Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:20640
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
WEDNESDAY, THE 5
TH
DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 14TH PHALGUNA, 1946
DBP NO. 78 OF 2018
PETITIONER:
COCHIN DEVASWOM BOARD
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
THRISSUR
BY ADV K.P.SUDHEER, SC, COCHIN DEVASWOM BOARD
RESPONDENTS:
THE SENIOR DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
KERALA STATE AUDIT DEPARTMENT
COCHIN DEVASWOM BOARD AUDIT, ROUND NORTH
THRISSUR , PIN 680001 (IS SUO MOTU CORRECTED VIDE
ORDER DATED 05.03.2025)
ADDL R2 TEMPLE RENOVAITON COMMITTEE
PAZHAYANNUR BHAGAVATHY TEMPLE
T.R.VISWAMBHARAN
THONIKUZHIYIL HOUSE, KALLAMPARAMBU,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587
N.MURALI
CHAKKINGAL HOUSE THEKKETHARA,
PAZHAYANNUR P O 680 587.
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
VIJAYAN KALATH
KALATH HOUSE, THEKKETHARA,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587.
T.KAMALAKARAN
THEKKEPAT HOUSE, KAITHACODE,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587.
A.K.RAJENDRAN
ALAKKAL PARAMBIL, (NEAR) NAVODAYA HOSPITAL,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587
K.RAVINDRA MENON
KAYARAT HOUSE,AMBALANADA,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587.
N.BABU
NARAYANA NIVAS, THEKKETHARA,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587.
BINOY.K.
KANIKUDIYIL HOUSE, THEKKETHARA,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587.
SUKUMARAN E.C.
EDAPARAMBIL HOUSE, VELLARKULAM,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587.
SIVARAMAKRISHNAN.P.M.
KAMALA VIHAR, THEKKETHARA,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587
KUMARAN.K.
KUNNATH HOUSE, KAKKARAKUNNU,VADAKKETHARA,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587
K.MOHANAN,
KUTTALE HOUSE, (KALATH), THEKKETHARA,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587.
RAMACHANDRAN.C
CHERUNGOTTIL HOUSE, VADAKKETHARA,
PAZHAYANNUR P.O., PIN-680 587
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
BY ADVS.
GOVERNMENT PLEADER
SRI.R.SUDHIR
OTHER PRESENT:
SRI. K. P. SUDHEER, SC, CDB
SRI. S. RAJMOHAN,
SRI. P. RAMACHANDRAN, AMICUS CURIAE
THIS
ADMISSION
DEVASWOM
ON
BOARD
05.03.2025,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
PETITION
THE
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
SAME
DAY
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
ORDER
Anil K. Narendran, J.
This DBP is registered based on CDB Report No.73 of 2018
of the learned Ombudsman in Petition No.16 of 2018 filed by the
Cochin Devaswom Board seeking permission to execute the
renovation work of Pazhayannur Bhagavathy Temple, which is a
temple under its management, on the basis of Annexure A2
revised estimate and Annexure A3 work order. The report of the
learned Ombudsman reads thus;
"This is a maramath petition filed by the Cochin
Devaswom
Board
through
the
Secretary
seeking
permission to the applicant Cochin Devaswom Board to
execute
the
renovation
work
of
Pazhayannur
Bhagavathy Temple, on the basis of Annexure A2
revised Estimate and Annexure A3 work order. The
petition is supported by an Affidavit sworn in to by the
Secretary.
2. It is averred that the Pazhayannur Bhagavathy
Temple belongs to the Cochin Devaswom Board and
renovation work of the temple was started as early as
on 2010 after the temple was substantially damaged
due to fire accident. The work was awarded to the
Pazhayannur Bhagavathy Temple Renovation Committee
on contribution basis and the contribution of the Board
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
was fixed as 100% of the valuation amount or Rs.50
lakhs whichever is less. The work though started, could
not
be
completed
after
a
long
period
and
the
OMBUDSMAN for the Board visited the temple and based
on the inspection conducted, SMC No 107 of 2017 was
issued directing the Board to explain as to why there is
delay in completing the work and to state the possible
time within which the work can be completed. Pursuant
thereto, the Executive Engineer of the Board submitted
Annexure A1. Thereafter. the Engineering Wing of the
Board was directed to prepare a revised estimate to
execute the work and as directed by the Board, the
Engineering Wing of the Board prepared a revised
estimate amounting to Rs.51,00,000/- as against the
initial estimate of Rs 1,10,00,000/-sanctioned earlier.
Technical sanction is Annexure A2 and the Order of the
Board approving the estimate subject to decision of the
Honourable High Court is Annexure A3. It is requested
that permission be granted to execute the renovation
work of the temple.
3. Pursuant to the notice issued, the Audit filed their
remarks. It is stated that the original work was
sanctioned on condition that out of the estimate for Rs.
1,10,00,000/-, the Board is to provide contribution of
100% or Rs.50 lakhs whichever is less and the balance
amount is to be contributed by the Committee and now
the estimate is revised to Rs 51 lakhs after a period of
seven years and after making the payment of more than
Rs. 24 lakhs in cash apart from sanctioning materials in
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
kind (copper). The comparative statement attached to
the file does not state the reason for the variation in the
estimate amount. Even if the reduction of the estimate
amount, the Committee was approached to find out the
balance. In terms of the original sanction and the
Committee is going to get Rs.50 lakhs after revision
without taking into consideration the income earned by
the Committee.
4. Learned counsel Shri T.K. Sajeev appeared on behalf
of the Board and the Law Officer was also present. On
behalf of the Audit, the Deputy Director was present.
The Assistant Executive Engineer was also present for
discussion when the case was taken up for hearing
today.
5. Based on the discussion I had with the Assistant
Executive Engineer, I am made to understand that the
reduction of the estimate amount to Rs.51,00,000/- as
against Rs. 1,10,00,000/- initially estimated happened
due to the fact that used and old copper sheet available
in other temples were supplied by the Department and
hence the cost of the materials supplied was reduced
from the initial estimate to items 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11,
16 and 17. Therefore, there is a total saving of
Rs.64,88,791/-. For some of the items, there is an
excess as per the comparison of the initial estimate. A
Statement is filed, copy of which is marked as Annexure
01.
6. Normally, when a revised estimate is prepared, the
estimated value goes up whereas in the present case,
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
initial estimated amount got reduced as per the revised
estimate which is to the advantage to the Cochin
Devaswom Board. Since the work was started by the
Temple Advisory Committee, fixing the contribution of
the Board at 100% or Rs.50 lakhs whichever is less, in
view of the revised estimate, there may not be any
contribution by the Renovation Committee, but it is to
be
noticed
that
even the
original sanction order,
contribution fixed is 100% valuation to be borne by the
Board or Rs.50 lakhs whichever is less. Hence there is
no profit as such earned by the Committee. However,
the Board can explore the possibility of some amount of
contribution to be made by the Renovation Committee
by generating from publicso as to reduce the liability of
the Board. However, since the work is of an essential
nature, the petition seeking sanction be allowed by the
Honourable High Court and the Board be directed to
complete the work without further delay as more than
eight years have elapsed after the renovation work was
started."
2.
