The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Here again, we cannot appreciate and recognise the argument of the learned counsel for the respondents, inasmuch as the Hon'ble Supreme Court has recognised the right of the employees based on a purposive interpretation based on the object and concept based upon which an annual increment is granted. This is all the more so, in view of the findings of the Hon'ble Supreme Court that, depriving the benefit, which emanates from a service which has been admittedly rendered, would lead to arbitrariness and unreasonableness, in the light of which, we can only find that the argument based on the proviso to Note I of Rule 33 is also squarely in the teeth of the arbitrariness and unreasonableness, as found by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. 2025:KER:24381
14. In the result, these original petitions succeed and the impugned Common Order of the Tribunal is hereby set aside. We direct the respondents to grant one notional increment to the petitioners, as also, to revise their retiral benefits after including such annual increment. We direct that the above direction shall be complied within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.”
8. The Honourable Apex Court in Civil Appeal No.2471/2023 pondered the same issue and upheld the dictum laid down in P.Ayyamperumal’s case (supra) of the Madras High Court. The issue involved in this matter is no longer res integra. In view of the judgment in OP(CAT) No.65/2023, OP(CAT) No.208/2020 fails and it is liable to be dismissed in our view. Therefore, OP(CAT) is dismissed. Sd/-
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:24381
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 14TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 25TH MAGHA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 208 OF 2020
AGAINST THE ORDER IN OA NO.654 OF 2019 OF CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS IN THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION:
COMMANDER, CDR (CP)-PAY AND FP, DIRECTORATE OF CIVILIAN
PERSONNEL, INTEGRATED HEADQUARTERS OF MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
(NAVY), NEW DELHI-110 001.
THE FLAG OFFICER COMMANDING IN CHIEF,
HEADQUARTERS, SOUTHERN NAVAL COMMAND, KOCHI-4.
UNION OF INDIA, REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF DEFENCE, NEW DELHI-110001
Sri.T.C.Krishna ,(DSGI incharge)
RESPONDENTS/APPLICANTS IN THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION:
P.R. SREEKUMAR, AGED 62 YEARS
S/O.LATE R.RAGHAVAN NAIR, UDC(RETIRED), COMMAND TRANSPORT
WORKSHOP, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI-4, RESIDING AT SREYAS, HOSUE
NO.26/985, NEAR KASABA THEATRE, THEVARA-13.
K.MUKTHA BAI, AGED 62 YEARS
D/O.LATE K.KESAVA SHENOI, OFFICE SUPERINTENDENT (RETIRED),
MATERIAL ORGANIZATION, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI-4, RESIDING AT
HOUSE NO.4/869, NORTH STREET, NORTH CHERLAI, KOCHI-2.
THIS OP (CAT) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 14.02.2025, THE COURT
ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OP(CAT) No.208/2020
2025:KER:24381
JUDGMENT
K. V. JAYAKUMAR, J
Feeling aggrieved by the order of the Central Administrative
Tribunal in O.A.No.654/2019 dated 03.12.2019, Union of India and its
officers preferred this OP(CAT).
2.
Succinctly, the facts in brief are as follows:
The respondents/applicants are retired as Upper Division Clerks
(UDC) and Office Superintendent on attaining the age of superannuation on
30.06.2017. On the implementation of the 6 th CPC, a uniform date of annual
increment was formulated viz, 1st July of every year.
The claim of the
applicants was that, had they been in service on 1 st July 2017, they would have
received an increment. The contention of the petitioners/Union of India was
that, as per Central Civil Service (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008, annual increment
accrues on 1st July every year. As per that Rule, employees completing six
months and above service in the revised pay structure as on 1 st July will
become eligible for one increment. The applicants can only be treated as
retired Government servants and not as Government servants on 1st July.
3.
The respondents and the similarly placed employees
knocked the doors of the Central Administrative Tribunal claiming one
OP(CAT) No.208/2020
2025:KER:24381
increment. The Tribunal, as per the common order, allowed all the original
applications and directed to grant one increment to the applicants.
4.
Impugning the said order, Union of India and its officers
preferred this OP(CAT).
5.
The short question involved in this case is, whether a
Government employee retiring on 30th June is entitled to claim an
increment?.
6.
The Tribunal, placing reliance on the decision in
P.Ayyamperumal v. The Registrar and Ors. [CDJ 2017 MHC 6274],
which was later confirmed by the Honourable Apex Court, allowed the claim
of the applicants and granted one notional increment for calculating
pensionary benefits and not for any other purpose. The relevant paragraphs of
the Tribunal’s order are extracted hereunder:
“8. In P. Ayyamperumal's case (supra) the
Hon'ble Madras High Court held as under:
4. Heard the learned Senior Panel Counsel
appearing for the respondents 2 to 4 on the submissions
made by the petitioner and perused the materials available
on record.
