The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
02. 09.2022 submitted on behalf of the State along with the Affidavit dated 03.09.2022 sworn by the Under Secretary, Home Department, Government of Tripura. Paragraph 4 & 5 of the said affidavit reads as under: “4. That, it is humbly stated that there are about 21 (twenty-one) number of total cases registered, and 18 (eighteen) number of cases have been disposed of by submitting Charge sheet and/or Final Report, 3(three) number of cases are pending out of which 1(one) number case viz., West Agartala PS Case No.181 of 2021, Hon’ble Supreme Court have stayed the investigation and rest two cases shall be disposed shortly within a period of sixty days. A Copy of the Stay Order passed by Hon’ble Apex Court in respect to West Agartala PS Case No.181 of 2021 is annexed herewith and marked as ANNEXURE-F.
5. That the humble Deponent most humbly further avows that the concerned authorities/officers shall try to complete the investigation either by submitting Charge sheet or Final Report in pending cases within a period of 60 days from 01/09/2022, except West Agartala PS case No.181 of 2021, investigation of which has been stayed by the Hon’ble Apex Court.” The status report indicates that in 7 cases out of 21 cases registered, charge-sheet has been filed and final report has been submitted in 11 cases. 3 cases are pending for investigation. [17] With regard to payment of compensation, the State- respondents in their Affidavit dated 10.02.2022 sworn by the Under Secretary to the Revenue Department have stated as under: Page - 10 of 11 “3. That as per Order dated 28/01/2022 the Hon’ble Court decreed the State Respondents “…..to file a specific affidavit giving the names as well as the amounts of compensation said to have been given to the alleged victims.” in pursuance to the Order the humble Deponent humbly averts that the compensation amount has been disbursed as per the amount prescribed in the scheme viz., Tripura Lynching/mob violence Victim Compensation scheme, 2018. Further, the Sub-Divisional Magistrate has yet again conducted an enquiry in this respect on 12/01/2022 to identify whether if any other victim(s) were left out, and upon such enquiry further 8 (eight) more numbers …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page - 1 of 11
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) (PIL) 22/2021
Court on its own motion
………. Petitioner(s).
Vs.
1.
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary, Government of Tripura, Department of
Home, Civil Secretariat, New Capital Complex, Agartala, PIN- 799010,
2.
Director General of Police,
Government of Tripura, Police Head Quarters, Fire Brigade Chowmohani,
PO- Agartala, West Tripura, PIN- 799001,
3.
Superintendent of Police, West Tripura District, Tripura,
4.
Superintendent of Police, North Tripura District, Tripura,
5.
Superintendent of Police, Gomati District, Tripura,
6.
Superintendent of Police, Khowai District, Tripura,
7.
Superintendent of Police, Dhalai District, Tripura,
8.
Superintendent of Police, Sepahijala District, Tripura,
9.
Superintendent of Police, Unakoti District, Tripura,
10.
Superintendent of Police, South Tripura District, Tripura.
………….Respondent(s).
BEF0RE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. INDRAJIT MAHANTY
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
For Petitioner(s)
:
None.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General.
Ms. Ayantika Chakraborty, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
5th September, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
Page - 2 of 11
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
(Per S.G. Chattopadhyay, J.)
This suo motu public interest litigation came to be
registered on the basis of newspaper reports published in various
national and local dailies reporting the widespread violence which
occurred in North Tripura district, Unakoti district and Sepahijala
district in Tripura on 26th October, 2021.
[2]
On 29.10.2021, when the matter was first taken up,
learned Advocate General submitted a brief note before the Court
indicating various steps taken by the State Government to prevent
the spread of violence and book the perpetrators of the crime.
Having considered the said note of the learned Advocate General and
the submissions made by him, the following order was passed by this
Court on 29.10.2021:
“After the learned Advocate General brought to our notice the
developments as noted hereinabove, the Court indicated to the
learned Advocate General its sole concern i.e. the protection of
life, liberty and property of all citizens of Tripura. There can be no
reiteration that the State owes its responsibilities insofar as
maintenance of law and order as well as providing citizens with
the security to protect their life, livelihood as well as their
properties. Today’s local newspapers of Tripura indicate that an
uneasy calm is prevalent and no repetition of the occurrences
which took place on 26th October, 2021 has yet taken place. It is
further informed that all necessary steps are being taken by the
State to ensure that such occurrences are not repeated.
