Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
Dated: 05th September, 2024
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DB: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWANATH SOMADDER, CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------TAX APP. NO. 01 OF 2024
Commissioner of Central Goods and
Services Tax and Central Excise,
Siliguri Commissionerate,
C.R. Building, Hakimpara,
Haren Mukherjee Road,
Siliguri, West Bengal-734001
…Appellant
-versusM/s Alkem Laboratories Ltd.,
Represented through the Plant Head/Unit Head,
Kumrek, Rangpo,
District – East Sikkim, 737132.
…Respondent
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Ms. Sangita Pradhan, Deputy Solicitor General of India assisted
by Ms. Natasha Pradhan, Advocate for the appellant.
Mr. Mahesh Raichandani and Mr. Ranjit Prasad, Advocates for
the respondent.
…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
JUDGMENT : (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
This is a statutory appeal arising from a final order dated 14th September,
2023, passed by the learned Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal,
Eastern Zonal Bench, Kolkata, (Regional Bench - Court No. 1) in Excise Appeal
No. 75147 of 2023 (M/s Alkem Health Science vs. Commissioner of Central Goods
and Services Tax and Central Excise, Siliguri Commissionerate) along with Excise
Appeal No. 75148 of 2023 (M/s Alkem Laboratories Limited vs. Commissioner of
Central Goods and Services Tax and Central Excise, Siliguri Commissionerate).
Tax App. No. 01 of 2024
Commissioner of CGST and CX vs. M/s Alkem Laboratories Ltd.
This appeal has been preferred by the Commissioner of Central Goods and
Services Tax and Central Excise, Siliguri Commissionerate, under section 35G of
the Central Excise Act, 1944 (hereinafter referred to “the Act of 1944”).
By the impugned final order, the learned Tribunal was pleased to allow the
two appeals referred above in the following manner:—
“8.
We find that refund claims were sanctioned in the light of the
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of SRD Nutrients
(supra) and thereafter the decision of the SRD Nutrients (supra) was
over-ruled by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Unicorn
Industries (supra), it does not mean that at the time of sanctioning of
refund claim, the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
SRD Nutrients was valid. As the decision of Hon’ble Apex Court in the
case of SRD Nutrients (supra) during the relevant period holding the
field, in that circumstances, the refund claims were rightly sanctioned
to the appellants as held by the Hon’ble High Courts in the abovecited decisions namely Tripura Ispat vs. UOI (supra), therefore, we
hold that the show cause notice issued to the appellant are not
sustainable.
9.
Accordingly, the impugned orders are bad in law. Accordingly,
the same are set aside.
In the result, the appeals are allowed with consequential relief,
if any.”
The learned Deputy Solicitor General of India representing the appellant
submits that the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court referred to and relied
upon by the authority which sanctioned the refund claims of the respondent,
being the case of M/s SRD Nutrients Private Limited. vs. Commissioner of Central
Excise, Guwahati, [(2018) 1 SCC 105] was subsequently overruled by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in the case of M/s Unicorn Industries vs. Union of India
and others reported in [(2020) 3 SCC 492]. As such, she submits that the powers
of the concerned authority to invoke the provisions of section 11A of the Act of
1944, for recovery of duty erroneously refunded, would have been very much
permissible in the facts of the instant case.
When asked by this Court as to when the M/s Unicorn Industries judgment
came into force, the learned Deputy Solicitor General of India submitted that it
came into force at a subsequent date, that is, after the refund claims were
sanctioned by the competent authority.
Tax App. No. 01 of 2024
Commissioner of CGST and CX vs. M/s Alkem Laboratories Ltd.
The short question which, therefore, arises for consideration in the facts of
the instant case is whether the subsequent judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court rendered in M/s Unicorn Industries (supra) overruling the judgment of M/s
SRD Nutrients (supra) will be applicable in the facts of the instant case.
