Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA
Page |1
Date: 2023.08.31 13:46:45 +05'30'
SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP (C) No. 644 of 2020
Dr. Choudhurimayum Anup Sharma, aged about 34 years,
S/o Dr. Ashok Roy Choudhury of Brahmapur Thangapat
Mapal, PO & PS Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
... PETITIONER
-VERSUS1. The State of Manipur represented by the Principal
Secretary/ Commissioner/ Secretary, University &
Higher Technical Education (Higher and Technical
Education),
Government
of
Manipur,
office
at
Secretariat South Block, Babupara, PO & PS Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
2. The Director of University and Higher Education,
Government of Manipur, office at Netaipat Chuthek,
near Manipur State Archive Office, PO & PS Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur.
3. The Governing Body, Pravabati College (Govt. Aided),
Mayang
Imphal,
represented
by
its
Secretary,
Governing Body, Pravabati college, Mayang Imphal, PO
& PS Mayang Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
4. The Principal, Pravabati College (Govt. Aided), Mayang
Imphal, PO & PS Mayang Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur.
......OFFICIAL RESPONDENTS
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
Page |2
5. Wahengbam Ajoykumar Singh, Assistant Professor of
Geology, C/o Principal Pravabati College (Govt. Aided),
-Mayang Imphal, PO& PS Mayang Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur.
6. Moni Oinam, Assistant Professor of Geology, C/o
Principal Pravabati College (Govt. Aided), Mayang
Imphal, PQ & PS Mayang Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur.
7. L. Ibomcha Singh, Assistant Professor of Geology, C/o
Principal Pravabati College (Govt. Aided), Mayang
Imphal, PO & PS Mayang Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur.
.... PRIVATE RESONDENTS
8. The University Grant Commission (UGC) through its
Secretary,
University
Grant
Commission
(UGC),
Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi-110002.
..... PROFORMA RESPONDENT
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. M. Hemchandra, Sr. Adv.,
::
Mr. Sh. Athoi, Adv. for R-5,6 & 7.
Mrs. L. Monomala, GA for R-1&2.
Mr. Kh. Tomba, Adv. for R-3 & R-4.
Mr. S. Jasobanta, Adv. for R-8.
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
10.08.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
30.08.2023
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
::
Page |3
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner to set
aside the impugned review/DPC proceedings dated 31.5.2020,
resolution No.1 and sitting No.24 dated 2.6.2020 of the
Governing Body of Pravabati College, Mayang, Imphal and the
appointment orders dated 3.6.2020 in respect of the private
respondents 5 to 7 and to direct the official respondents to
appoint the petitioner as Assistant Professor (Geology) in
Pravabati College (Government Aided), Mayang, Imphal.
2.
The case of the petitioner is that he is educationally
qualified and eligible for consideration for appointment to the post
of Assistant Professor (Geology) in Colleges/Universities as per
the UGC Regulations-2018. On 16.2.2020, an advertisement
was issued inviting applications from the eligible/qualified
candidates with 55% and above for appointment to the posts of
Assistant Professors in Pravabati College (Government Aided).
Six candidates, including the petitioner, had applied for the post
of Assistant Professor (Geology) and, accordingly, were
shortlisted as per the marks obtained in graduation, postgraduation and other higher qualification and experiences and
interview was held on 31.5.2020 by online mode. However, to
the utter shock and surprise of the petitioner, vide impugned
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
Page |4
order
dated
31.5.2020,
the
Selection
Committee/DPC
recommended five candidates for appointment as Assistant
Professor (Geology) in Pravabati College (Government Aided)
and also issued appointment orders to the private respondents
and two others leaving out the petitioner, who is much more
qualified, eligible and deserved candidate for the post of
Assistant Professor (Geology).
3.
Further case of the petitioner is that, among five
recommended
candidates,
three
candidates,
namely
respondents 5 to 7 are not eligible and qualified to be appointed
as Assistant Professor (Geology), as they are neither Ph.D
degree holders, nor cleared NET/SLET/SET which is affront to
the UGC Regulations-2018 read with Section IV of the Manipur
Education Code-1982 and other guidelines issued by the
Government.
Therefore,
the
impugned
interview/DPC
proceedings and the appointments orders issued to the private
respondents 5 to 7 are liable to be quashed and the respondent
authorities should consider the appointment of the petitioner as
Assistant Professor (Geology) in Pravabati College (Government
Aided), Mayang, Imphal.
4.
Respondents 1 and 2 have filed affidavit-in-
opposition stating that Pravabati College, Mayang, Imphal is a
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
Page |5
private Government Aided College.
All Government Aided
Colleges function as per Manipur Education Code-1982 and the
service conditions are as specified under the said Code and the
appointment has been made by the Secretary of the Governing
Body. There is no role of the Government and the respondents
1 and 2 have no power of quashing and setting aside the
impugned appointment order dated 3.6.2020 in respect of the
private respondents, as their appointments have been made by
the Secretary of the Governing Body and not by the Government.
