Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
RESERVED ON: 24.08.2026
DELIVERED ON: 24.09.2026
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE REETOBROTO KUMAR MITRA
WPA 15785 OF 2025
WITH
WPA 29040 OF 2024
CHITTARANJAN ADHIKARY
- VERSUS –
THE UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS.
Appearance:
Mr. Kushal Chatterjee,
Ms. Ritika Pipalwa.
… For the petitioner in both matters.
Mr. Ramesh Sharma,
Mr. Aninda Bhattacharya.
REPORTABLE
... For the respondents in WPA 15785 of 2025
Mr. Bishwambher Jha,
Mr. Amal Kumar Dutta,
Mr. Bhaskar Dolui.
... For the respondent nos. 2 to 9 in both matters
Reetobroto Kumar Mitra, J.:
1.
These two writ petitions are taken up together as they concern the
same issues of denial of promotion and seniority to the writ
petitioner.
2.
The issue raised in these two petitions is best addressed as
circumstantial anomalies.
3.
The petitioner's grievance is that he has not been given or at least
been considered for promotion due to a deficiency on the part of the
authorities on two counts. The first is that he ought to have been
considered as a direct recruit of the 2014 batch of Sub-inspectors
(Executive) and hence included in the 53rd batch of the concerned
battalion of the Railway Protection Special Force (hereinafter the
RPSF). He has been considered in the 54th batch.
REPORTABLE
4.
The second is that the petitioner, upon transfer from Railway
Protection Force (hereinafter the RPF) on his own request, cannot
be deemed to have lost his seniority in inter-cadre transfer, on
account whereof he ought to have been granted promotion and his
name included in Force Order No. 22 of 2025 dated February 27,
2025 and Force Order No. 25 of 2025 dated March 3, 2025.
5.
A brief enunciation of facts before adverting to the issue raised will
be essential to appreciate the chronology of events and the
applicability of the prevalent rules at the time.
6.
The petitioner was appointed as a Sub-inspector in the RPSF with
effect from March 1, 2015 by an order dated April 24, 2015. This
order had not been challenged till the time mentioned hereinafter.
7.
The petitioner was appointed as an Inspector on an ad hoc basis in
the RPSF on November 17, 2017.
8.
On July 20, 2023, the petitioner issued a declaration that he was
agreeable (in the event of transfer on his own request) to accept
"bottom seniority in the grade in which he was directly recruited".
REPORTABLE
9.
Having made such a declaration, the petitioner was transferred on
his own request on June 10, 2024 from RPSF to RPF, which he
joined on June 11, 2024 as Sub-inspector on an ad hoc basis.
10.
The provisional list for seniority was published on July 17, 2024.
The petitioner's name did not feature in this list, on account whereof
the petitioner made a representation on September 10, 2024.
11.
A further provisional list was published on September 12, 2024 with
a list of 60 eligible Sub-inspectors for promotion to the rank of
Inspector, which did not feature the petitioner.
12.
The petitioner made a second representation on November 11,
2024 and even though such representation was not considered, the
petitioner acted on the notice of November 13, 2024 and submitted
his APAR (Annual Performance Assessment Report).
13.
It was only thereafter that the petitioner filed the first writ petition
challenging, inter alia, the seniority list of July 17, 2024 and
September 12, 2024 and seeking to set aside the same, and to
consider his two representations which had been made by him. In
the said writ petition, an interim order was passed permitting the
REPORTABLE
petitioner to sit for the examination slated on December 20, 2024,
and to keep a vacancy in the post of Inspector.
14.
In terms of the said interim order, the petitioner sat for the
examination and secured the qualifying marks. After this
examination was held, a list of 24 successful candidates eligible for
promotion was published, which again did not feature the petitioner.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner filed the second writ petition being
WPA No. 15785 of 2025.
15.
It is in these limited facts, which are admitted by both parties, that
the matters have to be decided.
16.