Before we proceed to answer this question, we need to take notice of
section 11A of the Act of 1944, which reads as follows:—
“11A. Recovery of duties not levied or not paid or short-levied
or short-paid or erroneously refunded.— (1) Where any duty of
excise has not been levied or paid or has been short-levied or shortpaid or erroneously refunded, for any reason, other than the reason
of fraud or collusion or any wilful mis-statement or suppression of
facts or contravention of any of the provisions of this Act or of the
rules made thereunder with intent to evade payment of duty,—
(a)
the Central Excise Officer shall, within two years from the
relevant date, serve notice on the person chargeable with the
duty which has not been so levied or paid or which has been so
short-levied or short-paid or to whom the refund has
erroneously been made, requiring him to show cause why he
should not pay the amount specified in the notice;
(b)
the person chargeable with duty may, before service of notice
under clause (a), pay on the basis of,—
(i) his own ascertainment of such duty; or
(ii) the duty ascertained by the Central Excise Officer,
the amount of duty along with interest payable thereon under Section
11AA.
(2) The person who has paid the duty under clause (b) of sub-section
(1), shall inform the Central Excise Officer of such payment in
writing, who, on receipt of such information, shall not serve any
notice under clause (a) of that sub-section in respect of the duty so
paid or any penalty leviable under the provisions of this Act or the
rules made thereunder.
(3) Where the Central Excise Officer is of the opinion that the amount
paid under clause (b) of sub-section (1) falls short of the amount
actually payable, then, he shall proceed to issue the notice as
provided for in clause (a) of that sub-section in respect of such
amount which falls short of the amount actually payable in the
manner specified under that sub-section and the period of two years
shall be computed from the date of receipt of information under subsection (2).
(4) Where any duty of excise has not been levied or paid or has been
short-levied or short-paid or erroneously refunded, by the reason of—
(a)
fraud; or
(b)
collusion; or
(c)
any wilful mis-statement; or
(d)
suppression of facts; or
Tax App. No. 01 of 2024
Commissioner of CGST and CX vs. M/s Alkem Laboratories Ltd.
(e)
contravention of any of the provisions of this Act or of the
rules made thereunder with intent to evade payment of
duty,
by any person chargeable with the duty, the Central Excise
Officer shall, within five years from the relevant date, serve
notice on such person requiring him to show cause why he
should not pay the amount specified in the notice along with
interest payable thereon under Section 11AA and a penalty
equivalent to the duty specified in the notice.
(5)
Omitted by Act 20 of 2015, sec. 93(i) (w.e.f. 14-5-2015).
(6)
Omitted by Act 20 of 2015, sec. 93(i) (w.e.f. 14-5-2015).
(7)
Omitted by Act 20 of 2015, sec. 93(i) (w.e.f. 14-5-2015).
(7A) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1) or subsection (3) or sub-section (4), the Central Excise Officer may, serve,
subsequent to any notice or notices served under any of those subsections, as the case may be, a statement, containing the details of
duty of central excise not levied or paid or short-levied or short-paid
or erroneously refunded for the subsequent period, on the person
chargeable to duty of central excise, then, service of such statement
shall be deemed to be service of notice on such person under the
aforesaid sub-section (1) or sub-section (3) or sub-section (4),
subject to the condition that the grounds relied upon for the
subsequent period are the same as are mentioned in the earlier
notice or notices.
(8) Where the service of notice is stayed by an order of a court or
tribunal, the period of such stay shall be excluded in computing the
period of two years referred to in clause (a) of sub-section (1) or five
years referred to in sub-section (4), as the case may be.
(9) Where any appellate authority or tribunal or court concludes that
the notice issued under sub-section (4) is not sustainable for the
reason that the charges of fraud or collusion or any wilful misstatement or suppression of facts or contravention of any of the
provisions of this Act or of the rules made thereunder with intent to
evade payment of duty has not been established against the person
to whom the notice was issued, the Central Excise Officer shall
determine the duty of excise payable by such person for the period
of two years, deeming as if the notice were issued under clause (a) of
sub-section (1).
(10) The Central Excise Officer shall, after allowing the concerned
person an opportunity of being heard, and after considering the
representation, if any, made by such person, determine the amount
of duty of excise due from such person not being in excess of the
amount specified in the notice.
(11) The Central Excise Officer shall determine the amount of duty of
excise under sub-section (10)—
(a)
within six months from the date of notice where it is
possible to do so, in respect of cases falling under subsection (1);
(b)
within two years from the date of notice, where it is
possible to do so, in respect of cases falling under subsection (4).
