Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
Dated : 10th November, 2023
------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.04 of 2023
:
Appellant
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
versus
Respondents :
Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
---------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Pawan Gurung, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. S. S. Hamal, Senior Advocate with Mr. Tashi Wongdi Bhutia, Mr.
Mahesh Subba, Mr. Pradeep Sharma and Mr. Anirudh Gupta, Advocates
for the Respondents.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The three grounds agitated in this Appeal are;
(i)
That, the rate of interest placed at 9% on the Award, by the
Learned
Motor
Accidents
Claims
Tribunal,
Gangtok
(hereinafter, the “Learned Claims Tribunal”) is exorbitant
and ought to be decreased;
(ii)
That, ₹ 13,00,000/- (Rupees thirteen lakhs) only, awarded
under the “other heads” has no basis and ought to be
reduced; and
(iii)
That, the disability certificate of the victim indicates that he
suffered a 90% disability but the Learned Claims Tribunal
considered it to be 100% disability while computing the
compensation.
Hence, the compensation awarded to the
Claimant/Respondent No.1 is required to be reduced.
2.
Elaborating
on
the
grounds
raised
hereinabove,
Learned Counsel for the Appellant contended that interest @ 9%
imposed by the Learned Claims Tribunal on the awarded amount is
not in conformity with the interest rates of various Banks prevailing
during the period of the accident.
While relying on Dharampal and
Others vs. U.P. State Road Transport Corporation , it was canvassed
(2008) 12 SCC 208
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
that the Supreme Court has held therein that the interest to be
awarded is normally dependent upon the prevailing rate of interest
of Banks at the time of granting the Award. That, on the date of
Award the rate of bank interest was 6% which therefore ought to
be the interest imposed and not 9%.
That, the amount of ₹
13,00,000/- (Rupees thirteen lakhs) only, granted under the ‘other
heads’ is excessive and arbitrary awarded sans reasons, which
requires reconsideration.
That, the Learned Claims Tribunal has
also arbitrarily considered the disability of the victim as 100%
instead of 90% as actually indicated in his disability certificate
Exhibit 10, issued by the office of the Chief Medical Officer (West
Sikkim), duly signed by three doctors. Besides, no evidence was
adduced with regard to the permanent disability, by the authority
issuing the certificate, which has been accepted without proof.
Hence, the compensation granted be recomputed in light of the
grounds raised above.
3.
Learned Senior Counsel for the Respondents per contra
submitted that the Supreme Court has held in a plethora of cases
that not only 90% physical disability but even 50% disability can
be considered as 100% disability if the earning capacity of the
victim is compromised on account of the accident. That, the rate
of interest of 9% is not exorbitant as it is the discretion of the
Learned Claims Tribunal to Award the rate of interest and there is
no hard and fast rule that provides that the rate of interest ought
to be as per the prevailing bank rate. The compensation awarded
under the ‘other heads’ are in terms of the Judgment of the
Supreme Court in Raj Kumar vs. Ajay Kumar and Another2 and
nothing irregular or arbitrary can be said to have been made in the
(2011) 1 SCC 343
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
Award.
There being no merit in the Appeal, it ought to be
dismissed.
4.
The Respondent No.1, the victim of the accident, who
was the Claimant (hereinafter referred to as “Claimant”), before
the Learned Claims Tribunal in MACT Case No.46 of 2019 (Amrit
Kumar Manger vs. Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company and
Others) was eighteen years of age on the date of the accident,
which occurred on 16-05-2018 at around 1645 hours.
He was
employed as a conductor/helper in the Eicher truck, bearing
registration no.SK-02-D-0560 owned by Respondent No.2 herein.
When the truck approached “Kaleg” Bridge, Legship, West Sikkim,
the driver made way to allow the vehicle behind it to overtake and
in the process the truck went off the road to 100 feet below. The
driver of the vehicle succumbed to his injuries.
The Claimant
suffered from 90% disability which fact he sought to fortify by
furnishing Exhibit 10 a certificate issued by the office of the Chief
Medical Officer (West Sikkim), duly signed by three doctors
revealing his physical impairment.
It was observed in the
document that his condition was not likely to improve, however a
reassessment was recommended after a period of one year. The
Claimant filed his evidence on affidavit and was his own witness.
The owner of the vehicle was examined as witness for himself. The
records reveal that the Appellant did not examine any witness
although Written Objection was filed contesting the claims put forth
by the Claimant in his Claim Petition.
(i)
The Learned Claims Tribunal settled six points for
determination and decided all in favour of the Claimant.
Placing
reliance on the ratio of the Supreme Court in Raj Kumar (supra) the
compensation was computed in terms of the ‘heads’ laid down in
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
the said decision.
That apart, while considering the physical
disability of the victim to be 100% instead of 90% the Learned
Claims Tribunal claimed to be guided by the Judgments of the
Supreme Court in Sri Anthony alias Anthony Swamy vs. The Managing
Director, KSRTC
Another .
and Jithendran vs. New India Assurance Co. Ltd and
The Learned Claims Tribunal accordingly granted the
compensation as follows;
“25.
