Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 18TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 1319 OF 2004
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 05.07.2004 IN A.S
NO.73/1998 OF SUB COURT, CHERTHALA
ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT & DECREE DATED 28.03.1998 IN
O.S NO.869/1991 OF PRINCIPAL MUNSIFF'S COURT, CHERTHALA
APPELLANTS/APPELLANTS/DEFENDANTS:
CHELATTUBHAGOM NAIR KARAYOGAM,
TRICHATTUKULAM P.O.,
ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT.
CHELATTUBHAGOM NAIR KARAYOGAM, *(AMENDED)
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESENT PRESIDENT,
M.K.VIJAYAN,
SANTHI BHAVANAM,
THRICHATTUKULAM P.O.,
ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT.
*(THE NAME OF THE 2ND APPELLANT IS AMENDED BY
INCORPORATING THE NAME OF THE PRESIDENT AS N.ASOKA
KUMAR, REVATHI, TRICHATTUKULAM P.O.,
ALAPPUZHA, PIN-688526 AS PER ORDER DATED
07.10.2024 IN IA.NO.1/2024 IN RSA.1319/2004)
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
THE PRESENT SECRETARY OF CHELATTUBHAGOM NAIR
KARAYOGAM, *(AMENDED)
K.K.VIJAYAN,
THEKKEPARAYAKAT, THRICHATTUKULAM, ALAPPUZHA
DISTRICT.
*(THE NAME OF THE 3RD APPELLANT IS AMENDED BY
INCORPORATING THE NAME OF THE PRESENT SECRETARY AS
M.P.JAYASANKAR, MALIYEKKAL,
TRICHATTUKULAM P.O., ALAPPUZHA,PIN-688526 AS PER
ORDER DATED 07.10.2024 IN IA.NO.1/2024 IN
RSA.1319/2004)
THE PRESENT TREASURER OF CHELATTUBHAGOM
NAIR KARAYOGAM *(AMENDED), S.MURALEEDHARAN NAIR,
'DEVAKI SADANAM', THRICHATTUKULAM,
ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT.
*(THE NAME OF THE 4TH APPELLANT IS AMENDED BY
INCORPORATING THE NAME OF THE PRESENT TREASURER AS
C.N.NANDAKUMAR,CHEMMAZATHU,TRICHATTUKULAM P.O.,
ALAPPUZHA, PIN-688526 AS PER ORDER DATED
07.10.2024 IN IA.NO.1/2024 IN RSA.1319/2004)
BY ADVS.
SRI.M.GOPIKRISHNAN NAMBIAR
SRI.P.G.RAJAGOPALAN
SMT.T.RESMI DAMODARAN
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF:
KAVUKUTTY AMMA AMMUKUTTY AMMA *(DIED, LHRS
IMPLEADED)
VALYACHIRAVEETTIL, CHELATTUBHAGOM MURI,
PANAVALLY VILLAGE,
ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT.
JALAJA,
VALYACHIRAVEETTIL, CHELATTUBHAGOM MURI,
PANAVALLY VILLAGE, P.O.PANAVALLY,
PIN-688 581, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT.
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
HARIHARAN,
KANDATHIL PARAMBU, EZHUPUNNA VILLAGE,
P.O.CHANDIRUR, PIN-688 547, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT.
SOBHANA,
VALYACHALCHIRA VEETTIL, CHELATTUBHAGOM MURI,
P.O.THRICHATTUKULAM, PIN-688 581,
ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT.
INDIRA,
NALASHOUNGATTUVELI, MARARIKULAM NORTH P.O.,
S.L.PURAM,PIN-688 549, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT.
JAYALAKSHMI,
KANANGATTUVELIYIL VEEDU, THEKKUMMURI,
P.O.KURUPPAMKULANGARA,
CHERTHALA, PIN-688 539.
*(ADDL.RESPONDENTS NO.2 TO 6 ARE IMPLEADED AS
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES OF DECEASED SOLE RESPONDENT
AS PER ORDER DATED 22.06.2020 IN IA.2240/2011.
(IA.1/2011).
BY ADVS.
SMT.V.P.SEEMANDINI (SR.)
SRI.JITHIN PAUL VARGHESE, Addl.R1 TO R6
SMT.S.KARTHIKA, Addl.R1 TO R6
SMT.M.P PRIYANKA, Addl.R1 TO R6
SRI.SAJU THALIATH, Addl.R1 TO R6
SRI.K.SUNIL, Addl.R1 TO R6
SRI.M.S.UNNIKRISHNAN, Addl.R1 TO R6
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
08.04.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
THE
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
K.BABU, J.
-------------------------------------RSA No.1319 of 2004
--------------------------------------Dated this the 8th day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
This Regular Second Appeal is directed against the judgment
and decree passed by the Subordinate Judge's Court, Cherthala, in
A.S.No.73/1998, which arose from the judgment and decree passed
by the Munsiff's Court, Cherthala in O.S.No.869/1991. The defendants
are the appellants.
