Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA
ON THE 23rd JANUARY, 2024
WRIT APPEAL No. 1768 of 2023
BETWEEN:CENTURY TEXTILE AND INDUSTRIES LTD. THROUGH
AUTHOR I S ED SIGNATORY VILLAGE AND POST
SATRATI
A.B.
ROAD
TEHSIL
KASRAWAD
DISTT.KHARGONE AND NOW REPRESENTED AS
CENTURY BHAVAN DR. ANNIE BASENT ROAD
CENTURY BAZAR WORLI (MAHARASHTRA)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI BRIEN DA SILVA, LEARNED SENIOR COUNSEL WITH SHRI
SUDEEP BHARGAVA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT)
AND
1.
SHRAMIK JANTA SANGH THROUGH ITS
SECRETARY
SANJAY
CHAUHAN, VILLAGE
MAGARKHEDI,
POST
SATRATI
TEHSIL
KASRAWAD
DISTT.
KHARGONE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
LABOUR
COMMISSIONER, 518, NEW MOTI
BUNGALOW, M.G. ROAD INDORE(MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MS. MEDHA PATKAR, APPEARING ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT
NO.1)
Reserved on
: 20.12.2023
Pronounced on : 23-01-2024
.....................................................................................................................
This Writ Appeal having been heard and reserved for orders, coming on for
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 23-01-2024
04:36:24
pronouncement this day, Hon'ble Shri Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari
passed the following :
JUDGMENT
Heard finally with the consent of both the parties.
T h e present writ appeal under Section 2(1) of the Madhya Pradesh
Uchcha Nyayalaya(Khand Nyaya Peeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 assails the
o r d e r dated 13.09.2023(Annexure-A/1), passed in W.P. No.28206/2021
whereby, the learned Single Judge has allowed the writ petition by setting aside
the impugned order dated 13.12.2021 and remanded the matter back to the
Commissioner to make a reference of dispute in accordance with law, within a
period of six weeks. The appellant being aggrieved has filed the present writ
appeal.
3. Brief facts of the case are that the respondent No.1 had filed a writ
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India being aggrieved by the
order dated 13.12.2021, passed by the Labour Commissioner, Indore whereby
the Labour Commissioner has refused to refer the industrial dispute under
Section 10(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947(hereinafter referred to as the
'Act of 1947') to the Court, holding that there is no dispute in existence between
the workmen and the Company which can be referred to the Court.
4. The appellant had issued notice intimating that it intends to sell the two
Units to M/s. Manjeet Global Private Limited and M/s Manjeet Cotton Private
Limited and as a consequence, offered Voluntary Retirement Scheme/Voluntary
Separation Scheme to be availed within 15 days of issuance of notice. It had
also intimated that if the Workmen fails to avail the said scheme within the time
permitted, they would be dealt in accordance with law. The respondent No.1
alongwith two other Workmen being aggrieved with the said notice and the
proposed transfer filed a writ petition bearing W.P. No.11885/2021 alleging
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 23-01-2024
04:36:24
violation of the provisions of the Act of 1947. The said writ petition was
disposed of granting liberty to the respondent No.1 to avail the remedy available
under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Thereafter, the respondent No.1 being
aggrieved with the aforesaid order filed W.A. No.746/2021. The Division Bench
of this Court vide order dated 13.09.2021 dismissed the said appeal, holding as
under :14. Interestingly, the petitioner in relief A and B clearly stated that the
notice dated 29/6/2021 and their action of transferring the employee
is illegal and runs contrary to the provisions of ID Act, 1947. Thus, as
per petitioner's own pleadings, the provisions of I.D. Act are
breached. Thus, we are unable to hold that remedy under the ID Act is
not available to the appellant. Apart from this, in view of stand of
learned Sr. Counsel for the respondents., it cannot be doubted that
there exists a remedy under the ID Act, 1947. Pertinently, the
appellant earlier also raised an industrial dispute.
15. The validity of transfer agreement was considered in the previous
reference when intended transfer was to a different unit. As an
incidental and essential question, the industrial court examined the
'business transfer agreement' and said matter traveled to this court
a n d Supreme Court. This itself shows that an alternative statutory
remedy under the ID Act clearly exists. Thus, we are unable to hold
that petitioner will be remediless, if writ petition is not entertained. "
(Emphasis Supplied) .....
5. On 13.10.2021, the respondent No.1, in view of the aforesaid liberty
granted by the Division Bench of this Court, approached the office of Labour
Commissioner by filing an application dated 13.10.2021 under Section 10(2) of
the Act of 1947, seeking reference
of the "Industrial Dispute" before the
Industrial Tribunal.
6. On 21.10.2021, the office of Labour Commissioner, called upon the
appellant Company to file its reply, which was filed on 25.11.2021. Thereafter,
on 06.12.2021 the respondent No.1 filed its rejoinder stating that in view of the
contrary plea raised by the respondent no.1 and the appellant, there exists
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 23-01-2024
04:36:24
"Industrial Dispute" which is apparent on the face of it, and the same needs to
be referred to the Industrial Tribunal for adjudication under Section 10(1) of the
Act of 1947.