Insofar as the medical expenses incurred by
the claimant, he has filed Exhibit 9(coll) which are the
original bills and receipts indicating the expenses.
These documents could not be controverted by the
OPs No.1 & 2 or the OP No.3. …………………….
26.
The total amount above comes to ₹
50,355.18/-(Rupees Fifty thousand three hundred
fifty five and eighteen paise) only which is rounded off
to ₹ 50,356/-. This figure has been arrived at on the
basis of the clear & legible bills/invoices/receipts
above placed forward by the claimant.
…………………………………………………………………………..
30.
We may as such add the following amounts to
the figures of medical expenses arrived at above. ₹
2,00,000/- towards future medical expenses given the
extent of his disablement and his young age; ₹
2,00,000/- towards pain and sufferings (sic.); ₹
2,00,000/- towards loss of amenities and enjoyment
of life including loss of marital prospects and marital
happiness;
₹
2,00,000/towards
conveyance
charges(and cost of attendant); ₹ 2,00,000/- towards
food and nourishment. We may further add the
amount under the head 'loss of future earnings' and
loss of earnings which would be as follows. Since the
monthly fixed salary of the claimant was ₹ 10,000/we may add 40% of the said salary towards future
prospects in view of his age in which case the amount
would come to ₹ 10,000/- + ₹ 4,000/-(40%) = ₹
14,000/- per month. As such his annual income would
be ₹ 14,000/- x 12 months = ₹ 1,68,000/-. If
multiplier of 18 (as applicable here in view of the age
of the claimant i.e., 18 years) is applied, the amount
would come to ₹ 1,68,000/- x 18 = ₹ 30,24,000/-. In
view of 100% permanent physical functional disability
the amount under the head 'loss of future income'
would be 100% of ₹ 30,24,000/- i.e., the same
amount. Finally, in view of the serious nature and
disability of the claimant we may add an amount of ₹
3,00,000/- towards loss of expectation of life. The
overall amount would thus come to ₹ 50,356/- + ₹
2,00,000/- + ₹ 2,00,000/- + ₹ 2,00,000/- + ₹
2,00,000/- + ₹ 2,00,000/- + ₹ 30,24,000/- + ₹
Civil Appeal No.2551 of 2020 arising out of SLP (Civil) No(s).1738 of 2018 of SCI decided on 10-06-2020
2021 SCC OnLine SC 983
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
3,00,000/- = ₹ 43,74,356/- (Rupees Forty three lakhs
seventy four thousand three hundred and fifty six)
only.”
(emphasis supplied)
5.
Addressing firstly the issue of the rate of interest which
according to the Learned Counsel for the Appellant was high being
9%, apposite reference is made to the decision in Abati Bezbaruah
vs. Dy. Director General, Geological Survey of India and Another5
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court opined as follows;
“18. ………………….. The rate of interest must
be just and reasonable depending upon the facts and
circumstances of each case and taking all relevant
factors including inflation, change of economy, policy
being adopted by Reserve Bank of India from time to
time, how long the case is pending, permanent
injuries suffered by the victim, enormity of suffering,
loss of future income, loss of enjoyment of life etc.,
into consideration. No rate of interest is fixed under
Section 171 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. Varying
rates of interest are being awarded by Tribunals,
High Courts and the Supreme Court. Interest can be
granted even if a claimant does not specifically plead
for the same as it is consequential in the eye of law.
Interest is compensation for forbearance or detention
of money and that interest being awarded to a party
only for being kept out of the money which ought to
have been paid to him. No principle could be deduced
nor can any rate of interest be fixed to have a
general application in motor accident claim cases
having regard to the nature of provision under
Section 171 giving discretion to the Tribunal in such
matter. In other matters, awarding of interest
depends upon the statutory provisions, mercantile
usage and doctrine of equity. Neither Section 34 CPC
nor Section 4-A(3) of the Workmen's Compensation
Act are applicable in the matter of fixing rate of
interest in a claim under the Motor Vehicles Act. The
courts have awarded the interest at different rates
depending upon the facts and circumstances of each
case. ……………………….”
(emphasis supplied)
(i)
Considering the totality of the facts of the case
including the fact that the Claimant suffered physical impairment of
90% as certified by Exhibit 10, I am of the considered opinion that
the rate of interest placed at 9% on the Award, by the Learned
Claims Tribunal requires no interference.
6.
The Appellant was also aggrieved by the Learned
Claims Tribunal granting ₹ 13,00,000/- (Rupees thirteen lakhs)
(2003) 3 SCC 148
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
only, under ‘other heads’ and by assessing the disability of the
Claimant as 100%, instead of 90% which was indicated in his
disability certificate.
