Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)(PIL) No. 20 of 2021
Court on its own motion
..........Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 7 Ors.
-----Respondent(s)
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. INDRAJIT MAHANTY
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. H.K.Bhowmik, Adv. (Amicus Curiae)
For Respondent(s) : Mr. B.Majumder, ASG
Mr. S.S.Dey, Advocate General
Ms. Ayantika Chakraborty, Adv
Date of hearing
& delivery of
Judgment /Order
: 27.07.2022
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
YES / NO
Judgment & Order(Oral)
(Per S.G.Chattopadhyay), J
[1]
On October 12, 2021 a news item came to be
published in a local daily namely ‘Tripura Observer’ under the
heading ‘Karbong Community at verge of extinction’. An
extensive report about this tribal group was made which
indicated that it was likely to be extinct soon unless proper
measures were taken for its protection. The Chief Justice took
suo moto notice of this grave and serious issue on the basis of
the said newspaper report and pursuant to his direction, this
Public Interest Litigation came to be registered.
[2]
Notices were issued to the respondents including
Oil and Natural Gas Corporation (ONGC) [Respondent No.6]
since it was reported that ONGC adopted the Karbong para
village in Teliamura to provide educational and health care
support including safe drinking water to the members of this
community
towards
discharge
of
their
Corporate
Social
Responsibility (CSR). ONGC [Respondent No.6] was directed
to submit an affidavit indicating the steps actually taken by
them to support the ‘karbong’ community.
[3]
The learned Advocate General appearing for the
state and learned ASG representing the Union of India were
requested to form a team of appropriate officials to visit
Karbong Para in Rupaicherra panchayat of Teliamura subdivision and make an assessment about the needs of the
community and submit a report supported by an affidavit. The
state as well as the Union of India was also requested to
undertake all appropriate measures that would be necessary
to protect the members of the community without awaiting
further direction of the court.
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
[4]
On 19.11.2021 when the matter came up for
hearing, the learned Advocate General informed the court that
he along with other members of the team constituted under
the direction of this court visited the areas inhibited by the
members of Karbong community in Teliamura and came to
know
that
the
benefits
of
various
Central
and
State
Government’s beneficial schemes were yet to reach the
members of this community. It was assured by the learned
Advocate General that immediate steps would be taken to take
the benefits of those schemes to the members of Karbong
community. In view of the submissions made by the Advocate
General, this court passed the following order on 19.11.2021:
“.............In this respect, while recording the
aforesaid statement of the learned Advocate
General, we are of the considered view that
immediately a special team of doctors be
constituted to visit the areas concerned, carry
out health check-up of the community at large
and provide all necessary support if any is
required for their physical needs. Apart from
that, we are of the considered view that the
State
should
also
provide
immediately
entitlement of these people under the PDS
scheme. We are of the considered view that once
the health check-up of the people are carried out
and food under the PDS scheme is made
available, survival of this community will be
supported substantially. The possibility of
setting up of a primary health centre in the
nearby area may also be considered as well as
setting up of a primary school according to the
requirements of the locality. We are further of
the view that a special drive be undertaken to
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
carry out a census of the people belonging to the
Karbong community. The manner in which it will
be done is left to the discretion of both the
Central as well as the State Government. The
object of this exercise is essentially to come out
with facts and figures which are undisputed so
that the benefit of legislature, Government
schemes both Central and State can reach the
far-flung areas of our State.
Learned counsel for the ONGC is also
requested to come forward with any suggestion
or any programme they can undertake to
support of source of livelihood of the people of
the Karbong community. 6(six) weeks’ time is
granted to file further status report...................”
[5]
In the said order dated 19.11.2021, The Tribal
Research Institute (TRI) Tripura was impleaded as Respondent
No.8 and the Committee, constituted under the order of this
court, was given liberty to take the assistance of the experts
of Tribal Research Institute (TRI) for the purpose of carrying
out further research and identification of what were the needs
of Karbong community at large. The representative of ONGC
was also made a part of the said committee.
