Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
27.01.2026
Court. No. 25
D.Hira
WPA 29861 of 2025
Chandan Sengupta
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Swarup Paul,
Mr. Biswaroop Bhattacharya,
Mr. Swapan Kumar Pal,
Ms. Srijani Mukherjee.
Ms. Nilotpal Chatterjee,
Mr. Amrita Lal Chatterjee.
… for the petitioner
… for the State
1. The petitioner has challenged the notice inviting
tender issued by the respondent authorities for
engagement of agency for internal Security and
Housekeeping/Scavenging Services at the entire
premises
of
Midnapore
Homoeopathic
Medical
College and Hospital.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that in
the tender document under the heading ‘Eligibility
Criteria and Disqualification’ at Clause (A) xii (a), it
is mentioned that “the intending tenderer should
produce credential of similar nature of a completed
single work having minimum value of 40% (Forty
per cent) of the tender amount during last 3 (three)
years prior to the date of the issue of this e-Tender
notice or the intending tenderer should produce
credentials of 2 (two) similar nature of completed
works, each having a minimum value”.
3. He further submits that though as per the
aforesaid clause, the minimum value is given as
40% but in the tender document the tender value
is shown as 00 or N.A.
4. He further submits unless and until the authority
will show the value of the tender, how the
petitioner can value at 40% of the tender amount.
5. He further submits that in the tender condition, it
is mentioned that during the last three years prior
to the date of issue of the e-Tender notice but on
the earlier occasions, the similar matter came
before this Court and the respondent authorities
have accepted that the condition is to be rectified
by way of corrigendum and subsequently tender
condition was rectified by issuance of corrigendum
stating that the period of three years as mentioned
in Clause 3.1 in the tender document
means
service rendered after April 2011.
6. He further submits that subsequently on several
tenders have been issued wherein it is mentioned
that the bidder should have supplied in any 3
years after 2011 from the date of tender opening.
7. He further submits that the period is to be taken
into consideration from 2011 as Act has come into
force in 2011 only and thus, the tender process
initiated by the respondent authorities is not in
accordance with law and it is to be set aside.
8. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the State
submits that the petitioner is not taken the ground
of the tender value in the present writ application
though the petitioner has made submissions before
this Court at the time of making submissions.
9. He further submits that it is the prerogative of the
administration with regard to imposition of terms
and conditions of the tender document.
10. He further submits that the petitioner is still
supplying
the
Housekeeping/Scavenging
Security
Services
and
with
the
respondents, he knows with regard to the criteria
for participating in the tender process.
11. He further submits that the Government of West
Bengal time and again issued the circular fixing the
minimum wages for the unskilled security guard.
As per the circular dated 17th June, 2025, the
monthly wages of the unskilled security guard is
Rs.10.329/- and per day is Rs.397/12. He further submits that as regards the sweeping,
cleaning and scavengers, the minimum wages per
month is Rs.10,329/- and monthly is Rs.397/-.
13. Learned counsel appearing for the State has
handed over the calculation sheet and submits that
as per the tender document the firm has to supply
eight security guards and eight scavengers. If the
monthly amount
of Rs.10,329/- is taken into
consideration for 16 persons, the total amount
would be Rs.1,65,264 which is 24.58% of base
wages.
14. He further submits that if the management fees of
10% of the base wages is taken into consideration,
it will come at Rs.16,526.40/-.
15. Accordingly, the total monthly contract value would
be Rs.1,65,264 + 40,621.89 + Rs.16,526.40
=
Rs.2,22,412.29 and thus the annual contract value
is Rs.26,68,947.48 and thus the authorities have
rounded off the EMD calculation of Rs.50,000/-.
16. Learned counsel appearing for the State further
submits
that
in
the
tender
document
it
is
categorically mentioned that appropriate minimum
rates
and
wages
of
security
personnel
and
housekeeping/scavengers personnel will be treated
as unskilled categories.
As per the appropriate
minimum rates of wages of this zone the monthly
wages in 10,329/- and the total annual amount
would be Rs.26,68,947.48/-.
17. He further submits that the petitioner had the
knowledge with regard to the total value of the
tender document but in spite of having the same
the petitioner has filed the present writ application.