(i)
In Raj Kumar (supra) on the aspect of disability and loss
of earning capacity the Supreme Court opined as follows;
“10. Where the claimant suffers a permanent
disability as a result of injuries, the assessment of
compensation under the head of loss of future
earnings would depend upon the effect and impact of
such permanent disability on his earning capacity.
The Tribunal should not mechanically apply the
percentage of permanent disability as the percentage
of economic loss or loss of earning capacity. In most
of the cases, the percentage of economic loss, that is,
the percentage of loss of earning capacity, arising
from a permanent disability will be different from the
percentage of permanent disability. Some Tribunals
wrongly assume that in all cases, a particular extent
(percentage) of permanent disability would result in a
corresponding loss of earning capacity, and
consequently, if the evidence produced show 45% as
the permanent disability, will hold that there is 45%
loss of future earning capacity. In most of the cases,
equating the extent (percentage) of loss of earning
capacity to the extent (percentage) of permanent
disability will result in award of either too low or too
high a compensation.
11. What requires to be assessed by the
Tribunal is the effect of the permanent disability on
the earning capacity of the injured; and after
assessing the loss of earning capacity in terms of a
percentage of the income, it has to be quantified in
terms of money, to arrive at the future loss of
earnings (by applying the standard multiplier method
used to determine loss of dependency). We may
however note that in some cases, on appreciation of
evidence and assessment, the Tribunal may find that
the percentage of loss of earning capacity as a result
of the permanent disability, is approximately the
same as the percentage of permanent disability in
which case, of course, the Tribunal will adopt the said
percentage for determination of compensation. (See
for example, the decisions of this Court in Arvind
Kumar Mishra v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. [(2010) 10
SCC 254 : (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 1258 : (2010) 10 Scale 298] and Yadava
Kumar v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. [(2010) 10 SCC 341 :
(2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 1285 : (2010) 8 Scale 567]).
12.……………………………………………………………………..
13. Ascertainment of the effect of the
permanent disability on the actual earning capacity
involves three steps. The Tribunal has to first
ascertain what activities the claimant could carry on
in spite of the permanent disability and what he
could not do as a result of the permanent disability
(this is also relevant for awarding compensation
under the head of loss of amenities of life). The
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
second step is to ascertain his avocation, profession
and nature of work before the accident, as also his
age. The third step is to find out whether (i) the
claimant is totally disabled from earning any kind of
livelihood, or (ii) whether in spite of the permanent
disability, the claimant could still effectively carry on
the activities and functions, which he was earlier
carrying on, or (iii) whether he was prevented or
restricted from discharging his previous activities
and functions, but could carry on some other or
lesser scale of activities and functions so that he
continues to earn or can continue to earn his
livelihood.”
(emphasis supplied)
(ii)
Indubitably the accident led to the Claimant being a
Paraplegic. Paraplegia is defined as paralysis of the lower part of
the body and limbs, due to numerous causes, e.g. fractured spine
and damage to the cord, various tract degenerations in the cord,
and polyneuritis [See Butterworths, Medical Dictionary, Second
Edition, Critchley].
The accident thus sucked out the ability of the
Claimant to earn a living and instead has made him dependent on
his parents for his day to day activities as emerges from his
uncontroverted
evidence.
On
the
anvil
of
the
above
pronouncement and the facts before this Court, the assessment of
the disability of the Claimant placed at 100% by the Learned
Claims Tribunal, instead of 90% as indicated in his disability
certificate is not erroneous.
(iii)
Now while addressing the grievance pertaining to
compensation given under ‘other heads’, in Govind Yadav vs. New
India Insurance Company Limited ,
the Supreme Court opined as
follows;
“18. In our view, the principles laid down
in Arvind Kumar Mishra v. New India Assurance Co.
Ltd. [(2010) 10 SCC 254 : (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 1258 : (2010) 4 SCC (Civ) 153]
and Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar [(2011) 1 SCC 343 : (2011) 1 SCC
(Cri) 1161 : (2011) 1 SCC (Civ) 164] must be followed by all the
Tribunals and the High Courts in determining the
quantum of compensation payable to the victims of
accident, who are disabled either permanently or
temporarily. If the victim of the accident suffers
permanent disability, then efforts should always be
made to award adequate compensation not only for
the physical injury and treatment, but also for the
(2011) 10 SCC 683
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
loss of earning and his inability to lead a normal life
and enjoy amenities, which he would have enjoyed
but for the disability caused due to the accident.”
(emphasis supplied)
(iv)
In K. Suresh vs. New India Assurance Company Limited and
Another , the Supreme Court observed that;
“10. It is noteworthy to state that an
adjudicating
authority,
while
determining
the
quantum of compensation, has to keep in view the
sufferings of the injured person which would include
his inability to lead a full life, his incapacity to enjoy
the normal amenities which he would have enjoyed
but for the injuries and his ability to earn as much as
he used to earn or could have earned. Hence, while
computing compensation the approach of the
Tribunal or a court has to be broad based. Needless
to say, it would involve some guesswork as there
cannot be any mathematical exactitude or a precise
formula to determine the quantum of compensation.