Hence, they prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.
5.
The respondents 3 and 4 filed affidavit-in-
opposition, inter alia, stating that after the petitioner was not
recommended by the DPC for appointment to the post of
Assistant Professor of the College in Geology in furtherance of
the advertisement dated 16.2.2020 by taking “U” turn, the
petitioner has filed the writ petition. Such an action on the part
of the petitioner is barred by the law laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court. It is stated that the petitioner obtained his M.Sc.
degree in Petroleum Geology from Punjab University.
The
advertisement made by the respondents 3 and 4 was for
appointment to the post of Assistant Professor (Geology).
Therefore, the qualification possessed by the petitioner is not
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
Page |6
completely commensurate with the post so advertised by the
College. The engagement of the petitioner as Guest Lecturer in
the Department of Geology of D.M. College of Sciences, Imphal
was made by the Principal, D.M. College of Sciences at the
remuneration of Rs.3000/- per month. The engagement of the
petitioner as Guest Faculty in the Department of Geology, Imphal
College for a period of six months vide order dated 15.7.2019
was also made by the Principal of the College without
remuneration.
It is stated that as many as six candidates
including the petitioner applied for the post of Assistant Professor
(Geology) of the College. On receipt of the applications, the
Principal of the College sent a letter to the Director, University &
Higher Education, Government of Manipur on 20.5.2020
requesting for nomination of subject experts for online interview
for appointment of Assistant Professors of Pravabati College in
respect of the subjects indicated in the said advertisement.
6.
It is stated that in response to the letter dated
20.5.2020, the Director of University and Higher Education vide
letter dated 26.5.2020 nominated as many as 21 subject experts
for appearing in the interview for appointment to the post of
Assistant Professors of the College. One Dr.Th. Ranjit Singh,
Associate Professor, D.M. College of Science was nomination for
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
Page |7
the subject Geology. Thereafter, the Secretary of the Governing
Body, Pravabati College vide notification dated 29.5.2020
informed the candidates to attend the online interview for
appointment to the post of Assistant Professors. On the same
day, an order was also issued by the Secretary, Government
Body, thereby constituting four members of the DPC for
appointment to the post of Assistant Professors(Geology). The
DPC for appointment to various posts of Assistant Professors of
the College was held and, finally, the Director, University and
Higher Education, vide letter dated 14.7.2020, accorded the
approval to the appointment of the recommended candidates by
the DPC under certain terms and conditions, including the
condition that the appointments are to be made as per the
recommendation made by the DPC under Section 4(B) of the
Manipur Education Code, 1982 and subsequent resolutions of
the Governing Body and the appointment are to be made by the
Governing Body of the College at the College level. The entire
proceedings for appointment to the post of Assistant Professor
(Geology) as well as other subjects were made in accordance
with law. Therefore, there had not been any irregularity on the
part of the College authorities to the entire proceedings for
appointment to the posts. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the writ
petition.
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
Page |8
7.
The private respondents 5 to 7 filed affidavit-in-
opposition stating that pursuant to the advertisement dated
16.2.2020, the respondents 5 to 7 applied for the post of the
Assistant Professor (Geology) and the appointment of teachers
of Aided Colleges, including the Pravabati College, Mayangis
governed by the provisions of the Manipur Education Code.
There is no provision of law for recommending more qualified
candidates in a DPC and all the candidates have to be treated at
par,
in
case,
qualifications.
the
candidates
possessed
the
minimum
It is stated that the petitioner was not
recommended for appointment to the said post by the
DPC/Screening Committee and the private respondents have
been recommended for appointment to the said post thereby
appointment orders were issued in favour of the private
respondents and other persons.
8.
It is stated that the DPC was held in accordance
with the relevant provisions of law, including the provisions of the
Manipur Education Code, with the approval of the competent
authorities of the Department of Higher and Technical Education.
The DPC on proper examination and also performances made
by
the
private
respondents
along
with
other
persons
recommended the private respondents and two other persons to
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
Page |9
the said post. Hence, they prayed for dismissal of the writ
petition.
9.
Assailing the impugned DPC proceedings and the
appointment orders issued to the private respondents, Mr. M.
Hemchandra, the learned senior counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the petitioner applied for the post of Assistant
Professor (Geology) at Pravabati College as advertised by the
Secretary, Governing Body vide advertisement dated 16.2.2020
and the eligibility criteria as per the advertisement is 55% and
above for appointment to the post of Assistant Professors in
Pravabati College (Government Aided) including one post for the
subject Geology. The interview was conducted on 31.5.2020 by
online for six candidates, including the petitioner, for the lone post
of
Assistant
Professor
(Geology).
Vide
the
impugned
interview/DPC proceedings dated 31.5.2020 for appointment to
the post of Assistant Professor (Geology), the Selection
Committee recommended 5 candidates for appointment as
Assistant Professor (Geology) in Pravabati College, leaving the
petitioner. According to the learned counsel, the petitioner is very
much qualified, eligible and deserving candidate having qualified
NET and had also obtained Ph.D degree from Punjab University
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 10
for appointment to the post of Assistant Professor (Geology),
however, he was not recommended by the DPC.
