Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
7th June, 2022
DATED :
------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 01 of 2022
:
Appellants
Chandra Bahadur Chettri (Thapa) and Others
versus
Respondents :
Karna Maya Pradhan and Others
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
---------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Mr. K. B. Chettri and Mr. Umesh
Gurung, Advocate for the Appellants.
Ms. Pritima Sunam, Advocate for Respondents No.1 and 4.
Mr. Thupden G. Bhutia, Advocate for Respondents No.2 and 3.
----------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The short question that falls for determination in this
Appeal is;
Whether the Learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal,
East Sikkim, at Gangtok (hereinafter, “MACT”), vide the
impugned Judgment, in MACT Case No.35 of 2020, dated 3010-2021, committed an error in rejecting the Income
Certificate, Exhibit 8, issued by the Block Development
Officer (for short “BDO”), which quantified the monthly
income
of
the
deceased
as
Rs.50,500/-
(Rupees
fifty
thousand and five hundred) only, and instead assessed her
monthly
income
as
Rs.25,000/-
(Rupees
twenty
five
Counsel
the
Appellants
while
thousand) only?
2.
Learned
Senior
for
advancing his arguments, referred to Exhibit 8, the Income
Certificate,
dated
15-07-2020,
issued
by
the
BDO,
Block
Administrative Centre, Dentam, West Sikkim, certifying that late
Bishnu Maya Chettri, daughter of Chandra Bahadur Chettri, had an
income of Rs.50,500/- (Rupees fifty thousand and five hundred)
MAC App. No. 01 of 2022
Chandra Bahadur Chettri (Thapa) and Others vs. Karna Maya Pradhan and Others
only, per month, from agriculture and business. That, despite the
Certificate having been issued by the appropriate Authority who
was duly empowered, the Learned MACT declined to accept it and
proceeded to assess the victim’s monthly income at Rs.25,000/(Rupees twenty five thousand) only, sans evidence. That the
deceased owned two beauty parlours, was also an agriculturist and
obtaining income from all three sources. Hence, the Judgment and
Award of the Learned MACT be set aside and the compensation be
computed in terms of the actual income of the deceased as
revealed in Exhibit 8.
3.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.2 and 3,
(Insurance Company) contended that there is no error in the
assessment of the income of the deceased by the Learned MACT as
the statutes requires the compensation to be “just” and all powers
of the Civil Courts are vested on the Learned MACT to take steps in
this context. Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.1 and 4 put
forth no submissions.
4(i).
Having heard Learned Counsel for the parties and
examined all evidence and documents on record, the facts
summarized are that the Claimants (hereinafter “Appellants”) filed
a Claim Petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
(for short, the “M.V. Act”), on account of the death of the
deceased, Bishnu Maya Chettri, aged about thirty-four years,
daughter of Appellants No.1, 2 and allegedly of Appellant No.3
also, and sibling of the Appellant No.4, in a motor vehicle accident
on 20-06-2020 at Dhar Gaon, Zoom, Naya Bazaar, West Sikkim.
The victim succumbed to her injuries on the spot, the cause of
death being the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the
vehicle Mahindra Maxx, bearing registration No.SK-02-J-0348. At
MAC App. No. 01 of 2022
Chandra Bahadur Chettri (Thapa) and Others vs. Karna Maya Pradhan and Others
the time of her demise she had a monthly income of Rs.50,500/(Rupees fifty thousand and five hundred) only.
(ii)
The Appellants sought compensation of a sum of
Rs.71,02,200/- (Rupees seventy one lakhs, two thousand and two
hundred) only. The Learned MACT considered the evidence-onrecord and computed the compensation at Rs.34,30,000/- (Rupees
thirty four lakhs and thirty thousand) only, in the impugned
Judgment,
assessing
the
monthly
income
of
the
victim
at
Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) only, despite the
Income Certificate issued by the BDO placing her monthly income
at Rs.50,500/- (Rupees fifty thousand and five hundred) only.
5.