On
29.10.2018,
when
this
DBP
came
up
for
consideration, this Court noticed that there is a drastic reduction
in the total estimate in so far as the amount fixed as
Rs.1,10,00,000/- about seven years back has been brought
down to Rs.51 lakhs, which is of course is to the benefit of
Devaswom. At the same time, it is stated that the reduction to
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
the estimate is because of the supply of old copper sheets
available in other temples, by the Department. By the order
dated 29.10.2018, the Devaswom Board was required to file an
affidavit showing the particulars as to what is the quantity of
copper that has been supplied, what is the value that has been
fixed in this regard, etc.
3.
The order dated 29.10.2018 was followed by the
order dated 14.11.2018, which reads thus;
"The factual aspects noted by the Ombudsman in the
report reveal that, earlier, the estimate in connection
with the work was finalised and sanctioned at Rs.1.1
crore as per the Annexure.A1. But now a revised
estimate has been prepared and the same has come
down to Rupees Fifty one lakhs after a period of seven
years. It is also stated in the report that some used and
old copper sheets available in the other temples were
supplied by the Department and hence the cost of
materials came to be reduced and that there was a
saving
of
Rs.64,88,791/-.
The
genuineness
and
immediate requirement of the work to be carried out
stands certified by the Ombudsman. However, when the
matter came up for consideration earlier, we required
the Devaswom Board to give the facts and figures in
respect of the extent of copper supplied; pursuant to
which a statement dated 03.11.2018 has been filed;
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
giving the particulars in the form of a table. It is pointed
out that a total of 2804.017 Kgs. of copper was
supplied, having a total value of Rs.12,95,455.85. In
other words the total cost could be considered as
Rs.51,00,000/- + Rs.13,88,791/-Rs.64,88,791/-. If this
alone is the actual cost to be satisfied as on date, how
the same to be fixed and sanctioned as Rs.1.1 crore
seven years ago by the Devaswom Board, appears to a
matter to be looked into. Since nothing is stated in the
statement in this regard, the Devaswom Board is given
a chance to explain by filing an affidavit in this regard."
4.
The order dated 14.11.2018 was followed by the
order dated 05.12.2018, which reads thus;
"This matter came to be registered pursuant to Report
No.73/2018 dated 7.9.2018 submitted by the learned
Ombudsman in relation to the affairs of 'Pazhayannur
Bhagavathy Temple' under the Cochin Devaswom Board.
2. An application was submitted before the learned
Ombudsman by the Devaswom Board seeking for
permission to execute the renovation works of the
temple on the basis of Annexure A2 revised estimate
and Annexure A3 work order. The discussion made by
the learned Ombudsman in the Report reveals that the
same work was sought to be effected about seven years
ago at an estimate of nearly 1.1 crores and the Cochin
Devaswom Board was to provide contribution of 100%
or Rs.50 lakhs whichever was less, leaving the balance
to be contributed by the Temple Renovation Committee.
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
It is pointed out that the work could not be completed,
though it was started, and later, pursuant to further
steps, a revised estimate has been prepared, whereby
the total cost is stated as reduced to Rs.51 lakhs. It is
pointed out that the same is much beneficial to the
Devaswom Board, in so far as, more than 50% of the
expense
(original
estimate)
could
be
saved.
The
reduction in the estimate is pointed out as also due to
the supply of some materials (copper).
3. When the matter came up for consideration before
this Court on 29.10.2018, the Devaswom Board was
required to explain the particulars as to the supply of
copper sheets and also as to the circumstance under
which the reduction to a huge extent was resulted. This
was followed by another order passed on 14.11.2018,
which is in the following terms:
The factual aspects noted by the Ombudsman in the
report reveal that, earlier, the estimate in connection
with the work was finalised and sanctioned at Rs.1.1
crore as per the Annexure.Al. But now a revised
estimate has been prepared and the same has come
down to Rupees Fifty one lakhs after a period of
seven years. It is also stated in the report that some
used and old copper sheets available in the other
temples were supplied by the Department and hence
the cost of materials came to be reduced and that
there
was
a
saving
of
Rs.64,88,791/-.
The
genuineness and immediate requirement of the work
to be carried out stands certified by the Ombudsman.
However, when the matter came up for consideration
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
earlier, we required the Devaswom Board to give the
facts and figures in respect of the extent of copper
supplied; pursuant to which the statement dated
03.11.2018 has been filed; giving the particulars in
the form of a table. It is pointed out that a total of
2804.017 Kgs. of copper was supplied, having a total
value of Rs. 12,95,455.85. In other words the total
cost
could
be
considered
as
Rs.51,00,000/-
+
Rs.13,88,791/-Rs.64,88,791/-. If this alone is the
actual cost to be satisfied as on date, how the same
to be fixed and sanctioned as Rs.1.1 crore seven
years ago by the Devaswom Board, appears to a
matter to be looked into. Since nothing is stated in
the statement in this regard, the Devaswom Board is
given a chance to explain by filing an affidavit in this
regard.
4. Pursuant to the said order, an additional affidavit,
dated 28.11.2018, has been filed by the Secretary of
the Devaswom Board; paragraphs 3 and 4 of which are
relevant and hence they are extracted below:
3.
It
is
submitted
that
the
initial
is
for
Rs.1,10,00,000/-prepared as per Delhi Schedule of
Rate
(DSOR)
2010.
The
Revised
Estimate
for
Rs.51,00,000/- is also prepared as per DSOR 2010
considering site condition. Since there is major
difference in amount, the Engineering wing of the
Board is directed to prepare a report on comparison
of amount between initial estimate and Revised
Estimate and they submitted report on 27/11/2018.
True copy of the report No.H 1.1846/09 dated
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
27/11/2018 submitted by the Engineering wing is
produced herewith and marked as Annexure-A4.
4. It is submitted that as per the Annexure A4 report,
there is a total savings of Rs.64,88,791/- and an
excess
of
Rs.5,88,791/-,
ie.
(Rs.1,10,00,000/-)
(Rs.64,88,791/-) + (Rs.5,88,791/-) Rs.51,00,000/-.
The major difference in the amount is in the use of
irul/anjili
wood
instead
of
teak
wood,
copper
materials and copper nail. There is a savings of
Rs.28,55,416/- in teak wood work, Rs.23,23,860/- in
copper sheet material including use of 2804 kg old
copper
sheet
worth
of
Rs.
12,95,455/-
and
Rs.7,71,925/- in copper nail. The teak wood is used
for 'Sreekovil' and 'Balikkalpura' doors in revised
estimate and not for planks of copper sheet roofing.
The
planks
for
copper
sheet
roofing
is
in
irul/anjiliwood work (incorporated in item no.6 of
revised estimate). Thus the irul/anjiliwood work has
increased
from
initial
estimate
amount.
The
weight/area of copper considered in initial estimate
for material copper is 12.50 kg/m2 and 10.56kg/m2
but as per site condition weight/area of copper in
Revised
Estimate
is
6.05
kg/m2
only.
The
weight/area of copper nail in initial estimate is
2.50kg/m2 but as per site condition in Revised
Estimate
weight/area
of
copper
nail
is
only
0.093kg/m2 only. The roofing with copper sheet area
in initial estimate is 575 m2 but as per site condition
in Revised Estimate the area is 495m2 only.
