The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Before further discussion it would be appropriate to extract the relevant paragraphs of the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal. “Accordingly, we find that this matter is squarely covered under the conditions stipulated in paragraphs 12(i) and 12 (iii) of the Rafiq Masih (supra) judgment. It is not fair at this length of time for the respondents to turn around and issue a notice of recovery after the amounts were given more than ten years prior to the OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023 -8- 2025:KER:15549 issue of the recovery notice. What is to be considered, as also laid down in the judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Kerala in W.A. No.310/2022 dated 03.06.2022 in University of Calicut & Ors. vs. Dr.C. Rajendran & Ors. (2022) ICO 705 is that this Tribunal should examine, whether the circumstances in which the recovery of excess amount paid by mistake is being done would result in the hardship of such nature which would far outweigh the equitable balance of the employers right to recover. Such an interpretation is also found in Rafiq Masih (supra). In other words, the Hon’ble High Court of Kerala held that interference would be called for only in such cases where it would be iniquitous to recover the payment made. In paragraph 11 of the Hon’ble High Court held as under : “11. The only circumstance in which the recovery of excess amount paid by mistake is not recovered is when …
10. Flowing from the above, we hold that the recovery at this point of time from the pension of a retired UDC would be iniquitous and attracting the circumstances which have been laid down in the above judgment. We, therefore, do not allow the said recovery to be made and accordingly direct the respondents to refund the amount retained by them which they had deducted from the pensionary benefits due to the applicant at the time of his retirement. However, wer are not directing any payment of interest etc, in this matter as the retention was made with the direction of this Tribunal during the course of hearing of the O.A. on 09.04.2021. Further, it is also made clear that all other pensionary benefits, if not already released, should be released immediately to the applicant as due if there are no other issues to be considered.” On going through the order of the Central OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023 -10- 2025:KER:15549 Administrative Tribunal, we do not find any illegality, perversity, much less fallacy in the order of the tribunal. The tribunal is justified in disallowing the interest to the petitioner/applicant, in our view. O.P.(CAT) is devoid of merit and therefore, stands dismissed. Sd/AMIT RAWAL vv Sd/K. V. JAYAKUMAR -11- OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023 2025:KER:15549 ANNEXURE A13 MEMO.NO.KNR-7(2)/2017-18/AC/319 DT:22.2.2018 ISSUED BY THE 4TH ANNEXURE A18 MEMO.NO.KNR-7(2)/2018-19/AC/1078 D…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 7TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 18TH MAGHA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 23.09.2022 IN OA NO.1012 OF 2018 OF
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONER/APPLICANT:
C. RAVEENDRAN,
AGED 62 YEARS
S/O.LATE KRISHNAN, UPPER DIVISION CLERK,(RETD),
ALL INDIA RADIO KANNUR STATION,
KANNU-RESIDING AT SREEKUNJU CHEMPAD P.O.,
THALASSERY., PIN - 670694
BY ADV.
C.S.GOPALAKRISHNAN NAIR
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA,
REP.BY ITS SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL,
PUBLIC GRIEVANCES AND PENSIONS,
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND TRAINING,
SOUTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI, PIN - 110001
PRASARBHARATHI BROADCASTING CORPORATION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, NEW DELHI,
PIN - 110001
DIRECTOR GENERAL,
ALL INDIA RADIO, AKASHVANI BHAVAN,
SANSAD MARG, NEW DELHI, PIN - 110001
HEAD OF OFFICE,
ALL INDIA RADIO, KANNUR, PIN - 670004
-2-
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
2025:KER:15549
BY ADV.
SRI.T.C.KRISHNA (DSGI IN CHARGE)
THIS
07.02.2025,
FOLLOWING:
OP
(CAT)
THE
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
ADMISSION
ON
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
-3-
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
2025:KER:15549
JUDGMENT
K. V. JAYAKUMAR, J.
Dissatisfied
Administrative
with
the
Tribunal
order
of
dated
the
Central
23.09.2022
in
O.A.No.1012/2018, the applicant preferred this OP(CAT).
2.