The arguments of Learned Counsel for the Respondents
No.2 and 3 with regard to “just compensation” is to say the least,
obnoxious. It is but apposite to remark that the compensation
which is to be “just compensation” is in terms of Section 168 of the
MV Act and not in terms of any power vested on the Learned MACT
by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
6(i).
Now addressing the findings of the Learned MACT with
regard to Exhibit 8, the Income Certificate, the Learned MACT is
either unaware of the catena of Judgments of this High Court
propounding that the BDO is the competent Authority to issue an
Income Certificate or has opted to ignore the pronouncements of
this Court despite the observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
regarding Tribunals ignoring the law declared by the High Court,
which shall be discussed later.
(ii)
In the first instance, it would do well to recapitulate the
observations of this High Court on the BDO being the competent
Authority to issue an Income Certificate, in Sikkim.
MAC App. No. 01 of 2022
Chandra Bahadur Chettri (Thapa) and Others vs. Karna Maya Pradhan and Others
(iii)
In The Branch Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. vs.
Meena Bania and Others1, at Paragraph 17, it was held as follows;
“17. In so far as other two grounds are concerned, it may
be answered as under:
17.1 Income certificate issued by the BDO on
agricultural income is a valid and accepted
document in the State of Sikkim and the position is
the same as regards validity while being presented
to other authorities also. The BDO or the Block
Development Officer in a State is a revenue
authority and is competent under the State
Government Rules to issue such certificates, a fact
which this Court takes judicial notice of.
.......................................................................”
(iv)
In Silli Man Subba vs. Man Bahadur Subba2, this Court
observed as hereunder;
“20.…………………………….………………………………………………
(v) Having said so, I am inclined to set aside
the finding on the question in the impugned
judgment and hold that the BDO being a public
officer duly conferred with the authority to issue
income certificate,…………………………………………………….”
(v)
In The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Kavita Rai and Others3, at Paragraph 10, it was held as follows;
“10.…………………………………………………………………………….
It is not the case of the Appellant that the Block
Development Officer is not empowered to issue the
Income Certificate of the deceased. He is indeed the
concerned authority at the Block Administrative
Level to issue such a Certificate. The ratiocinations
of this Court referred to supra lend credence to this
stand. In the absence of any document to the
contrary, Exhibit 14 is accepted as the correct
information pertaining to the income of the
deceased.”
(vi)
In Branch Manager, New India Assurance Co. Ltd. vs.
Shyam Babu Singh and Others4, this Court again held as follows;
“…………………………………………………………………………………..
On perusal of the aforesaid, it is quite clear
that the BDO in the State of Sikkim is competent to
issue the Income Certificate, as per Notification
dated 03.04.2007. In terms of the powers conferred
on him, the Income Certificate (Exhibit-9) is the
relevant and relied by the Tribunal to determine the
loss of dependency and future prospects due to the
death of the deceased.
In the said context, it is to observe that if the
income certificate issued by a competent authority
has been relied by the learned Tribunal accepting
2013 ACJ 565
(2014) SCC Online Sikk 198
SLR (2019) SIKKIM 227
SLR (2021) SIKKIM 226
MAC App. No. 01 of 2022
Chandra Bahadur Chettri (Thapa) and Others vs. Karna Maya Pradhan and Others
the earning of Rs.20,000/-, the onus to disprove it
shifts on the insurance company. However, it was
the duty of the insurance company to call the BDO
in the witness box and put question to him whether
he has verified the books of transaction of business
recorded in the Books of Account while issuing
income certificate. In absence of taking such steps,
the argument so advanced by the counsel for the
appellant is of no help to him…………………………………..”
Despite these pronouncements, the Learned MACT in direct
violation of the law laid down by this High Court has given a go by
to the Income Certificate, Exhibit 8, issued by no less an Authority
than the BDO, which this Court time and again has reiterated is the
concerned Authority empowered to issue the Income Certificate.
