Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Revisional Jurisdiction)
Dated: 10TH MAY, 2019
------------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAI KUMAR BIST, CJ.
------------------------------------------------------------------------C.R.P. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Chingtop Bhutia,
aged about 44 years,
S/o Sonam Nedup Bhutia,
R/o Arithang, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
…
Revisionist
Versus
1.
Shri Ran Bahadur Chettri,
aged about 51 years,
S/o Late Tika Ram Chettri,
R/o Upper Ralong, Luingsing Busty,
P.O. Ralong, South Sikkim.
2.
Shri Naina Singh Chettri,
aged about 38 years,
R/o Lower Jarrong Busty,
P.O. Ravangla, South Sikkim.
3.
Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Ravangla Sub-Division,
Ravangla, South Sikkim.
…
Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Jorgay Namka, Mr. Karma Sonam Lhendup, Ms.
Panila Theengh and Ms. Tashi Doma Sherpa,
Advocates for the petitioner.
None for respondents No. 1 and 2.
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate for
respondent No. 3.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Chief Justice
This revision has been preferred by the revisionist
under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for
short, “C.P.C.”) against the order dated 09.07.2018 passed by
the Civil Judge, Yangang Sub-Division, South Sikkim at Yangang,
by which an application filed by the revisionist under Order VII
Rule 11, C.P.C. has been rejected.
2.
In this matter, notice was issued to the respondents
on 21.08.2018.
The case was listed on 24.09.2018.
Registry
submitted its report stating that respondents no. 1 and 2 had been
duly served. Respondent no. 2 appeared in person before the Court
on that day, but none appeared for respondent no. 1. The Court again
directed to serve notice upon respondent no. 1 through the Process
Server of the Civil Court, South Sikkim.
In compliance to the said
order, learned District & Sessions Judge, South Sikkim sent a
communication to this Court informing that the notice was duly served
upon the respondent no. 1. The revision was heard and admitted and
was listed for final hearing on 19.11.2018. Inspite of service of notice,
none appeared for respondents no. 1 and 2. The matter was fixed for
ex-parte hearing and was heard ex-parte.
3.
Respondent no. 1/plaintiff instituted a Title Suit No. 01 of
2018 for declaration, confirmation
and recovery of possession,
mandatory injunction and other consequential reliefs along with an
application
under
Order
XXXIX,
Rules
and
C.P.C.
The
revisionist/defendant no. 1 filed written statement raising preliminary
objections and gave para-wise reply. The revisionist/defendant no. 1
also filed an application under Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C. for rejection
of the plaint. In his application, the revisionist/defendant no. 1 stated
that earlier in the year 2015 the plaintiff/respondent no. 1 had filed a
Title Suit No. 05 of 2015 seeking declaration, confirmation and
recovery of possession, mandatory injunction and other consequential
reliefs along with an application under Section XXXIX, Rules 1 and 2,
C.P.C. before the District Judge, South Sikkim at Namchi, and valued
his suit at Rs.12,20,000/-.
He also stated that the plaintiff/
respondent no. 1 had deliberately concealed this fact and on that
ground the application filed under Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C. needed to
be allowed and the case of the plaintiff/respondent no. 1 to be
dismissed. It is also stated that as per the plaintiff’s own admission,
pleadings and the documents filed by him, the cause of action arose in
the year 2013, and thus, the case of plaintiff is directly hit by the
provisions of Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C. and the title suit filed by him is
hopelessly barred by law of limitation. It is also stated that as per the
plaintiff’s own admission and pleadings, the suit is undervalued.
4.
The plaintiff in his reply stated that the earlier suit filed by
him was withdrawn on the ground of technical errors and the Court
was pleased to allow the withdrawal with liberty to file a fresh. As far
as cause of action is concerned, the plaintiff admitted the fact that the
cause of action arose in the year 2013 but denied that the suit is hit by
provisions of Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C.
Regarding valuation of the
suit, the plaintiff stated that even in the event that the suit is found to
be undervalued, the same cannot be dismissed rather the plaintiff is
required to be given a chance to rectify the valuation of the suit and
pay the requisite court fees.
5.
Learned Civil Judge after hearing the parties, rejected the
application filed by the revisionist/defendant no. 1 under Order VII,
Rule 11, C.P.C. in the following manner : -
“Heard and considered.
