Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE BASANT BALAJI
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(C) NO. 1620 OF 2024
EP NO.150 OF 2011 OF MUNSIFF COURT, KARUNAGAPPALLY
PETITIONER/S:
CLETUS
AGED 51 YEARS
S/O FRANCIS, KANICHERIL, ARINALLOOR, SOUTH, THEVALAKKARA,
KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
SEBASTIAN
AGED 51 YEARS
S/O. FRANCIS, KANICHENL, ARINALLOOR SOUTH, THEVALAKKARA,
KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
JOSEPH CARLOS
AGED 45 YEARS
S/O CARLOS, LIJO BHAVANAM, ARINALLNOR MART, ARINALLOOR PO,
THEVALAKKARA, KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
LEELA
AGED 40 YEARS
W/O JOSEPH CARLOS, LIJO BHAVANAM, ARINALLOOR MART,
ARINALLOOR PO, THEVALAKKARA, KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN 695018
SNEHAMMA FRANKLIN @ MERCY
AGED 60 YEARS
W/O FRANKLIN, AIKKARAVILA THEKKATHIL, ARINALLOOR SOUTH P O,
THEVALAKKARA KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
SEEJA
AGED 35 YEARS
W/O. YESUDASAN (NIKHIL) AIKKARAVILA THEKKATHIL ARINALLOOR
SOUTH. ARINALLOOR PO THEVALAKKARA. KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM,
PIN - 695018
SOOSAMMA
AGED 42 YEARS
W/O EARNEST ANTONY, JIJO BHAVAN, ARINALLOOR.P O THEVALAKKARA
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
KARUNAGAPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
LATHA @ PUSHPALATHA
AGED 51 YEARS
W/O JAMES ANTONY, VELUTHEDATHUVILAVIL, ARINALLOOR MURI,
ARINALLOOR. PO, THEVALAKKARA KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN 695018
JIJIMOL, AGED 47 YEARS
D/O. LAWRENCE, ANIKKUZHIYIL, ARINALLOOR MURI, ARINALLOOR P.O
THEVALAKKARA, KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
JASSY
AGED 70 YEARS
W/O MILQUARE THOMAS OTTAPLAVILA, ARINALLOOR MURI, ARINALLOOR
P.O , THEVALAKKARA, KARUNAGAPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
BY ADVS.
HARISH GOPINATH
SURUMI NAZAR
RESPONDENT/S:
STANCY EDWARD
EDWARD BHAVAN, ARINALLOOR PO THEVALAKKARA. KARUNAGAPPALLY,
KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
FR. AJAY KUMAR
EDWARD BHAVAN, ARINALLOOR PO THEVALAKKARA KARUNAGAPPALLY,
KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
ANIL KUMAR
EDWARD BHAVAN, ARINALLOOR PO THEVALAKKARA KARUNAGAPPALLY,
KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
ANNIE MARY
EDWARD BHAVAN, ARINALLOOR PO, THEVALAKKARA. KARUNAGAPPALLY,
KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
SANTHOSH
S/O GABRIEL THUNDAYYATHU HOUSE, ARINALLOOR, THEVALAKKARA
KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
DAISY RAJAN
THUNDAYYATHU HOUSE, ARINALLOOR, THEVALAKKARA KARUNAGAPPALLY,
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
JOLLY (DELETED)
W/O SEBASTIAN, KANICHERIL, ARINALLOOR SOUTH, THEVALAKKARA,
KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
RAJAN (DELETED)S/O BELTHAZER,
OTTAPLAVIL, ARINALLOOR SOUTH, ARINALLOOR.P O THEVALAKKARA
KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
LUCY *( DELETED)*
W /O RAJAN, S/O BELTHAZER, OTTAPLAVIL, ARINALLOOR SOUTH
ARINALLOOR.P O THEVALAKKARA KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN 695018
EARNEST (DELETED)
S/O ANTONY, JIJO BHAVAN ,ARINALLOOR.P O THEVALAKKARA
KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
JIJO (DELETED)
S/O EARNEST , ANTONY JIJO BHAVAN ,ARINALLOOR.P O
THEVALAKKARA KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 695018
ALOCIUS (DELETED);
S/O KUTTIYIL PADINJATTATHIL ARINALLOOR MURI ARINALLOOR.P O
THEVALAKKARA KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM *( RESPONDENTS 7 TO
12 ARE DELETED FROM THE PARTY ARRAY AT THE RISK OF THE
PETITIONER AS PER ORDER DATED 30.07.2024 IN IA 1/2024 IN OPC
1620/2024.) PIN - 695018
BY ADVS.
