The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. The order passed by the learned ADM Jammu which had been ordered to be set aside by the revisional court, was not a reasoned order as the ld. ADM Jammu had not taken pains to refer to the evidence led by the parties before passing the final order, as such, the ld. ADM Jammu had aborted the legal proceedings against the procedure prescribed under Section 145 CrPC. So far as the contention of the learned Sr. counsel for the petitioner that the orders passed by the civil courts in civil suit as well as appeals regarding the conclusive finding of fact that the petitioner was in possession of the land is concerned, the same can be a factor to be considered by the Magistrate and this Court in my considered opinion should leave this matter to be decided by the Magistrate concerned, after hearing both the parties. Of course, the finding recorded by a civil court is a matter of precedence before the Magistrate invoking jurisdiction under Section 145 CrPC.
13. For the foregoing reasons and observations made hereinabove, this court is of the considered opinion that the order passed by the revisional court setting aside the order passed by the ld. ADM Jammu, without any reasons, has been passed perfectly in consonance with law and does not call for any interference by this court invoking inherent jurisdiction.
14. The petition is, thus, found to be devoid of any merit and substance and is hereby dismissed along with pending application(s). No order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRMC No.190/2019
Reserved on: 30.03.2026
Pronounced on: 08.04.2026
Uploaded on:-08.04.2026.
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced: Yes
Chanchal Singh
S/O Sh. Bajar Singh,
R/O Lower Barnai,
Tehsil & District Jammu
through his son Ranjeet Singh
.....Petitioner
Through :- Mr. Sunil Sethi, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Ankesh Chandel, Adv.
V/S
Hans Raj
S/O Mann Singh
R/O Lower Barnai,
Tehsil & District Jammu.
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Mr. G S Thakur, Adv.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Petitioner, invoking the inherent jurisdiction of this court under
Sections 561-A of J&K CrPC (akin to Sections 482 of CrPC and 528 of BNSS)
seeks quashing of order dated 28.01.2019, passed by the Court of ld. 1st
Additional Sessions Judge, Jammu (hereinafter called ‘Revisional Court’) in
Criminal Revision No.146 titled ‘Hans Raj V. Chanchal Singh’ whereby the
Revision was allowed and the order dated 11.10.2018 passed by the learned
Additional District Magistrate (ADM), Jammu on an application under Section
145 CrPC initiated by the respondent – Hans Raj, had been set-aside, allegedly
being totally illegal and contrary to the settled position of law.
2.
The impugned order has been challenged and assailed on the grounds,
that the same was passed against law and facts of the case; that the petitioner,
CRMC No. 190/2019
being recorded owner of the land in question and the respondent and his sons
being alien to the land in question having no concern, whatsoever, had no
occasion to file the petition under Section 145 CrPC and the learned ADM
Jammu had rightly withdrawn and vacated ex parte order of attachment dated
06.01.2016 passed in haste without evaluating the circumstances for breach of
peace, which warranted the attachment of the land in question; that the
revisional court had not appreciated this factual aspect of the matter and
committed a serious illegality in again setting-aside the order dated 11.10.2018
and remanding the case back, when already two rounds of same proceedings
were over; that the ADM Jammu had passed the order dated 11.10.2018, after
proper appreciation of the evidence led by the parties, hearing the arguments
advanced by them before him rightly withdrawn the preliminary order dated
06.01.2016 and, as such, order passed by the ADM Jammu, set aside by the
revisional court, was perfectly legal and valid order, which needed no
interference in the revision petition filed by the respondents; that the revisional
court had set aside the order passed by the ADM Jammu on 11.10.2018, on the
ground that this order was announced on 04.10.2018 but the same was passed on
11.10.2018 on a wrong notion, as the same was announced on 04.10.2018 and
was forwarded on 11.10.2018.
3.