In determination of compensation the fundamental
criterion of “just compensation” should be inhered.”
(emphasis supplied)
(v)
In Jithendran (supra) the Supreme Court was of the
view that when the victim suffered permanent disability it not only
impairs his cognitive abilities and his physical facilities but there
are multiple other non-quantifiable implications for the victim. It
was observed as follows;
“26. Before parting, it needs emphasizing that
in cases such as this, the Tribunal and the Courts
must be conscious of the fact that the permanent
disability suffered by the individual not only impairs
his cognitive abilities and his physical facilities but
there are multiple other non-quantifiable implications
for the victim. The very fact that a healthy person
turns into an invalid, being deprived of normal
companionship, and incapable of leading a productive
life, makes one suffer the loss of self-dignity. Such a
Claimant must not be viewed as a modern day Oliver
Twist, having to make entreaties as the boy in the
orphanage in Charles Dickens's classic, “Please Sir, I
want some more”. The efforts must be to
substantially ameliorate the misery of the claimant
and recognize his actual needs by accounting for the
ground realities. The measures should however be in
correct proportion. As is aptly said by Justice R.V
Raveendran, while speaking for the Division Bench
in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation [(2009) 6
SCC
121], just
compensation
is
adequate
compensation and the Award must be just that-no
less and no more. The plea of the victim suffering
from a cruel twist of fate, when asking for some
more, is not extravagant but is for seeking
appropriate recompense to negotiate with the
(2012) 12 SCC 274
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
unforeseeable and the fortuitous twists is his
impaired life. Therefore, while the money awarded by
Courts can hardly redress the actual sufferings of the
injured victim (who is deprived of the normal
amenities of life and suffers the unease of being a
burden on others), the courts can make a genuine
attempt to help restore the self-dignity of such
claimant, by awarding ‘just compensation’.”
(emphasis supplied)
(vi)
Indeed the mental trauma and other intangibles that
the victim of an accident suffers and is likely to suffer lifelong
cannot be quantified in material terms.
As the adage goes, only
the wearer knows where the shoe pinches. Thus, the victim of the
accident whose life at his age ought to be filled with joie de vivre,
has instead been the recipient of unpalatable consequences for no
fault of his own, due to the vagaries of life. He has to deal with the
suffering, both physical and mental.
The Supreme Court being
alive to such circumstances in Parminder Singh vs. New India
Assurance Company Limited and Others
observed as follows;
“5.12. Given the debilitated state of the
appellant, no amount of money can compensate him.
He has been in this condition since the age of 22
years when the accident took place, and will remain
like this throughout his life. The appellant has also
been deprived of having a normal married life with a
family, and would require medical assistance from
time to time. Being completely dependent, he would
require the help of an attendant throughout his life. In
view of these uncontroverted facts, we deem it fit and
appropriate to award a lump sum amount of
Rs.10,00,000 to the appellant towards medical
expenses and attendant charges.”
(vii)
In Kajal vs. Jagdish Chand and Others9, the Supreme
Court was concerned with the permanent disability of a twelve year
old girl, who till her accident was a bright child but after the
fortuitous accident was medically assessed to have the social age
of a 9 month old child. Her disability was assessed at 100%. On
this facet the Supreme Court opined that ‘attendant charges’
which had been worked out by the High Court @ ₹ 2,500/-(Rupees
(2019) 7 SCC 217
(2020) 4 SCC 413
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
twenty five hundred) only, per month for 44 years to a sum of ₹
13,20,000/-(Rupees thirteen lakhs and twenty thousand) only, was
not a proper system and the multiplier system ought to be used to
balance out various factors. The Supreme Court went on to hold
as follows;
“Attendant charges
22. The attendant charges have been awarded
by the High Court @ Rs 2500 per month for 44 years,
which works out to Rs 13,20,000. Unfortunately, this
system is not a proper system. Multiplier system is
used to balance out various factors. When
compensation is awarded in lump sum, various
factors
are
taken
into
consideration.
When
compensation is paid in lump sum, this Court has
always followed the multiplier system. The multiplier
system should be followed not only for determining
the compensation on account of loss of income but
also for determining the attendant charges, etc. This
system was recognised by this Court in Gobald Motor
Service Ltd. v. R.M.K. Veluswami [Gobald Motor
Service Ltd. v. R.M.K. Veluswami, AIR 1962 SC 1]. The
multiplier system factors in the inflation rate, the
rate of interest payable on the lump sum award, the
longevity of the claimant, and also other issues such
as the uncertainties of life. Out of all the various
alternative methods, the multiplier method has been
recognised as the most realistic and reasonable
method. It ensures better justice between the
parties and thus results in award of “just
compensation” within the meaning of the Act.