While taking note of the developments as noted hereinabove,
this Court also considers it appropriate to take note of the fact
Page - 3 of 11
that various peace committees have been formed in various
locations where communal strife exists. While commending such
efforts on the part of the state, this Court also commends the
steps taken by various political parties to restore peace and order
within the state. These steps, in our considered view, will go a
long way in regaining the confidence of the citizens at large.
However, these steps need to be further expanded. Accordingly,
the state may consider forming peace committees not only at
district levels but also at sub-divisional levels and if necessary at
panchayet levels as well and we call upon all political parties to
participate fully in such peace process so that confidence of the
people of the state can be restored and the underlying strife that
exists can be suitably dealt with.
Various cases have been registered pursuant to the violence
that took place on 26th October, 2021 and incidence which took
place prior thereto. We call upon the state to file an affidavit
stating the stages at which the investigation is going on and as to
whether any accused has been apprehended in such manner.
This Court also takes into notice of the fact that the Hon’ble
Chief Minister of the State has reported in the local press
yesterday as well as today that he has directed the officials
concerned to compute the damages that have occurred and to
immediately see the compensation as deemed appropriate is
granted to them. We direct the state to take urgent action in this
regard so that the livelihood of persons who have lost their
source of income can be restored at the earliest.
In this regard, we wish to record our appreciation of the media
at large, in particular the print media who appear to have taken
up a very active positive role in trying to restore peace and order
within the state. We assert that the media shall remain vigilant at
all time and continue discharging its duty in a responsible manner
which it has already exhibited. However, it is brought to our
notice by the Advocate General that social media in particular
have been carrying certain articles or visual footages which are
either morphed and/or unrelated to the State of Tripura with sole
intent of once again reigniting the passions of people. We direct
the State to initiate appropriate action against all such social
media platforms in order to ensure that such false, fictitious and
or fabricated news articles or visual footages do not come on to
the social media platforms and even if they do so that they are
removed at the earliest opportunity. This Court calls upon the
social media platforms to also act responsibly since today. Media
has every right, as a part of their activities to publish the truth. It
should not be allowed to be used to spread untruth and spread
communal passion.”
[3]
The State respondents were directed to file affidavit
before this Court on or before 10.11.2021 indicating the preventive
Page - 4 of 11
measures taken by them and their plan of scuttling the design of
stoking communal passion.
[4]
Pursuant to the order dated 29.10.2021, three affidavits
came to be filed on behalf of the State-respondents indicating the
status of investigation, payment of interim compensation to the
victims of violence as well as constitution of various peace
committees across the State.
[5]
From the statement annexed to the affidavit dated
08.11.2011 sworn by the Under Secretary to the Revenue
Department, it would appear that as many as 19 victims of the
violence were identified in North Tripura district and compensation
was paid to them for the loss suffered by them in the alleged
violence.
[6]
From the affidavit dated 09.11.2021 sworn by the Under
Secretary to the Department of Home, it would appear that peace
committees consisting of representatives of the cross-sections of the
society were constituted in all districts across the State to prevent
communal tension and promote harmony. Several cases were also
registered against the perpetrators of the violence and investigation
of those cases were taken up.
Page - 5 of 11
[7]
By another affidavit dated 17.11.2021 sworn by the
Under Secretary to the Home Department, Government of Tripura,
the State-respondents submitted the details of various fake Facebook
posts, fake twits etc. relating to the alleged incidence.
[8]
By order dated 19.11.2021, the State-respondents were
directed to submit further affidavit indicating the updated status of
investigation of various cases arising out of the incident and provide
the details and the methodology adopted by the State for computing
the amount of compensation awarded to the victims of violence.
[9]
Thereafter, by order dated 28.01.2022, the State-
respondents were directed to file a reconciled statement of various
measures taken by them to compensate the victims of the violence
and apprise the Court of the status of investigation of each of the
cases registered against the accused persons.
[10]
Pursuant to the aforesaid directions, an affidavit came to
be filed on 10.02.2022 by the State-respondents in which, AnnexureA was appended disclosing the names of the persons who suffered
damage due to the violence and the amounts of compensation
paid/disbursed to them. The said affidavit was taken on record and
the following submissions of learned Advocate General was recorded
under order dated 11.02.2022:
Page - 6 of 11
“Heard learned Advocate General Mr. S.S. Dey for the State.
