Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:34620
913.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
913 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2552 OF 2019
The State of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Dhawalabai Rawaji Khadke And Another
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2907 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12578 OF 2021 IN FA/2907/2021
Ganga Raghu Khadke And Ors
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Thr Collector, Ahmednagar And Ors
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2554 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Nawasu Deu Songal
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2555 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Laxman Deu Khadke And Another
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2553 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Dhawala Kanalu Kevari Lrs Soma And Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2560 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Gangubai Rama Khadkethr Lrs Vithabai And Others
….
WITH
913.odt
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2908 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12589 OF 2021 IN FA/2908/2021
Pandu Raghu Wagh And Ors.
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Thr Collector, Ahmednagar And Ors.
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2558 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Govinda Rama Khadke
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2557 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Vithabai Laxman Gangad
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2562 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Rahibai Laxman Khadke
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2895 OF 2021
Dhawala Kamalu Kevari (deceased) Thr Lrs. Soma Dhawala
Kevari And Others
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Through Collector, Ahmednagar And
Others
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2896 OF 2021
Barku Rama Songal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Through Collector, Ahmednagar &
Others
…..
WITH
913.odt
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2897 OF 2021
Govinda Rama Khadke
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Through Collector, Ahmednagar And
Others
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2898 OF 2021
Gangubai Khema Pokale
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Thr Collector, Ahmednagar And Ors
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2899 OF 2021
Vithabai Laxman Gangad
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Through Collector, Ahmednagar And
Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2900 OF 2021
Gangubai Rama Khadke (deceased), Thr Lrs. Vithabai And Others
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Through Collector, Ahmednagar And
Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2901 OF 2021
Rahibai Laxman Khadke
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Through Collector, Ahmednagar And
Others
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2902 OF 2021
Tukaram Chima Pokale And Others
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Through Collector, Ahmednagar And
Others
….
913.odt
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2903 OF 2021
Laxman Deu Khadke And Another
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Through Collector, Ahmednagar And
Others
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2904 OF 2021
Dhawalabai Rawaji Khadke And Anr
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Thr Collector, Ahmednagar And Ors
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2906 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12576 OF 2021
IN FA/2906/2021
Parvatabai Kusa Gudnar (died) Thr Lrs Bhagwan And Ors
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Thr Collector, Ahmednagar And Ors
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2563 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Tukaram Chima Pokale And Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2909 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12593 OF 2021 IN FA/2909/2021
Deoji Rama Khadke (died) Thr Lrs Thaka And Ors
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Thr Collector, Ahmednagar And Ors
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2910 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12591 OF 2021 IN FA/2910/2021
913.odt
Rama Bhiva Pokale (died) Thr Lrs Laxman And Ors
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Thr Collector, Ahmednagar And Ors
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2911 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12586 OF 2021 IN FA/2911/2021
Chima Kusa Nirgude And Ors
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Thr Collector, Ahmednagar And Ors.
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2913 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12579 OF 2021 IN FA/2913/2021
Ramchandra Savleram Khadke (died) Thr Lrs. Mahesh (died)
Damu And Ors
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra Thr Collector, Ahmednagar And Ors
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2561 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Pandu Bhoru Khadke And Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2556 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Gangubai Khema Pokale
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2559 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Barku Rama Songal
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2641 OF 2021
913.odt
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7788 OF 2013 IN FA/2641/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11975 OF 2024 IN FA/2641/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Ganga Raghu Khadke And Others
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2642 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7812 OF 2013 IN FA/2642/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11984 OF 2024 IN FA/2642/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Pandu Raghu Wagh And Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2643 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7792 OF 2013 IN FA/2643/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11981 OF 2024 IN FA/2643/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Kawaji Rawaji Songal And Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2644 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7782 OF 2013 IN FA/2644/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11942 OF 2024 IN FA/2644/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Sakhubai Mahadu Bartad And Another
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2645 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7817 OF 2013 IN FA/2645/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11985 OF 2024 IN FA/2645/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
913.odt
Parvatabai Kusa Gudnar And Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2648 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7772 OF 2013 IN FA/2648/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11943 OF 2024 IN FA/2648/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Kusa Ganga Pokale And Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2649 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7810 OF 2013 IN FA/2649/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11976 OF 2024 IN FA/2649/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Chima Kusa Nirgude And Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2650 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11950 OF 2024 IN FA/2650/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7778 OF 2024 IN FA/2650/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Ramchandra Savleram Khadke And Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2651 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11974 OF 2024 IN FA/2651/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7776 OF 2013 IN FA/2651/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Rama Bhiva Pokale And Another
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2640 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
913.odt
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7768 OF 2013 IN FA/2640/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11983 OF 2024 IN FA/2640/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Vitthal Alu Pokale And Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2646 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7806 OF 2013 IN FA/2646/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11980 OF 2024 IN FA/2646/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Deoji Rama Khadke
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2647 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7774 OF 2013 IN FA/2647/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11977 OF 2024 IN FA/2647/2021
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Mahadu Rama Pokale And Another
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2561 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Pandu Bhoru Khadke and Ors.
