The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. It is well settled that while interpreting any beneficial law, if two views are possible, such view as would benefit the employees ought to be preferred. Therefore, in the absence of a specific provision under Rule 6 (A) that it would apply only to confirmed or permanent work-charged employees as introduced on 21.6.1990, on the basis of which the first respondent has claimed the benefit of pension/family pension and in the light of the liberal interpretation given to Rule 6(B) by the Division Bench of Gauhati High Court in WA No.29 of 2009 dated 12.8.2010, we are of the considered view that the newly added Rule 6 (A) on 21.6.1990 as it stood, cannot be confined to WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR only the permanent or confirmed employees as contended by the appellants and can be made applicable to non-permanent or non-confirmed work-charged employees also. That apart, the work-charged employees of the first respondent organization are similarly situated persons of the work-charged employee in WA No.29 of 2009, dated 12.8.2010. Applying the said decision pronounced in WA No.29 of 2009, the learned Single Judge has rightly allowed the writ petition. We do not find any infirmity in the order of the learned Single Judge and the present writ appeal fails.” [7] Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that in view of the…
11. 01.1999, the husband of the petitioner and others were converted to work-charged staff from Muster Roll/Casual as one time policy and the so converted work-charged posts shall WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR stand automatically abolished as and when the concerned incumbents retire from service on superannuation or on termination from their service as the case may be. It is further stated that Rule 6 of the Terminal Benefits Rules, 1978 provides that only permanent worked-charged employee who has put 30 years of service as permanent, is entitled to terminal benefits. It is pointed out that the husband of the petitioner was not confirmed against any permanent post in terms of Office Memorandum dated 22.01.2001 issued by Finance Department (Pay Implementation Cell), Govt. of Manipur. It is submitted that the relied decisions are not precedent, as the OM dated 22.01.2001 was not considered in those judgments. It is prayed that the writ petition may be dismissed. [9] Mr. S. Suresh, learned counsel for respondent No.3 submits that the office of the Principal Accountant General, Manipur is the field office of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India with respect to functions such as GPF, Pension and Gazetted entitlement in Manipur. However, the administrative authority and power are vested with the competent authorities of the State Government. …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.951 of 2022
Smt Chingangbam Pateshori Devi
aged about 50 years, w/o (L)
Chingangbam Nobin Singh, resident of
Lamdeng Mayai Leikai, PO & PS
Lamsang, District Imphal West,
Manipur 795146.
… Petitioner
-Versus1. The State of Manipur through the
Additional Chief Secretary/Principal Secretary/
Commissioner, (PHED) Government of Manipur,
New Secretariat building, PO & PS Imphal West
District, Manipur 795001.
2. The Chief Engineer, PHED, Government of
Manipur, Khuyathong, PO & PS Imphal, Imphal
West, Manipur 795001.
3. The Accountant General (A & E), Manipur,
Babupara, PO & PS, Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur.
… Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A.GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, Sr.Adv. &
Ms. Nirmala, Advocate
For the Respondents:
Mrs. Ch. Sundari, GA
Mr. S. Suresh, Advocate
Date of Hearing:
05.10.2023.
Date of Judgment:
05.02.2024
WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR
JUDGMENT AND ORDER [CAV]
[1]
Heard Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel
assisted by Ms. Nirmala, learned counsel for the petitioner,
Mrs. Ch. Sundari, learned Government Advocate for the State
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 and Mr. S. Suresh, learned counsel
for respondent No.3, Principal Accountant General, Manipur.
[2]
The
petitioner
herein,
Smt.
Chingangbam
Pateshori Devi, is the widow of late Chingangbam Nobin Singh,
who was serving as Work-Charged Technical Jugali in the
Public Health Engineering Department (PHED), Government of
Manipur, who died while in service on 20.05.2018 leaving
behind the petitioner and her children.
[3]
The petitioner approached this Court by way of
the present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, inter alia, praying for giving direction to the respondents
to release family pension and other retirement benefits with
respect to her deceased husband.
The prayer in the writ petition is reproduced
hereunder:
“(i) call for the records of the case and issue
rule nisi calling upon the respondents to show
cause as to why the prayer prayed for by the
WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR
petitioner shall not be granted and after hearing
them make the rule absolute.
(ii)
issue a writ of mandamus by directing the
respondents to release the family pension and
other retirement benefits of the petitioner for the
service rendered by her husband as Work Charged
Technical Jugali in the PHED, Manipur within a
stipulated period.
(iii) pass
any
other
appropriate
writ/order/direction that this Hon’ble Court deems
fit and proper.”