10.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioner further
submitted that under the RTI information received by the
petitioner, it has come to the knowledge that the private
respondents are not at all eligible and qualified to be appointed
as Assistant Professor (Geology) in Pravabati College as per the
UGC Regulations on Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of
Teachers and other Academic Staff in Universities and Colleges
and measures for the Maintenance of Standards in Higher
Education, 2018, as the private respondents neither Ph.D degree
holders nor have cleared NET/SLET/SET. Further, the private
respondents 5 and 6 possess only Master of Science in Earth
Science from Manipur University in the year 2015 and 2016
respectively, while the seventh respondent possesses Master of
Science (Geology) from University of Mysore in the year 2011
which are considered as not qualified/not eligible for appointment
to the post of Assistant Professor in Colleges and Universities as
per the UGC Regulations, 2018 read with Manipur Education
Code, 1982.
11.
The learned senior counsel next submitted that in
respect of Selection Committee for recruitment of teaching staff,
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 11
the Principal of the Pravabati College should be the Chairman of
the Selection Committee, however in the case on hand, the
Selection Committee was constituted with the Principal as one of
the members of the Selection Committee and not as its Chairman
with no one being appointed as the Chairman of the said
Selection Committee.
12.
Drawing this Court’s attention to Clause 4 of Section
IV of the Manipur Education Code, the learned senior counsel
further submitted that the advertisement has to be published for
two consecutive days in the local newspaper and also should
have been published in the State Gazette in reasonable time.
However, none of those were done in the instant case. The
criteria for short-listing of candidates for interview for the post of
Assistant Professors in Colleges published by the UGC vide
notification dated 18.7.2018 clearly shows that the petitioner is
very much qualified for appointment to the post of Assistant
Professor in the Department of Geology, Pravabati College
(Government Aided). As per the said notification, the petitioner
scores 77 marks as on the date of the interview and as per the
criteria for short-listing of candidates for interview for the post of
Assistant Professors in Colleges.
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 12
13.
The next submission of the learned senior counsel
for the petitioner is that at the relevant point of time when the
Manipur Education Code was framed, 45% marks were
considered as Second Class Degree, however, as on date, the
qualifying mark for Second Class Degree is 55%.
14.
The learned senior counsel then submitted that any
selection/appointment at Pravabati College (Government Aided)
including the selection/appointment of Assistant Professor
(Geology) in the said College are to be done as per the Rules
and Regulations framed by the UGC and not as per the whims
and fancies of the Governing Body of Pravabati College.
Arguing so, the learned senior counsel submitted that the
petitioner is very much eligible and qualified for appointment to
the post of Assistant Professor in Pravabati College (Government
Aided) for the subject Geology as per the UGC Regulations,
however, his name was not considered and the appointment of
the private respondents are tainted with full of material
irregularity, arbitrariness, bias, favoritism and nepotism and also
adopting corrupt practice. The vacancies over and above the
number of vacancies advertised cannot be filled up. Therefore,
the proceedings of the impugned DPC and the consequential
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 13
appointment orders issued in favour of the respondents 5 to 7
are liable to be set aside.
15.
In support of the submissions, the learned senior
counsel for the petitioner relied upon the following decisions:
(i) Raj Kumar and others v. Shakti Raj and
others, (1997) 9 SCC 527.
(ii) Jeevan Diesels and Electricals Limited
v.
Janbirsingh
Chadha
(HUF)
and
another, (2010) 6 SCC 601.
(iii) Bhavnagar University v. Palitana Sugar
Mill (P) Ltd. and others, (2003) 2 SCC
111.
(iv) Public
Service
Commission,
Uttaranchal v. Mamta Bishi and others,
(2010) 12 SCC 204.
(v) Chairman cum Managing Director, Coal
India Limited and others v. Ananta Saha
and others, (2011) 5 SCC 142.
(vi) Pramod
Kumar
v.
UP
Secondary
Education Services Commission and
others, AIR 2008 SC 1817.
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 14
(vii)
Dhanajaya
Reddy
v.
State
of
Kartanaka, (2001) 4 SCC 9.
(viii) Moumita Poddar and another v.
Indian Oil Corporation and another,
2005 (4) GLT 538.
16.
Mr. Kh. Tomba Singh, the learned counsel for the
respondents 3 and 4 submitted that Pravabati College
(Government Aided) issued an advertisement on 16.2.2020,
thereby
advertising
various
Teachers/Lecturers/Assistant
posts
of
Professors
of
unapproved
the
College,
including the post of Assistant Professor (Geology). In pursuance
of the advertisement, applications were submitted by the
petitioner and the private respondents as well as other persons.
The short-listing of the applicants were made with the approval
of the competent authorities of the Department of Higher and
Technical Education, Government of Manipur and as many as 6
numbers of candidates were short listed for interview.