5. The learned Standing Counsel points out that both
the original estimate as well as the revised estimate
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
were prepared as per the 'DSOR of 2010' (Delhi
Schedule of Rates). But, apart from the amount credited
in respect of supply of copper sheets, there is also a
change with regard to the type of wood to be used. In
the original estimate, 'teak wood' was to be used;
whereas in the revised estimate, it is 'Irul/Anjili' and, as
such, there is substantial change in the wood value,
bringing it down, in view of the decision to make use of
Irul/Anjili wood in place of teak wood.
6. However, this Court has serious doubts as to whether
the change now proposed by using 'Irul/Anjili' wood in
place of teak wood for roof and other structures (except
doors) will be adequate enough to save the construction
from termite attack and natural calamities. We are not
given to understand whether this was on the basis of
any sanction/clearance given by the technical committee
or Chief Engineer or such other competent authorities,
but for an attempt to have the construction limiting it to
whatever amount is provided by the Devaswom Board;
i.e. Rs.50 lakhs; compromising with the quality of the
work involved.
7. In the said circumstance, this Court is of the view
that the matter requires to be considered by the learned
Ombudsman
again,
with
reference
to
these
vital
aspects, after affording an opportunity of hearing to the
technical experts of the Devaswom or such other
authorities. The Registry is directed to forward the
proceedings to the learned Ombudsman for scrutiny and
submission of additional report."
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
5.
By the order dated 07.01.2020, this Court impleaded
the members of the additional 2 nd respondent Temple Renovation
Committee of Pazhayannur Bhagavathi Temple as additional
respondents 3 to 15. Notice was issued to additional respondents
3 to 15 by speed post, returnable within two weeks. The
Secretary of the Cochin Devaswom Board was directed to file an
affidavit as to whether the renovation work has already been
completed and if not, what exactly is the stage of the renovation
work.
6.
The order dated 07.01.2020 was followed by the
order dated 10.08.2020, which reads thus;
"The captioned DBP was registered based on Report
No.73
of
dated
07.09.2018
of
the
learned
Ombudsman for Travancore and Cochin Devaswom
Boards in relation to the renovation works of the
Pazhayannur Bhagavathy Temple, under the Cochin
Devaswom Board (for short, 'CDB').
2. See the order dated 5.12.2018. It would reveal that
initially, an estimate was prepared for renovation works
as per the 'DSOR of 2010' (Delhi Schedule of Rates).
Going by the original estimate for Rs.1,10,00,000/- Teak
wood
was
to
be
used
for
the
renovation
work.
Subsequently, a revised estimate was prepared for an
amount of Rs.51,00,000/- and that was also prepared as
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
per DSOR 2010, taking into account the condition of the
site.
The
initial
estimate
of
Rs.1,10,00,000/-
was
brought down to Rs.51 lakhs pursuant to the decision to
use Irul/Anjili in place of Teak wood. The report
No.25/2019 in the above DBP would further reveal that
the work was carried out in terms of the revised
estimate. In fact, the report would also reveal that the
revised estimate and the petition for sanction was filed
after completion of the work. It is in the circumstances
that the learned Ombudsman observed that the petition
filed before the Ombudsman was one for ratification and
not for previous sanction. The report would also reveal
that earlier the CDB was advised to get a report from an
expert regarding the quality of the wood with reference
to its life and thereupon a report was submitted by Sri.
Raman Bhattathiripad, the former Chief Engineer/Chief
Technical Expert of CDB, to the effect that the wood
'Anjili' comes under the primary species of wood and it
is long lasting timber species which would not be
affected by fungus staining and not easily be attacked
by termites. The opinion of the expert was that Anjili
could be substituted in place of Teak wood. Taking note
of the said report and also the fact that the work was
over, the learned Ombudsman, as per CDB Report No.25
of 2019, observed that since the work was already over
and in such circumstances what could be done is only to
issue a further direction to the CDB to ensure that
hereafter in respect of maramath works, the work
should be started only after obtaining sanction. But the
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
fact is that without filing any other maramath petition
for getting previous sanction to effect further renovation
works, further works were started. What is a matter of
concern is that such works were commenced without
getting approval for such works as also for the estimate
for such works. No re-revised estimate, subsequent to
revised
estimate
for
Rs.51,00,000/-
was
also
got
approved.
3. A statement has been filed in the DBP by the
additional 5th respondent pursuant to the order of this
Court dated 10.2.2020. Along with the same, Annexures
R5(a) to (c) were produced. Paragraph 5 therein would
reveal that the Renovation Committee had raised an
amount of Rs.2.11 crores through donations from the
devotees. What is the source of power for collecting
such a huge amount? It is further stated therein thus:"Apart
from
this,
the
Renovation
Committee
constituted in the year 2009 has been taking care of
the temple festivals and rituals and the expenses
incurred is estimated at Rs. 1.80 crores during the
last 10 years."
4. At the same time, paragraph 4 of the said statement
would reveal that the renovation work was started in the
year 2012 and for undertaking additional works, (not
based
on
any approved
estimate)
the
Renovation
Committee had already spent an amount of Rs.2.30
crores.
In
fact,
the
Renovation Committee
got
a
grievance that out of Rs.50 lakhs agreed to be given to
the
committee
by
the
CDB,
only
an
amount
of
DBP No.78 of 2018
Rs.24,11,928/-
was
so
far
been
2025:KER:20640
given. In fact,
additionally, the CDB had given some more amount and
the total amount given by the Board is Rs.29 lakhs. We
are at a loss to understand as to how the committee
could collect and incur expense of Rs.2.3 crores ? As
noticed hereinbefore, for the approved renovation works
the initial estimate was Rs. 1.10 crores and at the same
time it was subsequently revised to Rs.51 lakhs.
5. In the context of the aforesaid statement, it is
relevant to refer to section 76A of the Travancore Hindu
Religious Institutions Act. It provides for formation of
Temple Advisory Committee. There is nothing on record
which would reveal that the Renovation Committee was
approved as the Temple Advisory Committee. So also,
there is nothing on record which would reveal whether a
Temple Advisory Committee, as provided under section
76A, was constituted in respect of the temple in
question.
Since
the
Renovation
Committee
was
constituted in the year 2009, it is un-understandable as
to how the said committee, if at all it is approved as
Temple Advisory Committee, could continue for a period
of 11 years and conduct temple festivals and rituals and
incur expenses. Nothing is also on record to know
whether the said committee had submitted separate
accounts for audit in relation to the renovation works as
also the expenses incurred for conducting festivals and
rituals, periodically. The afore-extracted paragraph 5
would
reveal
collected
2.11
that
the
crores
Renovation
and
Committee
expended
about
had
1.80
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
crores,for the latter purpose during the aforesaid period.
In the light of the statement filed by the additional fifth
respondent, prima facie, what is evident that they had
actually started renovation works without obtaining
proper sanction and also without getting approval for
the estimate. Report No.25/2019 would reveal that the
approved renovation works were already completed. It
is also not discernible from the materials on record as to
whether for such additional works, permission was
granted by the CDB and if at all permission was granted,
whether
maramath
petition
was
filed
for
getting
previous sanction for effecting such works and whether
an estimate therefor, was prepared and got approved. In
such circumstances, the statement of the committee
that they had raised Rs.2.11 crores or more through
donations from the devotees and that they had already
expended Rs.2.30 crores are to be explained by them.