The only point raised by the petitioner is that the petitioner is guided
by the amended Rule 99.2 and Rule 99.2A of the Railway Protection
Force Rules, 1987 (hereinafter referred to as “the said Rules”). For
the sake of utility, the said unamended and amended Rule 99.2 and
Rule 99.2A are set out hereunder:
Unamended Rule 99.2: “Seniority of an enrolled
member of the Force transferred on his own request…
from one zonal railway to another or to the Railway
Protection Special Force and vice versa shall be fixed
below that of all existing confirmed and officiating
REPORTABLE
enrolled members of the Force in the relevant rank…
irrespective of… length of officiating service of the
transferred member.”. In other words, voluntary
transferees join at the bottom of seniority in the
destination cadre.
Amended Rule 99.2 (Effective July 20, 2021):Seniority
of an enrolled member (except Sub-Inspectors or
Inspectors) of the force transferred on his own request
or on mutual exchange from one zonal railway to
another, shall be fixed below that of all existing
confirmed and officiating enrolled member of the Force
in the relevant rank of that railway irrespective of the
date of confirmation or length of officiating service of
the transferred member of the Force.
Inserted Rule 99.2A (vide Gazette Notification dated
July 20, 2021): There shall be no change in the
Seniority of Sub-Inspectors or Inspectors transferred on
mutual exchange or on own request from one zonal
railway to another zonal railway as these ranks fall
under centralized seniority.”.
17.
The petitioner has really not made any submissions insofar as the
seniority from the 54th batch to the 53rd batch is concerned.
18.
Before dealing with the question of seniority, it is necessary to
address the discrepancy appearing from the records as to whether
the petitioner ought to have been in 53rd or the 54th Batch of the
RPSF. As regards the petitioner's grievance that although his
selection was made along with the 53rd Batch, he was subsequently
placed in the 54th Batch on account of the commencement of his
REPORTABLE
training, the said grievance cannot be entertained at this stage. The
petitioner was appointed in the year 2015 and was admittedly aware
of the batch in which he had been placed. If the petitioner was
aggrieved by such placement and considered that the same had
adversely affected his seniority, it was incumbent upon him to raise
the issue at the earliest opportunity and not remain silent for several
(nine) years and seek to reopen the matter only after the seniority list
was published in 2024. A person cannot sleep over his rights and
subsequently seek to unsettle a position which had remained
undisturbed for years. This Court, therefore, finds no justification to
entertain the petitioner's grievance regarding his alleged loss of
seniority on account of his placement in the 54th Batch.
19.
The petitioner's grievance, in terms of the submission made by Mr.
Kushal Chatterjee, is restricted to the second element of seniority.
20.
He submits that the petitioner was considered for promotion only in
2024, that is, after the coming into force of the amended Rule 99.2
on July 20, 2021 and the newly inserted Rule 99.2A, also effective by
way of the Gazette Notification dated July 20, 2021.
REPORTABLE
21.
He submits that his date of appointment sometime in 2015 cannot
be a ground to keep him outside the purview of the amended Rule
as well as the newly inserted Rule, as he became eligible for
promotion in 2024. Thus, the amended Rule as well as the newly
inserted Rule 99.2A pertaining to promotion will have to be
considered for a promotion which takes place after the introduction
of such amended Rule and newly incorporated Rule. Merely because
the petitioner was appointed prior to the coming into force of the
Rules pertaining to promotion, he cannot be left beyond the purview
of such Rules.
22.
The respondent's only case has been that the petitioner is not
covered by Rule 99.2 or Rule 99.2A as both these provisions were
amended and incorporated respectively sometime in 2021. Thus, the
petitioner, being a direct recruit in the year 2015, prior to this
amendment and incorporation, is not covered thereunder.
23.
Learned advocate for the respondent submitted that the provisions
cannot be given a retrospective effect and have to be given a
prospective effect only.
REPORTABLE
24.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and considered the
documents on record.
25.
The interim order of this Hon'ble Court dated December 19, 2024,
by which the petitioner had been permitted to sit for the
examination, had granted the petitioner opportunity to take the
examination without creating any equity in his favour as specified in
the said interim order. The petitioner has taken the examination.
26.
Upon taking the examination, the petitioner had secured the
qualifying marks, which is also not in dispute. Whether or not these
qualifying marks are sufficient for the petitioner to enroll or be
appointed to the rank or post of Inspector is a completely different
matter.
27.