23. It would be apposite at this stage to refer
to
the
observation
of
Lord
Reid
in Taylor v. O'Connor [Taylor v. O'Connor, 1971 AC 115 :
(1970) 2 WLR 472 (HL)] : (AC p. 128)
“Damages to make good the loss of
dependency over a period of years must be awarded
as a lump sum and that sum is generally calculated
by applying a multiplier to the amount of one year's
dependency. That is a perfectly good method in the
ordinary case but it conceals the fact that there are
two quite separate matters involved — the present
value of the series of future payments, and the
discounting of that present value to allow for the fact
that for one reason or another the person receiving
the damages might never have enjoyed the whole of
the benefit of the dependency. It is quite unnecessary
in the ordinary case to deal with these matters
separately. Judges and counsel have a wealth of
experience which is an adequate guide to the
selection of the multiplier and any expert evidence is
rightly discouraged. But in a case where the facts are
special I think that these matters must have separate
consideration if even rough justice is to be done and
expert evidence may be valuable or even almost
essential. The special factor in the present case is the
incidence of income tax and, it may be, surtax.”
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
24. This Court has reaffirmed the multiplier
method
in
various
cases
like
MCD
v. Subhagwanti [MCD v. Subhagwanti, AIR 1966 SC 1750 :
1966 ACJ 57], U.P. SRTC v. Trilok Chandra [U.P. SRTC
v. Trilok
Chandra,
(1996)
SCC
362], Sandeep
Khanuja v. Atul
Dande [Sandeep
Khanuja v. Atul
Dande, (2017) 3 SCC 351 : (2017) 2 SCC (Civ) 276 : (2017) 2 SCC (Cri) 178].
This Court has also recognised that Schedule II of the
Act can be used as a guide for the multiplier to be
applied in each case. Keeping the claimant's age in
mind, the multiplier in this case should be 18 as
opposed to 44 taken by the High Court.
25. Having held so, we are clearly of the view
that the basic amount taken for determining the
attendant charges is very much on the lower side. We
must remember that this little girl is severely
suffering from incontinence, meaning that she does
not have control over her bodily functions like passing
urine and faeces. As she grows older, she will not be
able to handle her periods. She requires an attendant
virtually 24 hours a day. She requires an attendant
who though may not be medically trained but must be
capable of handling a child who is bedridden. She
would require an attendant who would ensure that
she does not suffer from bedsores. The claimant has
placed before us a notification of the State of Haryana
of the year 2010, wherein the wages for skilled
labourer is Rs 4846 per month. We, therefore, assess
the cost of one attendant at Rs 5000 and she will
require two attendants which works out to Rs 10,000
per month, which comes to Rs 1,20,000 p.a., and
using the multiplier of 18, it works out to Rs
21,60,000 for the attendant charges for her entire
life. This takes care of all the pecuniary damages.”
(emphasis supplied)
(viii)
The Supreme Court was of the view that the amount
for the ‘attendant’ ought to be arrived at in terms of the discussion
extracted above and by use of the multiplier as per the age of the
Claimant.
(ix)
In the case at hand, a lump sum amount of ₹
2,00,000/-(Rupees
two
lakhs)
only,
was
awarded
towards
“conveyance/attendant charges” by the Learned Claims Tribunal
without working out the details or assigning reasons for awarding
such an amount. In Kajal (supra), the accident occurred on 18-102007 and the Notification of the State of Haryana on wages for
skilled labourers for the year 2010, was taken into consideration
for assessment under the said head as seen at Paragraph 25 of the
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
ratio extracted hereinabove.
Following the same principle, the
daily wages for an “unskilled worker” under the Notification bearing
No.29/DL dated 14-09-2022, issued by the Department of Labour,
Government of Sikkim, under which the Claimant is covered, being
a “Khalasi” is taken into consideration.
The nomenclature and
wages are detailed at serial no.12, page no.2, of the said
Notification.
The daily wages mentioned therein are ₹ 500/-
(Rupees five hundred) only. Accordingly, the monthly wages of an
“unskilled worker” would work out to ₹ 15,000/-(Rupees fifteen
thousand) only, which would be ₹ 1,80,000/-(Rupees one lakh and
eighty thousand) only, per annum.
Considering the age of the
Claimant, the multiplier of 18 is adopted, the amount therefore
stands computed at ₹ 32,40,000/-(Rupees thirty two lakhs and
forty thousand) only. It would thus be appropriate to Award the
said amount as ‘attendant charges’ for one attendant for the
lifetime of the Claimant.
The sum of ₹ 2,00,000/-(Rupees two
lakhs) only, granted by the Learned Claims Tribunal is set aside.
(x)
In Kajal (ibid) while considering “pain, suffering and
loss of amenities”, reference
was made to the decision in
Mallikarjun vs. Divisional Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
and Another10.