7 . Vide impugned order dated 14.12.2021, the Labour Commissioner
refused the request of the respondent no.1 to refer the dispute for adjudication
to the "Industrial Dispute", holding that no industrial dispute exists under
Section 10(1) of the Act of 1947. Being aggrieved, the respondent No.1 had
filed the writ petition.
8. The Learned Single Judge while allowing the writ petition came to the
conclusion and held as under :10] A perusal of the aforesaid decision clearly demonstrates that a
dispute raised by the workmen regarding transfer of a unit to some
other entity can also be the subject matter of an industrial dispute as
provided under Section 10 of the Act of 1947. Thus, this Court is also
of the considered opinion that the dispute cannot be closed only by
referring to Section 25-FF of the Act of 1947. So far as reliance placed
by the Labour Commissioner in the case of Anakapalle (Supra) is
concerned, the same has extensively dealt with the scope of Section
25-FF of the Act as in that case, the workmen had demanded for their
re-employment which came to be referred under s.10(1)(d).. In view of
the same, this judgement is distinguishable and has no application in
the facts and circumstances of the case.
11] Accordingly, the petition stands allowed and the impugned order
dated 13.12.2021 is hereby set aside, and the matter is remanded back
to the Commissioner to make a reference of dispute in accordance with
law, within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of certified
copy of this order.
12] With the aforesaid, the petition stands allowed and disposed of.
9. Being aggrieved, the appellant has filed the present writ appeal.
10. Learned Senior Counsel for the appellant contended that the learned
Single Judge has allowed the writ petition solely on the basis of judgment of the
Apex Court in the case of Ariane Orgachem Private Limited Vs. Wyeth
Employees Union reported in (2015) 7 SCC 561 without considering the
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 23-01-2024
04:36:24
facts and merits of the case and without considering the factor of the judgment
submitted by the appellant.
11. In the case of Ariane Orgachem Private Limited Vs. Wyeth
Employees Union(Supra), the challenge was to the VRS(Voluntary Retirement
Scheme),
acceptance of VRS and the competency of the Dy. Labour
Commissioner (who refused to refer dispute) were under consideration, which
squarely falls under the definition of "Industrial Disputes" as defined under
Section 2(k) of the Act of 1947. However, in the present case of the appellant,
no such dispute exists. Further, it is stated that neither the VRS or acceptance
thereof, nor the competency of the authority who refused to refer matter under
Section 10 of the Act of 1947 was under challenge.
12. Learned Senior Counsel contended that the respondent No.1 is a
State Union and, therefore, it cannot represent any worker outside the State in
which it is registered i.e., in present case State of Maharashtra. Even otherwise,
none of the ex-employees of the respondent No.2 have authorised any office
bearer to represent them in this petition or otherwise. The Resolution dated
23.04.2023 is an afterthought and is without authority under the bye-laws of the
Union. Moreover, the resolution is dated 23.04.2023 whereas the petition is
pending since 2021.
13. So far as powers of Labour Commissioner is concerned, the learned
Single Judge has failed to appreciate the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Apex
Court in a landmark judgment of Rahman Industries Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State of
U.P. & Ors.[AIR 2016 SC 551]. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the above case
held as under :4. We find force in the submission made by the learned Counsel. In the
scheme of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as
‘the Act’), it is not as if the Government has to act as a post office by
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 23-01-2024
04:36:24
referring each and every petition received by them. The Government is
well within its jurisdiction to see whether there exists a dispute worth
referring for adjudication. No doubt, the Government is not entitled to
enter a finding on the merits of the case and decline reference. The
Government has to satisfy itself, after applying its mind to the relevant
factors and satisfy itself to the existence of dispute before taking a
decision to refer the same for adjudication. Only in case, on judicial
scrutiny, the court finds that the refusal of the Government to make a
reference of the dispute is unjustified on irrelevant factors, the court
may issue a direction to the Government to make a reference.
14. The ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as mentioned
above is squarely applicable in the present case. The learned Single Judge has
failed to consider that the respondent no.2 has not "adjudicated" anything but
has only narrated the correct facts, on the basis of documents on records
produced by the appellant and rightfully opined that there exists no dispute
between the appellant and the respondent no.1.
15. In view of the above, it is clear that the Labour Commissioner is duty
bound under the Act to apply his mind and decide whether the dispute
presented before him is an "Industrial Dispute" as defined under the Act or not.
In the present case, the Labour Commissioner has rightly reached to the
conclusion that the transaction of Sale is not an "Industrial Dispute" and the
same can not be referred to the Tribunal. Hence, the learned Single Judge has
erred in holding that the transaction of "Sale of an Undertaking" can be an
"Industrial Dispute" within the meaning of Section 2 (k) of the Act. Therefore, it
is most humbly submitted that the present appeal should be allowed and the
impugned order should be quashed and set aside.