[6]
Pursuant to the order passed by this court on
19.11.2021, the State respondents represented by Mr.S.S
Dey, learned Advocate General, assisted by Ms. Ayantika
Chakraborty, Adv filed affidavit on 18.01.2022 asserting that
the State Government in consultation with the Ministry of
Tribal affairs, Government of India had been making a base
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
line survey
for forming an action plan for protection and
development of Karbong community, a Scheduled Tribe, as the
said community was incorporated in entries six and fourteen
by the Constitution (Scheduled Tribe) Orders (Amendment)
Act, 2002 vide notification dated 31.05.2005. It was stated
that the Karbong Community would be immensely benefited
by such Special Plan Initiative and Development Program for
the Scheduled Tribes.
[7]
A
detailed
report
(Annexure-A
at
page
54)
containing the findings of the committee on various challenges
faced by the members of the Karbong community was
enclosed with the said affidavit. The said findings of the
committee were as under:
(i)Tribal Sub-Plan (TSP), now called as Scheduled Tribe
Component(STC) is dedicated source of fund for tribal
development. STC is a multi-pronged strategy which includes
support for education, health, sanitation, water supply,
livelihood etc. Major part of infrastructure development in
tribal dominated areas and provision of basic amenities to
tribal people in the country is carried out through various
schemes / programmes of concerned Central Ministries and
the State Governments concerned, while the Ministry of Tribal
Affairs (MoTA) provides additional funds to these initiatives for
plugging gaps. Details about allocation percentage prescribed
for different Central Ministries / Departments under STC and
amount allocated during 2021-22 is at Annexure-R/2. The
scheme wise details of the funds sanctioned by Central
Ministries / Departments to Government of Tripura under
central STC during last 3 years is at Annexure-R/3. State
Government is supposed to utilize the STC funds being
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
received from the obligated Central Ministries to address the
development gaps for tribal communities including Karbong
Community in Tripura.
(ii) As per extant Guidelines, State Government of Tripura is
obligated to earmark at least 31.8% of their total Plan Outlay
dedicated for tribal development as Tribal Sub-Plan (TSP)
funds. The State Government is supposed to utilize State TSP
funds for welfare and development of tribal communities
including Karbong community in Tripura.
(iii) Ministry of Tribal Affairs provides financial assistance to
the State Government with notified STs including Government
of Tripura under the scheme of ‘Special Central Assistance to
Tribal Sub-Scheme (SCA to TSS)’ and ‘ Grants under Article
275(1) of the Constitution of India’ based on the proposal
received from the State Government with the approval of
Executive Committee under Chairmanship of Chief Secretary
and after appraisal and approval thereof by Project Apprisal
Committee (PAC) to bridge the gaps in sectors like education,
health, agriculture, skill development, employment–cumincome generation etc. The details of funds released to
Government of Tripura under ‘SCA to TSS’ and ‘Grants under
Article 275(1) of Constitution’ during last 5 years are as
follows:
Fund released (Rs. In lakh)
Scheme of SCA to TSS Grants under Article 275(1)
of Constitution’
2016-17
1345.76
1280.99
2017-18
1649.77
2040.89
2018-19
1294.38
2006.73
2019-20
1362.97
2952.63
2020-21
1173.30
201.74
Year
(iv) State Government of Tripura is at liberty to seek funds
under the Grants under Article 275(1) of Constitution of India
within their share of allocation for development of tribal
villages including the habitations of the Karbong Community
in Tripura.
(v) Further, in regard to sectoral programmes and schemes of
development of tribal communities; each Central Ministry/
Development will be the nodal Ministry Or Department
concerning its sector. The concerned Central Ministries/
Departments, State Governments and Union Territory
Administrations will be responsible for the formulation of
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
policy, planning, monitoring, evaluation etc as also their
coordination for the development schemes of these
communities.
(vi)In compliance of the order dated 19.11.2021 passed by
the Hon’ble Court relating to safeguarding of Karbong
Community and carrying out a census of the people belonging
to Karbong Community in the State, Directorate of Economics
& Statistics, Government of Tripura has furnished the data of
“Karbong” families who are available in the Ration Card
database of the state. Letter of the Directorate of Economics
& Statistics vide No.F.4(75)/STAT/PUB/2021/3699-700 dated
30.11.2021 is at Annexure –R/4.
(vii) The Anthropologist (P) & Head of Office, Anthropology
Survey of India, North-Eastern Regional Centre (Shillong) has
been communicated for conducting detail anthropological
study and research in Tripura on KARBONG COMMUNITY to
identify the specific needs of the community at large in
respect of the order dated 19.11.2021 passed by the Hon’ble
High Court of Tripura. Letter for anthropological study and
research on KARBONG COMMUNITY vide F.No.18 /TWL/.Cell/
/2021/24313-317 dated 3rd December, 2021 is at AnnexureR/5.”