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2555 OF 2019
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Laxman Deu Khadke and Ors.
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2905 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.12596 OF 2021 IN FA/2905/2021
913.odt
Kusa Ganga and Ors.
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
….
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2912 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.12583 OF 2021 IN FA/2912/2021
Mahadu Rama Pokale and Ors.
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
….
FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 32748 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.13942 OF 2021 IN FAST/32748/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.13943 OF 2021 IN FAST/32748/2021
Pandu Bhoru Khadke and Ors.
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
…..
FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 33084 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.13948 OF 2021 IN FAST/33084/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.13949 OF 2021 IN FAST/33084/2021
Vitthal Alu Pokale and Ors.
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
….
FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 33088 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.13946 OF 2021 IN FAST/33088/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.13947 OF 2021 IN FAST/33088/2021
Sakhubai Bartad and Ors.
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
….
FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 33081 OF 2021
ALONG WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.13944 OF 2021 IN FAST/33081/2021
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.13945 OF 2021 IN FAST/33081/2021
913.odt
Kawaji Rawaji Songal and Ors.
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
______________________________________________________________
Appearance in all Appeals
Mr. S. M. Ganachari, AGP for the Appellants – State in Appeals by
State
Mr. G. B. Rajale h/f Mr. R. K. Temkar, Advocate for the respective
Respondents / Claimants in Appeals by Claimants
______________________________________________________________
CORAM :
NEERAJ P. DHOTE, J.
DATE
06.08.2026
:
COMMON ORDER :
1.
Not on Board. Upon mentioning, First Appeal Nos.2561/2019
and 2555/2019 by the State and First Appeal Nos.2905/2021,
2912/2021 as well as First Appeal (Stamp) Nos.32748/2021,
33084/2021, 33088/2021 and 33081/2021 by the Claimants are
taken on Board, as the connected Appeals are listed.
2.
Since the Appeals by the State and by the Claimants are
against one and the same common Judgment dated 27.02.2012,
passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Sangamner, in
a group of Land Acquisition Reference Applications (LARs),
common evidence is led by the Claimants before the learned
Reference Court and common submissions are advanced, they are
decided by this common order.
3.
The following Chart gives the necessary details in respect of
the acquired lands : -
913.odt
Sr.
No.
1.
First
Appeals
by State
2552/2019
First
Appeals by
Claimants
2904/2021
[Phawalabai
Khadke &
Ors.]
L.A.R.
No.
Area
Rate granted
by the SLO
Rate granted by the
Reference Court
78/2002
1 H. 50
R.
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
2898/2021
[Gangubai
Khema
Pokale]
80/2002
22.9 R.
2563/2019
2902/2021
[Tukaram C.
Pokale]
82/2002
1 H. 56
R.
4.
2562/2019
2901/2021
[Rahibai L.
Khadke]
83/2002
99.9 R.
5.
2561/2019
F.A. St.
No.32748/2
[Pandu
Bhoru
Khadke]
84/2002
4 H. 52
R.
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
2.
2556/2019
3.
6.
2555/2019
2903/2021
[Laxman
Deu
Khadke]
85/2002
38.5 R.
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
7.
2558/2019
2897/2021
[Govinda
Rama
Khadke]
87/2002
24 R.
8.
2559/2019
2896/2021
[Barku R.
Songal]
89/2002
42.6 R.
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
9.
2557/2019
2899/2021
[Vithabai
Laxman
Gangad &
ors.]
98/2002
50.6 R.
Rs.36,000/-to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
913.odt
10.
2560/2019
2900/2021
[Gangabai
R. Khadke]
101/2002
3 H. 89
R.
11.
2554/2019
--
103/2002
19.1 R.
12.
2553/2019
2895/2021
[Dawale
Kamalu
Kaveri]
104/2002
19 R.
13.
2640/2021
F.A. St.
No.33084/2
[Vitthal Alu
Pokale]
79/2002
32.9 R.
14.
2641/2021
2907/2021
[Ganga
Raghu
Khadke]
86/2002
88 R.
15.
2650/2021
2913/2021
[Ramchandr
a Savleram
Khadke]
88/2002
24.2 R.
16.
2648/2021
2905/2021
(Kusa
Ganga]
90/2002
48 R.
17.
2642/2021
2908/2021
[Pandu
Raghu
Wagh]
99/2002
1 H. 46
R.
18.
2649/2021
100/2002
1 H. 74
R.
19.
2644/2021
2911/2021
[Chima
Kusa &
Ors.]
F.A. St.