The claim of the petitioner has to be considered in the light of
applicable provisions, namely, Rule 99.2 and Rule 99.2A, of the said
Rules and Directive 60 issued by virtue of Office Memorandum
dated March 29, 2023. The culmination of the examination is the
Force Order No. 22 of 2025 dated February 27, 2025 and Force
Order No. 25 of 2025 dated March 3, 2025.
REPORTABLE
28.
To seek a complete annulment of these two Force Orders would
mean that all persons who were part of this issue would be severely
affected, irrespective of the fact that these persons may not have been
treated favourably by the authorities.
29.
None of these persons (24 in number) who have been promoted
have been made parties to the instant proceedings and have not been
given any opportunity of representing their case while the matter was
being heard. This is a choice exercised by the petitioner as the
dominus litus of this proceeding.
30.
The petitioner's case at best can be that these 24 persons are not
entitled to be promoted ahead of the petitioner only on these two
grounds:-
a.
they are junior to the petitioner;
b.
they have got the lower marks than the petitioner or they
have not got qualifying marks in the written examination,
on account whereof they are ineligible to be appointed to
the post of Inspector on promotion.
REPORTABLE
31.
The petitioner had not urged the second ground. The only ground
urged by the petitioner is that these persons, without specifying which
one of these 24 is junior to the petitioner, have all been granted
promotion.
32.
Interestingly, there is no date given in the Force Orders, which have
been challenged by way of this writ petition as to when any of these
24 persons had joined service. This has been retrieved by the court,
upon comparison with the list of September 12, 2024 appended to
the first writ petition.
33.
On careful consideration, it has been found that these 24 persons
who have made it to the merit list for promotion to the rank of
Inspectors are all appointees in the years 1992 to 1994 and are
hence senior to the petitioner. However, interestingly enough, these
24 persons were promoted to the rank of Sub-inspector sometime in
the year 2017.
34.
It has not been urged or argued by the petitioner in any manner that
the date of promotion to the post of Sub-inspector would be the date
of consideration for promotion and not the initial date of
REPORTABLE
appointment, which, in the case of these 24, is, as specified
hereinbefore, between the years 1992–1994.
35.
The provisions relating to Rule 99.2 and Rule 99.2A, as amended
and incorporated respectively, clearly keep the Sub-inspectors and
Inspectors beyond the realm of the bottom seniority rule while on
transfer from one zonal railway to another. A transfer from RPSF to
RPF would not deter or limit the petitioner or any other similarly
situated persons' right to be considered for the promotional post,
unless the same is specifically barred by law.
36.
It is in this perspective that Rule 99.2 and Rule 99.2A assume
importance as the definition of transfer from RPSF to RPF or vice
versa has been clarified in the Rule itself.
37.
The principal controversy between the parties concerns the
applicability of the amended Rule 99.2 and Rule 99.2A of the said
Rules to the petitioner's transfer from the Railway Protection Special
Force to the Railway Protection Force, Eastern Railway.
38.
The petitioner's original appointment in the RPSF was in the year
2015. However, the seniority-sequence which is the subject matter of
REPORTABLE
challenge did not arise in 2015. It arose upon his subsequent transfer
from the RPSF to the RPF/Eastern Railway, pursuant to the transfer
order dated 13th December 2023, which was given effect upon his
relieving RPSF on 10th June 2024 and joining RPF on 11th June
2024. The relevant event for determining the operation of a rule
regulating the consequence of a transfer is ordinarily the transfer to
which the rule is sought to be applied, not merely the date of original
recruitment. Therefore, the mere fact that the petitioner was initially
appointed in the year 2015 cannot, by itself, determine the rule
governing the seniority- sequence of a transfer which took place in
2023–2024.
39.
The respondents' contention that Rule 99.2A cannot apply to the
petitioner merely because he was recruited prior to its introduction
on July 20, 2021, therefore cannot be accepted. The application of
Rule 99.2A to the petitioner's case would not amount to giving
retrospective effect to the said provision. It would operate upon the
legal consequence of a subsequent transfer which took place after in
the case of the petitioner, the amended provision had already come
into force.
REPORTABLE
40.
The unamended Rule 99.2 dealt with transfers on own request or on
mutual exchange and expressly contemplated transfers from one
zonal railway to another as well as transfers to the Railway Protection
Special Force and vice-versa. Thus, the rule, in its unamended form,
covered both categories of transfer.