The
interview of the short listed candidates were conducted on
31.5.2020 by online mode. The Board consisted Dr.Th. Ranjit
Singh, Associate Professor, Department of Geology, D.M.
College of Science, Impohal, P.Shantikumar Singh, OSD
(University and Higher Education), Government of Manipur, Ng.
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 15
Jeyshankar Singh, Assistant Professor, Department of Geology,
Pravabati College and A.Sunil Sharma, Principal/in-charge of the
College and on proper examination of the performances made
by the candidates, including the private respondents as well as
other persons, the Committee had recommended 5 candidates,
including the private respondents 5 to 7. The petitioner was not
recommended by the said Committee, as he scored 214 marks
only. As recommended, the private respondents 5 to 7 and one
Venus Guruaribam, Dr.Khumukcham Radhapyari Devi were
appointed and have been discharging their duties in the College.
17.
The learned counsel for the respondents 3 and 4
urged that having taken part in the process of selection knowing
fully well, the petitioner is not entitled to challenge the criteria or
process of selection. The DPC which was held for appointment
to the post of Associate Professor (Geology) of Pravabati College
was made for the post of unapproved teachers. The appointment,
maintenance as well as the administration of such College i.e.
Grant-in-Aid College are governed by the provisions of the
Manipur Education Code.
The ground for challenging the
proceedings of the DPC is that the private respondents are
neither Ph.D degree holders nor cleared the NET/SLET, for
which they are not eligible for the said post as prescribed in the
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 16
UGC Regulations. The said provisions of the UGC Regulations
is applicable at the time of regular appointment/regularization as
full-fledged Government Associate Professor/Lecturers.
The
issue in the present writ petition is for appointment of unapproved
Teacher/Lecturer.
There is no rule other than the Manipur
Education
for
Code
appointment,
maintenance
and
administration of such Aided Colleges. The respondents 3 and
4 have acted in accordance with the provisions of the said Rules
with the approval of the Department of Higher and Technical
Education. The writ petition filed without arraying other persons
who were recommended and appointed to the post of Assistant
Professor (Geology) is not maintainable and, therefore, the same
is liable to be dismissed. In support, the learned counsel placed
reliance upon the following decisions:
(i)
Anupal Sinha and others v. State of
Andhra Pradesh and others, (2020) 2
SCC 173.
(ii) Union
of
India
and
others
v.
N.Murugesan and others, (2022) 2 SCC
25.
18.
Mrs. L. Monomala, the learned Government
Advocate appearing for the respondent State submitted that no
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 17
irregularities were committed by the respondents 3 and 4 at any
point of time while recommending and appointing the private
respondents 5 to 7 for the post of Assistant Professor (Geology)
in
Pravabati
College
(Government
Aided)
and
having
participated in the selection process, the petitioner is estopped
from questioning the selection process. Thus, a prayer has been
made to dismiss the writ petition.
19.
Mr. Sh. Athoi, the learned counsel for the private
respondents 5 to 7 submitted that the fifth respondent scored 219
marks and he stood 5th rank in the said DPC; the sixth respondent
scored 232 marks and stood 4th rank and the seventh respondent
scored 245 marks in the interview and he stood third rank. The
petitioner scored 214 marks only and, therefore, he was not
recommended
by
the
Committee.
Based
on
the
recommendation made by the Committee, appointment orders
were issued in favour of the private respondents as well as the
other persons whose names appeared at Serial Nos.1 and 2,
who scored 255 and 256 marks respectively.
20.
The learned counsel further submitted that the
petitioner by accepting the contents of the advertisement applied
for the post and after his name is not included in the list of
selected candidates, he filed the writ petition and filing of such
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 18
petition is not permissible and, therefore, on the sole ground, the
writ petition is liable to be dismissed.
21.
According to the learned counsel, in view of the
provisions of the Manipur Education Code as well as the
condition provided under the advertisement, the private
respondents are quite eligible for the post of Assistant Professor
(Geology) and the petitioner has no right to question and/or
challenge the proceedings of the DPC on the recommendation of
which, the private respondents along with other persons have
been appointed to the post of Assistant Professor (Geology) by
taking “U” turn. In support, the learned counsel relied upon the
following decisions:
(i)
Manish Kumar Shahi v. State of Bihar
and others, (2010) 12 SCC 576.
(ii) Anupal Singh and others v. State of
Andhra Pradesh and others, (2020) 2
SCC 173.
(iii) Union
of
India
and
others
v.
N.Murugesan and others, (2022) 2 SCC
25.
22.
Mr. S. Jasobanta, the learned counsel for the UGC
submitted that the collective wisdom of the Selection Committee
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 19
could not be questioned, as it is prerogative of the Selection
Committee based on the collective judgment after examining the
candidate’s educational background and performance in the
interview and without any deviation from the UGC Regulations
prevalent at the point of time. Thus, the learned counsel prayed
for dismissal of the writ petition.