5. The petitioner retired as Additional Director
General, Chennai on 30.06.2013 on attaining the age of
superannuation. After the Sixth Pay Commission, the
Central Government fixed 1st July as the date of increment
for all employees by amending Rule 10 of the Central Civil
Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008. In view of the said
amendment, the petitioner was denied the last increment,
though he completed a full one year in service, ie., from
01.07.2012 to 30.06.2013. Hence, the petitioner filed the
original application in O.A.No.310/00917/2015 before the
OP(CAT) No.208/2020
2025:KER:24381
Central Administrative Tribunal, Madras Bench, and the
same was rejected on the ground that an incumbent is only
entitled to increment on 1st July if he continued in service
on that day.
6. In the case on hand, the petitioner got retired
on 30.06.2013. As per the Central Civil Services (Revised
Pay) Rules, 2008, the increment has to be given only on
01.07.2013, but he had been superannuated on 30.06.2013
itself. The judgment referred to by the petitioner in State of
Tamil Nadu, rep.by its Secretary to Government, Finance
Department and others v. M.Balasubramaniam, reported in
CDJ 2012 MHC 6525, was passed under similar
circumstances on 20.09.2012, wherein this Court confirmed
the order passed in W.P.No.8440 of 2011 allowing the writ
petition filed by the employee, by observing that the
employee had completed one full year of service from
01.04.2002 to 31.03.2003, which entitled him to the benefit
of increment which accrued to him during that period.
7. The petitioner herein had completed one full
year service as on 30.06.2013, but the increment fell due on
01.07.2013, on which date he was not in service. In view of
the above judgment of this Court, naturally he has to be
treated as having completed one full year of service, though
the date of increment falls on the next day of his retirement.
Applying the said judgment to the present case, the writ
petition is allowed and the impugned order passed by the
first respondent-Tribunal dated 21.03.2017 is quashed. The
petitioner shall be given one notional increment for the
period from 01.07.2012 to 30.06.2013, as he has completed
one full year of service, though his increment fell on
01.07.2013, for the purpose of pensionary benefits and not
for any other purpose. No costs.
The Hon'ble apex court vide order dated 23.7.2018 in SLP
(Civil) Diary No.(s) 22283/2018 confirmed the judgment
passed by the Hon'ble Madras High Court and dismissed the
SLP.
9. We find that the Hon'ble Madras High Court had
already considered the issue raised by the applicants in the
present OAs are we are in full agreement with the judgment
passed by the Hon'ble Madras High Court in P.
Ayyamperumal's case (supra) upheld by the Hon'ble apex
court.
10. Therefore, the impugned orders of rejection
Annexure A4 in OA No. 180/654/2019 and Annexures A5 in
OAs Nos. 180/1055/2018 and 180/61/2019 are quashed and
set aside. The applicant in OA No. 180/109/2019 had sought
OP(CAT) No.208/2020
2025:KER:24381
relief to quash Annexure A6 which is only a reply to the
question posed by a Member of Parliament in Lok Sabha. The
applicants shall be given one notional increment for the
purpose of calculating the pensionary benefits and not for any
other purpose as held by the Hon'ble Madras High Court in P.
Ayyamperumal's case (supra) upheld by the Hon'ble apex
court. The respondents shall implement the order of this
Tribunal within three months from the date of receipt of a copy
of this order. There shall be no order as to costs.”
7.
The issue involved in this matter has already been
pondered by the Division Bench of this Court in OP(CAT) No.65/2023 dated
10.08.2023. In that case, this Court considered the matter in extenso, and
granted one notional increment to the applicants who are similarly placed.
The relevant paragraphs are extracted hereunder:
“12. The argument raised based on the proviso to
Note I of Rule 33 of the Central Civil Service (Pension) Rules
is that any increment other than the one referred to in Note 4,
which is not actually drawn, shall not form part of the
emoluments for the purpose of pension. We notice that the
said argument is attractive in the first blush. Rule 33 of the
CCS (Pension) Rules is extracted below:"Rule 33
33. Emoluments
The expression ‘emoluments’ means basic pay as defined in
Rule 9(21)(a)(i) of the Fundamental Rules which a
Government servant was receiving immediately before his
retirement or on the date of his death; and will also include
non-practising allowance granted to Medical Officer in lieu of
private practice.
