Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.60 of 2023
1. C/7743 Meghnad Saha, Son of- Nim Chand Saha, Resident of Vill. and P.O.Mohan Bhog, P.S.-Melagarh, Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799105. (Age-47 years)
2. C/11266 Nikhil Chandra Barman, Son of-Lt Satish Chandra Barman,
Resident of-Vill. and P.O.-Rabindra Nagar, Sepahijala, P.S.-Sonamura,
Tripura, Pin-799131. (Age-46 years)
3. C/1703 Ratan Chandra Mahajan, Son of Sri Jogendra Kumar Mahajan,
Resident of- Vill.-West Rajnagar, P.O.-Rajnagar, P.S.-PR Bari, South Tripura,
Pin-799150. (Age-46 years)
4. C/337 Nantu Chanda, Son of Lt Subhash Chanda, Resident of-Vill.-Unnayan
Sangha, North Badharghat, P.O. and P.S.-A.D. Nagar, Tripura, Pin-799003.
(Age - 42 years)
5. T/11373 Sahajahan Majumder, Son of Babul Miah, Resident of-Vill. and
P.O.-Durgapur, P.S.-Sonamura, Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799131. (Age-43
years)
6. C/432 Manoj Kanti Ghosh, Son of Lt. Sachindra Ghosh, Resident of Vill.
and P.O.-A.D. Nagar, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799003. (Age - 44 years)
7. C/6600 Md Azim Uddin, Son of- Lt Badar Uddin, Resident of Vill. and P.O.South Manik Bhandar, P.S. Kamalpur, Dhalai, Tripura, Pin-799287. (Age-46
years)
8. C/8003 Bipul Saha, Son of Lt Sunil Chandra Saha, Resident of Vill.- Chatak
Chari, P.O.-Sonai Bazar, P.S.- Sabroom, South Tripura, Pin-799145. (Age-43
years)
9. C/9285 Paritosh Das, Son of Lt. Makhan Das, Resident of - Vill. and P.O.Aralia, P.S.- East Agartala, Pin-799004. (Age - 49 years)
10. C/8428 Anup Saha, Son of Lt Anil Ch. Saha, Resident of-Vill. and P.O.A.D. Nagar, P.S.- A D Nagar, Agartala, Tripura, Pin-799003. (Age-43 years)
11. C/11782 Sanjoy Das, Son of - Satyendra Kr Das, Resident of-Vill-Ghilatali
(Police Para), P.O.- Gilatali Bazar, P.S.-Kalyanpur, Khowai, Tripura, Pin799203. (Age-45 years)
12. C/2263 Shyamal Majumder, Son of Sri Ratan Majumder, Resident of VillKashipur, P.O.-Rasham Bagan, West Tripura, Pin-799008. (Age-44 years)
13. C/7474 Sajal Paul, Son of Sri Kalipada Paul, Resident of Vill.-Ranjitnagar,
P.O.-Ramnagar, P.S.- West Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799002.(Age-43 years)
14. T/11235 Sudip Bhattacharjee, Son of- Lt. Ranjit Bhattacharjee, Resident of
Vill. and P.O.-Chandigarh, P.S.-Melagarh, Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799115.
(Age - 42 years)
15. C/2263 Md. Abdul Karim, Son of- Lt Md. Abdul Kadir, Resident of Vill.Nandan Nagar Masjid Para, P.O.- Bankumari, Tripura, P.S.-NCC, Pin- 799006.
(Age- 48 years)
16. C7601 Maran Debnath, Son of Nepal Krishna Debnath, Resident of P.O.
and P.S.-A.D. Nagar, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799003. (Age-44 years)
17. C/7976 Kallol Sharma, Son of Lt Ranjit Sharma, Resident of Vill.Sachindra Nagar, P.O.-North Ceabri, Khowai, Tripura, Pin - 799207. (Age - 41
years)
18. C/7414 Sanjib Kumar Deb, Son of Sri Jiban Kumar Deb, Resident of Vill.- Ramnagar Road No.08, P.O.-Ramnagar, P.S.- West Agartala, Tripura,
Pin - 799002. (Age-36 years)
19. C/452 Uttam Deb, Son of- Lt. Amulya Deb, Resident of - Vill.-Chanmuri,
P.O.-Tebaria, P.S.-Airport, Tripura, Pin - 799015. (Age - 45 years)
20. C/6661 Parshu Ranjan Kapali, Son of - Lt Chand Mohan Kapali, Resident
of - Vill.-Krishnapur, P.O.-Laxmipur, P.S.- Gandachara, Dhalai, Tripura, Pin 799284. (Age - 44 years)
21. C/2964 Md. Jahir Hossen, Son of Sekh Farid Miah, Resident of Vill. and
P.O.- Rangkang, P.S.-Birganj, Gomati, Tripura, Pin- 799101. (Age - 44 years)
22. C/3828 Sujit Ghosh, Son of Sri Nepal Ch. Ghosh, Resident of Vill. and
P.O.-South Charilam, P.S.-Bishramganj, Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799103.