6. A conjoint reading of paragraphs 4 and 5 of the
statement
would
gather
the
impression
that
for
renovation works, the committee had spent an amount
of Rs.2.30 crores and incurred expenses of Rs. 1.80
crores after collecting Rs.2.11 crores for conducting
festivals and rituals, during the last 10 years. The
functioning
of
the
said
committee
and
incurring
expenses in the aforesaid manner is a matter which
requires serious scrutiny, in accordance with law. In
such circumstances, touching the facts discernible from
the statement filed by the additional fifth respondent
pursuant to our order dated 10.2.2020, including the
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
matters referred above the Secretary, CDB shall file a
detailed affidavit. Such an affidavit should contain
statement as to how and under what circumstances the
Renovation Committee which was constituted in the year
2009 was permitted to continue to function as temple
festival
committee
and
why
despite
the
statutory
mandate under section 76A of the Travancore Hindu
Religious Institutions Act, TAC was not constituted in
respect of the said temple. Further, it should also
contain as to whether the collection of Rs.2.11 crores
(Rs.2.30 crores ?) was by using sealed coupons issued
by the Board and whether in respect of the renovation
works as also the expenses for temple festivals etc., the
committee had submitted separate periodical accounts
for audit. If such accounts are not submitted for
periodical audit, what action was taken by the Board for
obtaining and getting such accounts audited. Such a
detailed affidavit shall be filed, without fail, on or before
24.8.2020."
7.
The order dated 10.08.2020 was followed by the
order dated 30.06.2021, which reads thus;
"Circumstances revealed from the records appended to
Report No.73 of 2018 in Petition No.16 of 2018 led to
the registration of the captioned DBP. It pertains to
renovation work of PazhayanoorBhagavathy Temple.
Taking note of the extent of renovation works to be
undertaken, earlier an estimate was prepared for an
amount of Rs.1,10,00,000/- as per DSOR of 2010.
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
Obviously, at that point of time, the proposal was to
effect construction using Teak wood. Later, a revised
estimate was prepared in terms of DSOR of 2010 for an
amount of Rs.51 lakh. Obviously, the estimated amount
was
brought
down
from
Rs.1,10,00,000/-
to
Rs.51,00,000/- due to the decision to use Irul/Anjili in
place of Teak wood, for the works. The fact is that,
pending the application construction works, much in
excess of the estimate, were carried out and in that
regard, going by the pleadings, amounts in crores have
been collected and expended. Taking note of the said
situation, this Court suo motu impleaded the Renovation
Committee of the temple as additional respondents 3 to
15. While making a statement that Rs.2.30 crores have
been collected the stand of the Committee is that such
an amount was utilised not only for renovation works,
but also for conducting festivals and other rituals in the
temple. It is also a fact that in between the Cochin
Devaswom Board (for short 'CDB) has given an amount
of Rs.29 lakhs for the renovation works. This is evident
from paragraph 4 of the statement filed by the 5th
respondent. Be that as it may, it appears that despite
collecting amounts in crores and the lapse of more than
a decade since the formation of Renovation Committee,
the renovation works still remain uncompleted. It is also
a matter of concern that despite the introduction of
Section 76A in the Travancore Cochin Hindu Religious
Institutions Act, (for short 'the Act') the Renovation
Committee, which was formed in the year 2009, is still
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
acting as the Temple Advisory Committee. True that in
2009, taking note of the existence of the Renovation
Committee and also the Temple Advisory Committee in
the temple and the difficulties faced owing to the
existence of two committees, in the matter of smooth
functioning
including
the
works
connected
with
renovation, this Court passed an order permitting the
Renovation Committee to continue function and directed
the Devaswom Authorities to take into possession the
movable articles within the possession of the Temple
Advisory Committee required for performing the rituals
in the temple. Consequently, the Renovation Committee
was also permitted to conduct festivals. Shortly stated,
the Renovation Committee which was formed in the year
2009 slowly assumed the character of Temple Advisory
Committee and besides performing the renovation works
it continued to conduct the temple festivals, other rituals
etc. Needless to say that in such circumstances, it
continued to collect amounts from the Devotees. At this
juncture we notice that the exact amount collected till
date is not before this Court. So also, whether the entire
amounts were collected only by utilising sealed coupons
issued by the Board is also a matter of guess. When the
matter is taken up for consideration, taking note of the
situation this Court put a pointed question as to whether
the Renovation Committee which had earlier executed
an
agreement
dated
05.03.2011
and
given
an
undertaking to complete the construction within two
years could fulfill the undertaking? Based on the
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
response, this Court put a further question as to what
exactly is the stage of the construction/renovation
works. No definite answer is forthcoming from the
Committee as also CDB. What is available is the stage of
construction
as
on
09.03.2020.
Still,
from
the
submission made by the learned counsel for the
Renovation Committee as also the submission from the
learned Standing Counsel for CDB, what we could gather
is the renovation/construction works are still going on.
How long it will continue? We also put a question to the
learned Standing Counsel as to whether taking note of
the enormous amount collected and the period during
which the committee has been functioning at any point
of time, accounts of the committee were obtained and
subjected to audit. The answer is in the negative. Thus,
the unpleasant scenario is that, in the temple, during
the pendency of this petition moved for getting sanction
for a revised estimate of Rs.51 lakhs for the purpose of
renovation works, even without appropriate approval
and even without preparing and getting sanctioned
estimates, works were undertaken and certain types of
works are still undergoing. This kind of a situation
cannot be permitted to continue in Devaswoms. Though
the committee is accountable despite the lapse of more
than a decade of its constitution the accounts of the
committee werenot so far been made available for audit.
That apart, the very purpose of which the committee
was
constituted
in
the
year
still
remains
unaccomplished. The matter of concern is that in
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
between crores of rupees have been collected from the
devotees, taking note of all such circumstances, we are
of the view that an inquiry into the entire affairs with
respect to the construction/renovation works, manner of
expenditure etc may have to be done. But at the same
time, taking note of the entire aspects, we have no
hesitation to hold that the Renovation Committee, which
was formed in the year 2009 cannot now be permitted
to
continue
to
function
as
the
Temple
Advisory
Committee, indefinitely. We will consider the question
whether the said committee could be permitted to
continue to undertake the renovation works, later. To
pass appropriate orders on these aspects, taking into
account the aforesaid facts, additional respondents 3 to
15 are directed to file detailed affidavit, either jointly or
independently, with respect to the entire aspects, viz.,
what exactly is the amount collected so far for the
purpose of construction/renovation works and also for
the purpose of conducting festivals. They will have to
give details under each head separately. They shall also
state what exactly is the amount spent for renovation
works as also for conducting the festivals/rituals in the
temple. They should also state whether such amounts
were collected utilising the sealed coupons issued by the
CDB. They should further state in what manner the
amounts collected were kept and operated. In other
words, whether it was deposited after opening any
specific account therefor. We have no hesitation to hold
that on all those aspects the CDB shall also file an
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
affidavit. The CDB shall state as to what are the steps
taken for obtaining the accounts of the committee to
subject them to audit and what action was taken in case
of failure of the committee to submit the account
despite the request therefor. The CDB shall also state
the minimum time required for formation of a Temple
Advisory Committee in the temple under Section 76A of
the Act. The affidavits, as directed, shall be filed by the
respective parties in terms of this order within a period
of three weeks."