16. Learned Senior Counsel for the appellant contended that as per
Schedule-III of the Act of 1947, it is clearly mentioned as to what can be
referred to the "Industrial Dispute" and what cannot. The issue of transfer of
industry does not fall under Schedule-III, therefore, the finding of the learned
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 23-01-2024
04:36:24
Single Judge that the issue of transfer of a unit also amounts to "Industrial
Dispute", is totally incorrect. He further contended that if fraud or sham is
pleaded or claimed then it has to be proved, but in the present case, thee are no
specific pleadings with regard to fraud.
17. Per contra, Ms. Medha Patkar, appearing on behalf of respondent
No.1 Shramik Janta Sangh contended that the order passed by the learned
Single Judge is absolutely in consonance with the provisions of Industrial
Dispute Act, 1947 and the learned Single Judge has rightly set aside the order
impugned dated 13.12.2021 referring the matter back to the Commissioner for
adjudication under the Industrial Dispute Act.
She further relied upon the
decision rendered by the Supreme Court in the case of Anakapalle
Cooperative Society Vs. Kamgar reported in AIR 1963 SC 1489 in support
of their contention. She further contended that the transaction between Century
and Manjeet Global Private Limited and Manjeet Cotton Private Limited is a
sham transaction, and since no allegations have been made in respect of the
employment or the conditions of employment, the Labour Commissioner came
to the conclusion that the disputes cannot be termed as an "Industrial Dispute"
and cannot be referred under Section 10(1)d) of the Act of 1947 as the same is
contrary to the provisions of law.
1 8 . Ms. Patkar, appearing on behalf of respondent No.1 further
contended that Section 25(O) of the Act was not followed before Section 25FF of the Act was implemented. It was further contended that there was no
proper procedure for closing down the units was followed as envisaged under
Section 25(O) of the Act of 1947.
19. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
20. The definition of “industrial dispute” is very wide and includes any
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 23-01-2024
04:36:24
dispute or difference between employer and employer or between employers
and workmen or even between workmen and workmen which is connected with
the employment or even with non-employment or terms of employment. It is
contended that in view of Section 10(1)(d) of ID Act, only such disputes can be
referred for adjudication which are covered under II or III Schedule under the
ID Act. We do not see any merit in the said contention. A careful reading of
clause (d) shows that it talks about reference of dispute to Tribunal or any
matter appearing to be connected with or relevant to the dispute. The clause (d)
is into two parts. First part talks about reference of dispute whereas the
remaining part talks about any matter which may be connected with the dispute
and for said kind of matters, it is mentioned that it may be specified in IInd or
IIIrd Schedule. This is trite law that the word “or” is normally disjunctive and
“and” is normally conjunctive. See Principles of Interpretation of Statute by
Justice G.P. Singh (page 477 12th Edition). Thus, a conjoint reading of Section
2(k) and 10(1) (d) shows that the appropriate government can refer an industrial
dispute for adjudication even if it is not covered under IInd or IIIrd Schedule.
Any other interpretation will make the use of word “or” meaningless. This is
trite law that when a provision is clear and unambiguous it must be given effect
to irrespective of consequences. See 1992 (4) SCC 711 (Nelson Motis vs.
Union of India and another). Thus, as per the text and in the context “or” is
used, we are constrained to hold that power of appropriate government is not
confined to refer the dispute only when it is covered by IInd or IIIrd Schedule.
21. As held in the case of Ariane Orgachem Private Limited Vs.
Wyeth Employees Union(Supra), wherein the Apex Court has come to the
conclusion that these are the disputed question of facts in the case, which
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 23-01-2024
04:36:24
requires determination on the basis of evidence by the Industrial Tribunal and,
therefore, a valid reference has to be made to it by the State Government.
22. Prima facie, it is seen from the records that there exists a dispute
between the employer and the employees, therefore, the same needs to be
adjudicated by referring the matter to the Industrial Tribunal under the Industrial
Dispute Act. The learned Single Judge has rightly come to the conclusion that in
the case of Anakapalle(Supra), the same has extensively dealt with the scope
of Section 25-FF of the Act where the workmen had demanded for their reemployment.
The
said judgment is distinguishable in the facts and
circumstances of the case.
23. The learned Single Judge has rightly allowed the writ petition in as
much as the disputed questions of facts as to whether the units were properly
closed or not or the procedure under Section 25(O) of the Industrial Disputes
Act has been followed or not in true letter and spirit, can only be gone into by
recording evidence by the Industrial Tribunal. As such, no error has been
found to have been committed by the learned Single Judge in allowing the writ
petition filed by the respondent no.1. Accordingly, finding no merits in the
appeal, the same is hereby dismissed.
24. The concerned respondent/authority is directed to comply with the
o r d er dated 13.09.2023, passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.
No.28206/2021. The Commissioner is directed to make a reference of dispute
in accordance with law, within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of
certified copy of the order.
The writ appeal is accordingly dismissed. No order as to costs.
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 23-01-2024
04:36:24
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
pn
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 23-01-2024
04:36:24
(PRANAY VERMA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review