K.P.ANTONY BINU
SANIL JOSE(K/63/2013)
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 26.03.2025, THE COURT
ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
JUDGMENT
(Dated this the 26th day of March 2025)
Petitioners are additional judgment debtors in E.P.No. 150 of
2011 in O.S.No.191 of 2007 on the files of Munsiff Court,
Karunagappally. Respondent Nos.1 to 4 are the decree holders
therein.
2. The suit was filed by Respondent Nos.1 to 4 as plaintiffs
for a permanent prohibitory injunction and mandatory injunction.
In the suit, there were only 3 defendants.
The 1st defendant
passed away, and defendants Nos.2 and 3 contested the suit.
Defendants filed a written statement contending that the 1st
defendant and his wife jointly owned the property as per Deed
No.3962/1956, they are residing and using the pathway through
the property of the plaintiffs, and they were not obstructed by the
plaintiffs’ predecessor, at any point of time. The defendants
claimed that the counterclaim 'C' schedule pathway is the only
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
way to access their property and is also used by many other
persons residing further east of the properties of the plaintiffs and
defendants. The trial court, decreed the suit and the plaintiffs’
exclusive possession and enjoyment of plaint schedule property
was declared. The defendants were directed to reinstall the
western fencing of the plaint schedule property in its original
position by reconstructing the same, which had been removed at
the spot at a distance of 6 ft. towards the south from the
northwestern corner of the plaint schedule property.
3. The decree holders filed E.P. No.150 of 2011, to appoint
an Advocate commissioner to execute the decree of mandatory
injunction to reinstall the western fencing removed by the
defendants, to recover the cost, and to detain the judgment debtors
in civil prison. The decree holders also filed an application to
implead the relatives/neighbours of judgment debtors on the
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
allegation that they violated the prohibitory injunction. The said
I.A. is numbered as E.A.No.107 of 2011. E.A.No.108 of 2021
was filed to amend the execution application to incorporate a
prayer to execute the decree of a permanent prohibitory injunction
by detaining judgment debtors in civil prison, attaching their
properties, and closing the newly constructed pathway, and by
installing western fencing.
The execution court allowed the
impleading as well as the amendment application. Thereafter, the
petitioners entered appearance and filed a detailed objection
pointing out that they were not made parties to the suit and had
not committed any disobedience of the decree.
4. It was also contended that the decree-holder himself had
cut and removed the trees and made false allegations against the
Judgment debtors.
The execution court, by Ext.P14, on an
erroneous consideration of the facts and circumstances of the
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
case, allowed the E.P.No.150 of 2011 and the judgment debtors
and additional judgment debtors were sent to civil prison for
a period of one month, and the decree-holder was permitted to
close the newly constructed way by installing western fencing on
its northern end. Ext.P14 is challenged by additional judgment
debtor Nos. 4,5,7 to 9, 12, 14, 16, 18 and 19 in E.P.No.150 of
2011, through this O.P.(C).
5. An application is filed as I.A.No.2 of 2024 in I.A.No. 3
of 2024 to vacate the interim order granted by this court, by which
Ext.P14 was stayed. In the affidavit, it is stated that during the
pendency of the suit, the defendants and their henchmen
committed trespass into the plaint schedule property and forcibly
formed a pathway having a width of 3 ft and length of 15 meters
in an east-west direction on the northern side of the property.