(Age-44 years)
23. I/C HC Goutam Roy, Son of- Lt Kalipada Roy, Resident of Vill. and P.O.Ramnagar Road No. 05, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin - 799002. (Age - 49 years)
24. C/7833 Sanjoy Debnath, Son of Sri Santosh Debnath, Resident of - Vill.Hatipara, P.O.-Salbagan P.S.- Airport, West Tripura, Pin- 799012. (Age - 44
years)
.........Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, (to be represented by) the Secretary, Home Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin -799010.
2. The Secretary, Home Department, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat
Building, New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin -799010.
3. The Director General of Police, Tripura, Police Headquarters, Fire Brigade
Chowmuhani, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.
4. Sri Kamal Chandra Dey, Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police (Un-Armed
Branch), Care of – Office of the Superintendent of Police (Procurement), A.D.
Nagar, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799003.
5. Sri Chandra Uday Dey, Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police (Un-Armed
Branch), Care of Office of the Superintendent of Police, West Tripura District,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin -799001.
6. Sri Khokan Ch. Das, Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police (Un-Armed Branch),
Care of Office of the Superintendent of Police, Sepahijala District,
Bishramganj, Tripura, Pin-799103.
7. Sri Uttam Kumar Deb, Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police (Un-Armed
Branch), Care of – Office of the Superintendent of Police (Procurement), A.D.
Nagar, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin -799003.
8. Sri Ajitendra Chakraborty, Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police (Un-Armed
Branch), Care of – Office of the Superintendent of Police (Procurement), A.D.
Nagar, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799003.
9. Sri Ajitendra Chakraborty, Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police (Un-Armed
Branch), Care of – Office of the Superintendent of Police, West Tripura
District, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin -799001.
.........Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing & Judgment: 22.02.2024
Whether Fit for Reporting: YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Dipjyoti Paul, learned counsel for the petitioners and Mr. D. Sharma, learned
Additional Government Advocate for the respondents-State.
2.
Petitioners are serving as Constables in both Armed Branch and
Un-armed Branch under the Police Department, Government of Tripura. About
512 Head Constables (Un-armed Branch & Armed Branch) Men and Naik
(Armed Branch) Men have been conferred the rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector
of Police (Un-armed Branch) Men on a temporary basis by impugned PHQ
Order No.207/2022 dated 22.12.2022 issued by the Police Headquarters,
Tripura with the following conditions:
“2.
The officers mentioned in this order shall hold full duty charge, subject
to the following conditions:
(i) The officer shall not be entitled to any financial benefits, such as extra
pay and allowances, that are admissible for the higher post, except drawal of
honorarium for holding a higher Group-C post at monthly rate prescribed vide
Finance Department Memorandum No.F.1(15)-FIN(EXPDT-II)/2019/4107-4357
dated 24/09/2020.
(ii) The officer shall be eligible to wear the shoulder badge of Asstt. SubInspector of Police on his uniform.
(iii) The officer has no criminal case or departmental proceeding pending
against him.
(iv) The promotion of the officer in the normal course, as per existing
guidelines, would not be affected, in any way, by the date from which he has
been allowed to temporarily hold charge of the highest post.
(v) The holding of full duty charge of Asstt. Sub-Inspector of Police on a
temporary basis would not affect the inter-se seniority of the officer in his
original post.
(vi) The officer may be reverted to his original rank at any time, and
upon such reversion, the officer shall wear the uniform badge of his original
rank.
(vii) The officer shall submit an undertaking that he will adhere to the
aforesaid conditions at the time of assumption of charge in the higher post.
3.