[4]
It is the case of the petitioner that vide letter
dated 04.10.2013 written by the Special Officer, Directorate of
Management of Information System (MIS, in short) to the Chief
Engineer, PHED, Government of Manipur, furnished the list of
Work-Charged Employees of the office of the Executive
Engineer Drainage & Sewage Division of PHED, for verification
and the name of petitioner’s husband, Ch. Nobin Singh was
shown at Sl.No.4 with Specific Identification Number (SIN)
00797.
Vide another letter dated 5.12.2016, the Special
Officer, Directorate of MIS, further informed the Chief
Engineer, PHED, Government of Manipur that up-dation of
Work Charged Employees in the CPIS was completed and
name of the petitioner’s husband was shown at Sl.No.4. The
Executive Engineer, Drainage and Sewerage Division, PHED,
Manipur issued Pay Certificate dated 24.07.2017 of working as
WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR
Technical Jugali to the husband of the petitioner. The husband
of the petitioner, Ch. Nobin Singh expired on 20.05.2018 as
per Death Certificate issued by the Lamsang Nagar Panchayat,
Lamsang, dated 26.05.2018.
[5]
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel
submits that the case of the petitioner is covered by Judgment
and Order dated 10.08.2016 passed by a Single Judge of this
Court in WP(C) No. 369 of 2015, whereby interpreting the
provisions of Rules 6A & 6B of “Terminal Benefits for WorkCharged
Staffs
of
PWD/IFCD/PHED/MI
and
Electricity
(Manipur) Rules, 1978” (as amended) to the effect that
terminal benefits are entitled to both permanent and nonpermanent
work-charged
employees
and
their
family
members. In arriving the said finding, reliance was placed on
a decision of the Division Bench of the then Gauhati High Court,
Imphal Bench (now High Court of Manipur) dated 12.08.2010
passed in WA No.29 of 2009. Para 5 of the order dated
10.08.2026 in WP(C) No. 369 of 2015 is reproduced below for
easy reference.
“[5] It may be true that initially the Terminal
Benefits Rules, 1978 were contemplated to
provide terminal benefits only to the permanent
benefits only to the permanent work-charged staff
WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR
and there was no provision for grant of family
pension. But by way of an amendment vide
Notification dated 21.06.1990, Rule 6A was added
wherein it is provided that family pension is
admissible to the family members of the workcharged employees. Further amendment came to
be made vide Notification dated 06.06.1991
adding Rule 6B which provides that terminal
benefit is admissible to the work-charged
employees who retired prior to 16.09.1978 but are
living on the date of issue of the order and family
pension to the family members of the workcharged employee who died prior to 21.06.1990
provided the family members are living on the
date of issue of the order. From the conjoint
reading of the said Rule 6A and 6B, it is evident
that family pension is admissible to the family
members of all the work-charged employees who
had died and it is nowhere provided therein that
the terminal benefits shall be granted to the
permanent work-charged employees only or the
members of its family.”
[6]
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel has
pointed out that the afore-said findings of the Single Judge in
judgment dated 10.08.2026 in WP(C) No. 369 of 2015 was
upheld by a Division Bench of this Court vide judgment dated
03.05.2023 in WA No.48 of 2018. Relevant para are
reproduced below:
“20. While allowing the writ petition filed by the
first respondent, the learned Single Judge has
followed the judgment of the Division Bench of the
Gauhati High Court, Imphal Bench in WA No.29 of
2009 dated 12.08.2010, wherein a similar issue
was dealt with and held that for grant of family
pension, the confirmation of service is not
WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR
necessary and in case the confirmation of service
is required for it, the authority may do so by
passing appropriate orders as had been done in
many cases in the past. In WA No.29 of 2009, the
Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court further
held that the confirmation of service or
permanence in service by issuance of specific
order is always an uncertainty and in normal
circumstances, an employee after rendering a
particular length of service is entitled to get his
service confirmed or permanent. The Division
Bench of Gauhati High Court interpreted Rule 6(B)
by holding that to get the benefit of the newly
added Rule 6 (B), the work-charged employees
need not be confirmed or permanent. Nothing has
been produced by the appellants to show that the
judgment of the Division Bench of Gauhati High
Court in WA No.29 of 2009 dated 12.08.2010 has
been reversed by the Superior Court.
21. As stated supra, the original Terminal
Benefits Rules framed in 1978 had undergone
many amendments referred to above. The
Terminal Benefit Rules, 1978 have been framed to
give certain benefits to the employees belonging
to work-charged employees and not to regular
employees. Thus, the aforesaid Rules are meant
to be beneficial to the work-charged employees.