8.
On
consideration,
26.10.2021,
when
the
Amicus
learned
this
DBP
Curiae
came
for
the
up
for
learned
Ombudsman submitted that vide Annexure A15, the said Special
Commissioner has directed the Devaswom Officer, Pazhayannur
to furnish a copy of the audit report of the Temple Renovation
Committee and requested to offer its explanation/remarks to
Annexure A14 Audit report. The learned counsel for the 5th
respondent, who is the Secretary of the Temple Renovation
Committee, submitted that the explanation/remarks to the
points noted in Annexure A14 Audit report will be filed within a
week.
9.
Along with an affidavit dated 25.09.2021 sworn to by
the Secretary of the Cochin Devaswom Board, Annexures A14 to
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
A18 documents are placed on record. Paragraphs 3 to 5 of that
affidavit read thus;
"3. It is submitted that by Annexure A13 order the
Devaswom Board entrusted the Revenue Inspector of
Thiruvilwamala Group to audit the accounts of the
committee. After completing the audit, a report was
submitted by the auditors on 15.9.2021. In this regard a
true copy of the audit report is produced herewith and
marked as Annexure A14. On receipt of the audit report,
the Special Devaswom Commissioner has issued Order
No.
AS.
10426/17
dated
25.9.2021
directing
the
Devaswom Officer, Pazhayannur to furnish a copy of the
audit report to the committee and requested them to
offer their explanation/ remarks to the points noted by
the audit wing. In this regard a true copy of the order
dated
25.9.2021
passed
by
Special
Devaswom
Commissioner is produced herewith and marked as
Annexure A15.
4. It is submitted that this Hon'ble Court also directed
the committee as well as the Devaswom to inform the
stage of renovation works being carried out in the
temple. In paragraph 5 of the affidavit dated 24.8.2020
it was informed that the remaining works are item Nos.
4, 5, 14 and 16 of Annexure A2 revised estimate. As
directed by this Hon'ble Court in the order dated
30.6.2021, the maramath wing of Devaswom Board
conducted an inspection and submitted a report on
25.9.2021. In this regard true copy of the report No.
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
H1-1846/09 dated 25.9.2021 is produced herewith and
marked as Annexure A16. As regards item Nos. 14 and
16 mentioned in Annexure A16 report, the same has to
be done just before the NaveekaranaKalasham.
5. It is submitted that this Hon'ble Court in the order
dated 30.6.2021 further directed the Devaswom Board
to state the minimum time required for formation of
Temple Advisory Committee in the temple under 76A of
Travancore Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act,
1950. In obedience to the directions issued by this
Hon'ble Court the Devaswom Board considered the
matter and has passed Order No. A5. 10426/17 dated
26/07/2021. True copy of the said order is produced
herewith and marked as Annexure A17. In AnnexureA17
order the Board has taken a decision to seek time till
31.12.2022
for
forming
a
new
Temple
Advisory
Committee after completing the entire maramath works
and after doing the NaveekaranaKalasham. The decision
was taken by the Board considering the fact that
"NaveekaranaKalasham" has to be conducted after
completing the entire maramath works. The committee
was also directed to relay the damaged granite cut stone
slabs inside the chuttumathil. The said work is highly
essential considering the peculiar nature of the rituals in
the temple. In this regard true copy of order on H1.
399/21 dated 17.9.2021 is produced herewith and
marked as Annexure A18."
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
10.
The 5
th
respondent has sworn to an affidavit dated
26.09.2021, producing therewith Annexures R5(d) and R5(e)
documents. Paragraphs 4 to 10 of that affidavit read thus;
"4. By order dated 30.06.2021, this Hon'ble Court has
directed the respondents to file detailed affidavit with
respect to what exactly is the amount collected so far
for the purpose of construction / renovation works and
also for the purpose of conducting festival. This Hon'ble
Court further directed that they should also state what
exactly is the amount spent for renovation works and
also for conducting the festivals / rituals in the temple.
There was a further direction to state whether such
amounts were collected utilizing the sealed coupons
issued by the CDB. It was also directed that additional
respondents should further state in what manner the
amounts
collected
were
kept
and
operated.
In
compliance with the aforesaid specific directions of this
Hon'ble Court this affidavit is being filed.
5. The details of the amounts collected so far for the
purpose of construction/renovation works and also for
conducting festivals is as under:
a) The total amount collected is Rs. 3,30,80,245/-.
b) For the purpose of renovation works the amount
credited is Rs. 2,07,94,080/c) For the purpose of conduct of the festivals, the
amount credited is Rs.1,22,86,165/-
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
d) The amount spent for renovation works is Rs.
2.05,44,340/-.
The
amount
spent
for
conduct
of
festivals is Rs. 1,25,48,665/-,
6. This respondent states that all the amount specified
hereinabove less the amounts which were digitally
transferred by the devotees in favour of the respective
bank accounts of the Committee have been collected
utilizing the sealed coupons issued by the CDB.
7. The amounts collected for renovation work were kept
and operated through the account maintained with
Punjab National Bank, Pazhayannur Branch.
8. The amounts collected for conducting the festivals
were kept and operated through the account maintained
with Pazhayannur Farmers' Co-operative Bank Ltd.
9. Pursuant to the order of this Hon'ble Court dated
30.06.2021,
the
Special
Devaswom
Commissioner.
Cochin Devaswom Board issued proceedings dated
04/08/2021
directing
Pazhayannur
the
Bhagavathy
President/Secretary
Kshethra
of
Renovation
Committee to produce the records enumerated therein
for verification of the accounts of the Committee. A true
copy
of
Devaswom
dated
the
proceedings
issued
Commissioner,
Cochin
04/08/2021
is
produced
by
the
Special
Devaswom
Board
herewith.
marked
Annexure R5(d). The Committee has complied with the
directions contained in Annexure R5(d).
10. It is submitted that the petitioner in his capacity as
the Secretary of the Pazhayannur Bhagavathy Temple
Renovation Committee, had approached this Hon'ble
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
Court in W.P.(C). No. 36458/2010 seeking three years
time to generate the funds in addition to Rs. 50 lakhs
agreed to be contributed by the Cochin Devaswom
Board, required for carrying out the renovation works in
the Pazhayannur Bhagavathy Temple. The Writ Petition
was ordered by this Hon'ble Court clarifying that those
are not matters which, the Court should supervise. This
Hon'ble Court held that the parties will make their
application before the learned Ombudsman and the
learned Ombudsman will look into the stand of either
side and issue appropriate regulatory clarifications. This
Hon'ble Court further held that the parties will stand
bound to carry out such clarifications as may be issued
by the learned Ombudsman regarding the time frame,
expenditure and all other relevant aspects. This Hon'ble
Court also clarified that having seen the materials,
further approval from this Hon'ble Court is not necessary
in the case and it would be open to the learned
Ombudsman to issue clarifications on the question of
approval also and that the Board would act upon that. A
true copy of the said judgment of this Hon'ble Court in
W.P.(C) No. 36458/2010 is produced herewith, marked
as Annexure R5(c). This respondent submits that the
directions contained in Annexure R5(e) judgment passed
by this Hon'ble Court exercising jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution of India have become final and
binding on the parties to the said proceedings."