No.33088/2
[Sakhubai
Bartad &
Ors.]
102/2002
69 R.
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/-to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
913.odt
20.
2645/2021
2906/2021
[Parvatabai
Kusa]
105/2002
3 H. 50
R.
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.36,000/to
Rs.40,000/per Hector in
each matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
21.
2651/2021
2910/2021
[Rama B.
Pokale]
106/2002
4 H. 88
R.
22.
2647/2021
2912/2021
[Mahadu
Rama
Pokale]
107/2002
33.4 R.
23.
2646/2021
2909/2021
[Deoji Rama
Khadke]
108/2002
62 R.
24.
2643/2021
F.A. St.
No.33081/2
[Kawaji
Rawaji
Songal]
109/2002
19.3 R.
4.
The aforesaid lands came to be acquired for the Ghatghar
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Rs.2,00,000/- per
Hector in each
matter
Hydro Electric Project at Ghatghar, Taluka – Akole, District –
Ahmednagar, vide File No. LAQ/SR/2-A/1992. The notification
under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the L. A. Act’) was issued on 18.03.1997 and the
final Award came to be declared on 24.03.2000. The Special Land
Acquisition Officer (hereinafter referred to as ‘the SLAO’) awarded
the compensation within the range of Rs.360/- to 400/- per R. by
considering the acquired lands as dry. The Claimants filed the
aforesaid reference applications for enhancing the compensation
and led the evidence in LAR No.106/2002 for all the reference
applications as can be seen from the observations in Paragraph
No.7 of the Judgment passed by the learned Reference Court. The
Claimants relied on three (03) sale instances below Exhibits – 38,
913.odt
39 and 40 from the adjoining villages. The learned Reference Court
enhanced the compensation at Rs.2,00,000/- per Hectare.
5.
Heard the learned AGP for the State and the learned
Advocate for the Claimant/s. With their assistance, perused the
papers of lead First Appeal No.2552/2019.
[A]
It is submitted by the learned AGP that, the sale instances
brought on record by the Claimants, before the learned Reference
Court, were not from the village where the acquired lands were
situated. The said sale instances were from the different villages,
and therefore the same cannot be called as the comparable sale
instances. He further submits that, the learned Reference Court
gave no reasons at all for enhancing the compensation to
Rs.2,00,000/- per Hectare. The SLAO had rightly categorized the
acquired lands and determined the compensation. He further
submits that, the learned Reference Court has granted the interest
from the date of Section 4 notification, which is contrary to the
decision of this Court in the case of State of Maharashtra Vs.
Kailash Shiva Rangari; 2016 (4) All MR 513. He submits that,
the Appeals filed by the State be allowed and the Appeals filed by
the Claimants be dismissed. In support of his submissions, he
relied on the Judgment in Vithal Rao and Another Vs. Special
Land Acquisition Officer; (2017) 8 SCC 558, wherein, it is
observed that, the sale instances are required to be comparative
sale instances of nearby / adjacent area and the sale should be
proximite to the date of acquisition, possessing similar advantages.
913.odt
[B]
It is submitted by the learned Advocate for the Claimants
that, since no sale instance from the same village was available,
the Claimants brought on record the aforesaid sale instances from
the adjacent villages, i.e. Rozur and Sakhirwadi. The said sale
instances were proximate in time with the Section 4 notification
and were found to be comparable sale instance by the learned
Reference Court. He further submits that, the land under the sale
instances were undisputedly dry lands and the learned Reference
Court by considering the existence of well in the acquired property
and the cropping pattern, considered the acquired lands as semiirrigated. He submits that, though the average rates of the said
sale deeds were calculated as Rs.4,00,000/- per Hectare for the dry
lands, the learned Reference Court without any reasons enhanced
the compensation to Rs.2,00,000/- per Hectare. He submits that,
the enhanced compensation was contrary to the evidence on record
and the compensation be enhanced to Rs.6,00,000/- per Hectare. He
submits that, there can be no dispute in respect of the settled legal
position in the said case of State of Maharashtra Vs. Kailash Shiva
Rangari (supra) that, the interest should be calculated from the
date of final award under Section 11 of the L. A. Act. He submits
that, the Appeals filed by the State be dismissed and the Appeals
filed by the Claimants be allowed. In support of his submissions,
he relied on the decision in Udho Dass Vs. State of Haryana
and Others; (2010) 12 SCC 51, wherein, it is observed that, the
aspect of potentiality of the acquired lands can be contended at the
appellate stage, and further contended that, the purpose of
acquisition was commercial, as the electricity generated by the
hydroelectric project was sold to the consumers.
913.odt
6.
There is no dispute in respect of the extent of acquired lands
and the purpose, for which the lands are acquired. The purpose for
acquisition undisputedly was for generation of hydro electricity.