2. The facts giving rise to the appeal are the following:
2.1. The plaint schedule property is 10 cents of land, which
was the subject matter of O.A 300/1970 before the Land Tribunal.
This property originally belonged to defendant No.1-Karayogam.
2.2. The plaintiff pleaded the following:
The plaintiff has been in possession of the plaint
schedule property. She has been enjoying the property for the last
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
20 years. With the enactment of the Land Reforms Act, the plaintiff
filed a petition as O.A No.300/1970 before the Land Tribunal. The
Tribunal ordered to issue a purchase certificate in respect of 10
cents of land in favour of the plaintiff.
When the competent
authority visited the plaint schedule property to measure out it, the
office bearers of defendant No.1-Karayogam requested the plaintiff
to satisfy with six cents. They also represented to the plaintiff that
the title of the remaining extent of the property would be
transferred in her favour by way of executing a sale deed after the
general body of the Karayogam takes a decision.
The plaintiff
believed the words of the office bearers of defendant No.1Karayogam and therefore, she put her signature on a paper,
agreeing to reduce the extent of Kudikidappu to six cents. Even
after that, the plaintiff has been in possession and enjoyment of the
plaint schedule property. She constructed fence on all sides except
on the northern side. She also constructed an ESP-type latrine and
a shed on the property for collecting firewood. She also erected a
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
poultry farm on the property. The office bearers of the Karayogam
did not execute the deed as agreed.
execution of the sale deed.
They tried to prolong the
When the new office bearers took
charge, defendant No.2 along with his men, attempted to demolish
the fence erected on the sides of the property. Defendant No.2
threatened that he would remove the entire construction on the
property. The defendants have no right to trespass upon the plaint
schedule property.
2.4.
Therefore, the plaintiff instituted a suit for an
injunction restraining the defendants from forcibly entering the
property and committing waste therein.
2.5.
The defendants resisted the suit contending as
follows:
The plaintiff is not in possession of the property as
pleaded.
She filed O.A No.300/1970 before the Land Tribunal,
Thyacattussery. The Tribunal granted a purchase certificate in
respect of six cents of property in survey No.207/18. It was given at
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
the request of the plaintiff and also with the consent and knowledge
of the then office bearers of the Karayogam. The defendants did not
agree to sell any property as pleaded. The plaintiff is in possession
of only six cents of land in respect of which the Tribunal issued the
purchase certificate. In October 1990, the plaintiff trespassed upon
the defendants' property and forcibly constructed a latrine thereon.
In spite of repeated demands, the plaintiff did not remove the same.
The defendants had initiated steps to remove the same. Neither
defendant No.2 nor any office bearers of the Karayogam attempted
to demolish the fence as alleged. There has not been any fence, as
pleaded. The property other than six cents is in the possession of
the defendants.
3. The Trial Court framed the following issues:
“(1) Whether the plaintiff is in possession of the plaint
schedule property.
(2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the injunction
prayed for.
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
(3) Relief and costs.”
4.
PWs 1 and 2 were examined and Exts.A1 to A3 were
marked on the side of the plaintiff. On the part of the defendants,
DW1 was examined, and Ext.B1 was marked. Exhibit C1 was marked
as Court Exhibit.
5.
The Trial Court held that the plaintiff has been in
possession and enjoyment of the plaint schedule property for many
years. The Trial Court granted a prohibitory injunction as prayed for
in the plaint.
6.
The defendants challenged the decree and judgment
passed by the Trial Court, filing A.S No.73/1998. The First Appellate
Court confirmed the judgment passed by the Trial Court.
7. Aggrieved by the judgment of the First Appellate Court that
confirmed the decree and judgment passed by the Trial Court, the
defendants have come up before this Court under Section 100 of the
CPC.
8.
After hearing both sides, this Court reformulated the
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
substantial questions of law as follows:
(i)
Whether the absence of title over the entire
plaint
schedule
property
disentitled
the
plaintiff to claim the injunction as prayed for.
(ii)
Whether the Courts below acted in accordance
with law in the matter of appreciating the
evidence on record.
9. I have heard the learned counsel for the appellants and the
learned counsel for the respondents.
10. The learned counsel for the appellants contended that
since the respondent/plaintiff has no title or possession over the
entire property, except six cents of land assigned to her, she is not
entitled to the prohibitory injunction against the Karayogam, which
is the true owner of it. The learned counsel further contended that
the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court failed to draw
necessary inferences and presumptions based on the available
evidence.
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
11. The learned counsel for the respondents contended that
there is admissible evidence to show that the plaintiff has been in
settled possession of the entire plaint schedule property.
The Evidence
12. The plaintiff adduced oral evidence as PW1. The plaintiff
deposed that she has been in possession and enjoyment of the
plaint schedule property for the last 20 years.
She claimed
'kudikidappu' right over 10 cents of land (the plaint schedule
property) by filing application as O.A No.300/1970 before the Land
Tribunal, Thycattussery.