The Supreme Court observed as follows;
“Pain, suffering and loss of amenities
26. Coming to the non-pecuniary damages
under the head of pain, suffering, loss of amenities,
the High Court has awarded this girl only Rs
3,00,000. In Mallikarjun v. National Insurance Co.
Ltd. [Mallikarjun v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., (2014)
14 SCC 396 : (2015) 1 SCC (Civ) 335 : (2015) 1 SCC (Cri) 372 : (2013) 10
Scale 668],
this Court while dealing with the issue of
award under this head held that it should be at least
Rs 6,00,000, if the disability is more than 90%. As
far as the present case is concerned, in addition to
the 100% physical disability, the young girl is
suffering from severe incontinence, she is suffering
from severe hysteria and above all she is left with a
brain of a nine-month-old child. This is a case where
(2014) 14 SCC 396
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
departure has to be made from the normal rule and
the pain and suffering suffered by this child is such
that no amount of compensation can compensate.
27. One factor which must be kept in mind
while assessing the compensation in a case like the
present one is that the claim can be awarded only
once. The claimant cannot come back to court for
enhancement of award at a later stage praying that
something extra has been spent. Therefore, the
courts or the Tribunals assessing the compensation in
a case of 100% disability, especially where there is
mental disability also, should take a liberal view of the
matter when awarding the compensation. While
awarding this amount, we are not only taking the
physical disability but also the mental disability and
various other factors. This child will remain bedridden
for life. Her mental age will be that of a nine-monthold child. Effectively, while her body grows, she will
remain a small baby. We are dealing with a girl who
will physically become a woman but will mentally
remain a 9-month-old child. This girl will miss out
playing with her friends. She cannot communicate;
she cannot enjoy the pleasures of life; she cannot
even be amused by watching cartoons or films; she
will miss out the fun of childhood, the excitement of
youth; the pleasures of a marital life; she cannot
have children who she can love, let alone
grandchildren. She will have no pleasure. Her's is a
vegetable existence. Therefore, we feel in the
peculiar facts and circumstances of the case even
after taking a very conservative view of the matter
an amount payable for the pain and suffering of this
child should be at least Rs 15,00,000.”
(emphasis supplied)
(xi)
Considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the
case, the amount payable for the pain and suffering of the child
was found to be ₹ 15,00,000/- (Rupees fifteen lakhs) only.
(xii)
In Mallikarjun (supra), the Supreme Court held that;
“7. It is unfortunate that both the Tribunal and
the High Court have not properly appreciated the
medical evidence available in the case. The age of the
child and deformities on his body resulting in
disability, have not been duly taken note of. As held
by this Court in R.D. Hattangadi v. Pest Control
(India) (P) Ltd. [(1995) 1 SCC 551 : 1995 SCC (Cri) 250] , while
assessing the non-pecuniary damages, the damages
for mental and physical shock, pain and suffering
already suffered and that are likely to be suffered,
any future damages for the loss of amenities in life,
like difficulty in running, participation in active
sports, etc. damages on account of inconvenience,
hardship, discomfort, disappointment, frustration,
etc. have to be addressed especially in the case of a
child victim. For a child, the best part of his life is yet
to come.”
(emphasis supplied)
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
(xiii)
Bearing
in
mind
the
gamut
of
the
facts
and
circumstances in the instant case and the observations of the
Supreme Court in Mallikarjun and Kajal (supra), the Claimant herein
with 100% disability on account of paraplegia will obviously be
deprived of all the pleasures of life, augmented by his disability to
earn a living due to complete paralysis from his waist down. I am
of the considered opinion that, instead of ₹ 2,00,000/-(Rupees two
lakhs) only, awarded towards pain and suffering and ₹ 2,00,000/(Rupees two lakhs) only, awarded towards loss of amenities, a
total sum of ₹ 6,00,000/-(Rupees six lakhs) only, is appropriate
under the consolidated head of “pain, suffering and loss of
amenities”.
(xiv)
For “loss of marriage prospects” in Kajal (supra) a sum
of ₹ 3,00,000/-(Rupees three lakhs) only, was awarded by the
Learned Claims Tribunal which was not interfered by the High
Court or the Supreme Court. It is noticed that the Learned Claims
Tribunal while granting ₹ 2,00,000/-(Rupees two lakhs) only,
towards loss of amenities, included loss of “marital prospects” and
“marital happiness” under the same head. Reverting back to the
decision of Kajal (supra) under the head of loss of marriage
prospects, it was held as follows;
“Loss of marriage prospects
28. The Tribunal has awarded Rs 3,00,000 for
loss of marriage prospects. We see no reason to
interfere with this finding.”
Hence, for loss of marital prospects and marital happiness, I
deem it appropriate to Award ₹ 3,00,000/-(Rupees three lakhs)
only, instead of the ₹ 2,00,000/-(Rupees two lakhs) only, awarded
by the Learned Claims Tribunal which is accordingly set aside.