41.
The amended scheme is significant. The protection under Rule
99.2A was introduced in respect of the two ranks that of SubInspector
and
Inspector,
and
the
amended
Rule
99.2,
correspondingly, contains the qualification “except Sub-Inspectors or
Inspectors”. Thus, the effect of the amendment cannot be
considered by reading Rule 99.2A in isolation from the amended
Rule 99.2.
42.
The legislative scheme emerging from the amendment is that, while
Rule 99.2 continues to govern the general category of enrolled
members transferred on their own request or on mutual exchange,
Sub-Inspectors and Inspectors were carved out as an exception, from
the operation of the bottom-seniority consequence contained in Rule
99.2. The exclusion of these two ranks from Rule 99.2 is therefore of
considerable significance.
REPORTABLE
43.
It is true that Rule 99.2 explicitly refers to transfer “from one zonal
railway to another zonal railway” and does not separately use the
expression “from RPSF to RPF”. If the provision were to be read in
isolation, a transfer from RPSF-to-RPF would be beyond the ambit
of this provision.
44.
However, the Rules cannot be construed in isolated compartments.
The provisions have to be read harmoniously with the administrative
scheme governing transfer between RPSF and RPF, including
Directive 60.
45.
Rule 7.5 of the said Rules recognises that the enrolled members
constituting the Railway Protection Special Force form a separate
cadre for the purposes of fixation of seniority.
46.
This provision explains as to why, when a member of the RPSF is
transferred to the RPF of a zonal railway, the question of seniority
necessarily arises. The petitioner was initially appointed in the RPSF
cadre, and his seniority was consequently maintained within that
cadre. Upon transfer to Eastern Railway, RPF, he necessarily became
a member of the RPF cadre of the transferee railway. The existence
of separate cadres, therefore, cannot be disputed.
REPORTABLE
47.
But the fact that the RPSF constitutes a separate cadre for the
purpose of fixation of seniority does not, by itself, determine the
consequence of the petitioner's transfer. Though Rule 7.5 specifies
that RPSF and RPF constitute distinct cadres for seniority purposes;
it does not, by itself, answer the question as to what senioritysequence would be followed when a Sub-Inspector or Inspector
moves from one such cadre to the other after the amendment of
2021.
48.
This question has to be answered by reading Rule 7.5 together with
Rule 99.2, Rule 99.2A and the administrative directives governing
such transfer.
49.
The respondents have placed considerable reliance upon Directive
60. Paragraph 8 thereof provides that, for the purpose of transfer of
personnel from RPSF to RPF or vice-versa, the RPSF cadre shall be
treated at par with the executive cadre of a zonal Railway and that the
transfer shall be subject to Rules 91.2, 99.1, 99.2 and Row 5.1 of
Schedule II of the said Rules.
50.
It is true that Directive-60 does not expressly mention Rule 99.2A. It
is also true that the Directive specifically refers to Rule 99.2.
REPORTABLE
However, this omission cannot be construed as permitting the
continued application of the unamended Rule 99.2 to SubInspectors and Inspectors after the statutory amendment of July 20,
2021.
51.
The expression in Directive-60 that the RPSF cadre shall be treated
“at par with the executive cadre of a zonal Railway” is of significance.
The purpose of this deeming provision is to determine the legal
character of an RPSF-to-RPF or RPF-to-RPSF transferee for the
purpose of applying the transfer provisions. Thus, when the
Directive enunciates that RPSF is to be treated at par with the
executive cadre of a zonal Railway for such transfer, RPSF-to-RPF
transfer is to be understood, for the purposes of the transfer rules, as
falling within the same regulatory scheme as an inter-zonal transfer.
52.
Consequently, the expression in Rule 99.2A referring to transfer
“from one zonal railway to another zonal railway” has to be read in
consonance with Directive 60. If a restricted interpretation were to
be adopted, an anomalous consequence would follow: a SubInspector transferred from one zonal railway to another after July 20,
2021 would retain his seniority by virtue of Rule 99.2A, whereas the
same Sub-Inspector of the same Force, holding the same rank and
REPORTABLE
governed by the same RPF Rules, transferred from RPSF to RPF
after the amendment would lose his seniority under Rule 99.2,
merely because of the nomenclature of the two cadres.