13. The Land Tribunal ordered to issue a purchase certificate
for the plaint schedule property in favour of the plaintiff. The office
bearers of the defendants were present when the officials came to
measure out the property. The plaintiff is an illiterate lady. The
office bearers of the defendant-Karayogam requested her to
reduce the extent of the Kudikkidappu right to six cents. According
to PW1, the then office bearers of the defendant-Karayogam had
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
agreed to execute a sale deed with respect to the rest of the
property that remained in her possession.
Even after that, the
plaintiff has been in exclusive possession of the property by putting
fence on all three sides. PW1 stated that she constructed an ESPtype latrine and a shed for keeping firewood and a poultry house on
the property.
Once in three years, the office bearers of the
Karayogam changed.
When new office bearers took charge in
October 1991, they attempted to trespass upon the property and
commit waste therein. PW1 deposed that defendant No.2 and some
of his men
attempted to encroach upon the property and
threatened the plaintiff that they would demolish the fence around
the property.
While she was out of her house, the defendants
demolished the fence and destroyed the structures on it.
PW1
specifically stated that the property in her possession has welldefined boundaries on all sides.
14.
The Trial Court had issued a Commission to PW2 to
conduct a local inspection in the property and file a report. PW2
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
prepared Ext.C1 report. PW2 stated that there was fence on the
sides of the plaint schedule property, which somebody destroyed,
approximately two days before the suit.
PW2 deposed that a
poultry house was situated in the plaint schedule property. Exhibit
C1 report corroborates the oral evidence of PW2.
15. The defendants had filed O.S No.871/1991 seeking removal
of the ESP-type latrine from the plaint schedule property.
The
pleadings in O.S No.871/1991 corroborate the pleadings set up by the
plaintiff that she had constructed an ESP-type latrine on the plaint
schedule property. O.S No.871/1991 was ordered to be tried along
with the present suit. But the defendants had withdrawn the suit.
Exhibit A3 is a report of the Commissioner in O.S No.871/1991, which
also shows remnants of certain fence stumps, cut and removed and
again grown into branches. Ext.A3(a) plan shows the existence of
'thulasithara' on a portion of the plaint schedule property which is
beyond the extent of six cents measured out based on Ext.A1
pattayam.
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
16. DW1 gave evidence for the defendants. DW1 stated that
there was an understanding between the plaintiff and the
defendants regarding the issuance of a purchase certificate
confining to six cents of land.
The written statement is silent
regarding the understanding between the plaintiff and the
defendants. The defendants did not deny the fact that the Land
Tribunal ordered the issuing of pattayam with regard to 10 cents of
property.
17.
The Trial Court and the First Appellate Court concluded
that the pleading that the Land Tribunal ordered to give 10 cents
of
property
unchallenged.
as
'kudikidappu'
to
the
plaintiff
remained
It is pertinent to note that in Ext.A1 pattayam,
initially, the extent was shown as 10 cents, and subsequently, the
same was struck off inserting 'six cents' both in figures and words.
The contention of the defendants is that the purchase certificate
was granted only in respect of six cents even though she was
entitled to purchase 10 cents. The Trial Court and the First
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
Appellate Court, after appreciating the pleadings and evidence,
came to the conclusion that the structures in the plaint schedule
property were in existence even prior to 1990.
18. Therefore, the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court
found that the plaintiff has been in absolute possession and
enjoyment of the plaint schedule property, though the purchase
certificate was issued to her only in respect of six cents of land.
The specific conclusion of the Trial Court is that the plaintiff has
been in possession of the plaint schedule property from 1970
onwards.
This finding of fact has been confirmed by the First
Appellate Court.
19. The only surviving challenge is that the plaintiff had no
title over the property other than six cents of land. The pleadings
and evidence lead to the conclusion that the plaintiff is in settled
possession of the property. The submission of the learned counsel
for the appellants/defendants is that the plaintiff is a trespasser.
There is no foundation for these pleadings.
It is trite that the
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
person in peaceful possession is entitled to retain his possession.
In order to protect such possession, he may even use reasonable
force to keep out a trespasser.
20. The law will come to the aid of a person in peaceful and
settled possession by injuncting even a rightful owner from using
force or taking the law in his own hands. It is the settled
possession or effective possession of a person without title that
would entitle him to protect his possession even against the true
owner. The concept of settled possession and the right of the
possessor to protect his possession against the owner has been
settled by a catena of decisions. [See Munshi Ram v. Delhi
Administration (AIR 1968 SC 702)] In Munshi Ram, it was held that
no one, including the true owner, has the right to dispossess even a
trespasser by force if the trespasser is in settled possession of the
land.
21. In the present case, the plaintiff has settled possession
over the entire plaint schedule property. Admittedly, she has title
2025:KER:29698
RSA No.1319 of 2004
over six cents of land; the remaining property is in her exclusive
possession.
The substantial questions of law are, therefore, answered
accordingly against the appellants/defendants. The Regular Second
Appeal lacks merits. The Regular Second Appeal stands dismissed
with the costs of the plaintiff.
Sd/-
K.BABU,
JUDGE
KAS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review