(xv)
The Learned Claims Tribunal granted ₹ 2,00,000/-
(Rupees two lakhs) only, as “Future medical expenses”. In Kajal
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
(supra), it is noticed that the Claimant who also suffered from
100% disability was awarded ₹ 2,00,000/-(Rupees two lakhs) only,
by the Learned Claims Tribunal under the head.
The Supreme
Court disappointed by the amount awarded for the purpose held as
follows;
“Future medical treatment
29. The claimant has been awarded only Rs
2,00,000 under this head. This amount is a pittance.
Keeping in view the nature of her injuries and the fact
that she is bedridden this child is bound to suffer from
a lot of medical problems. True it is that there is no
evidence in this regard but there can hardly be such
evidence. She may require special mattress which will
have to be changed frequently. In future as this girl
grows, she may face many other medical issues
because of the injuries suffered in the accident.
Keeping in view her young age and assuming she
would live another 50 to 60 years, it would not be
unjust to award her Rs 5,00,000 for future medical
expenses.”
(xvi)
Adhering to the above observation, it would not be
unjust to award ₹ 3,00,000/-(Rupees three lakhs) only, for future
medical expenses considering that the Claimant in his evidence on
affidavit, has stated that on account of the accident, he is
bedridden and not able to perform his day to day works for which
he has to rely on his parents.
In view of this amount being
awarded, the sum of ₹ 2,00,000/-(Rupees two lakhs) only, granted
by the Learned Claims Tribunal towards food and nourishment is
set aside.
(xvii)
There is no reason to interfere with the ₹ 3,00,000/-
(Rupees three lakhs) only, granted by the Learned Claims Tribunal
towards loss of expectation of life.
7.
Hence, the compensation worked out by the Learned
Claims Tribunal and this Court under the “other heads” are
juxtaposed below for clarity:-
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
Learned Claims Tribunal
High Court
1.
Actual medical expenses
₹ 50,356/-
1.
Actual medical expenses
₹ 50,356/-
2.
Future medical expenses
₹ 2,00,000/-
2.
Future medical expenses
₹ 3,00,000/-
3.
Pain and suffering
₹ 2,00,000/-
3.
Pain,
suffering,
loss of amenities
and
₹ 6,00,000/-
4.
Loss of amenities and
enjoyment of life including
loss of marital prospects
and marital happiness
₹ 2,00,000/-
4.
Loss
of
prospects
marriage
₹ 3,00,000/-
5.
Conveyance/attendant
charges
₹ 2,00,000/-
5.
Attendant charges
₹ 32,40,000/-
6.
Food and nourishment
₹ 2,00,000/-
6.
₹ 3,00,000/-
7.
Loss of expectation of life
₹ 3,00,000/-
Loss of expectation of
life
Total
₹ 47,90,356/-
₹ 13,50,356/-
Total
8.
The
total
compensation
would
be
as
detailed
hereinbelow;
(i)
The “loss of earnings” and “future prospects”, i.e., ₹
30,24,000/- (Rupees thirty lakhs and twenty four thousand) only,
and “actual medical expenses”, i.e., ₹ 50,356/- (Rupees fifty
thousand, three hundred and fifty six) only, awarded by the
Learned Claims Tribunal are not in dispute thereby the amount
remains the same i.e., ₹ 30,74,356/-(Rupees thirty lakhs, seventy
four thousand, three hundred and fifty six) only.
(ii)
Under the “other heads”, the amounts are computed
and modified as follows;
Add Future medical expenses
(+)
₹
3,00,000.00
(+)
₹
6,00,000.00
(+)
₹
3,00,000.00
(+)
₹ 32,40,000.00
(+)
₹ 3,00,000.00
₹ 47,40,000.00
[In terms of the Judgment in Kajal (supra)]
Add Pain, suffering and loss of amenities
[In terms of the Judgment in Kajal (supra)]
Add Loss of marriage prospects
[In terms of the Judgment in Kajal (supra)]
Add Attendant charges
[For one attendant in terms of the Judgment
in Kajal (supra)]
Add Loss of expectation of life
Total
=
(Rupees forty seven lakhs and forty thousand) only.
(iii)
Adding
₹
30,74,356/-
(supra)
and
the
amounts
computed under the “other heads” i.e., ₹ 47,40,000/-, the amount
totals to ₹ 78,14,356/- (Rupees seventy eight lakhs, fourteen
thousand, three hundred and fifty six) only.
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
9.
Section 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, provides
as follows;
“168. Award of the Claims Tribunal.—(1) On
receipt of an application for compensation made
under section 166, the Claims Tribunal shall, after
giving notice of the application to the insurer and
after giving the parties (including the insurer) an
opportunity of being heard, hold an inquiry into the
claim or, as the case may be, each of the claims and,
subject to the provisions of Section 163 may make an
award determining the amount of compensation
which appears to it to be just and specifying the
person or persons to whom compensation shall be
paid and in making the award the Claims Tribunal
shall specify the amount which shall be paid by the
insurer or owner or driver of the vehicle involved in
the accident or by all or any of them, as the case may
be:
………………………….”