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
11.
Along with I.A.No.1 of 2022 filed by the Cochin
Devaswom Board, Annexure A19 document is placed on record.
Paragraph 2 of the affidavit filed in support of that application
reads thus;
"The above application is filed seeking sanction for
Annexure A2 revised estimate for renovation work of
Pazhayannur Bhagavathy temple. Based on order dated
30.6.2021 an affidavit dated 25.9.2021 was filed by me.
Along with the said affidavit, Annexure A14 audit report
was also produced. By Annexure A15 order dated
25.9.2021
the
Devaswom
Officer,
Pazhayannur
Devaswom was directed to furnish a copy of the audit
report to the 5th respondent committee and requested
them to offer their explanation remarks to the audit
report. The 5th respondent committee submitted their
reply to the audit objections and thereafter the matter
was placed before the Board and the Board has issued
Order No. A5. 10426/2017 dated 25.6.2022. In this
regard a true copy of Order No. A5. 10426/2017 dated
25.6.2022 issued by the applicant is produced herewith
and marked as Annexure A19. It is highly necessary in
the interest of justice that the aforesaid document be
accepted on file. If the document is not accepted on file,
this deponent will be put to serious hardship and loss."
12.
Today, when this DBP is taken up for consideration,
the learned Standing Counsel for Cochin Devaswom Board has
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
made
available
for
the
perusal
of
this
Court
an
Office
Memorandum dated 31.01.2023, which reads thus;
“പഴയന ർ
ക
ത
പ നര ദ രണ
കമ റ യ ട
കണക
പര ക ധനയ മ യ ബനട ട അപ ക കൾക കമ റ സമർ ച
വ ദ'കരണ( പര ക ധ ച നട) അ സ നത ൽ സ ചന (1)
തപക രമ ള ഉതരവ ൽ നൽക യ
ടഴ പ)യ ന ക ര0ങൾക
കദവസ2( ഓഫ'സർ ഇ വടര ) ക ർട സമർ ച ട ല ത ണ.
1) പഴയന ർ പ നര ദ രണ കമ റ ജന)ൽ കബ ഡ വ ള ച കണക
അവ ര
കകണ ണ.
2) മ ന റസ ബ ക ൽ എല വര ( ഒ ക ണ ണ എന ന ൽ
ജ'വ ച ര ക ന എല വകര ( ഒ ട മ ന റസ ബ ക സമ
യൽ
ന ന ( വ ങ ഹ ജര ക വ ൻ കദവസ2( ഓഫ'സർക ന ർക? (
നൽക ഉതരവ ക ന .
3) കദവസ2( ടചലവ കകണ സ(ഖ0കൾ സമ
ടചലവ ക യ
സ(ബന ച കദവസ2( ഓഫ'സർ ) ക ർട സമർ കകണ ണ.
(ക ടവട ക, പര സര( വBത യ ക ക എന വ)
4) ഉതവ കD ഷങള ട
വരവ ക ണ ക ന 13 ര ' കൾ
നഷ ട ട ന ൽ നഷ ട ട ര ' കൾ ഉൾട
ന ര '
ബ ക ടല ര ' കള ട
ര ര
ക കണക ക ആയ
നഷ ട ട
ര ' കള ട
വരവ യ
കണക ക ന ന
ഉതരവ ക ന . ആയ
തപക ര( സ(ഖ0 സമ
യ ട ക0 ഷ
ബ ക ൽ വരവ ടചയ ന ന (
സ(ഗ
പര ക ധ ച ) ക ർട
ടചയ ന ന
കദവസ2(
ഓഫ'സട)
ച മ ലട
തയ(
ഉതരവ ക ന .
വ ഷയത ൽ
ബഹ :ഹഹകക
മ മ ടക
കകസ
ന ലന ൽക ന ന ൽ കമൽ പ)ഞ ക ര0ങൾക സ ചന (2)
'ര മ ന തപക ര( മ ക പ ല ൽ ) ക ർട സമർ കകണ ണ.
എ(5.6195/2009 നമർ ഫയൽ തപക ര( കസ പ ന( ടപ
ഞ പഴയ
പ ചള വ ൽ ന ന ത ലഭ ച 6,200/- ര പ ടക ച ൻ കദവസ2(
കബ ർഡ ഉതരവ തപക ര( കദവസ2ത ൽ അ ച സ(ഗ യ ൽ
അസ സൻ്) കമ'ഷണർ, കദവസ2( ഓഫ'സർ എന വർ ) ക ർട
സമർ കകണ ണ.”
13.
Devaswom
Heard the learned Standing Counsel for Cochin
Board
for
the
applicant,
the
learned
Senior
Government Pleader for the 1st respondent Senior Deputy
Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Cochin Devaswom
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
Board
Audit,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
respondent, who is the Secretary of the
respondent
Temple
Renovation
Committee
additional
5 th
additional 2 nd
of
Pazhayannur
Bhagavathi Temple, and also the learned Amicus Curiae for the
learned Ombudsman.
14.
Act,
The Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions
1950,
was
made
for
making
provisions for
the
administration, supervision and control of incorporated and
unincorporated
Devaswoms and
of
other
Hindu
Religious
Endowments and Funds. Chapter VIII of the Act deals with
Cochin Devaswom Board. Section 62 of the Act deals with
vesting of administration in the Board. As per sub-section (1) of
Section
62,
the
administration
of
incorporated
and
unincorporated Devaswoms and Hindu Religious Institutions
which were under the management of the Ruler of Cochin
immediately prior to the first day of July, 1949 either under
Section 50G of the Government of Cochin Act, XX of 1113, or
under the provisions of the Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions
Act, 1 of 1081, and all their properties and funds and of the
estates and all institutions under the management of the
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
Devaswom Department of Cochin, shall vest in the Cochin
Devaswom Board. As per sub-section (2) of Section 62,
notwithstanding the provisions contained in subsection (1), the
regulation and control of all rituals and ceremonies in the temple
of Sree Poornathrayeesa at Trippunittura and in the Pazhayannur
Bhagavathy
temple
at
Pazhayannur
shall
continue
to
be
exercised as hitherto by the Ruler of Cochin.
15.
Section 68 of the Act provides for administration by the
Board as a trustee. As per sub-section (1) of Section 68, subject to
the provisions of the Act and of any other law for the time being in
force, the Board shall be bound to administer the affairs of
incorporated and unincorporated Devaswoms and institutions under
its management in accordance with the objects of the trust, the
established usage and customs of the institutions and to apply their
funds and property for such purposes. As per sub-section (2) of
Section 68, notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1),
the Board may, out of the funds under their control, set apart such
sum
as
they
advancement
deem
fit
for
and
economic
the
educational
betterment
of
uplift,
cultural
the
Hindu
community, after providing adequately for the purposes of the
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
institutions which have to be met from the said fund.
16.