Necessary reference is this context is also made to Notification
No.25/Home/2007, dated 03-04-2007, referred to the matter of
Shyam Babu Singh (supra) which is extracted herein below;
“SIKKIM
GOVERNMENT
GAZETTE
EXTRAORDINARY
PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY
Gangtok
Tuesday,
17th April,
No.139
HOME DEPARTMENT
GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
No:25/Home/2007
Dated:30/04/2007
NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred by section 21 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974), the State Government hereby appoints the Block
Development Officer, Rural Management & Development Department, Government of
Sikkim to be the Special Executive Magistrates for the performance of the following
specific functions with their respective jurisdiction, namely:-
(1)
(2)
Swearing in or Affirmation of Affidavits under Section 297 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Issuance of:-
(a) Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe Certificate.
(b) Other Backward Class and Most Backward Class Certificate.
(c) Income Certificate.
(d) Property Certificate.
(e) Employment Card.
(f) Married/Unmarried Certificates.
(g) Roof Level Certificate
(h) No Landed Property Certificate.
(i) No Dwelling House Certificate.
(j) Landed Property Certificate.
(3)
Verification of Birth/Death.
2.
In respect of the aforesaid functions, the Block Development Officers
shall be subject to the control and directions of the District Magistrates/and
other authority as may be specified under law.
3.
This notification shall come into force at once.
Sd/(N.D. Chingapa) IAS
CHIEF SECRETARY
F.NO. GOS/RMDD/07-08/242/11/HQ”
(emphasis supplied)
MAC App. No. 01 of 2022
Chandra Bahadur Chettri (Thapa) and Others vs. Karna Maya Pradhan and Others
The Notification thereby lends succour to the observations of
this High Court pertaining to the Authority of the BDO to issue
Income Certificate.
7.
In this context, the Learned MACT may educate itself
on the Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in East India
Commercial Co. Ltd. Calcutta and Another vs. Collector of Customs,
Calcutta5 which held as observed;
“29………………………………………………………………………………
This raises the question whether an Administrative
Tribunal can ignore the law declared by the highest
court in the State and initiate proceedings in direct
violation of the law so declared. Under Article 215,
every High Court shall be a court of record and shall
have all the powers of such a court including the
powers to punish for contempt of itself. Under
Article 226, it has a plenary of power to issue orders
or writs for the enforcement of the fundamental
rights and for any other purpose to any person or
authority, including in appropriate cases any
Government, within its territorial jurisdiction. Under
Article 227 it has jurisdiction over all the courts and
tribunals throughout the territories in relation to
which it exercise jurisdiction. It would be anomalous
to suggest that a tribunal over which the High Court
has superintendence can ignore the law declared by
that Court and start proceedings in direct violation
of it. If a tribunal can do so, all the subordinate
courts can equally do so, for there is no specific
provision, just like in the case of Supreme Court,
making the law declared by the High Court binding
on subordinate courts. It is implicit in the power of
supervision conferred on a superior tribunal that all
the tribunals subject to its supervision should
conform to the law laid down by it. Such obedience
would also be conducive to their smooth working :
otherwise, there would be confusion in the
administration of law and respect for law would
irretrievably suffer. We, therefore, hold that the law
declared by the highest court in the State is binding
on
authorities
or
tribunals
under
its
superintendence, and that they cannot ignore it
either in initiating a proceeding. If that be so, the
notice issued by the authority signifying the
launching of proceedings contrary to the law laid
down by the High Court would be invalid and the
proceedings
themselves
would
be
without
jurisdiction.”
(emphasis supplied)
This ratio was reiterated in Shri Baradakanta Mishra ExCommissioner of Endowments vs. Shri Bhimsen Dixit 6 and Hanuman
Anandrao Pendam vs. State of Maharashtra, Through Secretary Home
Department and Another7.
AIR 1962 SC 1893
(1973) 1 SCC 446
(2022) SCC Online BOM 572
MAC App. No. 01 of 2022
Chandra Bahadur Chettri (Thapa) and Others vs. Karna Maya Pradhan and Others
8.