(emphasis supplied)
(i)
Section
The Learned Claims Tribunal in terms of the above
is
clothed
compensation”.
with
the
responsibility
of
granting
“just
The concept of just compensation has been
succinctly explained by the Supreme Court in National Insurance
Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and Others
as follows;
“55. …………. The conception of “just compensation”
has to be viewed through the prism of fairness,
reasonableness and non-violation of the principle of
equitability. In a case of death, the legal heirs of the
claimants cannot expect a windfall. Simultaneously,
the compensation granted cannot be an apology for
compensation. It cannot be a pittance. Though the
discretion vested in the tribunal is quite wide, yet it is
obligatory on the part of the tribunal to be guided by
the expression, that is, “just compensation”. The
determination has to be on the foundation of evidence
brought on record as regards the age and income of
the deceased and thereafter the apposite multiplier to
be applied. The formula relating to multiplier has been
clearly stated in Sarla Verma [Sarla Verma v. DTC,
(2009) 6 SCC 121 : (2009) 2 SCC (Civ) 770 : (2009) 2 SCC (Cri) 1002 ] and it
has been approved in Reshma Kumari [Reshma
Kumari v. Madan Mohan, (2013) 9 SCC 65 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 191 :
(2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 826] . The age and income, as stated
earlier, have to be established by adducing evidence.
The tribunal and the courts have to bear in mind that
the basic principle lies in pragmatic computation
which is in proximity to reality. It is a well-accepted
norm that money cannot substitute a life lost but an
effort has to be made for grant of just compensation
having uniformity of approach. There has to be a
balance between the two extremes, that is, a windfall
(2017) 16 SCC 680
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
and the pittance, a bonanza and the modicum. In
such an adjudication, the duty of the tribunal and the
courts is difficult and hence, an endeavour has been
made by this Court for standardisation which in its
ambit includes addition of future prospects on the
proven income at present. As far as future prospects
are concerned, there has been standardisation
keeping in view the principle of certainty, stability and
consistency.
We
approve
the
principle
of
“standardisation” so that a specific and certain
multiplicand is determined for applying the multiplier
on the basis of age.”
(emphasis supplied)
(ii)
In Pappu Deo Yadav vs. Naresh Kumar and Others12, the
Supreme Court observed that;
“8. ………“just compensation” should include all
elements that would go to place the victim in as near
a position as she or he was in, before the occurrence
of the accident. Whilst no amount of money or other
material compensation can erase the trauma, pain
and suffering that a victim undergoes after a serious
accident (or replace the loss of a loved one),
monetary compensation is the manner known to law,
whereby society assures some measure of restitution
to those who survive, and the victims who have to
face their lives. ……………..”
(iii)
In Kajal (supra), the Supreme Court held as follows;
“33. We are aware that the amount awarded
by us is more than the amount claimed. However, it is
well settled law that in the motor accident claim
petitions,
the
Court
must
award
the
just
compensation and, in case, the just compensation is
more than the amount claimed, that must be awarded
especially where the claimant is a minor.”
(iv)
It thus concludes that the endeavour of the Court
should be to appropriately and justly compensate the Claimant
ensuring at the same time that it is neither a windfall nor a
pittance. It ought to place the victim in as near a position as she
or he was before the occurrence of the accident.
10.
From the facts of the case at hand, it emanates that
the Claimant was a mere boy of eighteen years when he met with
the unfortunate accident. It is trite that following the accident, he
cannot lead a normal life being a Paraplegic and the observation in
Exhibit 10 certificate for “Persons with Disabilities” records that his
(2022) 13 SCC 790
MAC App. No. 04 of 2023
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Amrit Kumar Manger and Another
condition is not likely to improve. He has also been shorn of his
capacity to earn a living for the rest of his life and has now become
a fully dependant person on account of his debilitated physical
condition. The contents of the Exhibit 10 the disability certificate
have not been disputed nor demolished under cross-examination
by any of the opposing parties before the Learned Claims Tribunal.
11.
Consequently,
it
is
ordered
that
Company-Appellant shall deposit the enhanced
the
Insurance
compensation
amount computed at ₹ 78,14,356/-(Rupees seventy eight lakhs,
fourteen thousand, three hundred and fifty six) only, as detailed
above to the Claimant, within a period of one month from today,
with interest @ 9% per annum, failing which the Insurance
Company-Appellant shall pay interest @ 12% per annum, from the
date of filing of the Claim Petition i.e., 14-10-2019, till full
realization, duly deducting the amounts, if any, already paid by the
Insurance Company-Appellant to the Claimant.
12.
Appeal is disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
13.
No orders as to costs.
14.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of
accordingly.
15.
Copy of this Judgment be forwarded to the Learned
Claims Tribunal for information, along with its records.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
10-11-2023
Approved for reporting :Yes
sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review