A perusal of the petition, documents and after hearing the
Ld. Counsel for the defendant No.1, it is seen that the defendant
No. 1 has sought for rejection of the plaint on two grounds. The
first being that it does not reveal any cause of action. This issue
has been correctly addressed by the Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff
wherein he has relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in AIR 2007 SC 1247 in which the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that a plaint cannot be rejected because it
does not reveal any cause of action. With respect to the second
ground of the suit being barred by limitation, it has been held by
the Hon’ble Courts of this country in the plethora of cases that
the question of limitation involved a mixed question of facts and
law and therefore, to decide this this Court is required to go
through the merits of the case.
Thus for the above reasons the petition of the defendant
No. 1 stands rejected.”
6.
The contention of learned counsel for the revisionist/
defendant no. 1 is that not only the pleadings made on oath by
the plaintiff in his two suits i.e. Title Suit No. 05 of 2015 and Title
Suit No. 01 of 2018, are similar but the reliefs sought therein are
also the same.
It is stated by him that the plaintiff for the
purpose of court fees and pecuniary jurisdiction had valued his
earlier suit i.e. Title Suit No. 05 of 2015 at Rs.12,20,000/- and
thereafter he for the same schedule land and reliefs sought, for
the purpose of court fees and pecuniary jurisdiction has valued
his second suit, i.e. Title Suit No. 01 of 2018 at Rs.500/- on
23.04.2018, without any supporting pleadings.
fee valued by him is insufficient.
Thus, the court
It is also contended by the
learned counsel for the revisionist/ defendant no. 1 that as per
the plaintiff’s own admission, pleadings and documents filed by
him, the cause of action arose in the year 2013, which are
directly hit by the provisions of Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C., hence
the Title Suit filed by the plaintiff is barred by limitation.
7.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel
for the revisionist/ defendant no. 1.
8.
Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C. deals about the rejection of
plaint. The same is reproduced below: “11. Rejection of plaint - The plaint shall be rejected
in the following cases:(a) where it does not disclose a cause of action;
(b) where the relief claimed is undervalued, and the
plaintiff, on being required by the Court to correct the
valuation within a time to be fixed by the Court, fails to
do so;
(c) where the relief claimed is properly valued but the
plaint is written upon paper insufficiently stamped, and
the plaintiff, on being required by the Court to supply
the requisite stamp-paper within a time to be fixed by
the Court, fails to do so;
(d) where the suit appears from the statement in the
plaint to be barred by any law;
(e) where it is not filed in duplicate;
(f) where the plaintiff fails to comply with the provisions
of rule 9:
Provided that the time fixed by the Court for the
correction of the valuation or supplying of the requisite stamppaper shall not be extended unless the Court, for reasons to be
recorded, is satisfied that the plaintiff was prevented by any
cause of an exceptional nature for correcting the valuation or
supplying the requisite stamp-paper, as the case may be,
within the time fixed by the Court and that refusal to extend
such time would cause grave injustice to the plaintiff.”
9.
From the bare reading of Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C., it
is clear that where the plaint does not disclose a cause of action,
the relief claimed is undervalued, and not corrected within the
time allowed by the Court, insufficiently stamped and not
rectified within the time given by the Court, barred by any law,
failed to enclose the required copies and failed to comply with the
provisions of Rule 9, the Court shall reject the plaint. It is, thus,
clear that in such situation the Court has no other option except
to reject the plaint. The power of the Court under Order VII Rule
11 of the Code can be exercised at any stage of the suit either
before registering the plaint or after the issuance of summons to
the defendants or at any time before the conclusion of the trial,
as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Saleem
Bhai v. State of Maharashtra and others : (2003) 1 SCC 557.
The relevant facts which need to be looked into for deciding an
application under Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C. are the averments in
the plaint.
10.
In A.B.C. Laminart (P) Ltd. v. A.P. Agencies, Salem,
(1989) 2 SCC 163, the Hon’ble Supreme Court explained the
meaning of “cause of action” in the following manner:
“12. A cause of action means every fact,
which if traversed, it would be necessary for the
plaintiff to prove in order to support his right to a
judgment of the court. In other words, it is a
bundle of facts which taken with the law applicable
to them gives the plaintiff a right to relief against
the defendant. It must include some act done by
the defendant since in the absence of such an act
no cause of action can possibly accrue. It is not
limited to the actual infringement of the right sued
on but includes all the material facts on which it is
founded. It does not comprise evidence necessary
to prove such facts, but every fact necessary for
the plaintiff to prove to enable him to obtain a
decree. Everything which if not proved would give
the defendant a right to immediate judgment must
be part of the cause of action. But it has no relation
whatever to the defence which may be set up by
the defendant nor does it depend upon the
character of the relief prayed for by the plaintiff.”