The Learned MACT despite the above settled position of
law, decided to reach a finding contrary to the law laid down by the
High Court. The Learned MACT is reminded that it is bound to
follow the law laid down by the High Court as also held by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the ratio M/s. East India Commercial Co. Ltd.
(supra).
9.
In A. K. Jain and Another vs. State of Sikkim and Another8,
this High Court had observed as follows;
“16………………………………………………………………….
In India, the legal position has been made clear by
S. 16(1) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, which
says that subject to the provisions of any law for the
time being in force, a Judge, Magistrate or other
person acting judicially shall also be liable for
contempt of his own court or any other court in the
same manner as any other individual is liable. That
the disobedience on the part of a judicial officer to a
specific order of the High Court or deliberate
conduct of not following the law laid down in a
previous decision of the High Court amounts to
contempt of court has the approval of the Supreme
Court in Bardakanta Misra vs. Bhimsen Dixit: AIR
1972 SC 2466. There the Supreme Court observed:
15-16. The conduct of the appellant in not
following the previous decision of the High Court is
calculated to create confusion in the administration
of law. It will undermine respect for law laid down
by the High Court and impair the constitutional
authority of the High Court. His conduct is therefore
comprehended by the principles underlying the law
of contempt. The analogy of the inferior court’s
disobedience to the specific order of a superior
court also suggests that his conduct falls within the
purview of the law of contempt. Just as the
disobedience to a specific order of the Court
undermines the authority and dignity of the court in
a particular case, similarly any deliberate and mala
fide conduct of not following the law laid down in
the previous decision undermines the constitutional
authority and respect of the High Court. Indeed,
while the former conduct has repercussions on an
individual case and on a limited number of persons,
the latter conduct has a much wider and more
disastrous impact. It is calculated not only to
undermine the constitutional authority and respect
of the High Court generally, but is also to subvert
the Rule of law and engender harassing uncertainty
and confusion in the administration of law.”
(emphasis supplied)
This Court presently does not contemplate any proceeding
against the concerned Judicial Officer, citing the ratio supra is an
effort to bring to the notice of the Officer that there cannot be
AIR 1992 SIKKIM 20
MAC App. No. 01 of 2022
Chandra Bahadur Chettri (Thapa) and Others vs. Karna Maya Pradhan and Others
violation of the law laid down by the High Court unless such law
has been set aside by a Higher Court.
10.
It is admitted by Learned Counsel for the Insurance
Company that the evidence pertaining to the income of the victim
being Rs.50,500/- (Rupees fifty thousand and five hundred) only,
in terms of Exhibit 8 was not decimated by any cross-examination.
In such circumstance, it is inconceivable and incomprehensible as
to how the Learned MACT without any basis on its own conclusion
made
a
random
assessment
of
the
deceased’s
income
as
Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) only and proceeded to
calculate compensation on that ground. There is no application of
judicial mind in the said circumstance. Infact, the Learned MACT in
Paragraph 24 of the impugned Judgment has inter alia held as
follows:“24.……………………………………………………………………………..
Further, though the above income certificate has
been filed it is not clear as to on what basis the BDO
had issued the same quantifying the monthly
income of the deceased as Rs.50,000/-. Strictly
speaking, the claimants ought to have put forward
cogent materials in order to sufficiently establish the
actual monthly income of the deceased. Having said
that, it would not be incongruous here to mention
that the OPs No.2 & 3 have not been able to
controvert the claims of the claimant that the
deceased had two beauty parlours and that she also
had income from other sources above. As such
considering the facts and circumstances of the case
it would be seemly to take the monthly income of
the deceased to be Rs.25,000/-. That would make
her annual income as Rs.25,000/- x 12 =
Rs.3,00,000/-.”
(emphasis supplied)
11.
Thus, the Learned MACT after having recorded that it is
not clear on what basis the BDO had issued Exhibit 8, in
contradiction to its own statement deemed it apposite to proceed
without any basis to assess the income of the deceased as
Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) only. It does not
behove the Learned MACT to clothe itself with the powers of an
assessing Authority without any statutory basis.