18. Learned counsel for the State has relied upon the
judgment in the case of Michigan Rubber (India)
Limited vs. State of Karnataka & Ors. reported
in (2012) 8 Supreme Court Cases 216 and
submits that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
categorically framed the principles for entertaining
the writ petition with regard to the tender matters.
19. He further submits that the Hon’ble Supreme
Court time and again has held that the fixation of a
value of the tender is entirely within the purview of
the executive and courts hardly have any role to
play in this process except for striking down such
action of the executive as is proved to be arbitrary
or unreasonable.
If the Government acts in
conformity with certain healthy standards and
norms such as awarding of contracts by inviting
tenders, in those circumstances, the interference
by courts is very limited.
20.
He further submits that in the present case,
there is no arbitrary action on the part of the
respondents
and
the
respondents
have
categorically stated that appropriate minimum
wages/rates would be applicable as unskilled
mazdoors in terms of the notification of the
appropriate government wherein daily wages have
been fixed.
21. Learned counsel for the State also relied upon the
judgment in the case of Afcons Infrastructure
Limited vs. Nagpur Metro rail Corporation
Limited & Anr. reported in (2016) 16 Supreme
Court Cases 818 and submits that the Hon’ble
Supreme Court further held that the owner or the
employer of a project, having authored the tender
documents, is the best person to understand and
appreciate
its
requirements
and
interpret
its
documents. The constitutional courts must defer
to this understanding and appreciation of the
tender documents, unless there is mala fide or
perversity.
22. He submits that in the present case, there is no
arbitrary action on the part of the respondent
authorities and thus this Court cannot interfere
with the tender process initiated by the authority
for
supplying
of
the
security
personnel
and
housekeeping/scavengers personnel.
23. Per contra, learned counsel for the petitioner has
relied upon the judgment in the case of The Silppi
Constructions Contractors vs. Union of India &
Anr. passed in SLP No. 13802-13805 of 2019
dated 21st June, 2019 and submits that the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has considered both the
judgments as relied by the respondents and the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that this Court
being the guardian of fundamental rights is duty
bound to interfere when there is arbitrariness,
irrationality, mala fides and bias.
24. He further submits that in the present case on the
face of the record it is find that the authorities have
issued the tender notice with the mala fide
intention to debar the petitioner for participating in
the said tender without mentioning the tender
value and the period of experience.
25. Heard the learned counsel for the respective parties
and perused the materials on record.
26. The petitioner is aggrieved with the Clause 3(xii)(a)
wherein it is mentioned that the intending tenderer
should produce credential of similar nature of a
completed single work having minimum value of
40% (Forty per cent) of the tender amount during
last 3 (three) years prior to the date of the issue of
this e-Tender notice.
27. Upon plain reading of the said clause it is clear
that
the
tenderer
should
possess
certificate
showing that the concerned firm has completed the
similar nature of the work during the last three
years. There is no dispute that the last three years
is to be considered till the date of tender i.e. last
three years.
28. The contention made by the petitioner that the
experience of any three years is to be taken form
2011 till the date of publishing the tender is not
correct.
The authority has to consider the
experience of the firm for the last three years i.e.
till the date of publication of tender notice. Thus,
there is no illegality with regard to three years prior
to the date of issue of tender notice.
29. As regard the value of the tender, the respondents
ought to have mentioned the tender value.
The
respondents have mentioned that the tenderer
should produce document of similar nature of
completed single work having value of 40% of the
tender amount. If no tender amount is mentioned
in the tender document, the tenderers will not able
to calculate 40% of the tender amount.
The
respondents during the hearing have supplied the
justification of tender value, the same could have
mentioned in the tender document.
30. Accordingly,
the
authorities
are
directed
to
immediately issue a corrigendum by mentioning
the tender value within a period of one week from
date.
31. After
the
mentioning
issuance
the
of
tender
the
value
corrigendum,
in
the
by
tender
document, the respondents are directed to extend
the time of submission of tender documents by the
tenderer.
32. WPA No. 29861 of 2025 is disposed of.
33. Urgent Photostat certified copy of the order, if
applied for, be given to the parties on compliance of
requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review