The holding of full duty charge of Asstt. Sub-Inspector of Police (Unarmed Branch) on a temporary basis would not change the inter-se seniority of
the officers in the rank of Head Constable (UB & AB) and Naik (AB). This
would also not affect the procedure followed during regular promotion to the
rank of Asstt. Sub-Inspector of Police (Un-armed Branch) at a subsequent stage
in respect of any officer.
4.
While assuming the full duty charge of Asstt. Sub-Inspector of Police
(Un-armed Branch), the officers shall submit an undertaking to the PHQ, Tripura,
through proper channel, stating that he shall adhere to the conditions mentioned
in Para 2 of this order.
5.
If any criminal case or departmental proceeding is instituted
subsequently against the officers mentioned in this order, then they shall cease to
hold the full duty charge of Asstt. Sub-Inspector of Police (UB) and they shall no
longer be eligible to wear the shoulder badge of the rank of Asstt. Sub-Inspector
of Police on their uniform.
Sd/(Amitabh Ranjan, IPS)
Director General of Police, Tripura.”
Petitioners, being aggrieved, have preferred this writ petition seeking quashing
of the PHQ Order No.207/2022 dated 22.12.2022 [Annexure-6] or in the
alternative to confer the rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police (Un-armed
Branch) Men to each of the petitioners along with all consequential benefits
which flow from a date anterior to the date on which respondents No.4 to 9 and
others have been conferred the rank of ASI of Police (Un-armed Branch) Men.
They have also prayed for direction upon the official respondents to consider
each of the petitioners for promotion to the rank of ASI of Police (Un-armed
Branch) Men.
3.
On behalf of the petitioners, reliance is placed upon the Schedule
to the Recruitment of Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police (Un-armed Branch)
(Men & Women) Rules, 2007 (Recruitment Rules of 2007, for short) notified
on 08.07.2008 [Annexure-1], in particular Clauses 10 & 11 which are extracted
hereunder:
SCHEDULE
10.
11.
Method of recruitment whether
by direct or by promotion or
transfer and percentage of the
vacancies to be filled up by
various methods
In case of recruitment by
promotion/deputation/transfer,
grades from which promotion/
deputation/transfer is to be made
100% by promotion
From
amongst
Head
Constables (both AB/UB)
(Men & Women), Naiks (Men
& Women), LNK (Men &
Women), Constables (UB/AB)
(Men
&
Women),
and
Constable Armourer (Men &
Women) as have two year
service as constable on 1st day
of January of year in which
DPC is convened on the basis
of departmental examination as
prescribed by the State Govt.
Procedure
for
holding
examination is in annexure.
According to them, petitioners No.1 to 16 have cleared all the three parts of
departmental exam and rest of the petitioners No.17 to 24 have passed Part-I
and Part-II exams, and though have appeared in Part-III examination but results
have not been published, even as per the case of the respondents. However,
they have not been considered for conferring the rank of ASI (UB) Men even
on temporary basis compared to the persons named in the PHQ Order
No.207/2022.
4.
In reply to the contention of the petitioners relying upon the
Recruitment Rules of 2007 dated 08.07.2008, it is contended by learned
Additional Government Advocate for the respondents-State that promotion to
the rank of ASI (UB) is done from amongst Head Constables (AB/UB) (Men &
Women), Naiks (Men & Women), LNK (Men & Women), Constables
(UB/AB) (Men & Women), and Constable Armourer (Men & Women) having
two years’ service as Constable on 1st day of the year in which DPC is
convened. As per the Recruitment Rules of 2007, procedure for holding
examination for the post of ASI (UB) (Men & Women) is done in three parts –
Part-I, Part-II and Part-III. It is further averred that Recruitment Rules provide
that those candidates, who have been declared as passed once in Part-I and or
Part-II, will not be required to reappear in the same part of examination. The
panel of the candidates fit for promotion to the rank of ASI (UB) (Men &
Women) shall be prepared in order of merit in accordance with the result of
Part-III only. Separate panels will be prepared for candidates belonging to
General, ST & SC categories. The panel for un-reserved (General) category will
include the names of Constables of all categories in the order of merit.
Similarly, the panels for ST and SC category will contain the names of
candidates of ST & SC categories only in order of merit. The total number of
names in the panel shall not be more than the number of existing vacancies plus
the anticipated vacancies in the coming one year.
5.