Tax App. No. 01 of 2024
Commissioner of CGST and CX vs. M/s Alkem Laboratories Ltd.
(12) Where the appellate authority or tribunal or court modifies the
amount of duty of excise determined by the Central Excise Officer
under sub-section (10), then the amount of penalties and interest
under this section shall stand modified accordingly, taking into
account the amount of duty of excise so modified.
(13) Where the amount as modified by the appellate authority or
tribunal or court is more than the amount determined under subsection (10) by the Central Excise Officer, the time within which the
interest or penalty is payable under this Act shall be counted from the
date of the order of the appellate authority or tribunal or court in
respect of such increased amount.
(14) Where an order determining the duty of excise is passed by the
Central Excise Officer under this section, the person liable to pay the
said duty of excise shall pay the amount so determined along with
the interest due on such amount whether or not the amount of
interest is specified separately.
(15) The provisions of sub-sections (1) to (14) shall apply, mutatis
mutandis, to the recovery of interest where interest payable has not
been paid or part paid or erroneously refunded.
(16) The provisions of this section shall not apply to a case where the
liability of duty not paid or short-paid is self-assessed and declared as
duty payable by the assessee in the periodic returns filed by him, and
in such case, recovery of non-payment or short-payment of duty shall
be made in such manner as may be prescribed.
Explanation 1.— For the purposes of this section and Section 11AC,—
(a) “refund" includes rebate of duty of excise on excisable goods
exported out of India or on excisable materials used in the
manufacture of goods which are exported out of India;
(b) "relevant date" means,—
(c)
(i)
in the case of excisable goods on which duty of excise has
not been levied or paid or has been short-levied or shortpaid, and no periodical return as required by the
provisions of this Act has been filed, the last date on
which such return is required to be filed under this Act
and the rules made thereunder;
(ii)
in the case of excisable goods on which duty of excise has
not been levied or paid or has been short-levied or shortpaid and the return has been filed the date on which such
return has been filed;
(iii)
in any other case, the date on which duty of excise is
required to be paid under this Act or the rules made
thereunder;
(iv)
in a case where duty of excise is provisionally assessed
under this Act or the rules made thereunder, the date of
adjustment of duty after the final assessment thereof;
(v)
in the case of excisable goods on which duty of excise has
been erroneously refunded, the date of such refund;
(vi)
in the case where only interest is to be recovered, the
date of payment of duty to which such interest relates.
Omitted by Act 20 of 2015, sec. 93(iii)(C) (w.e.f. 14-5-2015).
Tax App. No. 01 of 2024
Commissioner of CGST and CX vs. M/s Alkem Laboratories Ltd.
Explanation 2.— For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that
any non-levy, short-levy, non-payment, short-payment or erroneous
refund where no show cause notice has been issued before the date
on which the Finance Bill, 2015 receives the assent of the President,
shall be governed by the provisions of Section 11A as amended by
the Finance Act, 2015.”
A plain reading of section 11A, as quoted hereinabove, reveals that it
makes a distinction between the cases of duties of excise not having been levied,
paid, short-paid or short-levied, erroneously refunded, for reasons of fraud,
collusion or any mis-statement or suppression of facts or contravention of any
provisions of the Act or Rules made with the intent to evade payment of duty and
in cases where none of these elements are present, under sub-section (1) of
section 11A of the Act of 1944, where any such duty of excise has not been
levied or short-levied or erroneously refunded for any reason other than the
reasons of fraud or collusion, etc., the Central Excise Officer would, within two
years from the relevant date, serve a notice on the person chargeable to the duty
calling upon him to show cause why the amount specified in the notice along with
interest not be recovered. Sub-section (1) of section 11A thus authorises the
Central Excise Officer to recover any duty of excise, besides others, which has
been erroneously refunded. It is in this context that the term “erroneously
refunded” assumes significance.