Section 73A of the Act deals with duties of the Board.
As per Section 73A, it shall be the duty of the Board to perform
the functions enumerated in clauses (i) to (iv), namely,
(i) to
see that the regular traditional rites according to the practice
prevalent in the religious institution are performed promptly; (ii)
to monitor whether the administrative staff and employees and
also the employees connected with religious rites are functioning
properly; (iii) to ensure proper maintenance and upliftment of
the Hindu Religious Institutions; (iv) to establish and maintain
proper facilities in major temples for the devotees.
17.
Section 74 of the Act deals with vesting of jurisdiction
in the Board. As per Section 74, subject to the provisions of subsection (2) of Section 62, all rights, authority and jurisdiction
belonging to or exercised by the Ruler of Cochin prior to the 1 st
day of July, 1949 in respect of incorporated and unincorporated
Devaswoms and Institutions shall vest in and be exercised by the
Board in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Section 74 of
the Act deals with superintendence and control by the Board. As
per Section 64, the Board shall, subject to the provisions of Part
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
II of the Act, exercise supervision and control over the acts and
proceedings of all officers and servants of the Board and of the
Devaswom Department.
18.
In Ram Mohan Das v. Travancore Devaswom
Board and others [1975 KLT 55] a learned Single Judge of
this Court held that, under Section 31 of the Travancore-Cochin
Hindu Religious Institutions Act the Travancore Devaswom Board
shall manage the properties and affairs of the Devaswoms, both
incorporated and unincorporated and arrange for the conduct of
the daily worship and ceremonies and of the festivals in every
temple according to its usage. The position of the Board in
regard to the Devaswoms - incorporated and unincorporated - is
analogous to that of trustees. Any improper act of the Trustees
could be questioned by a worshipper.
19.
In M.V. Ramasubbiar v. Manicka Narasimachara
[(1979) 2 SCC 65], in the context of Sections 49, 51 and 52 of
the Trusts Act, 1882, the Apex Court explained the nature of the
fiduciary position of the trustee and his duties and obligations. It
is duty of the trustees of the property to be faithful to the Trust
and execute any document with reasonable diligence in the
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
manner of an ordinary prudent man of business would conduct
his own affairs. A trustee could not therefore occasion any loss to
the Trust and it is his duty to sell the property, if at all that was
necessary, to best advantage. Paragraph 4 of that decision reads
thus;
“4. There is some controversy on the question whether
Defendant 1 made an outright purchase of the suit property for
and on behalf of the trust for Rs 21,500 on April 19, 1959, or
whether he intended to purchase it for himself and then decided
to pass it on to the trust, for defendants have led their evidence
to show that the property was allowed to be sold for Rs 21,500,
which was less than its market value, as it was meant for use by
the trust and that Defendant 1 was not acting honestly when he
palmed off the property to his son soon after by the aforesaid
sale deed Ext.B13 dated July 14, 1960. The fact, however,
remains that Defendant 1 was the trustee of the property, and it
was his duty to be faithful to the trust and to execute it with
reasonable diligence in the manner an ordinary prudent man of
business would conduct his own affairs. He could not therefore
occasion any loss to the trust and it was his duty to sell the
property, if at all that was necessary, to best advantage. It has
in fact been well recognised as an inflexible rule that a person in
a fiduciary position like a trustee is not entitled to make a profit
for himself or a member of his family. It can also not be gainsaid
that he is not allowed to put himself in any such position in
which a conflict may arise between his duty and personal
interest, and so the control of the trustee's discretionary power
prescribed by Section 49 of the Act and the prohibition
contained in Section 51 that the trustee may not use or deal
with the trust property for his own profit or for any other
purpose unconnected with the trust, and the equally important
prohibition in Section 52 that the trustee may not, directly or
indirectly, buy the trust property on his own account or as an
agent for a third person, cast a heavy responsibility upon him in
the matter of discharge of his duties as the trustee. It does not
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
require much argument to proceed to the inevitable further
conclusion that the Rule prescribed by the aforesaid sections of
the Act cannot be evaded by making a sale in the name of the
trustee's partner or son, for that would, in fact and substance,
indirectly benefit the trustee. Where therefore a trustee makes
the sale of a property belonging to the trust, without any
compelling reason, in favour of his son, without obtaining the
permission of the court concerned, it is the duty of the court, in
which the sale is challenged, to examine whether the trustee
has acted reasonably and in good faith or whether he has
committed a breach of the trust by benefitting himself from the
transaction in an indirect manner. The sale in question has
therefore to be viewed with suspicion and the High Court
committed an error of law in ignoring this important aspect of
the law although it had a direct bearing on the controversy
before it.”
(underline supplied)
20.
In A.A. Gopalakrishnan v. Cochin Devaswom Board
[(2007) 7 SCC 482] a Three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court held
that the properties of deities, temples and Devaswom Boards are
required to be protected and safeguarded by their trustees/archakas/shebaits/employees. Instances are many where persons entrusted with the duty of managing and safeguarding the properties
of temples, deities and Devaswom Boards have usurped and misappropriated such properties by setting up false claims of ownership
or tenancy, or adverse possession. This is possible only with the
passive or active collusion of the authorities concerned. Such acts
of ‘fence eating the crops’ should be dealt with sternly. The Government, members or trustees of boards/trusts, and devotees should
be vigilant to prevent any such usurpation or encroachment. It is
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
also the duty of courts to protect and safeguard the properties of
religious and charitable institutions from wrongful claims or misappropriation.
21.
In Travancore Devaswom Board v. Mohanan Nair
[(2013) 3 KLT 132] a Division Bench of this Court noticed that
in A.A. Gopalakrishnan [(2007) 7 SCC 482] the Apex Court emphasised that it is the duty of the courts to protect and safeguard
the interest and properties of the religious and charitable institutions. The relevant principles under the Hindu law will show that the
Deity is always treated similar to that of a minor and there are
some points of similarity between a minor and a Hindu idol. The
High Court therefore is the guardian of the Deity and apart from
the jurisdiction under Section 103 of the Land Reforms Act, 1957
viz. the powers of revision, the High Court is having inherent jurisdiction and the doctrine of parens patriae will also apply in exercising the jurisdiction. Therefore, when a complaint has been raised
by the Temple Advisory Committee, which was formed by the devotees of the Temple, about the loss of properties of the Temple itself,
the truth of the same can be gone into by the High Court in these
proceedings.
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
22.
In Suo Motu v. State of Kerala and others [2022
(2) KHC 411], in the context of Sabarimala Devaswom, which is
an incorporated Devaswom mentioned in Schedule I of the Act,
under Chengannur Group, this Court held that, in view of the
provisions under the Act and also the law laid down in the
decisions referred to supra, the Travancore Devaswom Board is
duty bound to ensure proper administration, supervision and
control of Sabarimala Devaswom,. The Board has a statutory
duty
to
monitor
whether
its
administrative
officials
and
employees and also the employees connected with religious rites
are functioning properly. The Board is duty bound to exercise
proper supervision and control over the acts and proceedings of
all officers and servants and to manage the properties and affairs
of Sabarimala Devaswom and conduct daily worships and
ceremonies and also festivals in the temple according to its
usage. Position of the Board in this regard is analogous to that of
trustees, as held by this Court in Ram Mohan Das [1975 KLT
55]. Any improper act of the trustees could be questioned by a
worshiper. The Board and those entrusted with the duty of
managing the properties and affairs of Sabarimala Devaswom
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
are duty bound to protect the properties of the deity from any
wrongful claims, theft or misappropriation. Any such wrongful
claims, theft or misappropriation with the passive or active
collusion of the authorities concerned, which are acts of 'fence
eating the crops' should be dealt with sternly. Since the deity
being a perpetual minor, this Court is having inherent jurisdiction
to protect and safeguard the interest and properties of the deity
and the doctrine of parens patriae will also apply in the exercise
of such jurisdiction.