Learned Sr. counsel appearing for the petitioner has vehemently
argued that the impugned order passed by the revisional court is not sustainable
in law, in view of the fact that the ld. Revisional court had made a specific
observation that the order was passed on 04.10.2018 but was announced on
11.10.2018, whereas the fact that the matter is that the order was passed on
04.10.2018 and its copies were endorsed to the SHO P/S Domana on 11.10.2018
for compliance and necessary action; and the revisional court has taken a wrong
view of it.
CRMC No. 190/2019
4.
He also argued that the learned ADM Jammu had revoked the earlier
order, whereby attachment of the land had been made on the basis of his enquiry
that there was no threat to breach of peace, as is required to be considered under
Section 145 CrPC before withdrawing such an order. The learned Sr. counsel,
further, argued that during the pendency of this petition, a civil appeal was
decided against an injunction order qua the parties, regarding the subject land
passed by the court of Principal District Judge Jammu in a Civil Appeal
No.139/2019 titled ‘Hans Raj & Ors. V. Chanchal Singh’ decided on 29.06.2024
against the order dated 23.09.2019 passed in civil suit ‘Chanchal Singh v. Hans
Raj & Ors.’ by virtue of which interim application filed by the respondent
Chanchal Singh was allowed and the order dated 13.10.2018 had been made
absolute, wherein it has been held that once the land in Khasra Nos. 35 and 36 is
stated to have been purchased by predecessor-in-interest of the respondent
coupled with proceedings under Section 145 CrPC initiated by the appellant
having failed the possession, if any, taken from the respondent would be deemed
to have been given back, which is apparent from the revenue record, in which
entries were made after ADM’s order dated 04.10.2018. In this background, the
respondent Chanchal Singh had been able to satisfy the trial court that he was
holding possession of land and the case projected by the appellants that there is
exchange of land appears to be unsubstantiated and the appellate court came to
the conclusion that the discretionary exercise by the trial court was neither
perverse nor there was any material to warrant a view that it had resulted into
failure of justice.
5.
He has also drawn the attention of this court to an order dated
17.09.2022 passed by SDM Jammu North on a petition for correction of Khasra
Girdwari with regard to land in question moved by the legal heirs of respondentHans Raj against petitioner- Chanchal Singh was rejected having been found to
CRMC No. 190/2019
be baseless and mischievous. The learned Sr. counsel in the aforesaid
background projected by him submits that the first order passed by the learned
ADM Jammu on 06.01.2016 directing the attachment of the land and handed
over the same on superdari of SHO concerned was revoked by the second order
dated 11.10.2018, particularly, in the face of the fact that the trial court as well
as appellate court in the injunction suit/appeal had decided in favour of the
petitioner, as such, no further proceedings are required under Section 145 CrPC
and prayed that the impugned order be set aside.
6.
The learned counsel appearing for the respondent, ex adverso, argued
that there is a prescribed procedure to hold proceedings for setting aside the
petition moved under Section 145 CrPC, which requires that the matter has to be
decided finally after recording of evidence and that the learned ADM Jammu,
though closed the proceedings under Section 145 CrPC, but had not ordered
specifically with regard to the possession, which had been ordered by the initial
order to be attached on superdari of the SHO concerned. He also submits that
the civil suit had been filed by some other persons and no reliance can be placed
on those orders passed by the trial court or the appellate court having any
bearing on the Section 145 proceedings. He specifically refers to the order
passed by the ADM Jammu, which has been set-aside by the revisional court
that no evidence has been discussed, though the petitioner had filed evidence in
the shape of his affidavit as well as his witnesses.
7.
He has further argued that the intervening factors like passing of the
orders in civil injunction suit or appeal arising out of that shall have no bearing
on the proceedings to be conducted by the learned ADM Jammu including the
evidence to be led by the parties before reaching to some logical conclusion as
to whether the attachment of property was required or not. Submitting that the
revisional court has passed the order perfectly in consonance with law and does
CRMC No. 190/2019
not call for interference by this court invoking inherent jurisdiction, he prayed
that the petition be dismissed upholding the impugned order passed by the
revisional court.
8.