11.
In Fatehji & Company & another v. L.M. Nagpal and
others : AIR 2015 SC 2301, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
considered the case relating to Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C. Few
paragraphs of the judgment are reproduced below: “4. Defendants 1 to 3 filed an application under Order VII
Rule 11, CPC on 10.10.1996 seeking for rejection of the
plaint as barred by the law of limitation. The trial court
after hearing both sides by a speaking order held that the
suit is patently barred by the law of limitation and allowed
the application by rejecting the plaint. The plaintiffs
preferred appeal in RFA No. 350 of 1997 and the High
Court by the impugned judgment allowed the appeal by
setting aside the order of the Trial Court and restored the
suit to file. Aggrieved by the same the defendants have
preferred the present appeal. For the sake of
convenience, the parties are hereinafter referred to as
they were arrayed in this suit.
x
x
x
8. Yet another circumstance was pointed out to prove the
laches on the part of the plaintiffs. The sons of the second
defendant filed a suit in July 1985 against defendants 2, 3
and the plaintiffs seeking for declaration that the present
suit property is their ancestral joint family property and
the sale made by the defendants in favour of the plaintiffs
be declared as null and void. The plaintiffs herein
contested the said suit and it came to be dismissed on
5.4.1989. The suit for specific performance was not filed
within three years from the said date also.
9. The plaintiffs averred in the plaint that the last and
final cause of action accrued and arose to them after
August, 1991 when the defendants succeeded in hiding
themselves and started avoiding the plaintiffs and the
cause of action being recurring and continuous one, they
filed the suit on 29.4.1994. As already seen the original
cause of action became available to the plaintiffs on
2.12.1973, the date fixed for the performance of the
contract and thereafter the same stood extended till
1.2.1977 as requested by the defendants. Though the
plaintiffs claimed that oral extension of time was given,
no particulars as to when and how long, were not
mentioned in the plaint. On the other hand even after
knowing the dishonest intention of the sons of the second
defendant with regard to the suit property in the year
1985, the plaintiffs did not file the suit immediately. The
suit having been filed in the year 1994 is barred by
limitation under Article 54 of the Limitation Act.
10. We are of the view that the High Court committed
manifest error in reversing the well-considered order of
the trial court rejecting the plaint as barred by the law of
limitation and the impugned judgment is liable to be set
aside. In the result, the appeal is allowed and the
impugned judgment of the High Court is set aside and the
order of the trial court is restored. No costs.”
12.
In Hardesh Ores Pvt. Ltd. v. M/s Hede and Co. : 2007
AIR SCW 3456, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under: “21. The language of Order VII, Rule 11, CPC is quite
clear and unambiguous. The plaint can be rejected on the
ground of limitation only where the suit appears from the
statement in the plaint to be barred by any law. Mr.
Nariman did not dispute that “law” within the meaning of
clause (d) of Order VII, Rule 11 must include the law of
limitation as well. It is well settled that whether a plaint
discloses a cause of action is essentially a question of
fact, but whether it does or does not must be found out
from reading the plaint itself. For the said purpose the
averments made in the plaint in their entirety must be
held to be correct. The test is whether the averments
made in the plaint, if taken to be correct in their entirety,
a decree would be passed. The averments made in the
plaint as a whole have to be seen to find out whether
clause (d) of Rule 11 of Order VII is applicable. It is not
permissible to cull out a sentence or a passage and to
read it out of the context in isolation. Although it is the
substance and not merely the form that has to be looked
into, the pleading has to be construed as it stands without
addition or subtraction of words or change of its apparent
grammatical sense. As observed earlier, the language of
clause (d) is quite clear but if any authority is required,
one may usefully refer to the judgments of this Court in
Liverpool & London S.P. & I Assn. Ltd. v. M.V. Sea
Success I and another : (2004) 9 SCC 512 and Popat and
Kotecha Property v. State Bank of India Staff Association
: (2005) 7 SCC 510.
x
x
x
34. We are, therefore, satisfied that the Trial Court as
well as the High Court were justified in holding that the
plaint deserved to be rejected under Order VII, Rule 11,
CPC since the suit appeared from the statements in the
plaint to be barred by the law of limitation. We, therefore,
find no merit in these appeals and the same are
accordingly dismissed. No order as to costs.”
