updated report, it appears that at present there
are 22 nos. of UTPs in Dhalai District and none of the UTPs comes under
the mandate of 436A Cr. P.C.
Submitted by
Sd/(D.M.Jamatia)
Member Secretary,
Tripura State Legal Services Authority”
Learned Advocate General appears for the State. A perusal of
the report shows that though there are under trial prisoners in the concerned
Districts, but none of them come under the mandate of Section 436A of the
CrPC that means none of them have remained for more than half of the
sentence in custody during trial till now.
Learned Advocate General submits that in view of the updated
report received once again from the Tripura State Legal Services Authority,
the instant public interest litigation may be closed.
Compliance of the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
may be carried out by the State Legal Services Authority as directed.
Having regard to the aforesaid facts and circumstances
brought on record through the latest report of the State Legal Services
Authority, it appears that no under trial prisoners falls within the mandate
of Section 436A of the CrPC in any of the Districts of Tripura as on date.
As such, there is no purpose in keeping the instant petition pending and
accordingly, it is closed.
(ARINDAM LODH),J
sanjay
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH),CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review