The petitioner/applicant approached the
Tribunal claiming the following reliefs:
“(i)
To call for the records leading upto the
issue of Annexure-A13 and A18 and
quash the same.
(ii)
To direct the 4th respondent not to
effect any recovery from his salary or
any other amount due to him.
(iii)
To grant such other relief or reliefs that
may be prayed for or that are found to
be just and proper in the nature and
circumstances of the case.
(iv)
To grant cost of this O.A.”
3.
The
petitioner,
C.
Raveendran,
was
working as an Upper Division Clerk (UDC) in the All India
Radio, Kannur. While implementing the Central Civil
Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008 [hereinafter referred
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
-4-
2025:KER:15549
to
as,
‘the
CCS(RP)
Rules’],
the
pay
of
the
petitioner/applicant was revised on various occasions due
to erroneous interpretations.
4.
The respondents also accepted that, there
were a series of errors in implementing the relevant part
of the 6th pay Commission Report, which led to erroneous
pay fixation in many offices. The respondents contended
that the beneficiaries of these erroneous fixation took the
benefit of the same and have filed Original Applications
before various Benches of the tribunal across the
country.
5.
The applicant has still been drawing the
benefit under the erroneous calculation. The applicant
approached the tribunal and preferred this Original
Application, when he received a recovery notice stating
that an excess amount of Rs.4,15,302/- had been paid to
him on account of erroneous fixation of pay with effect
from 01.01.2006.
6.
The respondents have issued Annexure
A12 letter to him, in which, it was stated that an amount
-5-
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
2025:KER:15549
of Rs.4,15,302/- was paid to him as excess pay and
allowance and the same is due for recovery. They have
also produced a due-drawn statement applicable to him
in this regard.
Thereafter, the respondents issued
Annexure A13 notice dated 22.02.2018 and Annexure
A18
notice
dated
30.11.2018
directing
the
A13
A18
petitioner/applicant to remit the amount.
7.
Challenging
Annexures
and
notices the applicant approached the tribunal and he
obtained a favourable order of stay for the recovery, till
the disposal of the Original application.
During the
pendency of the Original Application, the applicant
retired from service on 31.05.2020. On 24.02.2021, the
learned counsel for the petitioner/applicant made a
submission before the tribunal that, the respondents
were not releasing the pensionary benefits since the
petitioner had filed the Original Application.
On the
basis of the submission, the tribunal directed the
respondents
to
disburse
the
retiral
benefits
after
deducting the claim of the respondents with regard to the
-6-
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
2025:KER:15549
recovery.
8.
parties,
Noticing the rival contentions of the
the
tribunal
petitioner/applicant
impermissible.
allowed
and
The
held
tribunal
the
that
claim
the
further
of
recovery
directed
the
is
the
respondents to refund the amount retained by them,
which they had deducted from the pensionary benefits
due to the applicant at the time of his retirement.
However, the tribunal did not award the interest for the
amount
of
pensionary
benefits
retained
by
the
respondents as per the interim order of the tribunal.
9.
The grievance of the petitioner/applicant
is that the tribunal ought to have granted interest for the
amount
of
pensionary
benefits
retained
by
the
department.
10.
On
the
other
hand,
Sri.T.C.Krishna,
learned Deputy Solicitor General of India (in charge)
appearing for the Union of India submitted that the
impugned order is legally sustainable and no interference
from this Court is warranted.
-7-
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
2025:KER:15549
11.
We have heard the submissions of the
learned counsel for the parties and appraised the paper
books.
12.
The
main
contention
of
the
petitioner/applicant is that, erroneous fixation of pay was
not the mistake of the petitioner. Due to the erroneous
fixation
of
pay and
consequential
proceedings,
his
pensionary benefits were retained as per the interim
order of the tribunal and thereby, he lost substantial
amount by way of interest. The grievance projected by
the petitioner is that the tribunal ought to have awarded
interest for the amount retained by the department.
13.
Before further discussion it would be
appropriate to extract the relevant paragraphs of the
order of the Central Administrative Tribunal.
