Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
KABORA Digitally signed
MBAM by
KABORAMBAM
SINGH
SANDEE SANDEEP
Date: 2023.01.31
15:57:08 +05'30'
P SINGH
Item No. 38
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (C) No. 765 of 2016
1. The
Central
Agricultural
University
(CAU),
Imphal,
Manipur, represented by the Vice-Chancellor (CAU),
Imphal, Manipur – 795004.
2. The Registrar, Central Agricultural University, Imphal,
Manipur – 795004.
3. The Dean, College of Agricultural Engineering and PostHarvest Technology, Ranipool, Gangtok, Sikkim – 737135.
Petitioner
Vs.
1. Shri Gopal Bhandari, S/o Nilakanta Bhandari, P.O. Rawtey
Rumtek East Sikkim, Pin Code – 737135.
2. Shri Pawan Chettri, S/o (L) B.B Chettri, resident of Lower
Pani House, Indira Bye Pass Road, Gangtok, East Sikkim,
Pin Code – 737135.
Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SANJAY KUMAR
HON'BLEMR. JUSTICE MV MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. BP Sahu, Sr. Advocate
For the Respondents
:
Mr. H. Maipaksana, Advocate
Date of Order
:
30.01.2023
ORDER (ORAL)
Sanjay Kumar (C.J.):
[1]
The Central Agricultural University, Manipur, and its officials filed
this writ petition aggrieved by the order dated 13.05.2016 passed by the Central
Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati Bench, in O.A. No. 040/00155/2015. The said
Page 1
O.A. was filed by the respondents herein assailing their termination from service
under orders dated 16.03.2015. By its order dated 13.05.2016, the Tribunal noted
that the University and its officials had shown little interest in contesting the O.A.
and had not even filed a reply, justifying the termination orders, and held on facts
that the termination of the applicants before it was in violation of the principles of
natural justice and contrary to the stipulation made in their appointment letters.
The termination orders dated 16.03.2015 were accordingly set aside and the
University and more particularly, the Registrar of the University, was directed to
reinstate them immediately along with consequential benefits.
By order dated 07.10.2016 passed in this writ petition, a Division
Bench of this Court suspended the operation of the order dated 13.05.2016
passed by the Tribunal. On 16.11.2016, the interim order dated 07.10.2016 was
directed to continue until further orders and is presently operative.
[2]
Heard Mr. BP Sahu, learned senior counsel, appearing for the
petitioners, viz., the University and its officials; and Mr. H. Maipaksana, learned
counsel for the respondents, viz., the applicants in the O.A.
[3]
Advertisement No. 2 of 2012 dated 15.06.2012 was issued by the
Central Agricultural University, Manipur, inviting applications for filling up the
posts of Library Assistant (1 post), Live Stock/Farm Assistant (2 posts), Fieldcum-Lab Assistant (5 posts) , Medical Attendant (1 post), Driver(2 posts),
Handyman-cum-cleaner(1
post)
and
Multi
Tasking
Staff
{(Field-cum-Lab
Attendant/Cook/Helper/Messenger etc.)(6 posts)}. These posts were at the
College of Agricultural Engineering and Post Harvest Technology, Ranipool,
Sikkim. The Advertisement did not indicate that the posts were temporary in
Page 2
nature or were contiguous with any particular scheme. The respondents herein
were selected and appointed as Multi Tasking Staff (Helpers) vide orders dated
23.09.2013. Their appointment as Helpers was stated to have been made under
the All India Co-ordinated Research Project (AICRP) on RES at the College of
Agricultural Engineering and Post Harvest Technology, Ranipool, Sikkim. They
were put on the pay-scale of ₹. 5,200-20,200 with Grade Pay of ₹. 1,800.
However, their appointment orders contained Condition No.3 which read thus:
“3. The appointment is till the continuation of the project by ICAR and
co-terminus with the project and he will have no claim for permanent
absorption /appointment in the university.”
It is the case of the University that the Project Coordinator (AICRP) on
Renewable Resources of Energy for Agriculture and Agro-based Industries,
ICAR/CIAE/Bhopal, intimated it by letter dated 01.01.2015 that the ICAR had
decided to close the Centre of the AICRP on RES located at Gangtok with effect
from 01.04.2015. In consequence thereof, the University issued orders dated
16.03.2015 to both the respondents, quoting the aforestated Condition No. 3 in
their appointment orders, and informed them that their services were no longer
required and would stand terminated with effect from 31.03.2015. It is against
these orders that the respondents approached the Tribunal.