23.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
24.
The grievance of the petitioner is that the petitioner
is educationally well qualified and very much eligible for
consideration to be appointed to the post of Assistant Professor
(Geology) in Colleges/Universities as per the UGC Regulations,
2018. However, his name was not recommended by the
Selection Committee/DPC and, on the other hand, the private
respondents were selected and appointed to the post of Assistant
Professor (Geology) in Pravabati College (Government Aided).
According to the petitioner, the private respondents are not
eligible and qualified to be appointed as Assistant Professor
(Geology)
as
per
the
UGC
Regulations
on
Minimum
Qualifications for appointment of Teachers and other academic
staff in Universities and Colleges and measures for the
maintenance of Standards in Higher Education, 2018 and the
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 20
eligibility criteria for the post of Assistant Professor by direct
recruitment has been stated in the UGC Regulations, 2018 as
under:
“i. A Master’s Degree with 55% marks (or an
equivalent grade in the point scale wherever
the grading system is followed) in a
concerned/relevant/allied subject from an
Indian University, or an equivalent degree
from an accredited Foreign University.
ii. Besides fulfilling the above qualifications,
the candidates must have cleared the
National Eligibility Test (NET) conducted by
the UGC or the CSIR or a similar test
accredited by the UGC, like SLET/SET or
who are or have been awarded a PhD
Degree in accordance with the University
Grants Commission (Minimum Standards
and Procedure for Award of MPhil/PhD
Degree) Regulations, 2009 or 2016 and their
amendments from NET/SLET/SET.”
The private respondents are neither Ph.D degree
holders nor cleared NET/SLET/SET which is directly affront to
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 21
the UGC Regulations read with Section IV of the Manipur
Education Code, 1982. In the impugned DPC dated 31.5.2020,
for appointment to the post of Assistant Engineer (Geology) in
Pravabati College, the Selection Committee recommended 5
candidates, leaving the petitioner who is much more eligible and
qualified with NET and also obtained Ph.D degree.
25.
It is also the say of the petitioner that as per the
notification dated 18.7.2018 published in the Gazette of India
notified the UGC Regulations on Minimum Qualifications for
appointment of Teachers and other academic staff in Universities
and Colleges and measures for the maintenance of Standards in
Higher Education, 2018, the petitioner scores 77 marks as on the
date of the interview. Since Pravabati College (Government
Aided) is affiliated to Manipur University and recognized by the
UGC, the provisions of the UGC Regulations are applicable in
the present scenario. Any selection/appointment at Pravabati
College (Government Aided) is to be done as per the Rules and
Regulations framed by the UGC and not as per the whims and
fancies of the Governing Body.
26.
On the other hand, Mrs. L. Monomala, the leaned
Government Advocate for the respondent State submitted that
Pravabati College, Mayang, Imphal, is a private Government
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 22
Aided College and all the Government Aided Colleges function
as per the Manipur Education Code and the service condition are
as specified under the Manipur Education Code and the
appointment has been made by the Secretary of the Governing
Body. There is no role of the Government.
27.
Mr. Kh. Tomba Singh, the learned counsel for the
respondents 3 and 4 contended that the DPC which was held for
appointment to the post of Assistant Professor (Geology) was
made for the post of unapproved teachers. The appointment,
maintenance as well as administration of the College i.e. grantin-aid college are governed by the provisions of the Manipur
Education Code. However, the case of the petitioner is that the
private respondents are neither Ph.D. degree holders nor cleared
NET/SLET for which they are not eligible for the said post as
prescribed by the UGC Regulations, 2018.
28.
According
to
the
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents 3 and 4, the provisions of UGC Regulations, 2018
are applicable at the time of regular appointment/regularization
as full-fledged Government Assistant Professor/Lecturers. The
issue in the instant case is for appointment of unapproved
Teacher/Lecturer. Therefore, there is no rule other than the
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 23
Manipur Education Code for appointment and maintenance and
administration of the College.
29.
On a perusal of the various provisions of the UGC
Regulations, 2018 as well as the Manipur Education Code, 1982
highlighted by the learned senior counsel for the petitioner, this
Court is of the view that the appointments of teaching staff/faculty
as well as non-teaching staff of Aided Colleges under the
Government of Manipur are governed by the provisions of the
Manipur Education Code.
In this regard, Section 4B of the
Manipur Aided College Employees (Service) Rules, 1974 of the
Manipur Education Code stipulates that the appointment is to be
made by the Governing Body at the College level.The Director of
University and Higher Education, Government of Manipur, in its
letter dated 14.7.2020 addressed to the Secretary of the
Governing Body, Pravabati College, accorded approval to the
list of candidates proposed to be appointed as Assistant
Professors/Lecturers at Pravabati College (Government Aided).