[8]
The Tripura Tribal Areas Autonomous District
Council (TTAADC) [Respondent No.5] in its counter-affidavit
dated 31.01.2022 filed by its Chief Executive Officer has
stated that the first priority to safeguard the Karbong
community is to protect their culture and customs which are to
be attended without wasting time .
[9]
Oil and Natural Gas Corporation (ONGC, for short)
[Respondent No. 6] filed affidavit on 16.12.2021 in response
to the order dated 19.11.2021 in which the said respondent
catalogued what they had been doing for the Karbong
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
community at Karbong Para towards discharge of their
Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR). It was stated that the
estimated value of the project undertaken by Respondent no.6
was Rs.57,71,835/-. Part of the said project was to generate
awareness among the members of Karbong community about
the usefulness of maintaining cleanliness in their surroundings.
This apart, the Respondent No-6 also installed 50 solar street
lights in karbong Para under Khowai district. Members of
Karbong community were also provided skill development
training under the sponsorship of the respondent. Towards
implementation of Swachh Bharat Program, 117 dustbins were
distributed among the inhabitants of Karbong Para and Radha
Charan Para and painting works were done in the markets.
This apart, the respondent also provided financial assistance to
the tune of Rs.19,67,060/- to NV Institute of Rural Technology
for implementing the project namely Solar powered Water
Treatment Plant, for providing safe drinking water to 30
families.
school
and
Anganwadi
centre
were
also
established at the instance of the said respondent in the
Karbong village. Details of the activities undertaken and
implemented are available in Annexure-1 to the reply filed by
Respondent no.6 (ONGC).
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
[10]
The Union of India (Respondent No.4) filed a
separate reply on affidavit on 19.01.2022 along with the
details about the allocation of fund to various
Central
Ministries/Departments under Scheduled Tribe Component
(STC) for the year 2021-22 in Annexure R-1 and the scheme
wise details of fund sanctioned by several Central Ministries/
Departments to the Government of Tripura under Scheduled
Tribe Components (STC) during the last 3 years. Union of
India (Respondent No.4) in paragraph 7 and 8 of the said
reply on affidavit has asserted as under:
“7.
That
Ministry
of
Tribal
No.18011/02/2020-SCA
dated
22.12.2021
had
sought
Affairs
vide
letter
26.11.2021
and
following
details
from
Government of Tripura.
a.
Actions taken by the Government of Tripura so far
for development of Karbong Community of Tripura.
b. Actions
proposed
to
be
taken
based
on
the
directions of the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura in
order dated 19.11.2021.
In response to Ministry’s letter No.18011/02/2020-SCA
dated
26.11.2021
and
22.12.2021,
Government
of
Tripura by its letter No.27750-754F.18/TWL.Cell/2021
dated 28.12.2021 has informed that following emergent
steps have been taken by them in compliance with the
Hon’ble High Court order dated 19.11.2021:
a. Health Camp has been organized in Purna Chandra
Karbong
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
Para,
Teliamura
on
09.12.2021
and
Administrative-cum-Health Camp was conducted on
last 15.11.2021 with the initiatives of the concerned
Sub-Divisional Administration in collaboration with
Health Department.
b. Administrative-cum-Health Camp was conducted in
Karbong
Para,
Champaknagar,
Jirania
on
29.12.2021.
c. Tribal Welfare Department has
extended some
benefits for running Grocery Business to 4 families
of Karbong Para, Champaknagar under Jirania SubDivision
@Rs.25,000/-
business
(for
only
families)
for
and
running
small
piggery/goatery
scheme (for 1 family).
d. Government has also taken steps for sanction of
loan in favour of 4 unemployed youth at the rate of
2(two) beneficiaries from each location.
e.
Funds under Nucleus Budget scheme are being
placed with the respective District Welfare Officers
for
extending
financial
assistance
to
ST
poor
beneficiaries for treatment and other need based
activities. Concerned District Welfare Officer shall
extend benefits to the poor inmates of the said
Karbong villages on priority.