“Accordingly, we find that this matter is squarely
covered
under
the
conditions
stipulated
in
paragraphs 12(i) and 12 (iii) of the Rafiq Masih
(supra) judgment. It is not fair at this length of
time for the respondents to turn around and
issue a notice of recovery after the amounts
were given more than ten years prior to the
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
-8-
2025:KER:15549
issue of the recovery notice.
What is to be
considered, as also laid down in the judgment of
the Hon’ble High Court of Kerala in W.A.
No.310/2022 dated 03.06.2022 in University of
Calicut & Ors. vs. Dr.C. Rajendran & Ors. (2022)
ICO 705 is that this Tribunal should examine,
whether
the
circumstances
in
which
the
recovery of excess amount paid by mistake is
being done would result in the hardship of such
nature which would far outweigh the equitable
balance of the employers right to recover. Such
an interpretation is also found in Rafiq Masih
(supra). In other words, the Hon’ble High Court
of Kerala held that interference would be called
for only in such cases where it would be
iniquitous to recover the payment made.
In
paragraph 11 of the Hon’ble High Court held as
under :
“11. The only circumstance in
which the recovery of excess amount paid
by mistake is not recovered is when the
recovery would result in the hardship of
such nature which would far outweigh the
equitable balance of the employers right to
recover.
In other words interference
would be called for only in such cases were
it would be iniquitous to recover the
payment made. In order to ascertain the
parameters of the above consideration and
test to be applied, reference needs to be
made to a situations noticed in the
judgment in State of Punjab and Others v.
Rafiq Masih White Washer [(2015) 4 SCC
334]. The exercise of jurisdiction under
Article 142 of the constitution of India for
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
-9-
2025:KER:15549
doing complete justice cannot be treated
as a precedent under Article 141 of the
Constitution of India. It is to be noticed
that public money wrongly paid at the
instance of the official cannot be allowed to
be retained except in the circumstances
noted above. In cases where the employee
had knowledge that the payment received
was in excess of what was due or wrongly
paid, or where the error was detected or
corrected, within a short time of the wrong
payment, courts will not grant relief
against recovery.”
10.
Flowing from the above, we hold that
the recovery at this point of time from the
pension of a retired UDC would be iniquitous
and attracting the circumstances which have
been laid down in the above judgment.
We,
therefore, do not allow the said recovery to be
made and accordingly direct the respondents to
refund the amount retained by them which they
had deducted from the pensionary benefits due
to the applicant at the time of his retirement.
However, wer are not directing any payment of
interest etc, in this matter as the retention was
made with the direction of this Tribunal during
the course of hearing of the O.A. on 09.04.2021.
Further, it is also made clear that all other
pensionary benefits, if not already released,
should be released immediately to the applicant
as due if there are no other issues to be
considered.”
On going through the order of the Central
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
-10-
2025:KER:15549
Administrative Tribunal, we do not find any illegality,
perversity, much less fallacy in the order of the tribunal.
The tribunal is justified in disallowing the interest to the
petitioner/applicant, in our view. O.P.(CAT) is devoid of
merit and therefore, stands dismissed.
Sd/AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
vv
Sd/K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
-11-
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
2025:KER:15549
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 155/2023
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A13
TRUE COPY OF THE
MEMO.NO.KNR-7(2)/2017-18/AC/319
DT:22.2.2018 ISSUED BY THE 4TH
RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE A18
TRUE COPY OF THE
MEMO.NO.KNR-7(2)/2018-19/AC/1078
DT:30.11.2018 ISSUED BY THE 4TH
RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE A1
TRUE COPY OF THE PAY FIXATION
STATEMENT DT:26.9.2008 ISSUED BY THE
4TH RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE A2
TRUE COPY OF THE PAY FIXATION
STATEMENT DT:20.6.2010
ANNEXURE A3
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.KNR/-1(11)
2013-S DT:7.1.2013 ISSUED BY THE 4TH
RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE A4
TRUE COPY OF THE STATEMENT SHOWING
FIXATION OF PAY ISSUED ON 25.7.2013 BY
THE 4TH RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE A5
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO.NO.A26022/02/2012-S.II DT: 19.9.2014
ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT ENCLOSING
A COPY OF THE E-MAIL
ANNEXURE A6
TRUE COPY OF THE PAY FIXATION
STATEMENT NO.KNBR/10(2) 2015-S /2440
DT:27.7.2015 ISSUED BY THE 4TH
RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE A7
TRUE COPY OF THE STATEMENT SHOWING PAY
FIXATION ON 22.3.2016
ANNEXURE A8
TRUE COPY OF THE PAY FIXATION
STATEMENT ISSUED ON 18.5.2016 BY THE
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
-12-
2025:KER:15549
4TH RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE A9
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO
NO.26022/02/2012-S.II DT:10.5.2016
ANNEXURE A10
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO
F.NO.26022/02/2012-S II DT:5.1.2016
ALONG WITH MEMO. F.NO.MISC.1/330/2012-PPC DT:31.12.2015 OF THE
2ND RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE A11
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION
F.NO.MISC.1/330/2012-PPC(PT.)