In the said letter, it has been stated as under:
“I am to refer to your letter no.1/PBC/MI/91 dated
02.06.2020 on the above subject and to convey
that, as per section 49B) of Manipur aided College
Employees (service) Rules, 1974 of the Manipur
Education Code, 1982, the undersigned has no
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 24
objection in appointing 52 (fifty two) candidate
listed
in
the
Annexure
Professors/Lecturers
at
as
Assistant
Pravabati
College
(Government Aided), Mayang Imphal by the
Governing Body of the College as per the
requirements of the College under the following
terms and conditions:
i.
The appointments are to be made as per
recommendations
constituted
made
by
Selection
the
duly
Committee
constituted under section 4(B) of Manipur
Education Code, 1982 and subsequent
resolution of the Governing Body of the
College.
ii.
The appointments are to be made by the
Governing Body of the college at the
college level only.
iii.
Under no circumstance, the appointed
teachers can claim to be Government
appointed/approved teachers.
iv.
The salary to the appointed teachers is to
be borne by the Governing Body of the
college from the college fund the State
Government shall not grant any financial
aid for the same.”
30.
From the above, it is clear that, as rightly argued by
the learned counsel for the respondents 3 and 4, the notification
issued by the UGC dated 18.7.2018 notifying the UGC
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 25
Regulations on Minimum Qualifications for appointment of
Teachers and other academic staff in Universities and Colleges
and measures for the maintenance of Standards in Higher
Education, 2018 has no role to play in the impugned selection.
The specific averments of the respondent State is that all
Government Aided Colleges function as per the Manipur
Education Code, 1982 and the service conditions are as
specified under the
Manipur Education Code and the
appointment has been made by the Secretary of the Governing
Body only.
31.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioner
contended that the Manipur Aided College Employees (Service)
Rules, 1974 states that in respect of Selection Committee for
recruitment of teaching staff, the Principal of the College should
be the Chairman of the Selection Committee, however, in
contravention of the same, the Selection Committee/DPC was
constituted with the Principal, Pravabati College as one of the
Member and not as Chairman and they proceeded with the
impugned interview/DPC proceedings for appointment to the
post of Assistant Professor (Geology) and recommended 5
candidates, including the private respondents, leaving the
petitioner who is much more deserving for the aforesaid post.
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 26
Thus, the argument of the learned senior counsel is that the
Selection Committee was constituted with 4 Members without
Chairman which offended Chapter XI Section 1(4) of the Manipur
Education Code.
32.
In reply, Mr. Kh. Tomba Singh, the learned counsel
for the respondents 3 and 4 submitted that in the said DPC for
appointment to the post of Assistant Professors of the College,
including the Assistant Professor (Geology), the Principal of the
College was the Chairman of the DPC. However, due to bona
fide mistake while typing the proceedings of the DPC, the word
Chairman was omitted under the Principal of the College. The
word Chairman was not reflected under the name of any other
members of the Committee.
33.
As could be seen from the records, with the help of
the subject experts, the DPC was constituted and proceeded.
Since the Committee was constituted in accordance with the
provisions of law, the omission of Chairman in the impugned
DPC proceedings cannot be faulted. It is also the submission of
the learned counsel for the UGC that the collective wisdom of the
Selection Committee could not be questioned as it is prerogative
of the Selection Committee based on the collective judgment
after examining the candidate’s educational background and
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 27
performance in the interview and without any deviation from the
UGC Regulations prevalent at the relevant point of time.
34.
invited
According to the petitioner, applications were
vide
advertisement
dated
16.2.2020
from
the
eligible/qualified candidates with 55% and above for appointment
to the posts of Assistant Professors in Pravabati College
(Government Aided). Accordingly, six candidates, including the
petitioner, had applied for the post of Assistant Professor
(Geology). The authorities shortlisted the names as per their
marks obtained in graduation, post-graduation and other higher
qualification and experiences and held interview on 31.5.2020 by
online mode. According to the petitioner, compared to other
candidates who applied for the post of Assistant Professor
(Geology), the petitioner is well qualified and deserved to be
selected, as the academic scores/records, performance in the
interview and the other qualifications are in high pedestal as that
of the other candidates.
35.
The case of the respondents 3 and 4 is that the
petitioner obtained M.Sc. degree in Petroleum Geology from
Punjab University. The advertisement made is for appointment to
the post of Assistant Professor (Geology). Therefore, the
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 28
qualification possessed by the petitioner is not completely
commensurate with the post so advertised by the College.
36.
The learned counsel for the respondents 3 and 4
raised an objection as to the maintainability of the writ petition by
contending that the petitioner having participated in the
interview/DPC, after his non-selection, cannot challenge the
entire proceedings of the DPC and the consequential
appointments orders issued in favour of the private respondents
5 to 7.
37.
According to the learned senior counsel for the
petitioner, there are illegalities in the proceedings of the DPC and
the conduct of the selection is not in accordance with the relevant
Rules and, therefore, the principle of estoppel by conduct or
acquiescence has no application. In support, the learned senior
counsel placed reliance upon the decision in the case of Raj
Kumar, supra, wherein, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held thus:
“16. Yet another circumstance is that the
Government had not taken out the posts from
the purview of the Board, but after the
examinations were conducted under the 1955
Rules and after the results were announced, it
exercised the power under the proviso to para 6
of 1970 Notification and the posts were taken out
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 29
from the purview thereof.