As per the facts emerging from the pleadings and the record, one Hans
Raj filed the petition under Section 145 CrPC alleging that he is in cultivating
possession of land measuring 1 Kanal 13 Marlas comprising of Survey No. 35
and land measuring 4 Kanal 2 Marlas comprising of Survey No. 36 situated at
Barnai, Tehsil and District Jammu from the time immemorial and that Chanchal
Singh petitioner herein, in connivance with revenue agency, had manoeuvred his
possession in cultivation column of Khasra Girdwari and under the garb of said
entry, he has been trying to forcibly take possession of the suit land and that a
criminal case was also registered against him and his sons alleging that these
acts have resulted in breach of peace, which had adversely affected the public
tranquility at large.
9.
On 16.07.2015, the ADM Jammu directed the parties to maintain
status quo on spot with regard to the land in question and vide order dated
06.01.2016, he passed the order of attachment of the land, however, vide order
dated 03.05.2016 withdraw the same and the said order was challenged before
the court of ld. Additional Session Judge, Jammu who was pleased to set-aside
the order vide judgment dated 31.01.2017; that the order passed by the ADM
Jammu with regard to conducting the demarcation of the property was
challenged before this court and after disposal of the petition by this court, the
ADM Jammu passed the order in October 2018, which became the subject
matter of criminal revision before the revisional court.
10.
On a perusal of the impugned order passed by the Revisional Court
after hearing the parties, it appears that the Revisional Court holding that the
impugned order had been passed in a mechanical and casual manner, without
CRMC No. 190/2019
specifying the grounds justifying withdrawal of the earlier order; that the learned
ADM Jammu had not considered the evidence produced by the petitioner in the
shape of affidavits and thus, the order passed by the learned ADM was set aside
and the matter was remanded back for recording fresh finding and this is how
the order passed by the revisional court setting aside the order passed by the
learned ADM Jammu and remanding for fresh findings has been assailed before
this court.
11.
Having heard the rival submissions and the facts as noted hereinabove
of the case, it has been found that the ld. ADM Jammu in the order passed on
04.10.2018, which became the subject matter of criminal revision before the
revisional court had not discussed or referred to any evidence led by the parties
though it appears from the record that the petitioner therein had not only
submitted his own affidavit but of his witnesses as well, which was neither
considered nor referred in the order passed by the learned ADM Jammu. Though
the revisional court has referred to two different dates of October to have passed
order by the ADM Jammu, which in the considered opinion of this court is not
the correct view taken by the revisional court as the order passed on 04.10.2018
was forwarded on 11.10.2018, which has been misconstrued by the revisional
court to have been announced on 11.10.2018.
12.
The order passed by the learned ADM Jammu which had been ordered
to be set aside by the revisional court, was not a reasoned order as the ld. ADM
Jammu had not taken pains to refer to the evidence led by the parties before
passing the final order, as such, the ld. ADM Jammu had aborted the legal
proceedings against the procedure prescribed under Section 145 CrPC. So far as
the contention of the learned Sr. counsel for the petitioner that the orders passed
by the civil courts in civil suit as well as appeals regarding the conclusive
finding of fact that the petitioner was in possession of the land is concerned, the
CRMC No. 190/2019
same can be a factor to be considered by the Magistrate and this Court in my
considered opinion should leave this matter to be decided by the Magistrate
concerned, after hearing both the parties. Of course, the finding recorded by a
civil court is a matter of precedence before the Magistrate invoking jurisdiction
under Section 145 CrPC.
13.
For the foregoing reasons and observations made hereinabove, this
court is of the considered opinion that the order passed by the revisional court
setting aside the order passed by the ld. ADM Jammu, without any reasons, has
been passed perfectly in consonance with law and does not call for any
interference by this court invoking inherent jurisdiction.
14.
The petition is, thus, found to be devoid of any merit and substance
and is hereby dismissed along with pending application(s). No order as to costs.
15.
Copies of this order shall be forwarded to the courts below for
information and compliance.
(M A Chowdhary)
Judge
JAMMU
08.04.2026.
Raj Kumar
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
Raj Kumar
2026.04.08 17:15
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRMC No. 190/2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review