Explanation:—Stagnation increment shall be treated as
emoluments for calculation of retirement benefits.
Note 1 - If a Government servant immediately before his
retirement or death while in service had been absent from
duty on leave for which leave salary is payable or having been
suspended had been reinstated without forfeiture of service,
OP(CAT) No.208/2020
2025:KER:24381
the emoluments which he would have drawn had he not been
absent from duty or suspended shall be the emoluments for
the purposes of this rule:
Provided that any increase in pay (other than the increment
referred to in Note 4) which is not actually drawn shall not
form part of his emoluments.
Note 2 - Where a Government servant immediately before his
retirement or death while in service had proceeded on leave
for which leave salary is payable after having held a higher
appointment, whether in an officiating or temporary capacity,
the benefit of emoluments drawn in such higher appointment
shall be given only if it is certified that the Government
servant would have continued to hold the higher appointment
but for his proceeding on leave.
Note 3 - If a Government servant immediately before his
retirement or death while in service had been absent from
duty on extraordinary leave or had been under suspension,
the period whereof does not count as service, the emoluments
which he drew immediately before proceeding on such leave
or being placed under suspension shall be the emoluments for
the purposes of this rule.
Note 4 - If a Government servant immediately before his
retirement or death while in service, was on earned leave, and
earned an increment which was not withheld, such increment,
though not actually drawn, shall form part of his emoluments:
Provided that the increment was earned during the currency
of the earned leave not exceeding one hundred and twenty
days, or during the first one hundred and twenty days of
earned leave where such leave was for more than one hundred
and twenty days.”
13. Here again, we cannot appreciate and recognise
the argument of the learned counsel for the respondents,
inasmuch as the Hon'ble Supreme Court has recognised the
right of the employees based on a purposive interpretation
based on the object and concept based upon which an annual
increment is granted. This is all the more so, in view of the
findings of the Hon'ble Supreme Court that, depriving the
benefit, which emanates from a service which has been
admittedly rendered, would lead to arbitrariness and
unreasonableness, in the light of which, we can only find that
the argument based on the proviso to Note I of Rule 33 is also
squarely in the teeth of the arbitrariness and
unreasonableness, as found by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
OP(CAT) No.208/2020
2025:KER:24381
14. In the result, these original petitions succeed
and the impugned Common Order of the Tribunal is hereby
set aside. We direct the respondents to grant one notional
increment to the petitioners, as also, to revise their retiral
benefits after including such annual increment. We direct that
the above direction shall be complied within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.”
8.
The
Honourable
Apex
Court
in
Civil
Appeal
No.2471/2023 pondered the same issue and upheld the dictum laid down in
P.Ayyamperumal’s case (supra) of the Madras High Court. The issue
involved in this matter is no longer res integra. In view of the judgment in
OP(CAT) No.65/2023, OP(CAT) No.208/2020 fails and it is liable to be
dismissed in our view.
Therefore, OP(CAT) is dismissed.
Sd/-
AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/-
K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
Sbna/
OP(CAT) No.208/2020
2025:KER:24381
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 208/2020
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A4
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER
CASE DATED 26.04.2019 BY
(CP)-PAY AND FP.
NO.CP(P)/2080/COURT
THE COMMANDER CDR
ANNEXURE A1
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 15.09.2017 IN
WPC 15732 OF 2017 ISSUED BY THE HON'BLE HIGH
COURT OF MADRAS.
ANNEXURE A2
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 23.07.2018 IN
SLP(C0 DIARY NO(S) 22283/18 ON THE FILE OF THE
APEX COURT.
ANNEXURE A3
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED NIL
JANUARY 2019 SUBMITTED BY MR.P.R. SREEKUMAR TO
THE FLAG OFFICER COMMANDING IN CHIEF.
ANNEXURE A5
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
REPRESENTATION
DATED
29.03.2019 SUBMITTED BY MR.P.R.SREEKUMAR TO THE
FLAG OFFICER COMMANDING IN CHIEF.
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF THE OA NO.180/00654/2019 FILED BY
THE PETITIONER DATED 08.08.2019 FILED BEFORE
THE CAT, ERNAKULAM BENCH.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER ISSUED BY THE CAT,
ERNAKULAM BENCH IN OA NO.180/00654/2019 DATED
03.12.2019.
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF LETTER F.NO.A-23011/136/2013AD.IIIA DATED 18.10.2019 OF THE MINISTRY OF
FINANCE, DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, CENTRAL BOARD
OF INDIRECT TAXES AND CUSTOMS, NEW DELHI.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review