Thereafter the
Selection
constituted
Committee
was
selection of the candidates.
for
The entire
procedure is also obviously illegal. It is true, as
contended by Shri Madhava Reddy, that this
Court in MadanLal v. State of J&K, (1995) 3 SCC
486 and other decisions referred therein had
held that a candidate having taken a chance to
appear in an interview and having remained
unsuccessful, cannot turn round and challenge
either the constitution of the Selection Board or
the method of selection as being illegal; he is
estopped to question the correctness of the
selection.
But, in this case, the Government
have committed glaring illegalities in the
procedure to get the candidates for examination
under the 1955 Rules, so also in the method of
selection and exercise of the power in taking out
from the purview of the Board and also conduct
of the selection in accordance with the Rules.
Therefore, the principle of estoppel by conduct
or acquiescence has no application to the facts
in this case. Thus, we consider that the
procedure offered under the 1955 Rules
adopted by the Government or the Committee
as well as the action taken by the Government
are not correct in law.”
38.
Countering the argument of learned senior counsel
for the petitioner, the learned counsel for the respondents 3 and
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 30
4 vehemently argued that the entire proceedings for appointment
to the post of Assistant Professor (Geology) as well as the other
subjects were made in accordance with law, including the
provisions of the Manipur Education Code, and with the approval
of the Directorate of University and Higher Education. Therefore,
there are not irregularities/illegalities on the part of the College
authority to the entire proceedings for appointment to the post of
Assistant Professors of the College, including the post of
Assistant Professor (Geology).
39.
Admittedly, nothing has been produced by the
petitioner to show the alleged irregularities/illegalities on the part
of the College authorities to the DPC proceedings. After taking
part in the selection process, the petitioner is estopped from
challenging the selection process.
40.
In Manish Kumar Shahi, supra, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held as under:
“16. We also agree with the High Court that after
having taken part in the process of selection
knowing fully well that more than 19% marks have
been earmarked for viva voce test, the petitioner
is not entitled to challenge the criteria or process
of selection. Surely, if the petitioner’s name had
appeared in the merit list, he would not have been
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 31
dreamed of challenging the selection.
The
petitioner invoked jurisdiction of the High Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India only
after he found that his name does not figure in the
merit list prepared by the Commission.
This
conduct of the petitioner clearly disentitles him
from questioning the selection and the High Court
did not commit any error by refusing to entertain
the writ petition.
Reference in this connection
may be made to the judgments in Madan Lal v.
State of Uttaranchal, Amlan Jyoti Borooah v.
State of Assam and K.A.Nagamani v. Indian
Airlines.”
41.
In Anupal Singh, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held as under:
“55. Having participated in the interview, the
private respondents cannot challenge the Office
Memorandum
selection.
dated
12.10.2014
and
the
On behalf of the appellants, it was
contended that after the revised Notification dated
12.10.2014, the private respondents participated
in the interview without protest and only after the
result was announced and finding that they were
not selected, the private respondents chose to
challenge
the
revised
Notification
dated
12.10.2014 and the private respondents are
estopped from challenging the selection process.
It is a settled law that a person having consciously
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 32
participated in the interview cannot turn around
and challenge the selection process.”
42.
In N. Murugesan, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that a person who knows that if he objects to an
instrument then he will not get benefit he wants, cannot be
allowed to do so while enjoying fruits.
One cannot take
advantage of one part while rejecting rest. A person cannot be
allowed to have benefit of an instrument while questioning same.
Such a party either has to affirm or de-affirm transaction. This
principle has to be applied with more vigour as a common law
principle, if such a party actually enjoys the one part fully and on
near completion of said enjoyment, thereafter questions other
part. An element of fair play is inbuilt in this principle and it is
also species of estoppels dealing with conduct of a party. In
paragraph 27.3, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held thus:
“27.3 …. A party cannot be permitted to “blow
hot-blow cold”, “fast and loose” or “approbate
and reprobate”. Where one knowingly accepts
the benefits of a contract, or conveyance, or of
an order, he is stopped from denying the
validity of, or the binding effect of such contract,
or conveyance, or order upon himself. This
rule is applied to ensure equity, however, it
must not be applied in such a manner so as to
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 33
violate the principles of what is right and of a
good conscience.”
43.
In view of the propositions enunciated by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, it must be held that by having taken part
in the process of selection with full knowledge that the
recruitment was being made under the applicable law, the
petitioner has waived his right to question the proceedings of the
DPC and the consequential appointment orders in respect of the
private respondents 5 to 7 or the methodology adopted by the
Selection Committee/DPC for making the selection of the
Assistant Professor (Geology). The result of the interview cannot
be challenged by the petitioner who has participated in the
interview and has taken the chance to get selected at the said
interview and ultimately finds himself to be unsuccessful.