(Copy of the letter No.18011/02/2020-SCA dated
26.11.2021 is Annexed herewith as Annexure-R/3)
(Copy of the letter dated 22.12.2021 is Annexed
herewith as Annexure-R/4)
(Copy of the letter No.27750-754F.18 / TWL. Cell /
2021 dated 28.12.2021 is Annexed herewith as
Annexure-R/5)
8. The State Government shall take appropriate action
for
welfare
and
holistic
development
of
Karbong
community of Tripura by the utilizing TSP/STC funds
under the relevant schemes of Central and State
Government in a time bound manner.”
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
[11]
Learned ASG, in the course of hearing had also
drawn the attention of the Court to the notification dated
27.10.2021
of the
Secretary, Ministry
of Tribal Affairs,
Government of India addressed to the Chief Secretary, Tripura
where the following action points were suggested by the
Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Government of India under reference
to order dated 18.10.2021 passed by this Court:
“i. Government of Tripura may formulate an
action plan for the development of Karbong
Community in Tripura through appropriate
convergence of resources at State Tribal SubPlan (TSP) and Schedule Tribe Component (STC)
funds of Central Line Ministries/Departments
and under Grants under Article 275(1) of the
Constitution of India as per the schematic
norms.
ii. Further, as directed by Hon’ble High court of
Tripura, State Government may constitute a
team of officers who shall visit the areas and
submit its report to the State Government for
filing an affidavit on or before 9th November
2021. Shri Manoj Bapna, Director, Ministry of
Tribal
Affiars
(emailedmanojb12365cgo@gov.in) is nominated to represent this
Ministry in the Committee.
iii. State Government may direct the Tribal
Research Institute (TRI), Tripura or any other
appropriate agency to study the challenges
being faced by the Karbong community of
Tripura and identify various gaps in provision of
basic amenities and other essential service to
this community.
iv. As per study report as suggested above,
remedial measures for development of Karbong
community may be enlisted and appropriate
action may be taken.”
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
[12]
In
view
of
the
replies
submitted
by
the
respondents and the result of the detailed survey in respect of
the habitants of the Karbong tribe and more particularly the
affidavit filed by the Government of India, this court was of
the view that the suggestions made by the Ministry of Tribal
Affairs, Government of India, if implemented, would bring
about paradigm shift in protection and development of
Karbong community in Tripura. This Court under order dated
11.02.2022, made the following observations:
“............From
the
affidavit
filed
by
the
Government of India, we find that the result of
the detailed survey in respect of the habitat of
the Karbong Tribes and information relating to
every individual from that community have been
gathered, compiled and produced with the
affidavit of the respondents No. 2, 3 & 9.
Prima
facie,
we find
that
if the
suggestions as made by the Ministry of Tribal
affairs are implemented, that would bring about
a paradigm shift in protection and development
of the Karbong community.
Having appreciated the suggestions as
made by the respondents, this court would
record that all the parties are on the task of
charting out an action plan, both short term and
long term, for protection and development of the
Karbong community.
Even, it is noticed that there is some
increase in the population of the karbongs.
Therefore, the holistic approach for protection
and development of Karbong community be
formulated providing a framework in tune with
the suggestions as introduced by the Ministry of
Tribal Welfare.
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
Hence, we will direct the respondents No.
2, 3 & 9 to file another affidavit stating what
action the Government of Tripura has taken on
the suggestions made by the Ministry of Home
Affairs, as referred above.”
[13]
Pursuant to our order dated 11.02.2022 the State
Government represented by the Secretary, Tribal Welfare
Department [Respondent No.1] submitted its affidavit on
20.5.2022 asserting that the State Government in consultation
with the Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Government of India took up
the matter in the right earnest to implement the actions
suggested by the Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Government of
India for creation of sustainable livelihood and upliftment of
the people of Karbong Community at two locations under
Khowai and West Tripura. It has been stated by respondent
No.1 that an inter-departmental meeting of all the stakeholders was held on 10.02.2022 in which the following
decision were taken up:
(i) All the concerned departments shall complete the targets
like Jal Jivan Mission, IIHL etc by the next 3(Three) months.
(ii) The Block Development Officers, Belbari and Teliamura
shall conduct all requisite survey on priority basis and submit
report to the concerned authority for providing PMAY House
facilities to the eligible Karbong families and other activities.
(iii) The Food Civil Supplies & Consumer Affairs Department
has informed that full coverage of LPG connections would be
ensured through PMUY along with Ration Card to all Karbong
families, if not covered.