Thereafter, the respondents have made categorical statement that
in the instant case, the full duty charge of higher post has been conferred on a
temporary basis as per seniority, suitability and eligibility of Head Constable
(UB/AB) Men and Naik (AB) Men as per PHQ Order No.207/2022 as per
approval conveyed by the Home Department in the interest of enhancing
operational efficiency, deployment in law & order functions, traffic law
enforcement and investigation of cases, etc. of Tripura Police on the basis of
memorandum dated 24.09.2020 issued by the Finance Department. It is also
contended that DPCs were earlier held for promotion purposes and not for
conferring of higher duty charge. The conferring of ASI rank as per Finance
Department memorandum dated 24.09.2020 does not amount to ad-hoc
promotion. Respondents then state that a new promotion policy dated
22.06.2021 has been issued by the Government of Tripura [Annexure-D to the
Counter Affidavit of respondents No.1 to 3]. As per point No.8 (vii) of the
notification dated 22.06.2021, ad-hoc promotion to different ranks of Tripura
Police is to be done, starting from highest grade of cadre service first. Till date,
promotions on ad-hoc basis have been granted for the post of Inspector of
Police from the feeder post of Sub-Inspector of Police. Further, a DPC has been
constituted for ad-hoc promotion to Sub-Inspector (UB) and Sub-Inspector
(AB) from its feeder posts. The impugned PHQ Order No.207/2022 has only
conferred rank of ASI (UB) Men on temporary basis to 512 Head Constables
(UB & AB) and Naik (AB) Men. It has also been further stated that the rank of
ASI (UB) (Men/Women) were conferred on a temporary basis as per seniority,
suitability and eligibility of Head Constable (UB/AB) Men and Naik (AB) Men
as per PHQ Order No.207/2022.
6.
The Counter Affidavit also enumerates the conditions imposed in
the impugned PHQ Order No.207/2022 which indicates that the officers shall
not be entitled to any financial benefits, except drawal of honorarium for
holding a higher Group-C post at a monthly rate. They shall be eligible to wear
the shoulder badge of ASI of Police on their uniform. There should be no
criminal or departmental proceeding pending against them. The promotion of
officers in normal course, as per existing guidelines, would not be affected, in
any way, by the date from which they have been allowed to temporarily hold
charge of the higher post. The holding of charge of ASI on a temporary basis
would not affect the inter-se seniority of the officer in his original post. The
officer may be reverted to his original rank at any time, and upon such
reversion, the officer shall wear the uniform badge of his original rank. The
officer shall submit an undertaking that he will adhere to the aforesaid
conditions at the time of assumption of charge in the higher post. The holding
of full duty charge of ASI (UB) on a temporary basis would not change the
inter-se seniority of the officers in the rank of Head Constable (UB & AB) and
Naik (AB). This would also not affect the procedure followed during regular
promotion to the rank of ASI (UB) at a subsequent stage in respect of any
officer.
7.
Respondents contend that the petitioners have given facts related
to previous DPCs which do not hold any ground here as no promotion has been
done. It is only conferment of the rank of ASI (UB) and does not amount of
even ad-hoc promotion. Learned counsel for the respondents-State submits that
the matter relating to promotion to the post of ASI (UB) on regular basis is the
subject matter of SLP(C) No.34965/2015 (Sri Bidhan Bhowmik & 3 others vs.
The State of Tripura & others) where the Apex Court has granted a stay upon
the order dated 29.06.2016 passed by the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court.
The case is pending for hearing before the Apex Court. This SLP is related to
promotion to the post of ASI (UB).
8.
Further Additional Affidavit was filed by respondents No.1 to 3
pursuant to the order dated 02.06.2023. This affidavit also reiterates that by the
impugned order only the concerned Head Constables (UB & AB) Men and
Naik (AB) Men have been conferred the rank of ASI (UB) Men on a temporary
basis as per seniority, suitability and eligibility in the interest of enhancing the
operational efficiency in the field formation and other law & order functions,
etc. with some conditions. Averments have also been made relating to ad-hoc
promotional exercise to the rank of SI (AB) (Men & Women) for which DPC
was held on 29.05.2023 and the matter has been placed for concurrence of
TPSC through Home Department.
9.