23.
In Arjunan T.N. v. President, Temple Advisory
Committee and others [2012 (4) KHC 155] a Division Bench
of this Court was dealing with a DBP registered on the basis of
TDB Report No.39 of 2011 of the learned Ombudsman on a
complaint made by the devotees of Kaippillikkavu Bhagavathi
Temple, which is a temple under the management of Travancore
Devaswom Board relating to purchase of 20 cents of land in front
of that temple, utilising the money collected from the devotees
by the Temple Advisory Committee of that temple. The Tantri of
the temple inaugurated the collection scheme. One Somanathan,
who was dealing with the affairs of the Temple Advisory
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
Committee, and Madhusoodhanan, registered a Trust in the
name Sree Bhagavathi Seva Trust and the land was purchased in
the name of that Trust utilising the funds collected from the
devotees. The registration of the Trust was more than two
months after the collection of funds and the property was got
conveyed in favour of Madhusoodhanan, Somanathan and
Raveendran on behalf of that Trust. The Division Bench held that
the acquisition on behalf of Sree Bhagavathi Seva Trust is,
obviously, in the form of a dedication to the deity of the temple
concerned and such dedication has been made utilising the funds
collected from the public at large, that too, by an entity acting on
behalf of the people, who were prepared to make such
dedication. For such collection, receipts have been issued by the
Convenor of the Land Endowment Scheme, a conglomeration of
well minded devotees. It has to be presumed that the benefit of
such collection is for the purpose of the deity.
Under such
circumstances, the Division Bench held that the extent of 20
cents of land covered by document No.6540/2006 is an item of
property which stands dedicated in favour of the deity and the
purchase of the land utilising the amounts was only for the sake
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
of; in favour of; and, in the course of dedication to, the deity.
The Travancore Devaswom Board holds all the properties of the
temples under its control, in terms of the provisions of the
Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act. Therefore,
the Division Bench declared that the land covered by the
aforesaid document and all structures standing thereon vest
absolutely in the deity of Kaippallikkavu Bhagavathi Temple and
those properties can only be managed by the Travancore
Devaswom Board. Any person occupying such property, including
Sree Bhagavathi Seva Trust, shall cease to occupy that parcel
and it will be exclusively under the management and control of
the Travancore Devaswom Board on behalf of the deity.
24.
In Arjunan T.N. [2012 (4) KHC 155], in the
context of the provisions contained in the Rules (bye-laws)
regarding formation of Temple Advisory Committees in Temples
under the management of Travancore Devaswom Board, the
Division Bench held that, in view of the prohibitions contained in
Clauses 9, 12 and 18 of the said Rules, any collection of funds by
the Temple Advisory Committee in connection with the conduct
of temple festival or construction or repair or renovation work in
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
the temple can only be made with the prior approval of the
Travancore Devaswom Board, against sealed coupons issued by
the Assistant Commissioner. The Secretary of the Temple
Advisory Committee has to cause the accounts relating to the
collection of funds, income and expenditure audited, which shall
be produced before the authorities in the Board before 30 th April
of every year. In view of the provisions contained in Clause 12 of
the Rules, in the event of any specific financial irregularities in
the activities of the Temple Advisory Committee, the Devaswom
Commissioner shall have the absolute power to remove that
Committee. Clause 18 of the Rules prohibits collection of funds
by the Temple Advisory Committee in connection with any
ceremonies in the temples by placing kanikkavanchies or hundis.
No receipts without the seal of the Assistant Commissioner shall
be used for collecting funds, when the Board has granted
permission for collection of funds at the initiative of the Temple
Advisory Committee.
25.
In view of the law laid down by this Court in Arjunan
T.N. [2012 (4) KHC 155], in the case of Temples under the
management of Travancore Devaswom Board, the collection of
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
funds by the Temple Advisory Committee, based on the approval
granted by the Board, against receipts with the seal of the
Assistant Commissioner, in connection with the conduct of
temple festival or for construction, repair or renovation work in
the temple, is collection of money in the name of the deity. The
purpose of such collection is for the benefit of the deity.
Therefore, the Board has to ensure that the amounts collected
by the Temple Advisory Committees in the temples under its
management in connection with the conduct of temple festival or
for construction, repair or renovation work in the temple, which
are credited into the account of the Advisory Committee, are
transferred to the Devaswom fund temporarily. Thereafter,
adopting the method of issuing payment cheques from the
Devaswom fund, on the basis of payment bills prepared by the
Maramath wing of the Board, payments can be released to the
contractor. If such a procedure is adopted, the supervision of the
Maramath wing of the Board will be more effective and the work
files can be kept in the Maramath wing, which can be subjected
to regular audit by the State Audit Department, annually.
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
26.
The law laid down by this Court in Arjunan T.N.
[2012 (4) KHC 155] has application with equal force in the
case of Temple Advisory Committees in the temples under the
management of Cochin Devaswom Board. Therefore, it is for the
Cochin Devaswom Board to take an appropriate decision to adopt
the same procedure, with appropriate modifications, if found
necessary, in the case of the Temple Advisory Committees in the
Temples under its management. A decision in this regard shall be
taken, as expeditiously as possible, at any rate, within a period
of two months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
order.
27.
Having considered the pleadings and materials on
record and also the submissions made at the Bar, we deem it
appropriate to direct the internal audit wing of the Cochin
Devaswom Board to transmit the entire files relating to the
renovation work in question to the 1st respondent Senior Deputy
Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Cochin Devaswom
Board Audit, for statutory audit. The 1 st respondent shall
complete the statutory audit, with notice to the concerned
Devaswom Officer and also the Secretary of the additional 2 nd
DBP No.78 of 2018
2025:KER:20640
respondent Temple Renovation Committee, as well as the office
bearers/members of the said Committee against whom there are
allegations. After completing the statutory audit, the report of
the 1st respondent Senior Deputy Director shall be filed before
this Court, which shall be numbered as DBAR and listed before
the Division Bench dealing with Devaswom matters.
28.
The submission of the learned Standing Counsel for
Cochin Devaswom Board that a Temple Advisory Committee has
already been constituted in Pazhayannur Bhagavathi Temple,
vide order dated 30.06.2021 of the Devaswom Commissioner
and the submission of the learned counsel for the 5th respondent,
who is the Secretary of the Temple Renovation Committee, that
the office bearers and members of that Committee will cooperate with the statutory audit by the 1 st respondent Senior
Deputy Director, are recorded.
With the above directions, this DBP is disposed of.
Sd/-
ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/-
MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
MSA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review