53.
Such a construction would also render the amendment only partially
effective in respect of the very category of personnel for whom the
transfer framework treats RPSF as being on par with the executive
cadre of a zonal Railway.
54.
The harmonious construction, therefore, is that Directive-60
continues to govern the character and mechanism of a RPSF-to-RPF
transfer, but the substantive seniority consequence must be
determined with reference to the Rules as they stand on the date of
such transfer. Directive-60 cannot revive or preserve the operation of
the unamended Rule 99.2 as the said provision has subsequently
been altered by the rule-making authority.
55.
This conclusion is further reinforced by the textual change brought
about in Rule 99.2 itself. The unamended Rule 99.2 expressly
included transfers to the RPSF and vice-versa. After the introduction
of Rule 99.2A, the amended Rule 99.2 excludes Sub-Inspectors and
Inspectors from its operation. Therefore, the RPSF-to-RPF
REPORTABLE
component which existed in the unamended Rule 99.2 cannot be
invoked independently against a Sub-Inspector after the amendment.
56.
In other words, Rule 99.2A need not expressly repeat every category
of transfer which was earlier covered by Rule 99.2. The amendment
to Rule 99.2 itself, coupled with the introduction of Rule 99.2A,
indicates the legislative intent to keep Sub-Inspectors and Inspectors
outside the general bottom-seniority rule. Directive-60 then clarifies
the amended rule 99.2 by supplying the necessary link by treating
RPSF, for the limited purpose of transfer, on par with the executive
cadre of a zonal Railway.
57.
Thus, the provisions can be harmoniously construed in the following
manner: Rule 7.5 recognises the separate cadre character of RPSF;
Directive-60 treats RPSF on par with a zonal executive cadre for the
limited purpose of transfer; Rule 99.2A protects the seniority of SubInspectors and Inspectors in the class of transfers covered by the
transfer scheme; and the amended Rule 99.2 excludes those two
ranks from the general bottom-seniority consequence.
58.
Accordingly, the respondents cannot rely upon the reference to Rule
99.2 in Directive-60 to apply the unamended Rule 99.2 to the
REPORTABLE
petitioner, when the statutory rule itself stood amended before his
transfer. Directive-60 came into force in 2023, that is after Rule 99
had been amended. Thus, any reference in Directive-60 to Rule 99
has to be necessarily construed as reference to the amended Rule 99.
59.
The respondents have also relied upon Rule 27.1 to contend that
separate seniority lists are maintained for personnel belonging to
RPF and RPSF and that, consequently, the petitioner was required to
be removed from the RPSF seniority list and placed at the bottom of
the RPF seniority list upon transfer.
60.
The said submission, however, proceeds on a misconception as to
the effect of maintaining separate seniority lists.
61.
The maintenance of separate seniority lists for RPF and RPSF does
not, by itself, prescribe the consequence of an inter-cadre transfer of
a Sub-Inspector or Inspector. The provision relating to maintenance
of seniority lists and the provision regulating the effect of transfer
operate in different fields.
62.
Even assuming that, upon transfer, the petitioner's name was
required to be shifted from the relevant RPSF list to the relevant
REPORTABLE
RPF list, it does not follow that his accrued seniority in the rank was
extinguished. The question whether such seniority is to be retained
or forfeited has to be determined by the substantive provision
governing the transfer.
63.
The respondents' reliance upon Rule 27.1, therefore, cannot by itself
sustain the application of Rule 99.2 to the petitioner. Rule 27.1 deals
with the maintenance and compilation of seniority lists; it cannot be
treated as an independent source for imposing a bottom-seniority
consequence which is otherwise excluded by the amended Rule 99.2
read with Rule 99.2A.
64.
The distinction is important. A separate seniority list does not
necessarily mean a fresh seniority. The former concerns the way the
seniority of personnel is maintained administratively; the latter
concerns the substantive position of an employee in that seniority
upon transfer.
65.
The respondents have placed considerable reliance upon the
declaration dated 20th July 2023 executed by the petitioner,
contending that by such declaration the petitioner accepted the
condition of being placed at the bottom of the seniority list upon his
REPORTABLE
transfer from RPSF to RPF. The declaration undoubtedly records
the conditions communicated to the petitioner in connection with his
transfer. However, the legal effect of such declaration has to be
determined in the light of the statutory Rules governing the
petitioner’s service.