DT:9.3.2016
ANNEXURE A12
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO NO.KNR/7(2)2017-18/AC/66 DT:5.1.2018 ISSUED
BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE A14
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO
NO.KNR.21(2)2018-S/RC/316 DT:22.2.2018
ISSUED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE A15
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION
DT:1.3.2018
ANNEXURE A16
TRUE COPY OF THE OM.F.NO.18/03/2015ESTT. (PAY-1)DT:2.3.2016
ANNEXURE A17
TRUE COPY OF THE OM NO.A22015/16/2018-S.II DT:22.11.2018
ANNEXURE R1
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION, ISSUED
BY THE GOVERNMENT, THE REVISED PAY
RULES (CCS(REVISED PAY) RULES 2008)
ANNEXURE R2
TRUE COPY OF THE CIRCULAR NO.A26022/02/2012-S-II DATED 3/4.10.2012
ISSUED BY THE DG AIR NEW DELHI
ANNEXURE R3
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.A 26015/3/2014-BAP DATED 20.8.2014
ISSUED BY THE MINISTRY OF I&B ALONG
WITH THE ID NOTE OF THE DEPARTMENT OF
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
-13-
2025:KER:15549
EXPENDITURE VIDE DATED 12.8.2014.
ANNEXURE R4
TRUE COPY OF THE DG :AIR LETTER NO.A26022/02/2012-S-II DATED 05.01.2016
ANNEXURE R5
TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION SUBMITTED
BY THE APPLICANT FOR GRANTING PAY
SCALE WITH GRADE PAY RS.4600/- IN PB2
ANNEXURE R6
TRUE COPY OF OPTION SUBMITTED BY THE
APPLICANT FOR 6TH CPC PAY SCALE.
ANNEXURE R7
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY ISSUED TO THE
APPLICANT WITH A COMPARATIVE STATEMENT
OF SERVICE PARTICULARS OF BOTH THE
APPLICANT AND SHRI. K.BALACHANDRAN
DATED 22.2.2018
ANNEXURE R8
TRUE COPIES OF REPRESENTATIONS
RECEIVED FROM THE APPLICANT
ANNEXURE MA 1
TRUE COPY OF THE PPO NO.285542000718
ANNEXURE MA 2
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER ON 30.5.2020
ISSUED BY THE PAY & ACCOUNTS OFFICER
(ALL INDIA RADIO) CHENNAI
ANNEXURE MA 3
TRUE COPY OF THE SANCTION ORDER ISSUED
BY THE PAO(AIR)
ANNEXURE MA 4
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.KNR-13(2)
2020 DT:22.7.2020 ISSUED BY THE 4TH
RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE MA 5
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DT:25.8.2020
ISSUED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P1
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
APPLICATION NO.180/1012/2018 BEFORE
CAT, ERNAKULAM BENCH
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT FILED
BY THE RESPONDENTS
OP (CAT) NO. 155 OF 2023
-14-
2025:KER:15549
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF THE REJOINDER WAS FILED
BY THE PETITIONER
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE MISCELLANEOUS
APPLICATION NO.631/2020
EXHIBIT P5
A TRUE COPY OF THE INTERIM ORDER DATED
09/04/2021 IN OA 1012/2018
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DT: 23.9.2022
IN OA NO.1012/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review