Learned Advocate General submits that there is another
petition being Writ Petition(s)(Criminal) No.504 of 2021 along with
IA No.156827/2021 and IA No.156828/2021 pending before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court which are under consideration. It is stated
that the aforesaid writ petition and the two interlocutory
applications were filed before the Hon’ble Apex Court by persons
who are being prosecuted by the State for having placed certain
articles in the social media. Learned Advocate General further
submits that he has in his affidavit before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court indicated that the High Court here at Tripura had registered a
PIL on 28.10.2021 on the issue of alleged violence which had taken
place on 26.10.2021 in North Tripura District. Various directions
have been passed in this matter calling upon the State to apprise
this Court about the prosecution of cases pertaining to alleged
violence which had taken place in North Tripura.
Learned Advocate General also submits that the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has called upon the State to provide details of all
arrest and/or investigation into all matters pertaining to the North
Tripura violence and affidavits are in the course of being filed before
the Hon’ble Supreme Court.”
[11]
The matter was then adjourned for a period of three
months and it was directed that once the Hon’ble Supreme Court
disposes the matter, State would be at liberty to bring the same to
the notice of this Court for earlier listing, if required.
[12]
On 08.03.2022, learned Advocate General submitted copy
of the order dated 25.02.2022 passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Writ Petition (Civil) No.1257/2021 which reads as under:
“UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following
ORDER
1.
A Division Bench of the High Court of Tripura headed by the
learned Chief Justice has entertained a Public Interest
Litigation suo moto under Article 226 of the Constitution.
For the record, the proceedings before this Court contain, at
Annexure P-9, a copy of an order dated 29 October 2021
passed by the Division Bench. The first paragraph of the
order indicates the genesis of the suo moto proceedings and
is reproduced below:
Page - 7 of 11
“This suo motu public interest litigation was
registered on the basis of various press reports
both in National newspapers as well as local
newspapers on the issue of violence which
occurred on 26th October, 2021 in North
Tripura District, Unakoti District as well as
Sipahijala District. On notices being issued
through the learned Advocate General, learned
Advocate General provided a brief note
indicating some of the important steps taken
by the State of Tripura to bring about
communal harmony as well as action taken
against the perpetrator of such violence.”
[13]
2.
The High Court is seized of the suo moto proceedings.
3.
Having regard to the above position, it would be appropriate
if the issues which are sought to be highlighted by the
petitioner in these proceedings under Article 32 of the
Constitution are permitted to be raised before the High
Court by the petitioner by filing an application for
intervention. We permit the petitioner to assist the High
Court so that a comprehensive view can be taken on all
aspects, including those which have been raised in the
present proceedings under Article 32 of the Constitution.
4.
Mr Prashant Bhushan, learned counsel submits that the
petitioner apprehends that coercive steps may be adopted
by the state police authorities for the petitioner having
raised the issue in the public realm. In view of the
apprehension, and without this Court expressing any
opinion on the merits of the case, we permit the petitioner
to make a request before the learned Chief Justice of the
High Court to be allowed to make submissions through
counsel on the video conferencing platform. Such a request
may be appropriately considered by the Division Bench of
the High Court.
5.
In the event that the petitioner seeks to appear physically
before the High Court, he would be at liberty to do so. No
coercive steps shall be taken by the Tripura police, nor shall
any precipitate action be taken which would impede his
access to justice. All the rights and contentions of the
parties are kept open. We request the High Court to take up
the proceedings expeditiously.
6.
We accordingly dispose of the present proceedings.
7.
Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.”
The matter was thereafter listed before this Court on
14.03.2022 when the following order was passed:
“……………….The State is directed to provide a list of all pending
cases and the status of investigation into those matters as well as to
Page - 8 of 11
indicate as to whether any accused has been arrested and/or
granted bail by competent Courts. Such list be prepared at the
earliest and filed before this Court.
In the meantime, the learned Advocate General is requested to
issue necessary directives for conclusion of the investigation at the
earliest.”
[14]
On 25.03.2022, the Hon’ble Apex Court passed the
following order in Writ Petition(s) (Criminal) No(s). 80/2022:
“1
[15]
Issue notice.
Tag with Writ Petition (Crl) No 470 of 2021.
3.