66.
In the present case, the declaration cannot operate to deprive the
petitioner of the seniority protection conferred by Rule 99.2A. The
statutory Rules governing seniority are binding upon both the
employee and the administration. An employee may undertake to
abide by the conditions of a transfer, but such an undertaking cannot
amount to a surrender of a statutory service benefit in a manner
contrary to the Rules, nor can it confer upon the respondents a
power to impose a consequence which the Rules, as applicable to the
petitioner, do not prescribe.
67.
The position becomes clearer from the amendment brought into
Rule 99.2 with effect from July 2021. By the amendment, SubInspectors and Inspectors were expressly excluded from the
operation of the general bottom-seniority provision contained in
Rule 99.2, while Rule 99.2A was simultaneously introduced to
provide that there shall be no change in the seniority of Sub-
REPORTABLE
Inspectors or Inspectors transferred on mutual exchange or on their
own request from one zonal Railway to another zonal Railway. Thus,
the statutory scheme itself makes a distinction between the general
rule governing other enrolled members and the specific seniority
protection applicable to Sub-Inspectors and Inspectors.
68.
The declaration dated 20th July 2023 cannot alter this statutory
position. The respondents cannot derive from the said declaration a
power to impose upon the petitioner a consequence which the
statutory Rules, as applicable on the date of his transfer, do not
prescribe. The Supreme Court has consistently held that the plea of
estoppel cannot be raised to defeat the provisions of a statute and
that a promise, declaration or undertaking contrary to law or beyond
the authority of the person making it cannot be enforced. Reference
may be made to Krishna Rai (Dead) Through Lrs& Ors. Versus
Banaras Hindu University Through Registrar & Ors [(2022) 8 SCC
713], Tata Chemicals Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Customs
(preventive), Jamnagar [(2015) 11 SCC 628] andAbhimeet Sinha and
others v. High Court of Judicature at Patna and others, [(2024) 7
SCC 262].
REPORTABLE
69.
The principle is equally applicable here. The petitioner's declaration
may establish that he was made aware of the condition sought to be
imposed upon his transfer; it cannot, however, confer upon the
respondents any authority which the statutory Rules do not confer,
nor can it revive the operation of the pre-amendment Rule 99.2 after
the statutory scheme had been altered. The declaration, therefore,
cannot be treated as a valid basis for depriving the petitioner of the
seniority protection available to him under Rule 99.2A.
70.
The consequence of the above finding is that the petitioner's
seniority could not have been determined by mechanically applying
the unamended Rule 99.2 merely because his original appointment
was in 2015 or because he had voluntarily sought transfer.
71.
The relevant transfer took place in 2023–2024, when the amended
statutory scheme was already in force. The respondents were,
therefore, required to determine the petitioner's seniority by applying
the amended Rules, read harmoniously with Directive-60 and the
separate cadre arrangement recognised under Rule 7.5.
72.
The petitioner had also served as Sub-Inspector and was promoted
as Inspector (ad hoc) in 2017. The respondents were consequently
REPORTABLE
required to consider his claim in accordance with the applicable
seniority and promotion provisions rather than treating the petitioner
as a fresh entrant at the bottom of the relevant rank solely by reason
of his transfer.
73.
At the same time, the petitioner's entitlement to consideration for
promotion cannot be equated with an automatic right to promotion.
Rule 71 provides the manner in which candidates qualifying in the
written examination are to be considered for assessment of their
service record and the preparation of the panel. Therefore, mere
success in the written examination does not confer an indefeasible
right to promotion.
74.
The petitioner obtained 49.62 marks out of 80 in the written
examination and thereby crossed the qualifying threshold applicable
to him. His qualification in the examination, however, does not by
itself establish an absolute entitlement to promotion, since the other
requirements of the promotion scheme, including assessment of
service record and preparation of the panel in accordance with the
prescribed seniority, are also required to be satisfied.
REPORTABLE
75.
Nevertheless, once it is found that the petitioner's seniority was liable
to be determined under the amended statutory scheme and could
not have been reduced by applying the unamended Rule 99.2, his
exclusion from consideration on the basis of such erroneous
seniority position cannot be sustained.