MAC App. No. 01 of 2022
Chandra Bahadur Chettri (Thapa) and Others vs. Karna Maya Pradhan and Others
12.
The findings of the Learned MACT assessing the
monthly income of the deceased as Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty
five thousand) only, and granting compensation of Rs.34,30,000/(Rupees thirty four lakhs and thirty thousand) only, is set aside.
The monthly income of the deceased is taken to be Rs.50,500/(Rupees fifty thousand and five hundred) only, in terms of Exhibit
8.
13.
The
quantum
of
compensation
hence
stands
re-
calculated as follows;
Annual income of the deceased
(Rs.50,500 x 12)
Add 40% of Rs.6,06,000/- as Future Prospects
Rs.6,06,000/(+)
Rs.2,42,400/Rs.8,48,400/-
Less 50% of Rs.8,48,400/[as the victim was a bachelorette, in consideration
of the expenses which she
towards maintaining
would have incurred
(-)
herself had she been alive]
Net yearly income
Rs.4,24,200/Rs.4,24,200/-
Multiplier to be adopted ‘16’
(Rs.4,24,200/- x 16)
Rs.67,87,200/-
[The age of the deceased at the time of death
was 34 and the relevant multiplier as per
Judgment of Sarla Verma (Smt) and Others vs.
Delhi Transport Corporation and Another : (2009)
6 SCC 121 is ‘16’]
Funeral Expenses
(+)
Rs.15,000/-
(+)
Rs.15,000/-
(+)
Rs.80,000/-
[in terms of the Judgment of
National Insurance
Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and Other : (2017
16 SCC 682]
Loss of Estate
[in terms of the Judgment of Pranay Sethi (supra)]
Loss of Filial Consortium
(Rs.40,000 x 2)
[in terms of the Judgment of Magma General Insurance
Co. Ltd. vs. Nanu Ram and Other : (2018) 18 SCC 130]
Total
Rs.68,97,200/-
(Rupees sixty eight lakhs, ninety-seven thousand and two-hundred)only.
14.
With
regard
to
the
Appellants
being
the
legal
representatives of the deceased, in the Claim Petition, at
Paragraph 22 of the impugned Judgment, the Learned MACT held
as follows;
“22.………………………………………As seen above, the
claimants No.1 and 2 are the parents of the
deceased while the claimant No.4 is the sister of the
deceased
who
was
reportedly
unmarried.
Interestingly, even the step mother of the deceased
has been arraigned as claimant No.3 in the matter.
However, only the claimants No. 1, 2 and 4 can be
regarded as the legal representatives of the
deceased……….”
(emphasis supplied)
MAC App. No. 01 of 2022
Chandra Bahadur Chettri (Thapa) and Others vs. Karna Maya Pradhan and Others
In my considered opinion this conclusion of the Learned
MACT is found to be plausible and requires no interference.
15.
The awarded amount of compensation is to be divided
as follows;
(i)
The Appellant No.1, the father of the deceased is
entitled to 40%, while the mother of the deceased,
Appellant No.2 is granted 45% of the computed
compensation.
(ii)
The Appellant No.4, being the unmarried sister of
the deceased is granted 15%.
16.
The Respondents-Insurance Company shall pay the
compensation computed supra to the Appellants as ordered. The
Appellants shall be entitled to simple interest @ 9% per annum on
the above amount with effect from the date of filing of the Claim
Petition before the Learned MACT, i.e., 10-12-2020, until its full
realisation.
17.
The Respondents-Insurance Company is directed to
pay the awarded amount to the Appellants within one month from
today, failing which it shall pay simple interest @ 12% per annum
from the date of filing of the Claim Petition, till full realisation, duly
deducting the amounts, if any, already paid by them to the
Appellants.
18.
Appeal disposed of accordingly.
19.
No orders as to cost.
20.
Records of the Learned MACT be remitted forthwith to
it.
21.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned MACT of
all Districts for information.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
07-06-2022
sdl
Approved for reporting : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review