22. It is well settled that while interpreting any
beneficial law, if two views are possible, such view
as would benefit the employees ought to be
preferred. Therefore, in the absence of a specific
provision under Rule 6 (A) that it would apply only
to confirmed or permanent work-charged
employees as introduced on 21.6.1990, on the
basis of which the first respondent has claimed the
benefit of pension/family pension and in the light
of the liberal interpretation given to Rule 6(B) by
the Division Bench of Gauhati High Court in WA
No.29 of 2009 dated 12.8.2010, we are of the
considered view that the newly added Rule 6 (A)
on 21.6.1990 as it stood, cannot be confined to
WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR
only the permanent or confirmed employees as
contended by the appellants and can be made
applicable to non-permanent or non-confirmed
work-charged employees also. That apart, the
work-charged employees of the first respondent
organization are similarly situated persons of the
work-charged employee in WA No.29 of 2009,
dated 12.8.2010. Applying the said decision
pronounced in WA No.29 of 2009, the learned
Single Judge has rightly allowed the writ petition.
We do not find any infirmity in the order of the
learned Single Judge and the present writ appeal
fails.”
[7]
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel for
the petitioner submits that in view of the settled proposition of
law with regards to Terminal Benefits Rules, 1978 (as
amended), the petitioner who is widow of a work-charged
employee of the respondent is entitled to the family pension
and other terminal benefits as mandated by Rules 6A & 6B. It
is accordingly prayed that necessary directions be issued to the
respondents for the terminal benefits and family pension.
[8]
Mrs. Ch. Sundari, learned GA for State Respondent
Nos. 1 & 2 submits that the above decisions cited by the
learned senior counsel for the petitioner are not applicable to
the fact of the present case. It is stated that vide order dated
11.01.1999, the husband of the petitioner and others were
converted to work-charged staff from Muster Roll/Casual as
one time policy and the so converted work-charged posts shall
WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR
stand automatically abolished as and when the concerned
incumbents retire from service on superannuation or on
termination from their service as the case may be. It is further
stated that Rule 6 of the Terminal Benefits Rules, 1978
provides that only permanent worked-charged employee who
has put 30 years of service as permanent, is entitled to terminal
benefits. It is pointed out that the husband of the petitioner
was not confirmed against any permanent post in terms of
Office Memorandum dated 22.01.2001 issued by Finance
Department (Pay Implementation Cell), Govt. of Manipur. It is
submitted that the relied decisions are not precedent, as the
OM dated 22.01.2001 was not considered in those judgments.
It is prayed that the writ petition may be dismissed.
[9]
Mr. S. Suresh, learned counsel for respondent
No.3 submits that the office of the Principal Accountant
General, Manipur is the field office of the Comptroller and
Auditor General of India with respect to functions such as GPF,
Pension and Gazetted entitlement in Manipur. However, the
administrative authority and power are vested with the
competent authorities of the State Government. It is only after
the State Government issues a specific order relaxing the
Rules/Instructions as the case may be, the Principal
WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR
Accountant General can implement such decisions/orders. It is
further clarified that until the family pension and other related
necessary documents in respect of late Ch. Nobin Singh ExW/C Jugali are received from the Administrative Department,
no action is pending on the part of Respondent No.3.
[10]
This Court has considered the rival submissions
made at bar, the pleadings of the parties and the settled
propositions of law in this regard. From the above cited
decisions, it is quite clear that on joint reading of Rules 6A &
6B of “Terminal Benefits for Work-Charged Staffs of
PWD/IFCD/PHED/MI and Electricity (Manipur) Rules, 1978” (as
amended), the terminal benefits are entitled to both
permanent and non-permanent work-charged employees and
their family members. It has been held that there is no
difference between the permanent and non-permanent workcharged employees for availing terminal benefits including
family pension. The Rules of 1978 does not specify any
requirement of confirmation to avail terminal benefit. This
Court does not find any force in the submission of Mrs. Ch.
Sundari, learned GA to the fact that the earlier decisions are
not precent, as the OM dated 22.01.2001 for confirmation of
WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR
work-charged employees was not considered in those
decisions.
[11]
In view of the above discussions and observations,
the present writ petition is allowed. The respondents are
directed to take steps for releasing service pension and other
retirement benefits to the petitioner in terms of Rules 6A & 6B
of
“Terminal
Benefits
for
Work-Charged
Staffs
of
PWD/IFCD/PHED/MI and Electricity (Manipur) Rules, 1978” (as
amended). The admirative department is directed to complete
the process of necessary papers within a period of 2 (two)
months from the date of receipt of copy of this order and
Principal Accountant General, Manipur shall issue necessary
authority within a period of 1 (one) month from the date of
receipt of necessary documents from the administrative
department. No cost.
[12]
Send a copy of this order to the respondents for
information and necessary compliance.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Priyojit
WP(C) NO. 951 OF 2022: SMT. CH. PATESHORI DEVI V/S STATE OF MANIPUR
signed
RAJKUMA Digitally
by RAJKUMAR
PRIYOJIT
SINGH
R PRIYOJIT
Date: 2024.02.06
SINGH
13:40:27 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review