In reply to the Counter Affidavit of the respondents, learned
counsel for the petitioners has contended that petitioners do fulfil the eligibility
conditions prescribed under Clause 11 of the Schedule to Recruitment Rules of
2007 and are entitled to be considered for regular promotion to the post of ASI
(UB) Men, but they have been left out. If no DPC has been held before
conferring the rank of ASI (UB/AB) Men on temporary basis, the respondents
could not have judged the suitability and eligibility of the concerned candidates
who have been conferred such temporary rank. The official respondents have
adopted an arbitrary criterion to confer a higher rank as ASI (UB/AB) Men to
these persons which in effect, gives them all the powers of the ASI during the
period they remain on the full duty charge. As such, the impugned action
suffers from arbitrariness and illegality failing to adhere to a uniform yardstick
even in the matter of conferment of a higher rank on temporary basis to the post
of ASI (UB/AB) Men.
10.
The issue had been deliberated upon a number of times in the
previous dates. Learned counsel for the respondents-State was allowed further
time to make the position of the respondents clear as to how this exercise has
been conducted ignoring the relevant conditions prescribed under the
Recruitment Rules of 2007 which require passing of departmental exam for
being eligible to be promoted on regular basis to the post of ASI (UB) (Men &
Women) and on what uniform standards, applicable to incumbents who are
eligible for promotion to the post of ASI (UB) (Men & Women) under the
Recruitment Rules of 2007, this conferment of rank on a temporary basis has
also been undertaken.
11.
In order to substantiate the stand of the respondents, learned
Additional Government Advocate for the State has, upon instructions, placed
the Recruitment of Naik (Armed) (Men & Women) Rules, 2010 notified on
16.02.2010 for promotion to the rank of Naik (AB) (Men & Women) from the
post of Constable. He has also placed the Recruitment Rules called “Head
Constable/Havilder (Armed Branch) (Men & Women), Police Directorate,
Recruitment Rules, 2006” notified on 23.10.2006 whereunder promotion to the
post of Head Constable/Havilder (AB) (Men & Women) is to be undertaken
from Naiks who have passed the departmental exam and have at least two
years' service as Naik. He has also placed the Recruitment Rules called
“Recruitment of Head Constable (Un-armed) Men & Women Rules, 2008”
notified on 26.12.2008 for promotion to the post of Head Constable (UB) (Men
& Women) and Recruitment Rules of 2007 notified on 08.07.2008, which is
also relied upon by learned counsel for the petitioners.
12.
On the basis of these recruitment rules, learned Additional
Government Advocate for the respondents-State submits that the normal
hierarchy of promotion on regular basis is from the rank of Constable to the
rank of Naik (AB) (Men & Women) as per Recruitment Rules, 2010 upon
fulfilment of the conditions prescribed under Clause 11 thereof. Further, for
promotion to the post of Head Constable/Havilder (AB) (Men & Women), the
Recruitment Rules dated 23.10.2006 prescribes that it would be filled up from
amongst Naiks, who have passed the departmental exam and have two years’
service as Naik, as per Clause 11 thereof. Further, the Recruitment Rules of
Head Constable (UB) dated 26.12.2008 provide for promotion to the post of
Head Constable (UB) (Men & Women) from Constables (UB & AB),
Constables (Armourer), Lance Naiks and Naiks (AB) not having less than two
years’ service in the grade as Constable (UB & AB). In such promotional
exercise, the quota is 95% from men and 5% from women. Lastly the
Recruitment Rules of 2007 dated 08.07.2008 [Annexure-1] for promotion to the
post of ASI of Police (UB) (Men & Women), prescribe eligibility conditions
for regular promotion from amongst Head Constables (AB & UB) (Men &
Women), Naiks (Men & Women), LNK (Men & Women), Constable (UB/AB)
(Men & Women) and Constable (Armourer) (Men & Women) having two
years’ service as Constable on 1st day of January of the year in which DPC is
convened on the basis of departmental exam as prescribed by the State
Government.
13.