The learned Tribunal took notice of the above position in law while going on
to observe that when the Excise Officer passed the order of refund, he was
applying the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court by virtue of Article 142
of the Constitution of India. The learned Tribunal proceeded to observe to the
effect that the Excise Officer had no other choice but to follow the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in M/s SRD Nutrients (supra). Any other action on his
part would have been wholly illegal. His order of refund thus was in consonance
with the law declared by the Hon’ble Supreme Court at the time when he was
passing the order. The learned Tribunal proceeded further to observe that in its
view any subsequent change in the legal position would not permit him to invoke
the powers of section 11A of the Act of 1944. As is well settled, all legal
Tax App. No. 01 of 2024
Commissioner of CGST and CX vs. M/s Alkem Laboratories Ltd.
proceedings on the date when are being decided by any Court, would be
governed by the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court which prevails on
such date.
A significant part of the order of the learned Tribunal is quoted
hereinbelow:—
“As is often happens, a decision of the Supreme Court is
reviewed, reconsidered or overruled by larger Bench. Such
subsequent decision would undoubtedly clarify the position in law and
such declaration would undisputedly apply to all pending proceedings,
the proceedings which are closed in the meantime, cannot be
reopened on the basis of subsequent declaration of law by the
Supreme Court. Any other view would lead to total anarchy. Based on
the judgment of the Supreme Court several proceedings would have
been decided. If years later such view is reversed, the parties who
had not carried the proceedings in higher forum and thus not kept
the proceedings alive, cannot trigger a fresh look at the decision
already rendered by the competent court on the basis of the previous
judgment of the Supreme Court which was correctly applied at the
relevant time.”
In this backdrop if one were to accept the submissions advanced by the
learned Deputy Solicitor General of India, then all judgments rendered by all
competent Courts — following judicial precedents laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court holding the field at that material point of time — would be set to
naught if at a subsequent stage those judicial precedents are overruled by
subsequent decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. A total chaos would result
and no lis would assume finality. This very fundamental principle was taken into
consideration by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in a judgment and order
dated 04th July, 2023, rendered in the case of Commissioner of CGST and Central
Excise (J&K) vs. M/s Saraswati Agro Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. (Special Leave Petition
(Civil) Diary No(s). 18051/2023). Relevant portion of the judgment and order
dated 04th July, 2023, rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, is quoted
hereinbelow: “With regard to the reference order made on 27.09.2021 on a
miscellaneous application filed by the Revenue seeking to undo the
judgment in M/s SRD Nutrients (P) Limited which was overruled in the
subsequent judgment of this Court in M/s Unicorn Industries (supra),
the question is whether there was a need at all to refer the matter to a
Tax App. No. 01 of 2024
Commissioner of CGST and CX vs. M/s Alkem Laboratories Ltd.
larger Bench. This is for two reasons: firstly, such an application could not
have been filed after a review petition in M/s SRD Nutrients (P) Limited had
been dismissed by this Court. Thus, in substance, by filing the
miscellaneous application the revenue was seeking a second review of the
said judgment which is impermissible in law (Order XLVII Rule 9 CPC).
Secondly, by ignoring the Explanation to Order XLVII Rule 1 of the CPC and
the principle that emerges from the same, what is sought to be contended
by learned ASG is that if a judgment is overruled by this Court by a
subsequent judgment, then the overruled judgment will have to be
reopened and on reopening the said judgment will have to be brought in
line with the subsequent judgment which had overruled it. This is not
permissible in law for two reasons: firstly, there has to be finality in
litigation and that is in the interest of State. Secondly, a person cannot be
vexed twice. This is epitomized by the following maxims:
(i) Nemo debet bis vexari pro una et eadem causa (No man should be
vexed twice for the same cause);
(ii)Interest reipublicae ut sit finis litium (It is in the interest of the
State that there should be an end to litigation); and
(iii)Res judicata pro veritate occipitur (A judicial decision must be
accepted as correct).
These maxims would indicate that there must be an end to litigation
otherwise the rights of persons would be in an endless confusion and fluid
and justice would suffer.
That is why the explanation to Order XLVII Rule 1 which is a
wholesome provision has been inserted to the Code of Civil Procedure. It
states that once there is a subsequent judgment overruling an earlier
judgment on a point of law, the earlier judgment cannot be reopened or
reviewed on the basis of a subsequent judgment.