There cannot be any dispute on the settled legal principles that, it
is for the Claimants to establish their case for enhanced
compensation by adducing the evidence. In support of their claim
for enhanced compensation, the Claimants brought on record the
certified copies of the sale instances below Exhibits – 38, 39 and 40,
which
were
dated
30.07.1997,
01.07.1997
and
12.09.1996,
respectively. Section 4 notification is dated 18.03.1997. The learned
Reference Court found the said sale instances within the
reasonable period of issuance of Section 4 notification, as is clear
from the Paragraph No.19 of the Judgment. The said sale
instances were from villages Rajur and Sakharwadi. The
observations from Paragraph No.15 of the Judgment goes to show
that, the said villages are nearby and adjacent to the acquired
lands. The case of the Claimants that, no sale instances were
available from the village – Ghatghar, it supported by the
observations in Paragraph No.15 of the Judgment, wherein, the
learned Reference Court noted that, the SLAO considered the sale
transaction of nearby village within period of 1961 to 1981, as
there was no sale-purchase transaction during the relevant period
of village – Ghatghar. Therefore, the consideration of the sale
instances below Exhibits – 38, 39 and 40 by the learned Reference
Court cannot be faulted. On the basis of these undisputed factual
aspects of the matters, no assistance can be drawn by the learned
AGP from the said decision in Vithal Rao and Another Vs. Special
Land Acquisition Officer (supra).
913.odt
5.
The observations in Paragraph No.14 of the Judgment goes to
show that, the learned Reference Court noted the existence of well
in the acquired lands and also noted that, the Claimants had taken
the crops like Rice, Groundnut, Jawar and Bajara etc. and
considered the acquired lands as seasonally irrigated. With the
said observations that, there was well in the acquired lands and
the cropping pattern, no fault can be found with the learned
Reference Court in considering the acquired land as seasonally
irrigated land.
6.
While considering the said three (03) sale instances, the
learned Reference Court found the average rate of the said sale
deeds as Rs.4,00,000/- per Hectare for dry lands. The observations
in Paragraph No.16 of the Judgment goes to show that, the learned
Reference Court considered the well settled principles that, the
rate of the irrigated land should be double the rate of the dry land,
and noted that, for the irrigated land, the rate should be
Rs.8,00,000/- per Hectare. When the learned Reference Court had
come to the conclusion that, the rate for the dry lands at the
relevant time was Rs.4,00,000/- per Hectare, absolutely no reason
or
justification
is
given
to
enhance
the
compensation
at
Rs.2,00,000/- per Hectare, though the acquired lands were held to
be semi-irrigated land. Considering the observations of the learned
Reference Court from the Judgment, it is clear that, the learned
Reference Court has misdirected itself in not determining the
enhanced rate of Rs.6,00,000/- per Hectare for the semi-irrigated
land. The observation in the Judgment by the learned Reference
Court, clearly goes to show that, the Claimants were successful in
establishing that, the acquired lands were semi-irrigated and the
913.odt
market rate at the relevant was Rs.4,00,000/- per Hectare for dry
lands and consequently, they were entitled for the compensation of
Rs.6,00,000/- per Hectare for the semi-irrigated lands.
7.
The operative order of the Judgment by the learned Reference
Court goes to show that, the interest is granted from the date of
Section 4. This Court in the case of State of Maharashtra Vs.
Kailash Shiva Rangari (supra) has held that, the interest is to be
computed from the date of award under Section 11 of the L. A. Act.
Thus, the same part of the Judgment by the learned Reference
Court needs modification. According to the learned Advocate for
the Claimants, the Claimants belong to the tribe, and are
exempted from paying the court fees.
8.
In view of the above, I proceed to pass the following order :ORDER
[a]
The Appeals filed by the State are partly allowed to
the extent of interest.
[b]
The Claimants shall be entitled for the interest from
the date of Section 11 award under the L. A. Act and
not from the Section 4 notification.
[c]
The Appeals filed by the Claimants are partly
allowed to the extent of the enhanced compensation.
[d]
The Claimants shall be entitled for enhanced
compensation at Rs.6,00,000/- per Hectare for the
semi-irrigated lands, along with statutory benefits.
[e]
The amount of compensation be calculated as per this
modified Award. Thereafter, the Claimants are at
liberty to withdraw the amount under the
compensation along with interest accrued thereon,
which is deposited by the State.
913.odt
[f]
Excess amount, if any after calculation, be refunded
to the State.
[g]
The aspect of the Court fees be dealt with as per
rules.
[h]
The State is expected to deposit the enhanced
compensation, if any, within a period of six (06)
months.
[i]
The Record and Proceedings (R & P) be sent back to
the learned Reference Court.
[j]
Pending Civil Applications, if any, stand disposed off
accordingly.
[NEERAJ P. DHOTE, J.]
Sameer/August-2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review