76.
In view of the aforestated discussions, the following conclusions are
ineluctable:-
a.
Though under Rule 7.5 of the said Rules, RPSF is
considered as a separate cadre, the same cannot be
equated with a right to exclude personnel from RPSF
from the statutory transfer framework as applicable to the
executive cadre of zonal railways.
b.
Directive 60 expressly provides that for the purpose of
transfer from RPSF to RPF or vice versa, the RPSF
personnel shall be treated at par with the executive cadre
of a zonal railway.
c.
The amended statutory scheme introduces a specific
provision, keeping the seniority of Sub-inspectors and
REPORTABLE
Inspectors under the amended Rule 99.2, outside the
scheme.
d.
Since these persons have been kept outside the scheme of
this altered provision of Rule 99.2, Directive 60 provides
the requisite clarification.
e.
Directive 60 (made on March 29, 2023) refers to the
amended Rule 99.2, to clarify that any transfer of
personnel from RPSF to RPF or vice versa is to be
treated, for the purpose of such transfer, at par with a
transfer involving the executive cadre of a zonal railway.
Directive 60 therefore provides the necessary link
between the separate cadre recognised under Rule 7.5
and the transfer provisions contained in Rule 99.2 (as
amended) and Rule 99.2A.
f.
Directive 60 and Rule 99.2A have to be read
harmoniously to uphold the pith and substance of the
entire legislation.
REPORTABLE
g.
The petitioner’s transfer having taken place in 2024, and
Rule 99.2A having come into force on July 20, 2021, Rule
99.2A is squarely applicable. There is no question of
retrospective applicability of the provision as being a
provision dealing with transfer, the same applies
prospectively on such event (the transfer) taking place.
Merely because the petitioner was appointed in 2015 it
cannot be said that the amendment relating to transfer, in
2021 will not apply to him, even though his transfer
occurred in 2024.
h.
Once the petitioner falls within the realm of the amended
Rule 99.2 and 99.2A, he cannot be subjected to the
“bottom of the seniority list” rule in the unamended Rule
99.2.
77.
In view of the aforestated findings, it is clear that the petitioner ought
to have been considered in the light of Directive 60 read with Rule
99.2 and 99.2A of the said Rules. Clearly, the transfer of the
petitioner falls within the inter-zonal transfer framework by virtue of
Directive 60 and the seniority sequence should be determined in
accordance with the amended Rule 99.2 read with Rule 99.2A.
REPORTABLE
78.
Since the seniority of the petitioner has been ascertained and fixed in
terms of the unamended Rule 99.2, his placement in the seniority list
published on July 17, 2024 and September 12, 2024 is set aside.
However, the list per se will remain as it is. It is only the seniority of
the petitioner reflected in such list which is set aside. However, since
the petitioner has already participated in the examination process
and secured the qualification marks, the petitioner’s right to obtain
promotion will be visited afresh by the authority in the light of Rule
99.2 and 99.2A of the said Rules as applicable to the petitioner.
Thus, WPA No. 29040 of 2024 is allowed to the aforesaid extent.
Since there is an interim order operating in favour of the petitioner
and a post of Inspector was directed to be kept vacant for the
petitioner, in the event he succeeds, the authorities are directed to
consider the petitioner’s candidature for promotion to the post of
Inspector (Executive) upon determination of his seniority position in
accordance with applicable rules.
79.
This order will, however, not in any manner give any vested right to
the petitioner to obtain promotion. For such purpose the respondent
authorities shall take into consideration all benchmark parameters
and criteria set forth by them including marks obtained by the
REPORTABLE
petitioner, the APAR and all other service records as may be
applicable.
80.
The Force Order No. 22 of 2025 dated February 27, 2025 and
Force Order No. 25 of 2025 dated March 3, 2025 will remain
unaltered. If the petitioner is found to be eligible, without insisting on
the bottom seniority rule, he shall be granted the promotion without
disturbing the two Force Orders or the persons who have been
promoted thereby.
81.
The writ petitions are accordingly disposed of.
82.
There shall, however, be no order as to costs.
83.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, shall
be granted to the parties as expeditiously as possible, upon
compliance of all formalities.
(Reetobroto Kumar Mitra, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review