The contention of the Revenue is that in view of the subsequent
judgment of this Court in M/s Unicorn Industries, recoveries could be made
from the assessees with regard to the refund of education cess made by
the Department or if not paid by the assesses following the judgment in
SRD Nutrients (P) Limited. In the above circumstances, appeals were filed
before the High Court by the assessees. In the instant case, the High Court
had raised the following question of law and answered it against the
Revenue:“Whether the assessee is liable to return the Education Cess
and Secondary & Higher Education Cess on the changed view
of law as subsequently laid down by the Full Bench of the
Supreme Court in Unicorn Industries vs. Union of India
reported in (2020) 3 SCC 492, overruling SRD Nutrients (P)
Ltd. vs. CCE (Supra) on the basis of which the aforesaid cess
was refunded to the Assessee.”
In our view the High Court has rightly answered the aforesaid
question. The High Court in the impugned order while considering the
judgment passed by this Court in SRD Nutrients (P) Limited (supra) as well
as in M/s Unicorn Industries (supra) has observed in Paragraph 74 as
under:
“Applying the aforesaid principle in the cases at hand, since
the assessee has been held entitled to the refund of the
Educational cess and Secondary & Higher Educational cess on
the basis of a judgment and order of the Supreme Court in
case SRD Nutrients which was in vogue at the relevant time,
the appellants are not entitled to make recovery of the said
refunded amount on the basis of the subsequent decision of
the Supreme Court rendered in the case of Unicorn Industries.
If such an action is permitted, it will open a Pandora box and
Tax App. No. 01 of 2024
Commissioner of CGST and CX vs. M/s Alkem Laboratories Ltd.
the lis between the parties which had attained finality will
never come to an end. This would be against the public policy
which envisages providing quietus to litigation at some stage.”
In substance, the High Court has stated that the decision in SRD
Nutrients (P) Limited (supra) had attained finality and was binding on the
parties thereto. Therefore, the subsequent decision of this Court overruling
SRD Nutrients (P) Limited (supra) in the case of M/s Unicorn Industries
cannot have a bearing on past decisions which had attained finality
although they had followed SRD Nutrients (P) Limited (supra), which was
subsequently overruled in M/s Unicorn Industries. Otherwise a pandora’s
box would be opened and there would be no end to litigation, which is
against public policy.
That is exactly what is sought to be done by the reference order
dated 27.09.2021. When we read the reference order in light of the what
has been discussed, we find that the reference order was unnecessary.
In the circumstances, the Special Leave Petitions are dismissed.”
The above position of law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court clears
the issue sought to be raised in the present statutory appeal and for reasons
stated above, we have no hesitation in dismissing the instant appeal.
Before we part with this matter, in our view, this statutory appeal is a
classic example of an instance where precious and valuable time of the Court is
lost because of the appellant choosing not to follow the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court which governs the field. The ratio of the decision
rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of CGST and
Central Excise (J and K) vs. M/s Saraswati Agro Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. (supra)
rendered on 04th July, 2023, is squarely applicable in the facts of the instant
case. Even then, this statutory appeal was filed by the Commissioner of Central
Goods and Services Tax and Central Excise, Siliguri Commissionerate on 20th
May, 2024. On that date (i.e. on 20th May, 2024), the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 04th July, 2023, was squarely governing the field. This
important aspect of the matter should have been taken into consideration by the
Commissioner of Central Goods and Services Tax and Central Excise, Siliguri
Commissionerate, being the appellant before us. Instead, ignoring the said
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, a frivolous appeal has been filed. We,
therefore, find that this is a fit case for imposition of cost upon the appellant. As
such, this Court imposes a cost of Rs.20,000/- (Rupees twenty thousand only)
Tax App. No. 01 of 2024
Commissioner of CGST and CX vs. M/s Alkem Laboratories Ltd.
upon the appellant which shall be deposited with the Sikkim State Legal Services
Authority within a fortnight from date.
At this stage, the learned Deputy Solicitor General of India prays before
this Court that the appellant may be exempted for payment of cost on the
assurance that in future any such frivolous appeal — which takes away the
valuable and precious time of the Court — without considering the relevant
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court holding/governing the field, will not be
filed by the appellant.
Considering the above submission made by the learned Deputy Solicitor
General of India, we refrain from imposing cost upon the appellant.
jk/ds/avi/ami
(Meenakshi Madan Rai)
Judge
(Biswanath Somadder)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review