13.
In Church of North India v. Lavajibhai Ratanjibhai and
others : (2005) 10 SCC 760, the Hon’ble Apex Court held as
under: “39. A plea of bar to jurisdiction of a civil court must be
considered having regard to the contentions raised in the
plaint. For the said purpose, averments disclosing cause
of action and the reliefs sought for therein must be
considered in their entirety. The court may not be
justified in determining the question, one way or the
other, only having regard to the reliefs claimed dehors
the factual averments made in the plaint. The rules of
pleadings postulate that a plaint must contain material
facts. When the plaint read as a whole does not disclose
material facts giving rise to a cause of action which can
be entertained by a civil court, it may be rejected in
terms of Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure”.
14.
While deciding the application under Order VII, Rule
11, C.P.C., the Court is required to go through the plaint. The
plaint must contain material facts.
When the plaint does not
disclose material facts giving rise to a cause of action, the
application moved under Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C. deserves to
be allowed. In the present case, it appears that the learned Civil
Judge did not go through the contents of the plaint and rejected
the application filed under Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C. by simply
referring a judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Prem Lala
Nahata & Anr. Vs. Chandi Prasad Sikaria : AIR 2007 SC 1247. It
appears that the learned Civil Judge understood the judgment of
Hon’ble Apex Court that the plaint cannot be rejected even if the
same does not reveal any cause of action. In fact, legal position
is not like this. The facts of the case in the matter of Prem Lala
Nahata (supra) were entirely different.
In that case, suit was
filed by the appellants for recovery of sum allegedly due to them.
In that matter respondent had also filed two suits for recovery of
sum allegedly due from the appellants. The said two suits were
pending in the Civil Court. The appellants moved on the original
side of the Calcutta High Court seeking withdrawal of two money
suits to be tried with another suit on the plea that common
questions of fact and law arise in the suits and it would be in the
interests of justice to try and dispose of the three suits together.
The High Court took the view that it would be appropriate in the
interest of justice to transfer the two suits pending in the Civil
Court to the original side of the High Court for being tried and
disposed of along with the suit pending in the High Court. In this
background the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that an
objection of misjoinder of plaintiffs or misjoinder of causes of
action, is a procedural objection and it is not a bar to the
entertaining of the suit or the trial and final disposal of the suit.
The Supreme Court further observed that it is open to the Court
to proceed with the suit notwithstanding the defect of misjoinder
of parties or misjoinder of causes of action.
But facts in the
present case are different. The learned Civil Judge without going
through the facts mentioned in the plaint simply held that the
plaint cannot be rejected because it does not reveal any cause of
action.
This finding of the learned Civil Judge is not correct.
Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C. clearly provides that where the plaint
does not disclose a cause of action, the same shall be rejected.
15.
I have gone through the plaint filed by the respondent
no. 1/plaintiff.
Pleadings do not support the reliefs. Lack cause
of action. Even if the facts mentioned in the plaint are taken to
be correct in their totality, in my view, the same are not
sufficient to decree the suit.
16.
On the question of limitation also the learned Civil
Judge simply observed that the Hon’ble Courts of this country in
plethora of cases held that the question of limitation involved a
mixed question of facts and law and therefore, to decide this, the
Court is required to go through the merits of the case.
The
learned Civil Judge failed to appreciate that according to the
plaintiff himself the cause of action arose in the year 2013.
In
paragraph 33 of the plaint, the plaintiff has stated that the cause
of action arose in the year 2013.
Suit in question has been
instituted in the year 2018. The suit is barred by limitation and
as such is hit by provisions of Order VII, Rule 11 of C.P.C.
17.
is allowed.
In view of the above discussion, the Revision Petition
Order dated 09.07.2018 passed by the learned Civil
Judge, Yangyang Sub-Division, South Sikkim at Yangang in Title
Suit Case No. 01 of 2018 (Shri Ran Bahadur Chettri vs. Shri
Chintup Bhutia & Ors.) is set aside.
The application moved by
revisionist/ defendant no. 1 under Order VII, Rule 11, C.P.C. is
allowed. Plaint filed by the plaintiff is rejected.
Chief Justice
10.05.2019
Index: Yes
Internet: Yes
jk/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review