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
(iv) The Public Works Department (DWS) has assured that
the fund for the up-gradation of AWC and drinking Water
facility is available with them. Necessary steps would be
taken shortly.
(V) The Public Works Department (WR) has assured that the
ground water irrigation system covering 1.5 hectare already
exists under Belbari RD Block under Jirania Sub-division.
However, further necessary steps would be taken for both
Jirania and Teliamura Sub-Division.
(vi) The Social welfare & Social Education Department has
assured that the AWC of Karbong para, Jirania Sub-Division
will be taken up as per Model AWC and some minor repairing
works will shortly be done in case of AWC of Teliamura SubDivision (Purna Chandra Karbong Para).
(vii) The Public Works Department(R&B) has assured that on
receipt of detail proposal from BDO Teliamura, the carpeting
of motorable road with brick soiling from Karbong para to
Patlabari (2.5 km) and from Karbong Para to Khasiamangal
BSF camp (2 km) would shortly be taken up.
(viii) The Health Department has assured that an
Immunization Camp/programme under Intensified Mission
Indradhanush will shortly be conducted under Jirania and
Teliamura Sub-Division covering all Karbong families.
Besides, there will be induction of Asha worker from the
Karbong community.
(ix) The ARD Department has informed that presently three
locations have been surveyed viz. Manu, Belbari, and
Teliamura having Karbong habitant areas. Out of 3(three)
locations, Manu and Belbari fall within the purview of ADC
area and Teliamura (Purna Chandra Karbong Para) under
non-ADC area, hence necessary steps for providing poultry,
piggery, goatery, and milch cows would be taken up through
ARDD based projects, through ADC fund in case of Manu and
Belbari. And, in case of Teliamura, necessary steps would be
taken up through State Fund.
[14]
ONGC, Respondent No. 6, in its affidavit dated
11.05.2022 has asserted as under:
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
“3. The Respondent No.6 may make arrangement of drinking
water in Rupaicherra location under CSR initiative of ONGC
as per CSR guidelines.
4. The arrangement for providing short term training for
maintaining drinking water sources to one person each from
both the locations can be arranged by ONGC. However, any
expenses for keeping those persons for seamless functioning
of water sources may be provided by ONGC.
5. However as an alternate ONGC may engage one eligible
candidate from each location for apprenticeship training for a
period of one year as per Apprenticeship Act and during the
apprenticeship training those persons will be paid stipend as
per the admissible rate.”
[15]
As stated, the committee constituted pursuant to
our order dated 18.10.20221, submitted its interim report on
11.11.2021. For preparation of the report, the committee
members visited Purna Chandra Karbong Para in Khowai
district on 02.11.2021 and Karbong Para at Champaknagar
under
Jirania
Sub-Division
in
West
Tripura
District
on
08.11.2021. The committee found a population of 52 in 14
families of Karbong community in Karbong Para of Rupaicherra
Gram Panchayat under Teliamura R.D Block and a population
of 82 in 23 families was found at Karbong Para, Champak
Nagar under Jirania Sub-Division in West Tripura District. In
the said interim report the committee felt the need of
immediate implementation of the beneficial schemes for
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
upliftment of the members of Karbong community. It also felt
the
need
of
establishment
of
residential
school
and
introduction of Post-Metric and Pre-Metric scholarship, solar
water pump for the agriculturists and safe drinking water
within the reach of every member of the community.
[16]
The said committee submitted its final report along
with an affidavit submitted on 18.01.2022 in which the
committee
highlighted
the
requirements
of
the
said
community in the areas of housing, health, education, water,
electricity,
road
connectivity,
Animal husbandry,
irrigation,
sanitation, Public
LPG
Connection,
Distribution System
(PDS), livelihood, market and implementation of various
beneficial schemes etc.
[17]
We have considered the reports submitted by the
committee and affidavits filed by the respondents. We have
also head learned counsel representing the respondents as
well as the learned Amicus-Curiae appointed by this Court and
considered the submissions made by him.
[18]
From the reports submitted by the committee
constituted by
us
and the
affidavits submitted by
the
respondents it has appeared to us that the action points
suggested by the Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Government of
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
India, in their letter dated 27.10.2021 and the various
suggestions made by the committee constituted by us in their
reports
as
well
as
the
decisions
taken
by
the
State
Government in the inter departmental meeting on 10.02.2022
are to be implemented at the earliest for the upliftment of the
Karbong community in Tripura. The concern expressed in the
newspaper report on the basis of which this PIL was registered
appears to us to be genuine and a coordinated effort, as
suggested, is necessary for protection and development of
Karbong community.
