Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.A. No.167 of 2026
….
Chakradhar Sahoo
Appellant
(In person)
-versusTata Power Central Orissa
Distribution Ltd. (TPCODL),
Bhubaneswar and another
….
Respondents
Mr. Pranaya Mohanty, Advocate
CORAM:
THE HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MURAHARI SRI RAMAN
ORDER
30.03.2026
Order No.
02.
1.
The appellant, beseeching indulgence in order dated 17.10.2022
passed in W.P. (C) No.21578 of 2022 and order dated
10.11.2025 passed in Review Petition bearing RVWPET No.49
of 2025 by the learned Single Judge of this Court, has filed this
intra-Court Appeal.
2.
The background facts leading to filing of this intra-Court
Appeal commenced in the year, 2008, when the appellant was
not selected to the post of Divisional Accountant in connection
with 3rd D.T. Examination conducted by the Central Electricity
Supply Utility of Orissa (CESU) [presently, Tata Power Central
Odisha Distribution Limited (“TPCODL”)] in April, 2008.
2.1.
A challenge was laid to the decision of the authority before this
Court in W.P.(C) No.8091 of 2009 which came to be dismissed
on 12.10.2017 by the learned Single Bench of this Court with
the following observations:
“Hence, the authorities after being found that the petitioner has
not secured qualifying marks in English Paper-1, hence he has
been declared fail, in consequence thereof, he has not been
found to be suitable to be promoted in the 3 rd D.T.
Examination, which is after all the scrutiny of the candidate for
promotion in the selection post.”
2.2.
A review petition, being RVWPET No.241 of 2017, against the
said order of dismissal suffered the same consequence vide
judgment dated 04.04.2018.
2.3.
A Writ Appeal, being W.A. No.220 of 2018, was preferred
challenging the order dated 12.10.2017 passed in W.P.(C)
No.8091 of 2009, which was disposed of vide judgment dated
12.02.2019. A Division Bench upon hearing, observed thus:
“4.
The petitioner-appellant made his submission before this
Court appearing in person and his sole contention before
us was that he has been illegally declared fail only
because his English Paper-I was evaluated by one of his
authorities being an Engineer and hence, his answer
paper should be examined by any other competent
person or may be verified by this Court, which would
make it evident that he has been intentionally given with
less mark on some personal grounds. Out of maximum
mark of 150 in English Paper-1, minimum mark required
for passing was 60 and the petitioner secured 52 marks
for which he was declared fail. The petitioner had
alleged in his writ petition that his answer paper was not
evaluated properly at the behest and dictates of C.G.M.
(H.R & A) with whom he had some personal animosity.
He pleaded that since he had made certain allegations of
irregularities against the said Officer, at his behest, his
answer paper in English Paper-I was not properly
evaluated. Hence, it contended by the petitionerappellant in person that his answer paper should be
called for by the Court and should be properly
evaluated. The petitioner also went on to give the
instances in which he had made the allegations against
the C.G.M.(H.R & A). As it appears from his own
pleadings in the writ petition on his representation for
revaluation. the AGM (Finance) in his letter dated
27.11.2008 had informed the petitioner that the marks
secured by him in English Paper-1 has been verified and
found correct. It further appears from his pleadings that
excepting bald averments regarding the allegations
against the C.C.M (H.R & A), no material was brought
on record on behalf of the petitioner in support of his
contention that his answer paper was wrongly evaluated
at the behest of the said Officer. The learned Single
Judge has quoted the details furnished on behalf of the
opposite party regarding the qualifying mark and has
observed that since the petitioner did not obtain
qualifying mark in English Paper-1, he has been rightly
declared fail.
5.
So far as the submissions to call for the answer paper
and to examine it or to put it for revaluation, such a
practice has been repeatedly deprecated by the Hon'ble
Apex Court.
6. It was observed by the Hon'ble Apex Court in a decision
reported in AIR, 1984, SC 1543 (Maharashtra State
Board of Secondary and Higher Secondary Education
and another v. Paritosh Bhupesh Kurmarsheth, etc. etc.,)
that:
‘the court should be extremely reluctant to substitute its
own views as to what is wise, prudent and proper in
relation to academic matters in preference to those
formulated by professional men possessing technical
expertise and rich experience of actual day today
working of educational institution and the controlling
them.’
It was further observed that if inspection, verification in
the presence of the candidates and revaluation are to be
allowed as of right, it may lead to gross and indefinite
uncertainty, in the instant case the evaluation has been
conducted by an internal process followed by the
competent authorities and as stated earlier, except some
bald averments alleging against the senior authorities of
the appellant, we do not find any convincing material to
have even a presumption that any partiality was made
towards the petitioner-appellant. It has been the
observation of the Hon'ble Apex Court that the principle
of natural justice cannot be extended beyond reasonable
and rational limits and cannot be carried to such absurd
length so as to make it necessary that candidates who
have taken a public examination, should be allowed to
participate in the process of the evaluation of their
performances or to verify the correctness of the
evaluation made by the examiners.