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
6. I.A.No.1105 of 2007 was filed under Order 39 Rule 2A,
and pending enquiry, the suit was tried and decreed. Since the
judgment debtors failed to comply with the directions,
E.P.No.150 of 2011 was filed for executing the decree. The
commissioner and Amin deputed for the execution of the decree
came to the property on 05.10.2016, and the 2nd defendant and
their men physically obstructed them, and this was reported to the
court.
7.
On 6.10.2016 the judgment debtors and their men
again committed trespass into plaint schedule property and
removed the fencing. Thereafter, on 14.10.2016, the decree was
executed by Amin and an Advocate Commissioner by
constructing a compound wall to a length of 1.20-meter portion,
which is 6 ft south from the north-western corner of the plaint
scheduled property. On 15.10.2016 at 9 pm, the judgment debtors
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
and additional judgment debtors trespassed into the property
again, cut and removed trees and formed a new pathway. This
was complained to the police, and a crime was registered as Crime
No.171 of 2016 against judgment debtors and additional
judgment debtors. The petitioner, therefore, filed E.A.No.107 of
2021, for impleading the additional judgment debtor Nos.4 to 19,
as they wilfully violated the decree and opened a new pathway.
8. E.A.No.108 of 2021 was filed to amend the execution
petition, which was allowed on 26.11.2021. The execution court,
thereafter, conducted an elaborate enquiry and evidence was
adduced by both the parties. PW Nos.1 to 5 were examined,
Exts.A1 to 5 marked, and the 5th additional Judgment debtor was
examined as DW1 and Ext.B1 and Ext.Nos.C1 and C2 report of
the Commissioner was marked. The original judgment debtors
remained ex-parte. Based on evidence adduced, the execution
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
court, found that the judgment debtors committed flagrant
violation of decree and demolished the fence and opened a new
pathway.
9. Challenging Ext.P14 order, the petitioners herein filed
O.P.(C) No.1091 of 2024 and secured an interim stay.
On
18.06.2024, a memo was filed stating that the petitioners were not
willing to continue with O.P.(C) and prayed that reserving their
right to approach this court again, the O.P. be dismissed as
infructuous.
Acting on the memo, this court dismissed the
O.P.(C) as not pressed by Ext.R1(a) without giving liberty for
approaching again.
10. Suppressing the dismissal of the said O.P.(C), this
Petition was filed on 26.7.2024 by a few of the judgment debtors,
who filed O.P.(C) No.1091 of 2024 and obtained a stay of
Ext.P14, to the extent it directed arrest and detention in civil
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
prison. After obtaining the stay order, on 7.10.2024, the
petitioners again committed trespass and demolished the western
boundary. An FIR is registered as FIR No.768 of 2024 u/s
329(3), 324(4), 189(2), 191(2) and 190 of BNS, 2023. This was
reported to the execution court, and thereafter, the demolished
fencing was reconstructed on 13.10.2024 under police
surveillance.
At that time, the police officials were also
obstructed, and another crime was registered as FIR No.779 of
2024, registered under Sections 189(2), 191(2), 126(2), 221 and
190 BNS.
11. On 17.10.2024, the petitioners again committed trespass
and demolished western fencing, and another crime was
registered as FIR No.799/24. Thus, it is evident that the judgment
debtors are in the habit of deliberately and wilfully violating the
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
decree passed by this court, and therefore, no interference is
warranted with Ext.P14.
12. The counsel for the respondent points out that it is
suppressing the dismissal of the O.P.(C) No.1091 of 2024, that
was filed challenging the very same Ext.P14 and having not
pressed the case and dismissed as not pressed, this O.P.(C) is filed
for the same relief and obtained an interim stay. He further points
out that in the affidavit in support of O.P., in paragraph No.2, the
1st petitioner sworn in that he has not filed any other petition
before this court similar to the subject matter of this petition. This
amounts to perjury also. Therefore, he prayed that O.P.(C) is
only to be dismissed as no liberty to approach again, was given
when O.P.(C.) No.1091 of 2024 was dismissed.