[19]
Having observed thus, we find it appropriate to
issue the following directions in the matter:
(i)Besides implementing the various directions
issued by this court vide orders dated 19.11.2021
and
11.02.2022
respondents
shall
recommendations
at
the
earliest,
the
state
implement
the
suggestions/
made
the
Committee
by
constituted under the order of this court in their
interim report dated 11.11.2021 and the report
which has been annexed to the affidavit dated
18.01.2022 as Annexure-A for protection and
development
of
the
members
of
Karbong
community across the state.
(ii) As indicated the Ministry of Tribal Affairs,
Government of India in their communication dated
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
27.10.2021 written to the Chief Secretary, Tripura
has
suggested
development
certain
of
action
Karbong
points
for
community
the
which
includes a study of the challenges being faced by
the
Karbong
community
of
Tripura
and
identification of the various gaps in provision of
their basic amenities. The state respondents are
directed to immediately undertake the actions
which are yet to be taken in terms of the said
suggestions made by the Government of India in
the Ministry of Tribal Affairs.
(iii)
An
action
plan
was
suggestions/recommendations
proposed
were
made
and
for
creation of sustainable livelihood and upliftment of
the members of the Karbong community across
the state in coordination with the concerned
central Ministries / Departments by utilizing the
fund realized under Scheduled Tribe Component
(STC) in an inter departmental meeting held on
10.02.2022. We have reproduced the same in the
preceding paragraph 13. We are of the considered
view that implementation of the actions proposed
therein shall go a long way in the protection and
development of the members of the Karbong
community. The state respondents are, therefore,
directed to implement those action plans in letter
and spirit in a time bound manner.
[20]
Learned ASG appearing on behalf of the Union of
India [Respondent No.4] by adducing communication dated
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
25.02.2022 of the Anthropological Survey of India to the
Director of Tribal Welfare, Government of Tripura has assured
us that anthropological study of the Karbong community along
with other tribes of Tripura would commence from July, 2022.
We hope and trust that the study shall be completed within
time and the report be submitted in the Registry of this court.
[21]
behalf
Mr.P.Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing on
of
ONGC
[Respondent
No.6]
submits
that
the
respondent has already undertaken various welfare activities
like providing safe drinking water in Rupaicherra location and
training of at least 01 members of Karbong community for
maintaining the water source besides providing apprenticeship
training to 01 or all the eligible candidates of Karbong
community
along
with
stipend
to
them
during
such
apprenticeship training. Mr. Chakraborty, learned Advocate
fairly contends that ONGC is ready to carry out further
direction(s) of this court towards discharge its Corporate
Social Responsibility (CSR) for upliftment of the members of
the Karbong community. From the reports submitted by the
Committee constituted by us, it has appeared that population
of the Karbong community in the state is not huge. There is no
doubt
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
that
ONGC
has
done
a
commendable
job
for
development and protection of the members of the said
community in Tripura. We hope that ONGC shall provide
stipend to at least 01 student from class I up to graduation
level from each of the families of Karbong community at both
the locations. Among them, half shall be girl students. The
amount of stipend shall be determined by ONGC taking into
consideration the actual needs of the students. The Tribal
Welfare Department, Government of Tripura [Respondent
No.2] shall coordinate with ONGC in identification of the
families and the candidates eligible for such stipend.
[22]
The respondents shall submit quarterly compliance
report before the Deputy Registrar (Judicial) of this court who
shall study the reports and place the same before this bench in
case any further intervention is required.
[23]
Before parting with the case we place on record
our deep appreciation to learned advocate general, the amicus
curiae
appointed
by
this
court
and
all
other
counsel
representing the parties for their prompt and positive response
and assistance in disposing this matter.
[24]
The English daily namely ‘Tripura Observer’ also
deserves appreciation for publishing an in-depth news item on
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
such serious issue concerning the Karbong community in
Tripura.
[25]
In terms of the above, the Writ Petition (PIL)
stands disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY), J
Saikat Sarma
WP(C)(PIL)20/2021
(INDRAJIT MAHANTY), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review