7.
2.4.
In the given circumstances, we do not find any merit to
accede to the contention made by the petitionerappellant that his answer paper should be called for and
reevaluated.”
Against the said judgment dated 12.02.2019, a review petition,
being RVWPET No.49 of 2019, filed, the Division Bench vide
judgment dated 24.11.2021 having found no merit dismissed
the same.
3.
A second journey commenced. The present appellant seeking
fresh evaluation of answer sheet (English) in connection with
3rd D.T. Examination, CESU held during April, 2008 filed
subsequent writ petition, being W.P.(C) No.21578 of 2022,
which came to be dismissed on 17.10.2022 with the following
order:
“1.
This matter is taken up through hybrid mode.
3.1.
2.
Petitioner, after making some arguments, seeks
permission to withdraw this writ petition. To that effect,
a memo dated 17.10.2022 has been filed.
3.
Accordingly,
withdrawn.”
the
writ
petition
is
dismissed
as
Though the writ petition was withdrawn without seeking liberty
to file fresh, against the said order of dismissal upon
withdrawal, an Appeal, being W.A.No.1737 of 2022, was
preferred which came to be dismissed on 15.01.2025 with the
following observation:
3.2.
“4.
In the memo of appeal, the appellant has stated that
according to the order passed by the learned Single
Judge, arguments were made and permission was
granted to withdraw the case, but no such argument was
made as there was no one present for the opposite
parties and, therefore, question of argument does not
arise. He has further asserted that the learned Single
Judge had directed the appellant to withdraw the case
otherwise penalty would be imposed upon him.
5.
The ground which has been taken in the present intracourt appeal questioning the correctness of the order
passed by the learned Single Judge of this Court is not at
all sustainable.
6.
We are of the view that the averments made in the
present intra-court appeal are contumacious.
7.
The writ appeal is dismissed with the liberty to the
petitioner to seek review of the order, which is under
challenge in the present writ appeal.”
With such liberty to file review, the appellant filed a review
petition being RVWPET No.49 of 2025 before the learned
Single Judge, which was dismissed vide order dated 10.11.2025
with the following:
“1.
This matter is taken up through hybrid mode.
2.
Heard Mr. C. Sahoo, Petitioner in person and Mr. P.
Mohanty, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Opp.
Party No. 1.
3.
Perused the office note.
4.
Since notice has been duly served on Opp. Party No.2,
notice against the said Opp. Party is treated as sufficient.
5.
Petitioner appeared in person and contended that the
present Review has been filed in terms of order dt.
15.01.2025 so passed in W.A. No.1737 of 2022.
6.
It is contended that Petitioner since on compelling
circumstances was asked to withdraw the Writ Petition
and accordingly a memo was filed with disposal of the
Writ Petition vide order dt. 17.10.2022, against the said
order, the Writ Appeal was field. The Writ Appellate
Court in W.A. No.1737 of 2022 while dismissing the
appeal granted liberty to the Petitioner to seek review of
the order.
7.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of Opp. Party No.
1 on the other hand contended that in course of hearing
of the matter on 17.10.2022, the Review Petitioner suo
moto filed a memo seeking withdrawal of the Writ
Petition and accordingly the matter was dismissed as
withdrawn.
8.
Having heard learned counsel appearing for the parties
and after going through the memo available in the writ
petition, it is found that such a memo was filed by the
Petitioner who was appeared in the matter in person on
17.10.2022 and under no compelling circumstances such
a memo was filed as pleaded in the Writ Appeal.
Therefore, this Court is not inclined to review order dt.
17.10.2022.
9.
The Review Petition according stands dismissed.”
3.3.
After dismissal of the said Review Petition, the petitioner has
come up before this Court in the present Writ Appeal.
4.
Heard the Appellant-Mr. Chakradhar Sahoo, who appeared in
person and Mr. Pranaya Mohanty, learned Advocate appearing
for the opposite parties-CESU.
5.
With the narration of the checkered career of the case, it is
pertinent to mention that after having withdrawn the writ
petition being W.P.(C) No.21578 of 2022 on 17.10.2022 by
filing a memo to the effect that “the petitioner does not want to
proceed with the aforesaid writ application and may be
permitted to withdraw the writ application”, the Writ Appeal,
being W.A.No.1737 of 2022 vide order dated 15.01.2022 has
rightly been dismissed. Upon dismissal of writ appeal (W.A.
No.220 of 2018) against order dated 12.10.2017 in W.P.(C)
No.8091 of 2009 and review petition being RVWPET No.49 of
2019 being dismissed against the judgment dated 12.02.2019 in
said writ petition, the decision attained finality as the same
remained unchallenged before the higher Court.