Pending further orders, there shall be a stay of
further proceedings in Case No. 2021 WAG 181
dated 3 November 2021, West Agartala Police
Station, Tripura.”
Heard Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate General appearing
for the State. It is submitted by learned Advocate General that the
latest status report dated 02.09.2022 prepared by AIGP (Law &
Order) of the Government of Tripura would indicate that for the
reported incidence of violence, as many as 21 cases have been
registered across the State. In 7 cases, charge-sheets have been filed
and in 11 cases, final reports have been submitted. 3 cases are
pending for investigation. Counsel has further contended that
adequate compensation has been provided to the victims of the
violence by following appropriate methodology for determination of
Page - 9 of 11
compensation in terms of the order of this Court. Learned counsel,
therefore, urges the Court to dispose the matter.
[16]
We
have
gone
through
the
status
report
dated
02.09.2022 submitted on behalf of the State along with the Affidavit
dated 03.09.2022 sworn by the Under Secretary, Home Department,
Government of Tripura. Paragraph 4 & 5 of the said affidavit reads as
under:
“4. That, it is humbly stated that there are about 21 (twenty-one)
number of total cases registered, and 18 (eighteen) number of
cases have been disposed of by submitting Charge sheet and/or
Final Report, 3(three) number of cases are pending out of which
1(one) number case viz., West Agartala PS Case No.181 of 2021,
Hon’ble Supreme Court have stayed the investigation and rest
two cases shall be disposed shortly within a period of sixty
days.
A Copy of the Stay Order passed by Hon’ble Apex Court
in respect to West Agartala PS Case No.181 of 2021 is
annexed herewith and marked as ANNEXURE-F.
5. That the humble Deponent most humbly further avows that the
concerned authorities/officers shall try to complete the
investigation either by submitting Charge sheet or Final Report in
pending cases within a period of 60 days from 01/09/2022,
except West Agartala PS case No.181 of 2021, investigation of
which has been stayed by the Hon’ble Apex Court.”
The status report indicates that in 7 cases out of 21 cases
registered, charge-sheet has been filed and final report has been
submitted in 11 cases. 3 cases are pending for investigation.
[17]
With regard to payment of compensation, the State-
respondents in their Affidavit dated 10.02.2022 sworn by the Under
Secretary to the Revenue Department have stated as under:
Page - 10 of 11
“3.
That as per Order dated 28/01/2022 the Hon’ble Court decreed
the State Respondents “…..to file a specific affidavit giving the
names as well as the amounts of compensation said to have
been given to the alleged victims.” in pursuance to the Order
the humble Deponent humbly averts that the compensation
amount has been disbursed as per the amount prescribed in the
scheme
viz.,
Tripura
Lynching/mob
violence
Victim
Compensation scheme, 2018. Further, the Sub-Divisional
Magistrate has yet again conducted an enquiry in this respect
on 12/01/2022 to identify whether if any other victim(s) were
left out, and upon such enquiry further 8 (eight) more numbers
of victims have been identified.
4.
That the humble answering Respondents most humbly avows
that the entire amount of compensation to all the victims have
been disbursed as per the scheme.
The copy of the report of disbursement of the compensation to
the
victim(s)
including
their
names
vide
Letter
No.F2(6)/SDM/PNS/ Disaster/2018-19/112 dated 12/01/2022
have been annexed herein for reference and marked as
ANNEXURE A.”
It appears from Annexure-A appended to the said Affidavit that
total amount of Rs.5,33,400/- along with interim relief of Rs.74,000/has been paid to 22 victims and the methodology prescribed under
Tripura lynching/mob violence Victim Compensation Scheme, 2018
has been followed in determining the compensation.
[18]
In view of the above, we are closing the matter with the
following directions to the State-respondents:
i.
The pending investigations except those which are
challenged before the Hon’ble Supreme Court shall
be completed at the earliest subject to the
order(s)/direction(s) of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
passed in this regard.
ii.
The State shall continue to identify the victims of
the violence who are yet to be identified and
Page - 11 of 11
provide adequate compensation to them after
appropriately assessing their loss.
iii.
The State shall create permanent mechanism at the
block level across the State to prevent recurrence of
such incidents.
iv.
Compliance affidavit shall be filed within a period of
three months from today.
In terms of the above, the matter stands disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY), J
Sabyasachi G.
(INDRAJIT MAHANTY), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review