[4]
As already stated supra, the University and its officials did not even
choose to contest the case before the Tribunal by filing a reply. Thereupon, the
Tribunal noted the contents of the Advertisement dated 15.06.2012 and the fact
that the respondents were placed on probation for a period of 2 years from the
date of their joining and inferred that their appointment was in the nature of a
Page 3
regular appointment. Opining thus, the Tribunal set aside the termination orders
dated 16.03.2015 and granted them relief.
[5]
Mr. H. Maipaksana, learned counsel for the respondents, contended
before this Court that others who had been selected and appointed pursuant to
the Advertisement dated 15.06.2012 were retained in service even though they
were less meritorious than his clients. This Court accordingly directed the
University to produce the merit list of the candidates who appeared pursuant to
the Advertisement dated 15.06.2012. With great reluctance and after a number of
adjournments, the University finally produced the said merit list. Perusal thereof
reflects that 501 applications were received against the 6 posts of Multi Tasking
Staff notified vide the Advertisement dated 15.06.2012. After shortlisting by the
duly constituted Screening Committee, interview calls were issued to 90
candidates and 81 (ST-14, OBC-27 and Gen-40) candidates appeared for the
interviews on 08.05.2013 before the Selection Committee. Based on the academic
records, relevant work experience, skill test and performance in the interview, the
Committee recommended 6 candidates for appointment to the 6 notified posts of
Multi Tasking Staff: Sonam Bhutia (41.90 Marks) was appointed against the ST
vacancy, while Gopal Bhandari (45.89 Marks) and Pawan Chettri (44.07), the
respondents herein, were appointed against the OBC vacancies. Sushanta Parida,
Deepa Pradhan and Anupama Chettri, with 49.51, 48.46 and 46.61 Marks
respectively, were appointed against the three general category vacancies. The
merit list placed before this Court further reflects that one Neeraj Kumar, who
secured 41.88 marks, was included in the 3rd waiting list. Surprisingly, the
Selection Committee made no such recommendation, but the words – ‘WLT’ were
noted against the name of Neeraj Kumar.
Page 4
[6]
Significantly,
when
Pawan
Chettri,
respondent
No.2
herein,
submitted an application to the University under the Right to Information Act,
2005, with regard to the list of 17 candidates who were selected against the
Advertisement dated 15.06.2012, a tabular statement of 17 candidates was
furnished by the University, under its letter dated 01.07.2015. Perusal thereof
reflects that, out of the 17 candidates who were appointed against the said
Advertisement, only Gopal Bandhari and Pawan Chettri, the respondents herein,
were terminated from service and all the others, including Neeraj Kumar who was
a waitlisted candidate, are being continued. Orders dated 23.09.2013 were issued
by the Central Agricultural University, Manipur, transferring Sandeep Kumar
Banya, Workshop Mate, and Sarina Thapa, Helper, from All India Coordinated
Research Project on RES, College of Agricultural Engineering and Post Harvest
Technology, Ranipool, to the said College with immediate effect. Both these
persons were not even shown as wait-listed candidates in the merit list and had,
in fact, secured far lesser marks than the respondents (Sandeep Kumar Banya –
41.21 Marks; Sarina Thapa – 37.09 Marks) but they were continued in service.
[7]
It is therefore clear that other employees who were appointed
against the same time-bound scheme were transferred to regular posts in the
College but only the respondents were targeted for termination from service on
the ground that their appointment was contiguous with the scheme, as per
Condition No. 3 in their appointment orders.
[8]
No doubt, the orders of appointment dated 23.09.2013 issued by
the University to the others who were selected against the Advertisement dated
15.06.2012 merely mentioned that their appointment was temporary and could
Page 5
be terminated by giving three months’ notice without referring to the
appointment being contiguous with the scheme, as was mentioned in the case of
the respondents, but that by itself did not justify the University adopting a
different stand against them. Crucial to note, there was no mention of any time
bound scheme in the Advertisement dated 15.06.2012 at all and the respondents
were amongst the candidates directly selected by the Selection Committee
against the 6 notified posts. There is no explanation from the University as to why
they are subjected to contiguity with a time bound scheme when others who
were waitlisted and appointed thereafter, with far lesser marks, were subjected to
favourable treatment by continuing them in service in the College even after the
winding up of the time bound scheme. This patent discrimination clearly shows
how the University is bestowing favours to candidates of its liking despite their
lower placement in the merit ranking and smacks of blatant arbitrariness.
[9]
In these circumstances, we find no reason whatsoever to interfere
with the order dated 13.05.2016 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal,
Guwahati Bench, in O.A. No. 040/00155/2015 and the consequential direction
issued to the University and its officials to reinstate the respondents in service
with all consequential benefits.
W.P. (C) No. 765 of 2016 is accordingly dismissed.
Interim order dated 07.10.2016 shall stand vacated.
In the circumstances, there shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sandeep
Page 6
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review