5.1.
It is trite that once the proceeding is withdrawn without grant of
liberty to file afresh on the self-same cause of action, it creates
an estoppel into the litigation to reopen the issues emanated in
the prior instituted writ petition. [See, Marion Bibi Vrs. Union
of India, W.P.(C) No.24817 of 2025 disposed of vide Order
dated 14.10.2025 of this Court.]
5.2.
In the case of State of Orissa and another Vrs. Laxmi Narayan
Das, (2023) 10 SCR 1049, the question as to whether after
withdrawal of a suit seeking the same relief without having
permission to institute fresh one for the self-same relief, the
writ petition would be maintainable before the Court, has been
answered in the negatived. In the said case, it is held as follows:
“37. On the question, as to whether after the withdrawal of a
suit claiming the same relief without having permission
to institute fresh one for the same relief, a writ petition
will be maintainable before the Court, the guidance is
available from the judgment of this Court in M.J.
Exporters Private Limited v. Union of India and others
(2021) 13 SCC 543, wherein the principle of constructive
res judicata was applied. The case concerns a litigant
who sought to file a fresh writ petition after withdrawal
of the earlier writ petition filed for the same relief
without permission to file fresh one. The Court held that
the principles contained in Order 23, Rule 1 CPC are
applicable even in writ proceedings. Para 15 thereof is
extracted below:
‘15.
38.
In these circumstances, we feel that when this
issue was raised and abandoned in the first writ
petition which was dismissed as withdrawn, the
principles of constructive res judicata which are
laid down under Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908, and which principles are
extendable to writ proceedings as well as held by
this in Sarguja Transport Service Vrs. STAT,
(1987) 1 SCC 5.”
Having regard to the principles laid down in M.J.
Exporters Private Limited (supra), in our view, applying
the principles of constructive res judicata, the present
writ petition filed by the respondents after withdrawal
of the civil suit, was not maintainable, in the sense that
it ought not to have been entertained. In case the
respondents still wanted to justify filing of the writ
petition, they should have at least disclosed complete
facts and then justify filing of the writ petition.”
5.3.
It may not be out of place to have regard to principle underlying
in Order XLVII, Rule 71 of the Code Civil Procedure, 1908.
The review petition, being RVWPET No.49 of 2025, has been
dismissed vide order dated 10.11.2025 by the learned Single
Judge. Therefore, on the principle enshrined in Order XLVII,
Rule 7(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, an order of the Court
rejecting the review petition is not amenable to be appealed.
5.4.
It is further noticed from the cause title of W.P.(C) No.21578 of
2022, that in said writ petition, the petitioner sought for “fresh
evaluation of answer-sheet (English) in connection with 3rd
D.T. Examination of CESU held during April, 2008”. Such
claim of relief and the factual position attained finality in the
earlier round of litigation. Perusal of judgment dated
12.10.2017 of the learned Single Bench rendered in W.P.(C)
No.8091 of 2009 it is unequivocally manifest that the subjectmatter of W.P.(C) No.21578 of 2022 is the same. The said
judgment in W.P.(C) No.8091 of 2009 having got affirmed in
Appeal bearing W.A. No.220 of 2018 vide judgment dated
12.02.2019, the findings and observations of the learned Single
Judge merged with the Division Bench Judgment. The said
findings and observations being not varied or set aside by any
Order XLVII, Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 stands thus:
“7.
Order of rejection not appealable. Objections to order granting application.—
(1)
An order of the Court rejecting the application shall not be appealable; but an order
granting an application may be objected to at once by an appeal from the order
granting the application or in an appeal from the decree or order finally passed or
made in the suit.
(2)
Where the application has been rejected in consequence of the failure of the applicant
to appear, he may apply for an order to have the rejected application restored to the
file, and, where it is proved to the satisfaction of the Court that he was prevented by
any sufficient cause from appearing when such application was called on for hearing,
the Court shall order it to be restored to the file upon such terms as to costs or
otherwise as it thinks fit, and shall appoint a day for hearing the same.
(3)
No order shall be made under sub-rule (2) unless notice of the application has been
served on the opposite party.”
higher Court, there is no scope for revisiting such finding and
observation made in earlier round of litigation.
6.
In the wake of above, this Court finds no merit in the present
Writ Appeal which is directed against the order dated
17.10.2022 passed in W.P.(C) No.21578 of 2022 and order
dated 10.11.2025 passed in RVWPET No.49 of 2025.
7.
In the result, the Writ Appeal stands dismissed.
(Harish Tandon)
Chief Justice
(M.S. Raman)
Judge
Bichi
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BICHITRANANDA SAHOO
Designation: Secretary
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Date: 06-Apr-2026 19:17:39
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review