13. I find force in the contention raised by the counsel for
the respondents. Order 23 CPC deals with withdrawal and
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
adjustment of suits. (i) At any time after the institution of a suit,
the plaintiff may as, against all or any of the defendants, abandon
his suit or abandon a part of his claim. Subrule (3) to Order 23
Rule 1 prescribed that if the court is satisfied (a)that the suit must
fail by the reason of some formal defect, or (b) that there are
sufficient grounds for allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit
for the subject matter of a suit or a part of the claim, it may, on
such terms as it thinks fit, grant the plaintiff permission to
withdraw from such suit or such part of the claim, with liberty to
institute a fresh suit in respect of the subject matter of such suit or
such part of the claim. Sub rule (4) prescribed where the plaintiff
(a) abandons any suit or a part of the claim under sub rule (1) or
(b) withdraw from a suit or part of claim without the permission
referred to in sub rule (3), he shall be liable for such cost as the
court may award and shall be precluded from instituting any fresh
suit in respect of such subject matter or such part of the claim.
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
Therefore, once the suit is dismissed as not pressed and no
liberty is granted to the petitioners to approach this court again,
challenging the very same impugned order, the O.P.(C) filed again
is not maintainable in view of the specific bar under Order 23
CPC. Therefore, I am of the considered opinion that this O.P.(C)
is not maintainable before this court, and hence, it is dismissed.
Sd/BASANT BALAJI
JUDGE
dl/
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1620/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 18-10-2011 IN OS
NO 191/2007 ON FILE OF THE MUNSIFF COURT
KARUNAGAPPALLY
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE EXECUTION PETITION IN EP NO
150/2011 IN OS NO 191/2007 OF MUNSIFF COURT
KARUNAGAPPALLY
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE IMPLEADING PETITION EA NO
107/2011 IN EP 150/2011 IN OS NO 191/2007 OF
MUNSIFF COURT KARUNAGAPPALLY
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE EA NO 108/2021 IN EP 150/2011 IN
OS NO 191/2007 OF MUNSIFF COURT KARUNAGAPPALLY
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN EA NO 107/2021 IN EP
150/2011 IN OS NO 191/2007 OF MUNSIFF COURT
KARUNAGAPPALLY
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN EA 108/2021 IN EP
150/2011 IN OS NO 191/2007 OF MUNSIFF COURT
KARUNAGAPPALLY
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION FILED BY THE JUDGMENT
DEBTORS IN EP 150/2011 IN OS 191/2007
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE TAX RECEIPT DATED 19-06-2024 IS
ISSUED IN FAVOUR OF 1ST PETITIONER
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE TAX RECEIPT DATED 19-06-2024
ISSUED IN FAVOUR OF THE 2ND PETITIONER
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE TAX RECEIPT DATED 6-7-2023
ISSUED IN FAVOUR OF THE 3RD PETITIONER
Exhibit P11
TRUE COPY OF THE TAX RECEIPT DATED 16-01-2024
ISSUED IN FAVOUR OF MERCY
Exhibit P12
TRUE COPY OF THE TAX RECEIPT DATED 12-8-2023
ISSUED IN FAVOUR OF 8TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit P13
TRUE COPY OF THE TAX RECEIPT DATED 11-10-2023 IN
FAVOUR OF THE 9TH RESPONDENT
OPC 1620/24
2025:KER:27815
Exhibit P14
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 12-4-2024 IN EP
150/2011 IN OS 191/2007 OF MUNSIFF COURT,
KARUNAGAPPALLY
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R1 (a)
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN OP© NO. 1091/2024
DATED 18-06-2024
Exhibit R1 (b)
TRUE COPY OF THE FIR NO. 768/2024 OF CHAVARA
THEKKUMBHAGAM POLICE STATION
Exhibit R1(C)
TRUE COPY OF THE FIR NO. 779/2024 OF CHAVARA
THEKKUMBHAGAM POLICE STATION REGISTERED
U/SECTIONS 189 (2), 191(2), 126(2), 221, 190 OF
BNS AGAINST THE PETITIONERS
Exhibit R1(d)
TRUE COPY OF THE FIR NO. 799/2024 OF CHAVARA
THEKKUMBHAGAM POLICE STATION ALONG WITH THE
COMPLAINT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review