Therefore, the decision in the case of Raj Kumar, supra, relied
upon by the learned senior counsel for the petitioner is not
applicable to the case of the petitioner.
The other decisions
relied upon by the learned senior counsel for the petitioner are
also directly not applicable to the case of the petitioner.
Therefore, the same are not elaborated in this order.
44.
In view of the finding arrived at by this Court that the
petitioner, having participated in the interview, on his non-
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 34
selection for the post is estopped from challenging the entire
proceedings of the DPC, the argument raised on behalf of the
petitioner that the advertisement ought to have been published
for two consecutive days in the local newspaper and should have
been published in the State Gazette has no legs.
45.
The further argument of the learned senior counsel
for the petitioner is that one of the DPC members tampered with
the marks of the private respondents and, therefore, the entire
DPC proceedings is to be set aside. Admittedly, to prove the said
allegation, no piece of material has been produced by the
petitioner. If the aforesaid allegation of the petitioner is genuine
and borne out by records, nothing prevented the petitioner from
approaching the competent forum for the same at the relevant
point of time.
However, the petitioner has failed to do so.
Therefore, the aforesaid argument of the petitioner cannot be
countenanced.
46.
As could be seen from the records, the authorities
of Pravabati College after shortlisting of candidates have
conducted the interview on 31.05.2020 by online mode.
Admittedly, the said online interview was conducted with the
approval of the Department of Higher and Technical Education.
The Selection Committee constituted made a panel of
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 35
candidates who appeared in the said interview according to the
marks scored by them. The records further reveal that out of 6
shortlisted candidates, 5 were selected, leaving the petitioner
who scored only 214 marks. The other candidates, namely the
respondents 5 to 7 and two others have scored more marks than
the petitioner. In fact, in the said list, by scoring 256 marks, Dr.
Khumukcham Radhapyari Devi got first rank; by score 255
marks, Venus Guruaribam got second rank; by scoring 245
marks, the seventh respondent got third rank; by scoring 232
marks, the sixth respondent got fourth rank and by scoring 219
marks, the fifth respondent got fifth rank. The petitioner has
failed to implead the first two rank holders as party respondents.
The non-impleadment of the aforesaid two selected candidates
seriously affects the writ petition.
47.
Though the petitioner contended that the private
respondents 5 and 6 possesses only Master of Science in Earth
Science from Manipur University in the year 2015 and 2016
respectively, while the seventh respondent possesses Master of
Science (Geology) from University of Mysore in the year 2011
which are considered as not qualified/not eligible to be appointed
as Assistant Professor in Colleges and Universities, nothing has
been produced by the petitioner to establish the said contention.
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 36
On the other hand, as stated supra, having considered the
educational qualification and suitability and also the performance
in the interview, the DPC has rightly recommended the private
respondents 5 to 7 for appointment to the post of Assistant
Professor (Geology) in Pravabati College (Government Aided).
48.
This Court is of the view that there is no illegality or
bias in the impugned DPC proceedings/interview dated
31.05.2020 and the same has been held in accordance with the
procedure. The plea of the petitioner that the appointment of the
private respondents are tainted with full of material irregularity,
arbitrariness, bias, favoritism and nepotism and also adopting
corrupt practice is not supported by any valid proof. The
petitioner, having taken part in the process of selection is not
entitled to challenge the entire process of selection. Equally,
having participated in the selection process, the petitioner is
estopped from raising the plea that the vacancies over and above
the number of vacancies advertised cannot be filled up. The
factum of increase/ decrease of the posts so advertised has been
clearly spelt out in the advertisement. That apart, the petitioner
has not questioned the advertisement dated 16.2.2020.
49.
The invocation of the jurisdiction under Article 226
of the Constitution of India by the petitioner after he was not
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 37
selected/recommended by the DPC is legally not sustainable.
The petitioner, accepting the contents of the advertisement,
applied for the post and after his name is not included in the list
of selected candidates, he filed the writ petition. Filing of such a
writ petition admittedly is not permissible in law. The conduct of
the petitioner clearly disentitles him from questioning the
selection of the private respondents as Assistant Professors
(Geology) in Pravabati College (Government Aided). As the
impugned DPC proceedings is valid in law, the consequential
appointment orders dated 3.6.2020 issued by the respondent
authorities in respect of the private respondents 5 to 7 are legally
sustainable and the petitioner has no right to question the same.
It is reiterated that in the interview, the petitioner has secured low
marks than the private respondents 5 to 7.
That apart, the
performance of the petitioner in the interview is very poor.
Therefore, the respondent authorities are right in not selecting
the petitioner for the post of Assistant Professor (Geology). The
action of the respondent authorities cannot be questioned by the
petitioner by filing the instant writ petition. The writ petition is
devoid of merits and, therefore, the same is liable to be
dismissed.
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
P a g e | 38
50.
In the result, the writ petition is dismissed. There
will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 644 of 2020
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review