In the exercise leading to issuance of the impugned PHQ Order
No.207/2022, no Departmental Promotion Committee meeting has been
convened because this is not a regular promotional exercise. As per the
recruitment rules referred to herein above, a Constable in ordinary course is
entitled to be considered for regular promotion to the post of Naik (AB) (Men
& Women) as per Recruitment Rules of 2010 on the condition of having passed
departmental exam and having put in two years’ of service. Similarly for being
promoted to the post of Head Constable/Havilder (AB) (Men & Women), only
Naiks, who have passed the departmental exam and have fulfilled two years’ of
qualifying service as Naik, are eligible to be considered for promotion. Further,
for the post of Head Constable (UB) (Men & Women), the Recruitment Rules
of 2008 make the Constables (UB & AB), Constables (Armourer), Lance
Naiks and Naiks (AB) not having less than two years’ service in the grade as
Constable (UB & AB) who have passed the departmental exam as prescribed in
the Recruitment Rules and have rendered not less than two years’ of service as
Constable (UB/AB) eligible for being considered for promotion. The
Recruitment Rules of 2007, relating to recruitment of Assistant Sub-Inspector
of Police (UB) (Men & Women), provide that for promotion to the post of ASI
(UB) (Men & Women), Head Constables (AB & UB) (Men & Women), Naiks
(Man & Women), LNK (Men & Women), Constable (UB/AB) (Men &
Women) and Constable Armourer (Men & Women) with two years’ of service
as Constable on the 1st day of January in which DPC is convened and passing of
departmental exam is a must.
14.
It is apparent from a reading of the recruitment rules referred to in
some detail hereinabove, the Constable (UB/AB) forms the lowest rank in the
hierarchy above whom are Naiks and next Head Constable and then ASI. It is
not in dispute that by the impugned PHQ Order No.207/2022, 512 persons were
conferred the rank of ASI (UB) Men from the post of Head Constable (UB &
AB) Men and Naik (AB) Men. No Departmental Promotion Committee
meeting has, therefore, been held. Passing of a departmental exam is a relevant
eligibility criterion for regular promotional exercise. Since regular promotional
exercise is not being undertaken due to pendency of the case before the Apex
Court in relation to promotion to the post of ASI (UB). At present the State
Government is granting promotion on ad-hoc basis in view of the promotion
policy dated 22.06.2021. This impugned exercise is not even ad-hoc promotion.
Under this impugned exercise, only Head Constables and Naiks have been
considered for being conferred rank of ASI (UB) on a temporary basis to meet
the operational efficiency, deployment in law & order functions, traffic law
enforcement and investigation of cases, etc. The instant exercise even does not
disturb the inter-se seniority amongst the persons eligible for being considered
for regular promotion to the post of ASI in Police (UB) (Men & Women) on
regular basis or even on ad-hoc basis. In order to perform exigencies of law and
order duty, traffic laws enforcement, etc., the State Government had to
undertake this exercise of conferment of rank to incumbents holding the post of
Head Constable and Naik on temporary basis as ASI (UB) (Men). These Head
Constables or Naiks have come in their cadre on promotion from the post of
Constables (UB/AB). As such, the criteria employed by the respondents-State
for conferring rank of ASI (UB) Men on temporary basis to these incumbents is
purely based upon their positions in the cadre of Head Constable and Naik
which are definitely above the rank of Constable to which the petitioners
belong. Since it is not a regular promotional exercise, the fact that the
petitioners have passed the departmental exam and are eligible for such
promotional exercise could not be considered to be a denial of a legal right so
far as the question of conferment of rank of ASI (UB) Men on temporary basis
is concerned as per the impugned PHQ Order No.207/2022 dated 22.12.2022.
15.
The discussion made hereinabove, therefore, leads to the
conclusion that in the matter of conferment of rank of ASI (UB) Men on
temporary basis to the incumbents of the cadre of Head Constables and Naiks
which is not a promotion or even an ad-hoc promotion, no arbitrariness or
illegality has been done nor the petitioners have been unfairly left out in the
matter of conferment of the rank of ASI (UB) Men as undisputedly, they are
holding the rank of Constable, which is at the lowest hierarchy in the set up.
The impugned order also very clearly mentions that the conferment of full duty
charge on the Head Constables and Naiks with only an honorarium and no extra
pay and allowances, in no way, would affect the inter-se seniority of the
officials in their original rank and that would not affect the promotion of the
officials in the normal course.
16.
As such, this Court is of the considered view that the impugned
order does not suffer from any vices of arbitrariness, discrimination or illegality
which calls for interference by this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India.
17.
Writ petition is accordingly dismissed. Pending application(s), if
any, shall stand disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
signed by MUNNA SAHA
MUNNA SAHA Digitally
Date: 2024.02.29 16:28:21 +05'30'
Pijush/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review